Giants Live Chat w/ NYG Weekly

[@Avery2Time]

I really need someone to answer this question. How are people saying Cam Ward wouldn’t be in the same tier as Drake Maye when Cam Ward has better numbers in almost every category playing in the same division that Drake Maye did against a similar level of competition with more wins? How can you legitimately say he’s not in that tier?

[@timdejoseph1595]

Thats a legitimate question id like to see answered.

[@adverseinperpetuity]

Because stats are not the most important part of an evaluation typically

[@Avery2Time]

@ yea it’s usually how you play and the stats match up to the play. By every measurable and the eye test he was better. There’s nothing you can point to that would show Drake Maye was a better QB

[@damiansenises3759]

Mayes biggest issue was his footwork in the pocket. Cam is so much better than him in every aspect. Go CANES and go Giants.

[@gqueue2U]

FINALLY...faces to Ethan and Weiss.... they are great!!!!!

[@rjharrold2907]

"If Dave Gettlemans year three was like his other four years he'd be the best GM in football" is one of my favorite misspoken statements ever

[@realzeno4493]

“Hey John you can’t escape us” 😂😂😂

[@Albert-zk9bz]

Prior to Mara / Tisch we had like 4 Gm and we have already gone through 3. ??

[@Albert-zk9bz]

We need to hire a head of football operations

[@davidriedy5977]

man I swear if they fire Daboll and keep Schoen.. The last 2 times you did that look at how it worked out. Definition of insanity

[@Danny2Zay]

get ready man thats where its headed

[@davidriedy5977]

@@Danny2Zay it's the Giants, so it wouldn't surprise me if they did lmao

[@Danny2Zay]

@@davidriedy5977i’d actually be more surprised if they didn’t do that

[@Danny2Zay]

@davidriedy5977 at this point it would surprise if this DIDN’T happen

[@Albert-zk9bz]

U couldn't franchise DJ and sign SB. I think JS hands where tied with Mara wanting DJ.

[@bartgrovenger1869]

I was 13 when they won their second SB. Since I've been a real fan I've known nothing but disappointment and have watched some of the worst football seen at the NFL level. I really think Eli did some Louisiana voodoo magic and cursed the franchise since Macadoo benched him before he could get his record....

[@Maxbrunell88]

I want cam ward so bad. I’ve been watching tape of sanders and ward. Ward will be the better pro I’d bet my life on it

[@cooldude7821]

I hope you have insurance. Because there's no way Cam is or will be a better pro than Sanders unless 1 ends up on a great team & the other on a $h!++y one.

[@Albert-zk9bz]

If JS has balls he says I stay and BD must stay

[@frankiecrocker]

If you keep both and draft a quarterback, you can't fire them in one year. You're automatically giving them two seasons Otherwise you're forcing a quarterback on a new GM and head coach who might not want him. Bottom line, the Giants are a bad team that does not develop players, why give them until 2027?

[@dontaejones8492]

49:57 yall just spoke to me😭

[@roflcopter117]

Luckily I was 21 when the Giants won SB XLII and 10 in 1996 when the Yankees won the WS. Young NY sports fans have basically only known failure and embarrassment, genuinely feel bad for them. These franchises are setting themselves up for a shrinking fanbase. The Knicks won 50 years ago and the Rangers have decided to turn the ice brown. 🙄

[@mikiec6894]

If the GMEN pick 1St & Oak is 2nd” Do you make the trade with them? More picks still get a QB 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@davidriedy5977]

I might possibly be tempted. If they have both QBs graded equally and Vegas has their sights set on one

[@kts_solboy6216]

No take cam

[@emirkuzbari2352]

Mara should meet with Flores, give him an apology and hire him. Maybe Aaron Glenn is another candidate if he doesn't go to the Jets

[@Thagomizer-U235]

Brian Flores is a POS who is suing the Giants. He is not accepting an apology and dropping the law suit to work for the Giants.

[@andrewmccabe3349]

Why do we have to take a qb, I don't understand it. And how are they in love with Shadeur, when I thought the Giants were averse to that type of off the field sideshow-if we pick him I don't care if he's good, I don't want to root for a douche like that. Take the best player available and go all out when the qb is transcendent. If we pick Shadeur Daboll better have his kneepads ready he will be a fulltime fluffer, and it will be awful to watch.

[@jjj2121]

Agree which is why this regime has to go. If they stay they'll be handcuffed into taking a qb imo.

[@Fastfalcon235]

You know he’s a douche bc you’re bffs with him right? Stop trying to act like you know them personally.

[@andrewmccabe3349]

​@@Fastfalcon235 You're right- I don't know him personally, maybe he's an upstanding guy. But none of us know these guys personally, and as fans, we project and evaluate various components of these prospects including character. Off the info we have, his character is a red flag, and it's valid to question it. Scouts include character in evaluations, and what we are doing as fans is talking about and sharing our amateur "scouting" so it's not out of line for me to comment one way or another on character. Obviously I don't know him-for all I know it's a script and they wrote him in as a douche, shit nothing would surprise me they are getting paid millions in NIL and he gets asses in seats- who knows what's real. I sure as shit don't believe the chiefs win was organic with the Taylor Swift stuff around it. The point is, I don't like the Sanders circus and rather have someone else. I don't think I am the only one who feels this way-seems like a personality that would fit better in a place like Dallas.

[@NYG4LIFE1973]

The hate on Sanders is crazy

[@Fastfalcon235]

Right acting like they know the guy personally to be making assumptions about his character. He could very much change this franchise .

[@NYG4LIFE1973]

@@Fastfalcon235 All people have to do is watch him play and how he reads the field ,the Oklahoma st game he threw to his fourth option plus he has the pedigree ...Is he flashy of course but so was his dad