TDI: What if Alejandro and Sierra were in Island? Part 2

What if in season 1 of Total Drama, Alejandro and Sierra debuted instead of in season 3?
PART 2
Tier list: tiermaker.com/create/total-dr...

[@chandelurewashedashore7557]

Why is this guy a better writer for this show then the actual writers

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

I agree tho

[@chosenofgaia2511]

Hate that you're right

[@maxchristopher4352]

Totally, He should work with the actual writers.

[@sameera.abdullah719]

I know, right? He's that good!

[@sameera.abdullah719]

​@@maxchristopher4352Exactly!

[@saltyricee]

I love how you gave Katie an actual character other than her whole character being obsessed with sadie

[@TDWonderer]

yeah, never really liked either of them or even thought about expanding them but saw the opportunity and figured it could be interesting, she was really fun to write for this season

[@saywhatnow24]

​@@TDWondererKatie is much more better to write than Sadie because she would have an good arc

[@gwyn3122]

To be honest, I would very much like to see the continuation of this in Action, and also if not only Alejandro and Sierra were added to the Action, but also the non-entered participants from the first season (Katie, Sadie, Tyler, Noah, Eva, Ezekiel, Courtney, Cody).

[@GenPocalipse]

Ezekiel… :(

[@austinwood2470]

I mean cody was kind of the main character of this one so he kinda has to be included, besides with the different relationships this time around it seems way more plausible hed be in the lake

[@gwyn3122]

@@GenPocalipse Oh, yes, I forgot about him at all, sorry

[@shellos31oeste72]

yes please 😭😭 @TDWonderer

[@garfieldeslazzannya6364]

Well it happened

[@cindy8966]

I would love a continuation of this for Action! You really understand the characters and how they would interact with one another and it's interesting to imagine this season playing out.

[@elitettelbach4247]

Really enjoyed the post merge! Cody convincing Heather to turn on Alejandro and him having a mini-badass arc were very cool plot points. Love that final two! And the explanations for the helper affiliations as well as the actual plot of the finale were so well conceived! Very satisfying. Would love to see a continuation of this canon. And yes I’ve chosen no sleep lol rip.

[@brianford4914]

Really liked this. Glad you had Heather betray Alejandro since it's way more likely. I'm a little sad that Heather didn't make it to the finals with Leshawna (I always thought Leshawna and Heather should have been the final 2 instead of Gwen and Owen), but it makes sense for her to get eliminated in the Final 3 since it's such an easy challenge to gang up on one person.

[@Joovo007]

its always feeling of dread when we get in to the episode "after the dock of shame" in a what if

[@dragonitematero]

I legit love how for every one of your What Ifs it’s like you randomly pick an undeveloped character and give it more focus despite them not being all that related with the main premise, like how having Alejandro here made Katie and Justin last longer and have more of a role in the story, while Sierra being here turned Cody into a main character I was actually rooting for.

[@-cookiez-]

I really liked this series! I loved how you still kept Heather as the OG villain instead of swapping her out for Alejandro. This was very well done and I can't wait to see if you're going to do Action. (P.S. I'd really like Eva to return and see her play a bigger role as an antagonist.) Good work!

[@redpandayt8758]

Loved the duo of Cody and Trent, the writing for this season was so awesome! really fun to watch!

[@trentsdandruff]

the trody is real

[@jadetheartist873]

If you do TDDDDI, I have a great idea for a duo, Ezekiel and Gwen. If you really think about it, they are sort of the outcast of the cast. Both of them are loners, and even though Gwen’s name would be cleared, people would most likely still be wary of her. So, with the promise that Ezekiel is respectful towards girls, Gwen teams up with him, and they could bond and become good friends.

[@mcsavage1846]

I would love to see an action version with Alejandro and Sierra along with Cody, Tyler, Katie, Sadie etc.

[@AznYunHou]

Awesome video!!! This also gives a good descent to a villain arc for Cody and really shows how he can actually make it to the top 4 and not just get carried in World Tour

[@lenameanslight2872]

The twists in this were reeaally well thought out. I don't know what pulled me back into TD recently, but I'm glad I stumbled upon this! If you drop another, I'm there

[@art_fright228]

The drama in action between Gwen and Trent is going to be huge

[@bayo1059]

I absolutely adore how you gave justice to some of these characters who went unappreciated in the org show

[@maricraft6969]

This what if was absolutely amazing! There’s so much I love about this alternative universe you made. Making characters like katie & sadie actually likeable, making alejandro & heather both antagonists while being unique from each other, making justin actually do things & have a personality, making sierra way better & far less creepy & annoying, & cody feeling like the protagonist of it all. The ships are also very enjoyable! It was nice to see lindsay & tyler get more focus & making the relationship between gwen & trent complicated. trent & leshawna are also great final 2. All around fantastic video! Your writing is so amazing & I would love to see a continuation of this in Action

[@okkshane]

OMG I absolutely love this! I love the development of Cody and Katie! I love the bond you explored with Heather and Cody, and Katie and Bridgette!!! Love this! Please continue this world in Action

[@CheshireKyle]

Very interesting for Lindsay, DJ, Geoff, and Heather to get eliminated in the same episodes as canon. Like a canon event lol

[@adamturek210]

Wow Alejandro actually got eleminated before Heather but I supposse people often overthink and all that scheming, planning is what actually caused his downfall. All he needed to do was chill while maintaing his friendly apperance and he could have won. I like the struggle the characters have between choosing of maintaing friendships while also wanting to win - especially Cody part. I said it before but you really created well crafted and engaging story.

[@slayyytersashtray]

I literally love this merge story sm and like u said, katie having an actual story to herself and more plotline was rlly fun watching and i think rlly worked well for her. And i was going to comment about a possible tda continuation but u said ur already thinking about it so i wont ask, just cant wait to listen to it if u choose to! Ty again for taking time to play out these rlly fun and good scenarios

[@LyokoGem]

Both of these were amazing and I'd love to see this go on to Action.

[@taroknight8464]

OKAYYYY CODY!!! Love Cody in world tour and I love how this actually fleshes out his capabilities, personality and his relationship with Heather which I’ve always felt was one of the most interesting dynamics never expanded upon

[@alexp.288]

You do a really great job of fleshing out ideas and subplots! Would genuinely love to see your take on Action in this universe

[@XXXmarquise]

What a plot twist! I truly believed it was going to be Heather being voted off instead of Cody, they were about to finally take her down. I thought Cody was going to win this for being the main player, and that was amazing. I always wanted Leshawna to win a challenge and that came true here. And Heather remaining the main antagonist and outlasting Alejandro made me happy, I enjoy her brutality much more. Also, the reason why Justin, Trent, and Owen are still sitting with Noah at the end of Dodgebrawl was due to them thinking he was a wuss for not playing. They all had angry glares on their faces, I think the writers just wanted to make Noah look inferior or emasculated to the other Gopher boys for not participating.

[@milanbeerepoot4260]

This merge honestly feels like a fan voted merge

[@Junyuzeng]

I mean it is voted by a fan

[@entymash]

Amazing just like every video so far! I like that you kept the bonding between Alejandro, Heather and Cody which definitely reminds me of WT. I'd love the see a continuation in TDA with similar characters dynamic, you can also include people like Cody and Tyler (if not everyone) who didn't make it in the season originally. Maybe you can develop a healthier or at least sane relationship between Sierra and Cody. Either way, I love your what if videos and I can't wait for the next one!

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! glad you enjoyed the video

[@JakesoontobeJack]

You can even give Trent and Gwen time to have discussions, and interact, therfore giving them time to build up their relationship.

[@RidleyKraid187]

Wow, literally immediately after I finished watching the first part!

[@jean-paul1767]

this was so good to the point that I was actually mad when Bridgette and Cody got voted out so close to the finale 😭😭

[@inimfonabasietuk617]

I will never stop being amazed at how fan write AUs for the show and it turns out better than the cannon show, this version of the show was better than island, I especially loved Cody and Sadie, they were my favorite characters in this rewrite, they had more character her than they even did in the show (except in world tour for Cody but I digress) and I look forward to more what ifs

[@billiejocrowl6214]

This guy makes the best total drama youtuber

[@TigerManRory]

seen this, instant reaction, 'YESSSSSSSSSSSSS' my sister is probably worried for my sanity..... Also, a what if similar to this that you could do is 'what if Everyone was in Action?' I also Love your Pahkitew Island What if as it gives the characters character development they deserve and I'd love to see a 'What If Sammy was eliminated in Twinning Isn't Everything' or What if Jasmine was eliminated in a Blast From The Past as she was worried about Shawn and not giving the challenge her all. You could even do 'What If Shawn was eliminated in A Blast From The Past as he was missing almost the whole challenge.

[@Nonya._.]

I love how fulfilling your endings are with these what ifs 😂 keep it up man 👍🏻

[@itsjustme8588]

I just finished watching both parts and wow, the characters and the stories were both really well written for a simple ‘what if’ plot. I enjoyed the fact you gave characters like Sadie, Katie and Cody having more development to their personalities. I also love Cody’s arc and him gaining friends then just being obsessed over Gwen the whole time (I also loved Sierra here, she feels more humane) and Katie and Sadie feels like real characters this time around. Heather betraying Alejandro was so cool, I was pretty happy that it was Cody who got Alejandro eliminated. Overall this was a very fun au and I might even prefer this over the original story lol.

[@AutumnPlains]

In regards to who is the least likely to do gross dares, I feel like that’d be Trent as he has an incredible weak stomach in the series. He was unable to handle a lot of gross foods by Chef and contently puked over things so I think he’d struggle in I Triple Dog Dare You. LeShawna is definitely more willing than Trent but even she has her limits as she gave up drinking the cockroaches against Owen. And since Heather in canon was shown to do every gross dare, it stands to argument she’d be the best dare taker until it came time for the head shaving.

[@AutumnPlains]

And since Owen isn’t there to accept every dare and hoard freebies, the element of one character having a lot of them would be removed since I imagine these 3 will keep passing dares among each other for the most part.

[@AutumnPlains]

Still a fantastic video, just wanted to toss my two cents on that particular moment :)

[@TDWonderer]

could definitely see what you're saying, but Trents kinda a weird character to analyze with this, if people wanna say that the finale is Heather and Leshawna then that's fine because it is kinda a toss up in that last challenge the challenge kinda brings into question peoples limits, since both Heather and Gwen did foul things to stay in the game and both of them have their scenes where they were skidish to do gross/exhausting things and even though Trent has his moments like at the Brunch of Disgustingness he still went through with it, so, personally, I feel like he could've made it (plus Heather might actually target Leshawna with her dares more since they had such a huge rivalry)

[@anchorsaway9500]

You really did a good job with Cody in this story. He was a true go getter and the MVP of this what if….maybe second to kattie

[@supermontythomas2159]

This was awesome thank you!😊

[@emiyes4667]

Interesting if I’m gonna stay up past 3 I might as well watch this

[@froggynico]

Omg both of these parts were amazing! You are very talented when it comes to storytelling. I do like the idea of having a sequel to this two part video with an action sequel. (:

[@Alliflowerr]

This video was amazing and so fun to watch! I love your storytelling and putting Leshawna my queen in the finals is obviously an extra + from me XD

[@AlexLovesArsenal]

The first part was honestly my favourite video of all time so I'm very exited for this

[@maxchristopher4352]

Once again amazing video, I'm so excited for another one. Suggestion : -What if everyone in from total drama island competed in Action and World tour (for action you could make one without Sierra and Alejandro as follow up to the canon universe of island and another with them as follow up for this video.) Or for Action you can first make one where they are in the season but with only the 15 contestants that were in the season and then the one where they're altogether.

[@oscarxmort]

was just finishing up the first one when this was posted! excited to watch. definitely a great what if 💓💓

[@TDWonderer]

thanks, glad you liked it

[@GothicPurple]

I like the Cody Bridgette friendship in Triathlon since they're kinda good friends as kids in dramarama but that's never explored in the main show lol

[@zekeathon]

Normally I just watch videos and don’t really subscribe, but honestly your dedication to this (and my love for total drama) has won me over, keep up the good work man

[@jadetheartist873]

This is a really good what-if! I originally wanted to make an idea like this, but I didn’t lol. I would actually like to see an Action, World Tour and even All-Stars with this, that would be really cool and would make my day! Also, I feel like a vengeful Courtney could be the main villain full time in Action, since Justin wouldn’t be a villain in this version of Action. Idk about World Tour.

[@rinrin5500]

Loved this part 2! I really enjoy the 2 finalist you chose, and you did a very great job on ending the season long storylines. I agree with some other commentors that if you would enjoy it, you should totally make an action and maybe even a world tour! It would interesting to see how these relationships push into other seasons (Esspically with storylines with Alejandro, and Gwen!)

[@niewiem2419]

Oh my god that was so good. I hope you will continue that storyline because action would be super interesting world tour as well

[@akashdude7672]

this video was amazing trent being my favorite character was always annoying because he was so lowkey and chill in season 1 then got ruined in action and then NEVER got a chance for a redemption

[@serenepastel]

This was a really good story! I’m glad this showed up in my recommended videos

[@cxmelkox3200]

Katy & lindsay would be such good friends in the show

[@marcelopulido5820]

Love your Videos man :)

[@TDWonderer]

thanks man :)

[@king.connzi]

I LOVE HOW CREATIVE YOU ARE FOR BITS OF STORIES AND STUFF

[@TDI279]

Nice to see my fav Trent make the finale! ❤ Btw this guy is a REALLY good at What ifs

[@TD_Scottyboi]

THE KINGS BACK LESS GOO

[@XSS.mm2]

This is the true ending the ending leshawna always deserved.. Her victory will be cherished

[@XSS.mm2]

Btw leshawna def clapping Trent in that final

[@Playandcatty]

I love this! You should make a follow up season of action, or just a what if action brought back all 22 campers

[@nateleslie2725]

I get the bike organization. I make a lot of AUs as well and one is if the Island competitors had to rack up points and there were no eliminations, and the extra amount of bikes REALLY throws everything off. Challenges get really confusing.

[@borahbros1664]

This is awesome! I’d love to see what if a different character joined the show instead of Courtney in TDA like Noah, Cody, or Geoff

[@heaterrrr]

These videos have me thinking about how Action and World Tour would play out if Alejandro and Sierra were in Island, because the only reason Alejandro got so far in World Tour was because he was new and no one knew what to expect from him so he was able to manipulate people more easily, and with Sierra I just think it would be nice to see Cody and Sierra's relationship when she isn't as creepy and stalkerish. I feel like those could be fun videos for the future. I've only very recently started watching your videos but they are very good and I've enjoyed them all so far🙏🙏

[@Ellipses02]

Something cool could be seeing how’d things go if they were both part of the action cast

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

I’m gonna watch this first thing in the morning, before having any breakfast, just to watch this

[@chrysanthosvice4867]

honestly???? cody in WGW is ICON behavior, he really said "let's pit these bad bitches against each other" and it WORKED. we stan.

[@RoundYellowThing]

My fave part of the video : leshawna being a finalist. Anyways I really liked how you thought this out and how much you changed the game just by adding two contestants!

[@MissAkechi]

I like how Katie was more important in this version of TDI and that Justin did more too. Justin x Katie is also a good ship in my opinion given the dynamic you gave them. I was sad to see Katie go but I didn’t see her making it to the finals. I also like that Trent has made it far. Feel really bad for Gwen

[@Blueberry-wn5fc]

Alejandro's elimination was bs. In world tour, he is shown to have affinity with animals, thus, the chipmunk would be easy to "control". In addition, Heather only eliminated him because she knew she could win against Cody & Sierry, however, now she is in a position with no alliance members, thus, putting her in a bad position.

[@aMxx-]

not gonna lie. It’s crazier to think how world tour plays out because the biggest thing about alejandro was that unlike heather, nobody knew he was evil in that season. If the cast knew by world tour that he was evil I think the whole season plays out differently

[@YayerSlayer2012]

Request: What if Dave did not vote himself

[@albatrossthedragon]

What if Eva didn’t lose her MP3 player?

[@Hohhot]

I love a 3-2-1 vote. Thanks for that

[@CrushAugust]

I chose no sleep? 😂 bet. I like what you did with Cody's character, he became a more or less good player towards the end. The romance between Justin and Katie surprised me, but it was def interesting. Looking forward to more videos, mayne 🤩

[@Shybandicoot1518]

It's 3 am Oh look part 2 of what if total drama let's goooooo

[@totaldramajoseph146]

Just been binge watchijg alll of your vids recently and you have an amazing channel !!! 🙌 I hope you get more subscribers I have a what if What if nichelle won it for her team in episode 3 ? Or What if duncan never retuned in world tour

[@edwinoliveros4863]

I was just checking to see if Part 2 was uploaded :0

[@V11Galactic]

It was so awesome that you added them to the plot without making them the center of everything but making them have a lasting lmpact Personality id like to see a Heather vs cody ending or trent vs cody ending but i think how cody got eliminated was actually really good so in total 10/10 plot

[@jakubwiktor5874]

i feel happy that cody gets THIS FAR!!

[@EspaALSC]

wooow, please make a continuation as to how the dynamics would play out in action following the events of this season!

[@Gwen1661]

I need that continuation like yesterday

[@happypika3]

If I had a nickel for everytime Bridgette was eliminated in After the Dock of Shame, I would have 2 nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it makes sense that it happened twice.

[@Elwasamusic]

Ideas: 1. What would have happened if the sisters had not caused the elimination of the best friends in the amazing race? 2. What Would Happen If The Reality Experts And The Sisters Never Make An Alliance? 3. What if The Sisters Came Second In Awesome Race?

[@midnightp2241]

Heyyy nice video must've taken a long timee 😊

[@xinyi4397]

Tbh I'm so so sooooo happy that aleheather is cannon tdi writers should hire him

[@cinnamaow]

an action continuation would be awesome!! esp with the non-competitiors, actually competing

[@ZoPoj]

now please do what if Izzy get to stay in Total Drama World Tour (as smart person)

[@aliherbert6453]

You should continue this AU into action

[@TDWonderer]

👍

[@Justheredoingmything]

24:42 I like how you used the Alejandro comforting m {I forgot his name so I’ll just call him “M”} thing but with Cody comforting Alejandro, I felt like when that happened before {talking about all stars} it kinda ruined Alejandro’s character, like he wouldn’t confront M, he usually keeps to himself except for mostly Heather but he said his whole plan to M, the person he’s targeting, also it shows M being a overpowered villain which I hate- But it makes sense for Cody standing up for himself and confronting ale, also Ale is strong so it makes sense for him to break his wrist-

[@thomask4538]

Good job. Kinda glad you gave constant changes to a unique story. Only thing I would say that constrains effect was Bridgette due to her being booted in such a weird way. Writers were so wack that episode. But the Alejandro and Cody dyamic was great.

[@totaldramatdmw-td.]

Yes the part 2 btw r u gonna do action and world tour ik I already asked but the part 2 is so good

[@booy3763]

I honestly hope you do action next I think you'd be very interesting to see how action could work with Alejandro and Sierra. And especially with the kind of a cliffhanger type of ending with Trent and Gwen.

[@plzzaboy222]

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE MAKE A TDA PART 2 OF THIS, I WOULD REALLY WANNA SEE WHAT DYNAMICS THAT WOULD HAPPEN IN TDA

[@havikrogers1801]

This was a great continuation from the first part. I liked how you went over the plot, like the Cody and Alejandro plot line, is Cody evil, the Katie and Bridgette drama. The only problem I really had is DJ kinda just exists and he never felt like he did anything. Other then that, great video (also, Disventure Camp what ifs sound pretty cool, so you could also do that for future videos). Also, I love that two characters I really like made it to the finale. Edit: Also, what do you plan to make the next what if be?

[@JakesoontobeJack]

Idea for a Disventure Camp/Adventure Camp: What if Lake actually made it to sunrise? What if Riya never found the advantage? What if Maggi won the tiebreaker? What if Fiore was never exposed? What if Ellie didn't betray Tom and Jake? What if Lake won invincibility in the final part of the challenge by completing the ring toss against Hunter? What if Riya didn't betray Rosa? What if Riya didn't expose James? What if Rosa never warned Hunter about Aiden, Riya, and James ganging up on Jake?

[@jakew6162]

@@JakesoontobeJack What If Yul and James successfully poisoned Aiden What If Grett didn’t stole Drew notebook

[@MrMixedGamer]

Just chiming in to say id also love to see your take on action in this scenario as well :) if you dont wanna i get it but i think itd be fun!

[@-Gamerly-]

Now we need more parts for the next seasons

[@Rias-sl6fq]

Yet another great video! I think it would be interesting if you did, what if heather didn’t take Eva’s mp3 player. Eva is clearly a strong competitor so heather getting her eliminated makes sense but if heather didn’t take it then Eva would progress further having a bigger threat in the game. Just an idea though

[@AmberIsSolo]

Yesss finally 🎉

[@amcuevas]

The reason they all thought it'd be a vote for the winner is because it's based off of survivor, where they do that.

[@TDWonderer]

i know, I said this is in my last Island what if video (What if Ezekiel wasn't sexist) and didn't really wanna repeat the survivor thing word for word again so just summarized

[@flourrrr]

56:15 i'd argue that ezekiel would actually pick leshawna over trent, hear me out: zeke was taught to believe women were inferior, he was also told to protect the women by his parents, which in his wt biography, he doesn't understand because "they're all stronger than him" i think leshawna is anything but a dainty/tradtional woman, so i feel like ezekiel would ultimately respect this because it is a fresh breath of air and different from what he was taught also because of the fact that ezekiel tends to favor and interact with more dominant/authoritative characters (chris, his parents) though i do understand he was put there to balance out the helper ratio, so i understand this decision

[@shellos31oeste72]

This writing is so much better than the original goddammit

[@Totalwerido]

Trent and leshawana deserved the finale two

[@evil778]

I think in "Are We There, Yeti?", Heather voted for Duncan and Gwen voted for Owen, and Chef was the tiebreaker. There isn't any solid proof for it, but it is extremely likely. Heather would've voted Duncan because he's stronger and Gwen would choose Owen because I think she was closer to Duncan. Chef would've obviously chosen Duncan because Duncan messed with Chef. But if there's any proof against this, go ahead and let me know.