The Beauty of Nostalgic Liminal Spaces

[@neonthunder3261]

Patmac the kind of guy to disappear for several months then come back into my life like he never left.

[@Sonikku_Za_Hejjihoggu_1991]

Is PatMac okay?

[@neonthunder3261]

@@linaboo24 Siah the clown knows a lot about that

[@neonthunder3261]

@@Sonikku_Za_Hejjihoggu_1991 idk but hes back with the milk

[@Icecalller]

@@linaboo24Cory has a lot of videos pac Mac has a lot but to little to supply a year

[@maccamachine]

Patmac used to get million or more views per video dude could have been making great money but doesn’t post a lot and I don’t think this vid will do as well just seems like a wasted opportunity to me

[@NICKtendoReviews]

God I hope there’s a fun graphic explaining why gangster SpongeBob is there

[@saulgzazueta]

I wish he could do a video on how he’s actually mysterious, pretty much nobody knows where Gangsta SpuchBop actually originated.

[@zeroh2hero]

I was wondering the same thing people are starting to use him in thumbnails like crazy

[@MarioToyCompany]

It comes from a bootleg T-Shirt ​@@saulgzazueta

[@pikmin_79]

I just like how calm and empty but full the liminal spaces feel

[@Sonikku_Za_Hejjihoggu_1991]

I don't think they're always empty.

[@senritsujumpsuit6021]

a reason older cartoons engage me so much is how they let the mood speak they don't overload things as much one my fav Christmas media pieces is just a guy wondering town at night confusing a child by not scolding him like adults should

[@Nzcade]

I never expected him to make a video, especially about this, but here we go, glad to see you back

[@idkany293]

He never left. He just uploads periodically.

[@EP1C_J3DA1]

he also put me in the thumbnail

[@SuperFlashDriver]

Dang, I didn't think he would make another episode after the July one but here we are, AND released on New Year's Eve. What a way to end the year with "123123" this year. It went from something that was somber, depressing, yet nostalgic, to a powerful message at the end mentioning how we should be encouraged to explore the world while we still can. And that is very heartwarming PatMac. Also, don't stop making these wonderful videos, it helps for people whom have loved your content over the past 8+ years since you've started back in 2014.

[@LevBC10]

“What a way to end the year with 123123” Me in England: 💀

[@SuperFlashDriver]

@@LevBC10 Yeeaahhh I know I posted this around the time Japan and London already had their New Year's Celebration so, I can't help it.

[@rampagedudesrb2]

Bruh wtf gangsta spongebob doin

[@SuperFlashDriver]

@@rampagedudesrb2 (Shrugs)

[@Rrainbox]

2014, not 2015

[@wingwall7892]

When the world needed him most, he returned at the very end of the year. Welcome back man

[@DonAsirobi]

I get similar feelings towards old reviews of merchandise. Videos like your own that talk about history of some old plush sets or just reviews definitely evoke similar emotions, reminiscing about the past when these plushies were available. The past that I wasn't even a part of. Great video PatMac, I'm glad that you keep making videos. As for a video suggestion, how about a video where you are showing off your merch collection? The video would probably flop when it comes to views but It'd be cool to finally see your collection in full instead of a few shots. Maybe you will find a way to make a topic out of that?

[@hilariousskullnamedcatzo647]

HE'S BACK!!! Edit: wow, this was unexpectedly a wholesome video, I was expecting a somber vibe like most videos on this topic, but that upbeat vibe and ending was a welcome surprise, keep up the good work pat :)

[@Theleopardgeckoguy]

He's been absent for 4 months now

[@Wabit_]

I don’t even care that there’s only a couple more hours of December, hell of 2023, but you’ve made my month. I rewatch your Mario and sonic bootleg videos quite literally annually. I’ve grown up with your stuff in some way. Thanks for uploading Pat.

[@deadfutureIV]

My room currently looks like 2004 never ended and I'm glad you're able to explain liminalspaces so well and in depth. Love your videos!

[@Snackolotl]

Fun fact: I was watching a compilation of these rooms and actually saw one from a hospital I visited as a child. If you ever see the image of the weird, whimsical-looking treehouse in the middle of a sterile building, that was a hospital in Fort Wayne, Indiana. They built a big play area on the second floor of the lobby, the door in the treehouse was the elevator. It got torn down eventually, so for me, it's genuine nostalgia.

[@BrightCrystalLegend-Astal]

This video was such a fun and unique ride and unlike anything you’ve made before! In a video talking about Nostalgia, seeing 7:08 was a mind boggling experience. This picture is from a old Disney store that used to be 20 minutes away from my house before it’s closure in 2020-2021. We would visit it every time we went to that mall. It’s a weird experience seeing people have nostalgia for a place they’ve never been in, yet you’ve been there and remember it in its prime. I guess that’s the power of liminal spaces.

[@conic2721]

At this point Pat is just this once in a year uploader that, every time he shows up, makes me insanely happy to see they're alive.

[@frostanimate]

As a person who loves visiting abandoned or dying malls, this has really got to me. I’ve never really liked packed malls or stores. When they start to die, it makes me appreciate them more. I usually wonder what they were like in their heyday but never get to experience them which makes me feel bummed that they are what they are now. My example for this is Fiesta Mall, a mall in Mesa, Arizona. I remember passing the road sign on the highway. I never really cared for it. I then started watching a channel called retail archeology who documented the mall a couple of times. I soon became fascinated with the mall. I decided to go to the abandoned mall. I managed to get inside of it (don’t ask why the door was just unlocked) and the site I saw was amazing. Being in a large space with literally no one there felt so nice and relaxing. Fun fact, the former Macy’s there used to be four different stores until closing in 2014. Very fascinating indeed. Unfortunately as of July 2023, the mall was demolished. I was pissed. I never went to the mall as a kid since I lived very close to a way busier one, but it still angered me that it got demolished. Although I know that the property owners can do what they want with the structure, I felt that the mall was like my own friend to me, my own liminal space. Although a mall filled with syringes, asbestos, or pp drawings might not be the safest place to be in, it was special to me and I’ll never forget it.

[@senritsujumpsuit6021]

a Mall near where I live has become a outdoor mall which bums me out a bit going to its indoor food court is cool instead of just eating in the car or at the Red-robin

[@frostanimate]

@@senritsujumpsuit6021 yeah a lot of malls usually get repurposed. Some of them get turned into power centers which are basically outdoor complexes with big box chains such as Walmart or target. Fiesta mall is being into a lifestyle center which is like an outdoor space with retail, office, and apartments. The thing though is that the area around has developed a lot of apartments. There shouldn’t be a reason to build more when there is plenty of them a couple hundred yards away. I think it’s probably because of the amount of people entering the state from California that there are more apartments now.

[@jpeezyYT]

Go to Cincinnati mall

[@ppp_ppp_ppp_ppp_ppp_ppp]

retail archeology is sooo good for my fascination of spaces

[@NoahClevinger]

It’s always a good day when PatMac uploads. Such an amazing channel!

[@heybrams]

He makes similar content to BlameitonJorge.

[@somerandomdude2085]

Everytime I watch your videos, I feel a sense of comfort accommodating it. That's why I love this channel, it has such a unique feeling that I've never seen recreated.

[@wishypaw]

such a unique video from your others, and one i adore just the same! i feel as though ive been stuck in liminality for my whole life. i have a poor memory, and even memories from yesterday can feel years apart. every second, i feel like a brand new person, for better or for worse. in my bad moments, i wonder if i will ever feel joy again. in my happy moments, i am confused as to how i could ever feel so glum! everything is cloaked in confusion and uncertainty, but maybe that parts not so unique to me and my brainweird. the other day, i was looking at half price christmas candy, and i bought a box of really big gummy krabby patty sliders, and it made me think of you. i really love this video

[@smashmaster12]

That ending speech was beautiful, goodness. Thank you so much Patmac, I know you don’t come by often but you make my week every time. Hope life is treating you kindly 💜

[@bastipadgamesandrandomthings]

I’m a 2012+’s kid, but I get nostalgia looking at 2000’s liminal spaces. (Example of anemoia) I’m not even in my adolescence. These photos trigger something within me, I swear I’ve seen some of these before. It could be a mix of dreams and real memories (example of hypnagogia). One thing I do know that is not a dream, is when me and my cousin went to an indoor playground in the mall. As far as I can remember, It was only us and our parents, no one else. That’s why I like mall and indoor playground liminal spaces. I also love airport liminal spaces, the reason for this is that we travelled a LOT before the pandemic, It’s really nice to get back the travel vibe. Alright that’s all. I don’t know why I wrote a whole essay of how liminal spaces effect me. Chances are you don’t care, and that’s fine so, bye.

[@TrialzGTAS]

One that comes to mind for me is the Carousel of Progress at Disney World. It’s my favorite attraction there and it is something that’s never changed from my first visit in 2002 to my last in 2016. Time slows down for me in there. I love it.

[@cecuniversity]

hes back

[@SynthWaveTech007]

I didn't expect to see the CEC community here tbh​@@cecuniversity

[@professorbadvibes695]

This video is really powerful. I've been having a lot of dreams lately about being in retro game stores or arcades. They're always full of games I've never seen or heard of before, whether they're totally original or lost entries in series I really love. These games are always very evocative of a specific retro game console, or at least a specific time frame. I think I have these dreams because of a longing for new and exciting experiences. When I was younger and first had access to the internet, I'd find out about new, interesting games constantly, and they always sparked my imagination. I didn't have fast enough internet to watch or download many videos, so oftentimes all I had to go off of were out-of-context screenshots and text descriptions. Now that we live in a time where information is much more easily shared, in addition to my knowledge of video games being much more complete due to my age, that feeling of discovery is very hard to recapture. I've been thinking a lot about getting into new, non-digital hobbies. It's a scary proposition to me since I'm so familiar with digital media and technology, and because I get a lot of my social interaction digitally at this point in my life. But on the other hand, it might fulfill that longing for the new and exciting. Watching this video, I can tell that you've changed a lot since you made videos regularly. Whatever you're doing now, I hope that you're closer to fulfilling whatever longing may motivate you. Not to mention, the fact that you still put out a video once in a while is proof to me that finding new hobbies or interests isn't necessarily a permanent goodbye to your old ones.

[@SpeedBoltz]

I feel like this channel is a liminal space but in a positive way.

[@eddiejunior8226]

Wasn't expecting such an existential video based on this topic but it left me feeling really optimistic by the end. Great video as always

[@RavenGwynwen]

This video was the exact thing I needed at this moment. No bit, I needed to hear that speech about how things would be better. Thank you

[@aortaplatinum]

7:10 holy shit the funny plushie man just directly quoted a terrifying thought that's haunted me for years The idea that memories can be fake never really fucked with me when it was a plot point in Sonic Adventure 2 and Blade Runner 2049, but I remember when I first considered that exact idea, that a "memory" I have from long ago has just as much likelihood as being a memory of a dream, as a memory of reality. And in that same vein, *how many of your "nightmares" were real memories your brain told you were simply nightmares to protect your sanity? How many horrifying things have you experienced but subconsciously supressed to avoid your mind breaking and your perception of reality crumbling to nothing?* This is terrifying and beautiful. Neon Genesis Evangelion vibes. Thank you.

[@dom0527-y]

Life is a mystery Patmac and everyone. We are never going to know the meaning of it. But cheer up and enjoy it for a new path that comes ahead in the future. Of course those times were sad but you have to move on from them. Make new ones and meet new people. I collect things from all decades and generations. To keep the memories alive! Cheer up Patmac I hope life will treat you well. If you are sad in anyway are prayers are with you.

[@DRP3838]

3:58 that HAS to be one of the smartest Rickrolls I’ve ever seen

[@Sebbiiboi]

Perfect video to end 2023. Patmac is back for another banger. And while this video was a little more mature than the average patmac feel, you managed to put gangsta SpongeBob in the thumbnail and I absolutely adore it

[@priorbj6562]

It’s always a good day when a new PatMac drops

[@zachsalamida2952]

I agree

[@MrHitmanJosh]

And then he disappears for a year

[@fafnirthe1st]

this is a beautiful piece of art that deserves to be appreciated, thank you patmac

[@diegomation3]

It is always a treat watching one PatMac’s videos. Sonic plushies, international anything, I’d watch it regardless on what it’s about.

[@superadrik09]

I should've said something when this video was new, but here goes. This liminal space is the saddest and the one all Americans and especially New Yorkers would agree is the world trade center after 9/11. It must have felt so sad during the transition of the destruction of it to the rebuild of it which happened for 10 years. Obviously this was a really big transition that will always be remembered.

[@superadrik09]

Also, 3:45 makes me feel like it's been decades even though I'm about as old as that place.

[@PinataTime]

This was beautiful. I always cherish your videos Patmac. Thank you for making them.

[@channannan2411]

Imagine you are at school, you see your lunchroom; it is filled with life, people having fun, eating food, ect. Then, come back on the middle of the night, there is not a single person there, the lights are dark and the only person that really is present is you.

[@skinnychumpz007]

living in the short time of a new PatMac upload is a liminal moment in itself

[@skullwolfsteam]

allmost half a year later HE RETURNS! while the windows XP install music plays in the background ..good to see you back patmac! i was wondering when id see you again!.

[@eaglejones856]

Hooray, pat Mac’s back I was wondering where he went

[@Sonikku_Za_Hejjihoggu_1991]

It's so good to hear your voice again.

[@slough.of.despond]

this shit almost made me tear up honestly there was something beautiful about the way you talked about growing up. great vid man.

[@JakeBrunton]

Sometime last year, I had a dream I still vividly recall because it centered around these sensations. I was on the inside of a closed down school I never went into IRL that was in my hometown. A section had been converted into a general store, for snacks and stuff. There was magical powers known in the universe and related. I or someone else did some sort of magic and in an instant, the year was apparently somewhere between 2001 - 2004 again. All of the snacks originally present in the store in the school were now branded with the logos I could remember from that time (eg how mtn dew used to be completely spelled out on the bottles) and newer snacks of today were simply not there. The news on the now present CRT in the corner was very much low resolution and dated. It was so eerie, but for some reason it filled me with an immense joy or bliss, or at least my dream self. Being able to experience the genuine feel of a long gone time period that I had only existed in as a more simple life form was just amazing. Despite the weirdness, I loved that dream.

[@wesdert]

Patmac, i just can't even explain in words how much i miss you. thank you for still uploading even after long periods of time.

[@debbiedunlap9306]

I miss when he uploaded more but those days are gone.

[@pikablu9375]

I haven’t even started the video, but getting a video from PatMac, hours before the new year is quite legendary. This feels like a christmas gift~ I hope you’re doing well PatMac, and that you don’t feel pressured to pump out videos. Have a good a new year’s eve! :D

[@2sussytoogodji]

I usually watch your videos while playing games on my PC, but this was different. I was planning to watch some of your videos on your channel then I saw this video, I clicked on it. Thank goodness I didn't watch this while playing. This video just have a different tone than any of your videos, it wasn't like any of the Liminal Spaces videos I have watch, its beautiful. Thank you PatMac.

[@UnsafestPony81]

It's been awhile. I'm always happy to another post from ya, PatMac. Regardless of the topic!

[@cyansaphire]

THE PAT IS BACK!!! And just in time, what a perfect way to start off the year! Love how you highlighted the importance of not growing too attached to our nostalgia and the importance of seeking out new experiences. I think as a concept, the backrooms and liminal spaces encapsulate that idea perfectly (especially in a horror setting). A lot of us are afraid of what the future may bring, so we cling to our Y2K (or the 90s or 80s depending on how old you are) aesthetics for comfort. We'd rather live in the empty, abandoned mall arcade from our childhood when life was simpler than accept the change that inevitably comes with the passing of time. But you're absolutely right, those periods of time are long past gone, and instead of trying to bring these times back we should stick to just admiring them in photographs and in our memories while looking to all the new possibilities the future holds! All of this to say, I loved the video, and can't wait to see what other videos you'll make in the future!

[@digimonsesealy4010]

I was up late at 6 whatever and chose this video Mid watch I’m thinking “dang this voice sounds familiar..I quickly check the. Channel name and I was then shocked to know it was the return of the king

[@GP12810]

It's so fascinating how just as I got back into liminal spaces, PatMac made a video about it around the same time after being gone for a while, in such a respectful and interresting way too This might just be my favorite video of his, keep up the great work

[@captainblu3028]

Good comment gp

[@Matatoplayz]

Bro disappears and magically returns like nothing happens

[@liamisawsome]

Why is he sounding depressed again like in his older videos?

[@fleshdior9414]

The last 5 minutes of this video made me cry, I can’t believe things chance so fast

[@Alanis1337]

When we needed him most, he returned

[@Sparktron87]

Possibly the best way to end off 2023! I remember going to MovieStop around 2011-2012. My sister and I bought a Pocahontas 2 DVD. Great stuff as always PatMac!

[@tiktokcompilations797]

Patmac uploading right before the end of the year truly is a Christmas miracle

[@_alexafterdark_]

There’s something sombering or rather mature on the presentation of the video, great stuff once again!

[@ItsmeGarrett]

This is one of the best videos PatMac has ever made.

[@Nic_2751]

YESSS HE CAME BACK FOR ONE LAST VIDEO THIS YEAR LET’S GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@luisumana1238]

Goddamn, I never thought a PatMac video of all things would make me cry, but here we are.

[@MattFoxyShow]

was having the worst day today til patmac dropped this 🙏🙏🙏

[@SPNarwhal]

I've never been in such a relatable point in my life. It's almost a little bizarre how relevant this video is to me right now. I do wonder how many people are going through anything remotely similar, as I've heard from many that the past 2 years has been very rough on them. Maybe it's a mix of world events as well as just being in this point in time as a generation who grew up and often observed/experienced similar things. Even things like Nintendo, where we got to watch them grow from a small video game company and now begin their expansion into a large media company. We got to see technology expand and refine with all of the growing pains, and even remembering the world prior to the internet and knowing there's no way to go back. Love the content. Was thinking of you today and checked on the channel and was extremely surprised to see an upload from today. Glad you still pop up from time to time.

[@neospaciantwili]

I’m so happy to see you back! Your videos really inspired me to start collecting things and I’m very happy to see another vid

[@winnerthecoolguy2009]

When the year was about to end the legend returned to give us 1 final banger

[@umbreongaming7137]

My Favorite Memory is McDonald's

[@bingus7900]

Day 297: Hi! I’m bingus and I’m gonna use this comment section as a diary (don’t worry. There won’t be anything too personal). I also have autism so my hyper fixations may creep through the cracks Eyyyy the boy uploaded again! Also, happy new years! Live and learn!

[@tobexomega]

I got my christmas present 6 days late. I haven't seen the video yet but I'm sure it's going to be a banger. Edit after watching the video: Since I learned what Liminal Spaces are I've been completely mesmorized by them. Everytime I see one of these images I feel a mellow nostalgia, which is weird since I was born in a different time and location. Ever since I was born I've always preferred 90's and 2000's stuff, for some reason, but I think that's the case because of their general aesthetic and charm. My love for this media has resulted in me having a huge apreciation for artforms like Vaporwave and Liminal Spaces that are based on nostalgia and that make feel very relaxed.

[@Frosty_CH]

THE KING HAS RETURNED

[@doggo4078]

God I love your content, such a good topic for a video, happy to see you back.

[@artawesome30]

During my psychotic episode, I experienced incredibly vivid dreams. I had hundreds over the course of the year that I was insane. The most common recurring theme was exploring infinite liminal spaces, usually by myself. Mansions that went on forever, unique facilities, beaches, towns, and other interesting places. I never felt afraid, or creeped out. In fact, I was enchanted. They gave me a profound nostalgic feeling. It never felt like demons were lurking in these places, if anything it was like I was playing hide-and-seek with an angel, or some long-lost infatuation. It was the most special, safe feeling. One of my favorite places was a shower room. It was incredibly dim, almost black. A faint, distant light allowed me to see. The walls, floors, and ceiling were totally smooth, as though they were made from hardened clay. If I pulled a rope, warm water would pour down from the ceiling, and wash over me. I felt so peaceful and at-home. I wish I could go back to having these dreams, my current dreams don’t compare.

[@caydencrawford18]

He’s back!

[@aaronMinceRaft]

Dude the science for this is so interesting and I appreciate the study!

[@TonyChan-eh3nz]

How did we go from plushies to questioning our existence? Is this april fools already?

[@jupieterr]

Rewatched this vid tonight after not watching it since you uploaded it.. my god is the message at the end beautiful. Hope you're doing well PatMac, always take your time with videos, we all get it.

[@manny878]

I miss you patmac

[@legend_oflouis9813]

I really needed this video! It’s been something on my mind for a while. I always try and enjoy the now, the small mediocrities and charms of life while still being nostalgic. There is something beautiful yet comforting about knowing that you will be nostalgic for the life and time you currently lead.

[@Microsave2]

It confuses me how patmac can upload a couple of videos and then randomly dissapear and come back again

[@elmomonster6043]

This is almost like a asmr video! So calm

[@gircakes2]

2:10 ZUZU PET LIMINAL SPACE LET'S GOOOO

[@freakphone-lo1ul]

seeing that video store at 6:16 brought back so many memories because i had a rental store like that near the place where i go to school it was called family video and it was where i rented some movies and games sometimes me and my mom just stopped by to look at the movies and games they had and get a gumball at the gumball machine there was always a special color gumball everyday that if you got it, you were able to rent something completely for free the place (and the entire rental chain entirely) is closed down now, probably because of covid their website is entirely non-functional, anything to do with buying or renting anything leads to dud errors the building and sign are still there though, the text on the sign just reads out a phone number to lease the building out i won't be surprised if the building is demolished in-order for something new to take its place it kinda hurts knowing a place from my childhood is gone or will be gone soon but the idea of the remnants of the place being on the internet giving people these feelings of nostalgia for the place gives me some happiness

[@Zak-bv4qm]

Cant wait for the next video man

[@therealdatenshi]

that message you gave towards the end was honestly quite beautiful man thank you

[@TheJPooka777]

It's so odd hearing patmac covering a non media topic

[@DuhSpeedyGreenFox]

He’s back but this is a change of pace

[@The-Chuck-E-Network]

Has anybody noticed that his voice is more deeper now? And his thumbnails are different now.

[@_-Lx-_]

He sounds low energy and depressed, it feels clear to me he's dealing with some issues currently. I wish him well.

[@Dogo0ncrack]

A more serious tone in the PatMac videos is very cool like how it’s going so far

[@thatplushieguy]

Come back bro 😭😭

[@stinkystonerharvey2774]

Actually finished the video. Damn patmac, this was pretty thought-provoking. I used to binge your videos a lot n always enjoyed em but this one hit a little differently but in a really good way. I hope you're doing good and i wish you the best for your future memories and endeavors.

[@JordanHotub]

We miss you king 👑 ❤️

[@llllama4686]

The king is back

[@bingus7900]

Day 373: Hi! I’m bingus and I’m gonna use this comment section as a diary (don’t worry. There won’t be anything too personal). I also have autism so my hyper fixations may creep through the cracks Been on the call with the Oklahomie as usual. Me, mom and Dalton went to Stillwater. I got a dragon ball Z dvd, a transformers beast wars dvd, and a predicon buzzsaw figure who is definitely not a waspinator repaint. Yesterday was actually the 1 year anniversary of my blaze crush

[@Marcus3205]

It's a shame this video didn't gain as much traction as your other mainline videos did. I dig this type of content as much as I dig the content you normally do!

[@crazyjedi5994]

4:45 greatest freakout ever!

[@_-Lx-_]

You're still sounding very low energy, Best wishes PatMac, I hope you can deal with whatever issues you are going through now. Life is tricky certianly, and this was a very nicely sentimented video, you are clearly in a rough phase of life, and I'm sure all your viewers wish you well.

[@FanaticMitchell1]

He's back for New Year's Eve, Hey, Patmac, could you do more look backs on more Sonic merchandises such as plushies and action figures and so on? Edit: like since 2020, I've been wanting you to do a look back on the toy Island Sonic Adventure and Sonic X action figures from 2000 to 2007

[@jeepmega629]

A day where Patmac uploads is a great day

[@jondot.fullstop]

why is gangsta spongebob in the thumbnail

[@Ilovcomputers]

Cuz he's real af💯💯

[@EA_sports147]

Why not?

[@stuff31]

Happy new year, PatMac. Thanks for this lovely present! Hope you're doing well :)

[@dripatin]

GOOD VIDEO IM SUBSCRIBED

[@Poyostar]

Ah, nothing like a new PatMac video to close out the year, and one focused on liminal spaces and how enchanting they are no less. Another phenomenal video, indeed; I especially adore the last couple moments of the video!

[@MediachatYT]

Please do a video on the many releases of Rayman 1!

[@EllieTheVA]

When the world needed him the most, he returned.. WELCOME BACK KING! 🗣️🗣️🗣️