The Big Picture : Reservation: Reviewing 50% cap

[@aryankumarsingh2937]

Thank you very much sir.Reservation should be based in economic criteria which was recommended by Mandal Commission but negeted by government

[@shobhitmanigopal7831]

Not just economic criteria, but mandal commission gave set of 11 points and in short they said it should be based on social, educational and economic progress of a community.

[@missionpehlapageair1holypdf]

@@shobhitmanigopal7831 yes but the economic criterion is ignored nowadays

[@shobhitmanigopal7831]

@@missionpehlapageair1holypdf constitution of india originally never had economic standing as a criteria. But subsequently and specifically mandal commission gave it importance and included it as one of the criteria. So OBC reservation does have economic criteria. Further Supreme Court introduced creamy layer concept in OBC reservation. Creamy layer is an economic criteria. Recent Economically weaker section reservation have economic criteria. So in short EWC and OBC does have it as one of the criteria. But one may always argue that weather economic criteria in reservation is correct or not? As a matter of fact economic criteria is being implemented in India.

[@shashwat8463]

@@shobhitmanigopal7831 because everyone was dirt poor at time of Independence.

[@shobhitmanigopal7831]

@@shashwat8463 not everyone... but only selected class of people were. Income inequality was much more drastic, if compared to current data.

[@politicalflashback.880]

Supreme court should make it clear, Reservation shall not exceed 50percent under any circumstances.

[@RekhaGupta-jx3fe]

Knowledgeable discussion Thank you rstv

[@rajivkumargupta8671]

thanks rstv

[@MANISHTIWARI-vl1hc]

Three panelists mean better and Interesting discussion

[@Ben-ee3ib]

Please on the autogenerated English captions

[@aspirant8996]

It will be always this: only pvt sector will flourish because of one certain thing: merit.

[@Imparivesh]

Reservation provision should have been for few decades at max, Incredible Indian politics that instead of thinking about removing the reservation, we are considering the extension of reservation, 🤣🤣, And still we are thinking that India will become superpower without concerning the merit.

[@xanushka_singh]

Please stop asking about Frank Sir all the time. I think Vishal Sir is doing a tremendous job. Everyone has their own style.

[@satyaharish7788]

True

[@saurabhsneh2709]

1.Reservation should not exceed 50% quota as per Indira shawhney judgement 1992 2.Changing social & economic Dynamics of reserved caste should be analysed sociologically & statistically 3. Creamy layer demarcation needs to be there for Sc&st as reservation is meant for those who truly deserve it . 4.income -based reservation is required 5.other forms of affirmative actions like empowerment & enhancement of minority & deprived classes from Early childhood is the need of hour . Above measures regarding reservation would be undertaken only when politics on reservation & vote bank consideration recedes into background & deep motive of directive principles of state policy is realised ( social justice for true upliftment &not misusing it for political gain .

[@hustler6012]

Nice points noted

[@xavioreditz927]

Intelligent Dada ji

[@TheStargazingGirl]

Needed this video ✨, thank you for bringing this up Sansad tv

[@user-svhhh]

Are you upsc cse aspirant?

[@vipin_kumar_singh]

Best video with neutral mind

[@gitacharak7167]

Tyy RSTV nd Vishal Sir for bringing this informative, important and interested topic in today's episode of" The Big Picture"...... Really very Great Discussion...... 👍👍👍👍

[@PriyaSingh-fq7do]

Yeah you are right...

[@pppodcasts9343]

it has been observed that whenever Vishal Dahiya ji hosts the show, the description given below is very short unlike in case of mam and frank ji. Requests to kindly describe little more...atleast full opening remarks.

[@mrinalmandal1940]

We need creamy lear for SC/st.

[@politicalflashback.880]

What's creamy layer?

[@rahuldoddamani298]

it wont happen

[@rumi_das_biswas]

@@politicalflashback.880 if 2 or more generations have reaped the benefits of reservation then the next generation will become creamy and will not be covered under reservation.

[@HarryPotter-yw9sd]

Person's parents or him in govtally have a high valued jobs

[@riichobamin7612]

@@rumi_das_biswas there are other parameters too. In OBCs, children of Grade A officers, engineers, doctors, judges etc are considered part of creamy layer.

[@ajeetvikram5046]

To the point 🇮🇳

[@pragathimedchal4029]

informative debate tysm sansad tv

[@aishitachowdhury2453]

Creamy layer should bring in for SC, STs otherwise only a particular section will eat the cream and exploit downtrodden.

[@IamKaranShirsat]

Similarly Brahmin Son should not become priest,Kshatriya Kids should not benefit from caste status as they were kings and landlords and village head neither Vaishya Kids should not get business benefits.

[@ashah1451]

@@IamKaranShirsat bhai cool down it's not personal comment... But creamy layer will definitely come

[@IamKaranShirsat]

@@ashah1451 even mine wasn't personal comment youtook it personally and landed here here to comment on me. Go ahead for creamy layer and also there shall be systematic selection of every section of society to temples big business houses.

[@time5551]

Thank u

[@sonaljha9888]

earlier there used to be 4 panelist then reduced to 3 and now to 2...... y??

[@ashishbehera3825]

Where is Frank sir???? And why only 2 panelists???

[@aspirant8996]

probably budget has been reduced.

[@bhumi_k21]

He left Rstv

[@pareshbhanushali2115]

Rajya sabha tv is now sansadtv because of merging of ls and rs channels , frank wasnt happy and left

[@ransingh4904]

There is a need to stop reservation in the society completely if the country really needs to a world power

[@ransingh4904]

Needs to be

[@nikhilvermaverma6909]

First remove the caste system reservation will no longer be there

[@ransingh4904]

@@nikhilvermaverma6909 agree 100%

[@libertyismyindefeasiblerig3838]

@@nikhilvermaverma6909 Agreed no problem at all Fuck caste culture 🙏

[@nikhilvermaverma6909]

@Rajneesh Pandey that is why hathras incident happens

[@Doggydilemmas]

reservation is just as a for push or upliftment of the weaker society in the country, so they could move aline with the the other classes of the society. but somewhere reservation breaching the basic principles of Reservation which must be look into and review the reservation criteria again. we are now living in technology driven world, but somewhere some group or tribes being lack of opportunities, for them we can go for reservations with keep in mind that this action would not effect the the other class. if do reservations above 50% it might collapse the entire government system.another aspect is we need to go toward review the reservation again and make criteria like annual income of the family, we know that backwards class, they don't have money to complete their basic needs like education, health etc. i think annual income should be the base for the reservation.

[@candidkunal]

Frank sir kahan gaye h?

[@nutandevi6589]

I think we should wholly abolished casteism.

[@jha_vishal4]

Reservation ko 100% hi kardo... Or general walo ko Zeher de do... Bat hi khatm😎😎😎😎

[@adv.poojasharma4514]

Plzz help yr there r some queries about 102nd Am.

[@santoshkumar-oo3vv]

Reservation is not beg., it is extension of poona pact, to, protect hinduism. Until 15-17% representation reached out of 22.5% atleast, No review, no creamy,, no economy. Be United bahujan, let teach them lession through election.

[@ashah1451]

Pakistan jao🤣🤣🤣

[@piyushprakash2422]

Remove reservation save nation👍

[@soniraj4970]

Frank sir is busy in his interview preparation 😁

[@suhagrastogi551]

Thanks soni

[@user-svhhh]

😂😂😂😂yaa right

[@ashah1451]

In St castes , only meena are enjoying vulnerable condition of bheel, kanjar , saansi...

[@radhika9006]

- Creamy layer should be there for SC/ST - reservation should be based on income - merit basis shouldn't be ignored - particular cap should be there on maximum possible reservation - monetary benefits should be there for reserved categories below creamy layer instead of seats reservation in jobs and education sector Thanks sir

[@abc18457]

🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@santoshkumar-oo3vv]

In Central govt, uc comprises 70% govt job, population is less than 25%, they r overrepresented. They aquire almost nation 45% wealth.

[@shikha19apr]

So what's the meaning of this thing that they have 70% central govt jobs does that mean that govt should give a crutch to other castes so that they can increase their percentage do you want to create a crripled workforce in india

[@Divya-cq2tk]

Sorry to say but I think need Frank as anchor his questions are really helpful

[@vijaysridhar9777]

Jains who constitute 3% pay 24% of tax and don't create stir for reservations; Anyone who is selected to work for Govt must work for all the citizens of the country regardless of his/her caste. Surnames should not decide who benefits from governance, proportional representation based on community is akin to creating parallel governance structures and has nothing to do with alleviating deprivation related problems. For this caste must be demolished ; as an initial step , govt may amend CRS related statutes to exclude caste in the names of newborn children such that official records seldom indicate caste

[@grapeshott]

Yes, bring 80% reservation. Already 75% reservation is done Pvt sector for locals in the states . Continue this to SC/ST/OBC in govt. jobs and education also.

[@rkstudygrouprahulrohit7181]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️

[@sonypriya5241]

The percentage of reservation in Tamilnadu is 69% , not 65%..

[@aspirant8996]

79

[@sonypriya5241]

@@aspirant8996 It is 69% before coming EWS.. Now, it's 79..

[@swaminathanmuthukrishnan9908]

@@sonypriya5241 sorry..it was still 69% , ews was not implemented in tamilnadu state govt service commission...

[@ransingh4904]

How long would you retain reservations... India gained independence in 1947..it's only political vote bank tactics.... provide equitable opportunities and facilities to each indian and let only merit be considered

[@yesh8340]

How long will caste atrocities exist? Destroy the source instead of cribbing about the medicine

[@lifejustmixtureof5-F]

Sc announcement to review its old verdict :

[@shobhitmanigopal7831]

Change logo and name of the channel. Its still rstv

[@ashah1451]

Budget

[@santoshkumar-oo3vv]

These panelist continuously saying, economic weaker section reservation Can, sc, st, obc apply in it? No, It is uc reservation, name changing doesn't work.

[@xyzabc996]

Ews reservation should be called upper caste reservation

[@as14prez]

The panelists are indeed very knowledgeable but they failed to answer the questions that were put to them. There were no arguments in this debate, it was merely a primer of the reservation jurisprudence in the country. Not helpful at all.

[@Paulshek3286]

Increase number of panelists

[@shikha19apr]

What about the talent harassment in country somebody has even thought about it

[@sourabhmate1411]

There should be uniform view about reservation across India.

[@nitingavali2435]

There is reservation limit up to 50% . Is remaining 50% is open for all open category as well as for OBC & SC ST ?????

[@as14prez]

Yes, the open category is available for all communities.

[@geetanjalisingh6875]

Anchor must not be verbose .. and be quick in asking questions in line. Frank sir is missed. So does J Sai Deepak sir

[@awsomeslayer1]

Dahiya: Aisa kya hai unme, jo mujh me nahi?

[@suzimanipur2983]

👍

[@santoshkumar-oo3vv]

Never fall in line with uc argument about reservation. Even they r frnd, etc.. Stand their ground, nation belongs to all.

[@santoshkumar-oo3vv]

Let sc to decide on reservation bt We must see, who r 5 judges? Because, in case sc-st atrocity act, two uc judge showed their character, for quid pro quo.

[@ashishbehera3825]

Where is J Sai Deepak sir... Increase to 3 panelists please....

[@GhostRealm8]

It's the need of the time that reservation based on caste also made stringent by including income criteria. Reservation instead of uplifting marginalised people is just causing vote bank politics for fool thick headed politician.

[@sagarbisht7006]

its better to leave the country earn there and sent money back to india than being under pressure of reservation

[@abhinavprakash354]

Frank sir?

[@amitkapoor3375]

Reservation for EWS is already crossed lakhman rekha of 50 percent reservation 🙄 then what is the relevance of this debate?

[@Aavii01]

Sansad TV 🥺🥺🥺

[@puneetpundir5540]

There must be other alternatives of reservation like education , good food, livelihood .but govt. has been escaping since from independence. Now general category candidates should come forward and take the lead.. unite us... Otherwise it will destroy our country definitely. Reserved candidates will be muted because they are enjoying. And that's exactly wt they do peeth pe chaku... Guys we are indians. After sometime when you will suffer from most dangerous thing then reservation.. thereafter u remember me... Be united .we are indians... Not biharis, bengali.. come out of this narrow minded thought

[@DigvijaySingh-ll8nn]

Political parties only care about their vote banks

[@jugad6924]

RIP for SC and ST reservation

[@fatherofpakistan7658]

We don't know any cap, we want just reservation because We have very less representation in Maharashtra beaura racy

[@civilbeings1955]

anchor talks to much very irritating