纯享：硬糖少女303《Handclap》 | 2021江苏卫视跨年演唱会 | 腾讯音乐TME | 2021音乐流行

[@Santpkin369]

Curley g希林是真的厲害，氣場超強，完全掌控了舞台節奏，跳舞厲害，唱歌巨巨巨厲害👍🏻

[@felixsunshine9482]

The girl with the ponytail was honestly the only stable one.

[@talentedgroupsaremylife928]

She’s Curley Gao!

[@moonlight_5244]

Best center

[@moonlight_5244]

Don’t forget about Wang Yijin 2:10

[@M4tchazz]

Omi god you should hear her "someone you loved" cover its so good

[@felixsunshine9482]

@@M4tchazz I just did. Her voice is amazing.

[@peachyl9028]

Honestly, I respect them for having 100% mic on with no backing track in the biggest live event of the year. I dare to say that they are the only one idol groups that did it in this event because I watched from beginning to an end. However, Mostly of them are not stable enough and they need more practice singing live. I knew It’s hard for live singing and dancing together but you can do it girls. Xilin and Yijin did a great job here, other members need more practice.

[@zamijuju5587]

my respect level for bonbongirls brave enough to sing mic on 100% with no backing track, even it's not perfect but I liked it a lot. the feeling of realness and everything I was impressed with. I hope they can increase confidence and do it again in the future. I love this kind of attitude and braveness they have for opportunities to be on every stages. my girls I am so proud of them.

[@peachpanda88]

I am not sure about the others girls but to be fair in all of Curley's solo & collab performances she always have mic on with ZERO backing. She always sang live except during BBG performance so she is technically more accustomed to live singing compared to lip-sync, I can tell she was always better during lives,

[@KenYoshiharu]

Watching all of their performances in this stage makes me feel as exhausted as they are. Even their main vocals are having hard time keeping up with the singing and losing breath here and there, let alone the dancers. Yijin is probably the only one who sings closest to her peak performance but really appreciate their live singing though.

[@xmeng137]

But did it worsen their dancing? Like Xu Yiyang said during Chuang202, it’s great to be brave, but if it drags down the overall performance then you’ve failed.

[@azmiaziz2549]

Yessss 🥰

[@user-dd4vk7bj7b]

@@M4tchazz Yes, I agree. And I rather see performances with 100% mics on, it's just more real and they can see their problems and improve.

[@nidting6588]

Curley Gao & Nene & Chen Zhuoxuan 💗😘

[@aparecidasantana6115]

Ffgfffffgggggggggggbhhhggggggggggggggr FGFFGR TU R ecife S À Ń À Á Ñ 5YY Á Ñ 5YY trad Tag S S FGFFGR crescer Hugh 💗😘

[@budisalim4557]

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😢🎉🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😂

[@budisalim4557]

😂😂😂😂🎉🎉😢😮😮😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😮

[@budisalim4557]

😢😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@budisalim4557]

😮😮😮😮😊

[@cc8588]

Nene, curley, yijin and xuan sing very well. 😉

[@ahoc14]

WOW BONBON GIRLS this has to be their best performance as a group. Singing live without backtracking. Curley carried it as the center!

[@mabelrandomsquishyvids5835]

Curley and NeNe carried this 👑❤️

[@云-m2l]

我知道為何希林會第一了.....我不是她的粉，但她唱跳完成度是最高的

[@tianyangliu9297]

全能

[@xinwang5478]

不愧是C位，也谢谢颗粒

[@dialing1111]

對 其他都不是很穩

[@janet2964]

气是真的足，又唱又跳的还不带喘

[@aileefhienchua9889]

Curley voice unique that alots of song suit her voice..ballad,rap,sweet,etc

[@kikawaii7561]

Damnn Curley’s vocals🥵🥰🥰 Zhuoxuan, Nene, and Yijin’s too damnn... they need to work on the choreo though 🥵

[@genieldoblados6676]

they have to sing live most of their performances so they have to lessen the movements, even the members who dont sing much have to actually sing. take rocket girls 101 as an example, most of them cant sing well but you can still hear their voices during their performances..

[@kelvinfai43]

希林真的好稳连续3首歌，声音也很突出

[@shahriarsadikjarifdaisy9692]

This song is kinda weird for me. It doesn't fit for the girls. Curley could carry the performance well because she can carry out any kind of song. But the rest...... I mean Nene, Xhouxuan, Yijin are great vocals. They couldn't show their vocal talent at all. It's a pity....

[@ggstan2439]

True, Curley adn Yijin are their best vocals but are not treated as main vocals at all.

[@leehui4035]

True

[@ms.random6203]

Agree. Only Curley can sing.

[@袁鱼欣-b2s]

Sing it no in the key

[@changweien9350]

This song is NOT suitabke for singing Its for danceing

[@xiaoyuezhang4256]

My one pick Curley!!!!

[@TJ_Dynamics]

That pony tail girl graduated from Berkeley college, that's why she's at another level! Some of other vocalists are good too but need more training still.

[@nancygrg2849]

And to get addmission in berklee is not joke at all . Its her hard work and her unique vocal which leads her to berklee.

[@talentedgroupsaremylife928]

She’s called Curley G and she has a youtube channel featuring her past songs before she joined Chuang!

[@guinnmyahslaysstaymad]

The others are actually good expecially wang yijin but this was a foreign language and it just wasn’t the best song choice

[@愛新覺羅弘曆]

當時很多人對希林C位很有意見，但團隊表演後才真正覺得她唱跳真的很能吸引目光，可惜蘇芮琪或徐藝洋沒入團，不然她們兩個小C可以減少希林的負擔，因為這個團最大問題就是成員不是太偏唱歌（如陳鄭王），就是太偏舞蹈（趙劉）。

[@maru6858]

Nene you did great love you

[@rolfazodepec5242]

Wow Curley Gao your the best💙💙💙

[@thinair6338]

You can she why the C girl is an ace. There's no doubt about it. She can pull and rock everything

[@fatfran309]

That is really Crystal Clear !!!! Most important !! Curley now !! Dances sooo well !

[@thinair6338]

@@fatfran309 ❤🔥❤

[@lsusan3840]

true!

[@qianc3919]

curley is sooo stable singing and dancing at the same time

[@choyingthosam1987]

Wang yijin and cunley were perfect,

[@Privateuser68]

Please give Curley Gao some Solo Stages !!!!! Her performance is very ATTRACTIVE.

[@syahputraraharja7483]

Curley you killing me😭😭😭🔥❤️❤️❤️

[@Suphawan02]

Nene Zheng Naixin 🤟❤️🍭🍓

[@curleyskeli5235]

My Vocal Queen Curley 👑

[@fatfran309]

As well as her dancing

[@thinair6338]

No doubt! She is an ace! 🔥🔥

[@estherliu7196]

Yes

[@weichen9792]

全團只服希林 第一名真的實至名歸 唱很穩跳也很好

[@twwuwu7527]

I really noticed Yijin is very versatile, she never fails any concept

[@jeffli4642]

唱英语歌的时候，希林简直开了挂一样了，跟其他几个vocal都拉开了距离

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅😂😅🎉😅😂😅😅🎉😅😂🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😊🎉😊🎉🎉😊🎉

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅😅😂😅🎉😅🎉🎉😊🎉🎉🎉

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅😅😂😅😂😅🎉😅😂😂

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉🎉

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉🎉

[@lalalai0905]

curley gao希林哇哈哈哈全員都很愛唉哈哈哈😘😘😂

[@twwuwu7527]

Saw Yifan's potential since day 1 and she absolutely doesn't let us down!

[@jqxx2538]

哇唧肯让糖妹开麦确实不错，但是也需要练好，准备好，尤其是舞担的现场实力，跳舞也要齐一点。加油吧，硬糖是有实力的，主唱发挥得都不错

[@BONBONGIRLS]

這個舞台是自己跟導演徵求全開麥的

[@lizaberdejo8053]

Curley your voice is awesome.💙💙💙💙💙💙💙.Amazing performance Bonbon Girls.👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🍭🍭🍭🍭🍭🍭🍭

[@kintaro444]

Nene ♡ good job all for being on mic. Respect

[@putrinadia7318]

Of course curley Gao . She voice so strong and powerfull Ong i loveher

[@perriesaga7725]

Curley really stood out in this one. ZY, LXN, & ZYF are not as bad as when I first watched but Curley still manages to blow me away with her overall performance. 定海神针 of the group indeed

[@ChuHuiEng]

希林，nene，艺瑾和卓旋的vocal是真的稳，赵粤和些宁有待加强vocal，一凡今天的vocal不错，整体来说舞蹈是不错，可是有点不齐

[@jen_6757]

nene高音有点破音啊还得练练

[@ChuHuiEng]

@@jen_6757 没办法，那也是她们第一次全开麦

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

Yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy76676

[@sridevijarapala9740]

All rounder Xillin love you so much 🇮🇳💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💓💚🧡💗💖💕🖤💛❤💙👍

[@zeyez6438]

Congratulations to xilin for being the only one who passed the test 🤯

[@nonenone241]

they need to practice on their vocals except for nene, curly gao and the girl in 2:10, the rest of them were like forcing their vocals for reach the notes but impressed bc they sing live. the outfits are just perfect

[@รัตนาต่วนขาว-ม9ซ]

💕💕Nene 😍😍

[@krystal7790]

I love love love Liu Xiening's voice when she raps 🥰😻 it's so nice and deep I hope we can her more of it ❤

[@psychedelicacynical]

I think it's admirable they even challenged themselves to take on a song in a language that most of the members don't even know

[@iMosi]

nene voice is pretty but she need more control. you can hear the shakiness. They did great. Kudos to them i never expect anything this live with no back up lol

[@jaraweech7362]

Only Nene and Curly can do it . This song high note for all

[@worawongdher7188]

No matter how, sing live better than lypsyn, that full of energy, full of emotion, inner full, that i feel the stage, very lively. Love you all bon bon girls. Love love.

[@sunshinemingi2967]

is it just me or does the song don’t fit their voices?? like they somewhat can’t keep up with the pace of the song. ik they can do much better than this, but on the bright side, curley carried the whole performance..

[@LaineML]

I think they didn’t adjust the key to make it more comfortable for the girls. It is too low for many of them so they end up speaking instead of singing the lines

[@sunshinemingi2967]

@@LaineML what i was trying to say EXACTLY and the tempo of the song just doesn’t fit for the girls to hit any high notes.. i feel bad for them. hope they come back with a bomb stage performance to prove these haters wrong 😖✊

[@glitching8012]

@@sunshinemingi2967 ikr. I knew Zhuoxuan is good at singing but she was off beat this time and having a hard time hitting the notes.

[@vaivaeb9724]

I agree with you

[@louisacheung100]

agree, the only one who fits this song best is Curley.

[@nunewNunew-xt3jd]

Nene sing and Yifan dance good part.

[@fatfran309]

Rock It !! Curley G !!!

[@nenefanclub3016]

Nene❤️

[@billychandra4477]

😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@fan-dr5tq]

Curley 💙

[@yuetyuet7970]

第一次听硬糖无修音的 我觉得张艺凡很棒❤️她虽然没有其他人那么有经验，但也不比其他人逊色，而且还算得上很好了 希林和王艺谨没有太大差别 nene和陈卓璇如想像中有点差别 (纯粹个人意见)

[@jaroonlaplamool2045]

Nene is so cute.👍👍🤟🤟❤️❤️

[@nhiang4321]

In my opinion, Curley Cao and Nene save the song, the others sound quite tired :'>>

[@fullsunvelvet5321]

Honestly, this performance was okay in some aspects. The song didn't really fit most of the girl's vocals. It felt honestly towards Curley Gao who perfectly fits for it. Nene did great too because of her better pronunciation. All in all, it felt odd, since a lot of them couldn't pronounce the lyrics well and making it sound like a mumble with the low key they are using. But overall, great job on them for their live performance!

[@sayonaravine1598]

CURLEY GAO💙🇧🇷

[@khanits1019]

Honestly Gao and Nene are main vocal!!

[@ariannalasquite3992]

what a powerful voice of curely

[@thaisregina4620]

I love bonbon so much!!! But Zhang Yifan is my baby and sometimes I catch myself thinking that maybe she would look good in rap line. She is improving a lot and I'm proud of her. Proud of all of them actually and want to give all my love to their work.

[@fan-dr5tq]

I do really love their performance here although it's not perfect. Also, the choreography here was so lit🔥Curley 💙💙💙

[@M4tchazz]

I hope they get choreos like this with an upbeat song. They are already in sync here

[@Chen.35]

希林娜依高 is that what you want to spell for your username?

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

Juiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii yang tidak pernah tahu di Sumedang kab Bali and download music

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

Yyyyy

[@sichengwang8308]

哇第一次听到硬糖全开麦无修音的表演，希林还是稳，其次是王艺瑾。陈卓璇和neinei有点离想象中有差距。

[@yuetyuet7970]

我觉得张艺凡很棒❤️ 希林完全没有差别

[@readyforthisshit]

@@yuetyuet7970 张艺凡声音是好听 可是声音太小了 唱功还需要加强 刘姐就有点不行了😂🤣

[@aixuegao3518]

嗯，不过毕竟陈姐和nene是半路出家的就会唱的没有那么好

[@vancao9443]

王艺瑾不是很好吗？

[@readyforthisshit]

@@vancao9443 一斤还是输过希林一点 不过真的很好了

[@พลอยพลอย-ส2บ]

Nene 😍😍😍

[@dpnanh1739]

希林太棒了！爱了💕

[@syahputraraharja7483]

Curley❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@kowcgco1233]

她们的歌舞翩翩动听,明亮凉爽,Nene郑乃馨先生一如既往的美丽。💕✨

[@qiantong322]

nene最棒又好看又有实力

[@qianc3919]

curley

[@UnKnOwN-ee3wm]

Zhao Yue and Xiening seems to be out of breath! But its okay they're dance was AMAZING

[@fahrijav4xofficial]

Both of them already great with her ways and its kinda risk to dancer to try sing without back up vocal🥲

[@UnKnOwN-ee3wm]

@@fahrijav4xofficial Yeah I agree

[@Mylantram]

Curley G

[@phochk2564]

Nene so great ❤️❤️❤️

[@findingyuri5467]

希林帅炸！

[@jacers14]

People are too use to Idol groups with BackingTracks that they think that is the REAL VOICE of the idols while performing. Honestly the Dance line here needs to work on vocals But the 4 Vocals were stable. And STABLE I mean you will notice that their movement of the mics affects the sound and alot of other things.

[@twwuwu7527]

很意外这首一斤hold得最好，完全唱在调上!

[@ngoanphamphuoc5351]

Chen ZhouXuan , NeNe and Curley Gao 😘😘😘

[@jeanhanslodeva4955]

王艺瑾 刘些宁 郑乃馨 wangyijin Sally nene

[@cleofame324]

Xilin's voice is like a thunder so strong and powerful 😍😁

[@cream5656]

Great job Nene!!~ 👏👏👏👏

[@nawapornkunachon8727]

NENE 💛

[@angelaz2576]

uuuuuuuuuuh..... I appreciate them singing live but I think without 7 Curleys it's not possible to make the song perfect.

[@M4tchazz]

Well nothings perfect 😊 everyone needs practice and they got a lot of praise for the courage

[@cnkpomelo5695]

Nene so​ cute :) 🍓🍓

[@jerylxt]

1:05 so lit

[@michadolfo8719]

Chen Zhuoxuan 💮陈卓璇💐

[@UnKnOwN-ee3wm]

CURLEY SLAYED!!

[@yoonastrash4953]

nene baby you did amazing ❤️

[@rezaariantosultan1963]

Curley Gao 🔥🔥🔥❤️❤️

[@Dominic199o]

劉些寧和趙粵剛剛第一首唱的像氣虛，在這終於唱回來了

[@vie8499]

Curley Gao 💜💜 .nene😘😘

[@tongtonmai5969]

🍋Liu xiening🍋You are the best dance that looks super powerful , I like your singing and everyone in BonBongirls 303 . All of you are the wonderful girl group. ❣️ BonBongirls 303

[@dialing1111]

1:09唱的最好

[@talentedgroupsaremylife928]

是希林娜依高哦，谢谢赏识！

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅😂😅🎉😅😅😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅😅😅🎉🎉😅🎉😅😅😅🎉😅🎉🎉😅😊🎉

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😮🎉😅😂😅😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉🎉🎉😅😂😅🎉😊😂🎉😂

[@BudiYanto-yn1wm]

😂😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅😂😅😂😅🎉😊🎉😊🎉😂😊😂😊🎉😊🎉

[@orangestop305]

อย่างน้อง ร้องสดคือกล้ามาก แบบไม่มีแบคกราวน์ mic on 100%👍

[@nnantipoxn2171]

งานใหญ่มากกกกกก แต่น้องๆกลับกล้าร้องสดอ่ะ ในงานนี้คือไม่มีวงไหนมาร้องสดสักกะคน ยอมจุยย

[@limhokeang4010]

糖果太棒了，全员全开麦还那么稳， Respect 💕 未来可期，加油加油💕 糖纸们永远是你的外衣支持你们啊🍭 🍭万丈光芒不一般，硬糖少女303🍭

[@dialing1111]

这。。。这也叫稳？

[@xinbeileeyau5566]

@@dialing1111 这首的表现在全开麦的情况里面是算稳的

[@xinbeileeyau5566]

@@dialing1111 超A就不太稳 但是这首可以

[@onceagain2818]

大部份人氣息有點不穩，趙廣東和Sally 特別明顯，舞蹈相對不算太激烈的狀態下真的要好好練一下 btw全開咪而言是合格值以上，大概70分左吧，個人認為

[@dialing1111]

@@onceagain2818 對呀

[@dialing1111]

1:27 我嚇到了 她怎麼那麼多人讃呀😨

[@twwuwu7527]

飘了还有粉丝说很好我也惊了唉

[@dialing1111]

@@twwuwu7527 9494

[@dialing1111]

@@twwuwu7527 都不知道为什么团员实力会这样，只会跳舞唱不好歌，但唱跳女团不能这样吧

[@twwuwu7527]

@@dialing1111 被粉丝宠的吧，路人就是听了粉丝的鬼话对团员预期过高，会反感唉

[@BONBONGIRLS]

@@dialing1111 素質跟唱跳實力的關聯性是？

[@哈哈哈-c6l]

我很喜歡希林，也覺得她超棒,唱的也超棒 但是真的沒必要把她的妝畫的很不適合她 感覺很顯老真的！

[@xinwang5478]

同意

[@xinbeileeyau5566]

她在总决赛和我们的歌2妆发都挺好看的 不知道为什么每次团体的妆发都不好

[@哈哈哈-c6l]

對啊真的，一回到團體，妝就很顯老，完全不懂是怎麼回事，哈哈哈哈

[@anis0269]

Liu xiening so beautiful

[@naelly75]

yifan❤❤❤nene❤❤❤curley

[@KimYung_GemmeryJayne_Luong]

Except from Nene Curley and Zhuoxuan ( she sounds tired during beggining ), the rest was quite unstable

[@AppleBoy-ep5tz]

You underestimate yijin's voice

[@四叶草-d1s]

陳卓璇的舞蹈很好，表情到位，唱跳穩，最抓眼球

[@dreamangels2110]

except for curley and nene, the rest of the girl's English pronunciation was not on point. Does anyone agree?

[@mylove9693]

Nene郑乃馨👍

[@DPP100]

nene 郑乃馨💕

[@myra12074]

希林超強 但王藝異常的好呢 nene也很好