Testing a Soap Frosting Recipe |

[@nicoleswanson4128]

You should make a soap for Lily! Change it slightly, or dramatically, as she grows up. Then when she’s old enough to change it, let her make changes.

[@CuriosityRocks]

The colour powder looks so pretty swirling round the liquid 😍

[@kathrynd6779]

CuriosityRocks Yesss that's what I really like about mica.

[@monicatrietsch7605]

Katie..... can you please show us how it looks and feels after its been all hard??? please..... and also if its not too much to ask if you can try it under water to see how it foams.... please pretty please.....

[@happyskye6713]

This frosting looks a lot more realistic! Love it!

[@sweetisrobottt]

Hi Katie! I was wondering if you could comment on how hard the frosting got after it sat for awhile?

[@emailpearlene]

Hello, I also would like to know if the frosting got hard after 24 hours

[@AM-uo9qx]

I would like to know as well! Hard enough to packed for gift

[@ThatBetchEllie]

I’m guessing we never found out?

[@paintedperfect3411]

I'd also be interested to find out

[@debfiel6585]

I made this and it stayed soft. I did find a video that the melt and pour soap frosting worked well. "HOW TO Make Whipped Melt & Pour Soap Frosting" at Before Bed.... This frosting did pipe beautifully and I wish it would have gotten hard. It didn't for me but I am at a high altitude too and maybe that affected the results??

[@clle_srra]

This is great Katie! Thanks so much for sharing. Never would have thought soap frosting was possible with melt and pour soap.

[@seejanehere]

Wonderful! I purchased your soap recipe but I have been searching for a quicker version to have on hand if I don't have all the other oils I need. Thank you for helping me with all my soapy projects -love this!

[@donnaharris6]

Your giggle is contagious! 😊 I really enjoy your videos!!!

[@babygurl4492]

Accidentally found your channel, found my new obsession!!! 😊

[@karlavelasquez3831]

I love how you teach us to make things. I did this recipe tonight, I loved how the frosting came out. I'm hoping that by tomorrow the frosting will be hard. The bad thing that I had a quite a bit left over.

[@leticiawilliams9808]

Did the frosting get hard or was it soft😮

[@JayAnnsCreations]

Thank you sooooo much Katie! I wanted so badly to do soap cupcakes for Christmas gifts but could not find a trust worthy recipe. Merry Christmas 💛

[@imlinhh5443]

wow, I'm looking for a soap frosting recipe without cold process, thank you so much. but if I don't have foaming bath whip, can I use hand wash or something else?

[@mycraftycrochetshop2496]

Thank you so much for showing this. I'm just starting into this soaping world. Tried finding a great melt & pour frosting. I think you nailed it spot on. I'll be trying it out this week. I ship a lot of my products so I hope it will be shippable. I love your videos your so awesome! Thank you so much!

[@soniasamson6133]

Hello Wonderful Carson Family! I wonder how you process your orders and organize to ship them. It would be great to learn about that! Thank you for all you are doing already!

[@sherrywhitman9820]

I am just starting out with Melt and Pour and wanted to pipe the tops of soap loaves like you do.. So, thank you so much for making this video.

[@krystolmoon]

Thanks for sharing this recipe. I look forward to trying it out when I start making soap!

[@jessicalewis1124]

Ik this is a older video but I used this recipe and it worked amazing

[@sherit8594]

So the frosting hardened as a soap ?

[@meloniebush9240]

This would be a perfect thing to do for a kids birthday party! My 12 year old would absolutely LOVE this!

[@suicidalgeishas]

Oooooo thank you for the video! I'm one of those people terrified of cold process lol

[@sheilikas8910]

Does the whipping stick to the cupcake? Since you didn't spray ra on it?

[@BEYONDREACHSTUDIOS]

You are a constant source of inspiration and ideas.. many thanks!

[@etchedinstone1]

As always, amazing videos and very entertaining!

[@daybyday1664]

Thank you! I was about to lose my mind finding a great whipped frosting tutorial.

[@AnaBarbara420]

I swear ur videos are so satisfying to watch!!😍

[@mabellerahme]

Hello , if i cant find a foaming bath whip , what can i use instead ?

[@SummonerOrthan]

This is also a good soap for a beginner soap maker!

[@namrataghosh7408]

does it get hard after the whole thing is done? it would be very helpful if you could answer that

[@HowToMakeSoapOnADime]

Thanks for sharing. I keep melting my piping with the heat of my hands to so I might give this one a try!

[@isabellac2037]

Love the nail polish you're wearing where is it from

[@taeishablack9042]

Hi Katie, do have a video that shows how to make CP frosting from scratch or a recipe to purchase.

[@leonorgross1479]

I loved the cupcakes ♥️♥️♥️

[@lillypawsltd79]

Would this work on top of bath bomb cupcakes too?

[@aimenkhan127]

Hey Katie, i had watched your videos and i really get inspired with them, can you please tell that if we piping with melt and pour so will it sweat or looses it shapes or its get soft after piping and drying?

[@elizabethC19]

I make my frosting soap w melted white melt and pour & clear unscented liquid soap while I'm blending w a hand mixer until fluffy and then I pipe it and let it cool and set up.

[@FarmerC.J.]

So cool! Thank you! Are the sprinkles basic sugar sprinkles like one would Use on edible cup cakes?

[@ThreesiaGoff]

Wondering if it actually stuck to the base?

[@RoyaltySoaps]

It stuck pretty well, enough to not break when packaged. But it would slide off when wet.

[@ElizabethDMoody]

This was awesome. Can't wait to try this out.

[@mariagonzalezdemolina5120]

Hello, I want to say thank you for all your video,,,I LOVE THEM Spc with the family and God bless you... I would like to know do you have tutorial on how to make soap frosting/piping? oooh and do you need to use FORMING BATH WHIP for melt in pour and does this work for cold process soap? :)

[@reneecormalis624]

It was interesting to watch, I don't think I would have had enough nerve to experiment with it. Thanks for doing it for us!!!

[@paigescorpion7946]

Do you always use fragrance oil in the frosting? What about in the embeds & soap gumballs?

[@sheronbrewer4255]

Hi Katie! I make CP but have been interested in MP frosting..trying to figure out how it actually performs. How hard did your frosting become? Would you be able to ship them the way this recipe turned out? Thanks and Merry Christmas to you & your beautiful little family!

[@mycraftycrochetshop2496]

I tried this recipe and it did really well. I didn't use any shea butter in it and did good. Although with my first try it was a lil sticky after a day of it sitting out. Wondering why? Should I use something else? Idk. But it did well with just to ingredients I hope it will harden more.

[@denisesmith7016]

The recipe didn't look like is was going to work at first but glad it did. I've never made soap before but I can't wait to try..God bless!

[@rachelgarcia1987]

Would this measurement be enough to go on top of a basic melt and pour soap loaf?

[@Lovebug04]

wondering if you have to use the Shea butter??

[@charlenechari]

Is there an alternative I can use to whip it up if I don't have the foaming bath? We don't get that where I live.

[@temanbelajar5495]

Can i replace the shea butter with another butter or colled oil?

[@JaneThomas58]

Hi, great videos. Is there a reason to use unrefined shea butter vs refined?

[@RoyaltySoaps]

I just did it because unrefined is a yellow color and I wanted white frosting. You could use both. :)

[@billinswpdx]

Cool. Thanks Katie

[@DickyBenfield]

Did the frosting seem to harden like you expect or does it kind of remain soft?

[@buttermilkbaysoap9416]

Katie I'm looking for a comparable brown mica and fragrance oil from Brambleberry to make chocolate candy M&P embeds since I'm placing a larger order with them. Any suggestions?

[@backbaydishes]

Thank you for sharing! Will have to try it!

[@MiniCooper007]

Hi. Did the frosting set hard?

[@LycansLife]

So if it starts to stiffen say similar to marshmallow consistency or a bit more tough, just keep mixing? Or did I botch this

[@veronicavjo]

Hi Katie can I use this frosting for cupcakes in cp??

[@dinolandra]

I can't imagine this hardened a whole lot since shea butter is so soft. It looks great though! Makes me want to make real cupcakes lol

[@OzarkSoaper]

Was it difficult to pipe I have carpel tunnel and it seemed like you were having to push quite a bit to get it through the tip.

[@tinytimfangurl5461]

Hello, novice soap-maker here! I tried this recipe today and I was wondering if the frosting is supposed to take significantly longer to dry than the actual soap. I made my batch this morning and the cake part of the soap seems completely hard but the frosting is still creamy. I’m wondering if it takes a day or two to dry down or if I messed it up somehow?

[@Rensremedies]

Caitlyn Carr had this same issue. The first time I made it the stuff hardened right away, and so I decided to do a large batch. It’s been about 18 hours and still soft. So weird. Wondering what happened.

[@tinytimfangurl5461]

Ren's Remedies It took almost 2 weeks for mine to finally harden- so strange! I ended up having to cut it into bars and let the frosting completely harden after they were cut up. The next batch I made hardened instantly but looks a lot less nice and realistic and glossy than the original batch I made. They looked the same in the bowl but look completely different piped. The original batch was smooth and piped beautifully and remained glossy, the next batch looks almost like whipped buttercream with more air bubbles in it. I prefer the first batches appearance and more flexible time window, but the dry time just isn’t very realistic for me. Not sure why they turned out so different.

[@mztee29]

I loveeeee this. Tfs!

[@calisuds9830]

How long do you let it get hard before you package them my Dear Katie??

[@domopix4387]

Yayayyayya more vids..... She makes my sour days, sugary and sweet

[@jamiejamerson15]

Does this frosting harden?

[@smolshay]

Is this frosting a recipe you have to take off before using the soaps or one one can just keep in the shower or bath?

[@L-M-O-1]

Cheyenne Watson it is a soap. You can keep it on the cupcake bottom. The whole thing is soap

[@angelapplepie]

Will this work with Palm Oil?

[@ijuoi06]

Pretty please can u make a Soap frost diy but with the lye. i would love to know how.

[@gramma9826]

What was the texture of the frosting after being allowed to set? Was it spongy or still tacky? Can you package it? So many questions left out of your video which is strange because usually you give us all that information and more

[@CupcakeChanny]

When you pipe soap do you have to have specific soap piping sets or can you use baking stuff? Btw: they look delicious. I’d be tempted to eat them 😂

[@Lovebug04]

you can use regular cake stuff as long as you don't plan on using it for food again :)

[@lyndamccoy9602]

I tried that mixture and it's been 3 days and my frostings not dry yet. Any suggestions from anyone

[@marykrafts4607]

I've used this and it stays a marshmallow like not really hard I even tried adding kaolin clay if I were to give it a star rating 1-5 it would be a 3 it's hard to work with. Really like doing CPOP after an hour in oven at 150-160* it goes through gel I let it sit in oven till next day. Less cure time do about 2 weeks to harden up bars. Or a fluid HP I don't like waiting 6wks for CP I'm impatient

[@suzannerwt]

Did it get hard enough to wrap?

[@Moonpaperr]

can we get a compilation like this? jeje

[@locklearca]

I need advice. I made this frosting yesterday for some soap cupcakes, but for some reason my frosting is still like soft whip topping consistancy. It piped nicely and looks fine, but if you touch it is still not dry 24hrs later. What could I do? Should I scrape it off and add something to firm it up? Help please : )

[@locklearca]

Update....scraped frosting off and I added more melt and pour.....it worked!!!!

[@Rensremedies]

locklearca how much more did you add? Having the same issue!

[@locklearca]

Ren's Remedies I added approximately 4 oz. more soap. You will have to work fast though, mine firmed up quickly. Not a fan of this recipe, it melts off too easily when using the soap....it was gorgoeus though.

[@angelsandfaes]

I have never used a melt and pour soap that I like. They leave my skin feeling weird. Am I just using the wrong kind? I know there are sellers that use melt and pour only so I just don't understand. lol

[@WendyPowellClarinet]

It is hard to make a judgment call on melt and pour soaps since there are now over a dozen varieties on the market. You may have to try several to find one you like.

[@youartsywitch]

Same

[@jnetbeams]

Love those

[@Jakeaddicts]

I would have liked to see a lather or bubble test with this recipe.

[@brandynettleton1658]

She said she was super interested to see how it hardened up and then neglected to mention whether or not it does in fact harden. My experience with any MP based frosting concoction has always ended up kind of spongey and definitely not solid.

[@kimberleyclohecy6284]

Where is description part with recipe found?

[@lornashandmadesoaps7034]

Thanks for sharing.

[@haileyrenae4882]

SOAPMAS IS MY FAVE

[@SweetdreamsOFU]

Just for clarification, the base you used was a melt and pour with Shea butter, you didn't add your own Shea butter right?

[@L-M-O-1]

SweetdreamsOFU she added shea butter I believe

[@mermaidjacy]

very cute!

[@johexxkitten]

**wonders to self** will I die if I eat these cupcakes? Oh sod it... I’m gonna eat them anyway! They look totally worth it!! Possibly RIP Me! 🍰🤪 *Actual serious point:* I do a LOT of baking, so I’d recommend when whipping stuff, try using a slightly wider container. It gives you more air across the surface of your mixture. You’re whipping it to add air, so the more air available across the top surface allows for faster whipping. Ps: I still wanna eat those cupcakes 🤪🤪

[@carlabrewer5273]

Hi can anyone help me please? I make melt and pour soaps. For frosting I tried foaming bath butter with a small amount of melted white melt and pour soap. Whisk it until it thickens and then I pipe but it doesn’t go hard so when I shrink wrap them they become a mess. I need a recipe to create a hardish frosting. I hope someone can advice me please x

[@AGee2217]

It made me hungry haha 😂

[@Maddiepaigebates]

How hard does it get and how long will it take?

[@Lovebug04]

I did this recipe and today is the afternoon after making them last night, they are still very much so soft and when you touch them the frosting comes off. it should take a little while. probably a week?

[@jessiedesena5687]

does the frosting get hard or soft?

[@RoyaltySoaps]

Jessie DeSena It gets pretty hard. Definitely hard enough to package without fear or shifting shape. It kinda has a rubbery texture when dry but the lather is AMAZING.

[@JakkieTea]

Thanks Katie! I'd love to try this out sometime.

[@jessiedesena5687]

Royalty Soaps Thanks Katie.

[@jo-annjewett7552]

Thanks Katie! Very similar to my recipe, except I add 3 TB powdered egg whites and 1 TB glycerine and no shea but I want to try your recipe. I would love to eliminate the egg whites. I think mine really i creases in volume. I can pipe 15 cupcakes with the same measurements. I like thay and probably it is due to the egg whites, which is great for the skin. Egg white soap is popular in Scandinavian countries.

[@laurielindahl1402]

Jo Jo ... I have tried your recipe and I love it! I'm gonna try this one as well.

[@JustTrying2MakeitToJesus]

I tried the recipe you did using powder sugar,SLSA, cream of tartar, mandarin powder, cold water ect... it came out beautifully - BUT I put it in the freezer over night , took it out today to thaw & cut & it completely fell into itself 😭😭 so that one did not work for ME - I'm assuming I did something wrong bc according to others its worked 4 very well for them..I'm not sure what I did wrong- maybe putting it in the freezer was a BAD idea !?

[@tiggerfly123]

Thank you Katie I watch so many of your videos for ideas and a go to help guide. I recently found a mp frosting recipe that is just the mp base and clear hand soap the frosting does not get hard but hard enough I could package them but eventually smeared on the bags. Have you tried this and how does it compare to this recipe if you have. Thank you 💙

[@yvonnekeehn7068]

I really enjoy watching your videos and also i absolutely love buying your products!!!!

[@christinawebb3016]

This is such a fun project, thanks for sharing.

[@justbelievebathnbodycrysta7686]

I keep melting my frosting with the heat from my hands..no matter how much my batter sets up my hands melts it as i pipe it..i got hot hands even through gloves!!! Arrrg!!!!! Those are awedorable!!!!

[@Ayeejayee13]

Just Believe Bath n Body Crystal McArthur Maybe I can offer some advice, I make cakes for a living and have a problem with hot hands melting my cake frosting. I’d recommend having a bowl cold of ice that you can dunk your hands in and then try piping your soap frosting! Hope I could help you even though I don’t make soap

[@justbelievebathnbodycrysta7686]

Aj Flores Brilliant!!! I will try that..thank you!!!!!!!!

[@Ayeejayee13]

Just Believe Bath n Body Crystal McArthur you’re welcome!

[@jlrouth]

The Great 2020 Rewatch continues onwards :)

[@firstandlast9786]

You're a soap snob. It works just as good!

[@xolveria]

Okay mine came out with to many air bubbles? Followed the recipe. Army I rather cold process

[@beccacramer7990]

That recipe is almost exactly how you make soap marshmallows.

[@WhinnyWoofMeow]

What do you end up doing with your failed experiments? What about your successful ones?

[@alwyngreen7205]

You could just add some glycerin to some MP base or use Foamy Bath Butter

[@estoeckle2710]

But how hard did the frosting get?

[@jlozano74406]

E Stoeckle it does actually harden up just like melt and pour soap!

[@jlozano74406]

Maya Fitr.i I haven’t tried it but I’ve seen a couple videos where you can just take the top off and use it like a second bar

[@EdensSecret1]

Lol, I noticed your nail varnish changed from M&P to foaming bath whip. P.S. your foaming bath whip is so different to ours here in the UK. Ours is much thicker and harder, wow. Thanks for the video

[@OnePillKillz]

wps used to be like the FBB but they changed the recipe in the FBW, has a more runny texture now

[@hayleagreaves6755]

Where do you get the whip from in the uk?

[@pennylowers9892]

I really love your videos. You are so sweet and fun. Your soap is beautiful. I don't understand the thumbs down. SOUR GRAPES perhaps?