The Battle of the Cardigans - Which one is my favourite?

[@teresawanderer4182]

Very thorough! Appreciate fabric sources and all comments!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Awesome! Thank you so much for watching!

[@cath3354]

Thanks for the reviews of these cardis. I have made the Harper cardi and I have on my cutting table another one to make.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

You are so welcome! The Harper cardigan is a really good one! 💞

[@pamelaliebelt9967]

Awesome video Izzy! Thanks for all the reviews.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

My pleasure!! 💞

[@gerrysiebert8639]

Love the style arc cardi! And the blackwood cardi is a wonderful colour for you.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you! The Style Arc cardigan is the one that’s been worn the most during my trip. It goes with everything!!

[@sherrelstroot3034]

Hi Izzy. Your video ( as usual) is very helpful and entertaining. Living in south Texas cardigan is what I need. I love your cardigans.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much! 💞

[@karolmolpus9536]

Love Style Arc because they always turn out beautifully! They expect you to know how to sew pretty well!😅

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

They really do assume you have quite a bit of knowledge!! I do love my finished cardigan though. ☺️

[@nancyhilborn885]

Nice to see so many cardigan patterns in one place for comparison. Thought you might want to take a look at the Yvonne Coatigan by Bobbins and Buttons. I won this pattern in a challenge last year. I haven't sewn it up yet but would like to get on it before the Christmas rush. It is relaxed fit with a raised back neck which is what drew me to it. Should be cozy for the Canadian winter to come.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Hi Nancy! I think you mentioned that one before and I haven’t looked at it yet. Definitely will look at it though because I do love a high back neck! 💞

[@joesmay]

Brilliant vlog, so informative. I will definitely try the Chashmerette Cardigan as I love raglan sleeves. I have made about five Harpers, which I love. Hope you have enjoyed your trip to the UK, at least you will have had some interesting weather!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you!! I definitely recommend the Cashmerette cardi - I’ll probably make at least one more. My trip to the UK has been fantastic (we come home tomorrow) and like you said, we were spoiled weather-wise. We saw rain for about 1 hour last week and sun the rest of the time. I carried an umbrella and a rain coat all over the UK for no reason and probably didn’t need so many cardigans. But not complaining! 😂

[@LostMyThread]

The Fuller Cardigan is only available in the original size range, not the smaller sizes. I love the look of it and even emailed them to ask if they have plans to make it in the smaller sizes, and they said no. 😢 Yours looks fabulous.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Oh no - I assumed it was available in their full size range because it came out not very long ago. That’s really too bad because it is a good pattern. 😕

[@socarole66]

Ooooo look at that red cardi on you ❤ Stunning . Harper cardi seems to be a winner for everyone, I know Jen loves it and did a Big 4 comparison. I also love the striped one and the longer length looks so nice on you. What a great bunch of cardigans…wonder what the collective noun is for cardigans…A closet of Cardis perhaps? 😂😂😂😂. I nearly made a Harper once but that’s a long story and I’m sure I have told you before… if not I will tomorrow 😂. Great video and you will be super cosy all Winter long now ❤xx

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

A closet of cardis does sound right doesn’t it? 😂 They’ll come in handy for this winter but I definitely did not need this many for my trip!! Xx 💞

[@madsenandco]

Great battle 🤩 thank you. They all look good on you . I Think i might give the Harper a go.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

You should - it’s a great pattern and it’s free!! Thank you so much for visiting and commenting! 💞

[@ZeldaSews]

I hear StyleArk patterns are skimpy with instructions and a little confusing. But the actual garments turn out nicely if you know what you're doing, and you did know what you were doing.😊

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

The Style Arc instructions on this pattern were extremely basic and not very useful. But I’m hearing that their newer patterns have better instructions so who knows!! 💞

[@InAgatasCottage]

Fantastic cardigans Izzy. Hope you are enjoying your time in UK

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

I am! The weather has been amazing the whole time we’ve been here except for a day where it rained a bit. 💞

[@kathyerikson637]

Love your review of all these cardigans. I just had the harper printed and will make it soon. I’ve been making the Metra Blazer from Love Notions. I call it my elevated cardigan as it is knit and doesn’t have buttons. I did size up as my normal size was a bit tight in the arms

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you! The Harper is definitely a good one. I LOVE the Metra Blazer and I’ve made it 3 times now. You’re so right about it being an elevated cardigan! 💞

[@lesliemcarthur9902]

I don’t have a problem with 1/4” seam allowances-I think maybe designers use that when the item is likely to be served-but I absolutely hate it when you can’t find the seam allowance easily. In fact, this is one of my major gripes with “indie” patterns: the SA could be anything and it can be almost impossible to find. When I took pattern drafting in college back in the dark ages (and we always used 1cm or 2cm allowances) that would have been an automatic fail. But thanks for your reviews of all these patterns. Very, very helpful.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

I’m so happy you found the video helpful. I agree - if indie pattern designers aren’t going to be consistent with their SA, the very least they can do is make it super simple for us to find them! Some indies are really good at that, but some aren’t. 💞

[@stephaniecruz8260]

Izzy, my Fuller Cardigan was snug too, I thought I messed up 😮. It looks great but I think Harper is my favorite 😊

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Ok well I’m glad it wasn’t just me that the Fuller turned out a little snug for! I do love the Harper too - that colour just makes me incredibly happy! Thank you! 💞

[@ErinSews]

I really like the curved hem of the cocoon cardigan but can’t stand things being fitted on my upper arms, so I’ll probably steer clear of it. I’ll definitely get the Harper cardigan since it’s free, so why not give it a try! If I buy one of these for the fall/winter it will be the Fuller. The raglan sleeve, shaping darts, and mitered corners are all amazing details. Thanks for this very thorough run down!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

The Harper is definitely one to have. It’s super quick to make and like you said, it’s free so why not. The Fuller is a really good one too, but a lot more involved. 💞

[@sammof7939]

from the mrs: great video. Enjoyed the pattern review and fabric selections. great makes!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much!

[@SewMyTime]

Really useful video again. You are so clear and concise. You never waffle which is great. Loved the Blackwood and the band sets it off. The Style Arc instruction comments made me laugh. I once spent over an hour on one line of a Style Arc faux wrap skirt pattern trying to figure it out. I got there eventually but boy, did my head hurt! Never made a cardigan but have just downloaded the Marlo and ordered fabric so watch this space. Hope you are enjoying your trip. 😊

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Awww thank you so much!! Yeah the Style Arc instructions just did not make sense to me at all. I like the Marlo but not sure it would look good on me. If I’m not mistaken, it’s really oversized and I tend not to like that on me. My trip has been amazing but I’m now anxious to get home. I miss hubby and the cats. 😂💞

[@debbiecook4270]

Thank you for the cardi run down! I really like that the stripes in the band of the Blackwood DON'T match across with the bodice pieces. I think it makes a greater visual impact. And it looks intentional since, as you said, they do match each other across your body. I've made a free In the Folds Slouchy Cardigan from Peppermint Magazine that I like a lot - it is a cocoon shape like your Sydney. I just found your channel recently and have been enjoying it!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much! To be honest, I didn’t think I’d like the Sydney as much as i do. And I wore it a couple of times during my trip and it’s super comfy! 💞

[@KTquiltsandsews]

great vlog Izzy! I love cardigans and enjoyed hearing about the details of and seeing all your different makes. More convincing that I really need to sew up the Harper Sinclair cardigan especially since i need a win. I finished the Cashmerette Kineton..even expanding it to fit my body but it looked awful so I have already given it away. Suppose each make brings learning so not a total loss. Also inspired me to dump probably half of my closet which leaves room for me mades. xx Karen

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much Karen! The Harper is a really, really good one and so quick to sew. I think it’ll definitely be a win for you. I made the Kineton last year and although I liked it, I think it would need a little bit of work to fit my body shape better. I had the same thought as you about a closet clean out last night. I’m running out of room and I need to have a good look at what I really wear and get rid of the stuff I don’t. Xx 💞

[@upcycledcopycat8389]

If you're machine gives you grief sewing buttonholes through different thicknesses....I started by-passing the foot pedal for ALL buttonholes and using the start-stop button (if your machine has that option). It was a game changer giving me so much less anxiety. I've had my janome for almost 9 years and never used that button. I thought it was a wierd button to begin with. But for buttonholes.... with all the different buttonhole options on my machine... My Buttonholes are perfect everytime.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much for the tip!! I’m not near my machine right now, but I’ll definitely check to see if I have that button on there. Can you believe I’ve had that machine for over a year and never thought to check if it has a start/stop button?? 😂

[@upcycledcopycat8389]

@@dizzyquiltsandsews ... If you're machine has two seperate plugs, one for the machine and one for the foot pedal then you prob have the button. You have to remove the foot pedal plug from the machine to engage the stop/start button.

[@MaryCunningham-u5j]

OK, why haven't I made a Harper cardigan by now???? I'm going to do it - you've convinced me! I do like the Style Arc one very much, too - they're all good!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Yes - definitely make a Harper!! 💞

[@ZeldaSews]

I picked up that free cardigan from Sinclair. Natieda did those buttons? Nice!!!😊

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Oh nice - you won’t regret it. The Harper is a really good one. Nateida sold the buttons, but Pigeon Wishes made them. 😊

[@karolmolpus9536]

Like large side seam pockets

[@jankerslake5813]

Well the Harper Sinclair wins it for me. Whilst I really liked the smartness of the Style Arc cardigan on you, the lack of instructions irritate me with Style Arc. I’ve made one of their patterns and KZbin was my friend! The Blackwood cardigan was lovely too. I actually thought the stripes on the band were intentional and I really like the effect! 😄 The red Harper fabric colour is awesome on you. I’ve just got this free Sinclair pattern and I think it’ll be my first try at sewing a cardigan. Thank you for an excellent review. 👍

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

You are most welcome!! The Harper is such a good pattern and you really can’t beat free! 😂

[@stillstitchin]

That was really interesting, Izzy. You have definitely filled a need in your wardrobe. I’m rather resistant to layering and rarely need to for my climate, but I liked the style of the raglan sleeve cardigan.Thanks for sharing! 😊-Deborah

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

You are welcome! Thank you for stopping by! 💞

[@sewsewsewist785]

I downloaded the harper some time ago and am very inspired to make one now. I really enjoyed your video and appreciate your substantial content and brevity. Just subscribed!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Awesome! Thank you so much! 💞

[@AndraMakes]

I am a cardi girl! Fab info, Izzy! Thank you so much! All yours are beautiful! 💗

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you Andra! 💞

[@DebsWay]

You made a nice assortment of cardis. I liked the rounded front of the Sydney but I'd have to change those fitted sleeves for sure. The Harper is pretty easy to do? I might have to give that a try. It looked comfortable and I like the different lengths. Thanks for sharing!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you Deb! I definitely recommend the Harper. It is super simple to sew and like you said, a bunch of different lengths. Also, depending on the fabric, you can totally change the look of it. 💞

[@DebsWay]

Thanks, Izzy! I actually got that one and another pattern called Sophia.

[@PracticalStitches]

They all look great on you. I agree with you the grey one is a nice style. I actually liked your stripes mismatched on the band I thought it was an interesting feature😊

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Oh thank you Shari! 💞

[@janepack850]

Perfect timing Izzy. I'm also a cardi girl. The Cashmerette cardi is on the to do list. Going to keep all your info in mind. Thanks Izzy💞

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

You're so welcome! Cardigans are just so practical in the Fall and Spring (and in the winter). You can wear a sleeveless top and just add a cardigan and you’re good to go!! 💞

[@Lorij83]

I especially loved this video. It is what I need to make plans for layering this fall. You did such a good job summarizing them.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

I'm so glad you found the video helpful! Thank you so much for visiting! 💞

[@ChristineSewsALot]

The raglan sleeve on the Cashmerette pattern fits you so well. How many cardigans do you have 😂😂

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you Christine! I have many - they are my favourite thing to wear from about September to May. I need one in every colour and style. 😂

[@maidenmakesreviews]

Hi, not sure if it's been mentioned but Style Arc is Australian and our sizing is smaller than the US. Women's 14 Au is smaller than American 14 by about 2 sizes. I love their patterns.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Hi! I chose my size not based on the number, but based on my measurements because I know sizes differ from pattern company to another and from region to another. But even after choosing based on my measurement, the cardigan turned out a little big. That’s also what I found in my research. Thank you for mentioning it though. 😊

[@donnaschindlbeck7457]

I’ve been waiting for this review! I love making and wearing cardigans but have only made the Harper and one from Love Notions. Would like to try the Cashmerette one next. I can’t wear DBP in tops but can in a cardigan, it’s one of my favorites.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

I feel the same way about DBP. I have one top in it that I wear only in Winter when it’s really cold. 😂 The Cashmerette one is really good, but definitely more involved. 💞

[@granjan252]

GREAT review, Izzy. Lots of helpful detail about each pattern. Since I have retired, I find that cardigans are a perfect layering piece for my current lifestyle. My fav is the Harper. I have a cropped Harper cut out and ready to sew. It is a black cable knit with contrast banding in cream lightweight Ponte. I think (am hoping) it will be a good one for a dressier look and feel.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much! A Harper in black with a cream detail sounds really stylish and definitely dressier!! 💞

[@marionmathews9852]

This was a great evaluation of all your cardigan makes. The only cardigan that I’ve made so far is the Heidi cardigan by Style Arc. I used the size that the pattern suggested, but in my case it came out too snug. I found the instructions very confusing at times. I’ve only been sewing for myself for 18 months. I am looking for another cardigan pattern to try, and I’m very tempted by the Blackwood cardigan pattern.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you!! Yeah the Style Arc instructions are pretty bad. If you like the style of the Blackwood (more fitted and won’t close in the front), I highly recommend that one. If you like a more relaxed fit, then the Harper is amazing. 💞

[@quiltygal6981]

I have the Harper but haven't made it yet, my go to cardigan is the Itch to Stitch Averio.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

I haven't tried that one - I should have a look because I love ITS patterns! 💞

[@bridget9111]

I’ve made at least five harpers they are so quick and good. I don’t think I’d bother with the Blackwood as it’s intentionally more open and I don’t think it will suit me. I made a Sydney and l love the more fitted cocoon shape, I did however find the pockets too bulky on the band seam as it’s a thicker cardie, rookie error as I was doing it I thought this will be bulky I’ve made it a bit better with hidden hand stitching but only wear it in the house. I’ve also made the itch to stitch Lisbon a round neck button through, very nice a bit smarter. A very fancy cardigan I’ve made is the Kirsi (shorter length) by forget me not patterns in a gorgeous knit jacquard definitely one for special occasions. As you can see I love cardies and would like to try the fuller next I take the same size as you so I’ll proceed with caution. Thanks for the great vlog I really enjoyed it ❤

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

I’m so glad you enjoyed the review! I also found the round hem of the Sydney was really thick because of the pockets and it doesn’t lie absolutely flat because of it so definitely something I’ll keep in mind if I make it again. If you made and love the Harper, I would definitely not bother with the Blackwood. 💞

[@TodayinJensSewingRoom]

Thanks so much for the comparison! I'm a huge fan of the Harper (as you know), but it's good to know there are other options out there. I should do the same for some Big 4's. You are inspiring as ever - xoxox

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Awww thank you Jen!! I also love the Harper and although I like all the cardigans I made, when I need a quick one that’s more relaxed, I’ll definitely make the Harper. 💞

[@angienorman5974]

Wow you’ve been busy! I’ve only ever made the Harper and am really happy with how perfect it turned out. Wondering if any of your fabric stores have online stores. I live in U.S. so probably not going to Canada for fabric!

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Hi Angie! The Harper is a really good one - I have another on my cutting table right now, but for my daughter this time. All the fabric stores i use in Canada are online shops and I usually put links in the description box. 💞

[@knottygnome]

thanks for the detailed comparison! i've made several blackwoods myself and it always bugs me how tight the sleeves are. i should really try the harper one of these days to see if the fit is more to my current taste.

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Your Blackwoods look amazing on you! The Harper is definitely more relaxed in the sleeves and the bodice. I usually choose the Blackwood when I don’t really need extra warmth, but a layer to finish the look. If I need warmth, I’ll go for the Harper every time. 💞

[@BYBabbra]

All five are lovely and fit you real well. I'm not a cardigan person so have never worn them and I don't think I will, but you make them look so stylish. Did they come in useful on your hols?

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you so much! I did not wear them as much as I thought I would because it’s been strangely very hot in the UK for the past 2 weeks. 😂 But they’ll come in handy in Canada this winter I’m sure! 💞

[@suemacfarlane7372]

Thanks for the video Izzy :) I love the line of the Harper, and am definitely going to make that. I have a few gaps in my wardrobe for cooler weather too, and cardigans is definitely one of them. I don't think I've ever made one, so looking forward to trying it. I have lots on my sewing table at the moment, and have not been doing very much as I've been sick with the dreaded lurgy. Just getting well, catching up on the chores, and starting to do some sewing again. I love waterfall cardigans, do you have any recommendations for one of these? Take care x

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Thank you Sue! The Harper is definitely a good one to try. I’m so sorry you’ve not been well but glad you’re on the mend. I don’t have any recommendations for a waterfall because I looked for one and couldn’t find one I really liked. 😕 💞

[@annewhitney8809]

I want a pattern with a collar. The back of my neck gets cold and then I’m cold all over.😉

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

Yes!! The Harper's neckband does come up in the back a bit and you can always widen it. 💞

[@MountainAccentsSewing]

I enjoyed this review. I have never made a cardigan. I do have the Harper cardigan. This may be the year I make it. 😊🧵🪡

[@dizzyquiltsandsews]

If you wear cardigans, I can definitely recommend the Harper! It’s very simple to sew and has a number of lengths for different looks. Thank you for visiting Cynthia! 💞