The Ahsoka Show... 1 Year Later

[@toganium4175]

Sabine surviving a lightsaber through the gut will never not make me mad. Why did she get medical attention when Qui-Gon didn’t?

[@isaackim7675]

Wasn’t Obi-Wan hanging on the edge of a massive hole while Maul thought he had the high ground?

[@FrozenJedi38]

First of all, it was on her side, specifically where there are no vital organs. Secondly, Qui-Gon was stabbed quite literally in his heart/lungs area. And finally, she had immediate medical attention since Ahsoka was right there. While Obi-Wan was busy with Maul so there was literally no way to help Qui-Gon (even though he stabbed in his heart/lungs area, so there wasn't anything Obi-Wan could do anyway).

[@squirrel176]

Idk maybe bc it took obi-wan several minutes after Qui-Gon got stabbed to defeat maul

[@aezyn8645]

@@FrozenJedi38 A lightsaber blade is approximately 1 million (that is 1.000.000) degree celsius hot. It would melt her insides within nano seconds. That is no argument. For reference Leia shouldve froze to death within a fraction of a nanosecond when she was ejected into space. And space itself is around minus 270.00 degrees celsius. So if a master of the force can barely survive for 1 minute in that environment, which she magically shielded herself from. How do you expect a novice to shield her insides from 4x the extreme heat? If the Leia scene was a major rewriting of the properties of both the force and space itself. What the fuck was the scene from Ahsoka then? Dave Filoni unironically is a con that took credit for work his underlings did. He couldnt deliver an intricate story so he had to bend, add and remove rules in the universe to create artificial shock moments.

[@1000g2g3g4g800999]

@@aezyn8645 I don't think any figures of how hot a lightsaber is should be taken remotely seriously considering how people turn them on all the time and don't die from being in close proximity, and weren't previously dying from having their limbs cut off. The figure you gave is orders of magnitude hotter than the surface of the sun, for reference.

[@macwelch8599]

Everyone in this show dominated their roles, despite the poorly executed script. I also appreciate the introduction of red-orange lightsabers

[@wickdaline8668]

The script was masterful compared to The Acolyte.

[@macwelch8599]

@@wickdaline8668 true

[@LaraA55]

@@wickdaline8668 Oh my yes, it had coherence.

[@xghostx9715]

I personally loved this show. And it was fun teaching my Dad these characters when he hasn’t seen Rebels.

[@LaraA55]

Great to hear

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

I hope we see some old and new faces on the next season

[@MayanFrighter100000]

I will not lie, I do love Ahsoka, Clone Wars and Rebels but strongly uninterested in watching any series that comes after return of the Jedi. I also do agree with you that it’s too heavily relying on people, or even watching the previous series, and it definitely needs to at least have flashbacks to those moments of a series so newcomers can get information about those series and maybe get interested in checking them out to.

[@soularprimestudios5930]

It ending with the prequels is proubly why you can't watch anything after ep 6

[@MayanFrighter100000]

@@soularprimestudios5930 no, it’s mostly because I strongly believe that Ahsoka should of took place between Clone Wars and Rebels.

[@isaackim7675]

There’s too many cliffhangers in the Ahsoka show not to have a second season. I would prefer this over the Acolyte anytime. I have spoken

[@FrozenJedi38]

I still haven't watched the Acolyte, but I agree

[@squirrel176]

Season 2 is confirmed

[@wickdaline8668]

Now we're talking.

[@kouvue1081]

By that logic Acolyte had many cliffhangers too, so it should get a second season as well... NOT

[@isaackim7675]

@@FrozenJedi38 Better skip the Acolyte

[@vvanderer2287]

I’m sick of people praising Dave Filoni like George Lucas II

[@emperorvader1310]

I like Dave and will defend him. But that is way too big of a comparison. No one will ever be or top George. Dave though was personally selected by him.

[@MCLegend13]

Wait it’s been a whole year????? Time be going too fast 😭

[@rexlumontad5644]

5:37 Huyang was voiced by David Tennant who played as Dr. Rufus Weller and Caliban from GenLock series.

[@thomasalmodovar9095]

6:39 the joke was amazing

[@wickdaline8668]

Hot take: Sabine's development wasn't undone. Sabine was going through the grief of losing her family on Mandalore to the Night of A Thousand Tears. Maybe a flashback or vision in season 2 can show us that and justify everything. Also, the end of Rebels kind of set up the idea of Sabine and Ahsoka searching for Ezra. It would make sense why the show begins this way.

[@garciaortizmiguelangel5130]

I think they did it wrong. Considering her family was important in her history in rebels. Killing her family off screen feels like an insult

[@wickdaline8668]

@@garciaortizmiguelangel5130 We only have Bo-Katan to blame for that. Given what occurred between her and Gideon. Her and Sabine must not be on speaking terms because of that, too.

[@LaraA55]

The show didn't go into what led to Ahsoka training Sabine. Did she sense force sensitivity in Sabine unlike Kanan and Ezra? There is a big gap here.

[@garciaortizmiguelangel5130]

@@wickdaline8668 yeah. But i mean we would have empatized more with Sabine if Filoni would have shown that and not only put a lame dialog of "oh yeah your family is dead lets continue with the plot"

[@loanraymond9654]

The continuation of rebels, this is. A second season, have, we must.

[@btecbradford5079]

As a rebels fan, I was sad that it wasn't animated, the live action shows have been far lower in quality than the animated ones

[@LaraA55]

I completely agree

[@PrettyboyAshtun]

all these “ shows “ feel so cheap

[@BrennySpain]

It’s so crazy how it’s been a year since this show first came out. I personally did enjoy it overall but it could’ve been so much better I think. It’s still a shame to this day the rebels sequel show was live-action. It would’ve been interesting to see it in animation like rebels beforehand, but thanks to the success of the mandalorian that was never going to happen at all.

[@jedimasterboltsproductions6433]

The Goldman needs to make this video!

[@1000g2g3g4g800999]

I think one of the things that Ahsoka had going for it as a strong positive was just how good everything looked. The visuals in some of the Disney+ shows haven't been super consistent; I don't understand how they thought making the Grand Inquisitor look like that in Kenobi was okay.

[@LaraA55]

I agree. It looked good.

[@TheAncientSith]

The only actual problems I had with the show was Sabine surviving a lightsaber through her chest. And episodes 7 & 8 just being a bit disappointing. But besides that the overall show was really solid, and I’m looking forward to S2.

[@darkvortex2410]

I remember a lot saying this show was bad but honestly it's easily my FAVORITE of the Disney Plus shows. Didn't care for Andor to much, couldn't get into it, still well made. Ahsoka had everything i wanted in a Star Wars show. Adventure, stakes, new locations, good action(wasn't Prequel action but it was entertaining), killer soundtrack, and Baylan. Did that man say anything that was fundamental wrong. RIP Ray Stevenson. Seriously the soundtrack for this show is so good. My favorites being The Hyperspace Jump, Epilogue II, and The Main Theme. Unlike The Acyote, i actually got emotional at some seens. Specifically Ezra reuniting with Hera and Anakin's Force Ghost at the end of ep8. I'll take anything Dave Filoni makes compared to The Acyote. At the VERY LEAST, his is entertaining. Can't wait for season 2.

[@LaraA55]

I agree. It was fun to watch. I found Andor so not fun to watch , didn't look of feel like Star Wars but yes it was well made.

[@amyborg2173]

I thought season 1 of Ashoka was great sure had some flaws but overall it's still good Star wars live action TV series and I can't wait for season 2 and give it 8/10🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠

[@ajmaldonado9720]

Although I agree with many points in the video, people also have to flow a little bit more. This show was a good start wars adventure story and it got room from improvement, sure, but that is why it is only the first season. Filoni has a track record where the first season isn’t the greatest but if you give him time, he ramps up the story to eleven. The same happened with Rebels, and clone wars. People need to suspend disbelief and just flow. The story was good enough, and characters were very complex for star wars standards (in a good way). Seeing ahsoka finally let go of her trauma over Anakin was peak, having had the choice to let into her anger, rejecting it. Baylan Skoll and Shin haiti are like a ying and yang of ambition. Loved the symbolism behind their names. Sabine’s actress was fine, she performed as the Sabine we know and was able to bring her to life. She’s now more rebellious than ever but it is because she’s acting out. SHE LOST HER ENTIRE FAMILY, Ezra might as well be the only thing she has to cling to her “happier past”. The fights scenes do seem clunky at times, they can improve them and seeing how they had no fear in more complex fights in Acolyte, i hope they can incorporate a more coordinated and martial arts style method of fight. Thrawn had a small role, and people say “he failed”, no, his plan was never to kill the protagonist, rather delay them. After all, Ahsoka is the apprentice of the Chosen One. Morgan Elsbeth was a great antagonist and a good “introduction” into nightsister magic (for people that didnt see Rebels or clone wars). Overall it was a good series with room for improvement, yet i still believe some of the critics towards this series are a little harsh, even unnecessary.

[@StarForceOne]

Very fair points, great comment!

[@BrennySpain]

I really do wonder when Ahsoka season 2 will eventually come out. Rumours say it’ll be 2026 but it could even be 2027 if there’s any further delays. I wonder which actor will replace Baylon Skull as well. Only time will tell.

[@d.o6356]

still doesn't make any sense that Kanen, Ezra, and Ahsoka did not know Sabine was force sensitive for 4 seasons straight of Star Wars rebels lmao

[@Elemento0420]

Vader didn't know Leia was force sensitive or his daughter when he had her prisoner in ANH.

[@d.o6356]

@hellstrom4209 because sidious told him that his wife passed. Vader expected his wife and their kid to be dead. And Vader didn't know padme carried twins

[@Elemento0420]

@@d.o6356 still doesn't explain why he didn't sense Leia being Force Sensitive

[@d.o6356]

@hellstrom4209 vader did know during the fight with Luke in ep 6. Because the chances of a child being force sensitive are high when at least 1 of the parents bring force sensitive

[@Elemento0420]

@d.o6356 he knew Luke has a sister AFTER sensing Luke's fears in episode 6. NOT when Vader had Leia right in front of him.

[@horatiocarrillo2176]

The Anakin scenes were astonishing. Seeing him in action again was worth enduring the rest of this. Why can't Disney understand that fans love Hayden Christensen and he deserves his own show? Ahsoka is his sidekick, and not a leading character.

[@TophDaGreat]

I thought the show was mediocre and the personality of the characters were unrecognizable for me.

[@William_Does_Coasters2255]

I thought it was great.

[@LaraA55]

@StarForceOne I really liked how you pointed out the negative and positives of this show and I completely agree with you. I wasn't a fan of Ezra in Rebels but Eman made me like him much more. I didn't like how Sabine was made into a padawan and how her character went so backwards. I love her character growth in Rebels but she was unlikeable in Ahsoka. There really was no hint of her being force sensitive in Rebels. There is a huge plot gap with no explanation to why Ahsoka chose to train her...did she sense some force sensitivity in Sabine...why didn't Ezra or Kanan state this? And why did Sabine choose to train with Ahsoka? I wanted her to only be a Mandalorian. That said, I thought the show was fun and entertaining to watch, despite it being not so good writing and directing wise. RIP to the amazing costumer designer.

[@l.b.nstudios2070]

I disagree i loved it and seeing ezra and thrawn again but i loved baylin

[@coletrain583]

Sabine is obviously in love with Ezra.

[@orvilleortiz8616]

Thrawn coming back to the main Galaxy is like when we heard the news “Some how Palpatine is alive” which is a slap on the face to Anakin Skywalker bringing balance, Ezra sacrificing himself for nothing!!!! Disney has destroyed Star Wars entirely IMHO….

[@secla_SC]

I loved this show and liked it even more the second time I watched it. I don’t get the criticism it got.

[@emperorvader1310]

Keep in mind, this will be the very last live action Disney Plus show.

[@UnswimmingFishYT]

There's a little more of both good and bad stuff in there. The new aliens were entertaining, the actor hired as Baylan did an excellent job, and the bandits having perfectly matching costumes and no clear reason for being there or known method of getting there didn't make sense. We also had a second case of seemingly a hollow inquisitor like the deflating one Ahsoka killed early in the imperial era which is interesting, signs of Abeloth being planned for live-action appearance, and the acting for Sabine was just bad. For me the show seemed almost like a 50% split between parts I liked seeing and parts that annoyed me a bit. I don't really mind how Thrawn looks there because he's meant to be several year older than before. Didn't notice the Musk resemblance was so strong, but it's pretty funny now that I see the visual comparison.

[@michaelarmstrong9722]

Balan skol and shin hati were the most interesting parts of the show. Most other things were meh personally.

[@garciaortizmiguelangel5130]

Sabine didn't need the force. She was already an blaster, explosive and lightsaber expert and only needed her mandalorian gadgets

[@LaraA55]

I just wanted her to stay as a Mandalorian and keep the focus on Ezra

[@garciaortizmiguelangel5130]

@@LaraA55 Exactly. When i express this people Say "it's because you're sexist and don't want a female jedi-mandalorian". And it's like. Bruh. Sabine is one of My favourite characters in Rebels. She being force sensitive feels unnecessary because she was already a badass mandalorian

[@LaraA55]

@@garciaortizmiguelangel5130 I am tired of hearing the racist etc rubbish when one offers a differing opinion. I loved Sabine in Rebels as she was unique, strong, independent and had much character development, grew as a character. She was my favourite. I disliked her in Ahsoka, she was unlikeable and there was no explanation given as to why she chose Jedi Training and why Ahsoka chose to train her...did Ahoska sense latent force sensitivity? Why didn't Ezra or Kanan sense this.

[@garciaortizmiguelangel5130]

@@LaraA55 They will tell you always the "She discovered her powers later" "Kanan was already training her in Rebels"

[@LaraA55]

@@garciaortizmiguelangel5130 True. I come back with well...Bo Katan could use the dark saber easily as well. Does she have force powers? I wouldn't be surprised if they make her force sensitive. I even heard some people saying Mando was force sensitive. Just let Mandalorians be Mandalorians

[@Ozzyorcborne1]

It was better-ish than boba (which was such a travesty). Scripting and dialog felt like it was written by 5 year olds. The actor they got for Ezra was the best thing about it.

[@LaraA55]

The actor for Ezra was so good. He did a great job

[@matthewst537]

Ahsoka and Lego Star Wars may have its cheesy moments but it’s at god tier compared to the acolyte and last Jedi

[@LaraA55]

I agree

[@baki484]

Just because the Acolyte is worse doesn't absolve this show of its nonsense.

[@ofearghailthefearless6481]

I actually liked it! Certain people just can't seem to take a real Star Wars heroine that's well written.

[@BrennySpain]

Rebels was an absolute amazing show and the Ahsoka show kind of ruined it in a sense. Not entirely of course, but I think you all get what I’m saying. I’ll leave it at that for now.

[@pbh9195]

I did like Ahsoka, but Sabines choices and her suddenly use the force really breaks the lore for me

[@PrettyboyAshtun]

take out the anakin flashbacks and this show is genuinely terrible i hate how all these disney star wars " shows" feel so cheap and the story always follows a side character and not the main character who's literally the name of it. i also don't like how obsessed dave is with ahsoka she was and still is a character who shouldn’t have existed anakin never needed a padawan.. but anyways should've lost to vader in rebels but as long as he is around she'll always be here unfortunately.

[@StarwarsFan-3131]

As long as Rosario Dawson is Ahsoka in live action I will never watch this show

[@daveonwheeler7412]

Zombies

[@rexlumontad5644]

At least Ahsoka tv show is not as bad as Acolyte.

[@LaraA55]

Indeed. The story was coherent

[@aura-bj4wr]

Sorry I tried getting through more than a couple minutes but I think you have a very fundamental misunderstanding about the series and the choices made. I get not really having the bandwidth to understand certain things, but why not rather not discuss things if you don’t get it? It’s like you’re asking all these questions but won’t put 2 + 2 together to find the answer using reasonable logic. View farming is one thing, plenty of other “Star Wars” KZbinrs do the same, but I was hoping for a more thought out video than most channels are giving nowadays. It’s a shame.

[@crashx9973]

Honestly, this show was just the definition of mid. Not a terrible show but it doesn’t really do much to stand out. Especially since Ahsoka herself isn’t even much of a highlight here…

[@fpineda101]

The show started out well but ended up being very predictable the last few episodes

[@5ccsomat]

Not exactly sure it was "largely positive". Bad writing, retcons everywhere, not respecting the original lore nor the lore that they created, destroying characters such as Ezra, Sabine, Thrawn...... Pretty much the same dumpster fire as Kenobi was.

[@59rlmccormack]

I don’t believe the show had poor writing.

[@lonewolf5054]

Of course those 3d cartoon Simps like the show, not real fans of star wars, just Dave faloni followers

[@JustCallMeJames]

What's a real star wars fan? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lonewolf5054]

@JustCallMeJames only those strong with the force and those that do not question, but sure go simp for ashoka ya weirdo lol 😆

[@cristainrodriguez5845]

Lol it was a terrible show

[@chadbrad8100]

average at best tbh