TDA: What if Lindsay didn't vote herself?

What if in season 2 of Total Drama. Lindsay didn't accidentally vote herself?
Tier list: tiermaker.com/create/total-dr...

[@GenZealous]

“What if Lindsay didn’t vote herself” The show would be saved.

[@heather_foreather]

This show you need to save This show you have to tell This show that you care Jamaica they're trapped down in Jamaica they can't even Japarty it's so unfair

[@fabriziov.p4475]

And Lindsay finally win the season

[@successfulsomewhat]

Duncan had the craziest plot armor in TDA

[@kevinasare4178]

He had like 1 save, and honestly the self vote was such a Lindsay thing to do.

[@liveandletdie22]

Still not as bad as Heather’s plot armor in Island.

[@ionut2751]

​@Defiant Singer nah, way worse leshawna elimination was also out of character of owen and made only for duncan to stay

[@liveandletdie22]

@@ionut2751 You could say the exact same thing about Heather, Gwen and Owen. And anyway, Duncan was eliminated next after Leshawna, so no, he didn’t receive plot armor in island.

[@SpookyMertilo]

​@@kevinasare4178 Justin, Leshawna, Lindsay and Harold elimination, they force to eliminate this characters for Duncan win

[@kurtmill9080]

I find it interesting that in your alternate history of TDA that Lindsay not voting herself off accidentally, leads to the remaining episodes being so heavily focused on cheating, deceit and reconciliation. It makes for a much better resolution to the season than what we got. I applaud your creativity.

[@youraveragenickel2177]

Okay, I did not expect that Mutiny on the Soundstage rewrite. That was actually so good and genuinely unexpected since most other what ifs would take the obvious route and have Harold and Lindsay make the final two instead. I also love how you had actual jury questions for the finalists instead of what they did in canon. This was really good!

[@TDWonderer]

thank you kindly

[@heatherssunglasses8313]

Heather congratulating Courtney In her ending would be so cute especially since they only had a couple interactions in island and action and they would be less enimies in world tour and even all stars

[@a.jdeets5527]

I want a Courtney and Lindsay final 2 so bad.

[@pistincup352]

So Lindsey had a really great possibility of winning Action if she never voted herself out

[@dylanjohnson3346]

Best final 3 ever wouldve made action so much better

[@CrushAugust]

dude, honestly love your videos. I always find them entertaining and they're so well written

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! I try to put a lot of thought in them so im glad you can find value in them

[@allexx2474]

This guy is the best at these ngl

[@TDWonderer]

thanks i try my best

[@justarandomperson976]

Okay i loved this sm! It was unexpected since in most what ifs with this it’s usually just Lindsay Vs Harold this was actually unexpected and i loved it!

[@TDWonderer]

thank you kindly

[@pepsicannot]

unexpended? the finale is the most popular pick i have ever seen

[@Hearts_for_Ellie]

Nah most ppl just pick Lindsay vc Harold for what if’s

[@lcc1221]

New idea(s): "What if team chris had won in i see london?" "What if Beth had joined instead of Blainley?" "What if Owen voted heather instead of justin?" "What if Justin won immunity instead of courtney?" "What if Owen didnt return?" "What if Beth didnt take the cursed idol?" "What if Ezekiel returned instead of duncan?" Thats most of my ideas.

[@sirdathale]

What if Harold never quit?

[@entymash]

My suggestions: TDA: What if Owen didn't have an eating disorder in episode 13 and helped his team win resulting in Courtney joining the Gaffers? TDWT: What if Heather was normally eliminated in episode 8? I think Chris would swap the elimination rounds since those weren't decided originally, making episode 9 a non-elimination and so on. ROTI: What if Scott was in the Maggots from the beginning? I know there's no realistic way for this to happen, but Chris picked the teams pretty random originally, so maybe this would work. I just think it would be interesting to see if Scott kept sabotaging the team too and what the elimination order would be. TDAS: What if Cameron was normally eliminated in episode 5? A lot of things don't make sense in AS and there are not many what ifs to discuss, but I think this one would affect Sierra's eliminations and the next few episodes.

[@larstem2080]

It ain’t an eating disorder, he’s just fat

[@nicks.857]

Your alternative versions are so good, you are really creative. I love that you go more indeph than and tell your own story. And can we just agree that this version would be much better than the original.

[@TDWonderer]

thanks, I try my best

[@YourNutzyBoo]

You’re videos are so good,they make my day whenever you post.Here’s an idea for another what if “what if sierra and alejandro debuted in island,instead of izzy and eva returning”

[@TDWonderer]

wow, interesting take. I have heard the idea of Alejandro and Sierra being in Island by someone else before but having them debut at that halfway point would definitely make things interesting. I'll try my best to get around to this idea at some point because i really like it

[@YourNutzyBoo]

Sorry that I didn’t respond to your comment earlier I’m only seeing it now,but I really hope you do it some day,I love your videos and keep up the good work

[@shellos31oeste72]

THIS ONE IS GREAT THIS SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE TOP 2 DAMN IT

[@samihi4721]

i think lindsay vs harold wouldve been the perfect finale in action, they wouldve been way better finalists

[@nathanterho-streck5546]

Ikr

[@randunker]

No duncan vs Harold with lindsay out in mutiny in the soundstage it felt like the season would building up to that

[@heather_foreather]

Yeah lindsay and harold because i hate courtney so much in this season

[@advicewbryyy]

i want it to be lindsay vs justin

[@kinderpingwin15]

@@heather_foreather yes but if Lindsay wins, I'd like to see Courtney's expression

[@JakesoontobeJack]

I feel like Beth and Lindsay has an unbreakable friendship, and I don't think Beth would intentionally hurt Lindsay and apologize after offending her, and Lindsay, the queen of forgiving people, would forgive Beth. So basically, if you alter what happens before Lindsay gets eliminated, Lindsay most likely will be in the finale. Now, what if Duncan told Leshawna about Harold in Island instead of confessing it in the confessional? You know, rigging the votes?

[@TDWonderer]

fair enough, Beth and Lindsay definitely have a very strong bond but in my opinion they are both a bit childish and I feel that them holding grudges especially given the serious topic warrants them fighting for at least one episode. (again entitled to your opinion, not saying you're wrong just givin' my perspective)

[@JakesoontobeJack]

@@TDWonderer Yeah, but what about the last part? You should make a video about that. Oh and I'm talking about Action. I respect your perspective and opinion.

[@JakesoontobeJack]

Oh and Lindsay is my favorite character, and that is mainly because of her prime in Action. So seeing Lindsay in the finale, as she was the more obvious choice than Beth, was so satisfying. Lindsay and Harold got robbed so hard, since they are both are more obvious finalists than Beth and Duncan. #justiceforlindsayandharold

[@heather_foreather]

YEAH LINDSAY AND HAROLD 🎉🎉🎉

[@XD-yn6hb]

I thought Duncan believed Heather rigged the votes and only found out that Harold did after Duncan got eliminated.

[@ellies.4781]

Literally just got the notification, and I really needed something like this, just had a heavy convo with my partner, and this is really gonna help lighten the mood

[@TDWonderer]

glad i could help make you feel better!

[@yngbro]

That mutiny episode was so epic, I didn’t see any animation and now one of my fav TD episodes, I love the twist with Courtney

[@elitettelbach4247]

Your hypothetical scenarios are well thought out and very interesting! Nicely done!

[@indecisive2insomniac610]

I'm currently at a Ren Faire and got quite overstimulated, you're voice is very calming and manages to keep me captivated. Thank you for the amazing vid! ❤

[@TheGodIvy]

Since you havent done one for Island, heres my suggestion What if Heather didnt target Justin, but rather say him as an ally and targetted someone else (likely Trent)

[@justarandomperson976]

That would change a lot tbh

[@TheGodIvy]

@@justarandomperson976 thats... the point, thats the point for all these videos

[@Pieified..]

Fun fact: If Duncan got out, Lindsay would have probally won!

[@heather_foreather]

YESSS LINDSAY WINS THANK YOU SO MUCH I LOVE IT 🎉🤩😭❤

[@truechad747]

TDWT:What if there was 2 teams instead of 3.Great video btw

[@TDWonderer]

I might do this one at some point since i've seen it float around my comments for a bit but for now I have my sight set on other ideas (however if you haven't already, a youtuber that goes by Lightro_Storm has made a great what-if on this idea and I would really recommend giving it a watch)

[@AdrowFigens]

Another great one! Keep it up TD Wonderer! Love each one you make

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! I remember you from the comments in some of my other videos and am really glad to see you're sticking around!

[@shadowkidd7018]

I love watching your videos

[@peterpatrick3159]

Duncan:Wait i got here because of lindsay🤯 Lindsay: Ur welcome

[@TheDudeNerd]

Here's an idea, what if Heather was eliminated in 'Not So Famous'

[@justarandomperson976]

I feel like Duncan or Courtney would take the role as the tdi villian then or maybe Justin

[@TDWonderer]

i want to do a lot of other videos first but im planning on doing an entire mini series of what ifs at different points in island where Heather doesn't have plot armor, since these types of ideas are suggested a lot (cody not getting mauled by a bear, beth not taking cursed tiki, etc.) and her getting eliminated in Not So Famous is also a part of that group. So expect this idea to happen..... just probably not for a while since I wanna get others videos out first.

[@lechonkenthusiast]

this would be a really short one, but what if duncan never blew up chris's house

[@TDWonderer]

good simple one, but also short so im probably gonna save this idea for a week where im real busy and just wanna get a video out (in other words don't expect this idea anytime soon)

[@sirdathale]

​@@TDWondererwhat if Harold never quit in wt?

[@mittyceo]

THE FINAL TWO WE ALWAYS NEEDED

[@froggynico]

Lindsay deserved that winning !

[@Junglejacob5]

This is the perfect TDA ending, i always thought Duncan and Beth were bad fnalists, this is much better

[@ericsanimatedshorts340]

If there was a vote between Lindsey and Courtney, Lindsey would win

[@Percy6]

I have one for TDI: What if Lindsay wasn't last in the bike race?

[@TheGodIvy]

She already wasnt :p

[@Percy6]

@@TheGodIvy But what if she didn't get out by Chris' rules.

[@TheGodIvy]

@@Percy6 then specify it more clearly from the start

[@chromabytebs]

@@TheGodIvy you dont have to be so rude about it lmao-

[@kronix_ae]

@@chromabytebsThat wasn’t even rude

[@Beaches_Peaches]

These videos are amazing, I subbed!

[@stevenquartzcutiepiedemayo8272]

"What if Lindsay won the tiebreaker in TDWT"

[@thebois6651]

It funny how this video is the shortest one you made so far and it is still 27 minutes lol. Keep up the great work dude.

[@MarxrileyAoki]

THE COURTNEY AND LINDSAY RIVALRY IS ONE OF THE BEST RIVALRIES IN TOTAL DRAMA. All-Stars could've explored that, All-Stars did do that, but Lindsay got voted off way too early for that to take FULL ACTION.

[@Robert___98]

This is waaayyy better than the original horrid endgame TDA had. Would've propelled this to my favourite season if it played out like this, considering the season had been going so strong up until Rock 'n Rule.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

I actually think Courtney would rather eliminate Lindsay than Beth since Lindsay was Courtney’s main target in recent episodes but I don’t think Courtney is realistically staying on. She refused originally despite her being in trouble after Beth betrayed her so I doubt she would do it this time, and then I think Harold and Owen vote each other, Lindsay and Courtney vote each other, and Beth votes Courtney, sending her home

[@justarandomperson976]

True but everyone likes Lindsay i don’t think she’d be able to make Lindsay look bad without Lindsay protecting herself by being dumb without even realising imo

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@justarandomperson976 I never said Lindsay would go home. I don’t think Courtney would try to manipulate anyone though-she’s known to not really recognise when she’s in trouble in TDI as she thought everyone liked her and wouldn’t send her home because she’s a CIT. I think she would vote Lindsay but I don’t think she’s staying on that episode

[@TDWonderer]

well courtney had immunity at the final 5 so she couldn't get voted off. I could see a point for her wanting Lindsay gone more than Beth because she probably would since she was annoyed with how Lindsay did things easily (making spark in caveman challenge plus taking Duncan on the movie reward) but like Just a random person said. Courtney would have an infinitely harder time trying to convince Owen and Harold to vote for Lindsay because of how likable she is

[@petalsssss]

“…I don’t have any of that” ICONIC

[@snom3270]

courtney and lindsay being the final girls would have been wayyyyy better

[@tailsic]

this was fun, i wasn't going to watch this at first, because i thought is was going to be bias, Lindsay should have been in the finals, Lindsay should have won deal, but you made work in a way that i can see this working with Lindsay actually winning within the show, instead of Lindsay winning for the sake of winning. not bad, i'm impress, i might give your other what if a try.

[@youraveragecrybaby]

if this was cannon i would’ve been actually screaming when courtney made it to the final 2 out of anger cause she’s my least favorite😭

[@idkwhattonamemyself6866]

what if team amazon was put up for elimination in the London episode

[@joshuavis2736]

As much as i wouldve liked harold to be in the final 2 in this scenario. You really justified the choice to have courtney win. I wish the season played out like this

[@jay-sss]

My suggestions, TDI: what if Beth didn’t take the thing from boney island in up the creek TDA: what if Courtney didn’t come back WT: what if team Chris is really really really hot won the challenge in I see London ROTI: What if Anne Maria didn’t leave the island cause of the diamond AS: what if Sam was replaced by brick RR: What if Jen instead of Tom did the challenge in Romania

[@idk9196]

I don’t think lindsay would realize court manipulating her bc she’s too ditzy

[@souleaterslaps7382]

I genuinely think if Lindsay didn't vote herself off she would've won

[@Nonya._.]

Since you haven’t done island yet, What if Ezekiel kept his mouth shut?

[@TDWonderer]

I've seen this suggestion float around my comments a lot and plan to do it (just not sure when yet)

[@Nonya._.]

@@TDWonderer okay, just do it when you can 🤷‍♂️

[@mariiexp]

these videos are really good! you've earned my sub :) as for suggestions, can you do what if team chris won the challenge in london?

[@TDWonderer]

I have seen this one around my comment section a ton and probably will do it at some point but I kinda wanna do other ideas first because this idea has been done by basically every what-if channel so for now i wanna try and do more unique ideas, at least until my channel has a wider spectrum of videos

[@mariiexp]

@@TDWonderer yeah that makes sense, I just really like seeing peoples takes on it for some reason

[@mariiexp]

@@TDWonderer ok idea: what if ezekiel never turned feral? (sorry I just thought of this randomly & wanted to share it)

[@Tiny33boom]

once you do another Total drama world tour what if, a good one would be "what if Geoff nether had a search party" which will mean that all the gen 1 cast plus Siera, al, and Dj's mom would compete in the season.

[@MagiTailWelkin]

What if Scott failed to sabotage Dawn?

[@chosenofgaia2511]

I'll top that, What if Dawn found the real Immunity Statue

[@MagiTailWelkin]

@@chosenofgaia2511 Well, that is one of the ways Dawn could out fox Scott. Really though Dawn should have seen through Scott's scheming when he claimed B hated nature.

[@eleazarlongart2866]

Tengo una idea para un What if... ¿Que pasaría si los votos alterados por Harold en la Isla del Drama no hubieran expulsado a Courtney del juego?

[@DaviCom2A]

Can you put the link to these tier lists in the description of your videos? It's so cool it makes me want to make my own

[@IdkT-ky3mf]

Also I’d like you to do this what if: what if Amy and Samey were in different teams in pahkitew island?

[@reelinginthelights]

thank you for using my idea! for a different one, what if chris followed the rules and gave the win to team chris in i see london?

[@lillrice27]

The final 3 being lindsay/courtney/harold is so much bettyer

[@joannagemmell6112]

Heres my suggestion "what if B spoke? "

[@luvlyvibez9105]

I love these videos, and honestly,I think that this finale would be 100x better than the show, because it’s been shown the those 2 already have had some fights in action, and in later seasons, so I think this finale would be amazing. Maybe that’s a little based bc the 2 winners r literally my favorite characters- but it’s ok. :D

[@TDWonderer]

thanks, glad you liked the video. Lindsay and Courtney are two very deserving winners (even though i'd prefer if Courtney won in All Stars as opposed to Action since she returned halfway in Action, but still)

[@luvlyvibez9105]

@@TDWonderer very good point, she did probably play her best game in action, but she was most deserved is all stars. We don’t talk about sundae.

[@gaminggaming5605]

Crazy entertaining ❤

[@kharihammon9784]

Can you do what if Scarlett doesn’t turn evil?

[@ramiromondragon8364]

I wanted that final to be: harold vs lindsay winner harold alt winner lindsay

[@huntervelin8122]

You should do what if Harold didn't tamper with the votes from island

[@esmi394]

Can you do a "What If: TDI Leshawna wasnt eliminated?"

[@PoliceRex]

I’m not sure if u did this but “What if Sierra didn’t explode the plane in TDWT”

[@transgaty2763]

Idea: What would've haopened if Izzy and Katie didnt switch teams?

[@justarandomperson976]

So basically what if Duncan didn’t have plot armour

[@kurthauxwell1147]

in terms of jury votes im gonna say that Beth, harold and owen obviously vote for lindsay, heather and duncan vote for courtney. izzy votes for izzy. as for everyone else its a toss up. justin and Gwen are interesting as i think they'd be the deciding votes. as for everyone else i think geoff, bridgette and dj would vote for courtney. based primarily on island as none of the voters were in action alongside courtney. trent and Leshawna would vote for Lindsay based on her actions this season and possibly (in Leshawna's case) to spite courtney.

[@emotionalkryptonite1161]

I like to imagine Lindsay would be the 'canon' ending, since it still accounts for Beth and Lindsay going to France and being thrown in jail.

[@sirdathale]

No her family is rich

[@Courtsfav]

I COULD HAVE HAD A COURTNEY WIN ENDING???

[@DJEKEA89]

Suggestion What if cody didn't vote sierra accidently and got 3 votes against courtney in world tour wich made gwen stayed in episode 16

[@havikrogers1801]

Alternative title: What If Duncan didn't throw a dingo at Cody?

[@dildeepsahasi1492]

Can you do I III elimination order but without the immunity vote

[@youraltaccount2081]

What if the couples were chosen correctly in world tours Niagara Falls Challenge

[@user-ny4iz9un6b]

its funny to me how many of these new endings just push lindsay to the finale, n honestly she deserves it

[@yoman976]

I will say this. Harold should’ve been in the final two instead of Beth. Duncan vs Harold would’ve made a much better story considering of all the beef they had in past with him bullying Harold and Harold rigging the votes to get Courtney eliminated

[@TDWonderer]

yeah, its always been kinda weird to me how after Lindsay VA had to leave early due to family issues that they chose Beth to be in the finale. when both Harold (or Courtney imo) could've taken Beths spot much easier

[@thebois6651]

@@TDWondererThis is a just a fake rumor

[@TDWonderer]

@@thebois6651 oh....my bad

[@thebois6651]

@@TDWonderer No worries a lot of fans think this.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@thebois6651Lindsay being supposed to win Action? Yeah that rumour is fake

[@aroramccracken2429]

What if dj didnt get the animal curse?

[@jackclough2312]

I like this better!

[@joeyobzut1448]

If Total Drama didn't do split endings and only have one winner, Lindsay would destroy Courtney in a vote, especially considering the fact that before the vote, the cast just watched Courtney claim to have no honor and kicks Harold in the nuts right after saving her/offering a fair race to the end.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

I don’t see a way for Courtney to realistically win. Assuming the same people that originally voted vote again, which I don’t think would change: Gwen didn’t like either of them that much, but I feel like she’d hate Courtney more so Lindsay DJ would vote Lindsay for the sane reason he voted Beth originally, plus he didn’t really like Courtney in TDI Heather would vote Courtney for playing a strategic game Justin would also probably vote Courtney out out of respect? (Assuming Duncan votes) he votes for Courtney (Assuming Beth votes) she votes for Lindsay Owen is friends with Lindsay and not Courtney so he obviously votes Lindsay Harold simply isn’t voting Courtney to win after her betrayal So yeah even if Beth didn’t get to vote Lindsay would still win

[@mariothebest1114]

​@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110I think Duncan,Heather and Justin vote for courtney Owen,DJ and Harold Votes for Lindsay Trent, Leshawna,Geoff and Bridget still don't vote and Beth is replacing Lindsay here so she probably lose her vote the same way Lindsay did. So it would be 3-3 vote and I guess Gwen would beth the deciding vote in each version(Like I assume she was in the original).

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@mariothebest1114 I guess, but I can’t picture Gwen realistically voting Courtney

[@mariothebest1114]

@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110 I can see it since they did become friends in world tour (before the stupid love triangle) and courtney never did anything to her in action since they only interact in the aftermath.Realistically she probably vote for Lindsay but I can see her vote for Courtney in her ending.

[@MarxrileyAoki]

I mean, the only reason why both versions got a winner is cause of Izzy voting for "Explosivo", you're correct though. But it's possible she'd win.

[@ChrisE405]

What if Harold did not vote himself in TDWT and Dj went home.

[@brooknova7573]

What if Heather and Justin did a tiebreaker (TDI) And Justin won it.

[@cosmotv5297]

I WISH THIS HAPPENED! It's so much better!

[@IdkT-ky3mf]

Decent theory but I can’t picture Beth or Lindsay holding a grudge for that long. Also if Harold could tell that Courtney was manipulative about trying to alliance with him and Owen is sabotaging contestants, Harold would be able to tell that Courtney drew on a magazine. Also in the original top dog episode i think Owen voted for someone that ate a lot of, but not himself. But idk if he’d vote for anyone this episode. Maybe Harold?

[@ParisRodriguez-vs6ee]

What if Trent didn't throw the challenges for Gwen.

[@loganfnafplushies882]

How about what if Dakota wasn’t a mutant when she came back

[@TheGloriousLobsterEmperor]

Personally I very much subscribe to the idea that Lindsay was supposed to be a finalist. Apparently her voice actress had to leave early due to a family emergency and couldn't finish the season. I think it just makes a lot of sense for her to have accidentally voted Beth off and then been the finalist.

[@thebois6651]

Nope that a fake rumor.

[@TheGloriousLobsterEmperor]

@@thebois6651 Source?

[@thebois6651]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/i6LWq6yrp62trpIsi=cvTVubzcquxSbsWv

[@IdkT-ky3mf]

Nice for Lindsay winning but sad that Beth didn’t win in this one and that Harold got robbed of a finalist spot again.

[@juancruzdiazbravo7338]

What if Eva win inmunity in the 15th episode of island?

[@VegitoBlue202]

What if the total drama cast was locked and betrayed in Boney Island by Chris for 1000 years.

[@PTUBE101_]

HOW DID HAROLD STILL GET ROBBED

[@baileylynn5562]

What if Duncan never quit in WT?

[@Sihan_fr]

I think ina hard battle courtney would win, but lindsay made a lot o friends and i think she would win.

[@TheRanker77]

Idk, I think that the way this season would've been fixed is to have Lindsay accidentally vote off Beth instead, then have Duncan get out next episode because of Spider shenanigans. Then Owen 4th, Courtney 3rd, and we get the Lindsay vs Harold finale we deserved.

[@xavier86479]

I think the finale 2 should be Lindsay and Harold

[@sirdathale]

What if harold never quit

[@tadpholes]

what if justin didn't get out in this universe?

[@amandabarry1339]

Yes finally

[@preppydonkee]

Lindsays voice actor had to quit