Suing Her Kidney Donor

The plaintiff says she’s known the defendant since eighth grade, and the defendant even donated a kidney to the plaintiff. She claims that since then, the defendant has refused to repay several loans the plaintiff gave her. The defendant says she’s disgusted that the plaintiff is bringing her to court after she literally saved her life by giving her a kidney. She’s countersuing for emotional distress.
#JudgeMathis #RealityTV #Court

[@wizardofahhhhhhz]

This lady is a TEXTBOOK Karen…down to the haircut!!

[@koribanks3641]

I thought the same thing...

[@irrationalQT314]

I was looking for this comment 💯

[@SamuelsReview]

Definitely the KarenCut 😂😂😂

[@aliciakerber3682]

Entitled to the core.

[@K_Cole0128]

Yup!

[@SamuelsReview]

Karen was NEVER a friend to the defendant. Karen waited until after she received the kidney to show Gina how little she respected her.

[@Hopeguz3]

This shit right here.

[@SamuelsReview]

@@Hopeguz3 Right! Couldn't even say "Thank you" or meet her for lunch 😔

[@ltc4125]

Exactly

[@victoriah.3413]

@@SamuelsReview - I doubt that. Friends don't borrow money and not pay. She could have got someone else's kidney she said. She should have. You don't give and expect something in return. No matter what. The money should have been paid back long before the kidney issue came up.

[@SamuelsReview]

@@victoriah.3413 Nothing is free in life. Only people who are looking to use/ take advantage of you use the line, "Give without looking for something in return." 😂

[@ginam2817]

Typical narcissistic behavior. "I had someone else that wanted to donate me a kidney" , "I didn't ask you for your kidney". Yet she accepted the kidney from her friend....

[@iamjphnycc5933]

And? Doesn’t change the fact she had another kidney she EVEN GAVE HER MONEY FOR IT😂wtf she’s tryna use her giving her a kidney to take off the focus that she’s been asking for her to be paid back

[@ginam2817]

@@iamjphnycc5933 shiiiiiiiiid she's paid in full, lol! She should've deducted her money from the hospital costs her friend racked up from donating it to her.

[@ДавайДосвидания-м4у]

@@iamjphnycc5933 she told her that she didn’t owe her money anymore than changed her mind AFTER she got the kidney. She wasn’t even entitled to the loan she did not forgive because she took the car back. Karen is tried to come back on her word.

[@NinaZuccaro0824]

She didn’t just save her life. She went through pain and suffering to do so. It is hard on the body to lose an organ, even if it can survive without it. It’s a very invasive surgery with a painful recovery. And there are always risks with surgery.

[@goofyrat2938]

OH! And let’s not forget that she also went against her family’s beliefs for this woman, meaning she probably got into so much trouble on top of all this pain.

[@teijaflink2226]

I feel the woman who got the kidney manipulated her giving her the kidney because she had borrowed money and at that time couldn't pay back. But shouldnt this be illegal though if it's what happened, I didn't quite understand what had actually happened

[@jcon5229]

Also they say that it's worse on the one who gives than the receiver....😢

[@tashajames2866]

I work in a Transplant office and I am appalled that this woman has the audacity to sue the woman who gave her a second chance at life. How sefish and unhumbled is she. The gratitude that I see when our patients recieve a new kidney is priceless and the fact that she is so ungrateful is just horrible.

[@floridagirl386]

I'm sure she was humble with gratitude when she first got the kidney too.

[@thatvalensteingirl]

You work in a transplant office and just casually overlooked that she admitted to committing a felony by essentially PAYING her friend for an organ?

[@xoangelicaf0523]

@@thatvalensteingirl yes we are going to overlook it bc I don’t care 🤷🏽‍♀️ lol.. plus she said she paid her for taking off work so technically so nothing anyone can do

[@rhysparkz4150]

@@xoangelicaf0523 okay but keep that same energy. How can you be apalled about her sueing when she paid for her to take time off on top of thousands she already gave her and a car..... I'd sue too. People die all the time she would've gotten another kidney. you don't do a service like that when ur already in debt and then throw it back in their face when they come to collect. Y'all weird

[@Sheila3444]

@@rhysparkz4150 She didn't give her the car, she held the title and had her son get the car.

[@MrChandlerjm]

When she said, “I had someone else lined up to give me a kidney.” The utter disrespect of the plaintiff. Have you no shame? I would never talk to you again.

[@karenhoyt765]

I thought the same thing and Judge Mathis wasn’t entertaining it either!

[@21hwhelan]

This when I would say, "then give me my kidney back."

[@ME-vb6pq]

Exactly! 😨 I clutched my imaginary pearls on that one. I was shocked! It only goes to show her heart is not in the right place to even say something like that!

[@sudhakhristmukti1930]

The ungrateful Ann, should have gotten the kidney from the one 'lined up.'

[@CeltycSparrow]

From what I can understand, she took her friend's kidney....she accepted this precious, LIFE SAVING gift....and then she spit in her friend's face and didn't even bother to call her or visit her during recovery to make sure she was healing and to thank her for this gift. Her money mattered more to this ugly, selfish, entitled Karen than her life-long friendship with this woman who literally saved her life. Shame on her, indeed. I wouldn't keep that friendship either. She's not worth it.

[@peachesandcaramel]

I received a kidney from a wonderful family who had to make a devastating decision due to losing their child. I owe them my life. I am forever grateful.

[@SpontaneousVirgo]

The same with my nephew! His heart stopped during the surgery and he had to be brought back. My nephew said that he was down in some water and eight angels swarmed under his body and lifted him up out of the water. They told him that it wasn’t his time and he had to go back to earth.

[@Bebe-og3bc]

Same here!

[@kathythomas6600]

i am happy for you. i am pretty much in shock, because people who donate kidneys are heros. i would have forgave the debt, good grief.

[@lyetaherb4703]

And most likely Would Never Sue Them for Anything..

[@robinleflore9999]

My daughter in law was a donor, til this day her only child has never been given the opportunity to meet any of the people who received her organ

[@kaidupree6407]

Somebody saves your life and then you sue them. No good deed goes unpunished

[@hottew_twat3963]

and over 12 hundred bucks too ugh

[@65lianne]

Don think its that simple! maybe watch the episode again......

[@hottew_twat3963]

@@65lianne what are you talking about

[@florian8599]

...in this world. But rejoice! The "punishment" for the good deed in this world only ensures a doubled reward in the Kingdom.

[@maryannanderson2213]

You said exactly what I was planning on saying. No good deed goes unpunished.

[@sunnyblake1980]

As a person who has been on dialysis since March 17, 2012 this is a hard life. I would NEVER sue the person who gave me life back. I would do anything for someone to give me a kidney. She is so blessed. This breaks my heart

[@hotfishfromsharktale]

"I had another kidney lined up" is where I truly lost it. That woman is appalling. She really said "you don't borrow money from friends"... BUT YOU CAN BORROW KIDNEYS FROM THEM????

[@astronomari]

It’s not even borrowing a kidney bc you can’t give it back- an extra level of disrespect 😤 Kidney donations are life changing decisions. I would be outraged!!!

[@traceyjackson4470]

I can’t believe this case made it on national television but it sure does show peoples TRUE COLORS!!!! What an abomination! What happens if God forbid the plaintiffs kidney anti rejects(?)🤦🏽‍♀️ If someone owes you money and has every intention of paying you back, give them time! If that person donated a LIFE SAVING body organ to you, give them a LIFETIME to Repay it!

[@jayjohnson8426]

I think a kidney overrides money she owes you and to say I had another kidney lined up and I offered to call it of im sorry she took the kidney she fagave the loan then wanted it again this woman is disgusting no she is not worth it and lets hope her body dont reject the kidney as she might need that other person she is probably blackmailing aswell

[@jamesflaherty9190]

@@astronomari umm she didn’t literally meant borrow a kidney *please act your age, not your shoe size!*

[@opulence_prime]

@@jamesflaherty9190 the joke went way over her head. She doubled down on the seriousness of the matter 😅

[@justmedoingme]

The nerve of the plaintiff suing this lady is disgusting Im a dialysis technician I’ve seen people be on dialysis for years with no donor

[@ursulatroxler7428]

I agree

[@definitelygryffindor]

Agreed! I work in Nephrology as an MA and this case in particular really disturbs me.

[@brennenjones6658]

This case touched me because I lost my mother 2 years ago who was on dialysis AFTER she already had a kidney AND liver transplant that extended her life by 18 years approximately. The kidney eventually failed and they tried to get her on the list again but by then she had some other health issues that they didn't feel she was a worthy candidate for, so I've been on this from both sides, seeing her get TWO organs donated to her then, unfortunately, having to get on dialysis for a little while before she died and the quality of life is that much better obviously without having to go to dialysis. That wears on you. She should be beyond grateful for what her friend has saved her from.

[@definitelygryffindor]

@@brennenjones6658 I am so sorry for your loss.

[@anjenue4894]

How about the line, “I had another one lined up!” *priceless*

[@peacheskong2245]

The defendant is traumatized, poor lady! This is SHOCKING to witness. How did she miss all these signs in the plaintiff?? I'm sure she always looked down on her.

[@jasminej6281]

True she’s acting like she did her a favour to take her kidney

[@FaithandNova]

Unfortunately ppl don’t pay attention. We all have a tendency to miss certain red flags at some point in life.

[@latashapearson3863]

Yes that’s what I said up above. Signs were there I’m sure. She just ignored them. Maybe bedding a friend. She’s hurt and angry.

[@lauralee9440]

She probably missed the “signs” because the defendant is an empath, where the plaintiff is a narcissist. Narcissists prey on empaths, and feel justified in doing so.

[@christinestanding]

@@FaithandNova Me too.

[@speaktrue77]

I love how the whole courtroom applauded in favor of the defendant 🥳👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@theresaholden7580]

Wow, sounds like someone also needs to give the kidney recipient a heart. Her friend went through a painful surgery and extensive recovery to help her. Unbelievable, so sad. May God bless the donor.

[@christineguttilla6465]

The Wizard of Oz forgot to give this lady a Heart AND a Brain 🧠 She’s absolutely unconscionable!

[@Irod567]

The plaintiff is unbelievably selfish and ungrateful. She's harping on money, while the defendant gave her something so precious that you couldn't even put a price on it- life. There's no way that I would sue someone that sacrificed to give me a second chance at life.

[@chuck9380]

A deal is a deal

[@nmc1859]

Dorinne ..oh my gosh i know !!!!

[@flowergirlproductions]

I agree with you! but I would be very disappointed in a friend who borrowed money and wouldn't return it if I needed it, I know they saved my life but now I'm living and struggling because you won't give me my money back lol. I wouldn't have sued her though.

[@josettecollins5376]

Exactly!

[@misterbee66]

True, however, that does not give you the right to take advantage of the woman who gave you a loan.

[@geostruth9115]

I could never sue a friend who donated a kidney to me. No way. As a matter of fact, I would have cancelled all previous loans, and anything going forward would be a gift to that friend.

[@dominiquejenkins5495]

Exactly I'm indebted to you for my life because you saved it.....just my opinion though

[@geostruth9115]

@@dominiquejenkins5495 That's not an opinion. It's right. Wrong vs. Right is the choice we all have to make. Deep inside, we all know the difference. What you said is a fact. The right attitude of gratitude. Not an opinion. 👊🥂

[@SamuelsReview]

She would have spent so many years in dialysis and surgeries that would have been wayyyy more than $10k, while waiting on a kidney.

[@RoughJustice2k18]

The way I see it: if a friend has borrowed money from you in the past, hasn't repaid it, but is kind enough to donate a vital organ that can save your life, be sincerely grateful to them and consider it as _"PAID IN FULL"_ because friendship and life are far more valuable than any dollar amount.

[@thatlsk]

You give me anything that saves my life, any and everything I have is available to you.

[@Lushus40]

The gift she gave is priceless

[@Bessie-ff7rs]

So priceless

[@Bessie-ff7rs]

I’m glad JM dismisses the case.

[@alstonhemmings1134]

I pressed Like,then pressed Dislike;then went back and pressed Like ; Now Iam feeling Depressed after so much pressing. I Love Judge Mathis with my daily dose. Now this plantiff's case have me guessing at my loyalty to the Mathis gang. I need therapy pronto.

[@lolopop12345]

@@Bessie-ff7rs i think she deserved the emotional distress

[@FaithandNova]

No dollar amount holds value to a life. She’s despicable

[@gaellaw2167]

Every now and then I say I've heard it all, but after listening to this, I realized that I hadn't. The woman who has a kidney from an angelic act by a friend, and then turns around and sues her is one of the most horrible things I've ever heard in my life. She's a horrible human being.

[@dirtbrat1760]

I donated my kidney to my Aunt (not blood related, but longtime family friend that I consider family) in 2020. To this day, it was one of the MOST beautiful, blessed feelings that I have ever experienced and I have absolutely NO regrets! When you go thru the testing to be a donor (I had 23 tests in a 5 day period), one of the required steps of the process is to have a psychological exam. This is to make sure you understand the extent of being a donor. The health risks, how you would feel if the recipient doesn’t “take care” of themselves after receiving the kidney, if you’re doing it out of guilt or obligation, etc. The fact that her friend passed the psychological exam proves that she was a donor for the “right” reasons. They tell you being any type of organ donor, especially to someone you know, you cannot feel that the recipient EVER owes you anything. You should look at it as a “gift”…..something that is no longer yours per se. The fact that she was to the point of needing a transplant proves that she was quite ill and could not have survived had she not received one. With that being said, the disgusting display of self-entitlement, arrogance and blatant disrespect that this woman did, bringing her friend on national TV to TRY to humiliate her, is beyond disgusting!! That woman sacrificed her own health to do the MOST unselfish, beautiful thing a person can do….LIVING ORGAN DONATION! Not to mention, the healing process for the DONOR is more painful AND extensive than it is for the recipient! This woman is an ungrateful, self-centered, narcissistic…..KAREN! Right down to the haircut!!! To Gina (Donor)-Bless you for making such a beautiful sacrifice of being a LIVING ORGAN donor. Don’t allow this woman to steal the joy you felt, at the time of donation, for literally saving someone’s life. It’s a beautiful, blessed feeling! To Jenny (aka KAREN)-Shame on you for being such an ungrateful, self-righteous POS! KARMA, KARMA, KARMAAAA!

[@angelictigerette]

Your comment makes me want to cry. I am a kidney recipient. Thank you for being so unselfish and willing to donate a kidney to your loved one. We need more people like you.

[@dirtbrat1760]

@@angelictigerette ❤️

[@happyinparis]

You are exactly right! Jenny is a horrible person. She is self-absorbed and narcissistic. Make HER real name known to all. Please don't give her cover by using someone else's name. Her name isn't Karen. It's Jenny and I wish I knew her last name.

[@KRoseB]

Thank you for sharing your insight. I cannot believe people don't understand what a loving sacrifice this donation was. That plaintiff destroyed it.

[@flyingnutrition6199]

i do not agree with the psychologist ...i think if you donate an organ, or save someone life, no matter how ... jumping into the water etc ... that person is in debt to you forever, for the entire time they live after.... and if money is all you need from them and they have plenty they should give it to you ...forever... life cannot be bought with money .... the gift they made for you is priceless .... so they should reciprocate... with whatever help they can offer... i think for someone that has money, money is the easiest way to pay back the gift...

[@StationOnLife]

If someone has given me a “kidney” to give a me second life, I don’t care if that person owed $100,000 dollars from me, I would have written it off. The fact is so sad that, because of that “kidney” the “plaintiff is still alive so that she can sue the defendant for the loan. Has the defendant let the plaintiff die, then she doesn’t have to pay the loan back. The plaintiff is selfish, greedy, ungrateful, disgusted, unconscionable person.

[@tarae5380]

That's so true! I wish the defendant would have said that very same thing to her; maybe it would've made the claimant rethink this case?

[@sharonsmalls6846]

The defendant improved the plaintiff’s quality of life, the kidney is not life-giving. The plaintiff was on dialysis, which is what is life-giving. Otherwise, every patient who is diagnosed with renal failure would die. It is dialysis that is life-sustaining, not a kidney transplant. That is what happened, the defendant improved the plaintiff’s quality of life because the plaintiff no longer needs dialysis.

[@tarae5380]

@@sharonsmalls6846 wow. Thanks for that information Sharon. And the nerve of this woman to still want her to pay her back. Shame.

[@sharonsmalls6846]

@@tarae5380 Yes, I was a hemodialysis nurse from 1993-2015. I began as a staff nurse, and was promoted to in-service coordinator, then promoted to charge nurse/clinical coordinator, then promoted to clinical manager/facility administrator. These different positions blessed me to learn a great deal about renal failure.

[@PIMPSTREZZ-DNA-FAM]

She gave you her kidney she gave you life leave that lady alone she made sure you were priceless and you're putting your price on it and you sadistic

[@2tactbrilliant51]

I'm lost for words,😲😲😲. The plaintiff is so ungrateful. She should have left her friend with that money. Her own family didn't donate a kidney and your friend did. OMG woman!! You should be grateful for having a friend like that.

[@tammi67able]

Indeed

[@audreyricci6383]

@@tammi67able Karen's do not value friendship.

[@tammi67able]

@@audreyricci6383 terrible

[@AuntieKim]

To sue someone after saving your life shows a level of depravity that knows no bounds.

[@flyingnutrition6199]

exactly ... it is so sad ... she did not deserve the kidney ...

[@whattomakeofit3436]

The lady is saved from having to sit with a dialysis machine for hours at a time several days a week so she could instead get her nails and hair done and celebrate with friends. But she def not celebrating her new life with the woman who gave her the kidney, just suing. How sad.

[@InTheNameOfLife1]

Look at her hair lol. Ultimate Karen

[@victoriajones8747]

Absolutely..well said

[@tikasinaga1284]

AGREE! Sadistic!! Crazy!

[@tanyahart2396]

Sometimes when you find out who a person is, believe it. And move on.

[@jimjimmyjam8242]

I absolutely love the dumb look on a Karen's face the moment they realize they won't get their way. God bless each and every organ donor 💙

[@Dee-cu8yr]

The plaintiff is the reason why good Hearted people shield themselves From the world Stay in the house And don’t offer their goodness This is heartbreaking

[@gggreens]

You sound like a fool

[@cathyramos4849]

So true

[@FaithandNova]

That’s true, that’s me right now. Don’t trust anyone cuz of the actions of evil humans

[@donnajacksonwhite5963]

The nerve of her....

[@tammi67able]

True

[@mangobee1372]

I won't sue someone who gave me a ride, let alone a kidney. That's absolutely crazy.

[@DetroitQueen74]

She gave her a kidney and then she sued her. How disturbing and sad.

[@tammi67able]

Very sad

[@deborahhershey3045]

it is sick and evil

[@Faith12162]

Very and selfish

[@marybruce4395]

@April Graham it is very disturbing indeed but human nature is very unpredictable and I trust that they reconcile because the unforgiveness and toxic nature of their relationship can cause their kidneys to become sick and affect their overall health ... mind & body connection is very real

[@deborahhershey3045]

@@marybruce4395 I disagree as huMAN behavior is very predictABEL and why HIStory always repEATS$

[@texasgoddess323]

I was a bone marrow donor to a complete stranger. The recovery was extremely painful, plus I was down for about 3 weeks. I was living with my parents, which definitely helped out. With any surgery, you are literally risking your life and/or complications with the surgery. The plaintiff should’ve immediately communicated to her friend that all debts would be paid in full, OR she should’ve told her that she would still owe her the money even after the surgery. That way the defendant would have the opportunity to back out, since the plaintiff did have another donor option (so she said). Although there should have been communication about the money before the surgery, it was literally COLD BLOODED for that woman to take her to court over green paper, when she now has a healthy life because of this woman!!!

[@britanimckinney1964]

I’m speechless. If I had to receive someone else’s organs, I would always fill like I owe them my life. No debt could amount to that person saving a life. I wouldn’t ask them to give me back a dime!! Honey I’m so sorry. You saved this woman’s life and she could have still be on a waiting list even if she did have someone else. They probably are glad they didn’t donate their kidney to her. Sad lady!!

[@islagirl6652]

I am appalled with the plaintiff. I received a kidney and wouldn't even think of doing what she did. Shame on her!

[@tammi67able]

Indeed

[@deborahhershey3045]

Karen$ have no shame as they beLIEve they are entitled

[@Faith12162]

Oh yeah

[@audreyricci6383]

@@deborahhershey3045 We only exist to serve them. When they have no further use for us they kick us to the curb.

[@conniechoward]

Even the judge is speechless. That said it all.

[@lovesilky]

I wish they would’ve went to Judge Judy for this one cause Judy would’ve ripped her a new one

[@tammi67able]

So true

[@bobstewart5262]

Kind of like when George Lopez's wife donated her kidney to him and then he divorced her. What a major asshole!

[@timlabeaux8123]

i think he wanted to cry

[@gordiemaldonado6008]

His “Woahhhh… woahhhh” got me lol

[@melanieryan128]

I rarely get emotionally involved in these cases, but I am absolutely disgusted with that plaintiff. Someone gives you their kidney... a part of their body... to save your life... that at some point if their are other kidney fails, they themselves are screwed. And you sue them over a couple thousand dollars? That woman did not deserve her kidney. I feel so badly for the defendant.

[@gawd4582]

The look on her face when he was ruling her against her...... was at least as priceless as the kidney.

[@ginajust-me2445]

My son when he died well was pronounced, he became a Donor he was able to help 5 people, his heart, lungs, both kidneys for 2 people and his liver.... Gina, you did a kind thing to give your kidney to her. I know as a donor it's hard for you, my cousin gave hers to her sister and her life has been harsh because of it, physically.. Hugs to you Gina...

[@ninadavis5517]

She's disgusting and money hungry. She needs to be grateful and humble. She was blessed the first time, she may not get a second chance...

[@SamuelsReview]

So true. Donated kidneys typically last 15 years. So the plaintiff will most likely need another transplant in the future...

[@cdubb8827]

Yes bc a transplant is fragile. She may need another one in the future

[@lyetaherb4703]

Because the body can reject a Transplanted organ. Ive seen it happen with a kidney transplant.

[@tammi67able]

True

[@deeransom]

I probably wouldn’t be suing my kidney donor. That’s just ridiculous

[@ericapolanco9379]

Exactly smh

[@Hazel.Eyed.Gemini]

She didn’t donate. She sold that kidney

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

EXACTLY🤡🤛🏿

[@bigbk3278]

@@Hazel.Eyed.Gemini watch the vid...compensate**

[@meekmeek2599]

Why not? A dept is a dept, just that. You can’t tell a bill collector that or they’ll be garnishing your checks.

[@dieKommentatorin]

The plaintiff's behaviour is absolutely disgusting to me. "How dare she?" is the right question!

[@lydiapaddie7763]

Can she asked her to give back the kidney?

[@jacquelinewright5985]

Agreed

[@dieKommentatorin]

@@lydiapaddie7763 I doubt it but that would be low as well imo.

[@FaithandNova]

@@lydiapaddie7763 she can ask for it back but that’s not how it works lol

[@tammi67able]

Yes it is

[@danya.9602]

There is no price tag for undergoing an operation and donating a kidney. The plaintiff was absolutely heartless to the women who gave her life

[@ultimatecouponlady]

She not only gave her the gift of a kidney, she gave her the gift of time as in expanding her lifespan and also the time that she would have spent in a dialysis chair three days a week for 4 hours over years.

[@mashondaknight9132]

The plaintiff is very ungrateful and this is exactly why you can't help everyone

[@misterbee66]

Exactly, I helped a former friend who pretty much left me to die, I helped him after the fact and his response to me was eff me and not to bother with him again, and he is the one who needed the money to keep from being evicted.

[@tammi67able]

So true

[@Faith12162]

N not even want to try help ppl sometimes

[@yvonnemoore1128]

I can't believe it! She is a very ungrateful woman.

[@nmc1859]

Trash

[@tammi67able]

Truly

[@yoongiswndrlnd]

it took my 17 year old cousin over a YEAR to get his kidney. and that was with a living donor being a family member. he was lucky enough to find a family member that was a match. suing your donor? that’s so disgusting.

[@awomanwithgritt.8837]

AMEN 👏👏!!!

[@yoongiswndrlnd]

@Patrick Baptist not so disgusting when it literally saves lives.

[@yoongiswndrlnd]

@Patrick Baptist lol i come from a catholic family. funny how you want to condemn a child to death when god gave us humans the ability to heal through medicine and science.

[@yoongiswndrlnd]

@Patrick Baptist i got bored like halfway through your reply as most of its irrelevant. tell me how it’s “robbing someone’s flesh” when my cousin got a donor kidney from a living, consenting, donor. as for the other catholic allegations…y’all be reaching too much. hitler and the priests/nuns that abuse children may call themselves catholic but they’re not. at least we agree that they’re evil abominations. i’ll take the name calling of a whore as a compliment, thank you very much ☺️

[@benvasilinda9729]

My dad taught me long ago, u don’t loan money to friends or family unless ur willing to never see that money again. He was more than right about that and many other things. Never let money ruin a good relationship.

[@liberiarose6565]

The plaintiff is complete trash. This is unbelievable.

[@nmc1859]

Totally. God is watching.

[@maggiegray8046]

I have been sitting here for like three minutes SO utterly dumbfounded, stunned and shocked, I couldn't even type a comment. You nailed it. Trash. Human waste. My god.

[@angelamaria2239]

Trash. Trash. Trash. Karma will come to her.

[@dinahbrown902]

So unreal

[@dinahbrown902]

She will get hers

[@ashleyrsai26]

Rarely does a case leave judge Mathis speechless, this was a tough one.

[@funteck_etv]

It's surrealistic

[@tammi67able]

I know right

[@tammi67able]

@Janet Louise true

[@PeanutsMommy]

The lady might owe her money, but the lady who got the kidney is VERY ungrateful.

[@crazzynez]

It didn't sound like she even owed her any money because of the 5k she put down on the car. I honestly would've given back the countersuit.

[@user-uj6sc7ls9y]

11:20 "...when I asked you for the kidney?" So she _asked_ Gina for the kidney. What happened to "I had another donor lined up"? She admitted it right there.

[@gardeningdianne]

A second chance at life is worth more than $10,000. As a Kidney donor myself, I would be absolutely devastated if the recipient did the same thing to me. It just shows that the recipient in this case is a self entitled person..

[@kayceem8109]

This is the first time I’ve ever seen Judge Mathis basically speechless. This lawsuit is complete bullsh*t. The audacity of the plaintiff!

[@criscat8239]

I wish a awarded the donor her counter suit. She was clearly emotionally distressed over this.

[@eddieojei9703]

If you ever want to give an example of an ungrateful person, this is one. An example of selfishness. The plaintiff is innately ungrateful.

[@therealjetlag]

“I PAID YOU FOR THE KIDNEY”….. admitting to a felony in front of a judge. 😂

[@xoangelicaf0523]

Dumb lol but then they said she was paid her for time off

[@brackenrobertson799]

Suing a friend who gave you LIFE? suing a friend for money she DIDNT EVEN OWE? That woman's a monster. If the defendant falls ill with kidney failure, I pray she never falls ill with anything, but that could quite literally take HER life. She's taken that chance for the plaintiff and she's repaid her like this. Disgusting.

[@SV-nk2we]

The judges response tells it all. Such disrespect to her friend who gave her a second chance for life.

[@DjProductions11313]

You know it's very upseting that that woman would even walk to Sue her when that lady gave you her kidney without that she wouldn't even be alive this is so heartbreaking

[@highlander666]

I don't think anything trumps "I gave you a kidney" card, wow😮 incredibly selfless, those loans should be forgiven; she literally saved her life

[@ME-vb6pq]

Plus don’t forget she also was suing for a car the defendant said (which the plaintiff didn’t deny) that she paid her for the use of, and now has the car in her own possession! What kind of person does that??? Just wow.

[@ruthpowell1944]

@@ME-vb6pq I would have bought her a car free and clear. How can someone be given the gift of life and then turn on the person who made that gift possible?

[@jazmynjohnson1060]

The plaintiff is full of crap. She’s downplaying receiving a kidney as if it was just this materialistic item of no true importance. That is a life changing “gift” on both parties and shame on her for downplaying the severity of it. Smh some people can be a bit cruel to the core 😒

[@KuriAxx]

Classic narcissist

[@ericrivera8410]

@@KuriAxx classic Karen down to the haircut

[@audreyricci6383]

@@ericrivera8410 Absolutely a classic Karen.

[@shelocsher2396]

There was a news story of a woman who donated her kidney to her boss. Couple months later the boss fired her because she took too much time off to recuperate 😩

[@yvonnemoore1128]

That's the second worse one I've heard. There was a woman who begged her brother to donate a kidney to her fiancée because she couldn't donate, after he got the kidney he left her!

[@KPbouj]

Yep and she sued her and won.

[@nmc1859]

What ??! Also terrible. They need to figure life oit on their own

[@eveningglow9023]

The kidney holds energy.......

[@rashidareeves78]

@@KPbouj good!

[@isabellecarbonneau4744]

The lady that got the kidney should be thanking her NOT claim money, what a brat with no heart......Pay her and get your kidney back let her go........

[@jdmarr2259]

I think, in cases like this, to make everybody "whole," the donor should repay the loans to the recipient.* The donor should then repossess her kidney & have it transplanted back into her own body. Then the now former recipient can go and get her hair & nails done between dialysis sessions. And the now former donor can enjoy the rest of her life with her two kidneys. * the former donor could charge the exact loan amount to the former recipient for the temporary use of her kidney. So, she would walk away the winner on all counts.

[@MiracleFound]

No good deed goes unpunished. I have learned that implicitly just over the last year and a half. Don't lend money if you can't afford to lose it. We lent money to friends, $18,000, so that they didn't lose their house. When the husband's colon cancer returned, we forgave the debt. We have no regrets and when the husband died we were thankful that we had forgiven the loan when we did.

[@thepriestess5969]

Thank you for your compassion

[@briancole1687]

Wow, that is amazing character....May The Most High bless you and keep you all your days. HalleluYah!

[@nelisiwegwabuzela4877]

God bless you 🙏🏾

[@bigvalley4987]

You and yours are absolutely beautiful empathetic people. You are the type of people that keep me going when I want to give up on the world and people.🙌🏾🙌🏾

[@Ashley-tl2kz]

God bless you're heart wow

[@LadyLondonDDG]

She used her and acted like they were great friends in order for her to give up her kidney...then stopped communicating once she got it...

[@msknich0le]

I would only risk that type of surgery for my child. She would have died or been best friends with that waiting list. Plaintiff is pathetic.

[@thomasskodzinsky3255]

When a person receives a transplant and when the person donates a body part, both of their health have been further compromised. They both will have to go on with their lives and live carefully so they both don't overdo themselves physically and mentally. So when they both started yelling at each other in the court room, I was getting worried they both with have medical emergencies. With the kidney swapping, money exchanging, putting their names on car titles to get around the laws, Judge Mathis was correct to deny both of their claims and send them home. The defendant was willing to be on national television to air out her side of the story and try to win favor of the judge but at the end of the day, they both were embarrassingly placed on a pedestal for millions to see what a crying mess this situation was, and inadvertently alert the state, the police, the IRS and the transplant ethics authorities of illegal doings going on between the two ladies.

[@MakeupMobster]

A kidney donation and saving someone’s life is priceless. My mom got a kidney transplant. You cannot put a value on that. This woman should’ve forgiven all debts once this woman donated her kidney. What if years down the road something happens to the kidney she has left? This is insane and this woman don’t appreciate a damn thing.

[@micjoshua1076]

This is the exact reason why sometimes you can't help people lady gave her a kidney she should be eternally grateful

[@stumack9755]

Had she not donated kidney Plaintiff would be dead. Defendant would not be n court. No good deed goes unpunished.

[@Proverbspsalms]

@@stumack9755 she said she had another donor lined up. Remember. So basically what she saying she did not need it

[@blueeplum8429]

@@Proverbspsalms if she did she wouldn’t of took hers

[@Proverbspsalms]

@@blueeplum8429 Well you’ll have to talk to her about it. I’m not the one who said it

[@blueeplum8429]

@@Proverbspsalms ok. But you was saying it like you was so sure and you know them

[@sabinalusbo4503]

Cost of a kidney is infinite. The cost of kidney cannot be measured. She saved her life. And she is not thankful for that. Such a selfish woman 😡😡😡😤

[@audreyricci6383]

She got 15 years added to her life but she did not appreciate her friend's sacrifice.

[@debjoyful1]

The plaintiff is ungrateful, and cold hearted. Her attitude is shameful towards her life saver. SMH.

[@tammi67able]

True

[@normatible9795]

Okay I’ll pay you the 3,000 dollars but please return MY KIDNEY !

[@rolando198174]

I'm just as speechless as judge Mathis. I only have one kidney, and yes you can survive with just one. I hope to at least live 20 more years with no major health crisis that puts me on the list of ppl in need of a kidney, but if I ever need and receive a kidney, or any other organ, I wouldn't sue the person who donated said organ. I'd be grateful, and forgive any debt owed of any. How can anyone put a price tag on a life? To me, its priceless. Apparently 3,208 is what the plaintiff thought her own was worth. It hurts my brain to watch someone so ungrateful, sue her donor, the person who saved her life. What's wrong with people? (That's a rhetorical question unless you know the answer)

[@oliviajohnson5507]

The plaintiff is so ungrateful!!! She literally gave her a body part! One you can't live without. Breaks my heart to see this.

[@augustmoon9973]

Even if the defendant did borrow the $9K from the plaintiff, the precious gift of life that the defendant so selflessly shared is worth so much more. Not to mention the risks involved with any surgery, her own recovery time, and God forbid she would one day need that kidney herself. This case is one of the saddest I've seen, and I'm so glad she didn't have to pay her a dime, because it's sad enough that she gave something so priceless to someone that doesn't even value the friendship or the giver. ❤️

[@ruthpowell1944]

She should have listened to her family when they told her they didn't want her to do it. They probably had the plaintiff pegged. Now, suppose a member of her family or even her needs that kidney.

[@tammi67able]

I know right

[@vanessawhite1041]

Just read your comment and my line of thinking was tracking with yours. It’s not a one time sacrifice. It’s a sacrifice she made for the rest of her life

[@criscat8239]

I wish the donor won her counter suit. She is clearly emotionally distressed over this.

[@latterrain09]

@@vanessawhite1041 Truth

[@abiolagonsalves762]

I will ask back for my kidney She is an ungrateful brute. How can you ever repay for someone giving you life It's so sad.

[@tammi67able]

Lol, I know right

[@veronicaharwick9013]

Sadly, I don't think Gina's former kidney will be able to live very long in such a toxic environment. 😔

[@cookieful448]

i wish he had asked how much a kidney was worth to her

[@opulence_prime]

Why would she loan her money knowing she couldn’t afford to take time off work to “donate” the kidney 🙄 the plaintiff is not a good person.

[@peacefreedom4930]

I literally gasped when I heard the basis of this case. I got nauseous when the plaintiff said she had someone else lined up to give her a kidney. I honestly believe the plaintiff took advantage of a person who lacked financial means. I do believe she was offering money to less fortunate individuals in exchange for their kidney. They couldn’t admit to that illegal activity. But how else did she have people lined up to give her a kidney. She’s a vulture. Stop saving people that God has put a tag on. Her behavior shows us why her time was up. Yet, the defendant sacrificed to grant this ungrateful, desperate, entitled, selfish biooootch more time to do more damage.

[@hollyperrin7353]

I thought the title must be click-bait, but sure enough, this woman was suing the friend who saved her life. This might be counter-intuitive, but I think that the plaintiff does need more time to find redemption before she meets her maker.

[@EK-fl8yz]

I feel the same way .I would be ashamed to have her in my family.

[@catmoore2443]

She did ,she took advantage of a person with little means. Vile

[@pickles5132]

yup, her time was coming up and she swindled her way out of it. what an awful vile creature.

[@maryjanebrown4667]

Yes.

[@arianefr78]

What a horrible plaintiff. She knew that it is illegal to 'buy' a kidney and when she let the defendant off the debt, it was a form of payment, but then goes back on that and now is no longer grateful to still be alive but wants her money back. It makes you think twice about giving up a kidney...

[@kepler186f4]

'Neither a borrower nor a lender be' - Willie

[@dianefrench1721]

What a Karen! Omg! God bless the kidney donor and the judge!

[@lillianwilliams5510]

This is sad! Does she want her kidney back? The plaintiff should be more compassionate, she is alive,because someone was compassionate enough to give up her kidney. The defendant could die from having only one kidney. The plaintiff is ungrateful!! The defendant is broken.

[@SamuelsReview]

Yep heartbroken. She donated to a woman that she was as a sister and now the plaintiff has turned into a nightmare

[@nombinintlahla8325]

This got to be one of the saddest... I hope Gina is doing better, I hope she got therapy for herself ... Even JM was speechless on this one

[@audreyricci6383]

I am glad he dismissed the case completely.

[@sheilae.9670]

What an emotionally charged episode 😪 I personally wouldn't have sued a friend, that donated their kidney to save my life. Hopefully, they mend their friendship but idk if that will happen..😔

[@ntakovacj3644]

I don't know how anybody could suggest mending that friendship. Once somebody shows you that side of them there is no going back.

[@audreyricci6383]

It won't. Karen 🔥👹😠 made that very plain.

[@latterrain09]

There was only one friend present, and one soulless narcissist.

[@deborahcole6999]

From the beginning she should have determined that if her friend could not pay her back she was either NOT going to loan her the money OR was never going to ask her for it. She knew this was only going to cause problems. I'm not speaking of the money to help pay her bills while recuperating from the kidney surgery. But loans made AFTER that. She should never have asked for it back, or never made the loan. This friend gave her LIFE. What if she kept asking for her kidney back..?? DISGUSTING....

[@ashleybaker6036]

What’s that saying? “Money is the root to ALL EVIL” Well here you go, this case is a PRIME EXAMPLE of just that! That woman DON’T have an utter ounce of kindness about for ex friend ONLY about the money🤬‼️

[@Bebe-og3bc]

I've had 2 kidney transplants, If someone would have donated to me a kidney I would have never disrespected them like this! Any amount of money owed would have been written off!

[@rinna.b]

Wow the audacity of the plaintiff that is so wrong I feel so bad for the defendant 🥺

[@nmc1859]

Absolutely thankless. Sounds like the defendant was coerced big time !!

[@nothgir]

She should ask for her kidney back. 🤷‍♂️ The donor obviously loves “Karen” but Karen seems to have used her. She had no valid reason for the disregard of her.

[@zeezee990]

Typical Behavior 😐🤨😧 Evil and ungrateful... the plaintiff is *Disgusting*

[@AtimTimLives]

Sorry but i do NOT recommend them being amicable or friends again. She doesn't need to forgive this lady. And because Karma is a dish best served cold, it's better you don't stay near her, because something is DEFINATELY coming for her!!! Her life will be over soon enough 😋

[@mrs.ssmith816]

She owes that lady her life literally……this is why you NEVER give an organ to anyone other than your child, mother, sibling or spouse

[@jeanniethompson561]

Or father?

[@lisabeaver2919]

Mrs. Smith , I have to disagree with you . Giving a kidney is the greatest gift you can give ..this lady is just one bad apple . Most people are so greatful.....I've been on dialysis for 2 years now and am getting a kidney from my sister... everyone from dialysis that I know is profoundly greatful..for their second chance.

[@deeransom]

Damn the fact she said she had another kidney lined up is crazy. I would have said give me mine back then b

[@Proverbspsalms]

😂🤣🤣🤣

[@2tactbrilliant51]

Me too.lol

[@Ririkrd]

I rather throw away a kidney but don't give it to someone who doesn't appreciate my sacrifice

[@tammi67able]

Lol

[@nelisiwegwabuzela4877]

Me too 🤞🏾

[@eb6644]

Everyone’s facial expression when she spoke on the kidney-priceless

[@sweetsweet81]

The judge had the same look

[@Juicetheeunuch]

The whole audience turning their heads back and forth was hilarious.

[@anonymousanonymous9680]

@@sweetsweet81 Plaintiff even got the Karen cut. It would win the Karen haircut of the year. Heffer.

[@sweetsweet81]

@@anonymousanonymous9680 Right!

[@prettylyricsmarie]

She looks like Kate in John and Kat Plus 8. That is why I don't give anybody anything from my body. Most people are so ungrateful, just as the plaintiff. Don't give kidneys to anybody, not even your family. The plaintiff doesn't deserve her kidney.

[@pinayladyoz8044]

This is exactly why "money" should not be involve with organ transplantations, because when you involve money it become business. In Australia and NZ, no way this kind of kidney transplantations arrangement will be allowed. Organ donation should be base purely on "good deed". The kidney recipient is so ungrateful to the woman who was the donor. To be in a dialysis patient 3x/week in USA is very expensive. To have a friend that donates kidney she should be forever grateful.

[@essammojalid8952]

What a horrible , heartless woman, how could she sue someone who really saved her life

[@KPbouj]

When I saw the Karen swoops In the thumbnail, I knew it was going to be messy just like I like it 😊.

[@Teyoncee]

“Just like I like it” 🤣

[@mmsmart1014]

I am speechless , she came in not even thanking the defendant for the kidney. If the defendant didn't mention it no one would know.. She shouldn't sue her.

[@mariearmstrong9185]

What a terrible, terrible woman. SHAME ON YOU!!!! Your friend saved your life and you took her to court.

[@waterbaby7834]

Think of how much time and money the defendant saved the plaintiff, just in saved trips to have dialysis. Her gift also added years onto the friend's life. In the end, I guess the friendship turned out to be worth a measley couple thousand dollars. Pitty how little the gift of life turned out to be. She should have listened to her mom's warnings about her so called "friend." Live, learn, walk away, and don't look back.

[@marqueldeaneee]

I feel bad for the defendant. I would have forgave every debt she owed me if she gave me a kidney. Hell I wouldn’t have been alive to collect the money anyway. 😒😂

[@tammi67able]

Lol that’s the truth