Going Overboard

The plaintiff says she and the defendant were roommates, but things didn’t work out with the temperamental defendant. She’s suing for the value of her belongings after the defendant threw them out on the street. The defendant says the plaintiff is lying. She alleges her former friend stole her items and donated them, so she’s countersuing for their worth.
Case: 25-425
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court

[@bjohnson1149]

I totally believe the plaintiff. Defendant's body language and eye rolling speak volumes about who she is.

[@joeylozano4215]

"She's crazy, but I don't want to bring that up cause I don't disrespect anyone." Says the angry lunatic that threw somebody's stuff off a balcony. She's never going to learn, she will always live in her wrapped little mind.

[@amberthomas3939]

I was thinking the same thing!

[@questioneverything8572]

Narcissists NEVER learn from their mistakes. They are perpetual victims. Even if she was to go outside and randomly shoot a stranger, that stranger would somehow be in the fault.

[@abochen2]

The people that say that, tend to be instigators.

[@KaiCluster]

It might be possible that she threw those things out the window because she got fed up with her. If they weren't talking, it was because of an ongoing issue.. We can't really know the whole story by watching a 15 minute clip of a case.

[@betrayall1011]

You for saying this because I just literally what I just said when I heard her say that

[@benjie128]

Defendant: she changed when she came back from Italy. Translation: plantiff was no longer a doormat.

[@peterlee584]

That's the vibe I got too. The Defendant was just upset that the plaintiff grew a spine and stood up for herself.

[@annereidy7981]

Yes, should have looked for your comment, you said it better than I did!

[@kafkal2281]

@@annereidy7981 Did the exact same thing - great minds...lol 😉

[@peekaboots01]

Why is nobody mad at Daphne for only giving 4 days notice and leaving them to deal with all her stuff, instead they threw her a going away party.

[@PrincessZaire100]

There’s probably a very good reason why she had to up and leave. No one just ups and leaves to another country and leave all there stuff behind

[@guccilady1017]

Because they wanted her stuff

[@hadley407]

‘She’s crazy’ said the woman that threw her shit off the balcony

[@Cheri022491]

I swear when the judge was tearing the defendant a new one she looked like she was about to cry. I wonder how much of what the judge said actually sticks... Bet her ego is bruised too.. Communication is key. Even if you strongly dislike the person, good clear communication could save your butt from things like this happening...

[@badgurl5758]

How immature the defendant is and yet she’s old enough to drink 🙄

[@RileyCullen1]

And vote

[@enniruth]

and enrol for war.

[@xoxolaineyoxox]

The defendant was dead wrong. Her friend didn’t have to “try to make her look crazy” her behavior was crazy. I wish the plaintiff had gotten more.

[@urnotavictim8134]

Was just coming to type this hahahaha

[@wvrjl]

Me too. I think she should have got $1,000, and the rest of it should have been punitive damages. She didn't get a criminal record for this, she needs to get some real consequences (although I'm not sure the losers actually pay in this show / binding arbitration).

[@sandrawestley4193]

@@wvrjlyour right, it’s not binding. Someone was saying they are actors, but that’s not the case, they are real cases and real people, but the arbitration is not binding.

[@AP-uo7sp]

First impression: defendant did it. You can see the attitude!

[@spacecase8791]

From a mile away lol

[@Laura-tp8wz]

Complete entitlement

[@valvano304]

Wow, the Defendant really thought she was justified in destruction of property because the plaintiff yelled at her. It was a miscommunication. It sounds like the plaintiff realized the defendant wasn't a positive influence on her life and cut it off.

[@denabee5232]

Sad

[@tanyadealmeida7104]

.

[@mymobilebuddy4392]

Someone had some anxiety issues it sounds like.

[@so_many_women_so_little_ti2833]

I agree with you. You know from watching people court I learned a lot,how to protect myself, prepare documents forthecourtjust incase I need to go,... I can be a lawyer and open an office. Anyone wants me to be his lawyer?😁😁

[@entheo302]

So let me get this straight. Defendant is salty because she has poor communication skills and expects others to just know that she wanted the bins. Mmm okay. Let me know how that works out as a life strategy for you

[@josephwillcoxson7334]

My high school English teacher gave me this wisdom: You have your friends and you have your roommates.

[@eangel74]

Más sabe el viejo que por diablo

[@Pepper9873]

This literally could have been avoided if the defendant said "Hey, I'm keeping the stuff in Daphne's room, so I'll clean it out." She knew they had to leave so why in the world would she think that the plaintiff would just leave the stuff if it wasn't claimed?

[@LeeoGoneWild]

Maybe it’s a girl thing or their age, but I had roommates in my early 20s and one that I wasn’t talking to, would literally avoid whenever I heard them in the home, but I absolutely communicated very clearly through text to avoid any confusion on moving out day haha and because of the communication, things went very smoothly despite us not talking or getting along.

[@JasShanelle]

Exactly…but then she says but she could’ve asked me. What could the plaintiff have asked if she didn’t know.

[@Lisa111999888]

But the plaintiff had no right to donate things that weren’t hers

[@JasShanelle]

@@Lisa111999888 they didn’t belong to anyone, the other roommate who left said anyone can have it. The dependent was immature and petty for not announcing what she wanted. Her loss.

[@sashabenoit1518]

@@Lisa111999888 the girls who stuff it was already moved out prior and abandoned all her things there and told them they could do whatever they wanted with the stuff and it was moving day so yeah it was the responsibility of the remaining girls living there to get it out of the apartment. She was totally in the right. Did you even watch the case because all of this was clearly said multiple times? Honestly just curious because I am so confused why you would say that..

[@kimberli3858]

I love when she uses Spanish sayings because it reminds me of what my parents say

[@derkiathomas7748]

I was just thinking this too!

[@kristinadanielle4031]

I Love it too!!

[@potter8488]

Just because your friends, even long time friends. Doesn't mean you'll get along when you live together.

[@elisabetpurve2908]

Someone said "The fastest way to lose a friend is to move in together"

[@zaymathew8203]

You said it! 🙌🏼

[@spacecase8791]

So much truth to this

[@Synch9256]

you're

[@potter8488]

@@Synch9256 you must have lots of friends. Correcting people the way you do.

[@MH-gw6ux]

Someone is mad because they didn’t get to go study abroad in Italy. Entire time she stood there with her hand on her hip in a court room. Better learn how to control her anger or she’ll be on another episode for not paying someone back who bailed her out.

[@Channel-JJ]

Fingers crossed maybe she'll turn up on an episode of Cops

[@peterlee584]

@@Channel-JJ I wouldn't be surprised,, with a temper like hers

[@yung1717]

@@Channel-JJ why would you hope for that? Weird

[@Channel-JJ]

@@yung1717 Yung Yung are you jealous? Ok fine fingers crossed maybe Yung will turn up on an episode of Cops, feel better.

[@rogerroo]

@@yung1717 lol for our entertainment 😂

[@ButtonsCasey]

The judge showed compassion for the defendant when she noticed the defendant was about to cry.

[@nismoj14]

The judge made her pay $350 just to teach her a lesson.

[@lenc3970]

Yeah no $hit Sherlock

[@peterknighton2757]

I lived with my best mate for 10 years. Was an absolutely brilliant decade of our lives.

[@fintyeli3]

Ikr, like it should be.

[@peterknighton2757]

@@fintyeli3 exactly own rooms and bathrooms and shared living kitchen dining areas. If you used the others food or borrowed stuff put it back or replace it simples

[@Channel-JJ]

How is Nigel doing these days?

[@rosem5361]

@@Channel-JJ we’re only making plans for Nigel😅

[@peterknighton2757]

@@Channel-JJ you mean Jeffery dahmer…

[@they-live1]

defendant is insane, people stay away from this nightmare of a person

[@chickstar69duplicity35]

She looks insane! 🤣

[@elainevankat5353]

@@chickstar69duplicity35 She looks like she has a bad temper!

[@LawsonPatterson]

The plaintiff is going to be so much better off without having that nasty witch as her friend. Unbelievable 😳

[@jackjules7552]

Never live with friends. That is why marriage is a bad idea.

[@joshcx7]

Jealousy is the reason why the defendant hates the plaintiff. Plaintiff is prettier and she went to Italy😂

[@therob827]

Definitely not prettier

[@reneeliverson8413]

@@therob827 she is, the other one is covered by the make up.

[@therob827]

@@reneeliverson8413 they both have make up on

[@reneeliverson8413]

@@therob827 well, I was saying, the one from Ecuador has much more. It's the type of make that once you remove it, the face looks different.

[@Maya.6868]

@@therob827 the plaintiff is prettier and smarter, the defendant needs a therapy to learn to manage her anger issues

[@CH-px1fw]

“She’s crazy” but I threw her stuff off the balcony. “I don’t disrespect anyone” but she she… she…she…she…. Wow! Maturity level of a middle schooler.

[@Pinchington]

"It was deeper than the tacos" Words to live by

[@mclaybry]

I have a friend with a daughter the same age as the litigants. She was moving out of her parents house and into an apartment with 3 other girls, all her closest friends. I told her, "Don't expect to be friends in 6 months" and sure enough- they all hate each other now and broke their lease to move out. It's a shame, but it happens way too often, especially with young women.

[@lokita6192002]

The defendant made herself look crazy

[@LeolaGlamour]

Um 😐 she is crazy

[@Synch9256]

The defendant has real anger issues. Fancy behaving like that in court. What would she be like in a REALLY SERIOUS situation??

[@al5945]

"I'm not gonna get into that because I don't disrespect anybody." 🙄🙄

[@peterlee584]

Yeah, I just throw their stuff out the window and break it!!

[@LeolaGlamour]

She’s not very bright

[@mamathemeat]

She’s ghetto af

[@tamekadavis6641]

Choose your roommate wisely.

[@matthewmorales94]

100% agree, don't always go off looks, breast size and the thickness of their buttocks. I learned this the hard way, no more females as roommates ....

[@AT-jm4dl]

You don't really know a person until you live with them.

[@Nottodaygoddamnit]

I feel like she went to Italy and stopped letting her walk all over her and that’s why she thinks “she’s changed”

[@msenglish8382]

defendant is not as fly as she thinks she is

[@lunasaucedo5348]

I wish Judge Milian would be my mom. I love when she goes on mom mode !!! She is the best !!!!

[@jcymngo]

LOL Neighbours freaking out rhat there's dead white girl in BK. We don't want that drama. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@thebalderthor4884]

She’s mad at her friend for laying down in a hallway? Wow.

[@CarrieRay]

I can’t stop laughing at the woman on the street who has her hair over her face-Harvey pretended he didn’t see her! 😂

[@JasShanelle]

Exactly why I can never have a roommate.

[@bluebutterfly244]

Defendant was really working hard to convince Kurt that she was not the "crazy" one 😂😂nice try. And that lady still got the hair in her face out there with Harvey!

[@ultimatecouponlady]

My favorite part of this case is 12:00-12:15. Love those words about people who are older! Facts!

[@billmoran3219]

Sounds as if plaintiff has become wiser with age and out grown her friendship with the defendant and the defendant is mad because she’s stuck in the mud. Defendant certainly thinks she above all this when really she is the cause of all this!

[@mikebravo3527]

The way she said zero made my day.

[@Tangaroa775]

Defendant didn’t like the judge giving her advice 😂

[@manthony777]

I agree. 🇷🇺

[@reformcongress]

Hey Defendant, you are crazy!

[@j3pelfrey]

I threw her property out a window and then walked downstairs and broke some more. The nerve of the last defendant to call anyone crazy.

[@PlugJh]

Love that JM made a fool of the defendant!! Made her feel real small! 😂😂😂

[@shannontrent3702]

That's the longest dude has ever let anyone talk in the hall, LOL!

[@BobBlumenfeld]

Defendant still doesn't believe she did anything wrong. She was angry, so she was entitled to trash the plaintiff's stuff.

[@devi229]

Sounds like the defendant is mad that her friend was broadening her horizons and felt left behind. She’s got some serious screws loose to think that tacos is the reason for them falling out.

[@MRGETEM247]

What I got from the Exit Interviews is that the the Defendant used to take advantage of the Plaintiff but when the Plaintiff came back from Italy she was more wiser and started standing up for herself and the Defendant didn’t like that .. yeah I’m glad the Plaintiff got away from her .

[@amjedhatu542]

Narcissists don’t see their own behavior as a problem. They only see peoples reactions after they do things.

[@A-A-Ron1823]

It’s true though. Don’t room with your best friend, it sounds good, but you will learn a lot about them. I wouldn’t do it ever again 😂

[@lovetatyanna2221]

Definitely have anger issues lmaooo and the fact that she still thinks she's right

[@dunkinjunkie5868]

She's your best friend and you destroy her belongings because you couldn't get some free storage containers? She was only your best friend when it was good for her! I hope she learns that you don't need friends like that !!

[@pattyneff4624]

The defendant is not even aware that her behavior is outrageous and she even tries to rationalize it.

[@jenelizabeth7822]

I hope anyone the defendant dates sees this…what a lunatic

[@tunisiancrochetchannel]

The defendant is an immature emotional brat. She still doesn't see that she was wrong. She will be a perpetual victim. Hopefully, she will see the light one day.

[@nunyabidness7313]

The defendant is just a hater because the plaintiff went to Italy. Some "friends" are just secret jealous enemies.

[@a.konadu4010]

Age doesn't equal maturity. The defendant has issues.

[@Laura-tp8wz]

Good for the plaintiff for donating to AmVets.

[@dharmawannab]

Did she really just say "no but she could have asked me too" at 7:47 ??? Putting it on someone else to ask if she wants stuff that isn't hers??!! Make it make sense. The Defendant just *assumed* the plaintiff could read her mind and knew she wanted Daphne's stuff....... Well we all know what happens when you *Assume*

[@mahailiabrown3972]

Miscommunication basically

[@magicworld3242]

The defendant is just evil. I really feel sorry for any guy that gets involved with her. Once he ends their relationship, she's going to cause havoc in his life.

[@lindaalvarez8855]

I was so glad that Judge Milian gave the Defendant hell for her nasty & nasty behavior against the Plaintiff. The Defendant definitely needs anger management!

[@coffeeaddictexpress5038]

Trust me people when there is No communication, miscommunication is expected. Don’t assume what other person is thinking.

[@benjie128]

So defendant asks daphne if she can have xyz. Daphne said sure. Wasnt communicated to plantiff, who only knew stuff had to be cleared bc their tenancy was over. So plantiff cleared stuff out.

[@shadowxoxo]

And Plaintiff should have double checked that it was okay to give away. 🤷‍♀️ bad communications all around.

[@mamathemeat]

The only burden of communication rested on the defendant who wanted some of the stuff. No one needs to be hyper vigilant in second guessing everything that’s already been discussed.

[@IvyLeagu]

The defendant had some nerve, childish and ignorant.. A bully if you asked me because she thought she could throw another's property away. Liar and plain stupid. Bins, 5.99 bins sounds like a broke girl issue

[@barbarapaton4005]

Communication was the problem here. Foolish and petty women, the defendant had attitude.

[@ScarfaceIsMissingYou]

The defendant is off...definitely entitled.

[@angelah7094]

Good morning and happy Monday everyone... I hope everyone had a wonderful weekend😉

[@lisaaddas7653]

"Monica".....enough said.

[@projectionv.accountability1010]

They saw a white girl & they thought she was dead. ell oh ell Yeah, hilarious... if you have the maturity level of a peanut shell. Defendant needs to grow up and realize she's not 13.

[@jluc9456]

The Defendant is a spoiled, entitled, disrespectful, arrogant child. Her parents did a horrible job in raising her!

[@ericasalazar3905]

She matured and grew, and the defendant was jealous

[@adamdavis5243]

i don't disrespect anyone...except that time i threw all her stuff out thew window. oh and also she's crazy.

[@user-vb3fb1rg3c]

If they weren't on speaking terms, the defendant could have written a note to let everyone know what belonged to her. She was too evil to even do that.

[@carmenultra1]

Girl, you should have told her about the items you wanted instead of playing the silent treatment game. 😂

[@kafkal2281]

"She went to Italy and she changed", code for "I can't push her around anymore".

[@inthemouthofmadness5910]

The defendant saying she's crazy in the hall and saying she's not going to get into because she doesn't disrespect anyone. Well by her saying she's crazy on national TV, she just disrespected her!

[@gaylewhauwhau3972]

No self control ,stupid actions have consequences .got Shamed in Court.😂 Good Ruling JM.❤

[@annettehamilton1969]

In Jamaica we call it see me and come live with me is two different things

[@wvrjl]

That defendant is going to have a criminal record by the time she is 40, because if I would have been the plaintiff, she would already have one. I also think the plaintiff should have asked for punitive damages and she should have gotten it. That defendant hasn't gotten any real punishment for her actions, and without real consequences the behaviour doesn't change.

[@Sunintheam8]

Exactly since this show pays judgement when the plaintiff wins.

[@annward4149]

Plaintive is CRAZY yet defendant is one who through her stuff over the balcony. Defendant 🤪

[@TerriLew]

Wow, defendant is a brat!

[@shurdell5014]

She literally threw someone’s things out of a second story window and she’s calling the other girl crazy?!?! Don’t throw stones lady. I feel bad for her next roommate(s) and/or boyfriend. One day, she’s going to do the wrong thing to the right person and she’ll learn a hard lesson.

[@KrazyVideoChick]

Dear Defendant, Grow up.

[@janicester]

YOU ARE CRAZY LOCO!!!! And the Judge ruled correctly.

[@SteveMichaelson]

0:05 “…. And they were roommates!” 😂

[@manthony777]

This case was too much excitement before lunch. ajajajajaja 😂

[@chrstphrmtthw16]

White girl down in Brooklyn 🤣🤣🤣

[@Channel-JJ]

😂😂

[@natinati5800]

😭

[@somebodywatchin]

How’s the plaintiff supposed to know the defendant wanted that stuff?!?!!

[@LeolaGlamour]

If she does that to a friend imagine what she’d do to a boyfriend 😮

[@spacecase8791]

Good point 😂

[@elvickRULES]

“She’s crazy, I’m not going to get disrespectful.” (Paraphrased) Too late.

[@griffin2263]

Defendant is clearly a horrible person ..

[@martinaanandam3620]

😂😂 no one can make anyone look crazy. If you ARE crazy, it shows. Even if someone had wronged me, my first response is not revenge.

[@nancylenau8997]

The defendant says” she is crazy” so she show her by acting crazy herself. Wow!

[@StationOnLife]

The defendant has anger issues and a lot growing up to do. If she could destroyed someone else’s property over trivial stuffs, imagine, if she were being dumped by a boyfriend or has issues with co-workers/employers.

[@stuffykong]

Yeah, I wish she would have met the judge's eyes when she was sharing her thoughts with her, almost like as a mom to a daughter. She's going to learn the hard way and after more mistakes, is likely.

[@StationOnLife]

@@stuffykong Agreed! she’s going to learn the hard way like “in jail”.

[@misscriss80]

Defendant is 100% jealous of the plaintiff, plain and simple.

[@kevinsimpson7324]

It be killing me how they be coming with all this paperwork that dont mean nothing 🤣.

[@WarGrowlmon18]

There SHOULD be a police report!!! Against the DEFENDANT!!!

[@everett-tnredsfan]

Defendant still thought she was right when this was over means nothing the judge said was listened to at all. Like a petulant child.

[@sandramika6710]

Who's crazy ??? LOL, that stuff wasn't even hers, and if she wanted any of it, she should have taken it and put in in her room.