TDI: What if Alejandro and Sierra were in Island? SPECIAL

What if in season 1 of Total Drama, Alejandro and Sierra debuted instead of in season 3?
SPECIAL EPISODE
Tier list: tiermaker.com/create/total-dr...

[@serenepastel]

The Zeke and Gwen friendship wasn’t something I thought I needed, but it was really sweet. The vibe in the same way Team E-Scope vibes

[@Airitzu]

This is gonna be a really good series if you decide to make an Action What If with Sierra and Alejandro. It has all the essential characters that can be developed more, and gives characters like Gwen and Trent more time to interact. Great video all around though!

[@randomname1924]

Courtney is naturally bossy but Duncan certainly played a part in making her more aggressive and rule defying. It makes a lot more sense for her to go full beast mode like in Action if she was the first boot in Island tho. Also I love the “it’s not gay if we wear socks” friendship between Owen, Tyler and DJ. It just makes so much sense

[@cindy8966]

These videos are like comfy viewing to me, they're oddly soothing yet engaging. It's really easy to get lost in the 'What if?'

[@TDWonderer]

thats nice to hear, glad my videos can be nice for you to watch!

[@alliumrose6862]

I feel like Ezekiel should have made it since he was with gwen the whole time he would've probably just followed her so he could keep hanging out with her not realizing that she was actually chasing the briefcase and would just fall into the water with her and trent. Plus narratively it fits since he is gwen's only real "friend" and would be a good way to develop the gwen and trent storyline.

[@TDWonderer]

gwen and ezekiel aren't like... how do i say this.... best friends? they're friends from this episode but this episode exclusively. they aren't super duper close and i don't see them sharing a braincell like lindsay and beth. also since they had the talk about trent where they both stayed silent afterwards i imagine they aren't really engaging with each other that much after that. plus I just really don't see ezekiel being quick witted enough to realize whats happening, since he didn't have a fair chance in the original to go for the briefcase I obviously can't say with 100 percent certainty that he wouldn't but i do have a lot of scenes in mind where ezekiel isn't exactly a quick thinker so I just didn't really feel the most comfortable with giving a spot

[@alliumrose6862]

@@TDWonderer that's a fair take on it. I kinda thought about it sorta as just a beard mentality where he would just see a lot of people going somewhere and just be like "okay guess we are doing this now" and follow everyone near by the cabins. Looking at it with your thoughts in mind it does make a fair bit of sense just to leave him out all things considered. Who knows maybe this semi-friendship with gwen could play a role in a possible world tour what if, but that's would be thinking way to far ahead for anyone to think of now especially when the part/parts about action aren't even out yet. All and all really looking forward to your take on this upcoming action what if👍👍

[@TotalDramaEthan]

I’m so happy cody made the cast since he’s my favorite character in the show, and honestly I think that the cast that was decided was overall pretty good, but personally I would have given Leshawna a guarenteed spot since she was the winner/runner up of the season so it would make since for her to be in the next, and if I remember correctly, all the people from at least the top 9 of the original show made it to action. At the same time though I understand why you did the random wheel, and that was probably the way to determine who would make it when it came to the diving board. Honestly I liked this video a lot more then I thought, I even voted no in the poll asking for it, but yeah, good job! Can’t wait for the actual season!

[@-Gamerly-]

Yeah, everyone in the top 11 made it to action

[@Geopez]

I agree, but imagine Leshawna having a storyline similar to Courtney's but this time is more justified, and people do like her so I honestly think that gives a really good oportunity there

[@Wellratedcharacther]

Honestly he shoulve have put leashwana instead of Courtney since Courtlney sued her way in to get in action but that leashwana isnt there now nobody can take Courtney spot

[@Gwen1661]

This was a fun experiment! And the cast for TDA in this AU is so different with some new faces thrown in that seeing a full season play out would be fascinating. You don't have to do it if you don't want to, but it would be fun.

[@TDWonderer]

dont worry, im gonna. already finished writing the first 3 episodes of action in fact!

[@audreybsullivan84]

@@TDWondererWOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@happypika3]

​@@TDWondereromg

[@jeremycel3032]

I love this. Sadie and Gwen needs their redemption arc!!!

[@Dalubussyquakin]

Can’t wait to see Actions. Curious if Gwen will get her arc of being debunked as a weirdo or even if Justin throws for Katie similar to Trent throwing for Gwen. Maybe even Katie & Justin will do the aftermath instead of Geoff and Bridgette (just a theory) Also kinda curious (if World Tour happens) to see if Eva, Noah & Izzy (team E-Scope) happens.

[@TDWonderer]

interesting you mention Katie and Justin hosting the aftermath, it was an idea that played around with and is something i'll make sure to elaborate on in the next video

[@spann7796]

This was a really fun video! The Island special has always been one of my favorite episodes, having a good mix of character interactions and competition, as well as having new character dynamics like Harold/Heather and Ezekiel/Beth&Lindsay. Only thing I’d say is that I feel like if someone on the diving board made it into Action originally, they should here. That would end up with a gender imbalance with too many women not in Action, but then I’d say that’s where you should’ve used the wheel to determine if Geoff, Owen, or DJ didn’t make the cast. But outside of that one nitpick, really cool idea, and I’m excited for a potential season 2

[@TDWonderer]

yeah i guess that would've made more sense for following the original, I just had a lot of grips with following the original since there was no rhyme or reason to lot of things that happened

[@spann7796]

No, I get that totally. I remember the first time I watched that episode I literally leaned forward and stared at the screen when Cody and Tyler somehow fell out of the unbreakable knot.

[@niewiem2419]

I actually preffer what he did because at least we have a chance to see some characters who were less developed in original like katie and sadie and not the same storylines with the same characters

[@spann7796]

Yeah, to each their own, it just feels weird having one of the main characters/winners of participate in the next season

[@lupin5489]

That wheel couldn’t have gone better, pretty sure all of them have story potential based on the changes made during the what if. Also removes the Bridgette/Geoff and DJ story lines completely

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

And the Leshawna storyline

[@liltaymoneyway]

YERRR HEATHER IS ON THE CAST AND SO IS ALEJANDRO WE WON AND QUEEN SADIE GETS DEVELOPMENT

[@SummerSideStories]

I'm super excited for this next season if I had to pick a character I'm excited for the most weirdly it's Sadie she has a plot that can be explored with drifting away from Katie and gaining independence which I hope to see. Also now there are more people meaning less non eliminations. The last thing I want to point out is how chef's alliance will play out my guess is Al will get it as it makes the most sense l.

[@ContradictoryKevin]

I really liked this. Ezekiel getting a friend is always welcome, he deserved better. Also, I could see the diving board scene be like the FID debut reveal scene, where the four who didn't make the cast end up falling off the board, so there's that. All in all, I'm excited for TDA with the World Tour debuters, I really like these in-depth what ifs, and you're cool. Good day.

[@ulp2020]

It would be really cool if you were able to rewrite Trent's OCD in season 2 in a way that works. Maybe that's how he is able to connect with Gwen

[@Zoroarkarceus123]

This actually was really interesting, mainly in how the changed circumstances affected the teams' dynamics all around. I do think Zeke should have made the cast, if only because he and Gwen are friend-ish and though he's oblivious, he has shown here to want to help Gwen and would likely chase after her solely to make sure she's okay. That is just my reasoning though, and they can probably re-explore their friendship in the Aftermaths or in WT. I never really noticed just how many people were kinda unfairly shafted from the cast via plot holes. Honestly, it was pretty cool to see, banger video as always.

[@PEACHiiMio]

I am super excited to see your Action "what-if"/series. I love that Katie and Sadie are gonna be in it and it didn't sound like they really patched things up ? So I hope to see them do so in the season. I like that some characters who I felt didn't really get a lot of development in the original series get more development in your series.

[@mamamiaawoodenboy]

2nd video of TDWT: What if Beth had joined in Aftermath Aftermayhem instead of Blaineley?

[@tinopulkka956]

15:33 I don't know why but that little Justin confessional just made me laugh

[@eriklin9541]

This is actually a good cast because off the people cut, only maybe Ezikiel would or could have major a character arc in Action (maybe proving he no longer wants to be sexiest) DJ had one, but still ended up quitting. Geoff and Bridgette get out first, and Beth did a little, but she didn’t do much. The others are probably completed, also when Bridgette, Geoff, DJ, and leshawna were on the diving board they were hugging each other right after Duncan was thrown off the moose. So it would make sense for them to be stuck together. But Five people fell off the diving board, not four. So an extra character might not have made the cast in this universe. (But let’s just say only four fell off in this universe) A cast of: Alejandro Cody Courtney Duncan Gwen Harold Heather Izzy Justin Katie Lindsay Owen Sadie Sierra Trent And Tyler Will be interesting. Sucks that LeShawna won’t be here, but atleast she won’t be hated by everyone from talking shit about them. I guess I’ll have to stay tuned for more Total.. Drama… ACTION, but if Alejandro and Sierra were in Island!!!

[@Seijohs_Manager]

I am so engaged in this storyline thank you for making this holy shit Sierra and Alejandro are two of my favorite characters of all time hense why world tour is my favorite season so seeing a storyline where there is more of them especially with their duo counterparts (ie Heather and Cody) makes me giddy and smile and i genuinely want this story canon rather then the main one lmao I can not wait for action and i garentee you will probably make me like action because in the original i did not Keep up the great work you deserve so much more views and appreciation 🙏

[@twick_original]

This makes me so excited for the what if season 2, take your time to make it!! love your videos and watched them all:)

[@TDWonderer]

thanks :)

[@mdincorporated]

Another great video! Glad to see other people talk about this show, loved watching it in my childhood and even now in adulthood.

[@user-nt9yi3zf6k]

I love this and DJ and Chef alliances can't happen, can't wait for action

[@happylol6179]

It’s was a very good season with Sierra and Alejandro. Also, my idea:What if Scary Girl gave her skull to Chris immediately?

[@summerlee00]

these videos are so good! I seriously couldn’t wait for the next what if sierra and Alejandro were in tdi! Keep up the great content!!

[@jadetheartist873]

Thank you so much for doing this! While the teams weren’t were I expected, but it was a pleasant surprise. The plots of Gwen and Ezekiel (did you get that idea from me, just curious), and Sadie being distant. Maybe without Leshawna, Heather and Harold would actually become friends! If I had to pick a nitpick, I would let Zeke in the cast to explore him and Gwen’s friendship, but that could be done if you do World Tour, I hope you do! But anyways, great video, and I can’t wait for this version’s Action!

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

He’s not deciding the cast, he’s going off of what he thinks would actually happen

[@TDWonderer]

i had the idea for gwen and ezekiel when I first considered making this video, but it was really cool though to see you call it before it happened so props on doing that!

[@7-BIT]

21:15 Since Courtney got eliminated earlier, would the pool of green jelly still be there?

[@TDWonderer]

no, technically not, but this is what I meant when I said I tried not to think/stress too much on this what if, because if i tried to write this without the pool of green jelly there I would be so lost on how to make the cast / if a cast could even be made

[@ballzcorps5146]

Love this video! You really do make these what-ifs engaging and I had a great time watching it! I did have a good What If for ya! What if Izzy and Katie didn't switch teams?

[@Literally_Claudia]

im so happy katie and sadie made it lol

[@havikrogers1801]

Pretty good video. I liked the cast you ended up choosing, especially the early boots getting in. If you make another one of these epilogs for a future Island what if (or What If Ezekiel wasn't sexist), the people who end up on that board above the green jelly, I would base it entirely on who has the most story potential which thankfully are the people that ended up making it. The only thing that sucks is Beth isn't in the season, since I like her, but since they're other's with more story potential, I'm fine with it (I'm also sad about Noah, but he didn't do anything in the What-if).

[@samuel_o9]

When i saw the video in my nodification i immediately click on the video I LOVE YOUR WHAT IFS ❤❤

[@TDWonderer]

THANKS ❤️❤️

[@midnightp2241]

Omg this is so good ik u worked super hard 👏 love the ending

[@babyyodafan573]

I don't know if you take requests but here's an idea for a video, "Tdpi if Sammy didn't trick people" which has Sammy not trick people that she's Amy during her elimination, whether she didn't do it or she failed (even if you happen to not make this I still think it's a good idea)

[@TDWonderer]

I do take requests and this an idea that has been thrown around my comment section a lot and i really like it! im pretty sure this is what my next pakhitew island video will be about

[@moxxieluvsu]

I absolutely love your videos, hearing all the different possibilities really makes you think about it. I was wondering if you've ever thought about what would happen if all the characters were eliminated in reverse? For example if Gwen or Owen was voted out first/second, heather 3rd etc. I'd love it if you could cover this

[@thebois6651]

There actually a blog on the total drama wiki on this

[@elitettelbach4247]

This was still a fun ride even though as you said it was a bit superfluous. But thanks for doing it anyway! Makes it feel more complete.

[@rinrin5500]

I think this was a really intresting vid! I just liked hearing what scenes from the original stayed the same, and which got changed, and who got on the cast. IDK I just like hearing about this alternate version of what could've happened, and hearing some of the build up for potential storylines in action!

[@niewiem2419]

oh my god that was so funny to watch! And the cast we will get in action is so good, I just can't wait!

[@Rias-sl6fq]

I really like this new cast, I’m a little sad that Leshawna didn’t make the cast but it was random so there wasn’t much you could do about it

[@fatcatsdotcom2194]

5 days after the last one! Youre doing great and i love ur vids!

[@Playandcatty]

I’m glad all the relevant people made it in. The action what if should be great!

[@kayke5714]

PLS MAKE A ACTION OF THIS

[@LovesVelvette_Cakes128]

WHY IS EZEKIEL SO MUCH BETTER NOW!!! God tbh I wished this is how it went instead

[@liv3172]

2 videos in a week??!!! holyshit ur literally my fav td content creator

[@phatdaddy7502]

I love ur videos man keep it up!

[@TDWonderer]

thanks man, i will!

[@Tiny33boom]

Thought the special will be in the next video of the what if and yay you made playlists🎉🎉🎉

[@whatfrog7357]

I absolutely love your videos!!! Especially the way you write characters (Mostly Sadie Katie and justin) . But I would love to see Justin still kinda be an antagonist in action. I'm not sure if that would work (especially cuz Alejandro is there) or if Justin will end just end up how trent did. but again don't really know how that would work cuz Trent would still have the obsession with the number 9 . I also would love to see what you do with Courtney and Duncan considering they're not a couple yet!!! Also I'm very interested that DJ didn't make the cut for action cuz now that leaves an alliance with chef to someone else

[@ericgymfan]

I think given in this what-if that Leshawna didn't make the cast for TDA, that she would be able to get in mid-season like Courtney did by threatening a lawsuit. I don't think it's unrealistic for her character to demand that sort of justice and Chris wouldn't be too opposed to letting her on at that point because she is entertaining.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

That could work but what would she use as a justification? She can’t say she was robbed of the money since she agreed to the challenge

[@soggymcgee]

sierra's definitely my favourite this is great

[@BlackSheep_777]

An idea for a world tour what if: what if team victory disbanded before Lindsay and DJ were eliminated?

[@maxchristopher4352]

Great video bro.

[@cdawg856]

YES THIS IS AMAZING

[@ment6480]

I love you, TD Wonderer

[@td_beardo9999]

Idea-What if Gwen won the tie in world tour so what if Cody actually did vote Courtney

[@cameroncahill4613]

great video man, i have an idea for a short video in TDAS What if chris didn’t change the challenge last minute in sundae muddy sundae so Courtney would’ve won immunity and she wouldn’t get voted out

[@heather_foreather]

YEAHHH TOTAL DRAMA ACTION CAST CHOICE WHAT IF THAT WAS SO GOOD YEAHHH

[@WitheredGoat]

A few ideas: -What if Trent didn’t go crazy for Gwen -What if B (Beverly) didn’t get framed by Scott -What if max had stayed in the game after scarlet got eliminated

[@CrushAugust]

I did enjoy the video and am more or less happy with the cast that got into TD Action. I agree this was fun and interesting, but not too important. Can't wait for the next video ✊🏿

[@joshuahemme3841]

I can't wait to see World Tour I wonder what type of differences Alejandro and Sierra will bring to the season.

[@froggynico]

This was a fun episode. It was very fun 😭

[@CowboyMikeShow]

Ezekial Redemption Arc

[@Psyco-leon]

I LOVE THE FACT KATIE AND SADIE GET DEVELOPMENT

[@courtney.sat3lla]

love the what if but also since courtney didnt sue her way on it might mean we get a actual relationship between duncney and courtney in action in this universe cause courtney was booted first in this univereses island 🤔

[@MadMadBob]

Love the vid

[@legendiam5536]

i really love your videos they are really the best i want to ask tho can you do “if heather was nice” i want to see what would happen to the main plot since she was the main antagonist and i want to see what happened too her but please still make her spoiled since that’s one of her main characteristics :)

[@PumpkinFox]

You know, your view on this part of the what if... actually kind of represents the original special. Funnily enough, the special doesn't really do anything for the entire time except for show us who's going to be part of the cast of the next season which... really doesn't feel necessary to know why? I don't know, I feel like the feeling here would be about the same no matter what.

[@youraltaccount2081]

What if Zeeke returned in I see London?

[@thebois6651]

This was a great vid as alway and I can’t wait for the action vid to come out but I have two questions. Are you going to cover the aftermaths and non elimination episodes because they don’t move the story?

[@leonierawbone6576]

Video Idea. What if Harold never rigged the votes

[@Pichu726]

I just subscribed

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! 👍

[@smashuniverse459]

What if Harold never quit in Total Drama world tour?

[@td_beardo9999]

This would be so good

[@lraerc]

my girl courtney needs some redemption ill actually cry

[@bugad1nho]

It would be cool to have Zeeke on the cast in this universe he could make friendship with Gwen

[@woahbuncherz]

I know you might not make this, but something I think about a lot but haven’t seen anywhere, what If dj joined team amazon (or team Chris). My reasoning is that heather and Alejandro were both trying to get dj to form an alliance with them since he was the last on his team, and since he was the last one on his team, I think it’s only fair that he joins another team to make it fair.

[@TDWonderer]

i've thought about this one before and plan to get around to doing sometime, just been really busy lately

[@woahbuncherz]

@@TDWondererWell I’m looking forward to it! Either way I’ll be here to see it!

[@smorelove4017]

an idea for all stars for a what if is: what if courtney didn’t make lindsey push the stroller?

[@mrwomp1918]

You should also do a continuation like this for the ezikiel not being sexist what if

[@tropicalfruit56]

I love this cast for Action sm in this au. Owen and izzy can have their plotline, Gwen gets her redemption, and Sadie gets to do more ig. I'm also happy Geoff and Bridgette don't get their weird make out thing, also dj wouldn't accept the chef alliance. Now I really only have a problem with one thing in the cast. Leshawna was a finalist but got short sided, I think Courtney doesn't deserve her spot in the cast, although she very well could debut by suing saying that it was unfair to let ppl compete in a new season based on who is in the water at the ending or smth. 1/4

[@tropicalfruit56]

Now for storylines I think chef could ask izzy for an alliance, like originally, and she accepts it. Now I never liked the whole chef thing with dj because I don't think it's really in dj's character to do so but I think izzy would very well take chef on this offer (and wouldn't leave the game). For possible team I came up with: Well first of all for the two first boots of the season I chose Sadie and Justin, my reasoning is that Sadie and Justin would fight so much over Katie that it would start to annoy everyone, probably including Katie. For team captains however I thought Alejandro and Heather would be pretty funny as their relationship is muddy as they on kinda on and off together. Heather goes first and choses Cody; they were pretty close in the last episodes. Alejandro is a bit insulted because Cody got him eliminated last season so Alejandro picks Leshawna; not only was Leshawna Heather's rival but Al was also Leshawnas helper. 2/4

[@tropicalfruit56]

Then Heather choses Sierra; Cody might want Heather to chose Gwen here but Heather knows Gwen would want to get her out as soon as possible. Alejandro then picks Harold; I would think Harold made up with Al a bit because Harold did rig the voted against Duncan plus Leshawna wanted Harold on her team. Heather choses trent; obviously. Alejandro picks kacy next; kacy was good friends for Leshawna and out of her, Lindsay, or izzy, I think it's a clear choice. Heather then choses Gwen here; Cody probably makes a promise to Heather that they won't vote her off based on what she did last season if they let Gwen on the team, Heather agrees. Alejandro picks Tyler next; out of Owen (who he didn't like that much), Duncan who he didn't interact with plus Duncan doesn't really follow orders that well, I feel like he would just chose Tyler. 3/4

[@tropicalfruit56]

Heather choses duncan; for one she wants to make Alejandro mad by letting Owen on his team, second Trent remembers Duncan from the boathouse and wants to befriend him. Alejandro picks Lindsay; kinda simple, Lindsay and Tyler threw challenges last season to see eachother so Alejandro decides not to separate them this time. So that leaves Heather with izzy and Alejandro with owen; I'm sad Owen and izzy didn't end up on the same team but izzy does rejoin pretty early on and might comeback on Owen's team 🤷‍♂️ 4/4 (Ps I encourage u to use my ideas if u want to) (I would be so honored lol 😭)

[@fatterplatter3029]

TD Wonderer uploading a new video in middle of me watching his previous video?? What are the odds??

[@LedybruhGuy]

tyler made it 🥳

[@SynthIsBored]

Video idea: What if Beth never picked up the tiki?

[@MrmonkeMonke-qy6fm]

What if Blaineley never accidentally won the come back in world tour?

[@IDK-kx5lh]

You should do a video on if Ezekiel didn’t feed team Victories stick to a crocodile in TDWT

[@yes2081]

A cool video idea I had in mind would be What if Katie and Sadie never went on the same team

[@PTUBE101_]

You need to do World tour and then All Stars after Action

[@OfficalSliceOfYT]

Day 1 of asking for you to make a what if Harold never sacrificed himself in TDWT

[@user-lh2xk8mx6g]

The video 🔥

[@JakesoontobeJack]

Owen is actually bi, since he likes Izzy and Justin. But now everything changes in Action.

[@luigi4life913]

What if Ella wasn't eliminated for singing

[@Gacha_elanaXX]

IDEA: what if Katie and Sadie were never on the same team?

[@KearnylJelo]

If you still continue it to Season 2 I would hope if you can continue it to Season 3 too! Since this timeline is actually very entertaining!

[@ElPsySneak]

I think it makes more sense to go by weight instead of a randomness to decide who gets in at the end. Owen and DJ got in while Tyler/Cody didn't so that seems to be what decided their fate

[@havikrogers1801]

But Bridgette is pretty light, and she was able to make it.

[@sirsquishymittens807]

LLKE A HOUR AGO I WAS GONNA BEG FOR TDA WITH SIERRA AND ALEJANDRO

[@dylanjohnson3346]

Celebrity man hunt next lol

[@Barrack_obesity]

PLZ MAKE A VID ON WHAT IF THEY WHEN TO ACSION

[@blackbear7966]

I’ve been thinking about this what if in my head for a while now, but what if Scarlett wasn’t evil

[@shellos31oeste72]

PLEASE MAKE AN ACTION WITH THIS TIMELINE

[@futureclubexampleturned1343]

What if Heather manage to fool Lindsay agian by faking her apologies in TDA? pleaseeee

[@zippytheduck2062]

You know video is good when Izeikeil is shown to have genuine emotions

[@Rubytheninja-qe7qb]

U mean Ezekiel

[@alittlechese2567]

Could you make a TDI what if with Katie and Sadie staying on different teams? I feel like they’d get further in this case.