t.A.T.u. - All The Things She Said (Live Ovion Show, 2022)

[@kathleen007]

Every one expecting them to sing with their 16 y/o voices. They do great and they don't playback.

[@sahinberg]

They suck at singing but at least they are honest.. Edit: Just learn that one of them got throat cancer and lost her voice. I feel bad now.

[@SuperVistaprint]

Rofl so wrong it’s almost adorable…

[@aizalindo7160]

​@@sahinberg who has throat cancer black jacket or white top?

[@sahinberg]

@@aizalindo7160 I am not sure.

[@valyria13]

@@aizalindo7160Yulia. The dark haired girl with the jacket 😊

[@adw6894]

4:15 Yulia looked like she almost cry, but was trying to hold her tear. It's so sad that she had throat cancer and lost her voice, it must be very painful. I hope their friendship will be healing and they both will be happy. Love to t.a.t.u

[@karlinha9893]

Glory to God that she was healed

[@karlinha9893]

Glória a Deus que ela foi curada

[@spyjamila]

​@@NohrazIt's her Body she can do whatever she wants

[@NorwegianNationalist1]

@@spyjamila Yes she can do whatever she wants, but it's still not good

[@aliyusha]

There is no friendship. They had abusive codependent relationship also their genius producer was abusive.. so after all these years Lena hates Yulia. And can’t stand being with her

[@raymondleggs5508]

20 years later and all the things she are still running through my head. ❤❤

[@starxhilmie]

i see what you did there

[@Shinsy-liberty]

yes ! i was sending damn SMS to tv show to vote fore the songs XD

[@RatedJBR]

I listened to this song because of Victoria when she was in WWE.

[@Crok2]

u need to change your head

[@Theweatherlady90]

​@@RatedJBR same

[@spyjamila]

Yulia did so well even tho she had throat cancer! Such a Queen🔥👑

[@Zoltan_Matravolgyi]

Are you serious, she had? Poor Yulia!! :(

[@spyjamila]

@@Zoltan_Matravolgyi yeah she did :( so happy that she recovered

[@bunnygirlmantra]

Poor girl wow

[@kalzangwoeser]

Which one is yulia

[@Zoltan_Matravolgyi]

@@kalzangwoeser the black haired

[@さしみ-r3v]

顔が変わったとか声が変わったとか当たり前のこと言うてる人いるけどこの歌22年前だよ。 22年間、声も顔も変わらずおれたとしたらそれはもう人間では無い。 色々あったと思うけど曲を大切に歌ってくれるのはありがたいし嬉しいことだと思う。 批判的な気持ちになったんなら見なければいい聞かなければいい。 批判する事より人を傷つけない選択肢を選んでほしい。

[@zutu9610]

"曲を大切に歌ってくれる" これにつきますよね。 聴き手側は本人達が歌を大切にしてくれることを第一に感謝すべき。 オクターブ下げた版もこれはこれで良し。

[@kuroteki]

人間ではない、は酷い！

[@miyamakalasu1]

深みが出て、よくなってる。 昔の声の音源にあわせるより ずっと好きです！！ ジュリア　ユリア　😊

[@vamm7377]

Muchas personas deberían pensar como tú.

[@잠시리]

캬 추억의 곡이네...tatu 분들 아직도 활동하는 것에 놀핬지만 전성기 때 같은 라이브에 더 놀라고 갑니다.

[@NorthernChev]

Yes, I agree. It was performed as if it were still twenty years ago.

[@zarathekittygamer5717]

never get bored with this song

[@god563616]

DAMN! I have not seen or heard tatu in a million years!!!! They Look great!!!

[@devilmaycry9969]

Aww my childhood. Two girls who transformed into two grown women. Much love and happy Yulia beat cancer!

[@leonlima1]

I love this Dangerous and Moving Intro! 😭 Their voices were beautifully worked, complementing each other. This was the best we can get of their 2000s essence.

[@bekahe4433]

Couldn't even hear them. They aren't famous for their voices...they're cute though😊

[@meilele3929]

これは2022年の映像なんですね？t.A.T.u.の二人が再び一緒にステージで歌っているなんて、日本では全く報じられていないから衝撃です。

[@gurcancan4139]

There is BELARUS

[@bakerstreet101]

Their adult voices are quite nice.

[@shikitashan]

Qué alegría verlas nuevamente juntas, después de tantas situaciones que pasaron durante todos estos años. Felicidades por tomar nuevamente este gran reto de estar en la música!

[@jackdriver9227]

What happened to them?

[@clover6236]

Pero ya no están en rusia ¿no?

[@zelenograd-c4j]

​@@clover6236si estan pero donde cantan en el video es minsk bielorrusia ellas como todos los artistas siempre estan moviendose y no se quedan en solo un lugar pero actualmente ellas viven en Rusia

[@indrathemaggot]

At least they didnt do lip-sync. Awesome to see them back on stage

[@MJW238]

That’s a nice way to say they sung poorly.

[@ahmedayaat2727]

​@MJW238 how do you expect Julia to sing w her old voice? But yes she did better in 2012.

[@bethhale6609]

They look so good

[@kong-i7d]

El tiempo no pasa sobre ellas siguen siendo hermosas

[@rileycoyote8275]

Even more beautiful than they were

[@tommisanz]

Saludos a Perú

[@Tarik-kb4ih]

Certos grupos, bandas, projetos quando caem nas graças da mídia não precisam de mais nada! Nem mesmo - MAIS -, de voz! Anos depois o TATU faz isso! 🤦🏻‍♂️ Impressionante!

[@julianne7397]

decades later and they still look awesome...

[@gudanggaram0475]

20 years later ... She's a legend !!!

[@K-POPlife-z5u]

They sound soooo good together , their voices sound heavenly

[@sahinberg]

Dude, are you sure what the word "heavenly" means?

[@forestings]

​​@@sahinbergyes they weren't like before but some people enjoy the contrast between their voices now. high and deep. what's wrong with people finding this good? not everyone is the same as you :)

[@Roman.M123]

I mean.. yeah they sing half live… and a bit playback. But with strong voices or heavenly has this nothing to do😂 sorry but i mean they have after 20y problems with the text. Its nice to see. Its a good memory. But thats all. For me! Just my opinion

[@laquica4608]

how LENA's beauty never fade.... she even more gorgeous!

[@MyintMoMyintmyat]

I agree with you 💯 But I also think Yulia is so beautiful 😍

[@MaksimPavlovich1977]

Юля , как жаль...Но все помнят твой Крик Души , обрамлённый в музыку... Спасибо за голос , потраченный на наши мурашки ✨

[@Sid-Rostovskiy]

Живем🙌🙌🙌Юля красотка... Сто лет назад в Токио цветы подарил ей.

[@mjzkul]

Respect for live singing ❤

[@ОлесяФедунова-ш3й]

Live: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZepqqycg6ebf5Isi=35cvg80qmQHKoxOK

[@wiratjajadi]

Was and Still the best female duet ever...Love you t.A.T.u. ♥

[@Crok2]

best fake lesbians duet ever

[@Ms.Delphine1204]

Yeah right!

[@SilverKATrin]

Спасибо вам девчонки, что поете живьем, что существуете и дарите нам такие эмоции и песни!

[@the_one_and_only_mr_arkham]

Они вообще петь не могут Жесть

[@GoodTyber]

​@@the_one_and_only_mr_arkham оффнись хйло

[@Panos_1821]

Good to see them back together. Wish cancer wouldn't ruin her vocals. What a great performance. Iconic duo

[@sahinberg]

Ah one of them got cancer?

[@shangchi2360]

@@sahinberg the brunette

[@rosaalmiron5929]

Dos genias, hermosas y talentosas. Feliz de volver a verlas cantar juntas. Lena y Yulia dos grosas. Las mejores.

[@denitomanson]

Cantaron pero pujando sin aire 😂

[@tonchititito]

Se les termino el dinero o que onda? porque ya no se podian ver ni en pintura

[@belenmexzaldivar6204]

​@@tonchititito lo mismo me pregunto

[@hugoricardoflores2496]

@@denitomanson a lo mejor no sabias pero Julia había perdido la voz casi por completo, con Lena ahí si la verdad no se que paso🤣

[@elpablo1992]

​@@tonchitititoони в то время заработали около 20 миллионов долларов, небыло выступлений из за проблем со здоровьем, несколько раз рак лечили

[@Ronin86killr]

First time hearing this song in 2002 I fell in love with it and hearing it again 12/24/2023 I still love it. ❤❤❤

[@MrSlippery65]

Great Performance, always loved this track!

[@alexskrebecs8073]

Голоса уже не те, но они с нами всегда как в первый день. Респект что не прячат голоса за фанерой. Они супер

[@nadezhdasokolova750]

Вы серьёзно? Тут 90% - это фанера. Они лишь немного пытаются петь в куплете, но припевы полностью фанера.

[@baltazar8763]

@@nadezhdasokolova750 как проф музыкант соглашусь, там дабл идет фанера в основном бекингтреки и там где они лажают это лайф))))

[@erkanalles7026]

Frauen kommen auch in den Stimmbruch....war bei den beiden vll etwas später...aber vor 20 Jahren war die beiden auch sehr jung

[@DJerreO]

The voices are no longer the same, because Julia Volkova fell ill with thyroid cancer in 2012, and unfortunately lost her voice in a medical error after undergoing surgery, Volkova did not speak, and went to a hospital in South Korea to have her voice restored, she was told that she was never going to sing again, if Julia Volkova had come here to be treated in the USA 🇺🇸, Julia Volkova I would continue to sing normally, greetings from Houston 👍😎🇺🇸

[@curce1]

Тут одна фанера почти

[@Ceiteach.O.Duibhir]

Shocked to seeing them playing in Minsk given the type of leader Belarus has

[@leandroduarte.88]

Yeah, this song is timeless

[@BlaCKFRozeN1]

Wow, this Song with their well aged Voices sound even better. after i checked some comments saying that one of the two beautys "lost" her Voice to cancer.. i mean, i cant believe that she lost anything :D btw stil a banger in 04.2024

[@KangSahiye_2999]

Aww verlas juntas me llena de alegría después de tanto tiempo de sus pausas las volvemos en los escenarios aun muy poco pero su presencia es super espero que regresen aun que sea por todo los años pero se que es imposible, las amamos mucho brillen siempre ^^

[@edudead7047]

Regresan por el dinero eso siempre pasa jaja pero si es nostalgia verlas juntas. Una lastima que terminaron mal.

[@KangSahiye_2999]

@@edudead7047 Si es verdad aun su carrera no fue como lo pensabamos pero hay que seguir apoyando aun que ya no sean como antes y volver a revivir esos momentos

[@q-vep9988]

​@@edudead7047de acuerdo, el dinero decide mucho, pero no debemos olvidar que cantan desde la infancia, literalmente, la música se ha convertido en su vida. Por ejemplo, Julia, incluso después de un cáncer de garganta y una operación fallida en él, todavía trató de cantar, aunque todos le dijeron que era imposible y estúpido. Pero ahora no suena perfecto, pero mucho mejor. Y, si recuerdas a su productor pedófilo, que jugó con Julia, de 14 años, primero rompiéndola, luego destruyendo las relaciones en el grupo, me alegro de que en los últimos años las chicas estén cada vez más en contacto entre sí. Согласна деньги много решают, но нельзя забывать, что они с детства поют, буквально музыка стала их жизнью. Например Юля даже после рака горла и неудачной операции на него, всё равно пыталась петь, хотя ей все говорили, что это невозможно и глупо. Но сейчас она звучит не идеально, но гораздо лучше. А, если ещё вспомнить их продюсера-педофила, который игрался с 14 летней Юлей сломав сначала её, потом разрушив отношения в группе, то я рада, что в последние годы девчонки всё чаще контактируют друг с другом.

[@theworldneedswinners91]

Gosh, they look fantastic!

[@BermanLinarez]

Me emociona mucho verla nuevamente tengo 38 anos y cuando era adolescente las escuchaba a cada rato siguen siendo muy bonitas

[@imjustwolf]

Its great to see those two back together doing music again. I thought it would never happen! Their voices have also matured beautifully!

[@brockhedge2750]

These two girls will perform "All the things that she said" together. Unfortunately they are not friends in their real life...

[@dusty616l]

goosebumps every time i watch this

[@laudcedec]

Brings me back emotions and so deep memories;

[@C4ami]

A Lena é uma maravilhosa, voz linda.

[@jorgesimoes9797]

beatiful ladies

[@KrisNolanFix]

My gosh their beauty is unreal. 😮

[@aliyusha]

Блин они выходят на сцену, держась за руки.. у меня аж слезы текут… started crying when saw them walking on stage holding hands

[@john01777]

This song never gets old

[@ForLorNVuLgaR]

omfg i finlly found why buying your album and me loving red heads have finally consided!

[@Helga_By]

Сколько лет прошло) я до сих пор помню весь первый альбом наизусть 😅

[@luxoflux5064]

So many years and I still can say they are one of my proudest ones!

[@ivylovestatuanna8684]

When they hug I was like omg they hug each other 😁😍😭 I was crying in the whole performance lol

[@dildoshwaggins3236]

They hate each other lol

[@gicervantes2738]

Son unas Reinas, me emocione mucho al verlas juntas con ese brillo en los ojos, Julia cada vez se le escucha mejor me emociona 💕

[@eduardoalcantara4509]

даже после некоторых указаний, которые Юля сказала в интервью, я горжусь тем, что она выходит на сцену и поет тем голосом, который, кажется, даже становится лучше.Делала ли она что-нибудь, чтобы улучшить свой голос?

[@nis_a5235]

Операции у неё были, последняя была в Корее

[@ДаниилСергеевич-й7т]

Она несколько лет жила без голоса из-за болезни, голос до конца восстановить не возможно, но так тоже очень круто поет

[@theemilnovruz8127]

В последнем живом исполнении оба голоса уже не те, что раньше, очень жаль Юлю

[@SilverKATrin]

@@theemilnovruz8127 а ваш голос тот что в подростковом возрасте?

[@mariafraulein6292]

@@SilverKATrin ну так @theemilnovruz8127 и не вокалист(ка).

[@Respect_356PZK]

SO MUCH TIME HAS PASSED UNTIL THE VOICE CHANGED HIM, THEY ARE LEGENDS

[@Mayra_o96]

Yulia went through cancer

[@jrambo7495]

Him? No sweetheart, those are girls, which would be her.

[@yoannbirrien3048]

1 of the gril have cancer in the past soo she lose some voice

[@lomarsweed6604]

@@jrambo7495 Maybe they identify as a bearded mountain man, don't judge.

[@Manderz89]

@@lomarsweed6604 that person wasn’t judging he/she was just saying that Lena and Julia are girls not boys

[@bangbang2566]

Лучшие 👍👍👍👍 столько лет прошло, а музыка звучит на века вперёд! Девченки побывали в будующем в прошлом и всегда останутся в настоящем !!

[@olgasokolova-hf2ny]

Юлечке зачёт ,за вокал даже с больным голосом ❤❤❤❤ искусство

[@МирамбекШаканов-ю6л]

Красавицы пели вживую !!!🙏🙏👍👍👍👍

[@MrDiomaK]

шептали... пения как-то не наблюдалось...

[@yulekmotilek7991]

​@@MrDiomaKу одной был рак горла

[@larissalivramento4992]

Caramba, esse arranjo da intro ficou perfeito!

[@mohamnadkhalifeh7314]

omg they're back i can't believe 🥰😍

[@angel.of.creation.orifiel]

今の時代に聞いても格好良い曲❤

[@evickaklierova3107]

Respect to Julia for beating the hell out of throat cancer and still singing. A true maladiec

[@_FearNoEvil]

Wow, I was expecting it to be lip synched , but I’m glad they did it live.

[@EuEu-re8lv]

This is real RUSSIA!!!1Stop bloody war, make music!!!! Loved them!

[@68404]

Better talk to the USA about that matter. They started it..

[@inoxide5454]

So tell me how USA started it? ​ @68404 Did USA invade Ukraine? I don't think so. Did USA bomb ukranian kids schools and hospitals? i don't think so.

[@DesertRainReads]

Damn, killer performance from both of them. Glad they're back. The backing band is also excellent too.

[@riverpenzo885]

Wow, the best. It's perfect and the meaning is even more beautiful now Thank you 💛😃

[@marcus813]

Hearing this brings me back to the last couple of years I was in college/university. I don't mind this banger running through my head!

[@andreabetgut]

vuelven a tener conexión. Esperé tanto este momento! ✨✨✨✨💫 Las amo...

[@НиколайСушко-с2и]

Если они приедут ещё в Минск,то точно не пропущу их концерт.Очень хочу увидеть наших легенд вживую ❤❤❤Обожаю t.A.T.u.😊❤ Мне 41 и мы взрослели под их песни на дискотеках!Незабываемое,счастливое время 90-х и 2000-х!! Я НЕ ХОЧУ УМИРАТЬ,НЕ УВИДИВШИСЬ С ЮЛЕЙ И ЛЕНОЙ,И НЕ ОБНЯВШИСЬ С НИМИ, НЕ СКАЗАВ,КАК Я ИХ СИЛЬНО ЛЮБЛЮ И УВАЖАЮ ЗА ТО,ЧТО ОНИ СДЕЛАЛИ СВОИМ ТВОРЧЕСТВОМ ДЛЯ ВСЕХ НАС!!! НАДО КАК-ТО ЭТО СДЕЛАТЬ!!!)))

[@connorclandfield8462]

There's a slight difference to when they performed in say 2002-2003 but I think that's just because they were younger so they maybe had more energy and could mess around more

[@taylormcgarry470]

Yea That and I guess it depends on how much they really wanted to be there together to do it.. how much into it they really are

[@anthonydeadman]

There was also the fact that one of them I believe had survived throat cancer so has far as singing is concerned, one of them can't put in as much energy as well as they used to.

[@raymondleggs5508]

Lol they"re not old

[@森下-d8g]

ユリアが声を酷使してしまったことを知っているからなのか、レナの高音パートのサポートが素晴らしい✨ t.A.T.u.は永遠に私のスター🌟

[@RossColdBloodedCreatures]

I miss them so much 😢

[@sarasanchez4861]

Por favor alguien que hable del guitarrista dándola toda!!!!!!! 🎉🎉🎉

[@kyanavt3395]

Finally together as band again, only bcs they are older, their voices are changed.. but well done ladie's 🙏💪🤘❤️

[@bin7405]

All the things that t.A.T.u sang are always running through my head. 😍

[@Max_Malinki]

No auto tune i love it

[@Sc9cvsd]

I dunno. All their old live versions are lip sinked and I'm not sure I like this better

[@aliyusha]

Yulia lost her beautiful strong voice because of cancer and unfortunate surgery. Also when she joined the group their producer made her sing with screaming voice. Her mom said that this would lead to her losing her voice (their is a video footage of her being a kid , when her says that to producer…) so cancer and producer ruined her voice and mental health

[@nadezhdasokolova750]

​@@aliyushashe has no voice. Another girl was singing instead of Yulia. Their old "live" perfomances were lip sinked because of that. TATU was the project. Two girls who can pretend that they are lesbians and do everything their producer said. Lena was singing, Yulia - not.

[@ahmedayaat2727]

​@@Sc9cvsd no 2012 wasnt lip synced.

[@ahmedayaat2727]

​@@nadezhdasokolova750 not 2012. She sang beautifully w the whisper back then here really wasn't it

[@NeverlandSystemZor]

They actually look HAPPY performing now... unlike back then. I hope this is a good thing for them

[@helgalithium2262]

Целая эпоха!!! Лучшая эпоха 2000-х!!!!

[@子ライオンのネットNEWS]

「Congratulations on 100,000 subscribers!」from Japan

[@terryschott3881]

Still after all these years, they're still my crushes

[@Starpinklittle]

*LUNCHING WHILE LISTENING THESE NOSTALIC MASTERPIECE! I don't even care if they're lesbians or not, because this song IS A GREAT BOP 🤩!*

[@DomceGT]

They aren't

[@jabronisauce6833]

Who asked if you cared and they aren’t lesbians lmfao

[@KingLeonidas_300]

they look and sound different. glad theyre still together. great song

[@finditandfixit2081]

what you expect people don't age? lol They stay a teen forever lol

[@diegomoreno4422]

Hicieron y siguen haciendo historia chicas!!!! Me alegra mucho!!!

[@terecee1204]

Always loved this song. So controversial when it came out.

[@gerardo996]

❤️ Exelente dueto tuve la oportunidad de verlas en el domo de cobre de la Ciudad de México y aunque alguno gente se quedó con la idea de mayores efectos visuales Su personalidad, su carisma y belleza valía mucho más de lo que pague por verlas en Vivo. TaTu Always on My Mind ❤️

[@TheAndym4n]

Yep, 20 years and i still love them.

[@takutakufd]

音楽番組出演のため、来日したのに、その番組出演を直前でドタキャンしたの忘れません笑　当時、彼女たちは若すぎたんでしょうね😊　大人になった彼女たちのライブを生で観てみたいです。

[@hildahilda7718]

Lo más hermoso verlas a las dos juntas cantando son lo máximo las dos ❤❤

[@danidicks]

haciendo Playback dirás...

[@kathleen007]

​@@danidicksqué ignorancia la suya.

[@X-STATIC-k9b]

Been a fan since this first came out i was just wondering why id hardly seen them lately read their whole story and everything theyve both been through this is beautiful and incredible to see ❤️❤️❤️

[@AndyZaturno]

Such rock stars. What they did with "All The Things She Said" 20 years ago changed music forever and opened the door for LGTB representation elsewhere.

[@ollegoop9]

in russia of all places. makes what lady gaga did look like nothiung if u compare them

[@ThinkCriticallyNow]

Lol, they were never even a couple, it was just a publicity stunt.

[@kemmpesa]

LOL....

[@tico8182]

Pink money apenas

[@samirSch]

And to think it was just a cheap shock marketing tactics...lol. G4y for pay.

[@faviourquiola5626]

Lena es mucha diosa griega, que hermosa!!!

[@johannetje1980]

i love tatu so freaking much

[@bunnygirlmantra]

Decades later they're even prettier than before

[@dreimioz]

Обичам тази песен като българка

[@МихаилБлинцов]

Это невероятно клёво бесподобно, потресающие зрелище, лучшие из лучших

[@yulekmotilek7991]

А изначально на русском в припеве совсем другой смысл... "Я сошла с ума, я сошла с ума, мне нужна она, мне нужна она, мне нужна она. " "I need her"

[@Труднопроизносимоеимя]

Усталость забыта, колышется чад, и снова копыта как сердце стучат...

[@rixsist7048]

2:00 damn both that guitarist and camera person were living their best lives

[@hajeribenkraiem4028]

VERY TOUCHING CONCERT ABSOLUTLY ❤❤❤❤❤ FULL RESPECT AND SPECIAL THANKS FROM TUNISIA ❤❤❤❤

[@Jadian-i3n]

Thank you

[@Variaznel1]

I can guarantee you that they were in different dressing rooms. I wish that hug was genuine, but it wasn't. 💔💔💔

[@noecases5940]

Pruebas?

[@gleefan3456]

What happened ?

[@tylerkochman1007]

@@gleefan3456 ​ in 2014 Yulia threatened Lena that she would ruin her if Lena refused to do a full reunion and to give Yulia full control over it. Yulia’s been a hollow awful person in the last decade

[@larrychu6396]

I was gonna say don't they hate each other ..

[@Bulletno]

JUST KISS ALREADY!

[@highlander4731]

Absolutely amazing love Tatu

[@izas.4600]

É triste demais ouvir a voz da Yulia assim, mas serão sempre as melhores ❤

[@weirdro]

Pois é, ainda assim foi bem nostalgico.