The Book "Fazail-e-Amaal" [Fadhail A'mal]?

[@paullovio7909]

I'm proud of this shaykh! He's mentioned about the mispronunciation of non Arab Muslims misguiding Muslim reverts to accept this incorrect pronunciation of the beautiful Islamic Arabic language.

[@ibraheem128]

Skip to 2:20 unleas you came for an arabic lesson

[@Nur12551]

No need for any sas ya akhi

[@AbdullahAbdullah-nc9yk]

Great review😁😁. This is really helpful

[@mmmukhtar9242]

This book fadhail e amaal is the nehej of the Prophet SAW and Sahaba. Today we go to schools where we are taught fadhail e Maal. Today the arabs believe that maal means success. Today the modern bedouins believe that by building the tallest building the Muslims have achieved success. Yet the prophet Muhammad warned and informed that you will see barefooted arabs competing with each other in building the tallest buildings. But this prediction has come true. Today people are neglectful of amaal because we are ignorant of their values. In the school of the prophet the sahaba learnt fadhail e amaal. The value of amaal was so ingrained in their brains that you will see a sahabi going regularly to the market but he never came back with goods. When he was asked why he said that he has been taught by Rasulullah a zikr which enables the reciter of it in a market millions of virtues. Thus he goes to the market to recite and earn these virtues. These are the fadhail the sahaba learned in their school. Sheikh Ilyas noticed that the decline in Deen and practice of amaal because the teaching methodology (nehej) has been abandoned and we now have deeni institutions based on the nehej of American universities. This is what maulana Ilyas meant when he referred to this work as "qarne awwal ka heera". The methodology of the sahaba has been given back to us. His fikr was how to make each individual of this come back on his maqsad like the sahaba understood it like Uqba bin Nafe when he reached the shores of West Africa he spurred his horse into the Atlantic ocean until the water reached to its neck and addressed his Rabb thus:"if I knew there was land beyond this I would have taken my army there." In Maulana's time there were dar ul ulooms and books. Knowledge was far more available in his time than in the time of the Sahaba. Then he realised that the school (i.e. the school of Dar-" ul-imaan) through which the worst of people became the best has been closed for centuries and this was the reason why in spite of ilm, being plentiful aamaal were little. Our methodology changed from "taallum nal imaan thoumma taallum nal Quran" to " taallum nal Quran thoumma taalum nal imaan". In most cases the "taallum nal imaan" has been removed from the curriculum altogether in our current methodology (nehej) . Even ulama did not notice its disappearance. This change in methodology was the cause of the degradation of this ummah. This was a dead sunnah which Maulana Ilyas tried to revive. No wonder even ulama got shocked with his methodology and some even called it "bidaa". Such a shock-provoking methodology can be easily understood if we take the analogy of a person who has been dead for many years coming back alive in front of his relatives. Will they be happy to see him or shocked? Similarly this methodology was dead for centuries no wonder even the most knowledgeable will get shocked. That is why the Prophet SAW, who was aware of the degradation of this ummah over the ages, has informed us that Allah Ta'ala will send mujaddids to revive the Deen not by modernising it but by restoring it to its pristine purity. Imaam Malik RA said: The last of this ummah can only be reformed by the methodology, (nehej) which was used by the pioneers of this ummah (the sahaba).

[@Omar-Asim]

Sidenote: Since the work was translated into Arabic later, "Fazail-e-Amaal" is actually the correct pronunciation in Urdu. Edit: Unless the author intended that his Urdu book would have a Arabic title.

[@Me-hu9br]

@@AhmedRaza-lh4oj well guess what I'm pretty sure the sheikh who wrote it is pakistani and most people who read it are pakistani as well. Most muslims don't speak arabic.

[@azadajk7128]

Ahmed Raza Please don’t use the word Paki. It’s an insult and usually intended to be derogatory.

[@AHK4680]

Me Na I’m pretty sure it was written back when the countries of Pakistan or India didn’t exist, so he was neither Pakistani or Indian.

[@Me-hu9br]

@@AhmedRaza-lh4oj bro if you don't like muslims speaking Urdu thats your problem. Urdu is their language. Most muslims don't speak Arabic. Islamic books need to be in other languages.

[@Me-hu9br]

@@AHK4680 lol do you even know how old india is?

[@Mohammed-sh6qs]

This respectable scholar gave a good balanced answer. It is not about offending but about right and wrong. He's answer keeps leads to no hate or fitna. This is a balanced scholar with balanced opinion. That is the best way to think and do your actions in a balanced way. Please go back to our prophet pbuh way and examples salam to all my brother's and sisters in Islam.

[@scribblerer7819]

With all due respect shaikh, the urdu speaking people usually pronounce 'dha' as 'za' because of the urdu influence. Commoners take it up thinking that's the right way to pronounce.

[@Bilal-ys6df]

He knows and we know, still it is an Arabic title and it is not hard to pronounce. Urdu speakers learn to pronounce the letter because otherwise they would change the Quran when reading it. Respect to all the pious brothers around the world

[@nazmulhossain6913]

Please change the spelling of the caption as Fadhail A'mal.

[@ehsaankhan7078]

Allah protect us from this fitnah, so many things wrong with this video, yes it is best to pronounce it correctly, but it was originally written(now translated to many languages Alhamdulillah) in urdu with and urdu title and Faza'il is how it is pronounced in Urdu, Gujrati, Punjabi, Hindi and Bengali. Languages spoken by millions of muslims, a large part of the ummah. When a 'Mufti'(not even one, Allah knows best) answers questions about matters, it is his duty to know enough about it and answer accordingly or else it can be grave dhulm period.

[@Warzone-eh3vw]

Quran and Sunnah was revealed in Arabic thus we stick with the 12 qarai recitation revealed by Gabriel and the Tongue of the Qaryash. Thus which is why most of the Urdu book arnt accepted by the Ulamah in the mainland of Hijaz (Mecca and Madinah), every other translation will have lots of errors which is why the Deen is in Arabic. Not Urdu, english, russian, Turkish etc.

[@azizdippty5999]

@@Warzone-eh3vw well said

[@Kihalchal786]

@@Warzone-eh3vw ilm is not concentrated in hijaz Was imam bukhari, ibn taymiyah, mujdidul alfesaani ahmed sirhindi etc from hijaz It's zaad not daad bring your proof if you are truthfull

[@knowledgerefreshed9876]

This has hadith mawdoo in it. Such that were not mentioned in the hadith collections and without an isnad. Narrating mawdoo hadith is not allowed this was reported as ijma by some ahlul ilm. من حدث عني بحديث يرى أنه كذب فهو أحد الكاذبين و الله أعلم

[@umarsyed7538]

That was a generic answer. Not specific to the question asked. Doesn't look like the mufti knows much about the book which is used as a handbook of Islam by the Tablighi jamat.

[@ibraheem128]

Only by non arabs

[@ibraheem128]

The arabs use riyad us saliheen

[@moussamohammad5073]

ibraheem adam I am not arab and I use Riyaadhu Saalihin because it is more correct and authentic and has sources of the ahaadith written in it and does not have fabricated stories like the book used by tabligh and other people of desires

[@ehsaankhan7078]

@@moussamohammad5073 brother you have little idea about it, Allah guide you and us all

[@braintree7502]

He isn't even a mufti

[@muhammadobaidullahhashmi4334]

Real name is fazail e amaal not fadaail amaal...the book written in Urdu and there is no word like fadaail in Urdu..

[@TheKhanthall]

8.39 you just proved the point of taqleed of scholars...good on ya mufti

[@telepost2250]

It only lasts 8:38 ! Anyway are you a hanafi scholar? If yes,you are most fond of taqleed without knowing what taqleed is.

[@azadajk7128]

Muhammad thall Haha - you guys clutch at straws. Taqleed is fine for a lay person up to the point of your capability. Blind taqleed of one man or small group of men is not permissible. There is a clear distinction between the two. And obedience is only for Allah azzawajal and our beloved Rasool Muhammad Salallahu alayhi wassalam. May Allah guide us all. Ameen.

[@muhammadmafaz8530]

We have to understand in order to understand value of amals we can use false hadith. Mostly saheeh hadith used to Islamic rulings.

[@Wassalaam92]

Muhammad Mafaz wrong. False hadiths are lies. You may use WEAK hadiths if they are not severely weak.

[@abdulmominbhati2977]

That book has Mawdu' Ahadith which are fabrications, lies , Batil That cannot be used in Any matter Daif Hadith can be used, but not for Ahkam

[@learnenglishnow6475]

Fadhail Amal (reward for actions) is not a book it is a principle in which Daeef (week) hadith are acceptable and there is ijmah on this. Why dont you mention that Kitab u Tawheed has Pretend hadith in it and tawheed means 1 but was changed into 3 and did not use Quran and didnt even use weak hadith didnt even use hadith... we class these hadith as "pretend"

[@faraazsiddiqui1930]

Fazail e Amal doesn’t doesn’t had only Daif hadith it has maudu (fabrications).

[@abdulmominbhati2977]

What about the 'Maudū' ' Ahadīth It has many fabrications against the prophet But Urdu/English don't mention that this Hadith is Batil Or Mawdu' Only the Arabic mentions I can give proof too

[@i.canalista7718]

Fazail amaal was also written by pedofiles who has sexual desires for children and there's soo much shirk it's not acceptable

[@nadimbaksh5988]

Salaam brothers and sisters to learn more about tawheed and your belief in islam they are some good aqeeda course for free by Abu ibraheem hussnayn and Abu mussab wajdi.Please learn your deen jazakallah

[@CheMatTokJanggut]

...so lack of adaab...

[@user-gy9sm3ob6r]

Bad adab is a sign of superficial knowledge

[@amth3400]

U ur self claim to be student of hadees so know about the author of the fazail e amal shaik Zakariya ra he buried in jannatul baqi and he's works in Arabic especially commentary on muwatta imam Malik named awjuz ul masailk

[@azarulahmed789]

Answer the question please

[@zedmelor8842]

he did

[@Watchman-vv5xx]

What lack of knowledge. The book "Faza'il A'maal" was written originally in the Urdu language, although the author Shaykh ul Hadith Muhammad Zakariya also authored volumes in Arabic as was his commentary on the Muwatta of Imam Malik known as Awjaz Al Masaalik ila Muwatta Imam Malik. Urdu as in the case of Farsi have the letter ض pronounced as "Z". So a man who changes his name to include the word Mufti in it is wasting everyone's time commenting on a book on Hadith written in Urdu with the correct pronunciation but accusing it of being mispronounced

[@Alex-bd4ov]

I didn't like this answer. Would you advise people to read the book? It seems you dont want to offend the JaamaitulTabligh. I hope you dont take into a Mufi Menk. BarakaAllah feekum.

[@muhammadmafaz8530]

We have to understand in order to understand value of amals we can use false hadith. Mostly saheeh hadith used to Islamic rulings.

[@osmanjibril8940]

akhi he is misguided, he said in the end the book has good in it and other than good in it, he couldnt say it clear shirk, fabricated ahaadeeth, and innovations as some scholars expained and warned against the book. first of all the author is a suufi deobandi. secondly this is the type of book which has 90 per cent mistakes so no point reading it. thridly theres difference when theres honest mistakes in a book like riyaad assaliheen and other books and when the author is promoting going to graves and seeking blressings with fabricated stories and hadeeths. this guy like mufti menk he dont want to offend misguided groups because he beleieves in the golden principle we cooperate in our agree upon and we excuse each other in what we disagree upon.

[@mussakhalifah1233]

@@osmanjibril8940 May peace be upon you Br. Osman. What exactly do you know about Fadhwayl a'amal...? Can you point out where the author insisted worshipping graves(shirk)...?

[@h.ch37]

@@mussakhalifah1233 kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHXMmqWcnpifoas

[@rabbi619]

@@osmanjibril8940 Yes the false golden principal many students of medina follow which is wrong.

[@mohislam3041]

TABLIGI jamaat does not follow the ORIGINAL ISLAM

[@nazeerpasha2075]

It is a Sufi revivalist movement.

[@walikhankakar313]

Original islam😂😂

[@MrSkittlesVEVO]

If you're going to go on for 2 minutes on how people can't pronounce the name (though the name in Urdu is actually pronounced the way you deemed incorrect), learn to say the name Allah correctly, there is a shaddah on the laam you miss when saying the word. You pronounce it as "Alaah" instead of Allah. Please be humble and speak out of that humility.

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

should of called out its shirk, mawdoo and fabricated hadith man.

[@naszbruhh8787]

They belive allah is in everything , thats like Christians believing God can inhabit humans or what Greeks thought God possed body of men had sex with woman and bred superhero demi god like Hercules. What they fai to mention demi god Demon God ... sounds like shiteen thing to do . In retro spect we are a speck of dust ✨ in cosmos which are even smaller before the mighty throne of allah .

[@thundafundamentalist]

He can't. He is a man of tamyee' (Blame worthy softness towards ahl ul bid'ah and their leaders/works)

[@diaz6636]

Naszbruhh no bruh😂 💯

[@diaz6636]

@HA A kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZWUZ3amjNVgpc0

[@mussakhalifah1233]

@@naszbruhh8787 May peace be upon you. Dear relative in Islam, do you have strong evidence to support this...?

[@rabbi619]

I dont like his manners how can you say that it is not your duty to know what is sahih or not no you cant say this and compare this with doctors even doctors are wrong many times and yes many people who are not doctors do correct the doctors mistake so yes even if you make a mistake we have the ability to correct it we are not illiterate we know hadith and quran so we can distinguish what is right and what is wrong you should not show arrogance.

[@Gog3453]

Who authorized this Wahhabi to give commentary on such great works

[@shah144]

shhhh He is qualified enough

[@Gog3453]

@@shah144 and you still ain’t telling me anything

[@Gog3453]

@@shah144 what school of Islamic jurisprudence does he adhere to for starters

[@Gog3453]

@@shah144 I’ll wait

[@shah144]

@@Gog3453 My man chillax take a chill pill, the book he is talking about is not even that great. It includes fabricated hadeeths. I'm assuming this sheik follows the authentic hadeeth and the Quran maybe salafi or hanbali

[@chillachilla1349]

I love fadail Amal my fav book I don’t care what u think of it

[@rabbi619]

please dont read that book it is filled with shirk and bidah.

[@abdulmominbhati2977]

No one cares about a person who is as ignorant like u

[@shahzadibnarshadahamed9726]

Mufti is not giving a straight answer. Beating around the bush.

[@mohamedmuienudeen8992]

True

[@Fedayeen77]

This is typical problem with the indo/pak people who butcher the Arabic language -

[@abdulhakim9537]

It’s not fazail e Amaal, is the title of the work in Urdu, Urdu is a combination of a few languages like Arabic, Farsi, Hindi, so in actual fact the pronunciation of the title is correct in Urdu, which is the language which most of its audience speak and read in and which was the language it was originally written in, but it is not correct in Arabic as that is not the language it was written in, it was later translated into Arabic

[@SASZA.101]

Stick to Rapping. 1 year Mufti..

[@radiokniferagunan3754]

This guy doesnt know the kaedah of mudharat

[@bilalsiddiqui2177]

This guy doesn't know what he is talking about 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@azadajk7128]

Bilal Siddiqui What did he say that was so wrong?

[@karimshah8535]

Maybe he should start speaking in urdu.

[@umarsyed7538]

@@azadajk7128 he didn't say anything wrong. He just didn't answer the question.

[@ehsaankhan7078]

@@THINKISLAM252 mate its full of ahadeeth from Rasulullah(S), yes we believe in those, Subhaan Allah

[@braintree7502]

@@ehsaankhan7078 fabricated hadith are not counted as hadith

[@PLEASE-CHECK-MY-PLAYLISTS]

What rubbish