The Appeal of Tally Hall

[@tallyballYT]

Awesome video! Can’t wait for you to cover Miracle Musical 😎👍

[@beetlebat]

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Will look at Miracle Musical fs

[@Apotheosis01]

​@@beetlebatyou GOTTA

[@sspoosh]

@@beetlebatthey are both rumored to be the same

[@cayzap]

@@sspoosh thats because they are

[@sspoosh]

@@cayzap i think that's what I said 🤦‍♂️

[@zukacounty]

the way you pronounced zubin, joe, bora and ross's last names i'm crying 😭😭

[@beetlebat]

Mannnnn i tried my best 😂

[@zukacounty]

@@beetlebat HEHE it's okay, but if you make another tally hall video get me on board... i know all there is to know about everything ^_^

[@Fiskiuggar]

HI ZUKA

[@zukacounty]

@@Fiskiuggar hey 📦

[@OfficialSongCoverers]

​@@zukacountyeverything? alright dude who's the ruler of "everything"?

[@tailseatingnails]

i love tally hall and i’m also genuinely surprised that i’ve been listening to the same songs from the same albums for 7 years and i haven’t gotten sick of them 💀

[@beetlebat]

The magic of Tally Hall

[@amazingpurplegirl0903]

Light and Night is on the modern release of Good & Evil as a hidden track. Now you've done Tally Hall, you should definitely cover Lemon Demon

[@beetlebat]

never heard of them hmm

[@amazingpurplegirl0903]

@@beetlebatit's a one-man band, who is Neil Ciecierega, who created Potter Puppet Pals. Many, many Tally Hall fans also like Lemon Demon for his quirkiness (and definitely internet music, he did Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Destiny)

[@limediamond4595]

@@beetlebatthen do Will Wood!

[@kusarikagami]

LEMON DEMON

[@Zeonixi]

@@beetlebathow do u not know lemon demon I’m actually taken aback his music is like synth heaven

[@Fooltomary]

18:40 Revealing that the hall is a place that aims to please unpredictable games and antiquities

[@naate2]

“ they’ll wait how many years for another album“ 12 years and three months, no joke I looked it up

[@beetlebat]

Insane!

[@Passw0rdYT]

​@@beetlebat the insane thing is that every member insists to this day that tally hall will be back together and another album will be made despite them all having dedicated seperate career paths and admitting that the very last time they were all in the same place together was on their final concert in 2011

[@tom-on]

They'll probably come back like 20 years

[@DigginThrough.MyOldMuscles.]

Just one more year to be the quirky version of TOOL fans!!! Yay!!!!

[@tylert5646]

Have you ever listened to Will Wood and the Tapeworms? I get the feeling from this that they might be up your alley

[@beetlebat]

Never heard of them actually, what’s their best record?

[@tylert5646]

I'd recommend either 'the normal album' or 'self-ish'

[@davefromhomedepot7416]

Selfish is so good and also my favorite song ever skeleton day in vestal ny it's absolutely stellar@@beetlebat

[@zukacounty]

@@beetlebatEVERYTHING IS A LOT IS SUCH A GOOD ALBUM

[@harrietsmells]

@@beetlebatI think self-ish or the normal album

[@project_letters]

I love this analysis! It's honestly extremely well thought out and properly answers the question in the title. I'm decently new to this fan base but am also decently well known in the community and I can say this video will most likely be extremely important to the fandom. You really took the time to understand all of it in depth. Basically, thank you

[@beetlebat]

Dang, appreciate that! Welcome to the fandom, there’s a lot more to learn lol

[@MinaWalker]

Going to MMMM as a TallyHall fan was a day I’ll never forget ❤

[@beetlebat]

It was actually soo cool

[@MinaWalker]

@@beetlebat pretty sure that’s an understatement lol

[@BlueCanaryNightLight]

Tbh the amount of their videos and skitsive watched and i have their humor when it comes to their skits 💀 MY HUMOR IS SO DETERIORATED

[@beetlebat]

that 2000s humor hits different

[@frostedbutcooler]

this was actually super interesting to watch. ive always considered my hyperfixation of tally hall just something like "haha what a cute silly band !!!!!" and now whenever someone asks why i like tally hall so much i can just whip out this video and go on a very sophisticated rant 💞😁 (also, could you do beetlebug or cavetown? beetlebug isn't that popular so ig there isn't much "appeal" but errrm i think it could bring more fans to her music so !!!yeah)

[@beetlebat]

I love that haha, let em know! Also, i’ll check those artists out fs

[@frostedbutcooler]

@@beetlebat thank you !!

[@Nathans_baking_YEAHHHH]

They’re now at 5M 😈😈

[@beetlebat]

Damn, they just keep going

[@TheFrogfather1]

I've been down a TallyHall rabbit hall thanks to my teen (aka Frog) who used to play Mind Electric on their ukelele some years ago. For some reason it decided to lodge in my brain a couple of weeks ago and refused to leave. From there and a bit of Wiki-ing I discovered the connection between Miracle Musical and TH and they've been pretty much on repeat play ever since.

[@beetlebat]

Dang you didn’t know they were connected? That’s kinda funny

[@TheFrogfather1]

@@beetlebat even funnier neither did Frog even though they knew about TallyHall! They’re now trying to get me into Lemon Demon!

[@Chrisdorian17]

It's been a long time since I've seen such a good video related to the band

[@beetlebat]

Appreciate it! I tried

[@REAL.ROSS.FEDERMAN]

3:27 FELDERMAN? 😭

[@HighDuck404]

Sorry mister felderman

[@REAL.ROSS.FEDERMAN]

@@HighDuck404 🤩👍

[@beetlebat]

Man the last names were kicking my ass in this video

[@REAL.ROSS.FEDERMAN]

@@beetlebat lol it happens

[@computerfighter2000]

I can’t escape them

[@beetlebat]

They’re everywhere!!!

[@RobertStoll]

I know what ended up happening to the band but... man I miss them.

[@beetlebat]

I’m sure everyone does

[@riantly]

I LOVE TALLY HALL IT MAKES ME SO HAPPY WHEN I SEE TALLY HALL CONTENT

[@beetlebat]

As you should!

[@DRAGONofFROST]

🖤🤍 I only found Tally Hall about 3 years ago, but ever since, I haven't been able to stop listening, and they are now my favorite band. As for my favorite song, i can't decide between 'Welcome to Tally Hall' and 'Spring and a storm'. And im still learning more about them every day! ❤️💛💚💙🩶

[@beetlebat]

I’ll have more videos about them coming!

[@DRAGONofFROST]

Awesome! Can't wait!💗

[@Cricklebite]

Awesome video! Can’t wait for you to cover Will Wood 😎👍

[@beetlebat]

It’ll be fun

[@theoriginalvivian]

"white boy magic" >zubin >andrew

[@beetlebat]

LOL

[@kevinralfi4641]

could you do That Handsome Devil one day, maybe this one's _a bit_ different but it's kind of a rock band with a mostly "underground" and "strange" vibe and pretty serious topic (you've probably guessed it), some songs that I often see people mention are Charlie's Inferno and Elephant Bones (I personally like the latter). btw that was a pretty good Tally Hall analysis you made, Banana Man is one of my favourite songs (and the reason I got into Tally Hall and listen to them alot lol). Apologize if my wordings is pretty wired and convoluted, I don't usually talk to other people that much 😅

[@beetlebat]

Will do, I adore Banana Man

[@BlueCanaryNightLight]

I cant stop listening and watching these people's skits 😭

[@beetlebat]

They are hilariouss

[@jumptrash]

whoever compared ajr to tally hall has committed a CRIME!! lol

[@beetlebat]

ahh come on you can’t deny their a bit similar in style 😂

[@StarWatcher_2024]

Could you maybe check out Lemon Demon? It's has my same type of fanbase as tally hall, though has MUCH more albums and the person behind it has made so much more stuff than just lemon demon

[@beetlebat]

So many bands to check out wow! Will do

[@QuillPGall]

i’ve never liked tally hall outside of a couple songs since i discovered them my sophomore year in 2016, but it’s nice to hear another perspective as always. fire video

[@beetlebat]

Dang, you caught them before a lot of people clearly

[@ezraoberheim1081]

Jukebox The Ghost is also fantastic lol I saw them last year, they put on a great show. Their music often has a simialr tongue in cheek attitude but its also a lot more sincere than what Tally Hall made. Jonathan Coulton also makes music quite similar to Tally Hall, and Flight of the Concords, and They Might Be Giants

[@beetlebat]

i just thought their name was funny

[@ZZZZierra]

i'd love to see one of these videos on jack stauber, super underrated tbh

[@Rule_0]

6:36 nope. not last... hawaii: part II is their last album... though its under miracle musical, it was made by the tally hall guys so it still counts... just dont look into the lyrics of variations on a cloud

[@beetlebat]

that’s fairly true, will discuss that in an upcoming video

[@BlueCanaryNightLight]

21:08 BETTY FROM ADVENTURE TIME IN THE BACKROUND!?

[@beetlebat]

good catch

[@bread-stick42]

BANANA MAN IS SO FRICKIN' GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I CAN AGREE, I JUST ACT LIKE IT IS ABOUT NOTHING CUZ THAT IS THE BEST THING I HAVE HEARD. so i love banana man, it is my favorite tally hall song.

[@beetlebat]

@@bread-stick42 it might be my favorite one too lol

[@bread-stick42]

some of my friends and family don't like my music interest, my grandma doesn't like Banana Man😭. so far what i have experienced is that if you find someone that doesn't like music like tally hall's just show them Be Born and they will get into it. that is so far the only song my grandma and one of my friends actually liked by them. (my friend kinda likes the band but loves their humor way more than their music)

[@beetlebat]

@@bread-stick42 I think The Bidding is more family friendly as well

[@RanchDressing-t8j]

Woah! I expected this to be from like two years ago at the start of the video. (Till I heard about the docs.) I really really should not be doing this right now as I do not want to be absolutely bashed by people online. Joe doesn't deserve the stuff thats been happening to him, as for when people draw the band as a whole, they leave him out and replace him with a different member. He doesn't deserve to be doxxed, anything like that. He isn't/wasn't in a good mental state at that time and still probably isn't. Does that mean i support him or think what he did was right? Absolutely not. Anyway how about I actually get to what this video is about. For one this is an amazing video and I will most likely use some of this for a school project if I even get too. Or just for a fun little thing that I want to make for all the songs. Especially the MMMM stuff. I love how you worded some of the stuff in this, at some points it was funny as well. Very much so sorry if this doesn't make sense I don't know what to say or whatsgha (And the fact that I'm commenting this 4 months later) 😪 AGHHAA AN EDIT SINCE I FORGOT TO ASK: if you haven't done Rob's album yet would you be able to do that?

[@beetlebat]

@@RanchDressing-t8j wow thanks for the support! i do plan to cover Rob’s album after i get through other suggestions

[@anabsolutejoke]

great video! i wonder if you could do one for nav

[@beetlebat]

That’d be interesting

[@Blabhabonsteriods]

Bro Ross Felderman is crazy bro 💀

[@saturnzhornetz44]

"white boy band" Zubin:

[@beetlebat]

Mostly white boy band

[@Nmac-]

Love Tally Hall bro. You should Definitely Cover YourFavoriteMartian (& Maybe Some of RayWilliamJohnsons other musical works)

[@beetlebat]

Oh that could be a trip

[@SolciteGuy]

It's weird seeing actual essays on the band lately. I'm too used to brainrot and shitposts. I hope you'll kinda go over the side projects one day! (mostly Not a Trampoline, Sketches, and Joe Hawley Joe Hawley)

[@beetlebat]

Will check out Miracle Musical!

[@Gao-t1b]

11:52 Correction : this song is NOT about a no or yes or why But is in fact about a little sigh

[@beetlebat]

@@Gao-t1b Yes.

[@anotherdnb]

Aight, sure. Now do Swans. THAT one is weird to explain why people like me like it.

[@beetlebat]

@@anotherdnb Ooooo good one

[@abyssyt2256]

You actually went to MMMM?? I love that. Tally Hall is amazing. I’ve noticed judging by your channel that we have similar music tastes.

[@theunluckyone1602]

32:10 MTV said themselves that Tally Hall is like a blend of Queen, Weezer and The Beatles.

[@beetlebat]

@@theunluckyone1602 makes sense

[@peenwald8852]

the biggest brain blast for me here was when you showed MY copy of the pingry EP in the footage. like i completely forgot that my scan of my original CD has been the definitive scan of that disc for a year or so and i can tell by the serial number on the inside of the disc!!! i cna tell that that's the old version of the photo straight from myphotocopier, from before people on the wiki color-corrected it like half a year later.

[@beetlebat]

@@peenwald8852 Oh that’s quite neat

[@nancymaximoff8172]

i like watching other peoples opinion on something i like. thank you.

[@beetlebat]

i’m glad you liked my opinion

[@awakenedxxz]

i feel like i'm the only socially, mentally okay, straight white male that likes tally hall

[@beetlebat]

@@awakenedxxz I can almost relate to this statement

[@GornGornStudios]

dude you gotta listen to neil cicierga/ lemon demon. its so good, and their fanbase overlaps with with tally halls

[@beetlebat]

never heard of them, so many artists out there!

[@GornGornStudios]

@@beetlebat trust me it's good

[@riantly]

@@beetlebatneil cicierega/lemon demon is super duper awesome please listen to lemon demon

[@moxxiepeppino]

This bane makes me happy that I was born in Michigan

[@beetlebat]

@@moxxiepeppino same

[@Flakiees]

This video is really well made!! Great work!

[@beetlebat]

Appreciate it bro

[@Screamingman10121]

banana man goes fucking crazy 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@beetlebat]

YESSS

[@Screamingman10121]

@OppositeHall I have a question for you Do you see banana man, hopping over on the white hot sand?

[@halfsine]

banana man goes bananas*

[@Screamingman10121]

@@halfsine wait real omg

[@REDGREENBLUEGRAVITY]

Banana Man Is My Favorite Tally Hall Song, Fight Me!.

[@beetlebat]

Based

[@_ridemoth_]

I know this is random but PLEASE check out Death Grips ! The Money Store is pretty good in my opinion :}

[@beetlebat]

I definitely will down the line. I’ve heard the name for years but never heard their music

[@mrfriendly504]

I love tally hall. And so far this is really good!

[@beetlebat]

Glad you are loving it

[@bad6327]

The way you pronounce the names are killing me(dont worry its fine...except for bora what were you thinking) also uh you should listen to chonny jash (not johnny cash,please I've heard this like a thousand times) he has covered tally hall, will wood, thd (that handsome devil) etc and i think you might like him and if you do please talk about him (please we need more fans)

[@beetlebat]

I’m gonna get these comments a lot I assume 😂

[@Adrobean]

Simple answer: They are fun to listen to and specific songs just get you thinking and theorizing. Simpler answer: LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORE+ funny meme

[@beetlebat]

I love lore and memes!!

[@p1xelat3d]

This band was my first obsession

[@beetlebat]

@@p1xelat3d I can see why

[@nuggiewuggiemusic]

You have to do The Appeal Of Lemon Demon. He is literally on the same level as Tally Hall, and also makes quirky kinda music sorta like Tally Hall. I recommend listening to his most recent and popular album Spirit Phone. He also has a whole career on his own, making Brodyquest, the Ultimate Showdown Of Ultimate Destiny, and the Mysterious Ticking Noise, and basically invented internet culture as we know it today.

[@beetlebat]

Expect a video from them in a few weeks

[@number2869]

PLEASE WE NEED 30 MILLION MONTHLY LISTENERS GUYS THEY NEED TO BE BACK TOGETHER 😭

[@beetlebat]

One day.

[@number2869]

@@beetlebat YES! ONE DAY, EVEN IF WE ARE ALL IN OUR 60’S

[@BlueCanaryNightLight]

I HOPE ZUBIN IS NOT SERIOUS WITH30 MIL 😭

[@number2869]

@@BlueCanaryNightLightI SWEAR IF HE IS 😭

[@fionak357]

Ok I mean what they make is for sure white people music but in such a good way 😭 splendorous whitey execution I must say 🫶🏻🙏🏻

[@beetlebat]

Shoutout white people amirite

[@fionak357]

@@beetlebat Now, as a white person, I would normally say no, but in this case, absolutely yes they ate

[@SandmanVR]

The first album is based off of the museum not the museum is based off of the first album

[@beetlebat]

I know lol? that intro was sarcastic

[@Pal_EX]

love this video! your editing style is fresh & i look forward to the bands you cover in the future 👍

[@beetlebat]

A lot of bands to talk about!

[@dr2unshine]

time to do will wood next 🤗🤗

[@beetlebat]

I plan to do a video on him eventually, “Hand Me A Shovel” is incredible

[@dr2unshine]

@@beetlebat YAYYYYYYY

[@straw_eater]

bro you should do weezer

[@beetlebat]

they have a longgg discography but i might have to

[@daisysandmarigolds7566]

Do miracle musical please!

[@beetlebat]

I have!

[@daisysandmarigolds7566]

Just saw it! Great video 👍❤️

[@Verze4826]

"ross felderman"

[@beetlebat]

@@Verze4826 oof

[@cambagonia]

id say their inspirational enough since i want to make music now because i listened to them

[@beetlebat]

Glad they inspired you!

[@aldenmccoy7561]

I went to MMMM the day we saw yuno miles!!!

[@beetlebat]

NO WAY I DID TOO

[@_ridemoth_]

This is the last place I’d expect to hear about Yuno Miles lol

[@sola_is_chilling]

felderman

[@summers97N]

I bet he wont reply to this

[@beetlebat]

bet

[@summers97N]

@@beetlebat man I bet 50 bucks on this

[@summers97N]

@@beetlebat I am in poverty

[@summers97N]

@@beetlebat my house was eaten by a giant radioactive rat

[@henryshedden1000]

I always thought hidden in the sand was about a failed proposal

[@beetlebat]

That could also be the case

[@tristanjae7780]

This video made me make a whole song based on the 5 minute song of tally hall 13 it’s called 24 and I will post later tonight

[@beetlebat]

Glad I inspired you, will check that out

[@tristanjae7780]

@@beetlebat thank you

[@masqueraid988]

I honestly think Tally Hall has a very interesting thing going with their idea of nothing. That having a kind of absurd run of lyrics with meaning behind it.

[@estenslop]

pretty good video but i want to make 1 correction: im 99% sure good day is about TV. i could be wrong, so dont quote me on this, however itmakes sense igåf you look at the lyrics

[@beetlebat]

That makes total sense actually

[@riiseingirl]

tally hall more like silly hall 😂😂😂😂😂

[@beetlebat]

A comedian 😂

[@Dinosaurchestra74]

Ok, I’m aware I’m late, but since you’ve done AJR and Tally Hall, you HAVE to do Lemon Demon, trust me, his music is amazing! (Uhhh don’t listen to his first two albums, they were kinda bad [maybe cuz they were his first albums he sang in and he didn’t do instrumental music like deporitaz])

[@beetlebat]

I already did a video on LD! Should be on my channel

[@Dinosaurchestra74]

@@beetlebat Got it!

[@yasquerda]

oh my god you should totally check out will wood!

[@beetlebat]

i got recommended him earlier! i guess i gotta

[@dr2unshine]

@@beetlebatYOU DO. WILL WOOD IS THE BEST MUSIC ARTIST TO EVER EXIST I LOVE WILL WOOD SO MUCH 🤗🤗🤗

[@riantly]

@@beetlebatYOU DO.

[@hotcrazy15]

taIIy haII

[@Guy96477]

Even though I lost interest in this band I will forever say that Fate of the Stars is my favorite song

[@Maybe2300]

Okay one sec their first album was named after the museum not the other way around

[@beetlebat]

@@Maybe2300 yeah ik

[@strateupgamr7]

6:03 Said the man named Beetle Bat

[@beetlebat]

you got me there

[@D4rkGreen]

lol i just saw the video, good work and ty

[@beetlebat]

Thank you! Did you see my other one about MM?

[@D4rkGreen]

yes, i just saw it like 2 hours ago, amazing vid aswell!

[@Astatine16]

Why are so many channels adapting to my music taste??? First AJR and now Tally Hall? What is this witchery?

[@beetlebat]

The white boys are taking over

[@Astatine16]

@@beetlebat The two bands have a lot in common too 😭

[@DaProEnderman]

the first album used the name of the museum

[@beetlebat]

Issa jokeee

[@computerfighter2000]

also do Oingo Boingo next 😈😈😈😈

[@beetlebat]

never heard of em, similar style?

[@computerfighter2000]

no, they were pretty popular in the 80's & have a new-wavey style in their earlier albums, but then later in the 80's moved to pop rock, & then in the 90's they completely changed their style@@beetlebat

[@aristotlesApproval]

T al l yhall

[@beetlebat]

Tall Y Ha Ll

[@peteindeed]

who's to blame?

[@beetlebat]

@@peteindeed idek

[@peteindeed]

@@beetlebat the automated players, i proclaim

[@Sebastian_Pressure12]

tal ha;l

[@beetlebat]

taly hal

[@Мартинчо456]

good video!!

[@beetlebat]

Thank you so much!

[@stitchgor3]

Tally hall

[@beetlebat]

hally tall

[@yellowyacket4886]

Hall Tally

[@Trilliumszz]

Personally I enjoy Good and Evil a lot :00 It is calmer but I really like & and Turn The Lights Off quite a bit ! It could very well be that I’ve listened to them WAAYYY too much though lol

[@beetlebat]

Turn The Lights Off is growing on me a bit admittedly

[@Trilliumszz]

@@beetlebat Excellent >:) the tallygenda is working

[@Tw2wuv]

I love this but please never say their last names like that again

[@beetlebat]

I tried

[@idontlikeyou4545]

im sorry but i have to say that i dont really like how you do your band video essays. the last video essay that i watched from you was about will wood and you got some things wrong about him and it seemed like you did more surface level research than anything. maybe that was the aim of the video, to cover surface level knowledge about him, but i just want to say that MMMM did not name the mueseum after their album. some of the band members that used to live in the area wanted to pay tribute to that mueseum and so they named the album after the mueseum, not the other way around. it really sounds like youre doing tiktok level research ://///

[@beetlebat]

Ok i understand the will wood video but the MMMM thing was a complete sarcastic joke in the intro. i’m aware they named the album after the museum and not the other way around!

[@idontlikeyou4545]

@@beetlebat oh shoot im sorry! didnt realise that was a joke that was my fault :0