TDPI: What if Sammy never switched places with Amy?

What if in season 6 of Total Drama, Sammy never switched places with her sister to avoid her own elimination?
Tier list: tiermaker.com/create/total-dr...

[@GameJack26]

amy as the season's main villain is infinitely better than sugar 😭great video

[@TeeThreeAre]

*THANK YOU! SUGAR WAS MY LEAST FAVORITE VILLAIN, LEAST FAVORITE THIS SEASON, AND LEAST FAVORITE IN THE ENTIRE FRANCHISE!*

[@thesmm2311]

@@TeeThreeAreLeonard apparently wasn't as bad as Sugar.

[@Maite-Maria]

100th like

[@voiceunderthecovers]

Gassing it a little there.@@TeeThreeAre

[@myr.drr_]

sugar and the main villain

[@entymash]

The fact that this what if made me like Amy only shows how insanely good your rewrites are 😭❤

[@TDWonderer]

glad you liked her! she was really fun to write for

[@Gwen1661]

You made the impossible (in my personal opinion), you actually made Dave feel tolerable!

[@TDWonderer]

im just as surprised as you lol

[@brunolike8631]

I love how this makes Amy the villain of the season

[@PepsieCat]

The video of all time for all 3 Amy fans

[@therealnoahfromtd]

OMG HIII

[@therealnoahfromtd]

I'm a big fan also when is the top 100 ep 11 coming out?

[@havikrogers1801]

YOO, IT’S PEPSIECAT, SO EPIC!!!

[@PepsieCat]

​​@@therealnoahfromtdtop 100 takes by far the longest to make out of them all. I left a statement in my discord server which a link can be found in every videos description

[@rEdbrICkmArOOnAUbUrn4975]

real

[@librae35]

I LOVE THIS AMY SO MUCH😭. She's so stupid and i loved how she made the "team amy" and had a rock named Sammy, you were so real for that

[@_k.hj_6873]

Help yes, Amy was so funny In this what if

[@TDWonderer]

writing for a self absorbed idiot is always really fun, glad you enjoyed her!

[@LarryStewart-hj7ky]

It's a coincidence that both TDPI what if were both around Amy and Sammy

[@_k.hj_6873]

Honestly I don't even like them that much, but they should've been the main characters of the season imo

[@cindy8966]

how is that a coincidence… he chooses what videos to do lol

[@vexillologymaster]

Is it also a coincidence that Ella is eliminated after helping Sammy in the first What if, and helping Amy in this one?

[@myr.drr_]

@@_k.hj_6873 There are never main characters, eh?

[@myr.drr_]

@@_k.hj_6873 that for the bad guys this season was sugar

[@shirogwyn5952]

What If Idea: What If Sierra and Izzy never swapped teams.

[@JaxsonPlays10]

I like this one

[@Justheredoingmything]

@@JaxsonPlays10agree

[@TeeThreeAre]

Not a bad suggestion…

[@ThatOneSandwichGuy]

I think the first few episodes mostly stay the same only difference is the Japan episode the girls where all bickering and Sierra and Cody had to come up with something. Now Izzy has shown she's not completely incompetent but it depends if Cody is able to get her to focus on helping him if not Amazons lose in Japan meaning Heather's probably out but that's a big IF, as Cody would have to work extra harder to give the Amazons the win for that episode

[@jacobadelsheimer9645]

@@ThatOneSandwichGuyChef said he chose Amazon because of the exploding donuts. Izzy loves explosions. I feel like Izzy would suggest blowing up different objects.

[@sabidab1292]

A What If I think would be interesting would be if World Tour wasn't a musical series. If so, Duncan wouldn't have quit the show, so Ezekiel would've stayed eliminated, Alejandro wouldn't have as easily find out about Duncan and Gwen's kiss without the song, if that would even happen, and Team Victory would've been the first team to make it to the turtle pond in New York.

[@TDWonderer]

interesting, i've seen the what if Duncan doesn't quit WT one a lot but I think this a more fun variation of that, definitely gonna put it on my list to get around to thanks for the suggestion!

[@eriklin9541]

I love the Season 6 what ifs because all of them are at least 10x better than the original.

[@TDWonderer]

yep, when you're starting from rock bottom you can only go up

[@sirsquishymittens807]

Did this man make Dave a actual okay character?!?!

[@TDWonderer]

yep, i am the messiah the legends speak of (but fr thanks, im personally still not big on him but at least he's better than the original)

[@niewiem2419]

Tbh even if I dislike pakithew I like ur rewrites of it cause you are fixing it. Your scarlett was better developed, dave got happy and not cringy ending, jasmine got into finale and amy became a good character with Sammy getting her revenge at the end. Perfect rewrite

[@cosmikpowa3133]

I seriously went "Oh my god" when Sammy was revealed to be the one making the challenge, and the poetic irony of everything that happens afterwards... best villain elimination ever

[@iEdit.becauseican]

Video ideas: What if Duncan never can back (world tour) What if Ella was allowed to sing (pawkeitew) What if Brick never swapped teams (revenge) What if Sierra and Izzy never swapped teams (world tour) What if Izzy never came back (action) What if Eziekial didn’t loose the stick (world tour)

[@therealnoahfromtd]

That's actually good ty for giving me a vid idea (im kinda a small ytber)

[@maxezzy1282]

I read a fanfic where Brick didn't swap teams

[@MasterStartist5]

I never thought I’d see the day where Dave and Amy are actually GOOD CHARACTERS?! Truly an impressive feat well done sir. What If Ideas: Island - What If Izzy And Katie Didn’t Switch Teams? Action - What If Courtney Didn’t Return? World Tour - What If Izzy And Sierra Didn’t Switch Teams? Revenge Of The Island - What If Anne Maria Didn’t Quit? All Stars - What If Sam Didn’t Sneak Any Pancakes? Pahkitew - What If Ella Was Allowed To Sing? Island(2023) - What If Millie Didn’t Vote Scary Girl In Episode 4? Island(2024) - What If Nichelle Didn’t Quit? Disventure Camp(S1) - What If Fiore And Gabby Never Swapped Teams? Disventure Camp(S2) - What If Yul Successfully Poisoned Aiden?

[@stupidperson8780]

Holy heck! This was such a good rewrite, definitely better than the original season, even of i don't like Sugar going that early. I loved Amy (surprisingly) and Ella in this, they were SOO good, your such a good writer

[@TDWonderer]

holy heck! thanks for such the high praise, i try my best and im glad you enjoyed the video

[@Nonya._.]

I feel like this is a much better version of the season compared to the canon imo, good job man 👍

[@TDWonderer]

thanks man 👍

[@krishnavinesh5638]

Overall thoughts (as an amyfan) - - Liked how Shawn told Amy that she has no friends because of her horrible personality, that was so cool omg - And Amy befriending Ella was also nice in a way, she first did it so that she won't get eliminated, but then she also felt offended by Sky's remark. I mean, she wasn't any kinder to Ella, but this came from somebody who verbally abuses Sammy every day - The boxing ring was a cool addition, because it was a W for everyone who wasn't Amy. Sammy got to take revenge on her sister, Jasmine got to take out her anger by beating her worst enemy - I was literally on my sofa paralyzed like omg I fucking love bitches that have like 1 friend in the competition where literally everyone else rightfully hates them. Julia is the sole exception to this

[@TDWonderer]

overall thoughts (as the creator) im happy there were things you enjoyed in my video! amy is a really fun brat to write for, definitely struggled with some on the intricacies to her but glad you liked her

[@supermontythomas2159]

Suggestion: What if Gwen and Trent were on the same team in Action? -What if Chris had the previous finalists choose their teams. Then, the alien challenge can happen, but the team with the most eggs wins immunity

[@joeyobzut1448]

What if... ...Courtney joined the Action cast from the beginning? ...the teams for All Stars were OGs vs ROTI? ...Ezekiel didn't lose the stick in World Tour? ...the teams for World Tour were organized the way they were for ROTI? ...in the Ridonculous Race, a time penalty cost a team the game (whichever one that came close to happening, Wonderer's choice)?

[@Nonya._.]

You know it’s a good day when TD wonderer posts 💜

[@therealnoahfromtd]

Kinda a bot comment

[@therealnoahfromtd]

Kinda a bot comment

[@unu9651]

The 'Samey 2' bit actually made me laugh out loud

[@JaxsonPlays10]

The Legend Returns, But like fr this is one of my favorite KZbin channels

[@havikrogers1801]

Pretty good What-If, if I do say so. I really like what you did with most of the characters like Amy, Ella, and especially Dave were done much better. My only problem was that there were times when I was feeling like this was just “What If Amy never returned?”, mainly with Sugar’s elimination, but that was about it (also, Scarlett still goes crazy). Anyways, time to idea dump: TDI: What If there were no purge challenges? TDA: What If Leshawna never trash talked the others? TDWT: What If Beth won the aftermath challenge? TDROTI: What If Jo and Scott never swapped? TDAS: What If Sam never stole pancakes? TDPI: What If Amy and Sammy didn’t cost the team the challenge? TDRR: What If Leshawna and Tyler were the Reality TV Pros? TDI Reboot 1: What If MK never slipped up? TDI Reboot 2: What If Nichelle never quit? DC 1: What If Fiora and Gabby never swapped? DC 2: What If Yul never got poisoned? Also, since it’s becoming closer to the channels year anniversary, you should also do “What If DJ and Chef never made an alliance?” continuing into World Tour. It would be a pretty good 1 year anniversary video for when that day comes.

[@therealnoahfromtd]

He did what if chef didn't make an alliance with dj

[@havikrogers1801]

@@therealnoahfromtd I meant that he could do a 1 year anniversary continuation video into World Tour, since we’re starting to get closer to that.

[@TDWonderer]

i agree with that it felt similar to my last what if especially in the early stages with Sugar and Max's elimination happening at the same places for similar reasons but it makes sense since both what ifs follow the butterfly effect of not having Amy return, as for the one year anniversary I already have a video planned for that.... (don't get your hopes up it really wont be that interesting)

[@havikrogers1801]

@@TDWonderer Whatever What-If you’ve got I’m sure will be interesting and I’ll pray it’s What If Staci won every season.

[@_k.hj_6873]

I love this version so much, even if the finale is a couple like zoke, i think it works really good with Shawn and Jasmine, specially since it feels like their canon plot didn't contribute to anything lol

[@TDWonderer]

yeah the canon plot of shawn not wanting to split really just existed so jasmine could get mad at shawn like dave did to sky (which was already a terrible idea for a finale) but i like the way it plays out with shawn and jasmine in a finale, its a good mix of tension and relations (also since they are both capable challenge competitors it makes for a good competitive finale)

[@RasmusVJS]

I think this What If (And maybe your other Pahkitew one, don't remember) proves something that I already believed. That whilst this cast is a lot wackier than previous ones, there are some workable character concepts in here that got squandered. Luckily this What If started after Leonard was eliminated, because he is unsalvagable.

[@havikrogers1801]

Leonard is god, my clan of three fans will not accept this slander!!!

[@mikaela3746]

omg, sammys revenge is just chefs kiss!!!!!

[@CoolPlayersVic]

I can't believe you actually made Dave likeable and made Skave work somehow and Dave and Shawn's friendship was nice Also Sammy getting to eliminate Amy at the end was peak

[@TDWonderer]

personally im still not a fan of dave even in this what if as the sky obsession in my mind would still be annoying but it was nice that it at least got to not end in a complete dumpster fire

[@voiceunderthecovers]

As a Pahkitew Island fan.. great video! Your writing is really good, both character writing and narration.

[@greenscarf1063]

YESSSSS NEW VID (What if idea "what if Courtney did her challenge in phobia factor")

[@czerwonystudio6301]

I thought that next TDPI what if would be my idea with "What if Topher had fake parachute and Chef the real one", but I acually liked this what if, especially that Amy lost her friends back home and Sammy became popular, and her come back at Amy by making the boxing challenge. I love Sammy, she is my favorite TDPI contestant, my favorite female contestant and my 2nd favorite contestant over all. You also somehow made Amy, the character that was really annoying acually funny, the "team Amy" arc was funny and fitted Amy a lot. BTW, i once sended an fan art to you with superhero costumes from "what if Sierra and Alejandro were in action part 2", and you never showed it so i don't know if you even got it. Some kind of answering this coment with "yeah i got it" would be enough, thanks.

[@lysanderlonshadow8653]

Always looking forward to your new uploads!

[@TDWonderer]

always looking forward to your comments!

[@LemonEditsAndReviews]

Amy didn't really have a plot other than bullying Sammy so I dont think she'd really have anything else to if Sammy was gone

[@pistincup352]

So, in summary, if Amy never gotten voted out, she would’ve been the main antagonist of the season

[@Tiny33boom]

the whole video was good and don't ask how I watched 1 hour of content in about a minute

[@serenepastel]

Good on Sammy for making friends on her own time.

[@Naggfruit]

pahkitew what ifs are my favorite because of how much potential it had. Suggestion: What if Rodney didnt fall in love with every girl that talked to him.

[@SummerSideStories]

Honestly this was a really fun what if and I felt satisfied that Sammy got to do the final blow to Amy's game but, I wish the finals weren't Jasmine and Shawn. I like them but, would have preferred maybe Dave vs Jasmine cause it would have been more fun to see

[@elitettelbach4247]

Glad you’re feeling better! Another very interesting season!

[@cytromancer1692]

Imo Samey deserved more episodes and she should’ve made it to the final 5

[@Chef67003]

glad to see you back!

[@user-nl2wo6mf4q]

i actually loved this version of the season. i always thought scarlet and jasmine could’ve been one of the best alliances in the season with their mental and physical strengths put together. this version also made me like amy, ella ,and dave way more. like with most of this cast in the original they’re so one dimensional so there’s no depth to the characters making amy’s “mean” bit fall flat because that’s all she is, ella’s “singing princess” bit annoying me to no end, and dave’s “hopeless romantic crybaby who can’t take a freaking hint” bit making me skip most of his scenes in the og season, so to see all of them get more depth made me like them a lot more. I particularly like that sammy going home was a blessing in disguise instead of her going home and things staying the same. Also the scene with her and dave helping jasmine/shawn in the finale was so wholesome. overall excellent video

[@DivineChaos204]

I love ur videos so much! I have some requests! What if Noah was a villain in Action? What if Trent was voted off in the Phobia Factor? What if Heather kissed Geoff instead of Trent? What if Dave listened to Sky? What if Dawn found the immunity statue?

[@supermontythomas2159]

I have a request, too. What if Trent didn't go crazy in action? One way he can do that is to have Gwen and Owen pick the teams because they are the previous finalists like the reboot season 2, and the alien challenge can still happen but the team with the most eggs wins immunity.

[@TD_Heather4TW]

It would be a fun what if idea to tackle WT where Gwen won the tiebreaker instead of Courtney.

[@worstspytf2824]

Its always a good day when you upload, looking forward to watching it, I needed a reason to smile today so cheers for the help :)

[@TDWonderer]

no problem thanks for enjoying my content :)

[@supermontythomas2159]

Welcome back, I missed your content, your awesome!

[@TDWonderer]

thank you! its nice to be back

[@Raddish-IS-Radd]

I would love to see a what if Scarlett was never evil.

[@JackOrange]

Idea I thought would be fun for you to cover after watching your reboot rankings is: what if MK’s plan to frame Julia worked in S1E6 and Julia was eliminated instead of her? You talked about the idea and it really got me thinking about it, so I was wondering how the merge would change with Julia gone and MK in her place. Might be too early to do reboot what-ifs with only two seasons of the cast but it would be interesting to see.

[@seangleeson8073]

Samey 2 is my new favorite character

[@DaBlaziken]

Babe wake up, TD Wonderer posted

[@XtraMal]

Total drama what if idea: what if Mike didn't have multiple personality disorder

[@saradyson9534]

fresh tv should be taking notes

[@littlechill]

That was a cool one dude, congrats.

[@TDWonderer]

thanks dude

[@Justheredoingmything]

Your videos never fail to make me happy and invested {I don’t know how to complement people-} keep up the good work

[@heed-shot4971]

Love these videos man ! Two ideas I have for this series is. What if Harold actully voted out Duncan instead of LeShawna in TDA and what if Sierra and Izzy never switched teams in TDWT. Keep it up man !

[@MickeyMouseTotallyReal]

Idea: what if Chris assigned the teams correctly TDWT version? Basically in the normal version Ezekiel was the last person to reach the finish line on the Egyptian challenge, so, he was supposed to be on team Amazon, Alejandro on team Amazon Cody In team Chris is really really really really hot and Ezekiel on team Amazon.

[@christy1385]

You have the best videos ever

[@TDWonderer]

you have the nicest comment ever

[@happylol6179]

A very great What if! I’m so glad you made this one, I was really waiting for this. A little sad that we got a couple final, I expected it to be Amy vs Jasmine, but I’m still okay with all of it. I can’t wait for you to make What if on a new cast. For example: “What if Millie voted with Scary Girl and Priya” “What if Julia failed to expose MK” “What if Chase and Emma didn’t had any relationships before the show” “What if Nichelle beats Scary Girl in challenge” “What if Bowie didn’t got Caleb eliminated first” “What if Priya was voted off over Emma in S2 Ep4” “What if Julia never wrote fake contract to Nichelle” “What if Damien could’ve said that he forgave Millie” “What of Chef never called out Scary Girl in S2 Ep1” I have a lot of what if ideas actually on new cast

[@riachuello]

Great rewrite! It really gave time for many characters to shine, Scarlett, Dave, Sugar, Amy, even Sammy got her sweet revenge. Well then, for what if suggestion: - What if Katie and Izzy didn't switch teams? (TDI) - What if Courtney joined the season from the beggining? (TDA) - What if Alejandro and Sierra weren't in world tour (TDWT, but it would start in TDA special) - What if Mal manifested earlier? (TDROTI, my guess is that either Mike hurts his head like Anne Maria in the first episode, by trying to climb the totem, or Mike fails to save Zoey from falling of the log, and the tumbling down would hurt Mikes head) - What if Gwen voted Heather instead of Joe? (TDAS)

[@KnotZMilky]

Crazy how you actually wrote the season better than how it was originally

[@pokehunterhd]

I've always been curious about how Amy would work without samey.

[@ja3714]

Great video dude 👍🏻 I can have a suggestion for a what if. What is Alejandro and Heather was in the ridonculous race?

[@brendantw]

What if Sadie stopped shooting apples at Courtney (Island) What if Trent didn't go insane (Action)

[@saltyricee]

Just finsihed the video, it was so good 😍

[@TDWonderer]

thank youuu

[@tdannemaria]

You should do "What if Harold rigged out Duncan instead of Courtney"

[@dylanjohnson3346]

This was so good you fixed amy dave and sugar lol

[@grandom7116]

What If ideas: What Julia was never rude?

[@undercoverchicken6268]

I would love to see what-ifs for the reboot, like: what if MK never uploaded the video of Julia yelling at the dinosaur?

[@seanconnolly7736]

Next do what if Courtney swapped teams with Gwen instead of Duncan in all stars

[@worstspytf2824]

A simple what if I just thought of is what if Sadie swapped teams instead of Kadie? So the Gophers would have the BFFs and the Bass would keep Izzy and have another member of the Gophers on there team. Not sure if it would be good but I haven't seen it suggested.

[@wacky_bean2]

Video idea: What if sadie and izzy never swap team (tdi) What if sierra was never obsessed with cody (tdwt) What if the love triangle never started (tdwt) What if alejandro and heather swap team (tdwt) What if scarlett never revealed her true self (tdpi) What if raj and wayne never got injured (tdir)

[@lestatcanada]

Some What if ideas I thought of (Total drama island) What if Heather had decided to swap teams with Sadie, letting Sadie and Katie be on the gophers while Heather would be on the bass What if Owen was eliminated in episode 10 for eating the ribs (Total drama action) 1. What if Geoff and Bridgette weren’t eliminated in episode 2 2. What if the entire total drama island cast competed in total drama action? (Total drama pahkitue island) What if Leonard was voted out in episode 1

[@Goatt448]

Wwwww finally ur back

[@klausing7114]

I wish this was the real season, Amy being a real annoyance, not like Heather level but makes her a good villain

[@maxchristopher4352]

How Pahkitew Island should have played out

[@leshawnaTD]

Here's some ideas: S1: What if Katie and Sadie never got to be on the same team? What if Heather didn't create any alliances? S2: What if Trent never went crazy? S3: What if Bridgette got off the pole? What if Team Victory were actually victorious? What if Sierra and Izzy never swapped? S4: What if Zoey was Commando Zoey the whole time P1? S5: What if Scott never hit Mike in the head? What if Zoey was Commando Zoey the whole time P2? S6: What if Ella *never* sang? S7/RR: What if Noah never fell in love with Emma? S8/RS1: What if Emma and Bowie stayed friends?/Emma and Chase never got back together? S9/RS2: What if Priya was out in E4 instead of Emma?

[@supermontythomas2159]

I really like the trent one

[@thesmm2311]

Commandy Zoey could be made villainous, at least to an extent

[@Ribbital]

so what your saying is, sammy ruined pahkitiew island

[@Lime0853]

Next what if: what if- gwen beat courtney in the tiebreaker

[@connorfour]

I have an idea: What if Cody Never Got Mauled by a Bear? I know someone already made one, but i'd love to see your take on it.

[@reidavi2323]

I think Amy could be a much better villain than Sugar!

[@Sam-tl4ho]

next video should be what if harold didnt sabotage courtney, s1 courtney is prob the most different courtney from the others so it should be interesting

[@Frognymphthing]

You need to be a writer,Tdpi would be good if it went like this,and more people would actually like it.

[@Brunette008]

What if idea: What if Izzy Never swapped places with Katie in the second ep of TDI?

[@mcsavage1846]

Great episode, will you continue the story of Alejandro and Sierra being in Island and Action going into World Tour. I think this time you can have Justin, Sadie, Katie and maybe Trent to not compete, but have Dj, Geoff, Bridgette, Noah, LeShawna compete.

[@tdtheorys]

awesome

[@raymondthefiregod5598]

Idea: What if The Ridonculous Race was an actual season of Total Drama with a Blood VS Water twist.

[@Supreme-AMVs]

Hey could you do what if Noah played in the dodgeball challenge

[@JakesoontobeJack]

Here is a What If idea: What if Millie went down the four pointer slide instead of tricking Damien to.go down it? Another idea is What If Emma ignored Priya on the last question and answered b.

[@joshbrodon]

what if suggestion: what if eva and izzy never returned (island)

[@dangthatsashortname7527]

Video idea like 6th time asking 😝😝 what if dawns idol was real

[@RandomsRebooted]

Omg why do you gotta post when is 12 for me

[@Fanofmanything25]

I would like too see a video about "What if Duncan didn't trow the dingo at Cody in WT?:

[@JujanGames]

What if Ezekiel was actually brought back for All-Stars?

[@ChristopherCapersJones]

My birthday is tomorrow!!

[@jeremycel3032]

At first I wasn't sure if I was going to like this What If since I don't like Amy. But I really liked what you did with her, I think she can be entertaining when Sammy isn't around and having Sammy be the one to make her lose is perfect. All the other plots were good but I think Amy was the best her brattiness and her plans ending bad are quite funny. Skave was good and I'm happy that even if you don't like the couple you gave them a decent ending. Oh and I also liked that everyone came back in the finale I feel like it was a missed opportunity in AS and here. If at any time you do another what if in this season and Sky Fall ends with 5 people again, I recommend that in addition to the fact that the one who comes last is automatically eliminated, there should be a vote to make a double elimination but that is just a suggestion. Since the next what if will be in WT it will be interesting what you will do with some characters who are eliminated soon in canon but now they are going to go further like Lindsay and DJ since their eliminations were affected by the animal curse (I know that Alejandro was the cause of DJ's but the curse was the reason Alejandro was able to manipulate him)

[@shellos31oeste72]

another different universe os pakhitew which is better than the original!! wow, the writers really messed up big time and it showed by eliminating both twins so early in the game

[@Aangfan06]

What if Bridgette and Geoff didn't kiss many times in TDA?

[@juancruzdiazbravo7338]

It's a shame, but I didn't like this ending. everything was great until the 3 finalists, but then, too much couple drama and I would have preferred to have Amy in the final

[@baileylynn5562]

Maybe I missed this, but why is the island malfunctioning in this timeline? In the original version, Max threw up on the tech in the tree which seemed to cause it, but that didn’t happen here

[@TDWonderer]

I thought I talked about this in my last what if but i guess its been a while, basically because theres no way for me to know what would happen for that challenge if the island didn't malfunction, in every pahkitew what if, regardless if Max throws up on the tree or not the island will malfunction

[@baileylynn5562]

@@TDWonderer ah, it’s been a while since I’ve seen that video. Thanks for clarifying

[@kianbakker3691]

Can you please please do a continuation on what if ezikiel wasnt sexisy