The Biggest Mandela Effects in Survivor

Hold up... bro? Do I have that right?
/ idoled_out
Music: Silent Partner - New Tires

[@BradleyBoy]

Mandela Effect: Natalie can I have your jacket? Actual quote: Natalie is there any way I could have your jacket?

[@LeoLeoLeo12P]

"No, but you can have this fake one" - Natalie Cole

[@kellydaunis]

@@LeoLeoLeo12P 🤣🤣

[@EzraDair]

@@LeoLeoLeo12P 😂😂😂😂😂

[@bbgxo7967]

@@LeoLeoLeo12P oh… my… fuck LOL best comment in a while

[@shelbyjohnson5623]

@@LeoLeoLeo12P 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jameslinehan8970]

Savage represented Jerry Springer and was voted out by a Jonny Fairplay, whose grandmother loved that show! Its a shame she died before making it to the loved ones visit...

[@ConcertgoerJ.R.]

Apparently that was a great lie by Jonny FairPlay!

[@larstem2080]

Fairplay lied and hate him now

[@Mentally_Will]

It all comes full circle!

[@mackenziefritz8169]

I’m pretty sure Jeff usually uses “does not count” in the case of idol plays, but sometimes says “will not count”. I’m actually pretty sure in a recent season he said both at one tribal council EDIT: Finally found out which one, it was in Island of the Idols when Jack is blindsided he first says "Dean, does not count", then for the second vote it's "Dean, will not count" and then he goes back to "does not count" for the rest of them

[@kellydaunis]

Yes he did

[@krittapastt.95]

OMG never notice this.

[@jessie3339]

he said “will not count” for all of the infamous wentworth idol play

[@chrisoneal2718]

I wonder why he switched the phrase for Wentworth? Mind you, it was so far the best idol play in that it cancelled out the most number of votes at 9

[@cdawg4021]

He also said it in MvGx to Ken.

[@alyssaulin2756]

"...a hobbit, a pirate with a broken toe, and Sandra." 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@georgestafford7843]

I think the “And I can’t stress this enough, literally no reason” line is starting to become a recurring joke on this channel.

[@moviemaniac14]

You're right. Cook Islands wasn't good... it was a GREAT season. It's in fact one of the all time best seasons the show has ever had. Yul, Ozzy, Penner, and Parvati ALONE made that season an all time classic.

[@berouja]

While I agree that CI was a great season, I disagree that Parvati helped made that season. Parvati became a legend in Micronesia but her CI game was... not it.

[@moviemaniac14]

@@berouja Parvati had some iconic moments though which includes the hilarious hot tub sequence and her banter about Aitu's continuous wins. It is also kind of cool in retrospect when Yul claimed Parvati was a much bigger threat than Adam. You are correct though with Parvati establishing herself as a legend in Micronesia.

[@zztanerzz]

Candice also

[@CP-ll6qg]

@@zztanerzz Candice? From Raro tribe?

[@a.jdeets5527]

Yeah 4 out of 20 is such a good cast (I only care for Parvati out of that list lol). Cook Islands is so underratedly bad.

[@thefirespecialist9007]

Number 1: There was never a "Russell Hantz" on Survivor, his name was actually... "Ruffel Pantz", and he Won Season 19, and 20.

[@reginamachamer821]

Not to be confused with Rustle Chantz

[@thefirespecialist9007]

@@reginamachamer821 Or the Brother that got expelled from BB14... Dillie Dantz!

[@draghag]

What

[@sheaman1118]

Rustle, rustle pantz

[@olivermensinger]

@@thefirespecialist9007 I remember watching Willie tank his game in less than two weeks.

[@Veralidainai]

I re-watched Cook Islands and I still really liked it lol. I liked the underdog story of four tribal players overcoming a majority and I loved Ozzy's challenge beast moments and Yul's godfather-like strategy. It was also the first season that introduced Queen Parvati so how can I not love it

[@raaaaaaaaaam496]

Surely the guy is joking? Cook Islands is an incredible season.

[@olivermensinger]

Parv wasn't good in Cook Islands, but without Cook Islands, we don't get Parv returning three more times, so I am happy with that.

[@nathan4327]

Top 5 season definitely

[@isaacmemtorie3347]

@@olivermensinger We had many epic 3-4 time returnees, and many original moments.

[@GeorgeEugeneBarrett]

It’s absolutely a great season. People feel like they are supposed to hate it based on the theme, which I actually consider bold and unique.

[@colinyork2215]

Cook Islands is a great season and you can’t convince otherwise

[@shesjustafrienduhhafriend8655]

Preach it was my first survivor season too

[@MiniJodaTV]

Cook Islands could have been great, but it was ruined by the Super Idol

[@dakotaterry62]

Penner at the Auction alone makes it a good season.

[@rebellaxbro]

So many iconic players on the season, what’s not to love? I do agree, the idol was very OP in the players eyes tho.

[@shelbyjohnson5623]

I loved it too! I couldn't decide between Yul and Ozzy. Great finale!

[@ThorHC11]

"...or that Cook Islands was a good season" "...like she's the Electoral College" Luke is feelin some kinda way today!

[@Schweinas84]

Yo I love Cook Islands!!! The introduction of Ozzy, Parvati, Yul, Candace, and CAO BOI (Inventor of the "Split Vote")!!! Beautiful beaches, unique challenges, and of course the famous "Mutiny." Definitely not misremembering that.

[@shesjustafrienduhhafriend8655]

Hmmm

[@a.jdeets5527]

Ozzy was a spoiled brat that season. Parvati did nothing. Yul is both boring and sanctimonious. Candice and Cao Boi were great, but the former lacked screentime and the other left too soon. The challenges were not unique and the mutiny caused production to rig the show so a minority would win.

[@jordansinger8841]

Thought I’d see Spencer’s “Kass, zero (percent) chance of winning the game” on here

[@ultimatessjin2644]

What did he really say?

[@jordansinger8841]

@@ultimatessjin2644 Kass, zero chance of winning the game. I thought it was “zero percent” (and that’s what it’s quoted as) until someone on Reddit pointed it out and it in fact is just zero!

[@kellydaunis]

Wait a minute. I just finished Cagayan again, and when Sarah got voted off, he did zero percent chance of winning the game.

[@siwap3809]

ikr, surprised that one wasnt on here, cuz i felt like i was the only one that knew what Spencer actually said that episode

[@andyland5555]

Spencer said "Kass, zero chance of winning the game" in Cagayan, but Kass quotes it in Cambodia where I think she says "Spencer Bledsoe, zero percent chance of winning the game"

[@TheDylPickle]

It’s so strange how amazing Amanda Kimmel was as a contestant, was favored by production, and did well every single season she went in (and she went in China, Micronesia, and HvV) and is NEVER mentioned or really discussed. She was one of the first women to find an idol (Micronesia she was the only woman who was capable and did), actually got to choose herself to get rid of Cirie (argued to be the best player who has never won), then somehow consistently beat the villans top women and got the heroes back on track when they were losing (but it clearly started to go quickly thanks to Candice), not to mention her original season she was the only reason her tribe had a chance as they did boy v girl challenges and no girl other then Amanda could compete. She was also so gorgeous and it just marks me as funny because she’s guaranteed the best contestant who never won because all 3 seasons she lasted til the very end except HvV, where she went out third on the jury. She beat Cirie every single season she was with her in. Parvati relied on Amanda in the beginning swaying Cirie in and in the end taking out alexis, manipulating Erik, and taking her to the end if Amanda went on her superwoman streak which happened after they got Erik out. She’s got quite a streak and I guarantee she could probably navigate a current game pretty well.

[@samonestanley3492]

I think she had a great chance on winning on both seasons she made it to final tribal council but her lackluster performance in convincing the jury members to vote for her did her in. I remember Jeff saying to her that's she's a good player but she backs off and downplays her game moves which deters people from voting for her at the end.

[@rpg_haven]

Probably because she lost a final vote-twice. Just like Russell Hantz. That's the definition of a bad Survivor player. The entire point and only goal of the game is to *win.*

[@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong]

I have always believed Amanda deserved to win over Parvati. But that is heretical thought in the Survivor fanbase.

[@benahrens9062]

Only thing I disagree with is the best player who never won was rob cesternino

[@handsoaphandsoap]

I think the difference between her and Cirie though is that in three of Cirie’s four seasons, she wins convincingly if she makes it to the end and just barely gets snubbed by random twists that she can’t even possibly play around (not knowing the final 2 twist until it literally happens, advantagegeddon sniping her out), while Amanda makes it to FTC twice but can’t convince a jury to vote for her despite playing well both times. There’s more glaring flaws in Amanda’s games than Cirie’s.

[@giovanniorellana2200]

How about the Top 5 Obviously Salty Jury Members?

[@kellydaunis]

3 of the jurors on All-Stars alone would be on it.

[@rmusic08]

Everyone from Gabon

[@Tatinstein]

Corinne definitely

[@isiahduran2041]

I never understood bitter jury members, like what's your problem? They beat you fair and square

[@theDuckysaurus]

@@isiahduran2041 it’s a lot of projection, mostly. Imagine someone you thought was a brainless idiot manages to make you lose out on $1,000,000 because they talked behind your back better than you did behind theirs.

[@reginamachamer821]

Colby screaming at his brother while his brother turns and laughs is one of my all time favorite Survivor moments 😂 Edit: also tbf that challenge is WAY easier when someone with long hair is catching.. hair holds a lot of water lol you'd be surprised

[@jaybird6396]

My favourite part of the reed scolding is the fact that reed is amused by his brothers frustration. Thats real siblinghood.

[@ironmantim33]

"Only Survivor legends like Mick could overcome those odds." Damn, I spewed my drink all over my keyboard after that line.

[@emmathedilemmma]

what about people thinking spencer said "kass, 0% chance of winning the game," when what he actually said was "kass, zero chance of winning the game"???

[@Mendejito]

I’ve always remembered it as “kass, zero chance of winning the game” who would even say it with the percent it even sounds weirder

[@briankaste6931]

Aww I should've read through the comments first, I just commented about this. On an non-Mandela effect tangent, Tony mocking Spencer's bobblehead motions here is awesome and often missed since Tony is barely on the screen.

[@Hockeyhobo89]

I remember it correctly 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@aperson22222]

I don’t think such minor changes in phrasing are interesting enough to merit inclusion here.

[@legendaryhulk5972]

does it really Matter? zero chance and 0% are the same darn thing.

[@ddhallway4752]

When Rob was on marquesas he was just way too ahead of his time because this was back when everyone was still trying to play with no lying or straight.

[@chillyisasleep]

The funniest thing about the wentworth quote to me is that on Kelley’s EOE application she answers the question “What’s your personal claim to fame?” with “Wentworth, does not count” x9

[@americanjohn500]

Cook Islands was a good season though!!!!

[@jayjasperjp]

No it wasn’t

[@boomz2526]

It's a decent season but the cast is so varied, some of the best characters ever and some of the biggest duds ever

[@JeanValjean875]

I JUST rewatched it and yes, it was perfectly good. Solid cast, good final tribal. The way they divided the tribes up by race was weird but otherwise it was a good season.

[@moviemaniac14]

@@jayjasperjp my calculations are correct, it was at least a good season.

[@spdprawcereal7181]

People either hate it or love it

[@kolekardashian9516]

I could NEVER forget Marisa saying that to Brad. Iconic

[@calebturner2961]

I’m gonna need an explanation for Cook Islands not being good

[@roger_towny_jr]

I mean isn't it obvious? All it did was give us one of the most colorful casts in Survivor history. Spawning several iconic returnees like Ozzy, Penner, and Parv, that shape several seasons in the shows future, and even without them has a sleu of endearing one-timers like Chao-Boi. Tells a compelling story of mutiny and payback. The seasons winner Yul playing one of the most cerebral and diplomatic games in the show's history. Fun Challenges The Billy Candice debacle... The three Oddball Aitus randomly showing up at Raro camp just to give them a hard time. Yeah, this season is a riot.

[@noahsmith561]

There's like a handful of good episodes but that's it, the rest of the season is pretty boring, and the cast gets hyped up as being amazing but there are so, so, so many duds

[@yaral9328]

Most of the cast is really boring

[@TransparentEclipse]

@@roger_towny_jr the guy was asking what idoled out meant by saying cook islands isnt good... not the other way around. hes asking for what could possibly be negative about the season, not what is positive.

[@TransparentEclipse]

as 2 ppl below me have already stated, the cast is extremely top heavy. 4 absolute fan favorites in Yul, Ozzy, Parvati, and Penner, a decent returnee in Candice, a couple good one off characters like cao boi, billy, and nate, aaaaaaaand literally everyone else is completely and utterly forgettable. becky is one of the biggest who? people in ft history, sundra and adam are both completely forgettable final jurors, and i for the life of me cannot remember a SINGLE premerge boot other than cao boi and billy without looking them up, every single other person is completely irrelevant, and the season has 20 fucking contestants on it. like bruh. top heavy cast is all. gives me like tocantins vibes, jt, stephen, coach, tyson, aaaaaand thats about it lol.

[@zachariahbecker9300]

I would religiously watch a series where you straight up just talk through each season and give your commentary on the stories and characters.

[@stacuu2222]

Cook Island was a MASTERPIECE and don't you dare suggesting otherwise

[@jayjasperjp]

Cook Islands is incredibly boring

[@shesjustafrienduhhafriend8655]

@@jayjasperjp I shocked

[@a.jdeets5527]

More like the opposite of a masterpiece

[@Vedrine-Videos]

You know I truly appreciate your creativity in your topics. You have a great brain for this. Way to go!

[@IdoledOut]

Appreciate you watching!

[@alcyone2129]

also, courtney doesn’t say “jean robert” when she says, “did *you* win an immunity?” people just remember it that way because that’s who she was talking to.

[@IdoledOut]

This is another big one for sure! If I do a follow-up I'll definitely bring this up.

[@Rodanguirus]

This is why I kind of roll my eyes at a lot of Mandela Effect examples. People go so hard on "there's no way so much of the population misremembered something this iconic...there's something more to this" when it's just a famous quote getting paraphrased or very slightly restructured because quoting it verbatim out of context wouldn't land quite as well.

[@bunny_0288]

@@Rodanguirus I don't buy into the little things like that. But I remember watching that James Bond movie as a kid. And I clearly remember Dolly smiling and having braces and it was such a cute moment when he smiles back at her. I do not understand how that memory I have is wrong. So something like that is what gives me the heebie jeebies lol Not misremembering a simple quote.

[@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong]

@@bunny_0288 I always thought it was the Berenstein Bears, not the Berenstain Bears. But I quickly came to the conclusion I had just simply always misread it rather than we went through a vortex an entered an alternate reality where only minute things like whether someone in a movie had braces or the names of children's books changed.

[@casperjokkins6668]

One Correction: Veterans Were On Galang Loved Ones On Tadhana

[@IdoledOut]

Thank you, I ALWAYS confuse these two tribe names for some reason

[@rudohk]

@@IdoledOut I think the reason is the tribe swap.

[@reginamachamer821]

I kind of see why Marisa was pissed by what he said bc she was definitely one of the stronger players on the tribe and they voted her out simply bc they were salty that Gervase was celebrating a win lmao I mean I agree a lot of blame was put solely on him unjustly, but as far as Marisa, I see why she was set off a bit by what he said.

[@YourPalJamieEllis]

No matter what the first vote is going to be based on minimal, sometimes arbitrary information...but this one always feels particularly unfair to me. (Y'know, if we ignore the possibly even less fair Candace vote earlier in the episode.)

[@Slackmana]

I'm currently watching season 27, and I can understand why people thought Candice said it. She was angry about being sent to exile right away, and because of that she developed a crabby attitude from day 1. Also Candice did really well on exile, outlasting Marissa, and others. So it's easy for people to forget Marissa, and mistakenly contribute her words to the crabby Candice.

[@cdawg4021]

And on account of giving Brad the 🖕 it's easy to get confused with the F**k you Culpeper comment from Marissa.

[@lomanic8573]

I think you Mandela effected yourself. Galang was the returnees and Tadhana was the loved ones

[@llorona7847]

I can’t believe Candace was featured in a video and didn’t get dunked on by Luke

[@ryleycarroll9486]

If rob’s game was played out today without seeing him before, the same people that say he sucks would say he was “robbed”

[@dembonez19]

Marissa 💖 It's surprising that people misremember such an iconic line.

[@derekrichardson1755]

Nothing like watching the new idoled out video monday morning to get me ready for the week. Thanks for always putting out great videos.

[@km_studios]

How about Russell at the HvV reunion show? People remember him saying "THE GAME IS FLAWED!", but what he actually said was "I think there IS a flaw in the game."

[@nightslap1]

Cook Islands is literally my favorite season

[@JesseTalksTruth]

The Mandela effect that hit me multiple times this last season was thinking Jake got eliminated. I would often make sure I'm watching the newest episode because I always swore that I saw him eliminated. Incredible he made it to the final 3 lol

[@jesses5465]

Cooo Islands is an amazing season! You are just wrong about that lol. We have Yule, Cowboy, Ozzy, Parviti, and Penner. We have the invention of the split vote, the first mutiny, and the win streak of the Aitu 4!

[@cousinmose3193]

And Billy's love story😏

[@tjrabbidfire3394]

1:31 "The loved one's tribe: Galang, and the Survivor Veterans: Tadhana" Notice you got the tribe names swapped. ANOTHER Mandela Effect. Lol

[@paulmcdonald3431]

Oh yes, one more to add: Cirie is famous as the most unlikely player to ever become a Survivor legend. No description of her stunning growth does not begin with "She came on the show afraid of leaves!" WRONG!!! Cirie never said she was AFRAID of leaves. She said she HATED leaves. That's an important difference. If there is film of her anywhere saying she is AFRAID of leaves, I would like to see it please. Let's take this opportunity to correct Cirie's legacy. Thank you.

[@EzraDair]

My personal Mandela effect is always believing that Survivor Amazon was the 4th season

[@mikhailvolpe3934]

For me its Amazon being the 5th season. Although I think that's just my brain's attempt to block out the existence of Thailand lol

[@rmusic08]

@@mikhailvolpe3934 in glad you said that because i was like... wait it wasn't?

[@siwap3809]

"or that Cook Islands was a good season" dont. dont go there buddy

[@jasonsnider3133]

Black Friday video idea: best deals players have gotten at the Survivor Auction XD

[@briankaste6931]

Another quote nitpick is what Spencer says after Sarah is voted out in Cagayan. I've seen a few variations of his infamous quote, but it's "Kass, zero chance of winning the game!". I think the most common misquote is "Kass, zero percent chance of winning the game!". I also love Tony mimicking Spencer's bobblehead tendencies after he says this

[@gabrielmurray929]

I assume people thought does not count because Wentworth taking Savage out was the only time I can think where he said will not count.

[@hot-sy2yd]

this isnt true, but he doesnt exactly say it often though.

[@rowanmoon]

My world is actually shook. I never realized "Wentworth, does not count" was incorrect.

[@jasperisarock]

Your video ideas are always so creative😌keep up the good work!

[@IdoledOut]

Thanks for watching!

[@petermcgill3405]

You got the tribes backwards in blood vs water. Tadhana was the loved ones tribe, Galang was the returning players.

[@IdoledOut]

Thank you, these tribes always give me trouble for some reason

[@Sequoya]

This channel is comedy gold for Survivor fans!

[@arynackerman7232]

When I lived in Florida we said "F you Brad Culpepper!" every time we drove by one of his billboards

[@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong]

I'm a big Savage fan, but that shade you threw at him was so great.

[@TheMaskedHero]

My ultimate Mandela Effect : I swear Cirie has won a season.

[@trevzeee]

I knew that the Colby one would be here. Also in HvV I could’ve sworn when Sandra voted out Rupert she said “I’ll vote your ass out and if I’m up there in the final three, you’ll still give me the million dollars” when actually she said “I’ll write your name down and if I’m up there in the final three, you’ll still give me the million dollars”

[@NotHaydenMoss]

It's kinda crazy, KZbinrs keep calling me 'chip' ... Not sure why

[@nealsidhu2697]

Cook Islands is an AMAZING season! The handful of stars in the cast and the awesome mutiny storyline make it a top 10 season AT LEAST. You upset a lot of fans with that joke smh. I do LOVE your channel btw. Keep up the good work!

[@IdoledOut]

I brought out the Cook Islands defense force with that comment 😂 I actually really appreciate all the love I'm seeing for it in the comments, and I'll give it another rewatch soon, my opinion might change!

[@MUDGameshows]

Idoled Out, how did you manage to remove the music at 11:53? I’ve been wanting to know for SO LONG as I’ve seen other people do it. If you could let me know that would be amazing! I don’t have enough magical skills! :C

[@oldaccount6297]

My biggest Mandela Effect is remembering all of the girls of Gota's names. They all pretty much fit the same casting criteria other than Sherri/

[@koshea44]

Ali and Hope (reynold and eddies ‘girlfriends’), Julia (the one Cochran said calling her vanilla is an insult to the flavor vanilla lol)and Laura I think is the other one. Yes I happened to rewatch Caramoan very recently.

[@bobbya9722]

Allie was the one with the attitude, Hope was the beauty queen, Laura was the preppie one, and Julia was the tomboy

[@oldaccount6297]

@@bobbya9722 Thanks! It’s just bad to admit that I watched this season in the past month, and I still can’t remember them.

[@bobbya9722]

@@oldaccount6297 No it's okay. They really weren't that interesting except for Laura who I think had potential

[@mallowout]

Is this going to reveal some big news where the 'snakes and rats' speech was actually 'shapes and bats'?

[@kellydaunis]

lmao

[@mikhailvolpe3934]

Actually it was rakes and hats

[@ttewelow1]

No Boston Rob played survivor 5 times and made the merge 3 times, one of which was his winning season

[@user_cat12]

#4 is even more funny considering swati from survivor 42 made the same mistake in her exit interview saying boston rob went 4th🤣

[@cousinmose3193]

Cook Islands IS a good season.

[@FANOFCHRIS]

Brad Culpepper and I graduated high school together. He is a trip! I would love to see him play a third time.

[@daphnerosales2072]

A hobbit, a pirate with a broken toe, and Sandra LMAO 😂😂😂😂

[@CarlosVardi]

What's wrong with Cook Islands?!!?

[@spencerclark4726]

Maaaan, here I was hoping this video was gonna be about Jeff having the mandela effect. Ben in Samoa is the "first kicked out of a challenge" as if half the cast weren't kicked out of a challenge in Thailand, "JT played the first perfect game" as if he hadn't already made the same claims about Earl in Fiji before later arbitrarily changing the definition of a perfect game, "a swap like this never happened before" at the swap in EoE as if the All Stars swap wasn't the exact same "tribes stay together except for one person" dynamic, Jeff acting like Chris D. was the worst person ever in Vanatu's reunion despite praising the hell out of BostonRob the previous one for the exact same behavior, and all the other times Jeff claims something is happening "for the first time" when in reality it had happened before.

[@KeyanCarlile]

That would be a great video.

[@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong]

To be fair on the whole "Earl played a perfect game" one, at the reunion I think everyone thought Earl played a perfect game because nobody remembered that random vote he got from Rita. But yeah Probst is an asshole who could care less about the truth, it's all about whatever he wants the narrative to be.

[@spencerclark4726]

@@Captain-Sum.Ting-Wong The definition of a "perfect game" is arbitrary anyway. Considering there's multiple ways to possibly measure perfection in Survivor: - Wins unanimously at FTC - Never once receives a vote for them (what if, like Jeremy, they get votes but they're voided by an idol play?) - Has a perfect track-record for voting correctly every time - Wins every single possible immunity (Tom Westman in Palau was the only person to come close, won every tribal immunity and all but two individual immunities) So like, wouldn't a TRUE perfect game be a unanimous win, perfect immunity run, with a perfect voting track-record? lol

[@PursellEditing]

Colby literally says "Come on Reed, Dammit!" in the clips shown....

[@markjackson6431]

5) never knew people thought Candice said it, i always remembered it as Marissa 4) again i always remembered him making the merge, not the jury 3) yeah, yeah, i always thought it was doesnt not count instead of will not count 2) again, i misremembered this too 1) idk where the “hold up bro” came from, i remembered it as “hold up, Reynold”

[@deluxeclavier345]

The edited “Hold up Reynold” part totally makes me want to see an entire season with no music (except the intro of course)

[@Frames12521]

I think it's quite the mandela effect when you say Tadhana is the tribe of veterans and Galang is the tribe of loved ones

[@cartaio123]

I cannot believe Colby didn’t say “DAMN IT REED” like what??? I’ve heard that line in my head for so many years 😭

[@patrickcallahan9206]

Ciera estan has a mandela effect in blood vs water. when her mom beats her in the sumo water bag challenge laura actually asks her “are you safe” and ciera responds with “i have an alliance” what we got shown was laura asking ciera “tell me you’re not mad” and ciera saying back “i’m not”

[@bella3987]

That’s not a Mandela effect that’s just incorrect editing lol

[@EzraDair]

Another huge Mandela effect I have: I always always mix up the cast of the season Sara won and the season Jeremy won, Sometimes I’m like .. wasn’t Tai sitting with Jeremy at one episode I swear he was lmao !

[@thestatmosphere7850]

Regarding Cook Islands, I like the season. I just don’t know why I like the season as I have lots of issues with it.

[@jimmyanderson5719]

"F**k you, Brad Culpepper" is literally my number one favorite survivor moment 😁

[@flamingtiger5673]

Cook islands is a good season I’m offended

[@johnpastaman]

In Blood Vs Water the vets were on Galang and the rookies were on Tadhana…. Sorry for giving you an added Mandela effect 😂

[@JimmyVermeer]

Mandela Effect: The veteran Survivors were on Tadhana tribe while their loved ones were on Galang tribe. Reality: It was the other way around.

[@gersondiaz2451]

4:05 he made the merge at least 3 times: marquesas, all stars, and redemption island

[@bluepower1177]

I’m just gonna pretend he still says hold up bro

[@Mathisonnn]

Not sure if this was just me, but for the longest time I could've sworn I remembered Cochran naming the Caramoan merge tribe after his mom, only to rewatch the season years later and seeing it was actually MALCOLM who did it.

[@zacharywright5625]

Wasn’t it Erik?

[@IdoledOut]

Erik named the tribe Dabu in Micronesia

[@zacharywright5625]

@@IdoledOut ah

[@wellingtoncamelo8466]

Cook islands is a great season

[@endezeichengrimm]

Jeff still said "guys" in episode 7 of season 41

[@patriciamillin1977]

Does it actually matter if Jeff says “does not count” or “will not count”?

[@otpyg13]

It really doesn’t. Absolute grasping at straws for a weak themed video.

[@pokechespingames9084]

Season 46 now is an amazing example.

[@Peachyspecter]

my family always remembers the first one (number 5 on the list) because we found it really funny that it was just “…you Brad Colepepper ” we still quote it to this day at random times

[@LivTheSlayer]

I always thought Jeff said “Wentworth will not count” for the alliteration purpose. But who knows, maybe he just lost his mind for a minute 🤣 🤣

[@JackLudolph]

i always remember morgan being voted out before sarah in cagayan i’m not sure why

[@strawberrylemonadelioness]

4:30 It's probably because I'm hungry, but damn that pizza looks good

[@reginamachamer821]

Yeah I've definitely seen a lot of people (especially on Reddit lol) say that it's bs that boston rob was even asked back for All Stars bc "he didn't even make the merge on his season"

[@kellydaunis]

He did make the merge, just not the jury.

[@craigresendes2403]

I’m 99% sure that back during Cambodia one of the Survivor Sucks forums had “Wentworth, does not count” as its header. So that’s probably where the confusion came from as well.

[@BlueJaybeard]

#4 isn't an example of the Mandella Effect. You said it yourself-people were saying Rob didn't make the merge "in an attempt to discredit his gameplay." That's gaslighting-not the Mandella Effect.

[@koshea44]

If only Dave proposing to Caroline at the Redemption Island Reunion was an example of the Mandela Effect, but unfortunately the cringe was all too real…

[@GoShiney]

you had your own Mandela effect, number 1 the Michael vote in Caramoan was NOT the merge vote like you said, corinne was the merge vote

[@SURVIVORkid23]

Cool islands is a top tier season with the best final 2 we’ve ever had (if you don’t look at Ozzy today that is)

[@dinohall2595]

There was no final 2.

[@SURVIVORkid23]

@@dinohall2595 I know it was a final 3 but Becky never had a chance, it was a final 2 with a placeholder seat like we see almost every season.

[@freestrike2000]

The Mandela Effect only applies to things that happened before 2012 and who could ever forget Rob running back to camp yelling "there's a merge! there's a merge!"?

[@ashtondelph9065]

How did I know rob crying was what he was going for as soon as he said “well maybe”💀

[@ToleratedMoments]

i always thought rob lost directly before the merge but i havent watched that season

[@kellydaunis]

He made it to the merge, just not the jury

[@divdesmitpieci6767]

Damn, now i need to rewatch Cook Islands because i thought it was a great season when i was fourteen.

[@SurvivorAndBone]

My Mandela effect was that Boston Rob was a two time winner.