Who Is Giulia’s Monster? | Pixar Theory

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Ok so who else has the Pixar Theory Song stuck in their head (again)?

[@Acnhfan]

First

[@Josephiah24]

Me

[@denierb1584]

Literally sing it when I do the dishes just on repeat. Haha

[@zoguy6988]

Your theme song slaps real.

[@orecula]

Hi

[@Dan-.-9]

Giulia’s Dad deserves a fictional dad of the year award for just IMMEDIATELY accepting what he’s hated for so long just because of his daughter

[@wolffisu]

And I think him and Alberto's bond also helped. He accepted him for who and what he was regardless of what he looked like cause he knew he was a good person. I imagine he can relate as he grew up with only one arm and was othered by society.

[@end_slayer]

Ikr

[@kerchow1837]

Up there with people like doofinshmirtz and I dunno Ned Flanders that works

[@pqcowboychanel]

Doof has won the last ten

[@Sp3ctralI]

@@wolffisu I thought Giulia’s dad was in the war and is a veteran.

[@michaelmcatee221]

I submit new evidence! Julia’s cat is an older cat he was most likely around when her monster was active and he despised Luca for his shapeshifting ability. More evidence for Randal!

[@mel-overthinks]

*THIS* is a great point!!

[@CruzingAroundTheBlock]

BIG BRAIN MOMENT!!!

[@whiterabbit3050]

If it was Randal how come he has to scare Andy and her if randall is Andy monster theory is correct and how Randal will scared Julia ok after andy door was destroyed the corporation sent randall a new kid to scare and her name is julia

[@whiterabbit3050]

Yes and how he is gonna scare both andy and her(I am a little late but though I kinda agree on this)

[@kingg3122]

well they shapeshifted into fish so…

[@redgiant7747]

Alberto did the exact pose we’ve seen Randal do CONSTANTLY, so I fully believe this. Kinda sad that Gulia was so friendly to Alberto and he gave her a whole ptsd flashback. The way she shouted “don’t hurt us ” while standing behind Luca makes so much more sense now. She didn’t even see Alberto she just saw Randal.

[@SuperSwordman1]

Dude I didn't even notice that! Awesome catch!

[@bumblebeeproductions1673]

Dude If it’s cannon that just makes that scene all the more sad

[@average_enby]

Wow.

[@madkirk7431]

Oh wow

[@Rachel-uy7pv]

TRUEEEE OMG

[@jediwolfgirl]

We’ve also seen how nimble Randal is, climbing on ceilings and such, so I think he would be able to get through her room without knocking over all her books and belongings - even despite how small of a space it is

[@incendiumaquila7605]

When he said how small it was Randal was my first guess so happy

[@king_t33th]

Yeah i thought about that too

[@PlatformingCyndaquil]

And consider the similarities between Randal and Luca and Alberto.😉

[@incendiumaquila7605]

@@PlatformingCyndaquil I was thinking the tail mostly

[@PlatformingCyndaquil]

@@incendiumaquila7605 That's the tip of the ice berg. They're all reptilian, and Randal even has a similar color scheme to Alberto in sea monster form. That might even be why she sort of freaked out seeing Alberto in true form, it brought a flashback of Randal in her room.😉

[@natasha6113]

Giulia's reaction to Luca's reveal didn't scare her as much as Alberto's did, which I think is further evidence that she thought her monster was back, because Randall and Alberto's colour scheme is very similar.

[@zbroadcast3414]

It even helps that Alberto took a hunched pose while baring his teeth. Very Randall-esque.

[@Shannon-ty6jg]

and it was dusk with shadows so that probably made Alberto's blue-ish color scheme look like a darker purple, which is more of Randalls color scheme

[@brianmcfadden5740]

Oh yea...

[@warriorcatsfan6906]

@@Shannon-ty6jg do you think Randal is Alberto's father? because Alberto and Randal have the same color

[@zimonzieclown1633]

@@warriorcatsfan6906 How would that work, though? You think Randall had the time to shag a sea monster while on the job?

[@markosziss6452]

So these are the results: Andy’s monster: Randal Riley’s monster: George Carl’s monster: Earl the terror Thompson Julia’s monster: Randal Who’s next on the list?

[@SuperSwordman1]

Probably Red. Unless we want to go backwards a bit.

[@katarinadreams6955]

We should probably check Molly (Andy's sister) and/or Hannah (Sid's sister)

[@aullette]

@EnigmaticAnomaly noooooo, they are too brave Edit: actually we could find their former monsters nvm

[@CheshireCat-cm1si]

Markos Ziss Once Turning Red comes out, I'm guessing that it'll be Mei Lee

[@sezzac155]

@@katarinadreams6955 It would be interesting to see the theory for Hannah's monster, like she lives with Sid who is absolutely not nice to her, she freaks out when seeing that he has replaced her dolls head with that pterodactyl toy's for example so on one hand that's some fertile ground for potential monsters but on the other hand it's implied that this is a regular thing that Sid does, so maybe she doesn't actually get scared of actual monsters that much because she just assumes it's another lame joke from Sid.

[@ghosty8193]

Randal is the most obvious candidate: he's nimble and can climb on ceilings so Julia's tiny room is no match for him. He also resembles a sea monster, so it would make sense this sea-monster fearing town would be where he goes.

[@zimonzieclown1633]

On that note you can make an argument that he had multiple children to scare in that town during his time as a Scarer.

[@raynitaylor1912]

Am I the only one who feels that there should have been a "These Socks are Amazing!" reference somewhere in the ad?

[@_konkrit_]

I miss those. My daughter actually quit watching due to them missing

[@Alijahs_Animations]

@@_konkrit_ wow I feel like that’s kind of rude

[@_konkrit_]

@@Alijahs_Animations it was her favorite part that and she's a 16 year old girl who changes interests on a whim. I'm sure she'll be back someday

[@jtthadon5068]

Lol I still say it for em

[@Mirrorcomics24]

@@Alijahs_Animations not really

[@madethistocomment727]

When J said, "also also" and didn't follow it up with, "actually actually", I have to admit I was a little upset.

[@nicolemelendez4415]

Me too! I said “actually actually” to myself 😂

[@castlecrusher909]

Me too

[@DrPOP-jp7eb]

Haha same here...

[@clairewilliamson5987]

@@nicolemelendez4415 Me too!!!!!

[@carsonneeley4862]

I did research, and 2021 here equals 2065 in the monster world

[@carolinemary7876]

So you’re telling me Guilia’s father hates monsters because they hurt his daughter? That’s low key sweet

[@Giselle.829]

*high key* 🥰

[@carolinemary7876]

@Olivia Rijkenberg The names are pronounced the same way, but Guilin is the Italian spelling

[@FiveFurys5]

@Olivia Rijkenberg I think Giulia's monster is the blue crocodile

[@carolinemary7876]

@Olivia Rijkenberg You’re totally fine!

[@tina8059]

Who else thinks they should do another video for the whole Pixar theory this time adding the new movies ??

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

It is just about that time again isnt it?

[@girlwithoutafairy]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers Maybe after Lightyear tho bc I think it might be very confusing fer newcomers. Also would the shows like Monsters At Work be included or no

[@michaeloluwajuyemi4546]

Yes! Especially Turning Red!

[@MojoTheMaginificent]

I feel like monsters at work should be added because it laces up what happens before and after the final parts of monsters inc.

[@lizzieallen9661]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers yes yes it is

[@UltimateKyuubiFox]

All of which leads to the question. Who was Linguini’s monster?

[@rowanw1312]

Alfredo, or abound I say AFRAID-O

[@mariaochs]

OMGG THAT'S A GOOD ONE

[@rowanw1312]

@@mariaochs well thank you my good *INSERT IDENTITY HERE* I appreciate it

[@bethanyzamora1146]

i feel like it would be Josh. Josh is terrifying.

[@cometmoon4485]

Isn't Linguini also the one being abducted by aliens in Lifted?

[@kdkz_bshg]

I’m not sure how much this affects anything but it’s more likely Luca was set in the 1960s rather than the 1950s because, and I’m not completely sure if the credits count as ‘canon’, in the credits Luca and Guilia watch the moon landing which was in 1969 and still look about the same age they were in the movie

[@Momy69420]

That changes so many things if it’s canon that would mean Guilia would’ve been born in 1956 making her 8 in 1964 which is around 9 years after the events of monsters inc

[@featherweight]

I actually think they might be watching the “Man in Space" an episode of Disneyland which originally aired in 1955. It had a space walk animated segment and The rocket Luca is holding is almost exactly the one Walt holds in the show.

[@kacperczylija1254]

or Americans can use high advanced technology from The Incredibles and moon landing in 50s. Btw-what we know about USSR in Pixar universe?

[@kdkz_bshg]

@@featherweight That would make sense. Although that rocket could just be an easter egg based off the rocket in “Man in Space”

[@StrikerSimp]

@@kdkz_bshg But the director said it takes place in the 1950s, being based off an old friendship of his.

[@RussGussDoodles]

This theory is pretty good but As a Disney Parks geek I would like to point out that some of the ride posters in the movie are for rides that came out after Disneyland’s opening. Specifically the Matterhorn and the Submarine voyage ride posters pose a problem for this theory. Both of these opened in 1959 as part of the Tomorrowland expansion, 4 years after the parks opening. Also a poster for the storybook land canal boats ride can be found in a coffee shop in Monster World. So either the Monster World has it’s own Disneyland and the human world is currently set after 1959 or the Pixar team are just big Disney Park Geeks like me :)

[@Jessie91J]

Also.. in the end credits they are watching the moon landing of 1969, without looking much older. And a little European perspective: having built in closets where monsters could come from is super American. Europeans are more likely to have dressers and wardrobes with narrow doors instead of proper doors like shown in Monsters Inc. I assume the reason behind that is, the way houses were built: stone instead of wood and simple designs with straight walls.

[@jeng.2117]

Also, wouldn't a film that premiered in theaters in 1958 air on television in 1959 or later?

[@jeng.2117]

@SomeoneOnlyWeKnow Really just a guess on my part, based on how long films that screened in theaters (as opposed to direct-to-tv movies) typically took to air in subsequent decades.

[@jeng.2117]

Of course, there was no VHS yet - a detail I completely overlooked - so perhaps they aired that much sooner.

[@darkamora5123]

@@jeng.2117 much later actually. Typically a film would air 5-10 years after being in theaters ( if not more). You see, without home versions, they'd re-release popular films every couple of years in theaters until the box office couldn't justify the distribution costs. It would take 2-5 cycles before they reached that point. That would make watching the Apollo 11 moon landing (August 1969) without looking much older much more realistic, as a 1958 movie airing on TV for the first time in 1968 would be normal. Heck even in the 70s and 80s when I grew up films could take a year or two to release on home media after a theatrical run. Television airings could still take 5 years or so, when studios judged most people who were going to buy a home copy had already done so.

[@coffeebean2]

Only OGs remember the original upload

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

haha oh yes way back when!

[@ibzdagamer]

Tried watching it back it got removed

[@melanietrader]

I was in the middle of it when it got taken down

[@seaweedbrain1930]

How was it different

[@greysonrouse6981]

@@seaweedbrain1930 the audio from the movie was overlapping with J’s audio

[@shika15]

“There is no spoon.” “The files are *in* the computer.” Highlight of the video for me 😆🤣 just the way he delivered those lines

[@addictofanimation2923]

I read this just before that part and I wound up cracking up.

[@rho-starmkl4483]

Was that supposed to be a reference to something? It feels like the “No Secret Ingredient” line from Kung Fu Panda, but that’s a DREAMWORKS movie.

[@jazzycatty]

@@rho-starmkl4483 The first one is a quote from The Matrix, the second is from Zoolander

[@danisarcher13]

theory idea: as you said, luca and alberto wouldn’t have monsters since they are monsters, but what if their monsters are humans? multiple times throughout the film the sea monsters refer to humans as “land monsters” so what if there is an alternative universe where humans scare monsters?? this might be a stretch, but this is just a thought that came to my mind :)

[@shaqthanos4716]

😮😂

[@yonggongaming]

I'll make the argument that before her parents separated she had a much bigger room with a closet. Because her current room has no closet. the reason she has no closet is because her father saw the monster.

[@z.i.q131]

That's what I was thinking lol, when j started talking about the size of the room I instantly thought "wait does she even have a closet?"

[@jaredildefonzo]

That’s actually a really good theory as well

[@zachh6868]

Mr. Carlin Brother: "it's all about the size of the room" Me audibly in a room by myself: "genius"

[@annajoseph9321]

“Mr Carlin brother” 😂😂

[@clairewilliamson5987]

You can call him J, you know, you don't have to call him Mr Carlin Brother. But you're right, that is genius. I love this channel. They make such good arguments for theories no-body would have even thought about at first. :)

[@FiveFurys5]

@@clairewilliamson5987 Giulia's mosnter: The Blue Crocodile

[@alyssag7801]

@@annajoseph9321 lol it makes sense though. Luca called Alberto Sir first few moments with him

[@Erethizon_dorsatum]

Personally, the fact that Julia is practically immediately ok with Luca and Alberto being sea monsters - indicates that she’s not too afraid of monsters. I personally think we’re looking for a jokester. We don’t know many so far, but we’re definitely looking to the cast of monsters at work.

[@icgthegreat7775]

Plus I don’t think from what remember a few teens were being scared/joked with so I agree

[@nerfboi1454]

I think its just not good directing

[@SuperSwordman1]

She was also quite afraid of Alberto when she first saw him monster out. I think she was scared by Randell in her past, initially thought Alberto was Randall, but was able to realize that was still Alberto and that Luca was also a sea monster once the initial shock wore off. And her door was shredded shortly after

[@SuperSwordman1]

Ignore the door being shredded part. Timeline got mixed up in my head

[@adammartinez8061]

Another failed scare attempt. Yup, her door probably got shredded and dismissed as another failed scaring attempt.

[@MariaPereira-tp7ll]

So if Randal is Boo, Andy, and Guilia’s monster- wouldn’t that mean that all three of them would have to exist in the same time span? They would have to be grouped into the same years that Randal has been scaring before the events of Monsters Inc.

[@TheGreeneson]

i think that monsters able to travel back to 1958 and can travel in between then and 1999, not just one year

[@intdisaster]

Imagine if it’s a combination. I mean, since radiation and pollution transformed people, it’s possible that people became conjoined.

[@anthonychang1426]

It’s great that you fixed the audio problem.

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Thanks for being patient!

[@Legopandaproductions799]

So that's why it was rereleased

[@hannahbasso7224]

I read this as “Who is Giulia’s mother?” And was confused on why there were monsters on the title and went “say what?” Now it makes more sense.

[@victoriarobinson6152]

I really like this theory because both Randall and Ercole are bullies in their respective films. Giulia, with the help of her new outcast friends, is able to overcome her fear of both of them.

[@djepp1261]

True fans saw this the first time they released this.

[@KadesKove]

Right here

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Thanks for bearing with us as we fixed our audio issues!

[@appsnake7225]

Yep

[@Jaberwalkie]

Yep

[@johnconner9296]

I tried but it was made private before I could watch

[@baystated]

Your spreadsheet was very nicely done. Like: proud-mum-puts-on-fridge nice.

[@melaniesoto7187]

Oh cool this series is back

[@FanOfAnimation]

It’s obvious who one of the Parr kids monster is. I can see Randall being Violet’s monster because of her fear of her powers.

[@gamergurl6931]

10:34 At about this time in the upper right hand corner you can see a poster for Disney land on Giulia's wall. The poster is from the rocket jet ride in tomorrow land this poster came out in 1967, this means that this would have been at least when the movie came out now we see in the credits Giulia and Luca watching the moon landing witch as you said takes place in 1969 so this means that this movie takes place from 1967 to 1969 So the middle of this would be about 1968. meaning Giulia was 8 around 1955 so anyone working during that time would be the best canidit for Giulia's monster. Love your guys stuff and this is my little tid bit that I noticed Love your guys channel

[@christinalittleton3771]

Can you even imagine Randal's reaction if Luca would dump water on himself and bare his teeth at him, just for trying to scare Giulia? Randal: Hey, how are- Luca: *growling and snarling* Randal: *screams like a girl* GET YOUR FREAKIN' MONSTER BACK! Giulia: *studying, not even looking up* He don't bite. Randal: *scratching the closet door like a scared dog* YES, HE DO!

[@stabbycat748]

I also like to imagine that Randel is Violet’s monster. They can both turn invisible and stuff. I also believe in the Boo grows up to be Violet theory. (Mostly cause of that one scene in incredibles 2 where violet seemingly teleports behind the fridge the way Boo used to do behind the bathroom stall doors)

[@KaizoKitsune625]

That door probably got shredded

[@willberger3873]

The only thing worse than Randall is a wedding planned by Voldemort

[@witheredbonnie7460]

Fax

[@foodofthegods]

lol facts

[@snaketooth0943]

Idea for a pixar theory: when did monsters start scaring kids? Did they scare kids before doors were invented? If so, how did they get to the kids?

[@tatsusama3192]

Haha, Now I'm just imagining, after 3-4 incidents of children using powers to fight their monsters, the Monsters Inc corporation just refusing to scare kids on that part of the timeline

[@torazely]

It could explain why there's a shortage... super kids means less kids to scare, so not as much energy. Plus they're gonna be a bit more careful for future generations in case they have powers too.

[@FiveFurys5]

@@torazely Carl's mosnter is Earl the terror Thompson because he is the oldest scarer in the 1920's and 1930's

[@randoml97]

I would argue that she has no monster. That is a fearless little girl if I ever saw one, her door was shredded IMMEDIATELY

[@SuperSwordman1]

yeah she probably yelled "Mostro!" and jump on it pulling at whatever she could.

[@theunitedcommonwealth715]

I doubt that given her first reaction to Albertos Monster form.

[@SuperSwordman1]

@@theunitedcommonwealth715 True. Somehow I forgot that when I left that comment. I don't know how. One of hte more brutal heartbreak scenes Disney has.

[@randoml97]

@@theunitedcommonwealth715 you... have a fantastic point

[@seanmcgovern1779]

This is a good theory, but I would think that the monsters just avoid this town since they're basically monster hunters

[@ashterrifictales7317]

They could still scare her when she’s at her mom’s house for school

[@demigodwizardtributejedi4052]

Giulia's monster is Luca, of course!

[@Thomas_the_train.]

Yes

[@FiveFurys5]

@@Thomas_the_train. And Carl's Mosnter Was Earl The Terror Thompson

[@theaspreysisters3587]

It also makes sense because of the smallness of her room Randall could hide in plain sight and jump-scare her easily

[@maddenboseroy4074]

I actually thought of: "Ma, 'nother gator got in!" "'Nother gator?! Gimme that shovel!!"

[@daeconStuy]

Additional theory: The events of Luca result in a whole town, and later a large city in Italy suddenly having no fear of monsters. This was the original trigger for the energy crisis at the start of Monsters, Inc.

[@jasonrobbins4001]

In monsters University we see that there are monsters that live underwater so does this mean Luca himself is a monster?

[@swolch]

I actually would have pushed the year to 1959 since the lady is watching the movie on a TV broadcast and not in the theaters. Not that it makes that big of a difference 😀. Well done otherwise.

[@ryleemorrow6811]

I always forget that her name is spelled that way, so I’m like, “who’s gwoolia?”

[@Lokear]

Gonna be easy to learn Italian for you, huh?

[@ryleemorrow6811]

@@Lokear I’ll admit, I’m not great with languages 😂

[@Lokear]

@@ryleemorrow6811 It's fine. I didn't know that that was a common thing in Italian words until I started learning it. I've noticed it a lot more in names I know since then (Michael Giacchino's last name, for example).

[@itsspelledgiulia1203]

It’s me

[@Lokear]

@@itsspelledgiulia1203 :0

[@brookez3116]

I want to make an argument that based on this theory Andy had a jokester and not a scarer and therefore did not have Randall as a monster (although I would love MaW to bring him back since he was such a genuinely good guy in MU)

[@LadyHuntress5580]

Just saying, I think Sullywould make Merida have flashbacks of her dad losing his arm. I think he would be able to make a little Merida scream for a few years.

[@dubbacheezbugga5366]

Just an idea: but what if her monster isn’t on that scare floor? Like… perhaps it could be squishy or Don due to his aquatic look and tiny size

[@drakephoenixfeather4056]

Massimo is hands down the best Disney/Pixar parent. There are some mighty good ones out there, loads that are doing their best...Massimo makes ME feel like I could talk to him about anything and he'd keep me safe and teach me things without getting annoyed at me and hed raise me really well...and I'm 31

[@peytongroth6482]

Hey SuperCarlinBrothers! Speaking of monsters, have you guys watched the new show "Monsters At Work" on Disney+ yet? I loved it and I'm sure you'll love it too.

[@DxC-95]

Seeing as he used "Jokesters" when referring to Scarers post-Boo, I'm guessing they've indeed watched it.

[@average_enby]

The intro is a bop and I love it as well as the show itself.

[@CherryFizzOfficial]

In Monsters University Mike looks under a bridge on his first day and sees an old building underneath it with the words ''School of Aquatics'' etched into it in fancy font, and it had several literal sea monsters swimming in and out of it, which I find really interesting because one it implies that not all monsters live on land, two we're never given an answer to ''CAN they go on land like Luca and Al, or would they die like fish, and if they can't, which would be why they have a seperate school building, how would these aquatics scare children, since humans obviously live and sleep on land?''

[@shadowcat5939]

When you're about halfway through the video and it breaks and you're like whelp guess I don't actually need the answer

[@LaneWinn]

There is a flaw in this theory: In one of SCB’s older videos, it is theorized that Randall is Andy’s monster as well. However, Toy Story takes place in 1995, just four years before Monsters, Inc takes place in 1999. If he is also Guilia’s monster back in our 1953, he would be 74 years old in Monsters, Inc if the older theory is still in practice. So either this theory is broken, or the other one is. Nevertheless, I always appreciate the effort you guys put into these!

[@adamsalt9423]

Randal can be the monster for more than 1 kid at a time, he's a professional

[@LaneWinn]

@@adamsalt9423 he certainly isn’t 74 years old in Monsters, Inc.

[@adamsalt9423]

@@LaneWinn they age very differently than humans, lizards last a very long time and Randal could be

[@LaneWinn]

@@adamsalt9423 he’s a freshman in Monsters University. And he was a good student, so I doubt he was held back 50+ times

[@Okfine42]

So how will the monsters get power once the time line catches up and all the humans are monsters?

[@highhfgy1368]

That would honestly make a good theory on the channel

[@Voidbear_FNaF_and_Undertale]

I've wondered that myself

[@kerriMcElnay]

*monster comes through Luca’s closet* Luca “oh hey Terry”

[@jyotiswami6746]

Fun fact : A new species of 'slithering' snake is found in India by Indian scienctists and they named the species after Salazar Slytherin, coz the scientists are potterheads. Its name is 'Trimeresurus Salazar'

[@jessicahill6207]

What if the reason kids start to become less and less scared is because of Luca/ other creatures like him? Stories of monsters in general would be a bogeyman to any child that hears about it. Sea monsters making it to the top of the list of why some children are afraid to swim in the ocean. Suddenly, these monsters are real, but instead of being terrifying, they're actually really nice. So, stories about monsters in closets/under the bed suddenly become less scary because- "Hey, the sea monsters are actually friendly, so why can't my monster?"

[@FabledThunder]

Only the OG’s remember the original upload.

[@MonicaCatapusan]

I’ll admit, I wasn’t sure on Randal when you first mentioned it but the look on Julia’s face when she saw Alberto’s PURPLE scaly arm definitely sold me. You did it again boys💯

[@gibbers313]

The only monster that could fit in there comfortably is boo in her costume so it’s definitely her

[@firepower7654]

Stick in the spokes: In the credits, Luca and Giulia are seen at Giulia's home for the school year and one of the pictures shows them watching a moon landing on television. There were two moon landings in 1969. Apollo 11 was in July, which they wouldn't be watching at Giulia's home because they were having summer shenanigans in Portorosso and the next was in November 1969, which would work and have put them now in Genoa at school. I present the year of Luca was 1969.

[@samuelbuch3658]

Alberto and Luca don´t have monsters in their closets because THEY are monsters in the closet :D

[@amiraameera8302]

I love that I've been watching these so long that as soon as Jay says the room's size is the answer, I'm like "oh, it's Randall" 😆

[@GraceOfDiamonds]

can u guys do a recap vid for all the children in pixar u've found monsters to?

[@fl4me_on]

I think the theory is good. the part when you said that Giulia's dad trusts her judgement. It was so sweet. ✨✨

[@markbrown2640]

Unless that film was made for television, your date is probably off by years. Movies did not transition to video/television soon after their first theatrical release in 1958. Or the 1960s. Or the 1970s. Films stayed in theaters for years. One week the print would be in Cleveland. The next week it would be in Chicago, or Cincinnati, or Fremont, or York, or any other town with a theater and an account with the distributor. For example, Star Wars came out in 1977, but I couldn't see it untill summer of 1978 when it played at the drive in theater in Fremont, Ohio (paired with Invasion of the Body Snatchers.) If that was a theatrical film playing on late night TV, it would have been years after its release.

[@terraphantom1039]

Alternate timeline, mr incredible has an amphobious rocket car in that same time frame, so maybe they can also get movies onto tv a bit quicker?

[@galacticgila219]

I’d love to see a series of shorts showing different kids from Pixar movies showing what their monster was Maybe like a fun non-canon Scary Stories type series from the monsters perspective Sids monster coming in to be terrified by the conjoined toys moving around, Miguel’s monster being confused when they don’t find him in his room one night- going out looking for him and being terrified about all of the people around, there’s so many fun oprotunities

[@Samanthajeanann]

So Boo and Guelia are just a handful of years apart in age?

[@anikao2145]

this may have been said somewhere else but i swear i haven’t actually heard this anywhere before. my theory: whenever alberto repeats the phrase “silencio bruno!” i always wondered where he came up with bruno. now that i think about it, bruno may be the name of his father. alberto says he was always afraid of holding his father back, so now he doesn’t let the negative thoughts from bruno (his dad in my theory) hold him back. this may or may not be possible but it was still a good shot at a debatable theory.

[@lemon-parker]

this was actually a SCB theory 🤔

[@rebekahc3073]

J: "Also, also!" Me: "Actually, actually!"

[@reinafox7639]

I love the explanation of Julia and her fathers relationship, really warms my heart.

[@bouloskhouri6513]

What do you guys think about the Disney + show monsters at work

[@Jesus_Sav3d_M3]

Good job with the audio, thanks for fixing it instead of giving up!

[@Ilikeegg-i4y]

i would like to see a theory on what happened to randy when he got stuck in the human world. i would like to see him trying to find a way back to the monster world and try to get revenge on mike and sully or try to find boo. and i would also like to imagine he gets taken into a circus and gets put into display. but anyway i like to see what he might be doing and maybe it could tie into the pixar theory

[@StasiaRetorts]

In the credit pictures, it looks like Luca and Guila are watching the lunar landing so I don't know if the timeline matches up. Plus, a lot of the smaller towns don't get movies immediately, sometimes it takes years.

[@marisolramirez9591]

0:26 Miguel has seen death, he fears nothing

[@multiplefandomlover7179]

I also think that it's such a cool connection that Randall, as a descendant of the sea monsters in Luca, is actually scaring a child who lives in an area that has a huge sea monster problem. Maybe that's why he's her monster too, because he not only is so equipped to handle small rooms withou difficulty, but he also looks very similar to them since he literally came from them. They're sort of one in the same. I wouldn't be surprised if maybe Randall, and any monsters that look like him, scare other children that we see in Portorrosso. A lot of them look younger than Guilia, so the timeline would still work.

[@JellyBelz]

You guys know that excel sheet you showed had the green line at Carl's childhood, right? Not Giulia's? Giulia's 8-year-old line only had Sulley named.

[@NSUDemon14]

It was 11:04 of the video when it occurred to me that J has officially lost it. The eyes, the manic tone, the Matrix reference. 😂

[@SpectralFlames05]

Kid: * exist* Carlin brothers: “I WONDER WHO THEIR MONSTER WAS!”

[@JeremeDavis]

The thing with Randall is he was a top scarier just like Sulley, so of course he would have many kids, it also would explain why he is linked up with both Giulia and Andy who are important characters in their stories, he is good at what he does.

[@huntermurdock6796]

The Pixar theory is beginning to feel like a huge reach to me, and it felt like you were reaching with her dad maybe catching a glimpse of Randall

[@sonomabruce7903]

I have been watching your vids for years. They are so entertaining and just fun to watch! One thing I really want you to do is an updated Pixar theory. It is beginning to get a little hard for me to keep track of everything again. The last video you did of this was like three years ago. That would be amazing! Thanks again for your vids!

[@lauracoles5595]

Always love these monster videos!

[@VenusVenom369]

Merida is an intereesting character to talk about imo, we know she wasn't always as brave as she's shown, there's a flashback in the movie of her being scared of lightning and Elenor comforting her. The only real issue with finding her monster is the timeline doesn't go far enough for us to see monsters from that time, but considering the nature of her fear of lightning I'm thinking it could've been one of the Sullivans, they have the perfect roar for someone afraid of thunder and Lions like what Sully's test kid was scared of

[@maxwellp.8728]

I knew it would be Randal from the very beginning

[@maxwell9211]

Probably doesn’t mean much, but in the credits Luca and Giulia are watching the moon landing and appear to be about the same age (or at least definitely not 23)

[@damiondraws8538]

for a second I read this title as "Who Is Giulia's Mother?"

[@starstuds]

Although that would be a good theory

[@sammylane21]

It'd be fun and funny if we had a one or two Pixar writers that could include both Super Carlin Brothers in as Easter eggs in a future Pixar movie.

[@fletch7212]

11:03-11:12 J went a little insane

[@daniellewhite3657]

I have been waiting for more Luca content

[@weresofansie1457]

A-ha! But you missed crucial information that ENTIRELY changes the time that the movie takes place!!! In the end credits, Luca and Giulia, still looking quite young, might I add, are watching the moon landing on TV. The moon landing wasn’t until 1969. So either they’re 24/25 year olds who look 13, or you need to re-think your theory. I’d like to say that the movie takes place in 1967-1968ish, depending how much time goes by in the end credits. Five years before that would be 1962-1963ish, so I think it’s safe to say Giulia did indeed have a jokester. This may be a more difficult case than we thought, considering we don’t know much of who it is after Mike and Sulley’s generation. In short, good theory, bad timeline.

[@winkcla]

He does mention 1969 at 7:37 but doesn't go any further on it

[@Voidbear_FNaF_and_Undertale]

Remember that he also said Randal was Andy's monster

[@LandonEmma]

Ive always thought that the monster universe was in a different universe or planet

[@latikasuryavanshi8449]

I don't know why but I read this is Julia's mom is also a monster and got me thinking WHO IS JULIA'S MOM

[@andrew4537]

Says he’s a slytherin, I MADE A CHART AND THOUGHT WAY TOO MUCH ABOUT TWO VAGUELY CONNECTED UNIVERSES. sounds like Ravenclaw to me

[@leahdavis9434]

If you think only Ravenclaws can be smart or care about data, sure. But that's obviously not true because they weren't genetically engineered to be Ravenclaws, it's just they valued Ravenclaw things the most at the time of sorting.

[@unknowndark1673]

I swear I called it , once I heard small room I thought it was Randal

[@soulalchemist387]

The Cat on Julia's bed looks like a Turning Red cat.I wonder where Turning Red will be placed on the Timeline.Maybe Soul 22 caused a Nexus event that alters the Pixarverse.What if Soul 22 was born as the last Monster and Met Boo/Possibly the with from Brave?

[@MSK-n]

i don't think just because the kid is brave they have no monster ; like how fearlessness isn't a lack of fear but doing the thing regardless

[@fordunderwood4493]

Why would you get Better help as a sponsor? They’ve been outed as a scam and terrible company forever ago, and people have know about that!

[@nitzeart]

Omg for real?? That's awful. They've been sponsoring a lot of youtubers latety. Which is worrying.

[@samjensen392]

I’d have to actually do some research on it, but I heard that after the whole controversy happened, they cracked down on it and made sure all their counselors actually were accredited and now they monitor it much more closely, so with this new round of sponsorships (which was likely spurred on by losing a lot of business because of the controversy), they’ve made a point in the ad reads to assure that they are actually credible

[@TheBananaDealer]

OK, so for the dating part - Ercole's Vespa appears to be a Vespa Rally 180, produced between 1968 and 1973. Knowing Ercole's... vain and self-centred nature, he most likely bought it as soon as it was available. From that, along with the credit shot of them watching the moon landing (they don't appear to have aged visibly, and it stands to reason that the credits would show what the kids were up to shortly after the movie, rather than several years after), I'd say the movie takes place in the summer of 1968, specifically the end of the summer, since Giulia has to leave to go back to her mother's and for school. Of course the shortcoming of this thinking is that pretty much every Vespa we see in the movie appears to be the exact same model, so they might have just used the one for inspiration/base... But hey, it's just a theory...