TDROTI: What if Scotts strategy didn't involve self-sabotage?

[@majinbuu3290]

The reason why Scott threw challenges initially was because he wanted to get rid of the stronger players first, such as B, and keeping those who were weaker or easy to manipulate longer as a way to win.

[@greg.167]

he says he wants to give them a flase sense of security until he picks them off

[@olaf-chan-728]

​@@greg.167 that part is so random we choose to collectivelly ignore that part

[@TheOneandOnlyBrasicaserliyFan]

like how he used mike and got him eliminated

[@Christina-y2m]

That’s not why

[@LightningvsLightning]

Um, he actually stats that he does it because he wants to give the other team a false sense of security before he picks them off (it doesn’t make any sense, but that’s what he stated).

[@nooby7411]

“boy wonder probably went off to solve world hunger”🤣

[@jeremycel3032]

What if Harold rigged the votes on Duncan? I feel like this could change several things since Duncan was an important player in the merge.

[@elliodh]

I’m not sure if I’m remembering correctly but I think he did this with Alejandro and sierra in island

[@jeremycel3032]

Oh yes I remember but there were several things changed before in that what if with Alejandro and Sierra. This would be in the normal season which I think works quite well since Courtney is not the first boot.

[@skylandprodigy]

i feel the whole season could be different if Harold didn't rig the votes at all

[@_twinklesprinkle]

I honestly think everyone would have picked up on the rigging much quicker had he rigged Duncan out. Everyone knew Harold was getting bullied, with Duncan being the biggest culprit. And since the other teammates at the time were all pretty close, they'd all know they didn't vote for Duncan, just as they didn't when Courtney was booted. However, it would be interesting to see how the rest of the season would play out had Duncan been an earlier boot.

[@user-nt9yi3zf6k]

or what if he failed since now we have Courtany

[@elitettelbach4247]

As a Dawn fan I really enjoyed this! Especially the round where she used the fake idol to bluff out a Jo vote.

[@azsazazsa]

In the MAJORITY of RotI what ifs Dawn goes far, because all things considered she should have. Love her sm

[@serenepastel]

I think you did a great job with the Scott-Dawn dynamic. It was a great way to show Scott as a strategic player

[@freebobux1585]

Your so underrated. You deliver the highest quality What-If's. You deserve bare minimum 80K likes and 607K Views.

[@Gold_Gamer_100]

I've got an idea: What if the aftermath cast was in World Tour? Y'know, Katie and Sadie, Beth, Eva, Trent, Geoff and Justin. I can see some potential dynamics play out. Beth wouldn't trust Alejandro due to Justin already manipulating her with his looks in season 2. Bonus points of she's in the same team as Heather. Justin would also not fall for Al since he used the same strategy as him. Sounds like fun

[@limit_breaker15]

Ngl that would be a good what if

[@TheSilIiest]

I would love to see Beth and Heather rekindle and form an unlikely bond over their hatred for alejandro

[@sevenoxia7199]

Honestly, with these 7 contestants being back, the teams become harder to predict, however I am almost certain that Beth would not be on Team Amazon. I kinda think Beth would be smitten by Alejandro because he's much better at the social game but eventually realise he's up to no good, I think that Eva will do the pyramid challenge with Owen, Noah, and Izzy, later reduced to just the former two, with Beth going through the pyramid with Harold, DJ, and Leshawna (since Alejandro wouldn't have the hand or shoulders for 3 girls, and Bridgette/Lindsay were WAY TOO SMITTEN in the original for Beth to be with them), thus Beth would be on Team Victory, Eva on Team Chris. Katie & Sadie would either follow Justin or follow Trent, not sure which one, and I have no clue which teams those 4, along with Geoff would be on.

[@Dxuser5]

Trent and Geoff would be interesting to see their reactions once the love triangle comes around

[@Trent.TD9]

And all stars would probably change

[@niewiem2419]

Okay but Scott and dawn interactions were so cute 😭 honestly I would love to see their interactions in all stars and maybe them taking the role of scott x courtney

[@kidcooper02]

LOVED this what if, i really love any ROTI what if because i think that season has such great foundations but shaky outcomes so i always adore using their setting. Im a huge fan of scott and dawn's dynamic and i really like where you took them, him having her use the fake idol against jo and lightning was amazing. And really giving them some genuine moments like the fang resolution! I like when td villains get scenes to interact with the others in a genuine way And much else may have not changed but i did like Brick having a more full arc into being a bit more assertive, its the ground work for him to be an allstar and coming equipped as a better leader Great what if!

[@MasterStartist5]

Bro I Was Completely *SHOOKETH* To Find Not One But TWO Videos In Less Than A Few Weeks?! Truly Amazing Work TD Wonder!

[@Davidmariodude]

What if Dave never fell for Sky? This would definitely change Dave's character and his elimination episode so I would love to see this one

[@catbloonblox]

maybe he would become a likeable character (maybe)

[@Davidmariodude]

@@catbloonblox I still like Dave even in the original lol I just wanna see this because I never saw anyone else do this before

[@Spacething7474]

alteratively: what if sky betrayed jasmine to free dave?

[@coltonchiacchia5206]

I feel like this could push dawn into allstars which would cause mal some problems so thats a fun continuation

[@briangalindo2]

I'd love to see a follow-up to this where Dawn and Brick are in All-Stars instead of Jo and Sam (due to placing higher in this version of Revenge) and Dawn being put on the Vultures for working with Scott, and how that'd play out. Would Dawn make a new pact with Scott? Would she actively work against him? How would Brick fare? Just a few ideas!

[@LightningvsLightning]

I doubt Brick would be in the season as he originally made it farther than Sam and Sam still got in. Plus, Sam only came back because he wanted to become a Fallout enemy like Dakota, and since Dakota is still mutated in this What-If, I think Sam would still return over Brick (unfortunately).

[@thomask4538]

Honestly I think Zoey be on the vulture due to her becoming more aggressive and now she booted off Dawn in the final 3 episodes

[@ThatRandomDude-qt1qd]

And maybe add b to just cause I think b dawn and brick could be a good trio

[@brianjusenius186]

"Acting class is dismissed " that line was too hilarious

[@brianjusenius186]

Also "bore wonder probably went to go save world hunger"

[@coriseoris]

I got the coolest idea ever. So in Lightning's audition tape he says "Man, Chris should've made Lightning a team of one, shabiggidy bam!". Well, what if he really was on a team of one? Toxic Rats and Mutant Maggots gonna each have 6 team members and then there will be Team Lightning

[@THSDropout]

I feel like these videos are getting better and better, keep up the great work!

[@TotalDramaEthan]

I have a what if! What if Jo voted off Lightning instead of Brick in TDROTI? Also, I haven’t watched the video yet, but I’m sure it will be great, and I’m happy you put out another one so soon!

[@Mirage_Phantom5404]

Here is an idea, What if Courtney was in Total Drama Action from the beginning of the season?

[@Anne_VonCleves]

Idk she might be eliminated earlier

[@AznYunHou]

Justin would be the season's main villain if that were the case.

[@Bread771]

Idea: What if the all stars writers could count. I know this is a tad more meta than your usual ideas, but basically in the 2nd all stars challenge the Villainous Vultures get nine pieces when they needed seven. They reuse the same middle piece three times. So now that the vultures win that challenge they’d likely win the third challenge with the number advantage. This would likely lead to a Heather Lightning alliance due to their mutual annoyance towards jo

[@entymash]

I think this 'what if' would lead perfectly in All Stars since Dawn has a bigger chance to be in the cast and episode 9 would be completely different without Zeke

[@JustARandomGuy219]

You know it's gonna be a good day (or night) when TD Wonderer posts.

[@angelinatheweird366]

I really like this what if! Dawn isn't my favorite character, but I do love how she was handled here! (Especially her interactions with Scott, and her giving Ezekiel the help he deserves.) Can't wait to see what you put up next!!

[@sebastianraven5887]

I’ve got ideas for every season: TDI: What If Duncan never woke up at the dodgeball challenge? TDA: What If Trent wasn’t obsessed with the number nine? TDWT: What If Alejandro and Sierra weren’t in World Tour? TDROTI: What If Mike didn’t have multiple personalities? TDAS: What If no one was switched to the opposite team? (For example: Cameron switched to Villains, Duncan switched to Heroes.) TDPI: What If Ella never sang and got eliminated because of it? TDRR: What If Devin didn’t fall off a cliff? TDR: What If Millie voted for Ripper instead of Scary Girl? I’d love it if all of these happened, but I know you’re very busy. I also have in mind, If Harold didn’t rig the votes against Courtney in Island and if Alejandro was on Team Victory.

[@TDPanic]

Can you do if Sierra and Izzy never swapped teams? Love your videos BTW, I watch them all!

[@sojuliia]

yessss

[@Capriasda]

YAY NEW VID Edit: Okay i watched it fully and as a Dawn fan i was so happy to see her in the final four!! Your content is great keep it up!!!

[@leopardsun]

Wow. In spite of the elimination order being mostly unchanged, this honestly sounds WAY more enjoyable than the actual season.

[@pankakequeen6080]

Always love an early Christmas gift, haha I really enjoyed this What If! B and Dawn are some of my favourite TD characters, so it’s nice to see them get more time to shine! I think I say this for all of your What-Ifs, but still, I think this version of ROTI is better then canon. Honestly I could see it actually BEING the canon version of ROTI if Scott didn’t self sabotage! Great video as always, and have a Merry Christmas/Happy Holidays, TD Wonderer! 👍

[@lysanderlonshadow8653]

Always great to see your videos!

[@shinnyboppers9802]

almost done this video, always like your storylines. I can't think of anything specifically but I'd love to see more ROTI content

[@queenzoroark]

For the person he is based in, self-sabotage is exactly what defines his strategy.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

Nice! I’d like to see another World Tour what if at some point since we’ve only had one short one so far, and we haven’t had one that covers the pre-merge of World Tour on this channel

[@SummerSideStories]

This was a fun AU snd would fix a few things for Dawn being a fan favorite and Scott x Dawm would make a bit more sense still bad but better. Also here is somethings you could do for all stars Swap Sam and brick (brick did even better then before and also got out in a more interesting way then Sam) Swap Jo and Dwan ( kinda joking but to be fair dwan did a few "villainous" things by working with all the villians that came from the season,tricking using the fake Statue, messing with the yeti indirectly getting Lindsay captured etc. Plus it could be fun with her rivalry with scoot and she might be able to sense Mal which could be cool.) These are just some ideas if you want to do a part 2

[@TD_Heather4TW]

Idea: Generation Swap: Swap the generations of TD. {This means the combined Gen 2 and 3 cast plays Island, Action and World Tour, while Gen 1 Cast plays ROTI} P.S: I'll send regards to your thumbnail.

[@thomask4538]

Danicus Green did make a fanfic version like that discussing a few early boots. It has things I didn't like, but it a decent read.

[@TD_Heather4TW]

@@thomask4538 Where can I find it?

[@SkyesStupidity]

I liveeee for the scott and dawn froendship

[@Simplyywoodland]

8:11 GOT ME LAUGHING ON THE FLOOR

[@sojuliia]

what if trent and gwen were on the same team in tda? i’ve been rewatching it and realized that trent and gwen only got voted because trent was throwing challenges for gwen who was on the other team, and both their teams noticed it, and voted the two out. if they were on the same team it would probably mean they both stayed at least a bit longer.

[@eriklin9541]

TDWT: What if Everyone in the cast was playing? TDAS: What if Duncan and Courtney never swapped teams? TDAS: What if Moon Madness (Episode 5) was an Elimination?

[@RashyTheGOAT]

Challenge idea: (This will take a long time to make so i understand if u dont want to do it) What if there was a mega all stars season after the reboot you can either decide who you wanna take from each season or make a poll (this is including the people from the reboot season) you can choose from 6-11 people from each season. Please make this the top comment

[@japes_l]

Id love to see the part 2 of this with Brick and Dawn being in All Stars instead of Jo and Sam (or maybe just Dawn instead of Sam)

[@ment6480]

Babe, wake up! New TD Wonderer just dropped

[@pies306]

Idea: TDAS - What if Sam didn’t cheat in the Pancake challenge.

[@ThatoneYuu]

23:54 i love this without context.

[@user-nt9yi3zf6k]

I am so curios how all stars would play since people could be different and no Ezekial for that episode since he got help

[@ScintillatingSusie]

"And I never kissed a guy" "Uh, that's cool, Lightning doesn't judge"

[@shellos31oeste72]

love your videos AS ALWAYSSSSS

[@Trottskee]

I would love to see how you would do All Stars if you were the writing team of the season. Is there any differences with the cast you would have, any major story changes, Elimination order? I feel like you'd absolutely make a GREAT All Stars Season

[@twick_original]

I have some what if ideas: Big Ones (may take two parts) What if Geoff and Bridgette didn't got eliminated in the 1st S2 episode? What if Katie and Sadie never swapped teams? What if Sierra and Izzy never swapped teams? What if Mal never existed? (can be kinda boring) What if Heather never stole Eva's MP3? Medium Ones (May take a vido abou 40-60 minutes) What if Anne Maria never quitted? What if someone was actually eliminated on episode 7 of S6? What if Harold rigged the votes agains't Duncan? What if all the ROTI episodes had eliminations? Small ones (may make a video of 10-20 minutes) What if in episode 19 of S1 there was a actual elimination What if Max wasn't eliminated unfairly on S6? What if Courtney's plan was never revealed? What if Owen never returned on S2? What if in episode 22 there was an actual challenge? (you can take one of the ones that had no elimination) What if Blaineley never entered the game? That's it, if you like this ideas like the comment :)

[@Jake_NekoNekoyama]

Idea: What if Chris hosted a marshmallow ceremony for Duncan and Owen after giving Heather and Lindsay invincibility for completing the race instead of unfairly eliminating Lindsay? What If Heather went with Lindsay's plan to allow both of them to turn in Owen and DJ? What If Sierra had a just normal crush on Cody, not in her stalker way? What If Dakota never came back to get more screentime, resulting in her not getting the intern job? What If Emma haven't got back together with Chase? What if Gwen and Owen chose the teams since they were finalists in Action? What if only Bridgette or Geoff was eliminated instead of it being a double? What If Gwen never kissed Duncan? What If Courtney was eliminated for making Lindsay drive? What If Amy apologized to Sammy for her mistreatment when Sammy stood up for her? What If Leshawna and DJ listened to the rules Gwen stated for surviving a horror movie? The reason why I said Leshawna and DJ is because they are most likely to follow them. What If DJ never saw Heather's green face mask?

[@buttonsfedora]

If Scott never involved self-sabotage in his plans ..He would be my favourite character. But goddamn, he had to get rid of 2 of my favourite characters. (B and Dawn.)

[@worstspytf2824]

Nice video, shame the gen 2 cast didn't get a second season by themselves as this what if and the original have a lot of potential for character interactions that just didn't get enough time in all stars. But then again, problems like that that's why we have what if's and fan seasons so its not all bad.

[@LightningvsLightning]

Welp, time for the review. This was a fun one. I don’t find myself religiously watching it, but it was really fun to see the dynamics between characters like Dawn and Scott getting developed. The only thing that did disappoint me was Jo’s elimination, as she felt like she was getting developed, but that was about it. Also, nice that this is the first What-If to have a boy vs boys finale (even if it was the same). Anyways, time for What-If dumping: TDI: What If Alejandro and Sierra replaced Eva and Izzy? TDA: What If Leshawna never trash talked the contestants? TDWT: What If Beth won the Aftermath challenge? TDROTI: What If Brick got eliminated in episode 4? TDAS: What If Sam didn’t hide pancakes? TDPI: What If the singing rule never existed? RR: What If Leshawna and Tyler were the Reality TV Pros? TDI Reboot 1: What If MK didn’t slip up? TDI Reboot 2: What If Julia never left the folder on Nichelle’s bed? DC 1: What If Fiora and Gabby never swapped teams? DC 2: What If Yul never got poisoned?

[@oxEASTENDERSox]

What if: ella was allowed to sing in pakatal Island. Its a fun concept.

[@pedrojosebellobelen3824]

NGL But I liked the Scott and Dawn interactions up to the end and I do hope if there’s a part 2 in All Stars, where Brick and Dawn took the places of Sam and Ezekiel respectively, we get an actual ship between them.

[@Jasonthe_monkey]

I have a cool what if so basically tdwt had three teams so what if it had two? I feel like that would change a lot who gets voted and some drama so it would be cool to see!

[@MickeyMouseTotallyReal]

Idea: what if Chris assigned the teams correctly TDWT version? Basically in the normal version Ezekiel was the last person to reach the finish line on the Egyptian challenge, so, he was supposed to be on team Amazon, Alejandro on team Amazon Cody In team Chris is really really really really hot and Ezekiel on team Amazon.

[@maxchristopher4352]

Ideas: -What if Amy and Sammy liked each other and still wanted to audition for total drama (cuz the reason why they auditioned was because Sammy wanted to get away from Amy and Amy because Sammy did it and she thought she'd a better pick than her sister). -What if Sierra and Alejandro weren't in world tour and were in revenge of the Island -What if it was Island cast vs revenge of the island cast in all stars -What if Scott never sabotaged his team but it's the continuation in all stars -What if Rodney never fell in love with any women on the show.

[@buttonsfedora]

What I think -Amy and Sammy: They might pretend to be eachother and probably do some cool stuff. -Sierra and Alejandro: Cody wouldn't be stalked 😝 and Sierra might get out early, then Alejandro is in the final 2. -Island VS Revenge: Would lead to some interesting stuff, I'd assume. It would be a bit boring to watch though as there's not much interactions. -Scott (All-Stars): He would probably get a final 3 elimination or something. -Rodney: He would most likely get a different truth in truth or scare, which would be unknown, but he might make it a bit further than the actual placement. Probably eliminated after Ella.

[@DarbyWyre]

Loved the different Dawn/Scott development

[@sevenoxia7199]

Good day when TD Wanderer uploads, nice to be here early to see some of the more underutilised rats get some more development/just last longer in the game. Idea: What If Team Victory was dissolved after Leshawna's elimination? I would like to see this because in the cast Team Victory were dissolved, I think Lindsay and DJ would get some proper development rather than being used for random gags like the Animal Curse or just... being dumb, so I would 100% love to see this one done.

[@thesplendidredengine05]

ZEKE GOT A HAPPY ENDING!!!!!!

[@sylveonmaster1205]

Tdwt: (in the shearing sheep ep) What if Cody didn't mix up his vote when he was dizzy.

[@gwens.diaryy]

Ideas

[@tdtheorys]

lol i literally suggested this today not knowing this would arrive lol

[@personalstory5178]

I would like to see a continuation of this to Total Drama All-Star cause I would feel that the dynamics change for a few characters and Dawn would be welcome as an All-Star. Replacing Sam, giving new Dawn interactions for Scott (former ally), Zoey, and Cam (friend and competitor).

[@dangthatsashortname7527]

I would of so much of rather this be the real season

[@CrushAugust]

Tricking her team with the fake idol? Genius, how do you come up with these ideas.

[@user-nt9yi3zf6k]

what if the team believed Dawn

[@Blackrunnerrising]

Here's a what if I bet not people have thought of: What if Sierra competed in Revenge of the Island instead of World Tour? The idea here is that, since Zoey was also a fan of Total Drama before she competed, we could have a Casual fan (Zoey) vs Hardcore Fan (Sierra) dynamic (and having even teams as a bonus), leaving Sierra out is simply a matter of adding her to Geoff's rescue team.

[@imjoker2823]

Future Idea- What if the team that won that week’s episode loss?

[@supermontythomas2159]

Idea: What if Heather didn't form the alience in Island, nice thumbnail btw

[@JustARandomGuy219]

She'd be voted out in Not Quite Famous

[@supermontythomas2159]

@JustARandomGuy219 but how would Heather be able to get Gwen's diary without the alience because Lindsay helped Heather get the diary

[@JustARandomGuy219]

@@supermontythomas2159 Sorry, I forgot about that part. Honestly, you make a good point.

[@supermontythomas2159]

@JustARandomGuy219 don't worry it's ok, tbh I really don't know what would have happened

[@JustARandomGuy219]

@@supermontythomas2159 ok :)

[@CloverPandaQ]

Also Brick wants to go to fashion school, i assume hed have fantastic cohesion.

[@IgnoreEverythingISay]

My God I love this thumbnail sm

[@TheDudeNerd]

What if in ROTI, instead of it going mostly from the order they came in on who's on which team, Jo and lightning got to pick their teams for being first

[@Pilotspie]

The dawn we never got 😔

[@MasterStartist5]

Video Idea: What If Ella Wasn’t Caught For Singing/What If Ella Didn’t Sing

[@jamisonisme5457]

I’m loving dawn having more “screen time “ ❤

[@TheMemeLordXD]

Idea: What if Mike never hid hiss multiple personality disorder? (TDROTI)

[@thearmchairgamer2668]

Here's a big one What if in Total Drama Revenge of the Island Camp Wanakwa wasn't filled with Toxic Waste

[@ThatsMyLime_TV]

I think Scott's plan would've made more sense if he was throwing challenges so we could handpick the good players to eliminate on his team to make merge easier. But I stead he was just trying to give the other team a "false sense of security"?

[@THSDropout]

What if Chris didn’t allow Sierra and Izzy to swap teams

[@SwaggyKitty101]

Honestly, I think I prefer this over the original 😂

[@VelvetteRose_doll]

I HAVE AN IDEA! What if Justin was an actually good antag in TDA?

[@TD_Heather4TW]

Idea: TDROTI: What If HEATHER didn't make a cameo? {It can be all the Gen 1 Cast not making cameos but it's up to you.}

[@WestbeachDevon]

What if there wasn’t a double elimination at the start off action?

[@cool-stuff11]

I got an idea: What if mal appeared in roti?

[@lechuguin3319]

What if idea: Courtney accepts Heather alliance in World Tour after the Gwuncan kiss

[@umbreon713]

TDA: What if the first elimination was only a single elimination or what if Bridgette/Geoff gathered the votes to eliminate Leshawna and save one of them?

[@SamuelDoherty]

What if all stars but scott had his roti personality and not his all stars one

[@scorpio1193]

Idea: what if heather embraced her nerdy side in world tour and made a genuine alliance with cody?

[@elliodh]

Not sure if you’ve watched the new season, but could you do what if the hockey bros never got med evac-ed and keep the castuary episode as a double elim?

[@pharaohfoxkhamen67x97]

Make a video of What If DJ did not touch the mummified dog?

[@mattspacc8570]

what if the winners of total drama island(owen and gwen ) get eliminited in episode 2 and 3 owen:got last in the awakeaton gwen:was so tired from last challenge that she didnt play letting herself eliminated edit:gwen lost the awakeaton to duncan

[@jabbajawz5273]

Idea: TDAS but there’s no team-swaps

[@andrewmartinez4176]

Td wonders idea: What if Beth never brought the curse statue from boney island?

[@olaf-chan-728]

43:47 i dont think she turns out to be commando zoey since she hasnt suffered that much here

[@blue_corn_man]

Honestly i just want anything involving Noah. What if team Amazon lost in Berlin? What if Noah was in Action? What if Noah… actually used his brains in Island?

[@jamsteranimations5582]

Idea: What if Cody didn’t get mauled by a bear?

[@Unvigintillionfan66]

Request: what if dj never quit in total drama action

[@LegoDrDoom]

What if Ezekiel never lost the stick in world tour

[@DropDeadOffical]

What if Gwuncan came before Duncney and it was Duncney that happened in world tour.

[@teamfly8379]

I would like to see a 2023 what if and I have 2 ideas What if Bowie never tried to eliminate Caleb What if Zee didn't try to eliminate Chris