What Would ACTUALLY Make Toy Story 5 Worth It | Pixar Film Theory

[@KristenyBridges]

I'd love if Toy Story 5 is actually the tale of Toy Story 0, where we meet Andy's dad and explore how he got Woody in the first place

[@musicalifornia49]

Same

[@judesir]

We know how already

[@CrazyManhog]

That would make more sense!

[@hassassinator8858]

As much as I want to defend Pixar, that idea's a bit too "different" for them. Can't go wrong if you don't take risks!

[@BabyGirlTiny]

We don’t need that tale the same way we didn’t need lightyear

[@dillontrainvids25]

If Pixar actually acknowledged the fan theory that Andy’s mom was Emily, and Jessie goes on a rampage of revenge for being given up lol. That’s the toy story 5 I’d actually watch

[@superwahrrior]

Me too.

[@zekecooper6055]

So horror story comedy

[@patricktichacek6171]

Haven't they left it open they nvr say her name that ik ofs

[@smb-c3po]

They'd better acknowledge Kingdom Hearts.

[@patricktichacek6171]

@@smb-c3po wait kingdom hearts?

[@bloob11]

There's this theory(headcanon? I think) on the internet that Sid grows up knowing that toys are sentinent (Idunno how you spell it), and whenever he finds an injured toy (which he does quite a lot with his garbageman job) he fixes them and gives them away to be played with, and I'd love it if that was in Toy Story 5 just like how once that old man fixed Woody. I would also love the line "hello old friend" from him if he finds Woody

[@micahtiel]

Ooo that'd be cool!

[@victoriagreer7609]

Due I want Sid to not only come back but have a speaking line as well. Like Woody reunites with Buzz and they conclude that Bonnies at camp or something but they have no ride to Andys old childhood home and then Sid the trash man comes has his possible converstaion with Bonnies mom overheard and Woodys like i got a crazy idea and shows himself to Sid and Sid reacts but agrees to take Woody to the house cuz he changed Sid for the better and maybe the gang meets some toys that Sid rescued along the way being his awesome self.

[@biancabrooks280]

I want more of this!! I want the sentience of toys to be revealed to the world!!

[@bloob11]

Omg y'all with your awesome ideas, they really have such good opportunities with TS5 that I can't argue, I WANT a 5ft movie! And I want Sid to be such a big part of it! I need my boi Sid, I need to see him again!

[@13thfullmoon3]

From villain to hero! I know it’s probably not going to happen, but I’d love if Disney/Pixar confirmed that theory.

[@angusmaxim3450]

Andy comes back as a father. Perhaps of a son that is similar to how Andy was in the first two films. That premise alone justifies a fifth film.

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

that wounds beautiful

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

@@darkrai7597 I wouldn't, Toy Story literally started with those guys

[@jellybloom17]

I LOVE IT!!! This would tie in perfectly with “memory permeates every Pixar franchise”

[@itskarma2909]

Yeeess

[@michaeloluwajuyemi4546]

Yes!

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

100%

[@thomasbennett0]

I would watch a Woody's Roundup Disney plus series.

[@reflectivedinosaur713]

No no no no no don’t say that because they’re gonna give us “monsters at work” type bs 😭😭😭 I don’t want that concept ruined for me in my head. Make it right or not at all…

[@Gashnaw]

Yeah sire throw one out that like seven people will watch every episode of season one. Most bouncing episode 2. We think we want it, But we don't

[@kekenaniwilson6138]

I'd watch it bcuz it'd show the character woody is based off and prob give us a glimpse of the prospectors character and I definitely think he's a corrupt toy based on a man led by greed and jealousy of woody. We'd get to c gunless law and maybe if his deputy was more dear to his heart in the show woody nvr even know about. I mean, Jessie is clearly attracted to a decisive leader type

[@TECfan1]

​@@reflectivedinosaur713 I liked Monsters at Work.

[@reflectivedinosaur713]

@@TECfan1 to each their own but it’s still made for really young kids.

[@NathanSpies]

It should be a prequel with Andy’s Dad & Woody’s true origins!!!

[@kaylieghskorner9650]

Oh my gosh! Absolutely!!

[@smb-c3po]

Or focus on Andy going on a journey to search for Woody.

[@moonlight2487]

Ever think about what Bonnie and her parents thought when the most important toy to Andy is lost? He trusted her to keep his toys safe. Here comes the guilt dodododo...

[@erikagholston6610]

I want to see a prequel too.

[@moonlight2487]

@@erikagholston6610 it would be better than another sequel after the 4th ones ending. Probably just another cash grab.

[@travishall7734]

Watched Toy Story since I was 4, I'm 28 with a kid and if Woody ended up with Andy's son or daughter, I'd breakdown with tears of pure nostalgia and joy. I genuinely hope this is what happens. Great video guys. 👍

[@artsyess]

My own idea: Wood and Bo doing the usual carnival thing, but Woody is starting to feel a bit sad seeing all these toys go with kids and he misses being a child’s toy. At a game booth helping toys get to kids, he hears someone calling out for Andy. He looks and recognizes adult Andy with his son (Andy Jr Jr I guess lol) and Woody is immediately brought back to all these old feelings and he goes to try to be with them, with Bo calling out to him to come back. He freezes up on the ground in front of them and the son notices, picking him up and pulling the string “there’s a snake in my boot!” Adult Andy immediately recognizes woody and they take him home. Bo goes after him. Meanwhile, Bonnie is at that age where she’s starting to grow out of playing with toys, so throwback to Toy Story 2: Yard sale! Toys are worried, but Buzz is like “Don’t worry guys, we’ve survived these before” but uh oh, they’re ALL put for sale. And they’re all bought by some random lady. They’re taken in a car and go. When they arrive to a random room, they’re all put in a box and wrapped up. (Maybe a moment of Jesse freaking out) and they all try to come up with plans to escape the box, but can’t bc they’re wrapped up. It’d be too obvious if they escaped. Meanwhile, Woody meets a new gang of toys from Andy Jr’s room. Not very many toys, but nice. They remind him of the old gang. And then he meets the ‘toy in charge’ that reminds him of how he used to be: (plot twist, it’s Lotso and he’s changed for the better) or just another random toy. While woodys exploring the room he’s in, he noticed that the wall paint is peeling in the corner. He’s messing with it just while he’s thinking and he realizes that under the paint is the old cloud wallpaper from Andy’s original room. He realizes they’re in the same room, same house that his Andy grew up in and is filled with nostalgia. Just then, other toys announce there’s an intruder, and they find Bo. Woody deescalates the situation and asks Bo how she found him (she explains) blah blah blah and asks him to come back, but Woody says that seeing them must’ve been fate, maybe he’s meant to stay with Andy, well, Andy Jr now. Bo tries to remind him what their new purpose is, that they can do stuff for other toys. Woody’s hesitant about it, and when he’s about to make the decision to go, Lotso/new toy invites them to stay for at least one more day, because tomorrow is a big day for Andy Jr. (It’s his birthday) Woody remembers the old toy spying operations they used to do whenever Andy got new toys, and Lotso/new toy says they do the same thing. Woody tells Bo, “Let’s help them, for old times sake?” And Bo agrees. The next day, their spy operation starts. They send Woody out to do the spying on Andy Jr opening his birthday presents and that’s when he sees them opening up the box that’s full of the old Gang! He spots Bonnies toys, Mr/Mrs Potato head, Rex, Slinky, Hamm, Jessie then Buzz. He stops communicating on the radio with the team as he slowly realizes it’s them and that they’re all together again. (Keep in mind, Woody hasn’t seen them in YEARS ) He goes back to the room fast after discovering Andy Jr is about to bring his toys up. He quickly tells Bo and the New Gang who’s down there. No doesn’t believe him at first, but then they hear Andy Jr approaching. They all freeze/take cover. Andy Jr drops off his boxes of presents on his bed and goes back downstairs for cake. It’s silent… then slowly, Woody steps out and calls out. “…Buzz..?” And slowly but surely, Buzz looked over the edge of the box and sees Woody. “woody?” “Woody?!” Jessie quickly pops out, other toys following. The old gang sees him and Bo and they all jump out, running to him and hugging the two. They ask how the heck they got there, and Buzz says it was a yard sale, the lady that must have bought them was Andy Jr’s mom. Then they see Lotso/New toy (if it’s Lotso, there can be a nice comedic moment where they all get in a fighting stance) but woody reassured them it’s okay, and he tells them this is Andy’s old room/house. And he looks to Bo and says this is where they’re meant to be now. There’s a reason why we’re all together again. Bo gives in and agrees to stay. They all greet each other (old gang/new gang) and it fades out into the credits with “You Got A Friend In Me” playing with pictures taken of Andy Jr, Andy and Mom all playing with the toys with each other. And it ends on a shot of Andy Jr with Andy, both holding Woody and wearing the old Jessie hat OR!!! A shot of the underside of Woody’s boot with ‘andy Jr’ written on it Fun post credit scene where the bunny/duck from Toy Story 4 are now in charge of giving toys out at the carnival. But then realize there’s no more toys to give out to the last kid, and they give themselves up and the kid ends up taking them to Sunnyside, where we get an update on Barbie & Ken! (Edit: I FORGOT WOODY DOESNT HAVE HIS VOICE BOX ANYMORE. Toy Story 4 wasn’t my favorite so I kinda forgot most of it)

[@catherinerebeccadavis]

that was a full on fanfic lol and I really enjoyed it. I love this premise! & I want the real film to be like this!

[@bluefrostryy]

cant be tho for starters woody doesnt have a voice box anymore

[@princessmarlena1359]

@@bluefrostryy **in George Castanza’s voice** “Why must there always be a problem!?” Other than that, I find OP’s idea charming…

[@DaddyLogan420]

I mean what’s the story or conflict though? They just all get brought to Andy’s house and don’t have to overcome anything. No character arcs, no story conflicts, etc.

[@artsyess]

@@DaddyLogan420 There doesn’t need to be any big villain or anything. It can all be personal/internal conflicts. I just have a little summary of the flow at the top of my head at like 3am. I wasn’t really focusing on that. I mean sorta. 1. If Jessie goes in a box, she has to deal with that trauma. 2. They have to go through the yard sale thing again. It was a big deal in Toy Story 2, so maybe they all try to find a way to escape the yard sale but they can’t? 3. Bo’s going on her own adventure to follow Woody. She’d probably have the most physical obstacles, I just summarized it as her going after him. 4. Maybe Woody’s paranoid of Lotso when he meets him, because obviously, who wouldn’t. So he has to deal with that. He would probably deal with internal conflicts the most. 5. Maybe there’s a new dog too in this movie and for some reason it just really wants to use Woody as a chew toy. That’s something to avoid now. Anything could be thought up of if there needs to be. I’m just some random person on the Internet. Disney could figure it out or anyone else. :)

[@captianbacon]

The biggest problem with lightyear is the fact they ignored the previous cannon characters of star comand cause if they would've made it tie into the classic masterpiece of a animated seris that movie would've printed money ngl

[@SgtSupaman]

I'd guess that Andy's dad didn't buy Woody to play with as a toy. He, like Al, wanted Woody as a collector's item. That's why Andy didn't get Woody until after his father's death. While the father was alive, he would have kept Woody protected away from little Andy (probably up on a shelf where Andy could look at him longingly). When Andy's father dies around the time of the little sister's birth, though, Andy's mom finally just gives it to Andy when going through her husband's things, because she doesn't care about the collectible value and just knows her son wants the toy.

[@9nikola]

This would also explain why Woody wouldn't have memories of that time, if toys awaken by imagination.

[@fishandjam5383]

Woody was given to Andy's dad after a promotion (of which he was supposed to be the prize) was cancelled. J made a video talking about that 5 years ago. It's called Toy Story Zero: The True Story Of Andy's Dad & Woody's Origin (ft. Mike Mozart)

[@fishandjam5383]

Oh. I just saw that he mentioned that video in this one...

[@TristenSarelvun]

@@fishandjam5383 That's a theory, not fact. A very fun theory, but still just that.

[@fixedfunshow]

@@fishandjam5383 yep that's still a theory

[@antoninocannizzo4905]

I want the Andy dad story reveal in 5 - Woody comes back valuing his life as a child’s toy and the truth is uncovered

[@SupportGamin2025]

That's not happening let the Andy arc go already

[@antoninocannizzo4905]

@@SupportGamin2025 just wishful thinking my friend, I don’t expect anyone to listen to me

[@maylonieldridge5658]

avThere is an article out there where a toy maker who was a consultant for toy story was interviewed and he actually provided the story for Andy's dad. If I can locate it I'll link it as well. But there is a story and when I read it, it made so much sense it was scary.

[@antoninocannizzo4905]

@@maylonieldridge5658 SCB shared that story - the link to it is on this very video and that is the very story I want told in a new film😉

[@Smooby_Dooperson]

So towards the end of the video … around the 14:00 minute mark … is it possible Woody doesn’t remember anything because of Andy’s dad dying ?? Like Woody lost his memory because his original owner died so Woody lost all his memory ??

[@misskat2817]

Honestly, if the upcoming movie is actually going to be about this, I would totally watch it.

[@mrmj30]

It would be cool to see Sox and Buzz recognize each other, even though they both know they’re toys.

[@joshuacrisanto7419]

that would make sense since Buzz believed he's an actual space ranger

[@snaketooth0943]

Yeah, I want Sox to show up again! He was arguably the best character in LightYear!

[@SimPilotMika]

Maybe it talks about the trend of children (Bonnie) spending more time playing video games and technology rather than playing with toys

[@pokefan366]

It's possible that Toy Story 5 is where Andy's mom and dad were kids when they got Woody and Jesse at the beginning and by the end, the toys DO end up as heirlooms, thereby living forever.

[@CarlyCatharsis]

I Feel Tbat His Mom Was More Of The Cowgirl Type & That His Dad Was A Pilot👮 Which Was Why BUZZ Meant Sooo Much To Him & His Friends! But As He Got Older & Had Kids Of His Own, His Dad Passed-Away! His Mom is Just Picking-Up The Pieces & We Don't RLY HAVE TO See Andy Or Molly Within THIS Feature! Just A Teenaged Bonnie & Emily Remembering HER Past.

[@SupportGamin2025]

It wouldn't be called Toy Story 5 then,it would be a prequel

[@CarlyCatharsis]

@@SupportGamin2025 There Are MANY Films Which Are BOTH A Sequel & Prequel, When It Comes To Reminiscing Memories! Even ToyStory2 Had Flashbacks To Jessie & Woody's Origins! (Hence: Emily & WoodysRoundup) So It's Totally NOT Farfetched.

[@katholmes7112]

Considering traveling carnivals are starting to die out Woody would need a new home anyway. I think there are only a couple carnivals left which is a shame as they were a huge part of my childhood and I have great memories.

[@lasercraft32]

I'm STILL waiting for them to make a movie or show where an actual _human_ discovers that the Toys are alive. The closest we got was Sid, but there wasn't a lot of toy-to-human communication, just threats and scaring the pants off of him. I want to see the dynamic between a toy and a human actually _talking_ to each other.

[@Starkill3r306]

If Woody realizes he made the wrong choice and tried to redeem himself, it would be worth it

[@OfficialMummyCat]

Going back to Andy and being given to Andy's son

[@smb-c3po]

And if Andy goes on a quest to find him.

[@metroidotherm6170]

How is that the wrong choice?

[@theredhare2483]

Toy Story 5: Bros Before Hoes

[@metroidotherm6170]

@@donian544 no it doesn’t, he’s still making kids happy. And it’s not like Bonnie is going to miss him

[@buddyzilla4557]

It's way too late but a fun alternate toy story 2 or 3 could have been the reveal of a favorite toy before Woody, back for vengeance. It could be a great villain, being some abstract baby toy that has become mangled due to neglect, like a an old FNAF animatronic. How interesting would it be to see Woody have to come to terms with the fact he himself replaced another toy and attempt to help that toy learn the lesson he has from the first movie.

[@eyuin5716]

That would be sick

[@victoriarobinson6152]

I've always thought the favorite before Woody was Mr. Potato Head. He was suspiciously antagonistic to Woody in the first movie.

[@callumbaurley716]

This also works with the idea in this video. Woody meets the rest of the gang, slinky mentions another toy, finds toy extremely broken (old favourite) woody comes to terms, hears about someone who fixes toys and is crazy saying they are actually alive. Go to Davis old house, Sid still lives on that street, go to old house, Andy is there, maybe even with his own kid, the new kid finds Woody. Ends with "Reach for the sky"

[@DarthOminis]

kind of full circle there with TS1 being Woody coming to terms with not always being the favourite toy and this plot being him accepting that other toys had to accept that too.

[@maylonieldridge5658]

There was an article I read about a month or so ago that was an interview of a toy maker who was the consultant for the original movie ToyStory. He actually gave you the backstory for Woody/Andy's dad. Woody is a rare toy that Andy's dad won from the cereal box company that sponsored the woody round up series that later was canceled due to "space toys". This is why woody is so rare and valuable in the 2nd movie. The first movie takes place in Andy's dad's family home. This is why they're moving. Andy's dad suffered from post polio syndrome and died. Woody was one of the things he was able to keep after he got diagnosed because he hid him in the attic before they burned all of his belongings. (They burn all of your possessions when diagnosed with polio). Andy found woody in the attic and if you pay attention in the second movie you can hear his mom say its "an old family toy". So if there is a movie about it- it wouldn't do too much to add to this story.

[@PlanetJayster]

You know what I think would be EXTREMELY interesting to see in Toy Story 5 (ON TOP of FINALLY seeing Woody’s backstory since his inception in the late 1950s)? A MODERN in-universe revival of Woody’s Roundup in the present day! 🤠 I mean, think about it! Regardless of Bonnie’s “interest” in Woody at least 5-7 years after Toy Story 4, a modern in-universe revival of Woody’s Roundup would result in lots of present-day children (both in the movie AND in real life) buying their own newer Woody dolls, as well as Woody’s face being plastered all over the Toy Story world for everyone to see! In turn, this would ultimately result in Andy (regardless of where he is in life) wondering how his old Woody doll is doing with Bonnie, Bonnie potentially fighting the temptation to replace Woody with a new Woody doll (if she even still cares about Andy’s Woody doll after losing him), Buzz and the gang most likely preparing to conduct a NEAR-IMPOSSIBLE COUNTRY-WIDE search to bring the Woody know and love home (no matter what it takes)……………………………………… And after at least 5 years of being lost toy with Bo Peep and their crew of lost toys, OUR Sheriff Woody being FORCED to see “himself”, in the form of hundreds of newer Woody dolls, bringing joy to dozens of kids. Personally, I think an in-universe global awareness spike in Woody’s popularity would be just the thing to remind OUR Woody (whom we’ve all loved since 1995) that being there for your kid is important. That and it’s a legitimate question if Woody will react with fear and dread at the thought of Bonnie potentially replacing him, just like Lotso had been. Whether or not Stinky Pete will also return (in the form of a NEW friendly doll based on the revival) is up to you! I personally think an in-universe modern revival of Woody’s Roundup would be REALLY interesting for Toy Story 5, as it would allow the movie to preach new life lessons through Woody about remembering why loyalty is so important, as well as how everyone in the world is unique in the eyes of those who REALLY love you, even in a giant crowd of look-alikes (and this applies to both toys and their kids). To put the moral I’m referring to into simpler words………………. In the eyes of the world, you may be one person (one Sheriff Woody doll among hundreds of newer ones), but in the eyes of one person (Andy, Bonnie, Buzz, and the other toys), you may very well be the entire world. What do you think of this premise?

[@victoriagreer7609]

That would be awesome. A little ohmage to the buzz situation in two but Woody has to prove hes The Woody from the rest would be a nice scene.

[@PlanetJayster]

@@victoriagreer7609 Yeah. That and UNLIKE how Incredibles 2 kind of squandered an opportunity to inform the general public why superheroes are such a BIG DEAL OF IMPORTANCE nowadays (especially with the amount of superhero movies in 2018 and 2019), I DO think a Woody's Roundup revival would be a GREAT OPPORTUNITY for Disney and Pixar to explain EXACTLY why reboots, revivals, and sequels are SUCH A BIG DEAL OF IMPORTANCE TO THEM (not that I expect them to even TRY doing this at all, but hey, I can dream).

[@maxleon61702]

It would make a lot of sense for one of us.

[@PlanetJayster]

@@maxleon61702 What do you mean?

[@maxleon61702]

Truth be told, there's a lot of Story potential on how can this version of Toy Story 5 can possibly work.

[@foxspirit2146]

I was literally thinking the same thing about a way they could do Toy Story 5, Before they even announced it! There’s a good 35+ years between 1957 and 1995 which leaves a Huge gap they could fill! About Andy’s dad though, sadly a theory Pixar has turned down, but it leaves us with still the question of well then how else could Andy have gotten Woody? I actually theorized that Woody, after the show was cancelled, ended up at a daycare (not one as nice as Sunnyside). Through the years of being there, forgetting his tv show, and longing for an owner of his own, he eventually finds Andy through the daycare and becomes Andy’s toy. Not only can it fit the timeline and the few possible places Woody could have been, but Woody himself says, “Let’s just keep this in perspective” when talking about Sunnyside, after he defines daycares as, “a sad, lonely place, for washed up old toys who have no owners.” What perspective is he talking about and why does he define daycares as sad and lonely? Unless, he’s been to one before.

[@Psychpineapples]

I like that theory. But also. I can see Bonnie is grown up now and no longer plays with her toys. She hears about Andy expecting a baby and plans to give him the toys during his wife's baby shower. Buzz hears too and develops the plan to find woody again. And that is how the toys reunite.

[@TheReal_Jonny]

I LOVE THAT!

[@catherinerebeccadavis]

that is so precious 😢

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

Also while those are going on Lotso and Stinky Pete can end up teaming up to go after Woody because they believe he ruined their life.

[@amyli092]

​@@Kenny-ep2nf Now THAT is a major plot twist that I'm willing to see! Nothing says villainous treachery than a good old bout of resentment and jealousy.

[@jackaweplushpro]

@@amyli092 or maybe buzz 2 and zurg could return, don’t forget about those guys

[@gregliana3405]

I hope somebody from the Disney company comes and finds this video. Because this is actually a great Story. Disney should take notes

[@TheReal_Jonny]

And there’s great ideas if they don’t like it in the comment section

[@jeovanylazcano305]

I have a theory , Andy is feeling nostalgic and wants to rebuy his childhood toys while woody is in the house he sees Andy on eBay trying to buy woody back so woody rings the door bell and Andy gets up to open the door and there he sees his old buddy woody and the rest of the gang and it’s a sappy whole full story moment .

[@Thedudson]

Yall are so amazing and im so glad I found yalls Channel.

[@callistamccracken3744]

I'm just baffled as to why Disney/Pixar hasn't snagged you two up to replace all of the writers. I really want to see this movie.

[@Hebrew-Nation1]

I believe it should end with the backstoru of how Andy got woody and ending woth woody speaking to andy for the first time

[@Daddyoh94]

I love the idea of having Toy Story 4 be called Woody: A Toy Story, and then they can continue to revisit classic characters like that

[@SamFlowers995]

So like the Star Wars spin-off lol

[@TimDaco]

That would actually be a Great Story. Having Toy Story 5 kind of be like Toy Story 0 is Genius! I hope Disney and Pixar take notes.

[@lasercraft32]

The problem with Lightyear WASN'T that we were expecting Woody, Potato Head, Rex, etc... The problem was that it didn't feel like Buzz, the writing was kinda mid, and it was overall inconsistent with pre-established information we know from Toy Story.

[@LucasHopkins2006]

I’d love to see Sox in this next movie and how Buzz and the toys react to it like Buzz being like “Oh, Sox, glad to finally see you as a toy” while everyone is just like “Buzz has a pet robot cat?!” but I swear if they make this seem like an actual ending like 3 and 4 only to make a Toy Story 6 I’m not sure how much more I could take from Disney

[@BabyGirlTiny]

They literally undid the entire ending of the third movie to make the fourth movie. They’ll be fine

[@oliverpony]

7:25 I called BS on that statement because we already had a Buzz Lightyear movie 20 years ago called Buzz lightyear of Star Command and it was Great and didn't involved woody, Rex or potato head Except for the opening

[@zaborne3540]

This is an amazing theory!!! I got chills when you mentioned Andy having a son.... u should be writing this movie.... I can't imagine a better story now.

[@meganrickards7902]

Or, there’s this SPECTACULAR fanfic about Toy Story called Toy Size that takes place between 2 & 3 that would make an AMAZING movie!!!! Without giving away the story, I’ll say that it was touching reading about Woody, Andy and some of the other toys, going on an adventure to get back home. Yes, it’s similar the Toy Story 2 we already have, but it ups the stakes and involves other kids. While it would be the darkest Toy Story to date, it is changeable to make it lighter and more in tone with the other movies.

[@SamFlowers995]

Where can I find it?

[@lthecatt9667]

The most shocking part of this video is realising that your twins are 3 already. I remember when you told on the Pop that you got twins. Now I'm feeling old

[@kiminimuchu__]

Right! I still remember him and Beth announcing on their vlog that they were having twins... I can't believe they're 3 already.

[@michaeloluwajuyemi4546]

I would ❤️ to see how Andy first got Woody!

[@micaelasparrow650]

They had what felt like the perfect ending in 3. I personally didn’t think the 4th one was necessary much less a 5th. I didn’t watch the 4th one and don’t plan to watch this one either. But your premise of Woody coming back for Andy’s kids is still sweet.

[@hirohiroarikawa6806]

You actually liked it, I liked 4 cuz we saw bo peep and they ending with “ to infinity and beyond” the whole series is just woodys stories and the problems he faces. Imo 3 felt like a meh ending

[@OkRoomer123-]

​@@hirohiroarikawa6806 4th installment wasn't necessary

[@CosmicNova1000]

@@OkRoomer123- Hush it was necessary the 4th was a nice epilogue for the whole franchise.

[@CosmicNova1000]

No, the 4th installment was a nice epilogue and it was necessary.

[@OkRoomer123-]

@@CosmicNova1000 naa it was trash

[@joshlong7680]

One point I’ve noticed coming from a kid that watched each movie as they came out is that the writers audience seems to be young viewers, of course, but also the people that were kids when Toy Story began. The timeline of Andy would resonate with the age of the original viewers so having Andy’s child would match the original viewers timeline of life as well. I was close to Andy’s age for the first movie, now married and planning for kids, a plot with Andy’s kid would relate to me and my family and connect to my storyline just as well. High level story telling if that was their intention.

[@krystalmendez2994]

My brother and I were predicting that toy story 5 may be about Andy having a kid, and just the thought of that being a possibility makes me so emotional

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

I thought that it would happen in Toy story 4

[@krystalmendez2994]

@@Kenny-ep2nf so did I at first, but I'm kind of happy it didn't happen because in 3 we say goodbye to Andy, so for him to come in 4 like HEY I'M BACK would feel too soon. Like bruh Andy we all love you, but you JUST left

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

@@krystalmendez2994 yeah it would be cool if his return was a result of building up of events lol

[@Jordansklar0698]

but rip Don Rickles so idk if potatoe head would have any lines or how theyd do that 13:38

[@victoriarobinson6152]

The major problem I had with Lightyear was that it was supposed to be the movie that made Andy obsessed with Buzz Lightyear, and you cannot convince me a child that age actually liked that movie. It would have been nice if they had just made a campy 90s/00s space adventure film that followed the lore introduced in Toy Story 1 and 2.

[@maxleon61702]

Some facts. That being said, the Cat is the actual Star of the entire show.

[@coloredfunwithbrother9286]

When we left the theater I told my dad,” Ya,the Toy Story series has ended.”

[@lollipopcorndog]

They should’ve made a prequel with Andy’s dad as a kid and it would’ve showed Woody and his gang before Andy’s Toys.

[@brandonspain12345]

I really want the 5th film to have Buzz be the other Buzz from Toy Story 2. I mean We saw Zurg was taken to the daycare center in 3 with no Buzz #2 around, and it makes you wonder what and where he was doing ever since then. And it would make sense if he became a lost toy after the second film living his own adventure. That way you'd still get Buzz Lightyear tagging along with Woody that wouldn't interfere or contradict the ending of the 4th film.

[@e_on_the_keys]

I think that they should do something similar the gotg3 with the main story in present day but periodically they cut to flashbacks of woodys backstory and maybe show Andy’s dad

[@pablopissacoproductions538]

My theory : Andys father gave Andy woodie before he passed away and thats why woody is his favourite toy.

[@danielknapp159]

Literally, the fulfillment of the film theory speculating that the toys would rebel against humanity in some way. Continuing where bo peep left off.

[@NotCharlesMorse]

"If woody helps andy out of some sort of adulthood jam..." made me pause the video and audibly go "YES."

[@Usernamegoeshere93]

Honestly if this isn’t the story line to Toy Story 5 I’m gonna be kind of sad lol 😂

[@idunnobutyay2520]

Slightly happier theory about the dad leaving: he’s at the new house with half of the stuff, so he’s just waiting for Andy, Molly, and his mom

[@madnessarcade7447]

I’m down for a TS5 we still need to grow with Bonnie the way we did with Andy there’s more story to tell And there are other toys to spotlight and become the main characters Toy Story five is the next chapter with a new protagonist Not sure why everyone assumes it has to end with Andy and woody there are dozens of other toys who haven’t had their stories told yet

[@BabyGirlTiny]

@@julyakacarrie6260 nah, there’s nothing buzz can do. He’s not the favorite toy

[@CarbonAnimationProductions]

god im gonna fight back tears in movies. especially since my grandfather isnt here anymore to watch it with me

[@jypsridic]

You guys seem to absolutely love everything that pixar and disney produce so I think the actual answer to this question for you two is to just slap the pixar label on it

[@smb-c3po]

The movie should be about Andy going on a journey to search for Woody after finding out Bonnie lost him on a family trip, the plot starts when Andy comes homr from college to check if Bonnie kept her promise and the movie could end at a flashforward to Andy's kids playing with the toys under his supervision.

[@AmyOnhercomputer]

please

[@smb-c3po]

@@AmyOnhercomputer It'd be perfect

[@BabyGirlTiny]

No, that would make Andy super creepy and weird. It would also make Andy a hypocrite considering he’s lost woody before in Toy Story 1 and 2. So he can’t literally hate and blame an actual child. That’s why the whole thing with Sid rubs me the wrong way as an adult. Because he was just a kid playing with his toys

[@jasonlewis9240]

Bonnie sucks

[@smb-c3po]

@@BabyGirlTiny You have to admit it'd be a perfect way to undo the ending of Toy Story 4.

[@liftlash98]

Anyone else have a wild theory that pixar announced toy story 5 with no story ideas in mind and right now is currently watching theories made in response to the announcement to work the story out?

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

I wouldn’t be shocked at all, that’s why I say whoever comes up with a theory should try the best they could to write a real solid one that would be awesome

[@edgarleft]

What I wanted to see in Toy Story 4 was Andy discovering that woody is alive. But now that may be a little too late

[@jessicaantonucci3720]

That'll ruin the Magic

[@thonglo1]

Maybe Toy Story 5 will be about kids are not longer playing with toys and are on devices.

[@siradof]

NOW I'm bursting with anticipation to witness the release of TS5! I'm eager to discover if I was correct in my predictions!

[@SkinnyMood27]

My theory is that Toy Story 5 will be about Andy in college, and some other person has a toy in their dorm room. The toy... comes alive. And Andy sees it! He would then get curious if His toys were ever alive, and then he goes a hunt to track down his toys for a final closure with the playthings of his childhood.

[@ezralu2911]

Yess this would be awesome!!

[@markbrown2640]

Huge problem: both Don Rickles (Mr. Potatohead) and Jim Varney (Slinky Dog) have passed away. Blake Clark, who replaced Varney, and Wallace Shawn are not young men.

[@natejablonski]

So has Mrs. Potatohead (I think her name was Estelle Harris?) It's not an easy fix.

[@NoUploadJustComment]

Before the video I was skeptical on how they could make a good ending to 5. After the video I’m convinced they have to make 5 and this is a great plot.

[@Kenny-ep2nf]

Toy Story 5 has to come out

[@mistingwolf]

What if _Woody's Roundup_ got rebooted, and suddenly Woody is famous again? Canonically, it's, what, 50, 60 years since the original? Sounds about the right time-frame for a rehash.

[@smahdif4527]

i really LOVED the idea of Woody being Andy's son's at the end. Also there can be a lot of detils in between this adventure to make it even better such as Woody talking to Andy and kind of comforting him as he's his dad.

[@stepheniekelley6995]

I’ve always thought, the complete ending to the Toy Story franchise would be, Andy has a child and then sets out to find all of his old toys he useto play with so he and his children would play with the toys. It ends up he actually finds all the original toys he had and ends with Woody and gang recognizing it’s him again and they start over…not sure what the rest of the movie would be about but that’s my dream ending. Every toy story has basically talked about fears that came reality or not being able to do something that they gone into into the next films. Fear of being thrown away to the dump, becoming a lost toy, having an owner who doesn’t want you anymore. It all fits for me

[@edwinreid8355]

Make it a prequel, there's so much material & minor back stories we've discovered through out the series.

[@oddfjell]

I needed this video. I had so many questions

[@madnessarcade7447]

TS5 is likely the end of buzz’s story

[@frog_flower_official]

Okay hear me out imagine they make Toy Story 5 about Andy grown up to have kids and the kids somehow find Woody and show their dad

[@ItzCarly16]

My prediction for TS5 We leave off in the same amusement park some years later Woody see’s a little girl crying in the corner cause she’s lost Her Family Woody then runs to her cuz “ she looks like Andy” Woody also helps The little girl find her family she find her dad then woody finds out that that’s Andy’s daughter. Andy’s daughter (that let’s call Zoey) then takes woody home with them. Also Teen Bonnie is Zoey’s babysitter and she loves bonnie’s toys so of course bonnie give them to her (so there the Gangs back together again ❤) so that’s my production for TS5 I want this as the new movie even though it’s probably not but I do think the theory in the video was very good and I’m pretty sure that will be the plot of the movie❤ I just want to see Andy again ❤

[@harrisonlittrell1140]

Did Mr. Potato Head even have arms in the 50s?

[@lucasgoad5691]

The plot and story for Toy Story 5: Woody becomes so sentient that he ends up realizing he's a movie character. He ends up finding out about the Monster world and their time travel technology ( The Doors) and gathers up as many Pixar characters as he possible can. He doesn't care how long it takes. He gathers them, eventually finding a portal to the real world where he finds Pixar Studios, and sleighs his tormentors, aka, Jim Morris, Aka the main man at Pixar. Before he finishes off Jim, Woody is told of the first Toy Story movie. He finds out about John Lassetter. He, along with the other Pixar gang gathers around the home of Lassetter. Lassetter comes to the door. As the door opens, we get a close up of Woody smiling. Fade to black, we hear a scream..... the end. Or maybe it's no that, IDK, I'm bored at work.

[@TheReal_Jonny]

Maybe a mini episode

[@karenjordan5731]

I Flippin love your storyline!!! That was awesome!

[@buddyzilla4557]

Anyone else love that Tot Story is the likly the most successful franchise to sell toys..of toys? Even better; McDonald's then sells the toys of those toys! Unpresidented inception level stuff.

[@JamesLawner]

I'd love to see Toy Story 5 feature Woody talking to Andy, now that would be something we've never seen in a Toy Story movie before.

[@Patrick61804]

If it ends up being Toy Story 0 with the Andy’s dad story then it’s worth it

[@CarlyCatharsis]

His Dad IS Literally A Pilot👮. Which Was Why BUZZ Meant Sooo Much To Him & His Friends! But His Mom IS Emily & Now That Andy is A Working Adult & Has Kids If His Own, It's Time To Refocus On Ms.Davis Picking-Up The Pieces Of Her Single Life! As Her Husband Had Passed-On & Pizza🍕Planet is Being Torn-Down Due To Being Abandoned & In Disrepair For MANY YEARS! That's Where Sid Comes-In... He's NOW A Construction🚧 Worker Hired To Help Demolish The Site, As Emily Looks On! He Sees Her & They Chat A Bit.

[@jackaweplushpro]

I think it would be nice if it’s about how it fixes the fourth movies ending. I like Toy Story 4 though I don’t like how it retcons 3’s ending

[@samanthaworthen1845]

Day 59 of begging for the SuperCarlinBrothers to please bring back Google Auto Fill videos please!

[@OfficialMummyCat]

Seeing woody return to Andy and be given to Andy's son

[@funlplayz]

The hate on the fifth movie’s announcement killed me, because I was wondering on what would happen after the last scene?

[@idunnobutyay2520]

I would like to see a Sox cameo in Toy Story 5, and as for a Woody’s Roundup spin off, I’d like to see them do it as a 1930s/40s singing cowboy musical

[@ravastarkskywalkermcqueen95]

Toy Story 5 might be the movie to turn the franchise from being about Woody Pride to the Toy Stories franchise where any toy character in that world can have a movie based around them. Sort of the Disney Planes of the Toy Story Franchise, set in the same world but very adjacent to the main characters that we’ve fallen in love with.

[@cagedtigersteve]

I'm crying! This story is so good. Can't wait to watch it.

[@serenabenting]

I don’t know if Woody will be in it all. 1-4 seems like the Woody saga. 4 seems to be the end of Woodys story, what with him leaving, but we also have buzz starting to take up his position as the leader of the toys. So maybe it will be all about buzz and him being alone without woody to guide him

[@BabyGirlTiny]

Don’t know what you can do with buzz considering he’s not Bonnie’s favorite toy.

[@TheReal_Jonny]

Maybe it could be about forky?

[@maxleon61702]

Unless, he is in a Supporting Role.

[@alex.bradford]

I have come up with a perfect plot for Toy Story 5 *major comment incoming PLOT: At the beginning, it parallels between playtime at bonnies, and her having Jessie rounding up all the toys, and Woody finding lost toys. Next it’s five years later, and bonnie is 11. Her mom is making her give away toys, and the first to go are trixie, dolly, and buttercup. Buzz makes it a mission to go and rescue them. Meanwhile on Woody’s side, the fair has come back to town, and they are rescuing toys from the road, the trash, and other places. A superhero toy says her friend GI Jack is stuck in the school, so Woody, Bo, Duckie, Bunny, and Duke make it a mission to go find him. Buzz, Jessie, Bullseye, Rex, Slink, Mr. Potato Head, and Hamm arrive at the school looking for their friends, and find them in the 5/6 year old room. They get caught and get put away in the preschool room. Woody, Bo, Duckie, Bunny, and Duke arrive at school just in time to see their friends being taken to the room. They get caught and are taken to the 3-4 year old room. Those broken toys acknowlege them and give their best wishes because once playtime begins, it’s downhill, especially for Bo being glass. Buzz and the gang try to find away to escape but can’t, until GI Jack wants to help them escape. They try to escape, but Lots-o shows up and has them locked away. Woody and Bo see this and ask the other toys to aid them. The other tattered, destroyed toys don’t believe they can, so woody sings to try to cheer him up. Bo, Ducky, Bunny, and Duke are shocked and joke because Woody has never done that before. He inspires them to all help free their friends. Locked away, the gang tries to free themselves to no luck. Race Car, Building Blocks, Lego Man, GI Jack, Stick Man, Lincoln Logs, and Wiz the Wizard toy try to help them escape. Woody and the other toys leave their room, and make it out in time to help the other toys free buzz and friends. As they are escaping, Lots-o finds them and tries to lock them in. Woody and Buzz tell him he won’t trap them again. They say there is a little girl named Bonnie who would love to have him, or Woody is looking for lost toys who kids would love to have. Lots-o says he has given up on kids love, and has them locked in a plastic box. Later that night, Mrs. Potato Head, Barbie, Ken, Mr. Pricklepants, Forky and Gabby Gabby show up to help. They free the other toys and they all escape. Lots-o tries one last time to trap them, but they all escape, throwing Lots-o in the trash. They hurry back to Bonnie’s house. They see Bonnie wasn’t worried thanks to her new electronics. Bonnie’s mom is surprised to see the toys, thinking she donated them. She asks Bonnie again what she wants to do with them, and Bonnie says she has the perfect idea. At the end, Bonnie gives her toys back to Andy for his daughter to have, showing how fast kids get tired of toys these days thanks to electronics. Andy holds his toys, happy to have them back. He holds Woody in his arms and says "Welcome back, partner"

[@maxleon61702]

And I can imagine Al McWhiggin being a part of this one too.

[@jennerhirata8404]

I feel like instead of a fifth Toy Story movie, a Lightyear movie for Woody in the style of westerns like Tombstone and The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly would a good movie

[@rtlthemusician5598]

In my heart, every video still ends with “THESE SOCKS ARE AMAZING”

[@rintmacleanen2972]

They are going to be making Toy Story movies to infinity and beyond at this point

[@TheReal_Jonny]

I’m stoked to see that one

[@ritakrill6211]

This is an amazing plot for a 5th movie.. I sincerely hope this is what they go with!

[@maxthebearshor]

6:27 Oh God ever since "Lightyear" came out my friend/girlfriend at school has been OBSESSED with Sox

[@miggytime85]

Here’s a wild idea! Let’s say the 5th movie is about woodys adventures with Bo and time has past and they gained new friends. Then midway in the movie they are on a play ground and a toddler picks up woody and plays with him. Parents don’t notice and toddler brings woody home. Child’s room is heavily themed to cowboys. Woody meets that child’s toys and he feels like he belongs again.near the end the father sees woody and says I used to have a woody doll when I was younger then looks at the boot at scraps away the old paint to reveal Andy’s name and camera pans up to fathers face and father reacts by saying woody is that you. 😢😢😢😢

[@HannahEvansOfficial]

Love your videos

[@MusicByOwlsome]

for me, they can make as many as they want. Its such a great concept! A toys journey almost never end!

[@renamon5658]

I would like toy story 5 to be about woody going back to bonnie with bo peep

[@Smithylufc]

I wish i hadn't watched this video. I now need this story to be the plot of TS5 or I will be terribly dissapointed 😅

[@kisds700]

I gotta say, I wasn’t excited for Toy Story 5 when it was announced, but hearing your guys’ ideas, I definitely am now!

[@lauryn7158]

I really hope Toy Story 5 ends up being the Toy Story 4 we deserved. But I don't have high hopes. I'm convinced it's just a cash grab which is really upsetting

[@ryandunnthegunn2348]

10:13 “🎶and as the years go by, our friendship will never die 🎵”