One problem about the subconcious heaven theory, Scout sees Tom Jones in heaven, but Scout didn't know he was dead beforehand.
@Felasonic124 ай бұрын
Could be he just imagined Tom Jones would be there to congratulate him as well. If scout sees himself as the gift to humanity, then a representante of humanity (Tom Jones, a popular singer beloved by a lot of people, good candidate) would be there to compliment him.
@TheWumpMan4 ай бұрын
@@Felasonic12 the thing with that is though, Tom Jones never actually compliments Scout. Right as he's saying hi to Scout, his neck gets snapped (again).
@Grakalor4 ай бұрын
@@Felasonic12then why would they need to snap his neck?
@caepez88124 ай бұрын
Scout didn't actually see Tom Jones, he was just there. The whole joke is that they had to re kill him and move the body so Scout wouldn't see him and realize he isn't actually his dad. So this might imply that Scout actually DID go to heaven, or that his personal afterlife/perception of afterlife was affected by events unrelated.
@milesedgeworth48454 ай бұрын
@@Grakalorso that the fact of Tom jones not being scouts dad doesn’t get broken.
@regionfuego64 ай бұрын
The biggest issues as others commented on is that Scout had no way of knowing Tom Jones had died, and that the Medic uses the pen he bargained with the Devil to trick the classic Heavy. I think the reason why Blutard and Redmond saw nothing was simply because they weren't really dying, they were in a coma state as the machine didn't truly allowed them to die.
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
Yes, I have no explanation for the Tom Jones part. Not a perfect theory by any means.
@BossKnight4 ай бұрын
or Ghosts are purgatory
@regionfuego64 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor Excellent video as usual anyway though! Peer review is an important part of any published work haha!
@johnnyjuice724 ай бұрын
I'm almost sure Scout would've heard something from someone at some point about Tom Jones passing, therefore the reason he appears so briefly before... dying in the afterlife?
@BossKnight4 ай бұрын
@@johnnyjuice72 but then why would tom jones be hidden then?
@butlazgazempropan-butan11k874 ай бұрын
I think emesis blue has a great take on death and respawning in tf2 universe
@Cub3_guy4 ай бұрын
It's eternity in there...
@Flamma_Dreemurr4 ай бұрын
@@Cub3_guylonger than you think
@BoinglyThe3th4 ай бұрын
"You're gonna make it Fritz" "I know"
@Mate_Antal_Zoltan4 ай бұрын
🥱 it's not canon
@GladiatorReal224 ай бұрын
He never said it was cannon 😂😂😂@@Mate_Antal_Zoltan
@Aibadenshi4 ай бұрын
Ghost usually mean unfinished business in alot folklore, and considering both Mann Brothers is still at war about what they want it kinda fit. Sniper is most likely an hallucination, since medic tell us outright. Scout most likely died and goes to actual heaven, since there isn't any other factor saying it isn't. On top of god hide the fact that Tom Jones is dead which Scout most likely doesn't know about. The devil does say the medic had committed countless horrific deeds before dying, so it most likely why he was send to hell. I don't think selling his soul mean you instantly goes to hell. And for what he sell his soul for, is most likely arcane knowledge or better medical expertise.
@assaraan94074 ай бұрын
i dont think snipers is a halusination as we dont know enugh about snipers parents to say they never wuld acept his profesion
@jokerofspades-xt3bs4 ай бұрын
@@assaraan9407 Yeah honestly outside of meet the sniper where he has an argument with them its pretty vague. And lets be honest who hasn't had an argument with their parents over something like a job
@reichtangleanschluss5094 ай бұрын
For Sniper: Despite his adopted parents hated his job, at least they cared him, unlike his biological parents, who both are selfish jerks. After meeting his biological parents, he kinda realized that despite everything, his adopted parents were always his "true" parents.
@Nilon2414 ай бұрын
I always assumed Blutarch saying there's 'nothing there' was just refering to the general absence of 'stuff' in purgatory. Administrator (and probably all life extender users) goes to purgatory in issue 7. We know its not Pauling hallucinating because at the end of the issue Administrator comes back to life after being dead for four hours (which is also what she tells pauling in purgatory). I would consider a purgatory where you're trapped forever in a tiny room with a bunch of cameras pointed in at yourself as 'nothing' compared to heaven and hell. Also the reason why Satan can't just drag Medic to hell regardless is because, canonically, his original job had been taken over by the Bominomicon.
@katkatkat8914 ай бұрын
Love the editing already, you've improved so much genuinely =)
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
That's very kind of you to say
@deputyrook62324 ай бұрын
this actually still works with Gray Mann saying there's nothing on the other side. He's never THOUGHT about the other side, he never considered what would happen to him after he died, he was always only preoccupied with his life, not his afterlife. so to him, the afterlife being nothing actually works. and the worst part is that now that he's seen that there's nothing after death, he BELIEVES that there's nothing after death, so there's never going to be anything after death for him.
@saturn3794 ай бұрын
[ insert emesis blue reference here ]
@Bluestlark4 ай бұрын
I love how engineer has seen ghosts, souls and mersamus shenanigans and refuses to believe in this shit. I chalk it up to "it depends on what the writter thought it was funny at the momment"
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
Honestly, this is probably the correct answer
@MooseChicken4 ай бұрын
Gray Mann went to purgatory cause it’s the gray area of the afterlife.
@The_Pup774 ай бұрын
Be invested to his theory✅ Lose attention and get drawn to his epic mvm game play and that funny moment where the pyro gets shot 20 times(7:12 - 7:16)✅
@BohemiaFortressTF2cz4 ай бұрын
average pyro in mvm (but is actually 95% pyros in mvm)
@vadimka_71544 ай бұрын
it's eternity in there
@garok24124 ай бұрын
I do not understand why all people claiming the hallucinations theory conveniently skip the most important part. How are the mercs magically coming back to life? Sniper was at least explained, but Scout and Medic went back from the dead without any apparent reason. So again, why do people skip this point? I personally believe that these are not hallucinations.
@military_snake4 ай бұрын
I like to think that because Medic stole all the mercs' souls, their views of their afterlife are basically like glitches. Sniper's is contradictory to his previously established relationship with his parents because even though he disagreed with them, he still loved them. there's also the fact that he comes back, and is so convinced that he saw what he saw, but Medic doesn't care much because he knows he has his soul. he even says it must have been a hallucination, not explaining, of course, that he has their spuls, so they cant TRULY move on. it would explain why God behaves oddly in Scout's death, and perhaps the real God's "punishment" for the ghosts of the brothers is to continue the curse from their father until they reconcile. perhaps that is their purgatory. Medic with Satan is the only one that people remember so well because it's the only one with stakes. there's tension when the Devil feels cheated, and how Medic's cunning grants him further unnaturally long life. I think all the afterlifes of any merc would be some kind of "glitch (or, as Medic said, hallucination)" in the sense that their seeing fragments of truth and happiness, but because their soul isn't bound to them anymore, the intrinsic good is either never seen (in Scout's case) or merely glimpsed (Sniper's reconciliation with his parents). you are right in the sense that Scout and Sniper's deaths seemed off, and it's because it possesses an attitude of "almost, but not quite," and I attrivute that to not having souls. so, rather fittingly, actually, an afterlife would default to whatever the desires of the person were (for Sniper, something wholesome; for Scout, very conceited). consider it an animalistic default, maybe? tough to attribute a word to it, I'll be honest. let me know if you read this, wanna know what you make of this
@angelavery38404 ай бұрын
Well when people become ghosts in folk lore it’s usually because they have unfinished business (AKA they still needed to decide who got the badland’s) so it probably wasn’t god that caused the man brothers to become ghosts but something else
@trenchrat.loonixtard4 ай бұрын
Afterlife in TF2 always seemed like a strange case to me
@pilotverse1794 ай бұрын
bot ahh comment
@elzeban4 ай бұрын
@@pilotverse179So you don’t know about Great Blue huh?
@aleflippy19974 ай бұрын
@@elzeban Don't know about the other fella, but I do know Great Blue. Doesn't change the fact that people can't let a freaking joke die.
@elzeban4 ай бұрын
@@aleflippy1997 why? It doesn’t need to die )
@osobatalentu69444 ай бұрын
Well my theory is that the heaven and hell exist, but we only saw hell. Medic made a pact with a devil, that's why he knew he would meet him. He also stole souls of his teammates and that's the reason why they didn't die, what they saw was hallucinations, because they could get to afterlife, because they lack soul and that's also the reason why medic can revive them. Mann brothers were just cursed by they father or by them selfs, that's why they can go to afterlife before ending the war between them.
@rhinol-only86544 ай бұрын
This is ecactly how ive interprited the c9mics when i read them, like theres clearly an afterlife but it is all up to what you expect it to be
@madcaker4 ай бұрын
At this point it's just whatever's the funniest/most absurd
@SpamtonG-mf4cb4 ай бұрын
death in the tf2 universe has always been a strange to me
@memes_gbc6744 ай бұрын
reminds me of scp 2718 where death is literally what you think happens after but then they found what really happens (nothing) and the higher ups when through amnestics to forget about it
@LinusDickens4 ай бұрын
Really great video
@lilchris9cmb4 ай бұрын
My prediction for the final comic; We see the line "Six months later" in the opening shot of the desert, which is likely another nightmare of Miss Pauling. I'm assuming the events taking place will involve the mercs trying to help Saxton take his company back, and likely are involved in a conflict with Charles Darling. We might see some of the history with Saxton and Mags (hopefully), and maybe some closure on Olivia (hopefully). But what I actually expect is that the comic will have the characters frequently mention events we hadn't seen, involving the Administrator who is nowhere to be seen. And later in the comic we get a flashback to the end of Naked and the Dead, where we see what the Administrator does with her one hour of youth, which gives context for a lot of the dialogue and events.
@phone_gal4 ай бұрын
ill give my 7th comic predictions (or at least wishlist) more engineer, i LOVE his comic design hopefully scout finds out the truth about spy, it seems wrong for him not to Soldier and Zhanna get officially married and buy a barn and have their daughter, Soldier Jr Heavy and medic sloppy makeout session Saxton Hale takes over mannco (obviously lmao) Scout fucking dies to a white fox robot on December 4th 1987
@jakubpociecha88194 ай бұрын
"It's amazing that the human body can live without the frontal lobe"
@mike15644 ай бұрын
I think that scout's in denial and that's why Tom Jones appears in his Heaven and gets killed.
@idowolf46234 ай бұрын
i kinda think you overthink this all ,lets go one by one ,the mann brothers became ghosts because they had unfinished buisness the sniper went to heaven because he was a good man sure he was a mercenery but he was not evil same for scout medic went to hell becuase he sold his soul to the devil not cause he expected to go to hell he expected it cause he sold his soul which means he will go to hell
@ТойХтоКоміксиМалює4 ай бұрын
If you die in TF Universe all starts laugh at you
@damaton4 ай бұрын
Or its a system of heaven and hell. Most people would go to heaven unless you do something like sell your soul. And if you are too attatched to the mortal realm like have a grudge you can remain on earth as a ghost like the brothers. (I do like your theory though, I even thought thats what you will say when i clicked on the video)
@thespringlock17944 ай бұрын
Nice vid! To offer a potential solution to Scout’s afterlife (a bit of a stretch): Perhaps Tom Jones showing up could be interpreted as being less about Tom being dead and more about Tom not recognizing Scout and therefore not being his actual father. If these afterlives are creations of the subconscious, since Scout has been shown to know that Spy is actually his dad (his conversation with Heavy in Blood in the Water, his dream in A Cold Day in Hell, etc.), it could be the dark recesses of Scout’s mind trying to interrupt his mental circlejerk, only for Scout’s God to have it be snapped away before Scout could fully notice. That being said, this is just to fit it in your theory, and it’s what I’ve been running with for the longest time to explain the no souls thing. I have a feeling that the afterlife in TF2, in reality, is just something that absolutely zero thought was put into, just acting how the writers wanted it to act in any possible instance, capped off by the whole “we don’t have souls” thing putting that final nail in the coffin. Also surprised you didn’t bring up Miss Pauling’s afterlife that may or may not be shared with Admin.
@murillosilva32834 ай бұрын
cool i guess, never thought about tf2's after life
@bonzairob4 ай бұрын
Medic sold his soul to gain his healing abilities, and then used those abilities to learn how to surgically graft the other souls and ensure the devil had no power over him afterwards - I always throught that was genius, but you're right that it's inconsistent when we see the other mercs going to heaven. Either the other 8 souls aren't the mercs', or it's all just jokes in a funny comic :)
@Faleko_Fares4 ай бұрын
Guys I played bloodborne and the enemy’s gun sound like the rocket jumper from tf2
@MBP19184 ай бұрын
Medic made a deal with the Devil after all
@CRTTekeren4 ай бұрын
You made me stop my playlist. I hope this is good to understand how a game treats death, same game made in 2007
@damaton4 ай бұрын
Another interesting thing is, if your theory isn't true what exactly would go to "heaven" or "hell"? since medic stole all the mercs souls, when scout dued, what exactly was up there? Like scouts soul should be stolen by medic so how would it be in heaven? Or are souls separate from the thing that goes to the afterlife?
@TheWumpMan4 ай бұрын
@@damaton well, we never find out who Medic's eight extra souls are. Theres a very good chance it's the tf2 classic mercs. Even if it is the tf2 guys, maybe Scout goes to heaven because he's meant to be god's gift to women.
@demitrischoenwald14364 ай бұрын
If this theory holds water and actually is the case, I imagine if Dell were to die he would see himself going to heaven and asked to fix complex stuff for God. I'm not sure about anyone else who hasn't died yet, like Heavy or Pyro, although I imagine Pyro learning how Hell is a vast space of endless fire would seem like heaven to him and he'd be happy to go there when she dies.
@BRNG20424 ай бұрын
Pyro's gonna have a hell of an afterlife
@Nykomil4 ай бұрын
The afterlife of TF2 is... 20s....
@Heavy_metal_luvrr707Ай бұрын
My personal theory is that the afterlife in tf2 works the same way as the afterlife in adventure time lol
@jokerofspades-xt3bs4 ай бұрын
I prefer to think of it like every heaven/hell/afterlife is real, but the one you go to is just up for you to decide, everything that happens there is not fake, like sniper meeting his parents for example, just that they all assumed they would go to heaven and ended up meeting in heaven.
@exiledhero37914 ай бұрын
My question is: why does Sniper’s parents disapprove of his job, but seem to be in a similar line of work (his post revival words were something along the lines of: that means I’m the deadliest man on the planet)
@bieyang3394 ай бұрын
chat get game theor- (flashback to tf2 vs ow video) on second thought, nevermind
@nonomanius4 ай бұрын
Discworld intensifies.
@menacingpyro20054 ай бұрын
Even after this video I’m still confused
@sniper73034 ай бұрын
This is compleatly untrue i am not gay even soldier knows i have a wife
@notawizard67144 ай бұрын
I personally like the fan theory that somehow the lack of soul was what allowed Sniper and Scout, mercenaries, to go to heaven.
@GreenFeatherGuy4 ай бұрын
Yea uhh pretty cool vidoe👍
@Nigolelel4 ай бұрын
Thanks Lon, my biggest fear has been turned into another slop video
@Galaxxi3 ай бұрын
1. a popular theory is that all the mercs besides medic go to heaven because medic removed their souls, and sin is tied to the soul. ergo, he has stolen the sins of all other 8 mercs as well, leaving the rest of them free to go to heaven 2. i don't really speak religion but i thought Heaven is supposed to be some kind of perfect world for you. sniper seems to want his parents to understand what he does, with the way he argues over the phone with them in Meet The Sniper - it makes sense then that his heaven would see his parents finally accepting his job, but also being proud of him for it
@IwanRoberts-m8j4 ай бұрын
What about respawning? Is that cannon in tf2 or do the mercs cannonically never die in the gravel wars, as that seems unlikely as it is implied blu team died before expiration date while red got their breifcase. If they died then why didnt the gravel wars end?
@bieyang3394 ай бұрын
the respawning thing maybe has to grab the mercs ghost since the mercs technically has a unfinished goal in mind, beating the other team, so maybe the respawn mechanic utilizes the ghosts to its advantage and just revives them, and maybe that's why the sniper had to be forcibly revived by medic since his goal was finished
@jamesThebulbmin4 ай бұрын
Wonder what happens if respawning goes wrong
@Nykomil4 ай бұрын
Emesis-
@bieyang3394 ай бұрын
probably deformed body parts, maybe an arm and a leg missing, and probably brain damage
@jamesThebulbmin4 ай бұрын
@@bieyang339 what if they get emesis disaipan in the case of valium so they end up in a mental time loop
@theredstormer80784 ай бұрын
How does it work in the tf2 universe? Whatever happens to be funniest.
@Lonqudor3 ай бұрын
Honestly, this is most likely the real answer
@nicolafoudre3 ай бұрын
What HUD do you use? Its cool, and btw cool vid
@Lonqudor3 ай бұрын
DARHud
@nicolafoudre3 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor Thank you very much !
@raytf24 ай бұрын
Mumbo Jumbo
@NoahWood-j1v4 ай бұрын
What happens when you die? Oh tf2 will never know
@gameplayerxjohnstone59954 ай бұрын
One thing you forgot to mention is Sniper’s parent’s attitude towards Sniper’s job. Wouldn’t it be plausible to say that Sniper always wanted his parents approval, but never got it on earth, and then the reason why Sniper’s parents are approving of him in the afterlife is because that’s what Sniper wanted to hear from them while alive?
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
I… literally didn’t forget that. Did you watch the segment?
@gameplayerxjohnstone59953 ай бұрын
I somehow missed it, even after rewatching the video to double check, sorry.
@bazukata37344 ай бұрын
look af the scout you miss something important
@Mrbleusky15 күн бұрын
You sounded like mumbo jumbo at the start
@mewatordaking11693 ай бұрын
Death is death
@itsTbomber4 ай бұрын
mumbo jumbo
@Typicalusername434 ай бұрын
I just realized something; Redmond and Blutarch are onryos
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
What does that mean?
@Typicalusername434 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor fancy word for vengeful spirit
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
Ahh I see
@Grakalor4 ай бұрын
How do the dead mercs come back though?
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
Majik
@Odium_DOB4 ай бұрын
I think all instances are within the same afterlife God, may have thought scout was his greatest gift but didn't pay attention to scout. and than learns how scout flounder his potential. I think that would be funnier. that god truely thought so, than learns later taht scout is a disappointment than scout is disappointed TWO FATHERS :D
@nneykobar_hali4 ай бұрын
What about helen's litle personal hell?
@Beetroo34 ай бұрын
if the afterlife is what you think it is the how did medic summon the devil and make a physical deal
@Lonqudor3 ай бұрын
If he was expecting to meet the devil, then it would make sense that he planned for it
@Beetroo33 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor Yeah but he made a deal before he died which means the devil would be summoned and is real.
@ApocAnarchy8 күн бұрын
What is the outro song if anyone knows?
@k90v854 ай бұрын
please mention the garden warfare possible comeback news in your garden warfare video
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
I think everybody’s heard it by now, mate
@k90v854 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor fair nuff also ur theory explains why specifically soldier comes back to life "we are foing to live forever!"
@hhhcontent39304 ай бұрын
Bro said emesis who?
@poker35424 ай бұрын
What's the name of your hud I really like it
@Lonqudor3 ай бұрын
DARHud
@poker35423 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor thank you
@pyrofromtf24 ай бұрын
I am Pyro. I became real.
@justhere46374 ай бұрын
Wowzers.
@Caterman_the_pomson_enjoyer4 ай бұрын
Thanks for taking my place in not letting anyone say "first", your work won't go underappreciated
@1vite4 ай бұрын
MMMM! HMMMmmh.
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
Earliest you've been so far I think
@tortilla-are-yummy4 ай бұрын
did you die
@FoxROD_4_U4 ай бұрын
My theory is that every religion in tf2 universe is real and whatever you believe in is what will happen Edit: im not sure if this is what he said im confused on his theory but what i mean is as in if you are christian you will go to hevan if you think you should then you will if you think it just goes black when you die then it will etc
@bazukata37344 ай бұрын
didn't miss pauli die to?
@Lonqudor4 ай бұрын
No, she just passed out
@bazukata37344 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor with no blood
@bazukata37344 ай бұрын
@@Lonqudor or i remenber wrong
@nevtf24 ай бұрын
9 seconds and only i have watched?? you fell off so hard
@bieyang3394 ай бұрын
just let the youtube algorithm do its thing and remind people this uploaded
@CyborgCharlotte4 ай бұрын
“Death in the TF2 universe is a weird thing……and seems to be completely illogical and random” So, fitting for the game itself then? :P