TDAS: What if Duncan never blew up Chris' mansion?

What if in season 5 of Total Drama, Duncan never abandoned the challenge to blow up Chris' mansion?
Tier list: tiermaker.com/create/total-dr...

[@applebee28]

okay idea idea: what if Ezekiel was actually brought back in all stars, it wasnt just a fakeout. Let's say he's still mutated and green and doesn't speak, but like he's still conscious and can function on a similar level to a human. so he's capable of being an actual contestant.

[@TAGG8]

Good idea

[@jadetheartist873]

Better yet, he can slowly recover as the series goes on, and by the end, he can get cured.

[@user-nk4wy1bc5z]

First boot

[@CheezyGuest]

@@user-nk4wy1bc5zprobably yeah

[@latiasswings]

@@jadetheartist873worse yet*

[@SuperMarioT]

I don't know if this would save All Stars, but it definitely would make it much better, especially in the latter half. The idea of Courtney & Scott's relationship going further but diving harder into Courtney's perfectionism and potentially giving her that angle of character growth would be very satisfying for her character since it was always the forefront for her personality and why her relationships fumble as well.

[@cindy8966]

It's kinda cute how the ending with Scott mirrors Duncan's ending in TDA with Courtney's reaction, except this time Court has grown and the relationship might work out this time around

[@blorg845]

That’s how the season should’ve been. U should been a writer for this season 😂

[@serenepastel]

I like the way that you portray the Scott and Courtney relationship in this. It was a cool way to take the direction of the story If I can offer an idea: What if Mal was also active during ROTI along with Mike’s other sides?

[@blackbear7966]

Or the other way round: what if mal never showed in all stars or what if Mike never got hit with Scott’s shovel

[@massimozilla]

I am a simple man; I see Mal getting eliminated early, I smile

[@FandomJay]

Real

[@pankakequeen6080]

Love this What If! I think this may be one of my favourite ones you’ve done! Absolutely love the Fang and Scott friendship, it was so sweet! Makes me wish it happened in canon, haha I also love how you focused more on Scottney instead of dragging the Mal plot line out like in canon. It was also interesting to have that mini cliffhanger with Mal in Sundae Muddy Sundae! Overall I really enjoyed this What If! I’m not sure if you’re take requests, but if you are, I have an idea! “What if Duncan never returned in World Tour?” Or even, “What if Duncan never quit in World Tour?” Could be interesting to explore!

[@andrewfelix8586]

Nice my boy Duncan got a little more far! New idea: What if Sadie and Katie were in Ridonculous Race Or What if Ella didn’t sang to save Dave (I think it was)

[@manlystarman68]

I have an idea that might be good: What if Izzy never never swapped places with Katie, leaving Izzy on the KIller Bass and Katie on the Screaming Gophers?

[@bOo0ony]

Yay Duncan redemption!

[@TotalDramaEthan]

I don’t know if it was because of my comment, but I’m so happy you had Chris tie down the balloons like I recommended, I was so happy when I heard you say that! Also, this what if was pretty good! It was rather predictable at times, but I still loved it, and I think a Courtney vs Scott finale worked really well! Also I loved how Fang and Scott made up

[@pokechar6440]

You should do all stars but what if Scott never hit Mike on the head which means no Mal which would change the story a lot

[@HasanDaader]

Also it would make the season good

[@tysonbot0914]

He would win just like in the original all stars

[@justarandomperson976]

@@tysonbot0914 Tbh I see him maybe getting eliminated a few eps before that

[@osen9881]

​@@tysonbot0914 Doubt it

[@lapinajustleft]

How to fix All Stars:

[@stephenxue5607]

This os genuinely one of the best what ifs so far. Theres so many logical stuff and it so entertaining. One of the best things in this is that Zoey and Mike are out earlier so we dont get a bunch of Mal and Dumb Zoey. The other stuff like no Duncan derailment, Courtney redemption, healthy gwuncan friendship and scott+fang friendship is amazing s tier as well. IM LOVING IT 😍

[@heed-shot4971]

I gotta say, This was very interessting to listen to. The "What if" is highly explored and it is very well written. Good Job !

[@lysanderlonshadow8653]

Ugh this was so good! Much better than what we actually got.

[@KG7Plaz]

I love this even just for more Duncan and Alejandro interaction, idk seeing those two compete against each other and being "bros" wink wink was always fun in World Tour.

[@julianmarco4185]

I really like that and I am actually happy with that ending. It feels like a great ending though. I really liked that Courtney would finally get some kind of redemption or at least a good ending.

[@eriklin9541]

Bringing back the Gwen and Duncan friendship ( and NOT the Gwuncan ship) was fun. I think Gwen and Duncan’s friendship was something I missed after all stars. The original wasted all of the Duncan/Courtney/Gwen relationships. All of them hate each other now. Which suck but in your what if we got Duncan and Gwen back! Which was great

[@eriklin9541]

@GWBush865 I don’t hate the ship, what I do hate is the way they broke up in all stars. After that, they shouldn’t get back together but they can still maybe be friends

[@eriklin9541]

@GWBush865 I prefer definetly Gwuncan to Duncney because Duncney was pretty toxic. Although I don’t think it was a pause when Duncan and Gwen separated. Gwen was really upset that Duncan kept wanting Courtney’s attention (even though Gwen fucking ignored him in episode 2 😒) but I prefer Duncan and Gwen’s and Gwen and Courtney’s friendships most. If they were just friends after all stars I would be much more happy.

[@eriklin9541]

@GWBush865 agreed

[@MickeyMouseTotallyReal]

Idea for a what if (love your channel btw) in world tour Ezekiel is the last person to reach the end of the team deciding challenge and he goes on team victory even tought he was supossed to be in team amazon, that would also mean Sierra would'nt switch because Cody would be in Cris is really really really really hot and Alejandro be in team victory, I know you would'nt do this second part but this would be another what if Cris assigned the teams correctly, but with world tour, so it would be cool (but again not probable) that you would making the all-stars of the what if about the correct teams considering this.

[@not_saige12]

The All-Stars we deserved

[@sevenoxia7199]

Wow! This was a great video! The development for Scott was my favourite part. While I'm not a fan of this season, you actually made it decently interesting, though I do prefer some of your other What If's because they're in a better season or change a bad season so much that it is nice to listen through. I have an idea that I think would be kind of cool because you don't have many World Tour What If's (just the one I think): "What If Bridgette never got stuck to the pole?" or you could tweak it to be "What if Anything Yukon Do, I Can Do Better was a reward challenge?" I think the latter would be a little more interesting since Bridgette would have to try and convince others that Alejandro is bad while they don't believe her. This also means that Broadway, Baby! would have to be an elimination challenge. Might be a nice idea to explore!

[@oledz_yt9503]

I’ve actually been waiting for this What if For awhile, Love it!

[@iloveyoufujisaki]

i'm so glad to see another video from you 😁

[@therealdogtroid]

why are you so good at these oh my gosh

[@latanyapowers406]

you might be my favorite total drama youtuber tbh, you a great writer, you almost never miss!

[@Landon_huh]

Yes finally I have been waiting so long for this video

[@IdkC0ffee]

As much as I am a Duncney fan I do like that it was a much happier ending

[@Nonya._.]

I wondered if you’d do this what if or not, nice to see you post though 👍

[@averyseldin8485]

Interesting idea and I loved the idea of Duncan and Gwen at the very least becoming friends again. And as for a possible one-what if MK never released the video of Julia's rant at the dinosaur?

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

This was uploaded at midnight for me so can’t watch rn, but I’m sure it’ll be great!

[@antjmashups9220]

Total drama: what is Gwen and Duncan never kissed in world tour?

[@healerseal]

I have a idea for a video: What if Brick followed his code? This may be confusing but in roti episode 4 “Finders Creepers” Brick’s team lost the challenge as he listened to Jo to just go for the finish line instead of helping out his teammates making him not follow his code which makes his team lose as the team with the most teammates not caught in the web and making it into the finish line wins but since Brick didn’t help them they lose, this makes him quit but instead he gets sent to the other team but what if Brick actually followed his code and got all his teammates and won the challenge?

[@czerwonystudio6301]

You haven't shown my fan art of superhero costumes to what if Alejandro and Sierra were in action

[@juancruzdiazbravo7338]

After complete and complex seasons it is good to return to a calmer what if I can't say I like it, but it's because of the season, the truth is it's very difficult to work with that.

[@josephburkhart6602]

Finally, my boy Scott gets a W.

[@luigi4life913]

What if Ella wasn't eliminated for singing?

[@the_zen_one]

Let's go! Another post! I thought of a potential idea you could do: "What If Heather Never Read Gwen's Diary" Thank you for being an inspiration to me for why I started posting Total Drama content myself. I actually have a video idea that I'm going to be doing and it's inspired by this very series! Thank you for everything that you do and keep up the great work! 🔥

[@LavenderMinnon]

Love all your Videos

[@ImXQR]

Idea: what if Owen never got hit with the book in action?

[@Jacktheboss932]

Loved fang and scott friendship

[@worstspytf2824]

Huh, I actually kind of like Fang and Scott as characters, something I didn't know I wanted, great video.

[@1NS1GN1USPH]

NOW THIS IS A W!! {TOPIC IDEA: What if: Lindsay is the villain of island?} {Now, Ik what y'all are thinking, Lindsay?! Yes, I'm basing this from the original Camp TV idea of Lindsay being the "villain" before it changed} Fr Fr tho, a new topic idea {unless y'all want that lol} - What if you can swap the original island cast with the Combined ROTI and PI cast? {I.E. Gen 2 and 3 plays Island - World tour, Gen 1 plays ROTI and PI.}

[@jelmervanriet790]

What if Harold rigged the votes to vote out Duncan instead of courtney? That makes way more sense in the first place

[@charteon9092]

Already happened in the Alejandro and Sierra video

[@havikrogers1801]

​@@charteon9092It could happen for a stand alone What-If, since Courtney didn't make it far in that What-If.

[@kharihammon9784]

Then Harold still goes 13th for being the outsider, Eva’s 12th & Trent’s 11th. The guys alliance thing never happens as it’s a 7 girls (Courtney, Heather, Leshawna, Gwen, Lindsay, Izzy & Bridgette) vs 3 boys (Geoff, Dj & Owen) However, I could see the guys teaming up without Duncan as Owen, Dj & Geoff all got along anyways. I’d say they still vote together against Courtney after Heather & Leshawna are safe. Heather lobbies for Owen to go & Lindsay follows her. Bridgette wouldn’t want to vote either Dj or Geoff & votes Owen. Gwen, Leshawna & Courtney will probably vote Geoff & Izzy is the swing vote. She wouldn’t want Owen out so Courtney’s 10th. Lindsay’s 9th & Dj’s 8th. I personally think in the original canon version that Izzy went out in a plurality & Gwen/Leshawna still voted for Heather. I could see the Ozzy couple voting Gwen (I think they did in canon), Leshawna/Gwen votes Heather. Heather voted for Izzy after she shot her, Bridgette probably wonders in the woods, also gets shot by Izzy & Geoff votes Izzy alongside Bridgette. Izzy’s 7th. Everyone hates Heather & she goes out at 6th. Leshawna’s 5th. Bridgette/Gwen vs Geoff/Owen. I’d say with Owen still in the game, he loses it for the guys & Chef eliminates him for eating his dessert. Owen’s 4th. Without Heather, nobody here has any incentive to lobby dares against anyone. I’d favor Gwen & Geoff to win a challenge like this & Bridgette’s 3rd. Gwen & Geoff F2.

[@Cryptic3000]

Courtney not being able to the the ice-cream is such a big plothole after WT

[@scorpio1193]

Ok I have a suggestion for a video. What if heather embraced her nerdy side? We've seen throughout the show that heather enjoys nerdy stuff, like Harold's nun-yo's and has teamed up with harold on separate occasions. In world tour she also teamed up (although it wasn't a genuine one) cody and seiera in world tour. In your previous re-write of alejandro and seiera being in island, you had heather and cody be in an actual alliance. In this suggestion it would take place in world tour. But heather from the jump would embrace her nerdy side, especially coming off from action. So her and cody would bond over it and develop a genuine friendship/alliance. Heather could also genuinely befriend seiera over glitter pens and nerdy stuff. Heathers dynamic with those two were my favorite. And the re-write you did with heather and cody was amazing! It's something I'm surprised the show never explored upon. In this re-write, it doesn't mean she becomes stupid. She'll still be smart and do villainous moves. But she'll also make genuine friendships! Hope you'll do it, you're the only guy who seems like they know what they're doing

[@skylandprodigy]

I got a What If idea, "What if Harold never rigged the votes?"

[@CrushAugust]

Loved the final 4 in this version

[@BlackSheep_777]

Idea for a world tour what if: What if team victory disbanded before Lindsay and DJ were eliminated?

[@bentleybutidk]

YOOOOO NEW UPLOAD LET GOOOOOO!

[@tanjastjepanovic3696]

Whenever TD Wonderer uploads is a good day

[@zekeathon]

hell yea! another td wonderer video!

[@sylveonmaster1205]

ANOTHER POSTTTT!! LETS GOO

[@throwaway7683]

I can't wait!!!! I'm watching now

[@mihaitavraciu2248]

Yooooo what? A What If this early after the other one??? Let's goooooo!

[@Gwen1661]

Any rewrites/what ifs that change this dumbass plotline makes my heart sore and you didn't disappoint with your version

[@subjectdelta7210]

he didn’t. he destroyed a cottage

[@clariey204]

A cottage? It's was mansion - courtney

[@RashyTheGOAT]

Challenge idea:(This will probably take a really long time so i understand if u dont wanna do it) What if there was a mega all stars season after the reboot season you can either do a poll or decide yourself who gets the to be in the season and have 6 to 11 ppl from each season Please make this top comment

[@jeremycel3032]

Good video, not my favorite but that's only because I don't like Duncan that much in general and AS is my least favorite season. I'm going to give some of my favorite what if ideas. What if Dawn had the real immunity idol? I feel like this could also be called what if Dawn found the immunity idol first but I think you get the idea. I think it could be interesting to see Dawn try to earn the trust of her teammates back. And someone else taking Scott's place would be interesting. What if Ella wasn't disqualified for singing? Something simple, but I think it can change several things. What if Katie and Izzy never swap teams? I would like to see this one in the future since I understand that we have had enough of Island. What if Sierra had not exploded the plane? Aka if he had waited for everyone to get on the plane after the elimination so everyone could celebrate. I think it made sense because of what Alejandro did in that episode, it may be too short but it could be interesting. What if the World Tour teams were like the ROTI teams? This is what I mean that when passing the finish line, every three participants go to different teams. This one is too difficult because the series is almost a reinvention of the entire season, so I don't expect you to do it but I still like to give the idea. Well that's all, some of these options are kind of meh but I think you could do something interesting with them, if you choose them.

[@pies306]

I have an idea: What if Sam didn’t cheat in the Pancake challenge when he saved some in his pockets in All Stars.

[@mysterious_559]

It would make All Stars slightly better

[@rzsdranb3789]

That was great

[@renatotapia845]

What if Scott didn't sabotage his team in ROTI? What if Alejandro was on team Victory? What if All Stars had a different cast?

[@joeyobzut1448]

Again, another "What If" scenario that's better than what actually happened Also, 2 video ideas: "What if Courtney joined season 2 from the beginning?" and "What if the All Stars teams was divided into OGs vs ROTIs?"

[@kyu12345]

This is my all-stars

[@emeraldicigool]

I feel like this makes all stars way better

[@shinnyboppers9802]

these honestly seem like solid endings for at least the gen 1 cast

[@denisesacco3894]

you've basically fixed all-stars

[@JakesoontobeJack]

Zoey and Mike eliminated? Courtney and Gwen are All-Stars? No one floats uo to space? I love it! New idea: What if Amy realized what she did was wrong ti Sammy in episode 3? Wha if Sierra just formed a crush on Cody, but not in a stalker way? What if Sierra never blew up the plane? What if befire Chris announced Lindsay as loser in That's Off the Hook, Izzy appears and Leshawna falls off and Izzy crosses with her bike? What if Lindsay never forgot Tyler? What if DJ never got the curse? What if Cody saved Bridgette from elimination fir not singing backup? What if Nichelle's skills was actually real, as in she never got a stuntman named Jerry? What if Emma didn't forgive Chase ine episode 7?What if Chris took the jackhammer away from Lauren (Scary Girl) on episode 4? Wha if Chase never cut Emma's brakes?

[@The_Prime_Bois]

What if Tyler actually got over his fear of chickens in TDI

[@XHeyall]

Suggestion: what if izzy was never medically evacuated in world tour

[@LovesVelvette_Cakes128]

What if Trent and Gwen were on the same team in TDA? Im curious cause it would mean that trent or gwen would throw the game.

[@hunter3711]

I like this

[@Superben21]

Idea: What if trent, geoff, justin, beth, katie, sadie and eva were in world tour season? Another idea: What if ezekiel wasn't stay on the plane and wasn't become a feral at world tour season?

[@havikrogers1801]

We can’t forget about Mama DJ, since he was part of the group with Geoff.

[@user-er1ig8qo5c]

How about what if cody didn't get mauled by a digo?(Episode 16 in WT).

[@Regular_Youtuberi]

ITS A COTTAGE!

[@reaper897]

I need this vid and if Heather had the statue in one vid

[@ladno68]

I have idea. What if Mal didn't exist(all stars will be much better)

[@ethanv0729]

Mike and zoey relationship derailment 💀 Edit: nvm i saw the end

[@PinkWonder4]

What if the robot didn’t have Alejandro so villains are down one

[@DefinitelyIsPad]

suggestion: what if the robot was never pushed into the water in heroes and villains?

[@brunolike8631]

Idea: what if all people who didn't made into the merge where in a season. Team 1: Eva Noah Tyler Katie Sadie Ezekiel Team 2: Dakota B Dawn Sam Brick Anne Maria Team 3: Leonard Amy Rodney Samey Ella Topher (I excluded Staci and Beardo due to the lack of information about them, and no reboot since we don't know who won't made into merge)

[@Rusty_Blue_Caterpillar]

Can you do, what if Courtney and Duncan stayed together in WT/AS ?

[@SCHLOMPY]

Muehehehehe TD wonderer has posted 🙏

[@baileylynn5562]

Would you consider doing reboot seasons? Curious to see your take on what if Raj and Wayne weren’t evacuated

[@Daansstuff-alt]

Then Julia would’ve been eliminated in episode 7 instead of

[@sylveonmaster1205]

Can you please do a WHAT IF: video on World tour (sheep shearing episode) WHAT IF Cody voted courtney instead of sierra (since he was dizzy) Would be interesting to see how it will all work out.

[@havikrogers1801]

This is definitely a pretty serviceable What-If. It's not anything special, but it's definitely an improvement. My only problem is I don't really like the finale of Courtney and Scott, even in this What-If, as Scott never felt like he really deserved it. Other than that, it was pretty good, and it made Duncan a good character. Also, time to dump ideas; What If Alejandro and Sierra replaced Eva and Izzy? TDI What If Leshawna never trash talked? TDA What If Beth won the Aftermath challenge? TDWT What If Scott didn't throw challenges? TDROTI What If Sam never stole pancakes? TDAS (Most wanted for me) What If the singing rule never existed? TDPI What If Leshawna and Tyler were the Reality TV Pros? TDRR What If MK didn't slip up? TDI Reboot 1 What If Scary Girl didn't talk? TDI Reboot 2 What If Fiora and Gabby never switched? DC 1 What If Yul never was poisoned? DC 2 Edit: Oh God, Alejandro is cursed to always be 7th, lol.

[@jelmervanriet790]

What is dc?

[@havikrogers1801]

@@jelmervanriet790 Disventure Camp.

[@jelmervanriet790]

@@havikrogers1801 oh i havent heard of that. I'll check it out. Is it good?

[@havikrogers1801]

​@jelmervanriet790 Both seasons for them are good but not amazing.

[@lakynfl]

This is way better than the original

[@Unvigintillionfan]

Idea: what if DJ never quit in total drama action

[@angelinatheweird366]

He kinda already did this what if

[@Lime0853]

Another idea: what if gwen won the tiebreaker in world tour

[@TDMrFairy]

can you make: what if: Scott wasn't in all-stars (if he died in the season 4, I want see for you who replaced he)

[@smashuniverse459]

What I'f Dave never fell for Sky? This one change would make this season so different because Dave wouldn't go crazy and the elimination order would change a lot

[@niewiem2419]

Maybe you could try in future what if duncan wasn't jelous of courtney in all stars? It is not something really spectacular but since gwen broke up with him she made up with courtney so I wonder if it would happen in this way if they were still potentially a couple and how the story would go on

[@TDPanic]

Can you do “What if Izzy and Sierra never swapped teams”

[@scorpio1193]

My other idea, what if alejandro and Heather teamed up in all stars? I find it kinda crazy that two villainous threats like that wouldn't figure out they have to protect one another. In this re-write, heather won't be as bossy and would actually prioritize strategies versus being right/in charge similar to world tour. She also won't leave her idol.

[@francogugiato5400]

Soooo closeeee...but really good headcanon, I approve! Courtney's finale would be canon imo

[@Futurezenosaiyan]

I want to see probably how it should have gone. I did not like the way Duncan just gets eliminated. And the whole thing bringing up his history in juvie with Mal. And then just completely ignoring it. The fact that no one could tell the difference between Mike and Mal. The only thing I really didn't understand about all stars was the fact that a previous winner didn't win again. I'm pretty content with this.

[@user-og9kz5mh5d]

I have an interesting what if about what if Alejandro and siara what if Harold just listened to Alejandro and went on with

[@gregoryfuller9736]

Country helper should be Duncan and Al should have been country helped since she dated both them

[@nicholasread2290]

Can tell the canon winners (Scott)

[@blorg845]

Can u do what if the rcmp never found izzy

[@blorg845]

In season 1