The Cost of Wood Walls vs Drywall - $$$

[@JB43186]

I’ve enjoyed watching you remodel 4 homes. Thanks for your hard work, creativity, and humor!

[@thecoz5700]

Yes they're getting so much better at there skills .. I'm so happy and proud of both of them..

[@MoYvStarkey]

You live in a humid climate. Wood will breathe better and not absorb moisture like the dry was. You made a good choice over all. Oh, right...its your house and you make it the way you want. Dont let the goobers get to you.

[@user70331]

Wood not absorbs moisture?? 😅that's incredible

[@vahneb7260]

There is no comparison to the beauty and warmth the tongue and groove that you are custom making for your home. Sometimes the cost is secondary to the outcome you are going for in the end. Be blessed

[@crinkle2649]

Ashley said she didn't want to deal with drywall anymore, so you made the right choice.

[@marystrenke3050]

Yes!!! I was designated mud and taper when we built our house. I worked nights--- lived in my mud caked jammies! It's all a blur--- just kept at it until it was done ❤️

[@bestlifeblessed]

I found your channel while y’all where in Indiana. I live in Indiana and searched for mobile home renovation and there your channel appeared. What really hooked me in was the Michigan Property. The work there was so suspenseful and moved along quickly. I couldn’t wait for the next video.

[@bestlifeblessed]

To be honest with ya tho…if it was my house I would of took it down to the studs throughout…saving all the boards and wood. Then running all the wiring and plumbing. Insulating and sealing everything. Then went back with drywall and trimmed everything out with the saved wood. I know working with drywall seams it’s a pain but, if I couldn’t of got it. I would of textured the drywall…then trimmed it all out. Then used the left over wood for creative ideas. Such as shelves, etc.

[@jacquicoder7160]

You know, I don't have any strong opinions about dry wall vs wood but even if I did, it doesn't matter. This is your house, your design preference, and your money, none of my business. But I do appreciate your willingness to go to the trouble of explaining the cost differences for those who want to know. And I do love the tongue and groove look of your walls, they are beautiful.

[@lanaperry9400]

It makes me happy seeing you have what you desire and to be in a warm climate! Good job guys!

[@leslietaylor1570]

My mom’s walls are true 1” thick tongue and groove and I love that you can hang anything on them and not have to worry about finding a stud! I’m sure back when these houses were built lumber was a lot cheaper than now but makes them a lot sturdier in my opinion! Love the way your renovations are coming out!

[@connierifenburg9758]

You did a very good comparison of wood vs drywall. I totally agree with all your reasons to use wood. I love the fact that you are not “restoring” an old home, but “rebuilding” an old home. You are bringing in your vision while keeping the idea of an old Florida “cracker” home. That deep mahogany colored wood already in the home is really beautiful and I’m glad you are mixing visually pleasing lighter colors that are still appropriate to the era of the home. Keep up the good work as usual.

[@Cam-wi3tp]

You both have come a long way since I started watching you in Indiana. Glad to see you are in a position where you can make more of what you like as opposed to what you can afford. Lot of respect to you for such a great work ethic and I wish you continued success

[@robertbuckley9303]

Thanks for your honest analysis. This fits my own thinking about tools and materials - don't skimp on quality, buy what you're going to love living with, and take the hit on cost if you possibly can. Your instincts are good. Go with them.

[@Zombie-adventures]

I know whatever you use, it will be beautiful. The house must be saying “Ahhhhhh!” Making it an awesome place to live; I love all the things you’ve done so far. Especially the glass doorknobs. My grandmothers house had those and it was so cool seeing you use them! Best wishes to you and the family. Darla

[@carolyncarlson3825]

My 4th house watching you ...has led me to know you are doing your best...what you what and you do incredible work...hugs

[@JoJoDragonslayer]

I just love how you two do things different each property and go with the flow whatever the issues that may arise, all the while teaching as you go. Thank you 😊

[@ruthannwatkins3914]

I love all your postings , I live in Canada and up here codes would not stand for just wood , fire ratings provide for drywall first , then you could lay your tongue and groove over so you guys are lucky there .Keep up the good work , I look forward to your stuff each week . Cannot wait to see more .

[@Azoreanislandgirl64]

When you want good product and you can do it yourself. It's all about preference. I kept my paneling up , I just preped it and muded the joints and sealed it. When from dark to light and dark mahogany flooring. It looks great to me.

[@jkbeattyable]

You said you wanted to finish the walls in keeping with the rest of your home ages ago. Personally I think it's coming along beautifully. Thank you for sharing ❤❤❤❤

[@JWimpy]

You get what you pay for. You are getting a far superior quality home with all wood. I absolutely love what you are doing with the house. It's turning out beautifully.

[@sheilavanduynfote5539]

Thank you for sharing the cost of wood for your project vs drywall. I love the wood tung and groove walls👏🏻👏🏻❤️❤️❤️

[@artysciencegal2521]

Since the wood is thicker, I bet it will provide better sound insulation which is an added benefit. It will be a dream for putting up artwork, cat shelves, etc. Looks really interesting and unique too.

[@laurahobbs5702]

Of course the cost is relevant. Budget often dictates over choice. But you only do this once so go for what you like as you have to live with it. I love what you have done so far. Well done and thanks for sharing. X

[@carriebishop8838]

Let's remember peace of mind is priceless. There's no real cost comparison when you have it done your way, to your taste. Everything is worth the cost when it all comes out the way you envision it.

[@pattycarosi9618]

Doug nice that you explained all this. I love the wood. Look forward to the next project you share. Have a great week.

[@hollyhasegawa6095]

Hi Doug, I feel like the wood looks so much better than drywall would, and I understand the cost of wood verses drywall, and so awesome that you created the tongue and groove, I feel like you are doing such an amazing job with your walls. Thanks for a great video and I hope that your week coming up is a good one and I will be excited to see you next video, take care sending love and hugs, bye for now. 😂😉🤗💜

[@brendahaire8824]

Yes, it is a little more expensive but, you are building the house that you want. Plus, drywall is so messy and time consuming and if you aren’t an expert drywall hanger, yo really have a harder time taping and mudding and finishing smooth.

[@brens7094]

I watch a lot of home improvement videos. Yours is my favorite!

[@diyfferent]

That's awesome, thanks!

[@cherylemaybury9967]

I didn’t realise how expensive it is to do the wood walls but they are much prettier and suit your house better. You need to live with your choices so always do what makes you happy.

[@ram_1776]

I like the look. Cost is no concern when your going for a specific look. Waiting to see the trim.

[@gondolin12]

I live in a humid part of europe and all the 200 years old houses actually mostly wooden because in humid areas wood works much better as it adats to the environment.

[@kenwalker5046]

Labour cost differences are hugely favorable to T&G. With drywall you have the labour to install, mud, sand, prime and paint. With wood you nail and you are done. For a DIYer the time can be a significant difference. Plus the finished product is easier to guarantee for an amateur with wood. Proper drywall and mudding is a big skill to get it uniform and flawless. Same with painting.

[@valeriejohnson1775]

Those wood walls are so much better than drywall. I am glad yall are able to keep with the house's history.

[@jimdelong949]

Hi Doug Thanks for the comparison. Why do people not get that this is your house. You're going to be living there. So it should be the way you want it. If cost isn't a factor for you, it shouldn't be for us I like that your trying to keep with the original character of the house. I would have too I say, on with the Doug & Ashley house renovation I for one will be here to see whatever you do. Wishing you the best Stay strong and safe

[@KenJ-61]

Fill up a bath tub with water. Dip the wood in water for 10 seconds then dip drywall in water for 10 seconds then let both dry. Which one held up better? Wood is a much better value in the long run.

[@erika_is_growing]

I appreciate your choice of wood over drywall: the texture, the finishes you've chosen...just beautiful and in line with the age of your home! And, I super love the door hardware 😍!

[@PegAMurphy]

I love wooden everything...walls, floors and ceilings 💖 I grew up in old houses and they all had tongue and grove and lasted over 100 yrs 💖 I know you made the right choice for your home it's beautiful ❤️💕❤️

[@Lynn4410]

You made a great choice. So much character instead of cookie cutter.

[@iamwhoiamd7056]

Excellent explanation Doug.

[@kathybond4202]

South LA native, when I was younger we had wood walls. Wood is much easier to keep clean. We dusted all the wall in fall and in spring we washed them. That’s it.

[@Abc-1973]

🦋You and Ashley are making a beautiful home together for your family. Im really enjoying following along on this journey with you all.

[@carolannbolinger3795]

That you for telling us the difference between the two. I enjoyed this.

[@Jessicablooming]

The wood looks so much better. You guys are doing a lovely job!

[@lynnpetre525]

I'm with Ashley, I don't like drywall. No caricature. You are going to the trouble to match the tongue and groove of the rest of the house. Very cool. Not cheep and it doesn't look cheep. The details show & shine. Thanks for sharing. LP

[@bevrawilliams4351]

I absolutely see why you are doing it . It goes with the Era of the home .and it's so classy, beautifully, pleasingly to the eye. You guys have done such a great job. You all be proud.

[@kathysultzbaugh3858]

Hi DIYfferent family! This is a good video! 👍. I love your channel, your renovations, your choices for YOUR home and your family. It amazes me how people come here to disagree with you. It's your house, your choice and your money! It doesn't matter honestly if they don't like it or agree, they don't have to live with it! Keep moving forward! Thank you for sharing your channel with us! You are doing a fantastic job!

[@pamelas9]

For the cost savings I’d be very tempted to switch to the premade t&g for the walls in the bedroom. The addition already has a few little differences, so it wouldn’t be a crazy switch up.

[@kth260]

Agreed. I really hope so.

[@bigredd1574]

Seems like a reasonable decision of choosing to extend wood to other rooms from the rooms that already had it.

[@Ladythyme]

You explained it well. Definitely a preference AND affordability choice.

[@phildodd5532]

Good information, Doug ! Thanks.

[@scotto40]

Actually, the wood makes the house structure much stronger. Doug and Ashley, I really enjoy your channel and the great work you are doing.

[@karlab9557]

Yes. I knew it was more $$. And the cost of wood these days is so much more than just a couple years ago. That's just crazy. Anyway, your work is beautiful, and it's just one part of the house, as the rest of the house already has the wood. And well, it's your house. I'm enjoying the process.

[@joniwarren3100]

It’s so worth it. I absolutely hate drywall. Plus your house is going to look gorgeous!..❤

[@stephanieb531]

Love what you guys are doing. It's a lot of work and coming along beautifully.

[@doyeworrell1680]

I’m loving the wood choice, it’s going to match with the style of the house. Sometimes being cheap is not the right decision, just pay the extra to begin with and you will be happier in the long run.

[@laurabongard2682]

I actually hate drywall and plaster walls. When ever you try to hang things on them, it seems like you always have to figure out what you need to do to hang those items. I had steel mesh underneath the plaster walls in my home. It was almost impossible to hang anything because there weren't any wood beems. It was easy to crack the wall when trying to put a nail up to hang a picture. Now I have a manufactured home and have drywall with seams. I suppose I could put beadboard walls up, but I do not plan on thta much of an expense in a home I don't want to continue living at anyway. Ideally, winning the lottery and building a new home to my specifications might work out the best for me. I am buying one lottery ticket a week ($2.00), so at least winning is a possibility, though a small possibility, lol! At least it's fun imagining what I would do with the winnings.

[@chrisworster4878]

I think wood ages well over drywall. I know in some areas drywall is sometimes required for fire resistance. My dad and I tore down 2 old 1850s houses and salvaged the lumber and sheathing from it. We have sold a lot of the wide 12-20 inch boards to someone who is remodeling their house, after it is planed and stained, it looks beautiful.

[@Osvaldium]

i think just comparing the cost without seeing the added potential for wood is kinda misleading. Usually with drywall you need extra tools to atleast put the boards in the ceiling, you spend money to finish the seams, and god forbid you try to hang anything heavier than a paper on drywall. Another added bonus is that wood is a warm material, and even acts a little as insulation.

[@Hollybank5]

You did your cost analysis and chose what works for your home design preferences. And - it looks beautiful ❤️😘

[@F-J.]

I would have gone with dry wall and done panelling. I'm shocked at the price difference. Thank you for the comparison.

[@brock8128]

Maybe you mentioned it and I missed it, but your time and labor is worth a boatload of money as well. I've said it before and I'll say it again, you are not afraid of a challenge or not doing things the easiest way. Not sure what that means, but hey...lol... I have been a long time follower and you guys are always entertaining and intriguing, take care, stay hydrated and rock on!!!👍

[@AndHence]

It would be interesting to include a contractor's labor in the cost comparison.

[@audreykavanaugh8589]

I love your choice of making the house's finishes more true to its original style. I think it's going to be great!

[@tjack9645]

Love your choice for wood over dry wall!

[@hammathguy3995]

The other cost to consider is time. I'm sure you could have had drywall up, mudded, and painted in a week. As they say, "Quality takes time". Who ever "they" are. So, take the time to do it the way that makes you happy.

[@cathybrewer8958]

The cost compared to what you want in a look, to me is a no brainer. You could have put used newspaper on the walls as a cover, but it isn''t the look you want. So I say, if you can afford a one time cost, go for it! It does look really good. A lot of work, but worth it in the end. Thanks for sharing.

[@barbaratankersley7117]

This is the thing You guys did what you wanted and its going to be beautiful and jus what you guys want GOD bless and stay safe

[@karensteele8147]

You are doing a beautiful job I am so enjoying watching you and your family projects. Thanks for sharing and explaining what you do. 🙂

[@tj_gsomething_]

The insulation (R-Value) is better with tongue and groove than drywall. So your cost is also saving on insulation.

[@shariprice4343]

Your videos are always interesting! Thank you for the info and keep up the beautiful work that you are both doing! Love seeing the house coming along step by step. I have learned so much from you. ❤

[@revjamescollins]

Hey! It's your time, your money and your home. Do it the way you guys want to do it. The place is looking wonderful.

[@ej115]

Thanks for this break down. I am glad you are happy with your wood choice--it looks beautiful!😀😍

[@justjan147]

Very informative! Thanks Doug. 😊

[@charlenefalk8479]

Dry Wall mold quicker in Florida. I love your walls. Plus you love the wood, and it's your house. Your doing such a great job.

[@Pisti846]

I doubt you could buy tongue and groove as nice as you make it even if it is cheaper. You do quality work.

[@mkel858]

The other thing is drywall is such a pain to put up and when you hire someone that cost goes up dramatically, my grandson has been trying to put up drywall and he hates it not the actual putting it up the mudding is what he hates, he says trying to smooth it out it seems it never gets smooth enough lol! Your houses is looking nice I love the wood!

[@Starrmiller]

Hey Doug! IMO the wood tongue & groove lQQks amazing! I'm with Ash "no more drywall" lol Your knowledge & tools alone makes for a Beautiful home!

[@pitsnipe5559]

It’s y’all’s home. How you feel about living in it outweighs cost. Just wondering, if you had someplace local where you could buy rough lumber, then mill it yourself with a joiner and surface planer, would that lower the cost? One big advantage would be consistent thickness of finished boards.

[@deannaoverstreet4146]

I love the wood! What your doing is beautiful!

[@picketfence2028]

Wood is beautiful, and it smells beautiful. Wood all day long if it's in your budget. I remember my uncles cabin up in the woods by a lovely river, all knotty pine. Between the smell of the pine and the woods with that running river, the place was magical I think y'all are making some magic there. ;)

[@lechatbotte.]

Drywall to finish needs mud and tape. People need to remember that, plus the cost of screws and the time it takes. Yes the wood is more expensive but they’re different products. Have to include the total on the drywall because it’s not finished just hanging it. Your wood is done when you hang it. Add in the price of someone doing the drywall professionally it isn’t cheap. The wood will out live drywall. Quality vs quantity.

[@pcno2832]

But cutting that much wood, which, unlike drywall, has to fit perfectly, is a LOT of work, not to mention milling the tongue and grove edges. I've put in a few wood floors and I'd much rather install the same amount of drywall.

[@bowlmeoverva]

Didn't think the difference was of that magnitude. Thanks for sharing!

[@glennmcgee1729]

Thanks Doug, as being one of the previous cost inquisitors, my curiosity is quenched.

[@robertamonroe3041]

I’d rather patch and sand wood than dry wall after relocating decor, etc. Easier and a better finished product every time!!

[@lindaroyal8161]

Great explanation. And....it matches the wood in the rest of the house and that was your original intention, to have it all match. I like the wood walls, seems so much more practical for every day living, scuffs less, more durable, so many good reason. I would think it would be more energy efficient and certainly more quiet, and looks very nice. The cost is up front and it's what you want, so why not!

[@LisaMarie51968]

I would have chosen wood too, just makes sense. Your home is going to be so beautiful when done, just like the others you remodelled!

[@susanmyers6375]

It's your house, your choice. I think it's great. Reminds me of my formative years visiting some very old houses of friends and relatives. Great job ! 👌

[@warrendelay]

Not to mention the cost of wood trim for corners and wall to ceiling angles. and then when it comes to resale of the property, to sale an all-clapboard interior finish, it will appeal to a VERY small percentage of buyers.

[@denisewilson8367]

You are not trying to design & decorate on the cheap. You are going for a certain look/style. It doesn't matter the price, it's your wallet & your home. And it's looking great.

[@curtainsup9]

the character the wood brings to the home is worth paying 10 times for ( and the labor ) if you can do it...and you are. It does take more patience because of the processing time. I wold love to have a home with all wood walls.

[@tyrehester5550]

Thanks for answering this question. I knew it was significant, but 10X is a lot. Keeping the walls the same throughout does add some appeal and value though. IMHO you made the right decision. 🙂

[@deloresochoa6235]

When you want a certain look/style, you do what needs to be done to achieve it. It's always worth doing. Seeing your work day in and out, it better be what you like and wanted. Keep up the excellent work it looks awesome. I will be doing this on one great wall in my studio. NO MORE YUKY drywall, lol. We enjoy watching your videos a lot. GOD bless you all .

[@liisaking1247]

Great video on a topic I've actually been searching recently. I'd like to add a bit to what you said. Yes, wood costs more initially than drywall, and custom wood (the way you're doing it specifically) costs more than stock T & G from a big box store. However, there are places that specifically mill several types of shiplap or T & G out of solid wood and their price may be better than doing it yourself. That might be another option, depending on where people live. Also, many blogs and articles point out that the cost of the major material isn't the whole story. With drywall, in addition to the cost of screws, tape, mud, and the like, you have to factor in the cost of labour. If you can tape and mud drywall yourself and have it look professional, more power to you. Many, many people cannot. If you pay to have drywall installed but DIY installing T & G (which is simpler), the drywall may well be more expensive at the end of the day. Drywall is also heavy and comes in large, inflexible sheets. I am looking at using either shiplap or T & G (solid wood, not MDF) to rebuild the interior of an addition to my rural home that had to be gutted after major water damage this year. As a widow, driving a smaller vehicle, and with a limited budget, I can buy smaller amounts at a time and put them up by myself. I would need to hire someone to do drywall for me. Drywall would cost more all at once, while wood could be stretched out over time. It just seems to make a lot of sense, although I may end up doing a limited amount of drywalling as well, for the esthetic (not sure I really want shiplap or T & G on my bedroom ceiling, for example). My questions about what you're doing would be: 1. How much did the additional equipment you had to buy cost (and will it be useful for anything else or is it task-specific)? 2. How long does it take you to prepare the boards before you can install them? I always enjoy your videos!

[@diyfferent]

If you buy it premade, you would really only need a saw, measuring tape, and a finish nailer. A hammer and nail punch are handy to set the nails that don't go in all the way. It's pretty basic stuff that you can use for all sorts of projects. We went a little overkill and bought two router tables and routers, plus the roller stands to support the boards as they come off the router table. The price will vary on those depending on what you want to buy. It doesn't take long to prepare the boards. Could be done in two days. Routering, staining, and sealing them is quick. If you are painting them you wouldn't need to sand them between coats of paint like we have to between clear coats.

[@vickie9633]

It’s your choice - I have lots of art that I love to hang so I would have done drywall top half wood on bottom on LR and BR’s…and I always think of resell value! You do you..

[@josephyoung451]

When I built my house drywall was 2-4x8 boards for 5.00 . Times have changed

[@doncc6080]

I have been thinking along this line that it must be somewhere around 10 times more with the cost of wood today. Once bedroom is done you may only have a few repairs in the other rooms. You have the hardest part done the ceiling peak.

[@paulgeluso5793]

Thank you. I figured the cost for you to do the wood was going to be way more. I love the tongue and groove.

[@casid9929]

Not sure, but think the 5 inch T&G boards are one half the thickness of the ones you are making.

[@Mari-B]

Your choice of woof is way more character than drywall! It reminds me of my childhood home and my grandparents home. 🙂❤️

[@lindacarruthers3423]

I love your house . No cookie cutter there , we’ll crafted unique and beautiful .

[@missykowalewski]

A true commitment to ur design style. That’s a design must. I know when we were having r house built I had to accept changes that I didn’t like. It sucked and the end product wasn’t as nice as my original design. Even if u have to take ur time and buy stuff in intervals it’s worth it. U did a great job explaining the cost. Hi Ashley. I know ur in touch with the comments and I don’t want to leave u out.

[@rexterrier1]

I think wood walls would be healthier. People are too opinionated & negative! And that is not healthy. I like what you are doing!!