THE BEST LORD OF THE RINGS EDITIONS | Book Collection

We take a look at several single-volume and three-volume editions of The Lord of the Rings to decide which of them offers the best collectability and readability.
Books reviewed:
The Lord of the Rings 50th Anniversary Deluxe Edition (2004) - Unboxing: • TOLKIEN DELUXE EDITION...
The Lord of the Rings Special Deluxe Illustrated Edition (2021) - Unboxing: • WORTH THE HYPE? The Lo...
The Lord of the Rings Illustrated Edition (2021) - Unboxing: • The ULTIMATE THE LORD ...
The Lord of the Rings Deluxe Edition | Pocket (2004)
The Fellowship of the Ring 50th Anniversary (2004)
The Two Towers 50th Anniversary (2004)
The Return of the King 50th Anniversary (2004)
The Hobbit & The Lord of the Rings Boxed Set: Illustrated edition (2020) - Unboxing: • UNBOXING TOLKIEN'S The...
________________________________________________
Hey! I just published a little poetry book ... interested?
Get your copy of 'Anarchy for the Innocents' on Paperback via Amazon: www.amazon.com/Anarchy-Innoce... or Amazon UK: www.amazon.co.uk/Anarchy-Inno... today
I also wrote my own Anglo-Saxon epic poem ... interested?
Order your hardback copy of 'Haestingas' here: mxpublishing.com/products/hae...
Get your copy of 'Haestingas' on Paperback or eBook via Amazon today: www.amazon.com/H%C3%A6stingas...
________________________________________________
Visit my author website: www.jamesmoffettwrites.com
Follow me on INSTAGRAM: / jimbrewingbooks and on WORDPRESS: atolkienistperspective.wordpr...
________________________________________________
MUSIC for video'Nowhere Known' by Your Friend, Ghost / yourfriendghost845 Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/l-nowhere-known promoted by Audio Library • Nowhere Known - Your F...
'Stark Goes Dark' by The Whole OtherThe Whole Other playlist: • Playlist

[@sunspot8]

Thank you soooo much for this vid!! I was getting myself in such a pickle trying to work out which one to buy, as I have to buy online. This was extremely helpful!

[@LilyMilos]

Really great idea for a video! And glad to find one of my copies on your list!

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks! 🙂

[@Mors_Umber]

Just ordered the 2021 Standard edition. It seems to have everything I want from a premium single volume Lord of the Rings book, can't wait for it to arrive!

[@brewingbooks]

Excellent choice 🙂

[@jintsfan]

Now this is a man who looovveessss books. I have personally found in my book collecting journey - that American editions, although not often as visually appealing than British Editions ordinarily, are usually far more readable because of the binding process.

[@theasianpersuasionk-g-s4912]

Thanks for showing your collection, its impressive love the artwork

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for watching!

[@catierodriguez13]

Thank you for this review. It helps a lot.

[@brewingbooks]

Glad it was helpful!

[@jasonvizcarra709]

I went with the standard illustrated edition because it looks very similar in design to the 1st edition red pages and all. I absolutely love it so far. My only issue is the dust jacket gets dirty and damaged easily. I’m tempted on getting the pocket edition since it’s more durable

[@brewingbooks]

The cover of the pocket edition might certainly be more durable than the standard’s dust jacket but the latter os still a fantastic piece 😁

[@fgdj2000]

Exactly the reason why I got it (well, that AND the significantly smaller price). Though I have to admit I find it a bit heavy to use. So, I'll probably stick to the 3-volume version if I'm simply reading it.

[@jasonvizcarra709]

@@fgdj2000 i ended up exchanging mine for a copy in perfect condition. I have yet to open it because it’s just too nice

[@kronosb6982]

I bought pocket edition recently. I'd highly recommend them; though small print, really beautiful, & 'user friendly'. But, in my opinion, you can't have you many copies of LoTR. Just wonderful

[@sirnilsolav6646]

Thank you very much for this! I got my father the 2004 copy as a gift for his 50th birthday, but I myself was dissappointed because it didn't have any illustrations. My father didn't care, but I wished to give him the best Delux Edition. However, seeing this review made me happy that I still got him a good copy as you rank the 2004 one as your favourite. I'd like to get the 2021 edition eventually, both for myself and him, but you made me happy that the edition I got him was a great edition as you ranked it your favourite.

[@brewingbooks]

That’s great to hear!

[@LUIS-vw1zl]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="61">1:01</a> this is my favorite edition, I like hes cover colour (dark red), beautiful.

[@brewingbooks]

It’s beautiful 🙂

[@jandunn169]

Thank you so much.....so helpful as most book sellers do not show the illustrations.....

[@brewingbooks]

Glad it was helpful!

[@tonberryhugs6435]

This is perfect. I want to get a proper edition for my small collection and the illustrated hardback set is the one! And I can still find it online!

[@GandalfGreyhame]

Great video! I personally got the 2020 illustrated box set a year ago and they're the most beautiful books I own :)

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks! Oh sure the 2020 is absolutely stunning and a top piece 😃

[@thecollector77]

I want to get one of these Box sets

[@abiriabdullah4832]

How can I get it if I'm overseas and is it a good one to start with ..I never read the Lord of the rings ..please help

[@abiriabdullah4832]

@@GandalfGreyhame I live in the middle east . Does the 2020 illustrated box set contain the complete story of Lord of the rings ? Because I never read so I'm looking for the complete story of Lord of the rings all at once what should I do which one I should buy?

[@frankc9086]

@@abiriabdullah4832 yes the 2020 illustrated box set is the complete lord of the rings story along with the hobbit story a fantastic set and in my opinion the best value for money as the art work is outstanding. I would really recommend buying

[@edouardlemarchand5029]

My friend showed me the standard hardback and I found the fore-edge writings so cool when you open the book :)

[@brewingbooks]

They are, I agree. I must be honest though that at first glance I wasn’t too convinced by the inclusion of the inscription on the side of the pages.

[@MrBig913]

Do a book case showcase! So many amazing looking books you have there!

[@brewingbooks]

Sure thing!

[@M-J]

Your video just landed in my feed! Happy to have found your channel. ☺️ - 📚MJ

[@brewingbooks]

Oh wow many thanks! Hope you find some of the content interesting :)

[@Keeperofcringestones]

Awesome review! Just graduated college and have time to read now!

[@brewingbooks]

Fantastic! And congratulations 😃

[@ofgodzeus]

I want to get the physical books to finally reread them because when I read them as a kid, I didn't have them in my hands and I'm really lost *cries* I really want to get just ONE book that contains everything, for the reasons you mentioned + they're so gorgeous but at the same time they're not very practical because I like carrying my books around with me.. so I don't know :( I'd probably end up either getting the first three separate ones you showed or maybe the big grey one, it looked pretty flexible and floppy and I like that! Thank you for the video, really enjoyed it and it was super helpful! I can't wait to watch the other Tolkien related ones until I decide what to get xD also, they're super fun... I was so happy when I found that they date as far back as 2014 hahahaha I just discovered your channel and I absolutely love it! Best of luck!

[@brewingbooks]

Hey many thanks for your kind words :) Glad the video help a bit. I'd suggest for reading to go for the three-volume set though. They're the most practical to handle.

[@michaeljdauben]

I've got the Red Book all-in-one edition, and the three book set illustrated by Alan Lee, and also the old paperback set with cover illustrations by Barbara Remington (which was the edition I first discovered the books with). I've also got copies of the book as ebooks and Audible books. 😁

[@brewingbooks]

Lovey collection you got 🙂

[@juliuscaesar9756]

I ordered the 2004 flexible grey one and am very excited to get it especially after this review!

[@brewingbooks]

Fantastic! You won’t be disappointed 😃 and enjoy!

[@vicckyyy2001]

@juliuscaesar9756 I know this comment is 5 months old but I own this edition and am currently reading it and I couldn't ask for anything better, I absolutely adore it

[@SuperINFINITY181]

If I may, I’m a big fan of the Alan Lee illustrated three-volume edition from back in the mid-1990s that are still available for sale today: the paper is thick and glossy, the typeface both gorgeous and easy to read, it’s bigger than other editions. I just got them myself and I love them! Also, any thoughts on the Millennium Edition which splits all seven books (including the appendices) into separate volumes?

[@brewingbooks]

Yes Alan Lee is a one-of-a-kind artist. As to the 7-volume set, whilst I love the practicality of it, I’m not so sure LOTR deserves to be split up into so many “books”

[@Patrick-sh9tt]

The 1992 Alan Lee versions are superior to everything seen here, and probably any versión ever released imo. I finally bought the Two Towers from that years today, it cost me an awful lot of money, but cannot wait to complete the trilogy and have them alongside the single version book. The Hobbit version from around that time is absolutely beautiful too with Smaug on the golden cover…never bettered.

[@kronosb6982]

Absolutely agree. The Lee hardback set wonderful

[@entropytango5348]

A good review. I have a single lovely volume, but you are right in that it is heavy and hard to read. So i will go back and find a suitable 3 volume HB set. Which you covered nicely at the end. Thank You

[@brewingbooks]

Cheers thank you 👍

[@phoenix3754]

There are two things I would like to say about the grey hardback or leather bound edition (Whichever you prefer to call it). 1. The paper quality in my opinion is by the far the best (not considering the Alan Lee illustrated edition which I do not own). 2. This is bound with dried leather if I understand it correctly. It tends to easily adsorb oil from your skin so it will develop dark patches over time as you repeatedly handle it while reading as it just adsorbs any kind of oil like a sponge. Just something I wanted to put out there to help you in your buying decision. If you are not bothered by the oil adsorption of the cover, this one will be the best one to use for reading as it is very comfortable to handle, has good sized font and very good paper quality as I mentioned earlier. Also, the color of the pages is very pleasing, as it is neither too white, nor too yellow, just very pleasant.

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for sharing! 🙂

[@Poodle_Ellie]

Hello, if it's not much of trouble could you specify the ISBN for this one for me please?

[@ColasTeam]

I wish they made the artwork by Tolkien available in every edition of the book, I love my small special pocket edition which includes the hobbit, and they're the format I prefer for reading, I am unlikely to read huge heavy hardbacks, but I'd still like to have the artwork!

[@augustuslxiii]

Yeah, really. I've never seen one without maps in it, so there's no good reason they all can't have versions of the artwork, too.

[@ColasTeam]

@@augustuslxiii Especially when the artwork for the hobbit is included in the normal editions as is and looks great!

[@TheEternalElir]

You have a magnificent collection. I'm so jealous (In a good, appreciative way).

[@brewingbooks]

Thank you friend. 😃

[@MissCaraMint]

I own three different versions of LotR. One of them only is in a single volume. It’s just a bit much to have that huge thing when you actually read them, pluss it’s in Norwegian because at the time I bough it finding books in english was actually pretty hard. Man that ages me to say, but it’s true. Had so ask my parent who was visiting the States to get me them in English. Endes up with cheep paperbacks with movie covers on them. Print is a bit small too. Anyway I just bought this Nice three volume hardcover set with Tolkiens original artwork peinted on them from HarperCollins (possibly the 60th anniversary editions). They just feel great to hold, and just are so comfotable ro read. Sure they don’t have a lot of extra art, but I found those with art by Alan Lee to have Pages that are a little to thick for them to turn in the most satifsting way for me. Might still get them later if I want something for display, but right now comfort was priority, and the ones I got still look damn good.

[@brewingbooks]

Lovely to hear! Enjoy your editions-additions 😃

[@MikeyGiambra]

After a whole day worth of looking through editions of Lord of the Rings, I must say the George Allen & Unwin First Editions (and facsimile designs from 1954-63) have an excellent reader's aesthetic, timeless design, the BEST by far, but of course are $3k. The Houghton Mifflins 1960's publication comes close to the original quality look, but not quiet. I settled on the Bookspan 2001 editions which have the classic Tolkien Illustration covers like the Hardcover set you showed, Harper Collins 2005, but are softcover and based on original typeset.

[@brewingbooks]

Some great insights. And I agree, the Allen & Unwin first editions are timeless.

[@DisHammerhand]

The grey flex cover has the best quality paper, similar to Everyman's Library. It's also the most portable. The cream tint in the 2021s is actually printed on the page. The entire book is essentially printed in color. I have not handled the 3 volume sets you reviewed.

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for the insight and informative input :)

[@tonybaker1268]

The 2021 deluxe edition was the most expensive book I've ever bought. Always wanted a really nice copy of my favorite book. Very happy with it. Ended up getting it for display and the standard hardback for actual reading. I actually love the bright red with the ring inscription on it as it stands out from every other edition. The pocket edition has been with me for over a decade. Its been my go to for years. I've read that particular edition more times than I can count.

[@InsertTheCoin1997]

Is the pocket edition still intact? I've read the reviews said that they tend to fall apart over time

[@tonybaker1268]

@@InsertTheCoin1997 I've read that edition so many times and taken it so many places. Pages are slightly yellowed, it's cracking a little near the binding, but overall for around a decade of reading it is holding up very well.

[@brewingbooks]

That’s fantastic to hear! The box set though admittedly is both expensive and pricey is a priceless addition to any collection 😉

[@simounobrien9096]

I love LOTR and these books look really beautiful. I only got the Standard Paperback editions but that's good because they are 3 separate Novels instead of One Book.

[@brewingbooks]

The three volume set is always helpful for reading purposes 🙂

[@nateeeeeeeeeeeeeee]

One book to rule them all One book to find them One book to bring them all And in the darkness bind them

[@guillermoespinoza3160]

Amazing video!

[@brewingbooks]

Thank you!

[@jacktellsayarn877]

Thanks for this video, the collector in me want's them all but the reality of my bank account really values your reviews to help me make the right choices :D

[@brewingbooks]

Cheers! :D

[@Jilktube]

Good video. I like the idea of collecting the single volume the way the author intended, but reading and studying the story in 3 volumes plus the prequels.

[@Emyrus17]

I bought the standard one. I really like it and how it is set up so far. I plan to frame and hang the maps on my wall.

[@brewingbooks]

Wonderful!

[@nathonbrewer7775]

I just got the hard back of the series. It has a companion guide and each books sleeve cover has Tolkiens original artwork on them. It's been really enjoyable reading it as an adult now.

[@brewingbooks]

Fantastic! 🙂

[@shrsklawliet3218]

Lol, my deluxe slipcased edition has arrived and you’re making the video! I love the book, but it would be better with illustrations, though I’m not going to change the perfect book for just some images that I can print or google online :D love this edition!

[@brewingbooks]

Ah the joys of receiving a new Tolkien book 😃

[@seanrm]

A quick shout-out for some of the best editions in terms of quality and practical "readability". My three personal favourites are: 1. Any of the Allen & Unwin or Harper Collins single volume Deluxe India Paper Editions. Expensive, but magical quality. 2. 1992 Harper Collins Centenary 3 volume hardcover boxed set featuring 50 of Alan Lee's Illustrations, commissioned to celebrate the centenary of Tolkien's birth. Each slim volume is the perfect size for leisurely reading - the only downside is it is very hard to find. 3. 1999 Harper Collins 7 volume hardcover Millennium Edition. As Tolkien originally intended, six parts plus a seventh volume of appendices - just so easy to hold and to read.

[@brewingbooks]

Great choices and thanks for sharing 😃

[@ThumpingThromnambular]

I bought the really pretty Special Deluxe Illustrated Edition one with the slipcase. Just finished reading it. No issues with sticking pages, but I've found quite a few pages that seemed to have been printed twice on. Slightly harder to read than normal. I'm not really disappointed but I did pay a good amount for it, and kind of expected perfection. Either way, will use it to read it again.

[@brewingbooks]

Some issues still seem to crop up somehow, but it’s a lovely edition 🙂

[@SirSethery]

I just found out there's a whole set of basically all of Tolkien's books in the format of the 2004 special edition, and I'm really looking to collect those now.

[@brewingbooks]

That’s amazing! Great find 👍

[@davidseleznova3199]

Can you link some information or pictures? :)

[@emilinebelle7811]

I’m interested, too! PLEASE all I have are these really old paper back ones and they have no art except in the front page.

[@himalayanwandererrr]

You missed the 60th anniversary single, illustrated edition which is a collector's edition. Glossy paper with Alan Lee illustrations that is not available in any other single deluxe edition.

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for the heads up :)

[@neiltaylor513]

It’s a collectors edition? Dam I remember seeing cheap a while ago

[@tomsleeckx409]

I do agree with your opinion; the 2004 Deluxe Edition is also my favourite of this selection of books. I just prefer the style of this book as it fits with all the other deluxe books already published. The spine is also minimalistic in design than the more flashy publictations of the 2021 editions. The lack of illustrations is no problem for me, there are many other works to refer to when wanting to see his artwork.

[@brewingbooks]

Agreed! 😃

[@fgdj2000]

Just noticed that I currently own 7 different editions of LOTR: 2004 De Luxe, 2021 De Luxe, 2021 illustrated one volume edition, 2020 illustrated boxed set, 2014 boxed set with the companion, black paperback and a pocket edition by houghton mifflin. I also once owned a one volume paperback, but sold that one last year, because it felt... redundant xD

[@brewingbooks]

Wow that’s quite a LOTR collection 😍

[@greenskynz]

hello , as per my comment above, im looking for a nice illustrated hard cover edition. but most of the so called illustrated editions have just sporadic illustrations and i would expect 1 or two per chapter. any suggestions? thanks

[@fgdj2000]

@@greenskynz Hi, I‘ll try to help out. The recent hardcovers by Harper Collins are gorgoeous and have beautiful illustrations by Alan Lee and indeed have about 1 colored plate per chapter, sometimes more. The Hobbit (included in the boxed set) actually has additional pencil drawings and features noticably more art than LOTR as far as I can tell. As you May know, Alan Lee’s art inspired the look of the Peter Jackson films and he was hired as a concept artist for them. There is also a one-volume edition from 2014 which also looks great and is identical other than being all in one volume (and not including The Hobbit), although I don’t own it. Last year’s Tolkien illustrated edition features actual illustration (often actually rather „sketches“ and „doodles“) by Tolkien himself. However these are far more infrequent throughout the book and if you‘re looking for beautiful art, I have to agree with Tolkien himself, his art isn’t great Although some of it has a nice expressionist touch.. I recommend Nerd of the Ring‘s video „Tolkien Gifts 2021“ if you want to learn more about current Tolkien releases. He also mentions a different Hobbit illustrated edition by a different artist, which harkens back to old children‘s books and actually has quite a striking an different look from Alan Lee, which I always find interesting. The regular hardcovers are reasonably priced, but I think you can also still find a paperback of the Alan Lee illustrated edition somewhere. Hope I could help.

[@greenskynz]

@@fgdj2000 thank you so much for taking time to reply. not sure if you are familiar with LOTR live card game, i feel that some of the cards art could be simply replicated in a book. just a digression..

[@fgdj2000]

@@greenskynz You’re welcome. Glad I could help. Actually I am not familiar with those, but I always love to see new Tolkien art. :-) It’s just amazing how much his words spark the imagination.

[@Castagnolle]

Great job, thanks you for your honest and interesting review. I would probably prefere the 2004 edition too, but it is not available anymore... Or at a higher price than the "super deluxe" edition !

[@brewingbooks]

Thank YOU for your kind words 🙂

[@sengan2475]

You can find it on ebay occasionally for a decent price

[@Castagnolle]

@@sengan2475Yes, thanks. I guess Harper&Collins printed some news "2004 edition" because I saw it on Amazon at regular price. It could be that more than few people shared our feeling about the new deluxe edition... Or maybe they never intended to replace the 2004 by the deluxe.

[@BenFrey1980]

I understand why you didn't, but I think mentioning the standard Folio Society edition (not the newer LE set that was $1k and sold out in a couple hours) would be justified at the end of this video where you talk about the 3 separate volume sets. The print quality of a 1997-2007 era Folio version is a whole different level from any of these. The paper is beautiful, the binding is sewn, the cover artwork is unique and executed on another level, and they come in an excellent slipcase. There are indications that more recent printings have "soft" text for Folio Society standards, but I haven't seen it in person. I would seek out a nice copy from around 2000-2005 just in case. There's matching Hobbit and Silmarillion options, and if you're insane, you can find the same "guts" in a full leather LE that rivals anything on your shelf back there excepting maybe the Poetic Edda (also from Folio). The same internal design has been in the Folio Society editions since their first publication, with just the cover treatment and slipcase getting updated a couple times. The two new one-volume sets are most interesting because of the Tolkien artwork inside, presented roughly in context. I wish there were better execution on the red deluxe one.

[@brewingbooks]

Great insights. Thank you for sharing 🙂

[@CathyFrontier]

Great video! I have the 2020 illustrated box set; however, I do find them way too big (and too fragile) to carry with me on the go. Do you by any chance have the leather-bound pocket-sized box set that also comes with ‘The Hobbit’, or do you know if it’s any good to read from? Also, would love to see a similar video on editions of ‘The Hobbit’ as well as an updated Tolkien collection tour! 😃

[@brewingbooks]

Reviews of The Hobbit editions coming soon! I have the leather bound pocket version of The Hobbit and it’s a good copy to read from but not for collecting surely!

[@rickbear7249]

If you can read the smaller paperback versions or the small printing in a dictionary, you won't have any difficulties with the "pocket" versions. Although, I might say that "travel version" is a better description. You wouldn't want to sit down to read the whole saga in the pocket version. But they're very useful for continuing your read when on an aircraft or away from home for a short spell. See my more detailed description, above.

[@preslim84]

man you have them all, you're just missing the Folio Society versions, would like to see how you rank those in comparison

[@brewingbooks]

That's the dream some day ... folio and easton press side by side :)

[@JoseMora-wc5zz]

Folio? What is that??

[@carlatate7678]

The Folio Society. Top notch!

[@feliscorax]

@@brewingbooks That is, indeed, “The Dream”™. Both look absolutely gorgeous.

[@Riri-oj1zs]

I have the 50th Anniversary Edition and it's gorgeous!

[@brewingbooks]

Oh that’s splendid!

[@Vinasear]

Very good video, cheers.

[@brewingbooks]

Thank you 👍

[@marcelo_1984]

The faux suede gray one really looks lovely. I was reading some reviews on Amazon though, and there were lots of complaints about the paper being bible thin and the cover being poorly attached to the paper block. I really need to see one in person to make up my mind.

[@brewingbooks]

They’re right about the thinness of the pages. It’s a ‘pocket’ book version after all so one would expect some compromises to condense the text in such a portable size 🙂

[@sr.chantilly7152]

This problem with the cover seems to be a quality control issue, it doesn't come in a plastic wrap so mine barely resisted Amazon's terrible quality shipping and i had to ask for a refund. But the paper quality is pretty good and i will try to get this edition from another seller

[@ernestocortez5820]

I have the copy and I find the paper quality to be quite good in my personal opinion. I also find the words easier to read relative to other lord of the rings book editions.

[@zooropa5722]

Purchased my third lotr edition today, I really need to stop hahaha. I bought the blue one-volume Alan Lee illustrated version, the illustrations are so damn beautiful. The 50th anniversary is my reading copy and I bought the red super deluxe Tolkien-illustrated version last year, what a beautiful edition that is, far too beautiful to be handled a lot to be read in my opinion, but I love having it with the others on the shelf to flip through every so often.

[@brewingbooks]

Sounds great! I’m interested in the one-volume Alan Lee version but I think I have enough copies of LOTR for now 😄

[@zooropa5722]

@@brewingbooks Yes this one is going to be my last one as well 😃 at least for a long time. I would love to see more books get the treatment like unfinished tales and silmarillion, illustrated slipcases and cloth bound books, these are very fine editions!

[@thelowmein9143]

I'm trying to decide between the three volume set at the end of this video or the single volume one you mentioned @Zooropa do you have any insights?

[@zooropa5722]

@@thelowmein9143 I don't own the 3 volume set. What I can say is that the blue one volume set I have is quite unfit for reading, I bought it only to have the illustrations and lick through it from time to time since my reading copy is the deluxe version, which is smaller in size and much more comfortable to hold. I you wanna read a copy with these illustrations, I'd go with the 3 volume set.

[@slorunner7086]

@@brewingbooks The blue one with plastic slipcase is the best if you are looking for great quality illustrations as they are printed on thick glossy paper and illustrations really pop into you. Unfortunately the spine is prone to damage as it is not well made for such a heavy book. So not a great reading copy. But this edition is not expensive and worth buying just for illustrations.

[@joegriggs7809]

I saw you mention on another comment that you’re hoping for the Easton press editions! They have payment plans run through the company. It’s really convenient!

[@brewingbooks]

Good to know, thanks!

[@dudejuice5668]

So far all the books you reviewed in the video are stunning

[@brewingbooks]

Many thanks 😃

[@xavierpaquin]

Honestly, for the single-volume editions, the grey one is the most appealing to me

[@brewingbooks]

And surely the most practical to read 😄👍

[@Fundinnn]

The grey edition: It's called a softcover when you have the covers flexible but sturdier than a paperback (I have all of these except for the one where they painted the sides red)

[@brewingbooks]

Well said 👍

[@renukaashok6819]

Can you tell which one can i for cheap but is kinda good.

[@somni2246]

Do Hobbit editions next!?! I've had the same pb edition of the Hobbit since I first read it as a kid (in a box set with the LoTR); I've just received the standard 2021 illustrated ed you showed in this video (I love it, and how it has the feel of a very expensive Bible), and now I want to purchase a nice illustrated hardback edition of the Hobbit to go with it. My number one contender is the Harper Collins edition illustrated by Alan Lee (it's sold separately from the box set).

[@brewingbooks]

Good choice! And Hobbit editions video coming soon 😉

[@somni2246]

@@brewingbooks sounds good...looking forward to it!

[@luccaaguiar3782]

YES YES YES YES, I NEEDED THIS VIDEO AND I DIDNT KNEW

[@brewingbooks]

Awesome! Thanks 🙂

[@SizarieldoR]

Which edition you would say is best for everyday reading? Surely the one with the largest font size perhaps?

[@brewingbooks]

Don’t size can make a big difference. But I would also look into the practicality of handling the book. The Houghton Mifflin pocket edition is the best imo, but it does have quite tiny font. To be honest, the most practical set to read would be a three-volume paperback edition. I’ve always found that to be the best option.

[@greenskynz]

thanks for the review. im looking for a nice illustrated hard cover edition. but most of the so called illustrated editions have just sporadic illustrations and i would expect 1 or two per chapter. any suggestions? thanks

[@brewingbooks]

The Alan Lee illustrated editions from 2020 would be your best bet. Though frequency of illustrations may be limited to the 1 or 2 per chapter but it’s nonetheless a feast for any reader.

[@krystalgurl12]

Thank you for this great video! I just saw the new Folio Society Limited Edition and am agonizing over the cost because I have been waiting and waiting to own a leather bound Alan Lee version as my only copy. Please share your thoughts!!

[@brewingbooks]

Too expensive in my opinion. Looks like a stunning set but the price is simply ridiculous.

[@krystalgurl12]

@@brewingbooks ​ Yeah...I've been trying to convince myself that I don't miss it. Like, no Tolkien rune! Or, only gilded on the top! Or, I could buy 10 deluxe versions for that price! 😅 Is the 2020 box set your favorite Alan Lee edition of all?

[@TheTyjah]

I purchased the hard back pocket edition, and have been enjoyed it immensely. It is great as a complete version of the book to carry around that I don't feel worried about damaging like I do my 50th anniversary edition.

[@brewingbooks]

That's great to hear! Enjoy :)

[@iconikreviews5377]

So the white 2021 edition includes: The Hobbit, Fellowship of the Ring, Two towers, and Return of the king? Am I missing anything? Thanks

[@MaksKhamaran]

Thanks for the review. It was a shame that you didn't say anything about the textual changes for the later editions - are they of significance? Should I go only for a post-2014 text?

[@brewingbooks]

The majority of textual changes are more of revisions and corrections that are constantly updated with newer editions. So yes, later editions would make for a more complete text in that sense.

[@adamrichter4113]

Great comparison, but what about the 2013 one volume edition illustrated by Alan Lee? I don't own it, but I imagine it could be a contender for best edition.

[@brewingbooks]

I think you’re right. From what I’ve seen it looks great but given I don’t have a copy, I couldn’t rightfully compare it with the others. But it’s certainly high up on the list ;)

[@xDoornroos]

Does anyone know if the Alan Lee illustrations from the 2020 edition were made after the movies and are based on the movies? Because I think he also made illustrations for the LOTR in the 90s?

[@TheXsaintz]

I ended up going for the 2021 illustrated slipcased deluxe edition (managed to snag one brand new for 60 euros). An absolute steal and imo the best edition. To me having the maps/letters loose in the book is extra appeal due to the fact it feels more like an exploration to me, it adds an extra dimension. Ofcourse i understand its not for everyone, just sharing my view:)

[@brewingbooks]

That’s great! And yes, if the loose maps work for you, then why not. Enjoy your edition. It’s still a fantastic copy 👍

[@delaceylehane7758]

Looks the best to me too. The Tolkien pictures are a must. Not a fan of the loose maps or thin pages, but i can overlook that

[@brewingbooks]

@@delaceylehane7758 same here, same here

[@delaceylehane7758]

@@brewingbooks thanks for the video, by the way. They’re always helpful, and your opinions usually reflect my own.

[@TheXsaintz]

Update: now a year later the gold letters start to fade on the back of the book, the letters "by" from the part "illustrated by the author" are almost faded completely and some lines are 30% faded, in hindsight very poor quality.

[@andreapolling]

The 2021 standerd delux edition. From what publisher do you have the book? Also Harper Collins?

[@brewingbooks]

Yes, the majority of my Tolkien books are HarperCollins 🙂

[@rarknivesandleatherwork8045]

Have you had chance to view a 2004 US Anniversay Edition? It looks like another great volume and possibly a challenger for top spot.

[@brewingbooks]

I’m afraid I don’t have a copy of the 2004 US edition but I heard good things about that volume too 🙂

[@dendericavillacis]

Wonderful video but I can't take my eyes of Folio Society's The Poetic Edda in the background!

[@brewingbooks]

Thank you! 🙂 Indeed, that Folio edition is perhaps one of my favorite ever. It’s a beauty.

[@josephrm662]

Hey a budding fan here and I would like to collect the best edition out there. What would you suggest? I saw someone suggesting folios and Easton and the ones he shows in the video. Which one is the best?

[@brewingbooks]

That’s great! Collecting is a wonderful thing. As for “the best edition” I don’t feel there’s any one “best” edition of a book. All have their merits and downsides, but I’ve said many times that the older deluxe editions of LOTR (70s, 90s and early 2000s) are by far some of the best

[@dabadguy7129]

I have the 2021 deluxe illustrated edition and I love it so much. I have also finished reading it recently, so the sticking gold gilding is not anymore an issue. My only issue with it is the lack of counterparts for (at least) The Hobbit and Silmarillion. The 2004 deluxe edition matches with the rest of the set. Any news of super deluxe editions for the other books? P.S. I actually prefer the maps being separately presented and not part of the book, because it’s extremely inconvenient to check the map if it’s in one of the book pages - also prone to tearing.

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for your input :) On potentially new deluxe editions, nothing yet so far. Though their's always the 70th LOTR anniversary in 2024, or the 50th anniversary edition of The Silmarillion in 2025, so there might be a possibility XD

[@dabadguy7129]

@@brewingbooks well, I’ll probably settle with the slipcased set for the other Tolkien books coz I can’t wait years to have a complete shelf. LOTR will be out of place, but it is what it is. Haha

[@jandunn169]

i like the Illustrated hardcover Silmarillion, now on sale for $28 on Amazon...Illustrations by Ted Nasmith.

[@Omnilatent]

Could you also make a video about the three volume versions of the books?

[@brewingbooks]

Will certainly take that into consideration, thanks :)

[@JohnStopman]

Question: What's the difference between: The Lord of the Rings - A Reader's Companion (written by Wayne G. Hammond & Christina Scull) *and:* The Complete Guide to Middle-earth (written bij Robert Foster)? 🤔

[@jpzolannski1476]

Omg Love it!!! Where did u buy these editions? I want to buy the hardcover of the LOTR and The Hobbit, but idk where to buy it😔

[@brewingbooks]

They were mostly from online retailers or major bookstores.

[@jpzolannski1476]

@@brewingbooks oh nice, do u have a link or a preferred store that u buy it✨💜

[@PrisonMike117]

Are all editions essentially the same? I can’t seem to find any complete set and I’m not sure what books to buy to start the series

[@brewingbooks]

All editions are the same in that they contain the complete text (with appendices and maps). Some editions have illustrations and other “special features” but they’re mostly for collecting purposes. If you’re looking to start your first read I would suggest going with something simpler than a deluxe edition for example. The pocketbook edition might be a great copy to start with 🙂

[@rifway22]

Hoping we'll get a Ted Nasmith illustrated edition soon

[@brewingbooks]

That would be great!

[@nathankirkha]

Given your english accent, i think you're a fellow Maltese :) beautiful books, but i'm torn between the 2021 standard and the 2004 harper collins 😅 might cave in and buy both

[@johnm1123581321]

What do you think is better, Folio Society or Easton Press as far as collectability and holding and or increasing in value?

[@brewingbooks]

Increasing of value is tricky as they don’t usually tend to do so - especially these editions. I’ve heard some criticism about the subsequent batches of Folio Society due to poor printing quality and quick wear. But I have personally not found that to be an issue so far. As for comparing them to the Easton press, I’m afraid I can’t say as I do not own any Easton editions. Hope this helps a bit though! 🙂

[@Yesica1993]

This was so helpful! There are so many editions and it's confusing. I will continue to read this story the rest of my life. I would like a better quality copy than my 20 year old (!) cheap movie tie-in paperbacks. I do have the Barnes & Noble Hobbit/LOTR "pocket" boxed set that came out some years ago. They're wonderful for taking with you. I do much of my reading out and about, whether on the train, in a park, coffee shop, or literally as I'm walking down the street. But the print is pretty small and my eyes get tired. The last gray one was tempting. But I do prefer a 3 volume set. Thanks for putting the time into this and explaining all the details.

[@brewingbooks]

Hi there! Thankfully there are many editions you can choose from. I also tend to prefer the three volume set for practical reading, and while the grey LOTR volume is handy, it is after all marketed as a pocket book so don’t size can be quite small.

[@5f768]

Would you recommend against using the 2004 deluxe edition for reading? I'd like it, but I'm super nervous about the paper spine over time

[@brewingbooks]

It’s pretty durable in itself. It’s a high quality finish after all. I’m just as nervous to go full tilt and open up the spine more than I feel comfortable, but it will surely not get damaged if handled well. I find it difficult to read though mainly due to its weight and thickness.

[@5f768]

@@brewingbooks thanks for sharing!! Good call on the weight of it

[@abiriabdullah4832]

Sir I need your help I never started reading the book of Lord of the rings but I need your help which edition I should get and how to get it as I prefer it to be a single book to read everything of Lord of the rings ..I really appreciate this video because I couldn't find any proper guide

[@brewingbooks]

For reading purposes I’ve always found a 3-volume set to be much more practical than a single volume. However, as far as single volumes are concerned, go for a paperback version for reading - for instance the Houghton Mifflin pocket book.

[@lawrencep.3896]

If i buy one edition that has no illustrations, do you have a book of illustrations and appendices and letters that go together and that i can bring while reading the main story.

[@brewingbooks]

All editions of LOTR come with the appendices. As far as I know there are no books with just illustrations and appendices.

[@johntabor2619]

Can someone tell me how it is reading the thick book vs the 3 book set? Thanks

[@brewingbooks]

I find it infinitely easier to read the three-volume set than the single edition. It’s just not as practical to flip the pages and hold the book when you have a 1,000+ page copy in your hands.

[@RealEyesRealizeRealLies21]

What about the Allen & Unwin editions printed in the 50's that were a single volume printed on rice paper, which is the thinest single volume that is pretty easy to carry around IMO

[@brewingbooks]

I haven’t got these editions but I do hear they are great publications 👍

[@paolojavier9653]

Great video. Can you make a review of the LOTR Allen Lee illustrated 3 book set from Houghton Mifflin and compare it with the LOTR illustrated 4 set book (which includes The Hobbit) please sir🥺?

[@brewingbooks]

Would love to do that 😃 unfortunately I do not own the Houghton Mifflin set so I can’t compare. Maybe some day 🙂

[@abiriabdullah4832]

Hello everyone. I want to start reading Lord of the rings but I have so many questions is it one book or is it split into many books if it is one book which edition I should start with and how to get it please help me sir

[@brewingbooks]

Hi there! So The Lord of the Rings is a single novel (and for reasons which will become evident when reading it, it is split into 6 books). It is normally published as a single volume but has also been released in 3 parts (which has erroneously given rise to the idea that LOTR is a trilogy). There are many editions to choose from, but given it’s your first time, I would suggest going for a three-volume set first. It’ll break up your reading nicely and make it more accessible 🙂

[@seifer9638]

Did you by chance get lucky and pick up the new 2022 Folio Society LOTR limited edition box set? Only 1000 printed, sold out within hours. I just paid 2 arms and 2 legs for a set off eBay but I’m incredibly excited for it when it arrives this week hopefully!

[@brewingbooks]

That’s great! I was really tempted, but ultimately backed out. So let me know what you think of the set once you receive it 😃

[@seifer9638]

@@brewingbooks Ahh that’s too bad. It would be the crown jewel of your already remarkable collection. I have you to thank for inspiring me to go out and collect a few of these editions such as the deluxe collection. Your insights and showcasing have been invaluable so thank you and keep them coming!

[@brewingbooks]

@@seifer9638 Oh wow thanks so much for your kind words 🙂

[@jorgehuerta97]

I'm debating which one is better to buy. Between the 50th years deluxe anniversary edition, the 2021 standard edition or the illustrated box set which include The Hobbit?

[@brewingbooks]

If it’s for reading purposes, go for the illustrated box set. Hands down.

[@jorgehuerta97]

@@brewingbooks And what about if it's for collectible purposes?

[@CandyLemon36]

This material is awe-inspiring. A book I read in the same realm was an epiphany. "Galaxies United" by Olivia Whitestone

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks :)

[@johnstark8516]

I like the the 60th anniversary edition a lot can't chose which one to buy the 70th or the deluxe 21

[@brewingbooks]

Just be aware that many publications of the 2021 deluxe have been plagued by issues. Some less severe than others.

[@chrisd3933]

The 50th anniversary edition that I see for sale (in the U.S.) looks different from yours. It has a black cover with gold leafed pages. Do you know anything about this version? It looks great to me but I am not sure how different it is to the version you recommended.

[@brewingbooks]

Is it this edition by any chance? ISBN:0618517650

[@chrisd3933]

@@brewingbooks That's the one! I actually just bought it and I really like it.

[@Pinguino-Narniano]

I just get Illustrated by Tolkien Edition, and I'm so happy, I no need any more 😍

[@brewingbooks]

That’s great. That edition is superb! 😃

[@Pinguino-Narniano]

@@brewingbooks yeaaah is the best to me 😍

[@Tyttebaer]

Disappointing that the pages have different colors, but at the end of the day it will just sit in the book shelf looking pretty 🙂

[@brewingbooks]

That is very true 😅

[@numapompiilius]

My 2021 deluxe edition has so many issues. The foil on the eye of Sauron is half gone, the bookmark is half as long as it should be and there are loose threads all over it.

[@brewingbooks]

Oh dear! Sounds really bad 🤨

[@rickbear7249]

Your American Houghton-Mifflin version *isn't* the "pocket" version. The pocket version comes as 4 pocket-size volumes including "The Hobbit", "The Fellowship of the Ring", "The Two Towers" and "The Return of the King" bound in stunningly beautiful faux leather, as a box set. Each volume is even smaller than the paperback editions, being approximately half the size of the normal three volume sets. It also has the flexible style covers (as on your larger single volume Houghton-Mifflin edition), and is a super convenient travelling version which I can highly recommend; providing, of course, you have good eyesight.

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for this, though I believe this version of The Hobbit is labeled as the Deluxe Pocket Edition.

[@rickbear7249]

@Brewing Books you could be right on the "deluxe". There's also another 'pocket' edition box set that's actually a true hardback complete with loose paper dust jackets

[@brewingbooks]

@@rickbear7249 I think I know which one you’re referring to. Thanks again for the input though 😃👍

[@WinterEC]

I'm a little surprised there was no mention of the 1993 Collector's Edition with slipcase (Houghton Mifflin). That's the version I have and I simply cherish this copy as the favorite of all the fiction books I own.

[@brewingbooks]

Thanks for the heads up 🙂

[@WinterEC]

@@brewingbooks I think it was actually the 1987 edition (mine is just a 1993 printing). It has the red faux leather and multi-colored metallic embossing. Classic!

[@Morocco99]

Hy @BrewingBooks! My 2004 slipcase edition is delivered today, but I saw an awful thing on the page where wrote the printing and binding place. This place is China. What do you think about this? Do you think this detracts from its originality or quality? Thanks the answer very much! Have a great day!

[@brewingbooks]

Hi! It seems that your copy may be a more recent printing as they have started producing these books in China.

[@captainnolan5062]

You didn't discuss the binding and whether it is sown or glued. Very important for the longevity of a book. Glued bindings will likely crack and split over time.

[@brewingbooks]

Good point.

[@piusschroh6361]

Do you have the Folio Society three volume?

[@brewingbooks]

Unfortunately no, but they do look absolutely wonderful 🙂

[@yeahthatsright33]

Has your opinion on these changed? Especially with other editions that have released since this one like the folio society ones?

[@brewingbooks]

I still feel the 2004 deluxe edition to be one of the best out there. That’s not to say the newer versions are not on the same level, but there’s something timeless in the 2004 deluxe.

[@yeahthatsright33]

@@brewingbooks ty for replying and the videos!

[@Alex-bv8ub]

The pages sticking is a common side effect of the gilt edging

[@brewingbooks]

Right you are 🙂