Super-Easy Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe

A delicious creamy filling sandwiched between two soft and chewy oatmeal cookies, this homemade Oatmeal Cream Pie recipe is way better than store-bought. These delightful little treats will remind you of your childhood, snacking on Little Debbies. They’re so easy to make from scratch and are deliciously satisfying to eat. And by the way this is the best way to eat oatmeal cookies, so indulgent and delicious!
RECIPE: preppykitchen.com/oatmeal-cre...
PRE-ORDER MY BOOK!
www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/AS...
www.barnesandnoble.com/w/prep...
www.indiebound.org/book/97819...
www.chapters.indigo.ca/en-ca/...
www.target.com/p/preppy-kitch...
SUBSCRIBE ► / @preppykitchen
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
ADD ME ON:
Tiktok: vm.tiktok.com/ZMJxw57rA/
Instagram: / preppykitchen
Pinterest: / preppykitchen
Website: www.PreppyKitchen.com
Amazon: www.amazon.com/shop/preppykit...
Facebook: / preppykitchen

[@i.a.7555]

Just wanted to let everyone know that I made these gluten free (alright my mom actually made them!) -- She used the exact same quantities but with gluten free flour and oats and they turned out amazing-- both gluten free and not gluten free eaters said they were the best cookies they ever ate! Thanks to a nice lady on here who let me know she made them gluten free and they turned out great. Can only recommend!

[@hummermama]

We have made many preppy kitchen recipes gluten free and they are amazing 😁 sometimes we have to add an extra egg or yolk for more moisture as gluten free flours can be drier.

[@i.a.7555]

@@hummermama Thank you, this is great to know! :)

[@theEHall17]

Hey! Thank you for adding this comment/message. I have gut sensitivities, so too much wheat starch can cause problems, so if I can adapt any wheat flour recipe to non-wheat flour gets bonus points! :)

[@hummermama]

Ya....we just use an all purpose gluten free flour...we usually decrease sugar as well 🤪 and fiddle with the moisture a bit....we like that his recipes are so perfect that we can get pretty close ❤️ you prob already have practice fiddling with recipes since everything has to be altered.

[@dhatch04]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@thecramptons]

Omg…you need to do a series where you do every little Debbie cake!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@davec5312]

Yes!

[@rachb3889]

I love this idea! ❤

[@lisagilbert8497]

Please ❤Christmas tree cakes

[@rachelbuster2826]

Yessss

[@candyluna2929]

Yes!!!❤❤

[@socalsal627]

These were my favorite treats when I was pregnant with my daughter. She's now 27 and I thought it would be so fun to make these with her from scratch! When I found out that there was a Preppy Kitchen video on it I literally squealed! Can't wait to try this, thank you! :) ❤

[@carolinea3899]

I laughed when your husband came on screen to eat the cookie. 😆 They look delicious!

[@nancyharman4795]

Weird Yoda quote came to mind: How you get so big eating food of this kind? Those cookies must work GREAT!

[@Mia199603]

Haha he had this bratty demanding energy about him "I want the cookie, I take the cookie" :D

[@Itsant33]

Seemed kinda choreographed

[@puchunful]

I made these for dessert tonight. Definitely true to the title of the video. So easy to make! The hard part was waiting for the cookies to cool. I added 2oz of cream cheese to my frosting for a bit more richness. This is going on my "make again REAL soon" list. Thanks John! Now back to binging the rest of the baking/cooking catalog you have. xD

[@acoustic.guitar.gal501]

My brother absolutely LOVES oatmeal cream pies! I am most defiantly going to make these for him. You always put a smile on my face and I love your channel!!! Have a lovely rest of the week :)

[@Dobr3967]

John, this might be your best video yet. These cookies were super easy to make and absolutely delicious. Thanks for teaching us!

[@SLYkutie]

This is one of my Dad's favorite sweets. He passed away in February and it's such bittersweet memories when it comes to food he always loved. Thanks for the recipe. ❤️

[@theresabergstrom3782]

I made these for my husband today for his bday, since these are his favorite Little Debbie's. They are freaking delicious! I just couldn't tell if it was supposed to make 12 individual cookies or 24 to make 12 sandwiches. I had 10 sandwiches and even with being generous with the filling I had about 1/4 cup left over.

[@theresamimnaugh1190]

I just love your videos. You really give the home baker the confidence to “give it a try”. Thanks❣️

[@wendymarie7151]

Wow John, Little Debbie would be so jealous. These look incredibly delicious!! I am definitely going to purchase your book, you always make these amazing recipes. This I am definitely going to try, I love LD oatmeal cream pies. These put those to shame!! Thanks John. 😉😉😉👏👏👏👏

[@froot595]

HE. HAS. A. BOOK.?! NOBODY TOLD ME

[@wendymarie7151]

@@froot595 take a peek in the counter behind John, you'll see it.

[@shannonkayatani3001]

Gotta grab this book too. Been following John's recipes for over a year now. Mahalo John 🤙

[@KarolinaPietryka]

Little Debbie’s cookies are fucking nasty.

[@user-lh9pj5px3i]

The book is a very good one...perfect as a wedding gift

[@EnhanceHerBeauty]

I was looking for oatmeal recipes for next week’s menu !! These are beautiful 😍🥰

[@mayraaristud4514]

My grandkids are going to love it 🥰 thank you !

[@moonshynegirl172]

I'm am so happy for this recipe! I stopped eating the store ones because I am working on eating less yucky chemicals. This is perfect. Thank you.

[@barbarawhite2283]

These are wonderful and really easy. Thanks John. Love the cook book. Thank you. God Bless. 😊

[@lauraforconi9111]

You are fantastic!!!!!!!! FROM ONE CHEF TO ANOTHER, YOU AND CHEF JOHN ARE BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@carltoningram3773]

so glad to see a recipe for this style of oatmeal cookies - my favorite cookies ever were the Little Debbie PB&J Oatmeal pies, and now I can try to recreate them!

[@tay9sdaughter121]

Yes this looks delicious. I love Oatmeal Cream Pies. I will definitely makes these. Thank you!! You're AWESOME

[@lenascraftingroom7753]

Thank you for bringing something from my childhood to your site. I look forward to making these.

[@lokiofdohmend996]

These are my favorite snack! Thanks for the recipe.

[@WhaterPrincess]

This are amazing!!!!! I have made them a few times and share at work! They where a hit everybody keeps asking for recipe and I kinda don’t wanna share it 🤭 love this recipe so much ❤❤❤

[@thinkuthink]

CAN'T wait to try!! Thank you John!

[@vencebuchanan]

As a kid I remember love going to the neighborhood corner store buying oatmeal cream pie delicious 😋 . Thanks for sharing John now I can make them myself.

[@popeyeschknisfknawsum]

Till this day I still do I'm now 38 years old

[@vencebuchanan]

@@popeyeschknisfknawsum I don't blame you. There absolutely delicious! 😉

[@tessamarie8698]

You may never see this but my god you are a talented and well rounded man. I remember your bar tending videos when I was learning for a job a long time ago. Now I’m in love with baking and cooking and you are just everywhere! With all the best recipes every single time! Im sure you’ve got one happy family. Keep doing what you’re doing you are a star.

[@christopherfelipe60]

Wow delicious 😋 thanks John

[@natalijaparadiso7566]

They look absolutely delicious John ....great recipe ❤️

[@AlanStephens]

Thank You!! My daughter and I made for Thanksgiving desert. Amazing !

[@Nope-fd1sq]

They look amazing!

[@lindacope7344]

Another winner! Something about an oatmeal cookie this time of year that just makes me want to fill the kitchen with yummy aromas! That and a cup of mulled cider makes for a delicious snack.

[@DrEnginerd1]

I made these a few weeks ago and they were really good. I’m about to make another batch without adding the filling, just the cookies

[@user-hg5wc4co5i]

おいしそう！ looks delicious .

[@pastorvega9056]

Must! Resist! Urge! To! Make! And ! DEVOUR!!! 😭😭😭 they look SOO GOOD!!!!❤️❤️❤️

[@Hyde103]

Hey thanks for making this video! I don't really cook often but I saw this video pop up in my recommended and I had to try them out. They are incredible! The only reference I had to go off of for oatmeal cookies with creme was those little debbies which aren't bad, but there is no comparison. If anyone is thinking about making these just do it and I promise you won't regret it.

[@jessieparker6004]

These came out so delicious!! Thank you for posting this

[@justme11B]

John, I love your recipes! My wife and I have stolen many of them as our own because they are perfect! Thank you sir

[@ryangraziano4606]

The store bought ones are my favorite so I am REALLY excited for these

[@wendylcm7643]

I just finished putting these together. I made them for a surprise for my husband and can’t wait to try them when he gets home

[@streamguyentertainment]

Now these are my kind of snacks . Thanks for sharing this

[@sharonl3722]

Oh be still my heart! 😍😍I can’t wait to make these! Thank you for another Aaaaamazing video!😎❤️

[@jmarcos1008]

Heavenly 😊

[@kingdomtalkchannel]

I did it they came out perfect. I will change the cream next time a little sweet for me but turn out delicious. I had to edit and add I purchased this mixer OMG absolutely fabulous.

[@MoonLight-ih3dz]

Most of your recipes are easy & delicious at the same , tried yesterday the orange cake was yummy, on the top of that your videos are full of positive energy, all the best 4 you John .

[@fabesohoulihan]

im making these this weekend. Thank you!!!

[@vasiliahilios4013]

these were incredible. I added about 1.5 oz cream cheese into the frosting with the butter and only 200 grams powdered sugar. I need to look into what will stabilize the frosting a bit more but it was all amazing. the extra filling i’m freezing for cinnamon rolls but if you don’t want extra i’d make half.

[@NaudiaVillalba]

John I literally spent an hour watching different oatmeal cream pie recipes yesterday and now you, the king of recipes, post a video today 🥰

[@user-lh9pj5px3i]

This is the best recipe I've found. Don't need to look further

[@MatthewLawrence886]

Looks so delicious

[@aaronfuegopop]

definitely making these soon i cant wait!

[@marmantole]

That looks soooo good! Definitely making these this weekend

[@jmarcos1008]

These cookies are the best, thank you.

[@jujubee7351]

I made these cookies two times now, I added chocolate chips . The best cookie ever !

[@ritatannehill7487]

Ooooo yummy variation ❤

[@CarpeDiem-ii5fu]

Thank you!! Oatmeal cream pies are a favorite in our house.

[@justpeachyAK907]

I will have to make these someday! How simple!

[@shannarobertson5975]

I look forward to making these!!

[@curtischildress9580]

I buy this kind of oatmeal sandwich cookies all the time for hiking & biking trips. I always wanted to make them but didn't have a recipe. Thanks!

[@chiot2875]

I love these, I rarely bake but I’ll have to try this recipe soon

[@elizabethsyddall3124]

First thing I have made from this channel, WOW I will be trying many more recipes.

[@borauniverseot7873]

I'm definitely trying this tomorrow.

[@jujubee7351]

Just made these tonight, I added 1 cup of butter on accident lol. They turned out large and flat but so good! Reminded me of oatmeal lace cookies . Will make again using the right measurements❤ thank you John Smart & Final sells the Grandma brand of molasses John uses .

[@DaveTexas]

When my brother and I were in elementary school, my mother would pack a Little Debbie oatmeal pie in our lunchboxes about twice a week. My brother LOVED them! I thought they were OK but I preferred anything peanut butter. I might have to make a batch of these to take for Thanksgiving; I bet my brother would love them. I might, too!

[@loriannperry5302]

I love your channel. Thank you for sharing. I make these but with the molasses I add a couple teaspoons of apple or pear butter amazing. Thanks again

[@luciaalegria752]

They look delicious! ❤️

[@Solomon1yez]

I made these and they are so good.

[@hannarose_]

oh my gosh this looks fantastic!! im going to try to wake up at 5am so i can make this before school!! thanks @preppykitchen!!!

[@DiaDia18]

Very nice recipie John! They looks amazing and so yummy! Have a nice day and good weekend! 👍👏🍴

[@iyabomarvel8506]

Made these but with brown butter. And didn't make the frosting cause I don't like it. But these are my new favorite cookies!!! Soo delicious!!!

[@gabriellabennett7024]

Why do I watch these delicious recipes too late at night? Now I won't sleep well until I make these! Your lucky family!

[@dianalucenti8709]

Yum yum! I’m going to give it a try!!!!

[@candicemorrison3442]

I have to try this. It look so yummy!

[@trainyourbrain99]

Tempting 😋 I love the way of your cooking!Your recipes makes me crave even more.. You're so great dude 😍

[@jll.vlntn01]

Omgg yummm ! I always enjoy your videos 😍😊 a thank you from Amsterdam !

[@angybean13]

Looks amazing!! I love a good cream pie. 🖤

[@gojiberry7201]

This looks great!

[@kimberleeoneal]

My husband LOVES oatmeal cream pies... I'm making these for him tomorrow ❤️❤️

[@akcirapoo3569]

That kitchen is so organized, clean, efficient and organized👨‍🍳💃🏾🕺🏾

[@bloodwolfgurl]

Your partner coming around to sample the cookie was pure gold! Very funny. Those look so good! Thank you for showing us how to make these!

[@sharonjones1880]

Omg…. These are one of my favorites since I was a kid my dad would put in our lunches.

[@roserichardson159]

OMG!!! Those are my favorite

[@ashleytwardosky3827]

🎉🎉🎉 We just made them. They’re delicious. A big hit with the kids. Very very sweet. But doi! It’s a crème pie… For my personal taste, I think I’d add more than a pinch salt or even 1/8-1/4 tsp salt to try to balance it.

[@anabaker9810]

I open youtube and I see this amazing new, another of your videos! Love your recipes 🤭

[@minhhop3208]

Looks so good ! Thanks for sharing ! Amazing channel !

[@ritatannehill7487]

The mother of one of my dear friends from childhood made the most amazing oatmeal crème pies - this recipe brings back that memory - I will need to make these ❤

[@BrodyStag]

We've all sinned. Repent and trust that Jesus died for your sins on the cross!

[@RuffiRaggaMuff]

This is a must try for me! I can’t wait

[@windermere2330]

I have stopped eating all added sugar 17 days ago. I threw out all sugar & flour. Now I want to make this recipe so badly. Looks so good!

[@journeytravelers5420]

Bless you , wonderful recipe once again , perfect for cookies and both oatmeal cream pies Brilliant !

[@BrodyStag]

We’ve all sinned, trust in Jesus and that he died for our sins on the cross. Our works can’t save us but Jesus can! Much love.

[@tomdececco2806]

Thanks John - these look great 👍 👍👍

[@themadcoachman]

Thy look great , gotta try that recipe

[@cookedbooks]

You hit this one waaaaaaay outta the park!!!

[@Melissa-dn5kd]

Looks delicious.

[@nosrah9660]

Seeing how pure and wholesome these comments are, I’m going to keep my mouth shut.

[@victoriacrossan1101]

ughh literally one of my favourite desserts that I have the LEAST often. I'll be making these for sure 🥰

[@pmafamily]

Very nice recipe brother thanks for sharing beautiful presentation

[@marvelboy74]

The Little Debbies are such a guilty pleasure and one is never enough. These look much more satisfying.

[@bakebite7374]

Looks soo delicious ❤❤❤ Thanks for sharing this supper recipe 💞💞

[@cowgirl515]

Yesterday I received my Cooks magazine & they have a recipe for these. For the crème they used marshmallow crème which sounded yuckie & I wanted to make these for the grandchildren so I head to KZbin to find a better recipe & what do I find you making these! Can’t wait to try these.

[@deborahojapinwa7834]

I just saw this on the blog post!!!! Thanks John❤❤❤

[@kateskeys]

I love you John. You rock!

[@patriciahartless2095]

Hello John . Your whoopie pies . Looks so pretty and delicious . I got the recipe to make them . Thanks for sharing . Have A Wonderful Evening . To You And Family .🍪🍪😋

[@TeresasSweets]

OMGG I've always wanted to make homemade oatmeal cream pies! The Little Debbie ones are so good but they have tons of preservatives so this will be better!

[@user-lh9pj5px3i]

Much better! 👍

[@camilletomer]

😋 Yuuuuum! Thanks for the recipe! 💕

[@JurassicParker13]

Holy cow, those look great! Thanks for sharing