I do something similar and I find it very helpful. I watch an Italian soap opera with 'sottotitoli' (subtitles) and I put the words I don't know into a spreadsheet with the translation. Then I can study it later and conjugate the verbs. They tend to use the words several times in an episode so I get to hear them repeatedly and remember them. I have to integrate your method into mine. Thanks!
@LanguageMatrix12 күн бұрын
Very good
@adamhersberger8993Ай бұрын
This is a really interesting method. People in the comments are getting too hung up on the fact that the video uses simple examples that are "useless" or that a beginner wouldn't know how to fill in the grid off the top of their head. It would make for a long, boring video if we had to wait for him to look everything up with no prior knowledge. Pay attention to the concept rather than the specific examples. This method provides a great structure to focus on what YOU want to learn IN CONTEXT. It's kind of like flash cards on steroids. You can create whatever cards you want. The difference here is that you've grouped all of the "cards" in a way that lets you learn how they work together rather than just vocabulary in isolation.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Thank you, yes that's right. ChatGPT can help you generate it. When people get hung up, it's because they are still assuming that the goal of language learning is to learn the whole language first then use it. This approach let's you follow one of the most important maxims this method has: What do I want to say, and to whom? Be able to answer that question, or at least remember to answer it, and you'll never be lost. You can think of that question as a north star. Learn to say the things you want to say first, then extract the patterns you need from that to say everything else.
@BradPuma19 күн бұрын
Thanks
@alejrandom6592Ай бұрын
Small corrections: It's sunny = Está asoleado It's windy = Hay mucho viento Do you like coffee? = ¿Te gusta el café? (we use articles when talking about something in a general sense)
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
You right you right
@liambyrne591Ай бұрын
As ol ea do , a sol e a do , a sol ea do
@MrSkribantoАй бұрын
En mi país se dice: Está haciendo sol. / Está haciendo un solazo (cuando el sol está muy fuerte). Asoleado es algo que se pone al sol. Ej. Sal a asolearte, la ropa ya está asoleada (llevó mucho sol, se está tostando)
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
@@MrSkribanto Gracias
@lisettegarciaАй бұрын
@@MrSkribanto 💯
@byronwilliams7977Ай бұрын
I find that the FSI audio material is absolutely PACKED with useful recordings, situations, and grammatical structures as well as drills which can be modified to help hammer home the target. language.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Nice
@beckyshockley6738Ай бұрын
What’s fsi?
@edualf4308Ай бұрын
@@beckyshockley6738 "The Foreign Service Institute (FSI) is the primary training institution for employees of the United States federal government, particularly those in the U.S. Department of State. Established in 1947, FSI offers language instruction, professional development, and area studies programs aimed at preparing U.S. diplomats and other government employees for their roles abroad. One of the notable aspects of FSI is its language learning programs, which are known for their comprehensive and practical approach to teaching foreign languages. The FSI language courses often include detailed audio materials designed to help learners gain proficiency through practice with real-life dialogues, grammar exercises, and other drills. These materials are sometimes used by individuals outside of government service because they are thorough and have been made available to the public." chatgpt
@edualf4308Ай бұрын
Where can you find fsi audio material?
@dafydd172229 күн бұрын
@beckyshockley6738 Foreign Service Institute. It's how US diplomats and government officials learn foreign languages. The material they use is available free online.
@arau_r16 күн бұрын
Wow, your spanish pronunciation is very good, even your english pronunciation is very clear, there are so many americans that I can't understand at all, nice video
@LanguageMatrix16 күн бұрын
Thank you very much
@whitemc213 күн бұрын
I realized that this is powerful for myself by also doing a bunch of methods that involve the spreadsheet. Thanks dude
@LanguageMatrix12 күн бұрын
That's excellent, thank you, and it's my pleasure
@PolarBear973326 күн бұрын
This looks like a great way to help learning to converse, which I am doing right now in Spanish. It could really help clear the hurdles of know what to say and how to say it. I am definitely trying it out.
@carolknapp282417 күн бұрын
Learning a language takes time and dedication, no shortcuts
@LanguageMatrix16 күн бұрын
True about time and dedication ... but when the wheel, inclined plane, plow, and computer were invented, we could say those were shortcuts, no? Or if shortcut isn't the right word, perhaps a tool. In any case, what I'm showing here is along the same lines.
@marinabraeckman733115 күн бұрын
Por qué critican? Es excelente la idea. Son los famosos prompts que proponen en los exámenes internacionales...
@jamesbond-xl3xsАй бұрын
This is heat rock. Good stuff Tony. I will begin to implement this method. Gracias my guy!
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
My pleasure. Thank you! Implement it right away and see where it takes you.
@jamesbond-xl3xsАй бұрын
@@LanguageMatrix definitely will. I had a few sessions with you prior and it helped me and I will be sure to reach back out to solidify things when needed going forward.
@xtaltheo17026 күн бұрын
beautiful clarity in your language, my brother!
@LanguageMatrix22 күн бұрын
Thank you very much
@MisterGames18 күн бұрын
A visual example of how lexical chunks work. Thanks!👍
@LanguageMatrix17 күн бұрын
My pleasure, thank you very much
@richakings636Ай бұрын
As a spanish native speaker I could understand the point🎉 thank you so much
@LanguageMatrix22 күн бұрын
Excellent, thank you very much
@madmad6915Ай бұрын
good idea, I'm learning English and this can be very useful, thank you
@LanguageMatrix22 күн бұрын
Thank you
@JCMcQueenOfficial26 күн бұрын
I Love the way you teach! So Chill. Your Spanish accent is so cute
@IgnacioVardy-dv5zx25 күн бұрын
I literally thought he has a cute Spanish accent😅
@LanguageMatrix22 күн бұрын
Thanks very much!
@LicLafarga16 күн бұрын
Good, very good!! I like it a lot, I'll implement it with my Thai, BTW your Spanish is on the money, cheers!
@LanguageMatrix5 күн бұрын
Thanks a lot :)
@teresita.lozada29 күн бұрын
I am finding it super useful. Thank you so much for this video.
@LanguageMatrix22 күн бұрын
Very welcome Teresita, thank you for all your engagement
@teresita.lozada22 күн бұрын
@@LanguageMatrix I am working on the White Belt questions in Italian. Today is my second day and I am having lots of fun.
@pingoleonfernandez763821 күн бұрын
Interesting method. I'm currently trying to work out a method of my own and this approach reminds me of the one used in a book called "Elementary Russian in Patterns", printed in the USSR.
@ryantw1921 күн бұрын
Very interesting! It would be useful to see this starting from a more filled out example of one conversation.
@LanguageMatrix21 күн бұрын
Thanks very much. You can see it expanded here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/j53damOQgtabpsk
@nigelsouthworth80821 күн бұрын
Fantastic, thanks
@LanguageMatrix16 күн бұрын
Thanks very much
@rudolphvalentinoconnection829816 күн бұрын
Sort of reminds me to Language Transfer, which is totally oral. The instructor leads the student(s) through a "building block" stream. I like the visual component of your approach! Everything is connected, instead of just LISTS...
@AshlynDeluxe18 күн бұрын
Ty for this
@LanguageMatrix17 күн бұрын
You're very welcome
@rjg613915 күн бұрын
This is essential for flashcards. Anki offers vocab decks that often lacks context, so I would string words and expressions together in ways no native would until I was corrected. Now I always add dictionary like expressions underneath in a similar way to this video.
@NewJerseyTicoАй бұрын
I really like that strategy; I’m going to try something similar. Thank you! It’s excellent.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Try it out! You can go forever
@TheJudeJane26 күн бұрын
¡Esta es la forma correcta de aprender español!
@charlesfitzpatrick380524 күн бұрын
Estoy de acuerdo.
@daniel_1625_sa12 күн бұрын
The template could improve though, I used to have a temple to do active recall, I think if you highlight the text as the same colour as the cell could be easier to do the recall and then you can colour the text back to the original colour when you want to know the answer
@KendallKruse-b7f20 күн бұрын
Tony just really starting out in Spanish and interested in this method, A question for example in the question column would it be appropriate to put a response that was not a question like when meeting "Mucho gusto en conocerte " or does this go in the expression column? Like your channel Thanks
@MisterGames18 күн бұрын
I am not Tony but will answer... If you put non questions in the question column, it stops being a question column and becomes a random stuff column. Questions in question column. Answers in answer column. Variable expressions in that column. KISS.
@LanguageMatrix16 күн бұрын
Hi, that's a great example of a Useful Expression, and can go into that category.
@LanguageMatrix16 күн бұрын
@MisterGames you got it
@thomasdennis900519 күн бұрын
Could you send me more information on your conversation generator. I've been studying Spanish off and on for more than a year using different methods. I find your approach something to look forward to. If you have a fee course, I would be interested. Please send me contact information.
@LanguageMatrix18 күн бұрын
Hi Thomas, I'm building a complete course here: langmatrix.com/learn-any-language
@mitchellbaker480618 күн бұрын
The weather is el clima. El tiempo is the time
@danielfreezer846914 күн бұрын
Weather is called both clima and tiempo, with subtle differences. Tiempo can also be time.
@wilsonalfa6614Ай бұрын
Useful tips
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Thank you, glad to hear that
@ScreenPrintR10 күн бұрын
Do you have a book?
@LanguageMatrix5 күн бұрын
Hi, a few ebooks on my website: langmatrix.com/ but not a comprehensive book on the. method yet
@Liopot6816 күн бұрын
If i received a penny every time some schmock online calls his half-backed idea "the most powerful tool", I´d be as rich as Elon Musk.
@LanguageMatrix5 күн бұрын
Try out the method, and let me know if you have any questions
@curtpiazza1688Ай бұрын
COOL! 😊
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Thanks Curt
@Cr7_the_G26 күн бұрын
thanks' man
@LanguageMatrix22 күн бұрын
My pleasure, thank you
@SodaDrinker94Ай бұрын
How come you call it a machine? There’s nothing automatic about it?
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
It takes some abstract thinking perhaps ... but it's automatic in this sense ... try it out for yourself. Think of a topic. Now think of a question on that topic. Now answer that question. What verbs and vocabulary did you use?
@israelquijada4324Ай бұрын
Good.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Thank you very much
@lisettegarciaАй бұрын
First example is already wrong. Nobody asks "¿Cómo está el tiempo?" That's speaking English with Spanish words. In Spanish you would actually say: "¿Qué tal el tiempo?" You would also never ask "¿Hace mucho sol?" Instead, the right way is "¿Hay mucho sol?" Bottom line, this generator reinforces bad habits. The way to avoid this is to read prize-winning novels and plays. It's the only way to absorb accurate, accepted expression in the target language. Edited to add that listening to a target language's most popular podcasters at .75 speed, while not helping with perfect grammar, will help in picking up typical expressions.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Lisette, just switch out the Spanish for the preferred way of saying it. ChatGPT can help. As for bad habits (and this may infuriate a lot of people :) -- but when it comes to bad habits, bad habits are better than no habits! Because at least you are building momentum. The perfection of great literature is not necessarily the most helpful thing for the beginner speaking student.
@lisettegarciaАй бұрын
@LanguageMatrix for sure this works for a person seeking to become functional at a low level in a hurry (law enforcement) but bad habits are a nearly impossible foundation to uproot. So, anyone requiring higher level communication (diplomats) should avoid this system like the plague.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
@@lisettegarcia Say the Spanish was perfectly native-like, 'cómo está el clima' rather than 'cómo está el tiempo', etc. ... your stance would still be to not take this approach? To clarify my point, it's simply a way to organize the language according to topic--question-answer, so we can practice generating conversation in conversation rather than memorizing words.
@lisettegarciaАй бұрын
@LanguageMatrix i totally thought that about clima but that actually speaks to the weather in broader terms and it sounded like you were using it here to ask about the day's forecast. To your question, though, yes, it's a good system for kitchen spanish (running a restaurant) not for growing into the level of fluency required to score a 3+ or better at FSI. I do agree that memorizing words out of context is useless. Hence, my suggestion to read novels/plays and listen to podcasts.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
@@lisettegarcia Great, so I would just argue that 'kitchen Spanish', or being able to converse is the base from which a person can grow from 0 to 3 -- kind of like learning crawl before you walk, and walk before you run -- and once a person is 3+ then absolutely we need novels/plays/poetry/podcasts. And even before level 3 is great too (never too early for input of any kind); all I'm saying is Comprehensible Output is just as important as Comprehensible Input, and that in the same way that CI automatically lead to CO, CO also automatically leads to CI.
@nonamenoname276712 күн бұрын
İf you know the language you can write it on a spreadsheet but if you dont you can not so that is not a learning method. The point is useless.
@LanguageMatrix12 күн бұрын
You have ChatGPT, a friend, or a teacher help you fill in the template
@ignacioagАй бұрын
El clima
@safiya59406 күн бұрын
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
@LanguageMatrix5 күн бұрын
Thanks very much
@liambyrne591Ай бұрын
What good is this if you are able to write all that in Spanish you already know it so what good isbit to you
@repairxproАй бұрын
This is almost useless. 3 reasons why: First, you gave examples of close ended questions to study. The answer to all of those is “yes or no”. That’s useless. A conversation is made of mostly statements not questions. In a conversation, you will most likely be asked open-ended questions, like “why are you studying ____ language”? Or “how was your day?” It would be way more useful to study what I call “referential answers” that directly references something already stated to provide context for the response, and “ambiguous answers” where you simply use filler words or repeatable phrases for stuff you don’t know how to answer. A person who is bad at a language can fake a conversation by saying these answers that work for almost any question: “Sounds like a good idea” “I would like to try that” “Let me think about that” “I’m not sure about that” “I don’t know know anything about that” “Could you repeat that?” “Probably” “Sometimes” “Always” “Never” “I’m not sure” “Its hard for me to explain” “Can you explain more about that” “This is/is not interesting” “I’m not into that” “I want/don’t want to try something else” “I want/don’t want to go there” “It depends on the situation” “Would you like some of this/that? “Do you need this/that?” “Is this/that your’s?” “Why do you think that?” “A little more/less, please” Second, you’re not focusing on the different questions that can be asked, regardless of the subject The topic is not relevant because the question could be the same for literally ANY topic. For example: Do you like to ____? Insert topic/verb/noun in blank. Done. You don’t need to make this question for every topic. You are suggesting make a topic list of “Do you like Sports, Pizza, Music, Dancing, etc”. You only need to know how to say “do you like…?” only once. Also, binary questions that ask for “do you want option 1 or option 2” don’t need to be studied either. The answers to a binary question are only 3 possible answers: “I want that one” and point to it or “I don’t like any of these” or “do you have something else”. Again, this is much more useful. It would also be more useful to study the 5 W’s (what when where why who) “Do you want…?, do you have…?, do you take..? do you buy…?, do you suggest..? do you think..? where is…? What is this/that..? what happened…? when is…? when should I go…?, who is this/that…? and the “why…” which you can simply add in front of all the “do you…” questions. Same thing with the “How…”. Done. (That’s like 20 sentences that once you know them, you can simply drop in a noun or subject as you learn them. You could even ask “what is this called?”, get the answer and instantly drop that into the above questions you just learned. Finally, you put infinitive verbs (or one tense of it) on the spreadsheet which is useless Even if you know the infinitive verb tense, you still need to study the past, present and future of that verb or you will be lost once someone asks you a question using that verb, especially if they use a past or conditional tense. For example, someone can still ask you “Would you like coffee? Did you already have coffee? Will you buy coffee?” You won’t know what they are asking because the other variations of this question were not studied. Also the answer is yes or no for all of these so studying the answer is useless. It would be better to simply study the top 100 verbs and their basic past, present and future tenses than to try to study a question with that verb as if you are trying to study that verb. It would take forever, and you would need to study 10 versions of that sentence to learn all the verb tenses. Always study verbs separately and insert them later. Summary: A language takes so long to learn, you can’t afford to study something you aren’t going to use. Again, studying “ambiguous answers” to use in conversation, the top 100 verbs in past, present and future, and studying the 5 W’s will take you father than studying random close-ended questions that all use the same beginning question.
@novaploca2080Ай бұрын
Interesting view thanks.
@LanguageMatrixАй бұрын
Interestingly, what you've just described is the same as my table. The question column is where the open ended questions go ... the verb column is where you can practice any tense you'd like ... and the phrases such as 'can you repeat that?' go in the useful expressions column.
@TheCompleteGuitaristАй бұрын
In Chinese verbs are never conjugated, a verb only has one form, it has no past, present or future.
@eboyeman8457Ай бұрын
Cool thoughts.
@TheCompleteGuitaristАй бұрын
@@eboyeman8457 we don't learn languages we acquire them. Big difference. Language is acquired when messages are understood. Not through explicit study but through implicit meaningful interaction with the language. Good language acquisition only requires good models of input that we negotiate with a purpose. Output, is a communication skill and secondary to acquisition.
@sonnetpoem17 күн бұрын
Dont make sense if you don't know that language you can't spell it.
@LanguageMatrix16 күн бұрын
ChatGPT will spell it for you
@matt92hun8 күн бұрын
Deepl, Google Translate, Bing Translate, dictionary, etc.