The Battling Bugler | What Happened to Corporal Metzger at the Fetterman Fight?

[@1WillyK]

The story of Cpl. Metzger is one I've known about a long time. The fact that the Indians did not mutilate him but rather covered him in a buffalo robe was a great honor not given to any other white man I know of. He obviously personified fighting spirit and courage to them. An honorable act given to an honorable enemy no matter how much they hated the invaders.

[@brysonbutler8942]

John 3:16

[@alwaysfourfun1671]

Thank you for telling the story of Adolph Metzger in a pleasant and respectful way. It is the most detailed account that I have heard about "the bugler".

[@cmcer1995]

This was an amazing story of bravery to the point that even the enemy looked towards him with respect and honored him in death. Even while severely wounded he still fought until he scummed to his injuries. Interesting that at least two Indians recognized and remembered him and spoke highly of him as well. It is good that even now he is being honored by the military too as he is remembered. Great video.

[@actionjackson1stIDF]

While I knew of the Fetterman fight I had never heard of Metzger. I really enjoyed the way this was presented, especially with the inclusion of Native American oral history. Far to often Native American oral histories are discounted when in reality they often can bring a new perspective on historical events. Great job and keep up the food work.

[@gregkerr725]

Great video. I have long known about the Fetterman battles, but had never heard of Metzger. Unfortunately life is full of such heroes whose deeds go unsung...thanks for highlighting this man's story!

[@Newjerseyblows]

A certain basterd with the same first name probably didn't help his cause either

[@bobbeaner2835]

Thank you for sharing the story of a brave immigrant bugler. Courage is an uncommon characteristic shared by people regardless of race or culture. A clash of cultures led to this sad story, and preserving the unique details is important. Thank you for creating this video.

[@jimgibson9753]

Job well done with your narrative of the story. Metzler's life and actions are truly inspirational. Thank you.

[@markbelmares7138]

I read this story as a youngster, I wasn't sure if it was the truth, so many tales are embellished. Indeed! what courage this man showed, and to be honored so by the Sioux and Cheyenne.

[@leo8049]

Great video! Super interesting to learn about these untold stories of American history. I assume most Americans wouldn't know of them either without videos like this!

[@TheStoryOutWest]

I’m doing my part. Glad you liked the video!

[@WyomingTraveler]

I knew about Metzger, but the exact circumstances of his death are a mystery. You did an excellent job of telling the Metzger story.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you sir!

[@sirpainter1]

Looks like you have some good content on your channel. I'll be checking your stuff out. I love good ole Wyoming History. I live in Laramie & my cabin is 2 years older than the Wyoming Territorial Prison which I can see from my house.

[@johnmatthews8524]

He was a brave man

[@matthewmarek1467]

Legit every time you post a video, I know I'm in for an entertaining and educational ride. This one did not disappoint. Your ability to coalesce a complicated story into complete and engaging narrative is beyond excellent.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

That legit means a lot to me. Thank you 🙏

[@jameshenderson3238]

A most enjoyable and informative video. As a Montana resident, I must say how much I enjoy the history of this area in SE Montana and Northern Wyoming. Thank you.

[@richarddavenport31]

THE POOR MAN WAS TERRIFIED TO KNOW HE WAS ABOUT TO DIE. WHAT A HERO, WHAT A MAN!!!! LOVED THE STORY ABOUT HIM!!! THANK YOU!!!

[@wookeybradbury]

You tell every story so eloquently. I wish your videos were twice as long!

[@powderfinger6597]

Counting Coup was the highest act of bravery a Plains Indian could do. Metzer’s act of only carrying a bugle into battle and fighting was seen as courageous and was treated like a brave warrior when he fell.

[@kittycatcat6962]

They carved a cross into his chest and covered him with a buffalo skin and other trinkets, as barbaric as that sounds it was a honour not bestowed on many on the plains, brave kid

[@roballen8431]

Musicians carried sidearms i.e 1860 army or 1851 navy.

[@cyberleaderandy1]

As a Brit and a European its interesting to hear this story and I always find your videos interesting and informative. Thanks.

[@JohnDavies-cn3ro]

I first came across this story in a book about the Plains Indian wars (can't remember the title now) a long, long time ago and was particularly impressed with it. Oddly, the way it read made Metzger sound almost like a boy soldier rather than a young man; howsoever what mattered was his courage which led his opponents to recognise and honour him. Nice to be reminded of it again, and get the full background. Peace to your bones, soldier.

[@robsmithadventures1537]

A remarkable story. I'd certainly say anyone going into battle with just a bugle is brave

[@davidfrench7035]

Thank you for this video! I've read a fair amount about Native American history, but had never heard about Cpl Metzger. Please make more of these!!

[@colinblick4903]

As an ex trumpeter/ bugler in the kings troop Royal horse artillery……I can fully empathise with this story…. Obviously honoured by the Indians….. I to was a C.O’s trumpeter….. and had to make all the troops calls through the day… mounted an dismounted.😎…… a little addition you might find interesting is that I’ve actually sounded the bugle that was used in the charge of the light brigade…🤨…..I served in the late 60’s an was involved in a small way with the remake of the above film……. And was present at the premiere of the film in London. Great story of yours about trumpeters/Buglers😉

[@sNs-jb5ss]

Thank you for sharing your uniquely personal connection. History is always closer to us than we think.

[@stratocaster1greg]

What a great story. Thanks to the Native Americans for their oral history. I have Cherokee blood and Im proud of it.

[@coldsteelrail1123]

Very moving story

[@KevinSmith-yh6tl]

Great to see you back! And once more,such a great story. You have that certain way of storytelling that alot of us wish we had. Can't wait to see what's in the works for next time. 👍

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you, I’m glad you dig it. I wish I could tell these stories more often 🙏

[@RichGilpin]

Thank you for this wonderful story. I had read much on the Fetterman fight but was unaware of this courageous Corporal. Allons! 11th Cav Vietnam.

[@ChesterWortham]

Much respect to 11th cav in Vietnam iv heard of them

[@robertthompson6346]

This is a great story of a man displaying simple courage - thank you for telling us it

[@vineetkaddu1214]

I am glad I discovered this channel. Not only is the history stuff and presentation great, I am also thankful for the inspiring message you gave in this episode.

[@robkunkel8833]

Nice job. The museum should be proud of the job that you did. Well written. That is important. People can be sincere as your are but telling the story properly without historical cliches is an art that starts with good writing. /// What does this German dissent musician think of this story? The understanding of the native American thought process is the amazing part of the story, for me. The notion of German dedication? Good stuff. We are a dedicated people. Five stars for bravery.

[@ronrobertson59]

I've read many accounts of the Fetterman fight and I knowsbout Metzger this video still gave me new information. I plan to visit the site next summer. (2023)

[@mineown1861]

You can see the warriors' point . To go into battle and be in the thick of it , without means to respond to the fire being directed at you and stay your post to communicate your officers' commands throughout , would have been an outstanding act of bravery .

[@walkietalkietraveller2932]

well said, mine own :)

[@joshuajones9035]

corporal Metzger's bravery reminds me of the charge of the light brigade... bravery and courage that no man, no matter the side, could view and respect

[@Tecumseh16]

I always look forward to your videos and this one also did not disappoint. Keep up the great work.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you 🙏

[@harryanderson6691]

Thank you for this wonerfully told historical story...

[@wysurvivor]

Very well done, the gatchel and it's director are some of the best in country.

[@joeronan2623]

I agree.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

💯

[@LittleLouieLagazza]

This is fascinating. From the beginning, I was pulled right in and mesmerized. Thank you for this EXCELLENT content--keep up the tempo!

[@TheStoryOutWest]

I’m glad you got something out of it

[@stevenbrown6277]

Good documentary. I have often stopped by this battlefield site. I am always the only person there. It is an eerie feeling to be in a place where such violence took place not all that many decades ago. As I walk the narrow path I have seen rattlesnakes basking in the sun. Looking at the rocks amidst the grass I can imagine the horror of the mutilated bodies of the soldiers. I have had thunderstorms suddenly come out of the Bighorn Mountains to break the dead silence and have had to dash back to my car. The sight of the freeway way down in the valley is jarring.

[@luismari5090]

Steadfast bravery while knowing he is at deaths door is honorable.

[@Daniel-fq5vq]

Foreal, what a tough dude? My heart goes out to him. His bugler was probably his pride and joy, like a rifle would be to a solider. So while smashing it on his enemy, he know it was over and he must of fought multiple people at once, to have respect from the Indians. I’d like to think he broke a Indians nose with the bugler, takes the Indians hatchet and throws it at the next one coming at him. It’s so cool the Indians carried that kinda respect for good warriors, Man, I love these stories! Your voice carries a nice cadence. Cool channel.

[@brianmccarthy5557]

Interesting story. I've been at the Fetterman site. In fact at the very rock you pictured. Thanks forxposting Carrington's report on the multilation of the cavalry dead. The media and even the publishers usually censor this out while detailing whire atrocities. Metzger was probably a Sargent in the Civil War Army and like everybody else had to go down a couplexof steps in rank. He had obviously seen brutal combat during the war.

[@davidhoward4715]

Get a clue. The native warriors mutilated the whites' bodies *_in retaliation_* for what the whites did at the Sand Creek Massacre, where most of the deaths were of unarmed noncombatants.

[@MrStrobey]

As a Vietnam veteran I cannot fathom going into a fight without my AR-15. Metzger was obviously a real professional, unbelievably courageous and, at the risk of further abuse of an abused word, a genuine hero. Excellent presentation of a great, great story.

[@yernotthebossofme1062]

🐗🎺🇺🇸🫡 Classic Germanic-American warrior, willing to make the ultimate sacrifice for his new adopted Country, in the Civil War. Made the sacrifice, doing his duty in such a way, it earned the respect of his enemy, fighting for their longtime homeland and for their way of life. What a wonderful find, meaning the story of Trooper Metzger, his duty and speciality, which still exists in the form of radiomen or communicatiom specialists. Not just that but the histories and testimonies preserved and provided from the tribes warriors. Thank you for this video.

[@danlines2725]

Just found you on KZbin. Really like your stuff. I'm a Native American with an archeology and paleontology background. I do my own thing but work with museums and historical societies. Great delivery of facts at hand. Thanks for your work.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you

[@stevenhall2408]

I needed to hear this story today to inspire me "to keep on fighting" for God and country.

[@justinnewton984]

Love to find these stories! So many great tales of the old west worth telling!

[@heplamp8041]

I like the story I like the story of all brave people no matter what race but what I really like is the story-telling and it is nice to hear the soft music playing in the background the music is like Chimes playing in a soft summer night's breeze

[@CaptRandall1]

The way that was instilled in me from a very young age was "never give up, never quit..." . When I was a teenager and reading all that I could about WW2, I remember reading about a General that made the comment , I think it was like this...."Never let the bastards think they won..." I have also greatly liked the saying..."It is not the size of the dog in the fight, but it is the size of the fight in the dog..."

[@Pw.asap99]

Shut up

[@gregandy4277]

I remember hearing this story told by a Native American man who descended from the combatants that were there. I remember him saying in their oral tradition Metzger was armed with a pistol, and after expending all his cartridges, picked up his bugle and began wildly swinging it around, before being killed. The reason they respected Metzger is because he did not run away, nor did he try to surrender.

[@LaRae4724]

Very interesting to hear this. Have been to the Fetterman Memorial, and this really explained so much more. We love your videos!! ❤️

[@TheStoryOutWest]

My pleasure, thanks!

[@Sarappreciates]

My dad had a bugle that was dented and battered form the American Civil War that my grandmother donated to a museum when he died. I don't think it was the same bugle, but I remember it rattled. Very messed up horn. I never heard this story until now, and it reminded me of my dad's old bugle in our basement storage.

[@mikekennedy4572]

Amazing story. Thank you for sharing this.

[@teresaarcangel1102]

I recently read Joseph M Marshall III's book about the Fetterman fight, Hundred in the Hand. Your video was a very interesting supplement. Thank you very much!

[@gallantcavalier3306]

I must say that the story of Adolph Metzger is an interesting one, and the story of his Regiment, the 2nd U.S Cavalry is a rich one. This was an amazing video!! If I may suggest another topic involving the 2nd Cavalry, might I suggest the death of Lieutenant Lyman Kidder and his detachment at the hands of the Cheyenne and Lakota in Kansas while delivering dispatches to George Custer? Once again, fantastic video!!

[@M35kriegsmarine]

I visited the Kidder Massacre site last month (March-2023). It’s a very bleak & desolate place.

[@jimsjacob]

These are great productions. I’ve been out that way, but failed to make a visit. I’d like to revisit some day and pay respects to these brave soldier’s.

[@lawrencefisher5256]

Excellent history and presentation. Thanks.

[@donaldkwasnicki9554]

Awesome video

[@debmclaughlin4355]

I knew the bugler but I did not know the background of their role in the military. I shared this with my high school class and they loved it.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Super cool. People like you are the reason I do this. Make sure to show them part 2

[@collectivesartori]

Beautifully told and quite emotional.

[@Kyleandbet]

I love any video that opens with praise for my towns history museum. Great story and well told.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

That place is legit, for sure. Glad you liked the video!

[@SKAIFEMEISTER]

Another impeccable presentation. Keeping these stories alive is invaluable and much appreciated. I find myself fascinated by the treatment of Metzger's body, and find myself comparing it to that of Tom Custer's. We can never know the exact circumstances of their deaths - but it's easy to conjecture that Tom didn't 'go down easy' either (based on his previous conduct) and his mutilations were an inverse form of respect, if that makes sense? It's an intriguing dichotomy.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

You make an interesting comparison. In Tom Custer’s case, he might have been recognized by some of the warriors (he had arrested some a few years prior) and so his body’s treatment might have had a personal, vengeful element to it. Very cool point, glad you’re watching!

[@JackDiamond21]

I'm a Dakota I had family had the little bighorn, I don't know what happened exactly but I can tell you Custer was shot trying to cross a Fjord. And about an hour later he and all the men with him were dead. The fight with Custer and his men was over quickly. It lasted as long as a man can eat lunch. A group of warriors who took a suicide pact to fight until dead attacked the men on last stand hill and broke the defense. After that it was what my people call a buffalo run. These men had no time to reload their single shot weapons and it was a close quarters hand to hand blood bath. So the state of Thomas Custers body was most likely due to a horrific 30 mins to 45 mins of sheer violence. It would explain why most of the men were "mutilated" when in fact it was a very very horrible and violent end. Some men were mutilated after death yes, but I don't think Thomas Custers body was, I think the state he was found in was how he died. All the scalping and stuff didn't happen on last stand hill where that hand to hand blood bath happened. All that gore was due to the horrific fighting that happened in 30 to 45 mins. Some men did manage to shoot themselves, but like I said it was a very horrible and very violent. Yes some of my people were about that life but I can guarantee the men on last stand hill were not mutilated that's just unfortunately how they met their end. 200 men?? Against 24 suicide warriors, and 2000 warriors in the fight with another 5000 to 8000 in reserves. By the way we knew who was attacking the camp we had been waiting for it for days. But back to last stand hill, you had about 800 warriors on Custer with the rest on Reno hill. Meaning you had at least 800 other warriors charge in after the suicide warriors charge. Reno and Benteen don't know what happened, they were too busy fighting their own battle. And the last of the fighting wasn't on last stand hill, it was in the fields going towards deep ravine. Conveniently left open for the soldiers to retreat to into more waiting warriors. Those 28 men are somewhere in that ravine, they were just left there because that was the last of the alive men. So really the last stand of Custers men is in deep ravine. There are many last stands all over the battlefield too.

[@JackDiamond21]

That could explain why Thomas Custers body was "mutilated" even though he fought bravely. Each those men were all fighting a fight that was 15 to 1 odds. There will be definite overkill with that much people coming for you. I'm not making excuses just sharing oral history from my side.

[@SKAIFEMEISTER]

@@JackDiamond21 Thanks for the reply. Unfortunately the Lakota and Cheyenne oral history was ignored for far too long. There's a similarity with the Anglo-Zulu war, were the British were horrified by the Zulu ritual disembowelment of dead soldiers. Looked at from the Zulu point of view it made perfect sense to cleanse themselves and honour was to be gained from 'washing their spears.' Obviously the British weren't too gentle in their treatment of injured Zulu's either. War is brutal.

[@MrTodfoulk]

great narration, subject and a great man in metzger!

[@charlesshaft639]

Respect! Speechless 😶 thinking of it !

[@jjdjj5392]

Metzkers great great grandson went to school with my youngest son. My sons class went to the fetterman fight site when i found out this young man was a direct relative. It was pretty cool.

[@REM1956]

I've really enjoyed all of your videos I've viewed. Great story telling and detail.

[@randywest9417]

great story, thank you for your hard work. awesome

[@darthmikeempiresupporter.1871]

Great Story and great video.

[@henrykrecklow817]

In the Book Custer battlefield casualties. It's stated that one Weston Harrington of Company L was found under a blanket and not disfigured in any way. Have to wonder what kind of fight he put up?

[@SteveGee67]

Thanks for your hard work on this.

[@katiesioux7757]

Beautifully told

[@stevebuffinton1094]

Awesome story

[@ianmcclellan7695]

Really enjoyed this video and I’ve shared on Twitter too.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Awesome thank you! 🙏

[@markbelmares7138]

Read the story when I was 10-11 yrs. Old. Of several versions I've heard, the story of the bugler is always mentioned and honor that was shown him for his tenacity and courage.

[@getoffenit7827]

Yesss!!!! Another video!!

[@saltleywsc]

Love your videos ,that man was a real hero

[@jeffsmith2022]

Nice video, thank you...

[@SlowcutTV]

Very interesting. thank you 👍

[@nomansland4811]

Great story and well told.

[@jamessampson964]

No matter what side of the debate someone is on as it relates to the wars against the Plains Indians no one can reasonably deny the fact the Corporal Metzger was a brave and honorable man and that deserved the honor and respect that he was given and that the Native Americans that gave him that honor and respect were Honorable also

[@BWIL2515]

Very well done

[@king300h4]

Great History. Great Video.

[@grassroot011]

Reminiscent of the story of Gunga Din. Poem by Rudyard Kipling. Bugler sounded the alarm till he fell under the bullets of the Khyber rifles. Bugled to the last !

[@ontherunplmr1218]

Excellent Video, well done

[@joeshmoe8345]

Real cool stuff! thanks for sharing this with us boss.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thanks Mr. Shmoe! 🙏

[@rustysawyers5109]

Great video and excellent story......

[@pontificusrex1501]

Great story of the bravery of this American soldier and the honor and respect shown by the Native Americans after he was killed. I really appreciate your telling of the stories out west (which is a really cool channel name, by the way).

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you, I appreciate it

[@daviddonaldson1096]

Thank you for taking the time to create another great video. I recently read "Ridgeline" by Michael Punke and found his portrayal (albeit fictional) of Metzger very interesting and tragic. It seems to line up rather well historically with information you've provided. Looking forward to future videos.

[@TheStoryOutWest]

I haven’t heard of that book, but roads converge when you’re getting close to the truth. Glad you liked it!

[@daviddonaldson1096]

I would definitely recommend the novel to anyone interested in the Fetterman fight. The author strikes a very good balance between engaging storytelling and historical accuracy. Being released last year, it also attempts a more revised, less anti-fetterman perspective. Anyways, thanks again for the good content.

[@guykarafa5866]

Awesome job !

[@GaryCSchade]

Excellent !

[@kije6639]

phenomenal stuff as usual

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you, I’m glad you enjoyed it 🙏

[@getoffenit7827]

Usually in your videos there are details about people and events that are not present in other channels renditions,Same for several books ive read,details are usually footnotes Further still,some channels dont actually dig around for additional facts or details..they are actually just reading from an already existing book,I know this because i have the books and read them numerous times and,i recognize which paragraphs and pages and which book they are reading from...i dont like that,its like a waste of my time to listen to somebody read..what ive already read. I dont get that here,...usually i hear something that i didnt know before And that approach can change the entire perception of an event,add to that very good speech,Subtle humor and sincerity make for a excellent channel

[@JohnnyButtons]

3:30 I grew up in Winchester ❤

[@aa64912]

One hell of a soldier. Rip

[@ewmhop]

GREAT VIDEO SIR,MANY GERMANS CAME TO AMERICA FROM 1840 TO 1860S. MY GRANDFATHER DAD WAS ONE OF THEM.MANY FOUGHT AND DIED FOR NEW COUNTRY,BUT GOT A BAD RAP IN THE CIVIL WAR..THEY FACED MANY PREJUDICE FROM THEIR COMMANDING OFFERICERS.GOD BLESS

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thanks 🙏

[@thomassmith7374]

Don't forget the Germans had been coming to the US before the War of Independence fighting for both sides during it.

[@ewmhop]

AGREE,THE T V MOVIE THE CROSSING IS A GOOD EXAMPLE. TAKE CARE@@thomassmith7374

[@Prairiewolf45]

Sounds worthy of the medal of honor

[@TheStoryOutWest]

I suppose he sort of got it, from his opponents

[@mkd7961]

great story!! yes you would have to have a pair!!!

[@c1collector]

Good job.

[@davidkurvach3993]

Really enjoying your channel!

[@TheStoryOutWest]

Thank you, glad you enjoyed it

[@steve-mr8be]

A Eternal Warrior.

[@jameshelring9944]

I have seen the bugle in person at the museum in Buffalo Wy. My son and best friend were on our way to fish the Bighorn in Montana and I knew the story of the Fetterman fight but they didn't so they were puzzled as to why I wanted to stop. As three retired soldiers I can tell you it has an impact when you see it. You ask yourself what would you have done. I don't think the bugle was found as the story told us. Supposedly one of the natives kept it after the battle and later on traded it to a store keeper whose family eventually gave it to the museum.

[@jamesivie5717]

It was my understanding that he used the bugle as a weapon fighting to the end. That would explain why the bugle is so beat up.

[@geneotrexler8246]

Good video 👍🏼

[@bassmangotdbluz3547]

Everyone knows about the Battles of First & Second Manassas but when he said, "Third Battle of Winchester" I had to laugh knowing that Winchester, Clarke County, VA changed hands something like 26 times during that War. Jackson's HQ is still there on Piccadilly Street. I lived near there briefly. It's a quaint little place with some really beautiful old antebellum homes and other incredible architecture.