the BEST rhythmic shift ever

[@MoioTube]

"I hope i made it somewhat simpler", he says right after changing my perception of drumming like it was first day of school.

[@YavorArseniev]

Screw you for making me appreciate music I don't enjoy, Yogev. Jokes aside, fantastic episode as usual.

[@YogevGabay]

hahahahahahahah EPIC

[@JustLilGecko]

I really need you to make it big on youtube, the effort and production quality you put into this is fantastic. You're like... the 12tone of rythmic analysis, but with better production quality.

[@YogevGabay]

Wow, thanks man! 12tone actually helped me when I got started he's a cool guy indeed!

[@TheDelahunt]

Really liked the visualisation for this groove. Very clever

[@matthewenglund3502]

Dude u gotta let us know where u get your MIDI paper 🤣

[@YogevGabay]

hahahaha arts and crafts stores here are SUPER HIGH TECH

[@leroytrailer2]

Yogev: the compositor mentions that the beat 1 is actually here Me: sorry, I don’t speak wrong Joke aside, great video, I love this song! The introduction confused me for so long, now I can see that the same shift happens as in the section you treat and it makes perfect sense, thanks to your explanation

[@nileprimewastaken]

I hear the 4/4 part with the kick/bass/vocals being onbeat quarter notes (could also be 8th notes but I hear it as quarters), and the hihats being offbeat

[@wolfram4321]

Best analog visualibilty I ever saw. I could not guess the time he invested but I appreciate very much. So great and helpful

[@YogevGabay]

Glad it was helpful! It took a while to make hahahah

[@crackedsystem2158]

I read it as,"This might be the coolest rhythmic shit ever"

[@YogevGabay]

Still valid

[@warwickjay3907]

This is similar to the part after the guitar solo in blackened by Metallica. The guitars never change but the drums shift the groove by 1 x 16th note (and back again) and it makes it feel totally different. Art of guitar broke it down pretty well

[@levimerenciano]

2:08 to 2min15s In Brazil is named "baião"

[@76madhur]

This a really cool explanation, visualizations are super clear to understand and help a lot!

[@YogevGabay]

Glad you think so!

[@scosstard3542]

Really cool explanation, even though I don't know the song. I think there is a similar rhythmic shift (from 12/8 to 4/4) in the song Iluminate by Leprous. Also if you could one day do a video about Leprous - The Sky is Red (especially the final part of the song) it would be awesome and extremly insightful!

[@MauriceGuibot]

Yes please we need more 11/4 in our life

[@brutalvocalcovers]

This is such a cool concept.

[@YogevGabay]

Oh yeah

[@BharathKumarIyer]

Wooohhh! That's a trip. I played this song 2 years ago, but didn't really notice the intricacy of the groove shift the way you've explained. Very well put. Thanks for this! ❤️

[@YogevGabay]

Well good for you for playing it without knowing all this hahahahah it's super musical which makes it just the coolest thing!

[@jaakezzz_G]

i heard the triplet feel the whole time it just makes more sense that way

[@DJazium]

I've watched this so many times. Might be my new favorite song of all time!

[@vishalgulve]

Thank you for introducing me to some insanely good music

[@matthewbenedict5923]

Finally! I love this song

[@ce_wono]

I admit: this is pretty awesome!

[@rikhaaksman8178]

This is brilliant! I'd love a Tower Of Power episode!

[@antoniopola542]

Very interesting. This is a masterpiece, I agree. When I first listened to this piece I immediately understood that's a very special rhythm/metric. Now you've clarified, thanks a lot!

[@ethangueldenzopf3808]

you continue to out-do yourself with the visualizations! fantastic stuff

[@YogevGabay]

Yeah this one was cool huh?!

[@jacob.gamble]

I discovered you today. You deserve way more subscribers.

[@YogevGabay]

Welcome aboard!

[@yanpierrecardona]

Thanks for this! Incredible.

[@francescotorrigiani5386]

Drum Didactics GENIUS!!

[@MRZEDDA]

ok this is fucking genius...obviously I agree with the shifted perception of beat 1 it's just...inevitable, but the snare thing ...yeah booi

[@TheWindseed]

Such a clear exposition.

[@danielmugnaini5735]

What a fantastic lesson!

[@Vinc3n7]

At 08:46 I had my 'Eureka!' moment. Thank you!

[@stuartthorne4872]

For me, your channel is fast becoming a rabbit hole with a very slippery slope. Great, now you’ve got me treating metaphors the way you treat rhythmic groupings... thanks a lot, Yogev. 😩😁🦁🌞

[@YogevGabay]

hahahah Happy you like it !

[@PlottierCityWach]

Gracias! Saludos desde la Patagonia

[@SgtPowell]

This is the video I show my musician friends when I want to introduce them to your channel. Always a mind blowing experience.

[@YogevGabay]

Ohhhhhh amazing !

[@SgtPowell]

It's one of the first videos of yours I ever watched and when you pulled the tabs as the groove shifted, I was like... 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 [[[SUBSCRIBE]]]

[@YogevGabay]

@@SgtPowell hahahahahahahh I always knew I want to make a video about this song, but I waited till I had a cool visual idea for it. Happy you like it !

[@roblosh8417]

You’ve probably already heard it but I think you would LOVE Hiatus Kaiyote’s “Choose Your Weapon” album. Especially “Molasses”, “The Lung”, and “Borderline With My Atoms”. Every song on there is super special but I figured I’d give a few specifics if you wanted to check them out :)

[@YogevGabay]

love that band ! will go over their stuff again

[@florentthirion5393]

This is so coooooool.

[@CallipygianMarmoset]

WOW. This is amazing.

[@ryehlb]

Thanks, Yogev. Apart from the great dissection of the tune, this makes your subscribers discover other genres with such clever rhythmic concept.

[@mostlyleg6049]

HELL YEA! this song is so unique

[@25dbz-ot9br]

So cool. Tks Yogev!

[@threee1298]

That’s amazing, great video

[@stephenmorton6732]

Awesome video! Thank you for breaking this down!

[@asymmetree2748]

It's so funny that every song you present is one I know and like, even if genres are so diverse :D

[@YogevGabay]

That only means you can send me some other ideas for songs!

[@auxphoenix]

OMFG, saw the title of the video and this song immediately came to mind, and then it turns out that YES that is what you are talking about!! haha awesome. Love your channel by the way, and would love if you would be able to revisit Gnawa and take a look at the actual qraqeb patterns at some point. There are basically no good resources for learning those rhythms that I can find.

[@alonkalonk5813]

Yogev you the man! Great video 🎧

[@ignaciojauregui7423]

love this

[@kayserjean9050]

Saw your Meinl videos, then with Tigran Hamasyan, then here, you’re everywhere ! Instantly subscribed, the content is top notch stuff, you deserve way more recognition

[@YogevGabay]

Thanks man! Happy you like the stuff!

[@jamiewashere]

This is very cool, thanks for explaining it

[@zoombinii]

Love the content, Also using your channel to discover great music, keep it up

[@YogevGabay]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@RileyStockwellMusic]

amazing man. Love this

[@marloc2019]

Simply awesome! Great vid. Immediately subscribed!

[@ElementalTJ]

You have amazing content. Thank you.

[@VillaCarrington]

I don't have any strong musical knowledge but I came up with that logic ages ago because of two things: Metal music Blasting my music very high before putting my headphones. I would notice another perceived song/beats. It helped me realize the existence of syncopation and how it could be shifted (not really) by the high hats. Now I always play in my head with alternate version of songs that I enjoy by shifting some stuff. It's relaxing but I'm still confused as fuck when I hear the intro of "Taste My" by Chimaira. Like my brain prefer the groovy interpretation and is always disappointed when the rest of the drum is catching up on beat lol.

[@darkkroastt]

Your way of dissecting music in these videos is truly great and easy to grasp! Also the type of songs you do are right down my alley :) subbed!

[@YogevGabay]

Glad you like them!

[@mishabeast]

You an amazing human being and such a nice guy. Awesome video

[@YogevGabay]

Thanks a lot Misha !!!

[@carlopelusomusic]

AWESOME AWESOME

[@arthurfurman5362]

This beat is soooo tasty! Awesome video as always!

[@YogevGabay]

kkkkeeennnnn

[@francosanguinetti817]

Maestro

[@coloripple]

wow awesome! Found this song a couple of years ago on Jacob Collier's spotify playlist, and I've listened to it a LOT! really cool to see it here!

[@coloripple]

and now having watched the vid, that sliding snare/hihat-paper consruction is super clear and nice! 2 other songs where I personally hear the 1 differntly than others are Jamie Woon - Message kzbin.info/www/bejne/iWLNh3-MdrmIpZY and Oscar Jerome - Gravitate kzbin.info/www/bejne/jmK1fWhomLqIe7c , maybe fun to analyse for you?

[@YogevGabay]

Ohhhhh I don't know either of these! Checking them out!

[@amjan]

Dude, you're fantastic! What a beautiful idea for rhythm explanation videos! I'm totally inspired, since I've wanting to make these kind of videos myself for many years now as well.

[@YogevGabay]

Awesome, thank you!

[@HaimDayan]

Great job Yogev "hakol barosh" Gabay! 😉

[@YogevGabay]

יא אללללהההההה חחחחחח מלך

[@Encysted]

You made my ears feel like they were hearing a magician pull a rabbit out of a clear, glass hat.

[@YogevGabay]

That song did the same to me !

[@eddieavakian]

This was such a great breakdown. Well done 👍

[@NiceToolsRemix30]

Thanks for doing this one. Been trying to figure it out for a while and had most of it right 🤘

[@YogevGabay]

Man isn't this the best one?! I love it.

[@bshubo]

excellent lesson! thank you1

[@vicentealvarado5608]

Nice, i didn't quite get it from rob's video

[@FilippoMignatti]

great !!!!!!!

[@viniciuscavalieri4161]

Friede, Freude, Fußball by Panzerballett is a good example as well

[@zkkzkk32312]

This song reminded me of Black Eyed Peas before they went main stream.

[@mikepostdrums]

3:10 I wasn't expecting Garibaldi but should have.. his book Future Sounds will get you started with the concepts in this video!

[@YogevGabay]

Hell yeah his book is incredible !

[@MattHSh4dow]

3:13 you're getting really italian Yogev!

[@YogevGabay]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@briancherry8088]

I don't play drums. Why do I keep watching these? Because rhythm is amazing. And you do such a great job of explaining it all so clearly! and I play bass.... so I'd better understand rhythm.

[@YogevGabay]

Ohh yes ! Good on you Brian. Bass players with good time is an asset !

[@weryxavier]

I'm pretty sure there's absolutly no way to explain this better. Great trick ! I will check garabaldi. Hi from france.

[@YogevGabay]

Oh man he's a beast. Check out songs like "Page One" by Tower of Power. Check out that groove. It's a 4 bar phrase, super syncopated, and sounds epic!

[@weryxavier]

@@YogevGabay I just listen a few other songs and page one...I fucking love this song. My mind is as warming as I listen meshuggah to understand what he's doing. I think he change the feeling of the pulse for just a quadruplet late the most part of one measure one two while hiting the snare before the pulse as he wants while( and I'm not sure of that because I'm just a guitarist ;) and it depends of the parts of the song :) he's sometimes quite very early on the beat/time , which is very rare in funk music I beleive. ( Don't know all this is understandable because I' m french and never practice speaking english !). But your're right he's a great killer. I hardly can stop trying to understand more precisely his groove which is such strange and unique. I feel my limits as a non drummer. He's more complexe than thomas haake. He reminds me a bit "morgan agren" (known for jaming with frederick thordental from meshug , and playing zappa's song when was 12 years old) and I don't really know why yet. I'll investigate.

[@YogevGabay]

Oh you should. He has a book that has a bunch of information in it called "Future Sounds" and it's great, It has a lot of drum notation obviously, but it expands on this topic a lot. These are all monster players, and as a guitar player I think you'd benefit a lot from listening to these drummers! Do you know Mattias Eklundh?

[@MauriceGuibot]

we have this game with my brother where we try to pulse on the upcoming 6/4 while listening to te 4/4 intro. It is pretty tough, at least for me

[@YogevGabay]

hahahahah I do the same

[@benjibuss5733]

This one's an "oldie, but a goodie". Japam by Botch off of An Anthology of Dead Ends. I think you would enjoy breaking this song down.

[@0r1onMovies]

Everyone talking about the song when bro has three arms

[@girlinagale]

Love to see a breakdown of Senegalese mbalax rhythms.

[@nocturne9257]

This kind of reminds me of another cool polyrythmic section from Constant Sleep by Car Bomb, at about 1:02

[@color-head1696]

👍🏻 Your explanation style to me is as fan-taste-tic as the composition your decoded! In a time when most people woluld use computer grafix you simply use paper, and ... uh .. whats the thing called again? ... a pen! ... and hands and fingers ... kudos! ...wow. Instantly subbed.✊🏻🙏🏻

[@YogevGabay]

Yes!! Analog !

[@Klingelong]

Think Master-Inventive-Drum -Rhythms ‘Gavin Harrison’ will appreciate this really great beat as well :-)

[@YogevGabay]

He's our savior from evil

[@moadot720]

BRUH I DIDN'T EVEN NOTICE THE CHANGE UNTIL 7:16, AND NOW I CAN'T UN-HEAR IT!!!! Also, love the song! 😍😍😍😍

[@YogevGabay]

Dude this song is gold I love it !

[@moadot720]

@@YogevGabay Fun fact: This song is NOW considered the song of January 2022 (To me.)! 😂😂😂😂

[@YogevGabay]

@@moadot720 Well that's a great start to the year !

[@tristanpaxton51]

Loving these vids. How about 'background music' - Rafiq Bhatia?

[@YogevGabay]

Will check it out! thanks!

[@adamj.benefield6044]

Great video, have you considered analyzing The Mirror by Dream Theater?

[@Digiphex]

Explain AFX Monkey Drummer next!

[@YogevGabay]

Yo such a good song! It's all in 4, but it's so fassttttt

[@jmpsthrufyre]

Car Bomba please Garrucha I dare you

[@ouie-fl4qo]

is it weird that i heard the song as 4/4 from hearing the lyrics as the pulse (straight eights)

[@itayresh]

זה כאילו אנחנו שומעים בול את אותה מוסיקה. משהו הזוי.

[@YogevGabay]

חחחחח נו אז שלח לי דברים שלחחחחח

[@matthewbenedict5923]

Awesome visuals! How did you do that with the paper?

[@YogevGabay]

Two pieces of paper stapled to each other, and two separate strips for each instrument. Took a while to get to a clean version of this, but my girlfriend (who helped me a lot) pulled it off eventually!

[@PJBonoVox]

@@YogevGabay I bet she did (˵ ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°˵)

[@giemmi76]

Woww

[@rafaelklitschko4085]

Reminds me of Overlord by Lamb of God.

[@silver1788]

And the Composer is also the Bass-player of Jacob Collier.

[@YogevGabay]

Yeah I just figured that out! Damn that bass player played with some HUGE artists

[@silver1788]

@@YogevGabay yeah he's a beast

[@mingnrich]

Jesus Christ. I’m finally listening to the song. You only described ONE thing this song did, but it’s far from the only interesting thing done rhythmically.

[@YogevGabay]

Oh man this song is gold !

[@Micropterus06]

This reminds me of a genre called M Base kzbin.info/www/bejne/h2GqqYt4d9Z0mac As well as some Tribal Tech kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3vUfJmNjK-ojdk

[@damienkurast]

Meshuggah anyone?

[@joshwest8882]

Can you just do like every song ever

[@YogevGabay]

Be careful, I'll do wonderwall

[@joshwest8882]

@@YogevGabay well I'm not gonna backdown now! Haha

[@YogevGabay]

@@joshwest8882 hahahahaha I got a 1 view guaranty right here !

[@joshwest8882]

@@YogevGabay you know it

[@blauwzakjecrack]

I love you

[@YogevGabay]

hahaha right back at ya !

[@Racosz]

Excellent explanation of this song. Do you know an American noise rock/post-rock band called Blind Idiot God? They have a song called "Rollercoaster" that features an interesting tempo shifting, maybe interesting for you to solve it out. Here is the link of the song - kzbin.info/www/bejne/kIjXg6KhaJumsMk Greenes forma Bogotá, Colombia.

[@YogevGabay]

Yo will check it out !

[@jayromasanta8072]

First