The BEST Doctor Who Episode YET! - "Rogue" Review

[@NankitaBR]

I absolutely loved this episode! This season is going from banger to banger, really! Are there things I don't like in the episodes? Yes, obviously, but that's true of every single TV show, including all previous seasons of Doctor Who.

[@VidDuality]

Sorry your comments are attracting the unified rage machine that spams all Doctor Who content these days. They sure are obsessed with a show they claim they can't stand to watch. Loved this episode! I would LOVE to see Rogue become a recurring character like Captain Jack Harkness or River song. Doing their own thing, but intertwined with the Doctor's adventures as well. ❤️

[@MatD1979]

Does anyone know if they will release a blu ray season for region 1? I live in Canada and don't do Disney plus. I still like physical media.

[@AnotherScifiGuy]

I tend to import from the UK myself.

[@dapablo2]

You're better off keeping well away from this tripe iah

[@MatD1979]

@@dapablo2 Space babies was odd but the rest are okay. This is part 1 of 3 seasons. I bet season 2 and then 3 will be a blast.

[@PatrickF.Fitzsimmons]

He isn't playing the Doctor he's playing Ncuti.

[@lanceuppercut3498]

My thoughts too, he his just playing himself (no pun intended!!) and seems he is mostly wearing his own fashion too. He has no identity no trademark costume and is not coming across as the Doctor. And below comment says custom made for The Doctor? Nah there is no Doctor in any of them. I had such great hopes for Ncuti and RTD, now I want them gone and the sooner the better.

[@MovieMagic515]

​@@lanceuppercut3498all the actors have played themselves, just a more pronounced version.

[@DeusLucifer]

exactly this entire season i have yet to see the doctor only this dunce that call himself the doctor

[@paparazzo99]

@@lanceuppercut3498 every piece of clothing he’s worn was custom made for the Doctor.

[@anvalisok]

I had just finally watched the Scream of the Shalka last Monday. Perfect timing.

[@malta_ball701]

This is not the best

[@PaulChiesa-db5zn]

Agree.

[@CedricLlwyd]

Literally…

[@Problembeing]

This is absolutely the worst, and I say that as a gay man. Dreadful.

[@NankitaBR]

​@@Problembeing Sure, you're a gay man... We all believe that

[@Jasminestealth1]

first i loved they picked jodi for the last doctor... but her entire run.. never showed an episode in which being a female, and how that interacted with reality... for the love of all that is holy... the doctor was in the dial for 4.5 billion years... repeating everyday... and afterwards was called out by the council as the oldest timelord...i can accept over all of those years... the outershell.. the body of the doctor can change.. even sex or color... but.. to go from getting married... to his love of the Tardis.. itself... to being a black male.... and even with the face of BO.. to just suddenly being gay??? And not doing any real.. story line? Do not get me wrong... I was so invested.. in there banter.. and connection.. and i loved they kissed.. but i am a lesbian.. BUT!!! If we are not addressing the struggles.. of facing these kinds of attractions.. if we are only portraying some magical bullshit... who are we serving? Def not those that follow DOC WHO!! AND>>> if we do not bring all of those "anti-gay" people along with understanding the real drama of being gay.. and making it real.. then we kill the DOC... and who wins?? If it kills the series.. the current and last DOC can say "i was the first female doc.. and he can say i was the first gay black doc" But for those of us watching.. who want to believe in heroes..we lose.. because they will shut it down!! Show the struggle of being black.. not like the "bubble"... show the real impact of a guy that gets on the knee at a posh event... show what that impact is on the doctor!!

[@rukevweb5674]

i feel like that would be doing way too much for a show that is basically a travelling time lord and his everyday BS. just because the doctor is now black and queer does not mean all of a sudden that the show should become a melodramatic mess. The Doctor is more than what he looks like or who he’s attracted too

[@Jasminestealth1]

@@rukevweb5674 and yet here we God - he is Married - and now kissing men... ? and Amy and Rory were THE BEST!! melody pond? River song!!! oh drama humanity

[@Aurora_Lightbringer]

​​@@Jasminestealth1 So the simple question is why should a genderless alien from another planet only be attracted to women?

[@Jasminestealth1]

@@Aurora_Lightbringer who said the doctor is "genderless"

[@Aurora_Lightbringer]

@@Jasminestealth1 It's a being that can turn into a man or a woman at will.

[@여보-f6m]

I'm South Korean 안녕하세요, 한국인입니다. 한국에서 'Doctor Who'를 즐기는 사람이 많지 않지만, 소수의 한국인들은 좋아합니다. 저는 이 영상의 내용을 이해하지 못했지만, 'Rogue'에 대한 한국인 시청자들의 반응을 말해 주고 싶습니다. 나는 영국에서의 Gay에 대한 시선이 어떠한지 모르지만, 한국에서의 Gay에 대한 시선은 매우 좋지 않습니다. 그래서 이 에피소드를 혐오하는 시청자들이 많았습니다. 그리고 저는 'Rogue'를 좋다고 생각합니다. 하지만 Best는 아니라고 생각합니다. 1. 73 Yards 2. Dot and Bubble 3. Boom 4. Rogue 5. The Devil's Chord 6. Space Babies 저는 이렇게 생각합니다. *** 저는 2007년 겨울에 South Korea에서 태어났습니다. 'Voyage of the Damned'가 방영되기 8일 전에 태어났어요! 저는 9살 때부터 'Doctor Who'를 즐겼고, 어느덧 16살이 되었습니다. 저는 'Classic Season'을 볼 수 없어서 아쉽습니다. 한국에도 'Whovian'이 있다는 사실 잊지 말아 주세요! 그리고 'Doctor Who'를 보는 한국인들은 Chris Chinall을 싫어합니다. 그리고 저는 David Tennant를 사랑합니다.

[@simongardener7662]

Best??? It’s not even the best episode in the last two weeks!

[@MeidasWhovianAdvocate]

We need more Rogue.

[@echsIncognito]

More so, we need more Rogue! ☺️

[@gameburn178]

Similar to the Capt. Jack style of character, but much more restrained. Perhaps the actor is just not into overacting.

[@milkhunter6317]

This is hardly the best, but that's just my opinion

[@rpzaprasza162]

now i know i am homophobic

[@NankitaBR]

Glad you recognize it, now the next step is go get some help to fix your problem 😉

[@rpzaprasza162]

@@NankitaBR it is not my problme :)

[@redfieldblair]

Really? No plot, the Doctor turned into Captain Jack - an enemy that would be embarassed by Peri's 80's bird transmogrification? Not the worst of the season, but bottom 3 for me.

[@NankitaBR]

No plot? Have you watched the episode?

[@redfieldblair]

@@NankitaBR Alien bird cosplayers decide they want to cosplay in other peoples skin (poor cosplayers, used to get homages like Osgood). Doctor stops them. Did I miss any important story beats? In 60 years of phone box travel I think only the Edge of Destruction had a less intricate storyline, and at least it did it with style.

[@kaptainuke]

@@redfieldblairexactly. Zero plot. Nothing happens. Doctor flirts with his new BF while Ruby is in danger and she sorts herself out. His contribution? Almost gets her sent to prison. Utterly awful story.

[@redfieldblair]

@@kaptainuke In fact we could argue if he hadn't distracted Rogue then Rogue could have sorted it; I mean it was Rogue's tech he used. The Doc really didn't do anything, just took the credit.

[@RobertMcMurrer]

I hope we see him again.

[@dapablo2]

Keep your homosexual fantasies to yourself, we don't care and we don't want to see it. It's obscene to parade thrusting groins and leeching in front of children.

[@NankitaBR]

I need Rogue back! If he doesn't come back I'm going to riot!!!

[@mattthesilent777RED]

No, you don't

[@wingpang9626]

This is not doctor who.

[@PaulChiesa-db5zn]

Agreed.

[@NankitaBR]

Cry harder

[@yonaunega]

​@@NankitaBRretard

[@SpikeyMikey341]

Getting bored of all this campy fluff.

[@dapablo2]

I thought I 'd gotten away from it after they shut down "Are you being served"

[@SpikeyMikey341]

@@dapablo2 Mrs Slocombe as the new Doctor, great idea, she had the hair for it, perhaps add a septum piercing to complete the look?

[@NankitaBR]

Have you ever watched Doctor Who before? Camp is the name of the game in Doctor Who.

[@SpikeyMikey341]

@@NankitaBR So if it's barely changed why is the fanbase pushing back so much against it and the viewership in freefall. You can't move on KZbin for RIP Dr Who Vid's.

[@cowanb65]

Get Captain Peacock in to rescue this episode

[@Mark-nh2hs]

The villains look utter shite and comical - the Cheetah people from Survival look way more realistic than these lot 😂

[@NankitaBR]

That's Doctor Who for you 😉

[@kaptainuke]

Really awful. Zero plot and pointless love story. Worst episode ever. It was a massive cringe fest pushing an agenda no one wants. I’ve enjoyed all of the stories this series but that was dire. Aliens were a joke. This is what happens when RTD takes a day off from writing. Should be better next week.

[@milkhunter6317]

I don't know what you're on about, but this is not RTD's best work. It feels like Doctor Who in name only, this is more like a fetish now, always in your face "Look at me, I'm a gay guy". The Doctor kissed men before, Rory and Captain Jack Harkness. Yet no one made a big deal out of it back then

[@alberttatlock1541]

Even if you like this kind of thig, it is NOT Dr Who. This is Queer as Folk with a tardis. Why doesnt RTD just write a new series of QAF, and leave Dr Who to those who like REAL Dr Who.

[@joso7228]

Even if the unnecessary insipid Gay Stuff was removed this would be a terrible bland Episode. The Doctor cries... twice... pathetic.

[@NankitaBR]

And here you are, crying

[@AllyAlwaysBAwesome]

It’s okay to feel feelings and even cry

[@robslide3466]

God no this possibly the worst episode of Doctor Who. Time and the Rani, Love and Monsters and the one about the scribble monster are looking good right now. RTD the man who destroyed Doctor Who, thank the universe we still have Big Finish.

[@NankitaBR]

Can you point out exactly what is so nad about the episode?

[@robslide3466]

@@NankitaBR Well, we have gone back near twenty years to the RTD lets make an alien by sticking an animal head on a human body. Ncuti Gatwa suffers from ‘Tom Baker Syndrome’ he can only act as a slight variation of himself. There is no spark in the Doctor/Rouge interactions and personally don’t like the Doctor having romantic/sexual relations with humans a creature at least 10 Million years ahead of us on the evolutionay scale wouldn’t have any interest in a less evolved lifeform. The plot was a thin remake of Human Nature combined with The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances with Faux Captain Jack.

[@DaveLynchWriter]

Stunning, and soooo brave!

[@gameburn178]

I can remember when two men kissing was forbidden in film and not often seen in real life either. And yet straight couples are comfortable with this, even celebrated for it. Still remember how favorably the Obamas dance and kiss was celebrated. If Buttigieg had been the nominee instead of Biden... I suppose we could have seen two men celebrated for kissing in the Whitehouse, going on date night... and a kid or two in the Whitehouse, but younger this time. May yet see this.

[@andrewbarbarash3116]

Awful

[@grantmason740]

This was utter dogs!te and the overnight ratings agree. This was dreadful.

[@lanceuppercut3498]

Exactly, down from last week, that say all you need to know. A episode with a weak story, historically inaccurate as they just wanted the Bridgerton fans and in the end was all about the kiss and nothing else mattered.

[@gameburn178]

I liked it too. Dot and Bubble was not good at all -- certainly neither plausible nor subtle, but this one gave us something to think about. The Doctor is lonely, needs a love life -- not sure I fully understood this up to this point. "I lost everyone," kind of says it all. Apparently, saving the worlds and hanging around with friends might not be enough. Big changes. Long overdue. Yes, it changes the story and creates a different focus, but let's be honest: the show needs change. As a straight man, I think it was kind of interesting to see a gay relationship or at least the potential start of one. Not too different from straight stuff but because both are men they kind of know each other a little bit already, sort of. Not sure how to explain it. LIke everyone else, I have known a few gay people -- the boss on my last job was gay I found out (after 3 years working together!) -- but seeing a bit of how this might work in practice is another thing. Not too scary, kind of sweet actually. Although I assume in real life that gay people, like straight people, probably don't propose marriage in the first hour, not even as a ruse. The bird people threatening the world with cosplaying them to death was kind of lame but then again a lot of the Who stories are often silly. Another stand-alone adventure too, which is smart, long story arcs are asking too much of viewers time. But the hint that love might return for the new Doctor and it might be in the form of the guy named "Rogue" -- what is his real name, we wonder, will he ever be trusted enough to learn our Doctor's real name? This allows a different kind of anticipation and longer story arc. Good idea. The Doctor should be happy, at least not as lonely. We owe him that much, lol.

[@Anna-zi7sx]

Loved the Episode!

[@seoulgt86]

Wasn’t the greatest episode. It was alright tho but definitely not the greatest episode. That’s a reach.

[@hevsreids6989]

It was a great episode, the wedding actually plays into it because there's always a wedding in Bridgerton 😂

[@marknowak]

The show used to be about how a hero masterfully (sometimes comically, sometimes thoughtfully, sometimes with deep feeling) saves the day. Now it's about the hero's identity as he goes from setting to setting. We can see he's black and we know he's gay. But it seems like that's pretty much all he is ... in a new place ... every week. Rogue even had to provide the means to defeat the bad guys.

[@NankitaBR]

Are qe eveb watching the same show? Have you ever watched Doctor Who before?

[@marknowak]

@@NankitaBR Since Tom Baker. Maybe 1980. I even met Peter Davison and got his autograph. I used to read the books. When did you start?

[@yonaunega]

​@@marknowakdon't worry about these non fans. They have no idea about doctor who. They only know about nurse what. I am rewriting every single episode from 2018

[@icreateworlds]

Who is dead and gone.

[@rhysdehaan]

It was a fun episode but was VERY far from being the best.

[@geraintrees7878]

RIp Doctor Gay

[@davidmckay7847]

This is not Dr Who