Support and Resistance Vs. Supply and Demand

[@jonatancarmen5653]

This knowledge is the best I found in KZbin in almost 2 years. Thanks a lot

[@carmine_rosato]

No, thank you for that!

[@ElVikingodelRock]

I'm new on trading and since i have been studying price action and smart money concepts, couldn't understand until now, the difference between support and resistance and supply and demand areas. I have been comparing the charts with the information that you are sharing on your video and also, this could explain perfectly well what hunting liquidity is. Almost for me. Many traders such as me, sometimes trust on a support or a resistance strength until it is suddenly broken, then we are stopped out and then, the price continues it's way just on the same direction we expected. I must have to add this concepts to my trading strategy. Thanks for the video.

[@Lawestyo1]

Been paper trading this strategy for two weeks. First real trade using it today...green my man. 🤜🤜

[@freshprinceofali]

THANK YOU for showing where the demand form was formed (in your BA example) This really helps understand how supply/demand zones are created. Please continue to do this in future videos. Love your content!

[@carmine_rosato]

Appreciate it!!

[@oscarvivar5986]

Totally agree with you. This video is the best at showing what Carmine finds a great S/D

[@tyscof]

@@carmine_rosato Why wasn't there also demand around that support line though? right after where you put your demand zone there was a green red green candle zone. It acted like a demand zone later on hence the bounces and making it a support which would mean it is used up, is that why?

[@imabeast6594]

Yo bro I couldn't grasp supply and demand and you finally made me realize!! Dude thank you. I checked the charts and was astounded

[@carmine_rosato]

Glad I could help!

[@oo-sm5oi]

its easy to identify supply and demand areas for candles in the past. do we trade in the past or in the present though? How do you identify supply and demand zones if you are trading live?

[@joeb956]

Good question

[@joeb956]

Does he sell a course with these answers

[@bmatt9379]

This supply and demand zone theory is mind blowing. Completely different way to look at charts. Thanks.

[@Hknasw]

How do you determine the height of the zones you draw? I understand where to mark the zones but confused as to how to determine the height of them

[@carmine_rosato]

Usually to the top of the basing period

[@navketan1965]

Sir, Trading with supply & demand method on 4 H charts, is it better that the area have additional confirmation with MTF fractals. Even if S/D area gets respected OR rejected, market can still whip saw in the area & trader can still lose. Do you recommend sticking with 4H,/Daily chart S/D levels for trend direction OR is that not necessary. Market makers in forex also play their liquidity harvesting to pick pockets around these levels. We need your wisdom.

[@carmine_rosato]

yes HIGHER timeframe for trend direction and MARKET CONTEXT

[@navketan1965]

I find that for intraday forex trend trading most important relevant (Guide)trend direction is ON 15 minute, 1h and 4h charts only-- For intraday trading weekly & monthly trends do not matter much(too far removed from intraday field of activity) & can be ignored. For simplicity sake if 15 minute ,1h & 4h trends are in the same direction, you have a trade set up in the same direction (one could fine tune entry 0n 5 minute charts). In general if daily candle be in the same direction for any trade it is better but not A must.--Sir, what do you have to say?

[@19961471]

This was really good! In the other video you talked about imbalance and balance. How does that relate to support and resistance?!

[@roki520]

So how to draw s/d zones, how to identity those zones, what is the rules? Wicks, consolidation zone, smalls bodies?

[@UrDadisMe]

Thank you so much for these videos. I can't tell you how appreciative we are of them.

[@cryptoron8732]

Not sure how I missed this channel! Carmine you are absolutely AMAZING SIR!! THANK YOU !!!!!!!!!!

[@abdul.maajid]

with all due respect , I feel somehow, Support is similar to demand and resistance is similar to supply. Price stops from falling further because there is a new demand similarly, price stops from rising further cuz der is more supply . thank u

[@navketan1965]

SIR, When trading forex with daily support/resistance levels trades get executed infrequently--so next choice is S/R 4 H chart levels, as directional bias & 15M chart price action live execution. Anyone recommends putting standing orders at 15M,S/R levels in direction of 4H trend in 6-8 forex pairs every day & SIT. After all at S/R levels odds of TRADING EDGE are still better than even, Each order has stop loss but no TP--need your wisdom.

[@mrmonaco6800]

Yes way! Such a great vid. Best one I've seen on supply and demand. Subscribed.

[@setofirons]

How do you how thick to draw the demand /supply zone? You could shade $4 worth and be right or be wrong if it only lowers by $1. Be elaborate on how you determined how much to shade in for both. Thx

[@WeenieTradesLLC]

Great Video Carmine! When I did my trading recaps for the month, a great chunk of my losses were from longing in supply zones and a few shorts in demand zones. A lot can and will learn this over time.

[@carmine_rosato]

Long in demand. Short in supply. Don’t fight the trend!

[@WeenieTradesLLC]

@@carmine_rosato Yes, but sometimes the trend is still intact until it catches that order imbalance to reverse price. They're all pivot points and sometimes you can catch a really nice breakout/breakdown.

[@mdtrader885]

Once again...Very important video boss... This is the reason Breakout trade fails , i experienced these kind of situations..

[@carmine_rosato]

Yep!

[@christopherbeharry5294]

It’s easy to draw support and resistance. However, what would be some tips on getting the supply and demand zones on there?

[@carmine_rosato]

I have some videos on it. The key is finding price imbalances on the chart. Find where the market was balanced before a violent and aggressive drop which would have caused an imbalance

[@timsimspon5510]

Carmine Rosato are these videos in here?

[@oscarvivar5986]

@@timsimspon5510 Yes they are.

[@winsonliu1691]

Thanks for putting out all this content. I just saw these videos and I'm actually having quite a bit of trouble following how you determine what is a demand zone or a supply zone. I watched several videos and it doesn't seem to click. Do you have another more introductory video where you have a completely new chart without any zones drawn and you explain how you determine those zones? I understand the underlying actions to buy and sell when they approach those zones, but I have absolutely no grasp on picking those zones. It seems arbitrary/subjective, even though I know they aren't. Can you help?

[@winsonliu1691]

Like at minute 8, I'm not comprehending how you know there's a buy-order imbalance. The large red candle going down tells me that sell orders are pushing the price down. But how do you know there are buy orders sitting there waiting for the price to come down before a bunch of buy orders fire off and send the price shooting back up? You said you already knew there was a demand zone below the support. But how'd you even determine that demand zone to begin with?

[@joeb956]

Winson Liu did you get a answer

[@joeb956]

I thought he mentioned about a certain candle which indicated a zone

[@joeb956]

I think you have to buy a course

[@bidxask4666]

I’m in the same boat. The only logic he shares is the buy or sell orders sitting there after a large move down. The same could be said of support and resistance. It resisted there because too much supply. I don’t see how that’s differentiated from a zone where there’s to many sell orders on one side. Whether it’s 1 institution or a lot of ppl too much supply is too much supply. I feel like every vid is jus “this happened cause it came to supply. It’s supply because price moved from there. Buy at demand sell at supply “ but never actually says why that is supply. No hate or shade meant to be thrown either. I appreciate everyone educating others but every vid sounds the same. There is no more new detail being added in any vid.

[@bradwheeler7287]

Carmine i like the way you explain things. Very easy to understand and comprehend. This kind of smart trading makes all the difference in knowing what you're getting into. Nice Work

[@sagesilverman6842]

Thanks for the different perspective. So much free knowledge!

[@carmine_rosato]

Always!

[@Khanh88tran]

Carmine, Great video...how was you able to put a note (demand zone) on supply and demand line?. I don't have that option on TOS. I was only able to do the zone for supply and demand but unable to noted on the line.

[@BobbyBoucher41]

Wow man I’ve been trading for a couple months now and I feel like I’ve been tossed and dragged into different directions. I like how simplistic and easy to understand you make it. Definitely joining up the discord.

[@BobbyBoucher41]

@David M it has! Definitely recommend it. Especially if you’re a beginner. I went and bought the entire course just to reteach myself and it’s been so worth it. He actually teaches you trading from the very beginning and helps you understand it better than 99% of the people teaching it online. It’s not all about the money it’s about the strategy and education and the money follows. If you have any hesitancy I can assure you it’s worth it.

[@rese2litt24]

What trading app do you use to get that view on the computer ?

[@Ahmed.Hamza.Salman]

Makes since and appreciated Didn't understand though how to draw supply and demand zones rather than just trying to figure them out. Thanks a lot for sharing

[@carldominguez4478]

Thanks Carmine! Your knowledge is so valuable and it helps tremendously to learn something new about the markets and your strategy!

[@WALKWITHHIM]

thanks i had that question from watching other i want to ask if suport and resistance was supply and demand this video answered it

[@kidcool7773]

How big should the supply and demand zone be

[@carmine_rosato]

As big as the imbalance was created

[@chiz_o3794]

So we break above supply, get a pull back to said previous supply zone and start to get a rally of buyers... does the mean our supply zone has turned into a demand zone?

[@jamevolve8380]

Do you go super in depth on supply and demand zones in your course? Like why the basing candles prove the specific zone is a supply or demand zone ?

[@carmine_rosato]

Everything you need to know

[@jamevolve8380]

@@carmine_rosato good to know, definitely going to buy your course then

[@lindslou9654]

Well done! So helpful & insightful! Thank you for sharing your wisdom!

[@Luis-zh9eb]

I found you by simply searching for supply and demmand. I've found that using S&R lines on my chart causes me to get on the wrong side of the market often. However, once I started using zones, I could see how accurate those reversals occurred in those zones. In this video, you said you have a video on what timeframes to use to conduct this type of analysis, I will look for it but could you point it out incase I am unable to find it in your video library.

[@joeb956]

Luis did you get a answer

[@leemelvin6514]

you need to wait for confirmation when using S/R. and make sure you are using higher TF and trading with the trend.

[@balaskonis]

at the end of the video you mention another video about the best timeframes to draw supply/demand - which video of yours is that? I know you start at monthly-weekly-daily-4-2-1-30-15 is that all the time? anytime you don't do that?

[@sickwitit289]

Nice! I have been using the supply and demand strategy but have not used it with S&R going to start using both together

[@EscoPicoTrane]

Excellent video once again, Thanks and keep up the great work!

[@stateofmyned]

Imma newbie imma ask a question: im someone is selling which denotes a red candle, there are buyers who's buying that tree candle right but why the price falls if there are buyers in that red candle

[@peter9style]

First of all, a big thank you for sharing your insights! One question though, at 9:35 you have a demand zone based on a 2h candlestick (which is clearly part of the uptrend). If these are the signals for a "balanced" market, I would need to draw 5 bazillion supply/demand zones in my chart. Understanding that breaking down the 2h into perhaps 15min candles will give a different picture - but isn't that just looking for self-fulfilling prophecies nonstop?

[@psianime]

Great video as always. I will keep this strategy and chart observation in mind when I am looking for trend reversals which provide great risk:reward.

[@carmine_rosato]

Yes. They provide the best risk:reward in my opinion

[@jklfghjkl]

Great lesson Carmine.Thanks for sharing.

[@giglehart]

Those were definitely key points. Might help me get an edge and avoid getting trapped. Didn’t know that’s how price acts in S/D zones.

[@MalcDiesel21]

thanks carmine. you give a lot of great information most definitely helping me to learn the market. since I'm a beginner I got to keep watching your videos over and over cause you move so fast lol. But once I grasp the concept it's smooth sailing. keep up the good work!

[@rombusworkmoney22]

You used the term "aggressive orders". What makes an order aggressive?

[@fabiennevdk7045]

Market orders are aggressive orders, as traders want to enter/exit the market immediately and are willing to get filled at whatever the current best bid/offer is. Limit orders are passive orders, as traders are willing to wait until their desired price is reached and their limit order will just sit there until the condition is met.

[@justinb2374]

I wish you'd go into how u know where to draw these supply and demand zones

[@kannankapoor5921]

Hey! I was wondering how you identify these supply/ demand zones. I mean once we know the zones, it's a different picture. But when we have to identify the zones from scratch, I can't distinguish a S/D zone from a S/R level. Thanks.

[@setofirons]

Did he answer your question?

[@joeb956]

If you find a video that explains this let us know

[@oscarvivar5986]

S/D became my favorite topic but my zones are nog always confirmed as much as yours. Can you clear your areas and then explain what qualifies as a zone and how to mark it.

[@carmine_rosato]

I will try to make more in-depth videos on this. But I would recommend going through my channel and you will have a better understanding by linking all the pieces together of my supply demand videos

[@oscarvivar5986]

@@carmine_rosato I watched all your videos like 3 times already 😅 That's how I've been able to get some consistency but still not at your level. I love how you explain about order imbalances btw

[@kumarvishwaranjan7359]

You explained supports and resistances to be areas. But you marka horizontal line as support and resistance.

[@carmine_rosato]

Supply & demand are areas. Support and resistance are horizontal price points

[@Hknasw]

Why not use the Nasdaq Full book on TOS instead of level 2 when it shows more than Level 2?

[@carmine_rosato]

Full book?

[@Hknasw]

@@carmine_rosato Yeah. When you click on Level 2 there is an option to use the Nasdaq full book which shows you all price levels and not the few Level 2 give

[@carmine_rosato]

Oh yes I understand. Market was closed at time of recording so full order book wasn’t shown

[@Hknasw]

@@carmine_rosato Do you use the full book since it shows way more than level 2? If no why not?

[@ParthPatel-ic4ip]

Imbalances happen when price aggressively moves in one direction right? Sorry I’m pretty new only have 2 months of learning experience

[@mayer1107]

Does supply and demand work for the 1 minute time frame at all?

[@TheBloodGospel]

thanks for the free information. I can't wait to buy the course and enter the discord chat!

[@carmine_rosato]

Thanks for supporting. Let me know if you have any questions before joining !

[@TheBloodGospel]

@@carmine_rosato sure thing 👍 does the A-Z course include the full supply and demand course?

[@carmine_rosato]

Yes, that’s correct

[@TheBloodGospel]

@@carmine_rosato okay ill be getting it tomorrow. thank you

[@TheBloodGospel]

@@carmine_rosato Hey sorry, I'm looking to get the course right now but there's a question, If I start the course can I Pause and come back if something comes up? also how many times can I watch the 9hr course?

[@dcsck1]

a friend refers your video, it's a great video, question, can we generalize that Supply zone is area near the Resistant and Demand zone is ate area near the Support? TIA

[@bookbearerplus]

Excellent video, thanks!

[@milanstankovic8991]

Hi @Carmine Rosato !! You put out amazing stuff ! I just wanted to see if I’m understanding this correctly- is the supply and demand zone strategy essentially helping you predict and take advantage of double/triple tops (shorting supply zones) and double/triple bottoms (buying demand ) as they develop.? Appreciate your reply and all the help you give out here on YT

[@timsimspon5510]

How do decide that Aug 5 was a demand zone?

[@acelee6063]

Excellent video Thanks 😊

[@worklove5147]

support and resistance are also zone... not a line like you said. The video was kind of disappointed but thank you any way.

[@thomasadin7189]

Thank you Carmine!!!

[@carmine_rosato]

Thanks for supporting!

[@JonnyW.]

Good one. Thanks Carmine

[@BananasananaB]

I still don't understand how one knows there is a supply or demand imbalance.

[@arshia1678]

very good content

[@kapasihome]

I learned soo much, thank you very much!

[@howardhill3395]

Well explained & illustrated. The differences are important. Just be careful with terminology. i noticed a couple of times you said resistance & support zones. I know you meant levels not areas. Best to say levels or lines, otherwise it adds to confusion.

[@jacksonkabura6012]

you are a true genius!

[@TheRealSirHansfelix]

Well done bro!!

[@cheetahpsg4988]

Thank you for another great video Carmine. This stock market is something else, and having a decent understanding (and I need more) of Supply and Demand trading has helped me cut my losses down even though I often have a hard time milking my gains properly in a volatile market and when playing longer timeframe options for emerging stocks.

[@carmine_rosato]

Awesome!!!

[@LexiesMidnight]

Very good, thank you.

[@goodnatureification]

Nice video. I’m still struggling with drawing supply and demand properly.

[@kurtjohnson8378]

I learn alot from your video today thanks for sharing

[@carmine_rosato]

Thank you for watching!

[@persianson4172]

Super video👍

[@carmine_rosato]

Glad it was helpful!

[@misstinytrader88]

OK, now I'm even more confused because I see stocks do this at resistance and then buyers at support levels. They seem the same to me just different names for areas of buyers and sellers, with the big boys buying at lower prices and selling at higher prices to us retailers. Plus we have to buy programs to show these supply and demand zones. It is all becoming too much to know while trying to be in a trade.

[@dylanstox]

Great video! Very informative

[@carmine_rosato]

:)

[@alil2005]

the document you got there is 'Untitled' meaning, it ain't in the course yet

[@seekingtrades]

Great work. I would like to support your channel. I think you have a course. I will buy it and pay it forward. Great work. I trade off of supply and demand zones as well. It works like magic!

[@fernanmartinez1699]

always excited when you post new videos! keep up the awesome work Carmine! always learning from you!!! God bless

[@carmine_rosato]

Thank you! I appreciate that !! :)

[@jadedx6399]

Thank you brother!

[@carmine_rosato]

Thank you for watching !

[@davidstark_]

Anyone can confirm this? So basically supply and demand zones are zones under/over the support or resistance that the price bounced from. Am I understanding this correctly?

[@BonkersFutures]

Good shit man. Thank you.

[@dominiquemartinelli330]

Awesome video.

[@leemelvin6514]

I disagree with your definitions of S/R. For me S/R are not necessarily exact that price cant break. When mapping S/R you often times move it to get the most touches going left and there will be numerous or even many small breaks of it.

[@chicktrader]

Thanks for the information great videos.

[@alphatrader630]

THANK YOU

[@favourmusonda993]

Thank you so much

[@thinkmirror8507]

It seems perhaps because of your name and mine, I totally understand your video. Thankyou..

[@BenniePChildsIII]

Articulated well! ✊🏾🔥

[@joeb956]

benny I at this point I could not differentiate between s&or and s&D zones confused

[@juke1225]

Made 600.00 on TSLA am using demand zones. Had I just held all day would have been 11k trade! ugh

[@juke1225]

used your training again today, and made $710.00 on ZM, BUT did the same thing and took profits too soon watching my premiums increase to where I would be up thousands more. Carmine, do you have any advice for controlling nerves and being more patient? It seems that is 80% of my problem.

[@wcc4269]

@@juke1225 You probably figured this out by now but it just takes practice to get used to it. It sucks because you might be up 500$ then it eats it all the way back to like 20$ and you exit, but when you finally stick in there and that $500 turns into 5000$, 8000$, ect it will be worth it. One quote I heard somewhere that really stuck with me was "You become a "real" trader when you start to add to winning positions rather then exiting them out of fear."

[@juke1225]

@@wcc4269 thanks, that’s a great perspective.

[@mrincredible7169]

🔥 🔥 🔥

[@ParthPatel-ic4ip]

Wouldn’t they cancel their orders bc they missed their opportunity but I guess they would put their order again when the price hits that zone. That’s what I imagine happens

[@priscillazirombwa8346]

Hie Carmine May you please pin the video for different time frames to trade supply and Demand.

[@Kloutkulture]

You drop fire

[@christianfiguroa7147]

O ok thanks

[@itsdrake1688]

Guys I recommend following his IG, he has great info on there and trade recaps. He also helped me get my account started up this week. He’s an active user and if you have any questions you can DM him. Thanks for everything Carmine!

[@carmine_rosato]

Yes! Thanks a lot man :)

[@marietawalton4164]

First 1 to view this video!!

[@umairafzal6692]

its free

[@neiltroupe716]

I hate these KZbin’s man they use this fast past lingo like there trying to impress someone with there I knowledge. No we are dumb.