Postmodern Jukebox Reaction CREEP - This is my first time hearing PMJ and Haley Reinhart CREEP

[@nathanknipmeyer2189]

If I've watched 100 reaction videos to this exact song, there have been 100 times where there is just silence at the end of her performance. Every. Time. I. Love. It. She's super special. Best reaction to this song yet.

[@mdfield1]

The CRAZY thing about the song is that Haley wasn’t feeling well when she arrived to do the song with PMJ and she told them she wanted to do it the first run. This was the first run. It was SO good that another wasn’t necessary. Haley is simply PHENOMENAL!!

[@celestialmanrichard8846]

I agree completely

[@michellebarry1555]

Scott Bradlee (the guy on the piano) is the one who put PMJ together and creates most of the arrangements, he is a musical genius!

[@markrose6096]

My other Haley favorites are Seven Nation Army and Black Hole Sun. Also, there's a fun version of All About that Bass that you'd enjoy.

[@mdfield1]

She also does one of her own releases. The official version is SO GOOD. It’s called ‘Don’t Know How To Love You’. Here’s the KZbin link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aGSwaKKVbrR7fKM

[@chrisfraiser1954]

Blackhole Sun is absolutely amazing

[@thetorresons297]

It’s such a joy to see someone discover this song for the first time. Your reaction was wonderful!💖

[@robinrichards6577]

One of the Morgan James songs i’ve suggested, “dream on“ is with postmodern jukebox. Another song I think you would enjoy by Postmodern jukebox is “all about that bass“ which features both Haley and Morgan, along with a third female vocalist.

[@charlottevan_8]

The third vocalist is Ariana Savalas, daughter of Telly Savalas, late actor on the old TV show "Kojak".

[@kirkzentner3262]

All About That Bass also has a male vocalist, Casey Abrams, and some CRAZY string bass work. Casey and Haley have been friends since their time on Idol. This is a must.

[@anttiypya8264]

Ooh, Morgan James...❣❣❣

[@LoRyder]

Yes, Yes, Yes!! Both of these, please!!

[@Smo1k]

All About Tha' Bass was my intro to PMJ. It's a hallmark performance starting straight jazz, turning sexy, then funny, then sexier, then showing skillz, and finally getting down to it. ... Did I just describe a date w/ happy ending? =.O

[@maddalenacherchi]

Hi,please react to Morgan James Dream on Aerosmith cover for Postmodern juke box, incredible! Haley and Morgan, Divas!❤❤

[@charlesparadise5712]

So cool u heard about hailey she is the best kept secret of the music world.. I have no idea why she is not huge. U have to hear "lay it down" and "don't know how to love you" have fun

[@ckh57]

Words fail don't worry,. That was an epic masterpiece by Haley!!

[@m.autumngazr0714]

Travis, you need to watch PMJ (Postmodern Jukebox) with their version of “All About That Bass”, featuring Haley Reinhart as well as Casey Abrams (he was on American Idol as well) singing and playing bass. It’s so much fun, especially the bass solo.

[@dwfarr]

She is one of the best singers out there. Her Jazz training really shows. Other great PMJ performances with her in it include Seven Nation Army, Oops I Did It Again, and All About The Bass (with Morgan James and Ariana Savalas).

[@jessebynum9355]

Her blues heritage stands out as well.

[@jehuxtable]

PMJ does vintage style (20s-50s) covers of modern songs. Same band with a variety of singers. Like going to a night club.

[@JeffTokayer]

Gotcha! You're one of the few reactors that actually knows of Haley. Welcome to the club. As others have mentioned, Seven Nation Army, Black Hole Sun, All About the Bass, are a must.

[@dawgeral333]

Haley is my very favorite female vocalist...hands down. It's been 3-4 years. Try CAN'T HELP FALLING IN LOVE. Her rendition will captivate you...for sure.

[@celestialmanrichard8846]

I agree with you completely

[@michaeldanieljordan]

SEVEN NATION ARMY next PLEASE!!! also check her out with Jeff Goldblums band singing my baby just cares for me!

[@robbin.s]

I second My Baby Just Cares for Me. I also like her duet with Thomas Dutronc’s on his Frenchy album singing If You Go Away.

[@JeffTokayer]

@@robbin.s then you may also like Haley doing No Regrets. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hX_PhXeOqbmerdU 13:52 I'm a Fool to Want You 17:28 No Regrets

[@MsRegi64]

She did Seven Nation Army with Post Modern Jukebox too and it's actually my favorite with her.

[@alanwyllie7814]

She is a vocal genius. All time greatest vocalist competitor for sure. The whole arrangement is amazing as well.

[@paulmason6474]

So pleased you got your rocks off on this. I agree with every word you said. At least you have found it. Keep smiling….

[@Mahiahtree]

I love all the ones Haley has done with Post Modern Jukebox. They are incredible!

[@debbierhodes4479]

I stopped the minute I saw this! Had to watch your reaction! This is one of the Big 3 videos I love to find!(The other two are the first time people hear Pentatonix and get Mitch Slapped and the first time someone hears Angelena) The look on your face said it all!!! I like her Seven Nation Army and All About That Bass. Awesome Reaction.

[@davidphillips4476]

LOL Same Debbie!! exactly the ones I look for!

[@bertpainter8385]

Love Angelina 1st time reactions. Here's another jaw dropper for Courtney Hadwin kzbin.info/www/bejne/mmaceWOLrc2sl7s

[@davidp6635]

Haley just released her video of an original on August 26 called "Roll the Dice." More blues, less jazz, but just as good, showing she still has it!

[@frankphillips5660]

Thanks Travis for getting to this so soon! I love Angelina and I love PTX but now you've discovered the best singer on the planet. As you know Haley came in 3rd on American Idol in 2011, which was robbery but she has been relatively successful since doing her kind of music which is more jazz and blues. She has released some albums.. Lo-Fi Soul has many great originals. This was recorded in 2015 the same year she covered Elvis' "Can't Help Falling In Love" for a Wrigley's Extra Gum commercial that went viral. She just released a new song a couple of days ago that is awesome "Roll The Dice". As far as PMJ, their most viewed videos have Haley as the lead including: 7 Nation Army, Blackhole Sun, All About That Bass,Mad World,Oops I Did It Again and Love Fool. Every one will capture your attention and blow you away. Travis, I've got to love your channel because your reacting to all of my favorite stars!!!! Thank you!!!!

[@TGrimm]

She and morrisette amon are tied for me in best singers. Both have amazing technical ability, onsets offsets growls slides pitch and vowel modifications for days. Morrisette edges out a bit because of her amazing fragiolet, and signature vocal squeaks. Haley edges out with her scatting, creative inflections, and that octave change slide she did here.

[@frankphillips5660]

@@TGrimm Yeah, I like Morisette too

[@frankphillips5660]

@@TGrimm I like Morrisette a lot but I prefer Angelina Jordan's tone, vibrato, breathiness, rasp, lower range and jazz style phrasing

[@nolaknowles9888]

At 40 seconds in you were gaping like a goldfish and already had the chills. I was giggling and thinking you ain't heard nuttin! Black Hole Sun is another good one.

[@VinE83656]

Seven Nation Army, Black Hole Sun, Love Fool, All About that Bass, and Mad World. Also, cheddar her out with Morgan James on the Beatles song Dear Prudence. Finally, watch the video of the Extra Gum commercial with Haley

[@jonchicoine]

That performance is simply smoldering… good heavens!

[@richardbezila6495]

Try PMJ & Morgan James "Dream On" or Haley Reinhart "Seven Nation Army" or "All About That Bass" (European Tour version)... Welcome to the PMJ rabbit hole!

[@sheryldoughty8820]

Seven nation army ROCKS!

[@travisrussell9166]

Seven nation Army with PMJ and Haley , also All About The Bass.

[@frankbowman9493]

You should see them team up with Hailey again to put their spin on "Oops I did it again!"

[@michellebarry1555]

PMJ always has the best arrangements. They make modern music jazzy and vintage. I saw them live before lockdown and it was one of the most entertaining shows I’ve been to. People dress up in the clothing from their era. It was so fun!

[@Thyrwyn]

This performance is everything. The arrangement is sublime and her performance is un-paralleled. Insane.

[@elmarwinkler6335]

Travis, PMJ brings modern music back into different stiles. Scott Bradlee, founder of PMJ, often asks musicians winning American Idol if they want to try out his Band. He leaves them their freedom. Those talent shows often, chew up the artists for profit and than spit them out, to be on their own. (seriously no conspiracy theory but hard facts told by many artists). After a few years of existence, the rumor mills among the musicians told that if you work with PMJ, it is a real career step ladder. Many of the musicians, that worked with Scott Bradlee, today can choose where to play, they even are invited to Las Vegas. But when Scott calls, maybe about a tour or just a gig, most of them hurry back. PostModern Jukebox has about 50 Bandmembers changing. Oh, this knowledge is partly from an Interview Morgan James (Dream On) had with Elizabeth Zartloff (The Carismatic Voice) had. Some of them, like Haley and Morgan James have their own channels today, thanks to Scott Bradlee, because he brings an idea about a song, but the musicians themselves develop the performance, including a bit of comedy. As usual stay safe and sound, watch your TeaCup. German greetings

[@vidpie]

Scott Bradlee started out in NY. PMJ achieved viral recognition there with Robyn Adele Anderson covering Miley Cyrus's We Can't Stop' (25M views). He then moved to Los Angeles and, in tapping the talent there, found sax player Jacob Scesney who went to school with Casey Abrams and occasionally performed in his band. He introduced Scott to Casey and Haley. This was not long after Scott had arrived in Los Angeles. PMJ typically records from his home, but he wasn't really settled yet so the first videos featuring Casey and Haley were recorded at an ad agency with an in-house bar. (Haley recorded "Habits" which has picked up a million views in just the past week because it was recently used in a TikTok meme) When Haley recorded "Creep" that is when PMJ really went viral. The song reached the top of FB trends and remained in the top 10 for an entire week. PMJ and Haley contributed to each other's success, which helped him draw new talent. Couple of notes: PMJ recorded "Creep" previously. That version has 95 million FEWER views. Blake Lewis was a runner up on Idol and he's appeared with PMJ, but no winner has yet.

[@ritathomas5167]

I just recently discovered Postmodern Jukebox myself! As others have said here, it was founded in 2011 by the piano player, Scott Bradlee. He does most of the arranging of the songs. Most of the other musicians change from song to song, as well as the singers. He takes a song and reworks it to fit into a jazz/swing genre of like the 1920 to 1950 or so era of popular music. Most of the guest singers I have seen are really excellent, but they haven't quite hit that big time star category yet. I call it undiscovered stars. One of my favorite Postmodern Jukebox songs is "Closer", sung by Kenton Chen. Kenton is fabulous! Please consider reacting to it! Great reaction! Thank you!

[@jankreps5115]

You’re not the first to be a little speechless when you first hear this! . She is incredible!! PMJ has several singers! Listen to their version of “All About That Bass”!! Casey Abrams on the bass fiddle from American idol is also part of PMJ!! He, Haley and several others are featured in the next song! awesome reaction!! have a great week!!

[@Eric1SanDiego1]

Anyone else predict he'd be speechless at the end of this song?

[@lottiep3134]

Can I echo everyone who recommended Morgan James and her version of Dream On. Also there's an acoustic version of Haley and Morgan singing Dear Prudence by The Beatles that is outstanding. Great reaction and welcome to the PMJ rabbit hole. P.S. Try listening to Puddles Pity Party with PMJ! You'll thank me unless you have a fear of clowns!

[@summerbreeze5459]

Another great reaction from you bradah! Haley Reinhart was my favourite to win in season 10 of American Idol. She is the modern day Joplin. And this jazzy rendition of Creep is my favourite cover of this song.

[@TeamMisguided]

Dream on with Morgan James.

[@sterlingknight8087]

This is a very good example of what PMJ does with a song. Takes it back to a 30's jazz club. Try 7 Nation Army.

[@alvinsavage1775]

HEY TRAV , I m 70 and I love ALL the PMJ stuff : they cover songs I've HATED in the past ; and now LOVE THEM ! ! ! ! ! ! !

[@george40nelson4]

You Must Watch Their "It,s All About The Bass " Right Up Your Alley ..What a Number !!

[@vincentsablan732]

Ok...First of all, your "teacup" is BIGGER than my bathtub!!! Jealousy aside, LOVED your reaction, and the fact that you acknowledged the BRILLIANCE of the arrangement. Haley's voice is definitely next level, but it's the rhythmic delivery of the arrangement that allows her to soar. A PERFECT coupling...along the vein of Bobby Hatfield's "Unchained Melody". Nobody's gonna do it better...

[@TeaTimeWithTravis]

YES!

[@agnesregards2286]

Postmodern Jukebox have some amazing covers, all with unique arrangements. Aerosmith's Dream On cover with Morgan James on vocals is another one that would blow you away, and she sings with Haley Reinhart, Ariana Savalas and Casey Abrahms in a brilliant version of All About That Bass. Another worth checking out is Crazy with Hannah Gill and Casey Abrahms on vocals.

[@joanbaillie9925]

Please do her doing Seven Nation Army and her other Post Modern Jukebox numbers. She is fabulous!

[@lonniekramlich6241]

"Don't Know How To Love You", by Haley 😎

[@carihenson8019]

This is *such* a fun group. And her talent is unbelievable.

[@smittyfiggpaints]

They just covered don't speak by no doubt. It's amazing!

[@melisamundy7714]

I wholeheartedly agree!

[@AudioVile]

Best version EVER. Amazing! LOVED your stunned reaction!!

[@bonnieflynn4798]

Hi. , Love this so much. My favorite is all about that bass. It kicks and makes me dance and shout.

[@GriffinUSA]

OMG...Can not wait to see your reaction to Haley Reinhart/PMJ and their cover of Seven Nation Army!! You may have to lay down lol. I just love her and her voice, like no other.

[@roguemerlin1969]

Scott Bradlee is the piano player, founder and leader of PMJ. He does all the arrangements and composition, including the vocals though I'm sure Haley adds her own touch. If you like this you need to check out what they did with Seven Nation Army, with Haley on vocals again. Great reaction.

[@Violet316]

There is also another MV of Haley doing a rendition of Can't Help Falling In Love featuring Casey Abrams so, so good. Casey was also on American Idol the same season as her.

[@Nonnie335]

When you get done listening to Haley sing Creep you feel like you need a cigarette 🚬 even when you don’t smoke!! She is just that good! I have watched this video probably 50 times and it never gets old! When I suggested you listen to it I knew you would be blown away. I loved Brian Justin Crumbs version but for different reasons I love Haley’s more. They are both over the mood talented and it would be awesome to hear them sing anything together!!

[@iarocks44]

Welcome to the rabbit hole that is PMJ. Haley is amazing. Also consider this song was done in a single take after recording 2 other songs that day. Other PMJ to check out is All About That Bass, Umbrella, Seven Nation Army, Dream On, and Mad World. There is so much more but that is a good start.

[@dylangintherofficial]

Ellas a trumpet Haley’s a trombone she is absolutely phenomenal

[@barbaraflorentine2043]

Your reaction is pure Joy! Just like getting a puppy for Christmas joy!

[@susanbeckmolloy9536]

Haley is a Goddess. The vocal gymnastics she performs in this song are crazy. From her grit and growl to her jazzy vibrato to Scatting to the multiple key changes while belting. I love her. She has original music too. "Don't Know How To Love You " is beautiful. She released "Roll The Dice" 3 days ago. Great reaction😎

[@romeunissola8027]

Haley is beautifull woman, unique voice, control vocal, wow, great talent, great female singer. Sugestion for you SEVEN NATION ARMY Vintage Postmodern Jukebox by Haley Reinhart ou Black Hole Sun. Im brasilian, by.

[@judydempsey3957]

Travis,Travis.......Now you have to do PMJB cover AreoSmith’s Dream On...With Morgan James...... Brace yourself.......Judy D

[@woody9x656]

I've watched a ton of reactions to this video and this was definitely one of my favorites. Just great, genuine reactions which I feel right along with you. Great job, thank you!

[@heidisumner4321]

This is my favorite rendition.. She is amazing..

[@chris210racer]

My mom loves this cover to absolute bits and always asks me to play it for her whenever she’s cooking or to add it to a playlist she’s got in mind for any upcoming dinner parties for her and her friends.

[@SissyKool]

Love that stank face! lol. Great reaction! Thank you!

[@DML575]

Haley owns this song, flippin' amazing performance.

[@rs-ye7kw]

I haven't seen this one mentioned by anyone else, but Haley does an amazing cover of The Shirelles song "Baby, It's You".

[@davidphillips4476]

Haley = most underrated female vocalist out there. She has several with PMJ and all are good. Her originals "I Don't Know How To Love You" PMJ style influenced, and "Lay it Down" which shows crystal clarity of her upper range. The other Beast in the PMJ lineup..Morgan James doing "Dream On", Yes the Aerosmith song, is a killer. (There are several artists that are great with PMJ, these 2 are my personal favs)

[@Erfedwe]

Haley and Morgan are both underrated. I think Floor Jansen also needs to be on that list.

[@davidphillips4476]

@@Erfedwe Ya gotta agree with you there Floor is amazing!!

[@robertmccracken1226]

Definitely check out PMJ featuring Puddles Pity Party, either "royals" or "mad world" or my favorite "all the small things"

[@aj71169]

I’ll suggest one you probably won’t get many recommendations for, but now that you’ve seen what PMJ can do, think about the possibilities of their version of Boulevard of Broken Dreams.

[@auroraobers1]

Love Haley - Seven Nation Army, Lovefool and her with Puddles the Clown doing Mad World for PMJ and her with her dad at Chess Records. Pmj- all about that bass, but with Kate Davis playing a stand up bass and singing, Shake it off with Von Smith.

[@bobpeacock3842]

Speaking as an "Old Timer", After I heard Haley sing "Creep" for the 1st. time, I pictured myself back in a 30s-40s era, in a late night juke-joint, listening to Ella Fitzgerald sing. That's the only other singer I can put up with Haley Reinhart. I appreciate your work. RWP.

[@sallysmith5090]

Watching you watch this was priceless... check out Haley Reinhart and Morgan James singing a cover of the Beadles "Dear Prudence"thats a great one too.. both have sung with PMJ... and as it has been stated below Casey Abrams (The stand up bass player) who was also on American Idol is a part of Post Modern Jukebox.... Between that show and The Sing Off.. nice showcase/treasure trove!

[@serenepeacefulrelaxingmusi3874]

It was a flawless performance.

[@stormy081464]

Told you so!!! This is a giant rabbit hole to jump into !

[@lrfcowper]

You're going to get a lot of recommendations for other Haley songs which area awesome, so let me mention some other awesome / fun ones: Thriller, Perfect Duet, Blurred Lines (yes, even if you seriously hates the original like I do, check it out), Mr Blue Sky, Juice, anything with Miche Braden or Morgan James, All of Me, Video Killed the Radio Star, and, I repeat, anything featuring Miche Braden or Morgan James.

[@justinvincent8987]

You MUST react to their rendition of Don’t Speak by No Doubt. That is their song now. Phenomenal!

[@heatherwicker9990]

Her single Dont Know How to Love you is fantastic too.

[@Violet316]

Loved your reaction, her doing Seven Nation Army next. Haley also has a song called "Free" and she just released a new song this week called "Roll the Dice".

[@becca2383]

Another first for me! That was great!

[@rayhutchinson640]

Eargasm guaranteed, with every listen!!!

[@elizabethperkins7262]

I will watch anything with Haley. Love her so much

[@danielcarter94]

Haley’s album of 60’s and 70’s tracks. Baby, it’s You and White Rabbit. Gorgeous covers. Perfectly done. Can’t recall the name of the album. It is one of the song names….

[@carajay1851]

I had that same reaction when I first heard this version. It's always on repeat and I have to stop and watch every time x

[@Russ_Keith]

First off, congrats on the 10k. That was FAST! You so deserve it. When it comes to PMJ you are as likely to find a duff track as you are with PTX. i.e. you're not. They have a real knack for getting the right singer for the song and the accompaniments are to die for. So go ahead, dip in. If pressed (and it's been a minute let me tell you but that's another story) I'd suggest Mad World ft. Puddles Pity Party & Haley Reinhart because, well just because. The first frame will explain all. Onwards and upwards!

[@blu82fan]

So there is very little from PMJ that I don't like. You really can't go wrong with any of it. But some of my favorites: Zombie ft. Maiya Skyes (she envokes all the emotions in that song). Dream On ft Morgan James Their cover of Africa which is a fun video too. Mad World ft Puddles Pity Party and Haley Reinhart Seven Nation Army ft Hailey Sooooo many are so good though!

[@rossinme]

PMJ "Lovefool" with Haley is special

[@NightFogFilms]

Check out All About That Bass with Haley Reinhart, Morgan James and Ariana Savalas (Telly “Kojak” Savalas’ daughter) - kzbin.info/www/bejne/l33Ri2SEhtJlq80&ab_channel=PostmodernJukebox and Dream On with Morgan James - (kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6KXfHRmorqheZo)

[@MrGobluebilly]

"Dream On" PMJ featuring Morgan James is awesome.

[@georgephillips3625]

They're known to take popular songs and make them sound vintage 1920s to 1950s.

[@chitownsiren]

Morgan James w Post Modern Jukebox singing a basic Maroon 5 song, MAPS, turns it into a GD masterpiece! Also, Morgan and Haley singing the Beatles Dear Prudence is heaven.

[@agwyvern]

You'll get a batch of around 5-10 songs with multiple recommendations (all will be great). There are *hundreds* to choose from. My recommendation (I have several, which I've stated at other locations) would be ... - Is there a song from the past 25 years that you despise? - Is there an artist that you refuse to listen to? - Is there a genre of which you are just not a fan? Pick one (or more) of those, and go to the PMJ channel, then search the videos for that song (fair chance you'll get a hit), that artist (really good chance you'll get hits), or that genre (guaranteed you'll get hits). Press 'Play'. I'm serious. Nine Inch Nails as 70's funk. Lizzo's 'Juice' redeemed. My Heart Will Go On rediscovered in Doo Wop format. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For as Gospel. Bieber and Swift turned enjoyable. :-D

[@lindashankar8286]

Thank you for introducing me to this! It is amazing, as you said. Love your channel. I came because of PTX and I look forward to more Pentatonix reviews. But I also like other things you do like this one!

[@TeaTimeWithTravis]

Thank you ! So good right ?!

[@awalmer5]

@@TeaTimeWithTravis Did you ever see that they did that in ONE take on a break in the middle of a tour, somewhere in Europe. ONE TAKE!!!!! And you're correct that this is incredible.

[@lisazaccardimeunier8378]

On American Idol she was a diamond in the rough with more talent than she knew what to do with.

[@bertpainter8385]

Too many comments to read through but I hope someone mentioned the fact the Haley recorded this while being run down and getting sick on a tour with PMJ. She did it in one take according to Scott Bradley. Haley wanted to redo it because she felt she could do it better. But Scott said "No I think we got it". I wish Haley would sing more of the old classics today. She is such a talent and there are so many songs she's sang in the past either for fun or on Idol that blew me away when she went with that raspy rock vocals she uses. The girl can flat out sing.

[@lauragreen5622]

PMJ is awesome. One of my favorites is their klezmer version of Talk Dirty to Me.

[@jodypark8898]

You should check out Haley's version of Habits!

[@barbaraflorentine2043]

Best reaction for the best voice!

[@whydarumisgone]

She has more control over her vocals than I do over my day to day life lol 😂

[@bartdrennon1764]

It's noteworthy how many of these reaction people are speechless at the end of this number.

[@SissyKool]

Really hoping to see some more pmj reactions!