Testing Top Rated Makeup Cleansing Balms

[@chanel58style70]

My grandmother washed her face with Ponds cold cream and also Ponds face cream as a moisturizer (no plug). I remember her bathroom containing only these 2 products. Maybe it was genetics, but all her life until the day she died, her skin looked like a baby’s skin. Funny Isn’t it, we all look for the holy grail of cleansers and moisturizers, and there are so many. I’m not putting down any product, I’m just saying that for her, being poor, she found her holy grail. Miss you Grandma.

[@rree4551]

Ahhhhh !! That is what MY grandma used also! When I was a kid, I would lock myself in her bathroom and go through all of her products ....It was one of my ‘happy places’!! Blessings to you and your family, and I miss my grandma too! She was the 💗 of our family!

[@netw52]

My grandmother, too. Ponds all the way to 93. Hardly a wrinkle.

[@chanel58style70]

@@rree4551 Thank you so much for your kind reply. I know that no one can live forever, it’s not God’s plan. But how much I wish my boys could have known my great grandparents, my grandparents, and more of my family. Along with my parents, they were some of the best family I could have asked for. God bless you.!

[@rree4551]

@@chanel58style70 I very much understand. My daughter got to know her great grandpa until she was 7. She learned a great deal of compassion towards others as my mom and I took care of him. It was a VERY difficult time but I am so thankful for it. We just have to continue telling our families how great these people were in our lives. God bless you and your loved ones as well 🌺🌺🌺

[@Nobodyシ-s7g]

I’m so sorry for your loss my grandad died..

[@tinac3880]

The Banila in the purple tub is my favorite. It takes off waterproof mascara and lash glue easily. I can’t justify spending more than $20 on cleansing balm since or use it daily and go through it so quickly!

[@Mar-velousMarlenak8]

LOL Milana that thumbnail is right on trend for Halloween! I also have super sensitive eyes so I appreciate you doing this type of review. It's so hard to know which cleanser will work without buying an entire tub that you may not like after one use.

[@DKNyborg]

I've only ever used Elf, but I'm pretty new to using a balm (thank you Robert Welch!) Maybe I'll give one of the others a try. Love this video, thank you!

[@juliehayes4891]

Same!

[@lagatita1623]

Wet& Wild has some good stuff. And a lip scrub watermelon scented.

[@angelshalo28]

James does the skin!!

[@juliehayes4891]

@@lagatita1623 I have that lip scrub and love it!

[@faerietygers1323]

@@angelshalo28 yes, but Robert does the makeup and what to use to remove it.

[@danielahaight3383]

I love the ponds cleansing balm. I found it at the store once, and then got it on Amazon. But, its so hard to find now. It really worked great. Now on the hunt for one that's not overly expensive.

[@samanthamorales-carroll4037]

I love using the Farmacy Cleansing Balm and the one from good molecules. I also trying the sephora brand. It's pretty good.

[@ilcyra]

I bought the Then I Met You cleanser on a whim a couple of years ago, and I have been loyal ever since!!

[@LauraLVTGW]

Used the Farmacy Green Clean, the Elf and the Banila Zero. I agree the Elf burned my eyes. Been using the Dear Klairs fresh cleansing oil, loving it! I love the balms for travel, oils for home.

[@Sumthing4theWkend]

I use coconut oil instead of cleansing balm @ this step…it’s cheap in comparison, removes all makeup, nourishes my dry skin, and works wonders if I have any acne spots!

[@April_K75]

Oh my goodness, I laughed so hard with your thumbnail!🤣🤣🤣 Awesome video as always!🥰

[@deliacabrera8928]

I use the yellow one, for more hydration and it does a great job with eye makeup and waterproof mascara. I’m so happy with it. My dry mature skin loves it!

[@thevintagemagnolia3448]

I am currently looking for a new cleaning balm. Was super happy when I did a search and found this video. I trust your reviews and this video helped me make an educated decision on which balm to buy for what I’m needing without trial and error with waisted product and money. Thanks a ton! 💕

[@SodaSiren]

My favorite is Clinique’s Take The Day Off Balm.

[@jackieensley1874]

Pons I wish you a big thank you because you have blown up the market on their product. It now cost $34.99 on Amazon. I wish I had bought it last night. Keep the information and the good videos coming!

[@saracristina]

I've been using the versed cleansing balm is its amazing its very hydrating and really takes your makeup off easily I love it

[@juliabelova-pachefsky4426]

I use the clean it zero in the purple tub and it's completely scent free. I have extremely sensitive and acne prone skin, and my skin has been loving it. I have used the Elf one but I did find that it irritated my eyes pretty badly to the point where it blurred my vision. So when I was using it, I would use my miscellar water wipes to take my eye make up off, and the balm for the rest of the face. I am glad I changed to the clean it zero. It's doing a great job. 👍👍

[@-nellie-m3711]

I’ve been loyal to Clinique Take the Day Off cleansing balm for years, but the only issue I have with it is that it can leave a film on your eyes if you don’t take it all off completely another Great one at a fraction of the price is the Good Molecules cleansing balm, it’s really Great in removing all your makeup and doesn’t leave a film on my eyes and it doesn’t have a scent either.

[@jerridorr107]

How much is it?

[@rare2b]

I have dry/combo and sometime dehydrated skin amd Clinique is literally perfect for me

[@Strawberry__girl13]

I agree! It always feels like I have a waxy feeling on my eyes after I use it. It’s a good product but I do not care for the feeling after.

[@faerietygers1323]

I also feel that with Clinique. I love the take off the day eyes and lips remover and never have an issue with the film and was taken aback the first time I used the balm.

[@yiolia]

I’ve tried SO many balms and the best by faaaaaar in my opinion, is the one from the body shop. They also make a cleansing oil version, just as amazing. The best balm, it has no perfume, actually removes waterproof mascara, not crazily priced and leaves absolutely no residue on the skin but also doesn’t leave it dry. Give it a try 😊

[@MsBeautyRush04]

I’m a big fan of Farmacy’s Green Clean cleansing balm! I have tried that one and also Then I Met You but I prefer Farmacy! Both are awesome cleansing balms though!

[@christyhoehn8244]

I love this thumbnail!!!! How adorable!!! Loved this “ comparison”. - I just ordered “ then I met you”….. thank you so much!!!!❤️

[@joylewullis9538]

Thanks for this testing of balms. I also do a double cleanse. Clean it zero also comes in a hydrating formula. I use that one and actually have the Ponds on order. Good, informative video.

[@maybeido03]

I have been using zero for the longest time it's soooo good! Cleans everything and my pores are not clogged!

[@lavendertwilight08]

Love the Farmacy Cleansing Balm. I want to try the GLOW recipe one next!

[@angelafahlenkamp9311]

I love them both, Glow Recioe is my absolute Favorite but I love all their products 🤷‍♀️

[@Auraya25]

I am a huge fan of the I'm from "fig cleansing balm" I love the smell (not too much) and it gets everything off in the first cleans. If you really rub it into your hairline and wash it off with warm water instead of a wet towel you don't need a second cleanser or toner. Toner anyways just dry your skin since most of them are ethanol based.

[@DeborahKeleman]

Thanks for doing this review. I actually ordered the elf one before I saw this and it will be my first time using a balm.

[@emilyg528]

I actually really love the E.L.F cleansing balm. Personally, it makes my skin feel so smooth and soft after use and does not irritate my eyes at all. I have recently bought Glow Recipe to try but want to finish up my current E.L.F. 1st.

[@angelafahlenkamp9311]

The Glow Recipe is my favorite one, Farmacy comes in second for me and then the Banila brand, I have their green one 🥰

[@Chorkymom]

How do you like the Glow recipe now?

[@angelafahlenkamp9311]

@@Chorkymom is this question for me or for the OP?

[@Zil_Senczy]

Ok I loved this video and because of it I bought Then I met you and am OBSESSED. What's killing me though is you don't have a part two of this for second step cleansers. Please please please make one! I find your recommendations really reliable. You've never steered me wrong.

[@angeles381]

I love the Banila Co, but now I love more the Good Molecules one, it doesn't have scent and don't irritate the eyes 😉

[@TheSiobhan12]

I personally love IUnik Calendula Cleansing Oil, or I using the Heimish All Clean Balm both 👍👍

[@grr848__]

how did eve lom not make this list! It's legendary

[@vzeimen]

I love Neutrogena cleansing balm. Does a great job and no scent. On Amazon 2 jars for $11.99

[@kimberlytrotter3800]

Not mentioned on here but Soap & Glory Glow your mind is amazing!!

[@ericamorgan5492]

I love the Ponds cold cream! It’s a wonderful cleanser! It’s takes off all the makeup including waterproof makeup! And it don’t bother your eyes! I encourage you to try it! And it’s so cheap!

[@Lashlove16]

I love your videos … I love using Costco organic cold pressed coconut oil and a muslin cloth . Works amazing and my skin has never been better

[@darkkstar5647]

A cleansing balm that directs you to avoid around the eye area is ridiculous. Eye makeup is typically the thickest, most pigmented cosmetic one puts on their face. If I can't use it directly on my lashes it's useless. Ponds works well but I won't buy it again unless they change that fakey scent. It almost induces a headache. Would be great to see your review of Mizon Cicaluronic! I'm hoping that one will turn out to be my holy grail of cleansing balms.

[@kazhastell1099]

Great video the only thing I would of said you should have the same make up for each day so you can see how well it does on heavy make up x

[@heidialvarez4873]

I use Soap and Glory Nourishing Cleansing Balm. It melts away makeup, including waterproof mascara, and becomes milky when water is added. It's affordable, gentle, and awesome! $11.99 at Target or a few dollars more at Ulta.

[@deebo8924]

I’ve needed this video so much! I literally Googled this for days because I know how Life changing these balms are, so thank you!!! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@caitlinboyle2741]

I noticed when you use the balm, you don't go all the way to the sideburns or side of your face, but with the toner you do. This is why you're probably seeing makeup on the pad

[@KendallM0219]

She mentioned that

[@radleyrayne287]

I love Antipodes Grapeseed Butter Cleanser. It’s beautiful, feels so moisturising, takes off make up so well & I adore the smell of it too.

[@60Airflyte]

Thank you for the review. I'm currently using Clinique's Take The Day Off Balm but it's not taking off all of my mascara. It could be my method of cleansing. I do use waterproof mascara and I don't recall you mentioning wearing that. You did mention other waterproof products. I'll finish my Clinique and then try the other top rated product. Thanks!

[@purpleskiesforever]

That is my favorite one. But I do have to rub it around my face and eyes for 90-100 seconds for it to melt waterproof makeup off.

[@alejandraislas5890]

It works well for me. Waterproof mascara/ eyeliner, everything. I massage it, use water to turn it to a milky texture and clear it with more water. That just the make removing part. Then i wash my face.

[@60Airflyte]

I had success tonight by rubbing it between my hands and then spending more time rubbing it into my eyelashes. I was just using the wrong technique. I also purchased a makeup eraser cloth.

[@amytrumbull156]

I have the same issue with one particular mascara I use and what I do is use a thicker cold cream after the balm to get the rest of the mascara off….I like Ponds cold cream or Vaseline but you can really use any type of oil or petroleum product.

[@rosieej5267]

I used Zero before and it blurred my vision when it went into my eyes. I’d close my eyes but it would still run in and I kept worrying. It’s still doing its job tho :)

[@jungkookwillbethedeathofme]

SAMEE. i love how effective it is in removing my eye makeup but my vision gets foggy and it’s so annoying i thought it was just me 😭

[@busymeowser]

Yes its the worst if you do it with contacts in your eyes. I still buy it though lol

[@SandraB1000]

Old school Pond’s in the white jar/green cap is their cold cream/cleansing balm. I just tried it for the first time since all this talk of cleansing balms has started on YT. It’s $6 a jar @walmart and works just fine - they didn’t need to create a fancier $14.99 version, but hey, I guess it’s all a big $$-market of course. 💁🏼‍♀️

[@TheMunchyelena]

Last week I spent hours on Amazon looking through cleansing balms. Derma e has a great one and I bought one by the brand versed which isn't terrific... it has eucalyptus oil and the smell is strong. I love the elf one, I also have super oily skin but never felt my skin was stripped of oils. It's one of my faves but farmasi got me on this band wagon!!! Great video

[@Nobodyシ-s7g]

Ur natural beauty is so beautiful- Ur so pretty! OML we need a morning Routine!

[@pashaboutnails5821]

Great video. Elemis (original not rose or mint) is my favourite. I have tried a few of the others in your video but I keep going back to Elemis as I love the smell. But I do like a strong scent so I will try and get the Ponds one. Thank you.

[@nikkibailey5439]

I’ve been obsessed with the shop miss a cleansing balm and the price is fantastic!!

[@laurabaldock7218]

I use that too. I bought the big tub after trying the little one. It’s so good. Works amazing. Definitely a hidden gem

[@lorimcdonald3926]

Where do I get the shop miss a cleansing balm? Fragrance free? Thanks so much. ❤

[@ykk239]

Jergens old school cold cream is the best. $3. I've tried so many others, always come back.

[@TexasMom1776]

The thumbnail is great!! 😂 I’ve been using the Clinique cleansing balm and really like it.. I tried the Glow Recipe but it burned my face 🙁

[@susanmunson6389]

I have been looking into these balms and this video was perfect! Thank you 🦋

[@nataliesheff4092]

I CANT CTRESS ENOUGH HOW MUCH I WANT YOUR OLDER HAIRSTYLES

[@katherineklevenow1808]

They are still online 🌝

[@brendastevens9077]

I Love Kora Organics Milky Mushroom Cleanser. It takes your makeup off and cleans your face effectively with certified organic ingredients that's healthy for your skin and you.😊❤

[@sarahrushton8154]

Not a balm but it emulsifies the same and they make it unscented is the pond’s cold cream. The price is unbeatable and I prefer it to balms personally 💜

[@nikkistuart4211]

I personally love Farmacy's Green Clean Makeup Meltaway Cleansing Balm. It works so good, smells so fresh and does not make my face feel gross after.

[@ANDREA-yt9dn]

Because I heart you so much, I am going to tell you the cheapest most effective makeup remover out there. And as a mommy its great to have on hand for chapped lips, burns, (including sunburn), fever blister, dry skin, any kind of chapped skin anywhere and of course, makeup removal. Drum roll please......Aquaphor! Its odorless and doesnt burn or irritate skin, even with my eczema. It moisturizes as well. Please try it if you havent already :D

[@cbchick1981]

I got a sample of the Banila Co and love it. I only where eyeshadow and have very sensitive skin and this is so far the best I have tried with no reaction.

[@angelafahlenkamp9311]

I got a $3 sample from Ipsy, it is the green one and it worked great!

[@user-dn4qn7fj4h]

I just use baby oil. It's cheap, it works amazingly, and it moisturizes my skin too!

[@MrsLoretta]

Miana, your thumbnail is so funny!! I love the Pond's products..My mother used them for years and had beautiful skin..I enjoy Philosophy cleanser...It does a great job and doesn't burn my eyes..or make them blurry..Love these videos!! Good Job!! Hugs and Love Loretta

[@happy2vent76]

finally! an influencer that actually use the cleansing balm as per instruction. all these influencers who fail to use product correctly and then claim that the product is not effective... shame on you!

[@patvrabel908]

I love Beauty Pies Plantastic cleansing balm! Leaves a clean face, and hydrated skin!

[@michelled34]

I tried my first cleansing balm 3 months ago and I agree. 100% love it. I am waiting on a cleansing oil I ordered just to see how I feel about the oil vs balm.

[@sakurapixey3043]

Do you have an update on the oil vs balm?

[@michelled34]

@@sakurapixey3043 The cleaning balms work better. I am trying to put myself on a budget so I just tried ELF cleansing balm and it works really well. :)

[@tamananaderi6067]

10:33

[@tamananaderi6067]

10:33

[@tamananaderi6067]

10:33

[@Heretopaint]

Love your reviews! I use either the Clinique, Farmacy or Glow Recipe cleansing balms.

[@baileydubs]

You should review physicians formula matcha cleansing balm!! I love it!!!

[@kathysbigdream2084]

I bought Then I Met You because of the great review you gave but after I opened it I read "j Caution: Avoid Contact with eyes. If contact occurs rinse well with water". I would not have bought it if you mentioned that. You mentioned it for Naturepathica. I know you worked hard on these videos and I appreciate that but this was a very expensive mistake for me and a lesson learned!

[@IOANNA333]

Congratulations on the 1,5 m subscribers.👐🏻💞🎉

[@vzeimen]

Best cover thumbnail EVER!

[@jurassicjaws]

I was surprised to hear you mention the fragrance in the Pond's balm. That stuff has been my holy grail, yet I've never noticed a strong fragrance, and both my nose and skin are crazy sensitive to fragrance! A little goes a long way, so I've been using the same container for over a year now. I hope the next one isn't a fragrance bomb.

[@jilliansmith8080]

Cleansing balm=It is solidified oils that has a balm texture . It's usually in a pot form like a lip balm but There are other devices... This balm when placed on the skin breaks down into oil to break down makeup and spf. It's usually the first step in a Double cleanse routine.. You should follow-up in most cases with a gentle cleanser to remove any oily film as the oil. Is there to break down makeup and spf.

[@rree4551]

💛💛💛 DUPE ALERT!! Good Molecules cleansing balm ALSO has Sea buckthorn in it (accounts for the yellow color) and other similar ingredients!! 2.5 oz for $15 at Ulta (I have never tried it...yet). Great video GF! 💛💛💛

[@dheredia2789]

I use Good Molecules cleansing balm. So good and reasonable. I actually use all their products!

[@Helena-3]

Wondering where did you find the Cleansing Balm from Ponds since it was discontinued.

[@carlamitch9964]

I hardly wear makeup. eyeliner and mascara if I feel like it. so I don't really feel I need a cleansing balm. But I love watching these types of videos.

[@tracynp7644]

The thumbnail for this video scared tf out of me for a second!!!!

[@Stephanie-fw7wv]

Best ever has to be the body shop camomile balm! I’d love to see you review that! X

[@sarahtomlin6398]

Looove the thumbnail, lol! Salute to the joker 🤣 I like the Ponds cleansing balm and the Estée Lauder one

[@yankies0002]

I’ve been using Abolene for over 40 years

[@duhnay]

The MOST slept on cleansing balm is Tony Moly's Peach Punch Sherbet Cleansing Balm. Hands down. I almost don't want to write this comment because I want it all to myself hahaha

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

Tell me more! What do you like about it?

[@mistytells]

Oooh, thanks!

[@duhnay]

@@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE I like it because it's so easy to work with, especially if you're new to cleansing balms and/or double cleansing. Some of the ones in this video she mentioned were difficult to move around or were waxy or left a residue after... Tony Moly isn't like that at all. The best way I can describe it is that it almost feels like a creamy face wash in a semi-solid form. It moves easily around the face and comes off completely with water without that residue. If I ever have difficulty getting makeup off (especially mascara/waterproof makeup), I rub Tony Moly onto the difficult makeup and let it sit for about 30 seconds. That's all it takes to loosen it up enough to cleanse right off. Not to mention is smells peachy but not in an overwhelming or fake perfumey way 😍🍑

[@susangronsbell6096]

Yes! That one is so wonderful.

[@lillydominguez2157]

Thanks for doing this! I was stressing out trying to figure out the best one to get 😅

[@rketek]

Clinical Take the Day Off is terrific. No fragrance, no sensitivity. $34 for a big jar 3.8 oz. Key ingredient is a natural safflower seed oil.

[@irairod5160]

Your thumbnail scared me first, then made me laugh. I had to watch!

[@Michellehjj]

I always thought that we were supposed to wipe the oil base cleanser instead of washing it off with water

[@cm_mb]

You could probably do both even if you're using a thick balm, but you still have to rinse your face, then follow with a second cleanse. That's what I do.

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

You are supposed to wash them off. I don’t know why she uses a wipe. That way the review isn’t complete because what I most want to know is how it washes off.

[@AllyKit]

@@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE Exactly! I have those wipes and they take off makeup on their own with just water. That’s their purpose. So that totally skewed the reviews! 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@Michellehjj]

@@cm_mb Hi! I believe that Koreans first use oil base cleanser, wipe it off with a tissue, then rinse it off with a water base cleanser. That’s why I was surprised when I saw the video. I could be wrong though, assuming that all Koreans do it just bc that’s how I learned. I guess there is no right or wrong way to do it, we do what works best for us :)

[@cm_mb]

@@Michellehjj oh, I've used the Makeup Eraser to wipe off as well. I only use that to wipe off a heavy balm, like Albolene or Take Off the Day. I like the oil cleanser better. It has a thinner consistency and it rinses easily, so over time, I stopped wiping it off. I'm not aware of the Korean method, but I suppose it wouldn't be wrong either way, as long as it's followed by a second cleanse. Since I started using a cleansing oil or balm a few years ago, I stopped using disposable wipes. Watching videos like this is informative and I learn about new products. Hopefully, more people will be inspired to stop buying wipes.

[@josephandowensvlogs2035]

Yay!!! Thank you! Ive been looking for a video like this. So helpful!

[@permegkenth5567]

The ponds cleansing balm has been discontinued. There is a cleansing cold cream in a green and white container that’s not the same but a good alternative. Comes in both fragrance and fragrance free options. I believe it’s under $9

[@lucerofamily5414]

I use Drunk Elephant Slaai Makeup Melting Butter. Love love this. The result looked very similar to "and then I met you". I will definitely try it!

[@adriennewells8134]

I’m so glad you did this. I’ve been looking for one to try but didn’t want to waste money on one that doesn’t work.

[@happyshot485]

Pond Brand is popular in asian countries more than 50 years ago. I've never used any Balms in your video only Clinique Balm, next time shall try some of them if I can find in my country. Thanks for your Video.

[@giddygrub7176]

This thumbnail made me chuckle 👏

[@LaceyNatasha41]

I'm so glad u did this review very helpful bc ive never used a balm but have been wanting to get some, I think I'm gonna try either the zero or the ponds, and where can i get the zero at? I can't afford the 60 dollar something balm thats just stupidly high lol

[@maiden411]

You can get the Banila Zero from Ulta and Amazon

[@lsr00]

Liking this video just for your thumbnail alone

[@Ashley-jv8vj]

I love then I met you! I did not like elemis as much as then I met you. It felt like elemis didn't clean my face thoroughly.

[@rasikamakhija2097]

Can you please review the Squalene Cleanser from The Ordinary?

[@DimaRakesah]

I always wanted to try the Then I Met You balm... it looks like some kind of mango buttery goodness and I wannit... but I just cannot justify the price tag!

[@katherineklevenow1808]

I like DHC Deep Cleansing Oil, it made my blackheads disappear

[@lookitsgrandma]

One of my favourites, too! Been using this oil for years and love that it doesn't take much to cleanse the face.

[@laura-lee8482]

I recommend Juno 10 balm. Tried it because Robert Welsh recommended it and it's so good and costs just £14

[@meganlutz6306]

Try farmacy, I used to use clean it zero until I found farmacy green clean. The ingredients are better in my opinion, it emulsifies beautifully, and a little goes such a long way. My skin feels amazing after, I even use it on my son who is going through a special effects face painting phase.

[@backwardshousecoat]

Boxycharms very cherry was amazing.

[@debradavis2888]

You can't go wrong with Ponds. It's a great staple brand.

[@laurenpetro4807]

Looking for a suggestion for having my professional makeup on Saturday.

[@lyndseylee7612]

Try Juno, 10 products and it's vegan and it works so good, I love it and makes my face so soft and clean!

[@hjcdormouse7337]

Never mind balms where did u get hair band from

[@jackiewilson8772]

Omg, Milana, your thumbnail pic scared the living crap out of me!!!🤣🤣🤣