The Dark History of the Kibbutz | How "Socialist" Zionists colonized Palestine

Support the Channel on Patreon:
/ besdmarx
Feedback and Questions on my Twitter:
/ besdmarx
Sources (to be updated soon):
- A History of Modern Palestine One Land, Two Peoples (2006) - Ilan Pappe
- Colonizing Palestine: The Zionist Left and the Making of the Palestinian Nakba, by Areej Sabbagh-Khoury, 2023
- Crisis, Revolution, and Russian Jews (2009) - Jonathan Frankel
- Decolonizing Israel, Liberating Palestine Zionism, Settler Colonialism, and the Case for One Democratic State (2021) - Jeff Halper
- Expulsion of the Palestinians - The Concept of Transfer in Zionist Political Thought, 1882-1948 (Nur Masalha), 1992
- Israel and South Africa the many faces of Apartheid (Pappe, Ilan)
- Land, Labor and the Origins of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, 1882-1914 (1996) - Gershon Shafir
- Might over Right How the Zionists Took over Palestine (Adel Safty)
- Rethinking Israel and Palestine Marxist Perspectives (Oded Nir (editor), Joel Wainwright (editor))
- Righteous Victims A History of the Zionist-Arab Conflict, 1881-2001 (Benny Morris)
- Ten Myths About Israel (Ilan Pappe)
- The Class Origins of Zionist Ideology (Stephen Halbrook)
- The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (2007) - Ilan Pappé
- The Gaza Strip The Political Economy of De-development (Sara Roy)
- The Hundred Years War on Palestine (Rashid Khalidi)
- The Idea Of Israel A History Of Power And Knowledge (Ilan Pappe)
- The Invention of the Land of Israel From Holy Land to Homeland (Sand, Shlomo)
- The Myths of Zionism (John Rose)
- Zionism and the Arabs, 1882-1948 A Study of Ideology (Yosef Gorny)
- Zionist Colonialism in Palestine (1965) - Fayez Sayegh
- Zionism a very short introduction (Michael Stanislawski)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This video is for educational purposes. If you have any copyright issues, send me an e-mail ([e-mail]) and I will remove this video right away or we will find another solution.

[@passion27x]

Real socialist should be against colonialism, ethnicism nationalism.

[@zubal6121]

Real socialism stands for the unification of the people under the construct of the state! /s

[@stormstriker2000]

why, what does that have to do with economy, truth, is, if socialist had choosen ethno nationalism, then by 1970s, all capitalism would have been destoryed,

[@lorenckotini]

socialist are liars

[@lorenckotini]

socialist are liars

[@karate4348]

Absolutely. It's same in Australia.. Capitalism on colonization-mad cruelty and loss of wisdom about the land, life and culture in balance with all of life, land, waters, skies here. Utter mad cruelty generated by child abuse.

[@nadilene789]

All these cheerful little settler colonies built on top of the Palestinian villages that the majority of Gazans originally came from…it’s beyond sick.

[@RiseofTaitoShirei]

Get over it.

[@nk-gp1ml]

@@RiseofTaitoShireiyou are a perfect expression of arrogance, shamelessness, inhumanity and deceit.

[@SpoopySquid]

​@@RiseofTaitoShireino

[@victormeidan1062]

Who cares ? Arabs did horrible things too

[@ChitChatLLMs]

why@@RiseofTaitoShirei

[@HaziqHusaini-kn8cf]

"Israel is not a state, it a project. A settler colonial one." - Prof. Ilan Pappe

[@stinkeye460]

Most professors are full of shite.

[@vanessazlatic7849]

@@stinkeye460 Not this one!

[@justice4549]

@@stinkeye460”anyone who says something I disagree with is full of shit! Especially people who’re educated on topics while everything I know is just shit I made up or read online and now fervently believe!”

[@stinkeye460]

@@justice4549 Israel has been the Land of the people or Israel for 3,500 years. Even after it was conquered by its enemies through out history a remnant remained or came back. If the Arabs had chosen to accept Israel instead of supporting the IsraeIsrael

[@stinkeye460]

There Was Never A Country Called Palestine If you consider Palestine to be a "Sovereign" and "Independent" country that goes back through most of recorded history as many would have you to believe, then a few questions need to be answered: When was it founded and by whom? What were its borders? What was its capital? Who was the President? What was its form of government? What were its major cities? What constituted the basis of its economy? Who was the Palestinian leader before Yasser Arafat? Was Palestine ever recognized by a country whose existence, at that time or now, leaves no room for interpretation? What was the language of the country of Palestine? What was the prevalent religion of the country of Palestine? What was the name of its currency and what was the approximate exchange rate of the Palestinian monetary unit against the US dollar, German mark, GB pound, or Japanese yen on any particular date? And, finally, since there is no such country today, what caused its demise and when did it occur? If these so-called "Palestinians" are anything but a generic collection of Arabs from all over the rest of the Arab world and if they really have a genuine ethnic identity that gives them right for self-determination, then why did they never try to become an independent and sovereign nation until Arabs suffered their devastating defeat in the Six Day War in 1967? A Few Forgotten Facts 1. Israel became a nation in 1312 BCE, two thousand years before the rise of Islam. 2. Arab refugees in Israel began identifying themselves as part of a Palestinian people in 1967, two decades after the establishment of the modern State of Israel. 3. Since the Jewish conquest in 1272 BCE, the Jews have had dominion over the land for one thousand years with a continuous presence in the land for the past 3,300 years. 4. The only Arab dominion since the conquest in 635 CE lasted no more than 22 years. 5. For over 3,300 years, Jerusalem has been the Jewish capital Jerusalem has never been the capital of any Arab or Muslim entity. Even when the Jordanians occupied Jerusalem, they never sought to make it their capital, and Arab leaders did not come to visit. 6. Jerusalem is mentioned over 700 times in Tanach, the Jewish Holy Scriptures. Jerusalem is not mentioned once in the Koran. 7. King David founded the city of Jerusalem. Mohammad never came to Jerusalem. 8. Jews pray facing Jerusalem. Muslims pray with their backs toward Jerusalem. 9. In 1948 the Arab refugees were encouraged to leave Israel by Arab leaders promising to purge the land of Jews. Sixty-eight percent left without ever seeing an Israeli soldier. 10. The Jewish refugees were forced to flee from Arab lands due to Arab brutality, persecution, and slaughter. 11. The number of Arab refugees who left Israel in 1948 is estimated to be around 630,000. The number of Jewish refugees from Arab lands is estimated to be the same. 12. Arab refugees were intentionally not absorbed or integrated into the Arab lands to which they fled, despite the vast Arab territory. Out of the 100,000,000 refugees since World War II, theirs is the only refugee group in the world that has never been absorbed or integrated into their own people's lands. Jewish refugees were completely absorbed into Israel, a country no larger than the state of New Jersey. 13. The Arabs are represented by eight separate nations, not including the Palestinians. There is only one Jewish nation. The Arab nations initiated all five wars and lost. Israel defended itself each time and won. 14. The PLO's Charter still calls for the destruction of the State of Israel. Israel has given the Palestinians most of the West Bank land, autonomy under the Palestinian Authority, and has supplied them. 15. Under Jordanian rule, Jewish holy sites were desecrated and the Jews were denied access to places of worship. Under Israeli rule, all Muslim and Christian sites have been preserved and made accessible to people of all faiths. 16. The UN Record on Israel and the Arabs: of the 175 Security Council resolutions passed before 1990, 97 were directed against Israel. 17. Of the 690 General Assembly resolutions voted on before 1990, 429 were directed against Israel. 18. The UN was silent while 58 Jerusalem Synagogues were destroyed by the Jordanians. 19. The UN was silent while the Jordanians systematically desecrated the ancient Jewish cemetery on the Mount of Olives. 20. The UN was silent while the Jordanians enforced an apartheid-like a policy of preventing Jews from visiting the Temple Mount and the Western Wall.

[@chrisyim5692]

Free Palestine, end imperialism

[@bennelong8451]

Israel created a first world country while Muslims struggle to create

[@victormeidan1062]

Yes, free fakestine from illegal Arabic invaders.

[@victormeidan1062]

Free Palestine from 7th century settler colonists.

[@victormeidan1062]

Yes, free it from 7th century invaders.

[@chompythebeast]

@@victormeidan1062 Imagine arguing that a land needs to be freed from "7th century invaders" but somehow not 19th and 20th century invaders. Also the people of Palestine are indigenous and have been there since before David, but you know that, Hasbara bot

[@veronikalynn5084]

I’m really glad to see people going farther back than just 1948. There’s so much history ignored. For very good reason it seems, by those who benefit from it staying buried

[@stinkeye460]

There Was Never A Country Called Palestine If you consider Palestine to be a "Sovereign" and "Independent" country that goes back through most of recorded history as many would have you to believe, then a few questions need to be answered: When was it founded and by whom? What were its borders? What was its capital? Who was the President? What was its form of government? What were its major cities? What constituted the basis of its economy? Who was the Palestinian leader before Yasser Arafat? Was Palestine ever recognized by a country whose existence, at that time or now, leaves no room for interpretation? What was the language of the country of Palestine? What was the prevalent religion of the country of Palestine? What was the name of its currency and what was the approximate exchange rate of the Palestinian monetary unit against the US dollar, German mark, GB pound, or Japanese yen on any particular date? And, finally, since there is no such country today, what caused its demise and when did it occur? If these so-called "Palestinians" are anything but a generic collection of Arabs from all over the rest of the Arab world and if they really have a genuine ethnic identity that gives them right for self-determination, then why did they never try to become an independent and sovereign nation until Arabs suffered their devastating defeat in the Six Day War in 1967? A Few Forgotten Facts 1. Israel became a nation in 1312 BCE, two thousand years before the rise of Islam. 2. Arab refugees in Israel began identifying themselves as part of a Palestinian people in 1967, two decades after the establishment of the modern State of Israel. 3. Since the Jewish conquest in 1272 BCE, the Jews have had dominion over the land for one thousand years with a continuous presence in the land for the past 3,300 years. 4. The only Arab dominion since the conquest in 635 CE lasted no more than 22 years. 5. For over 3,300 years, Jerusalem has been the Jewish capital Jerusalem has never been the capital of any Arab or Muslim entity. Even when the Jordanians occupied Jerusalem, they never sought to make it their capital, and Arab leaders did not come to visit. 6. Jerusalem is mentioned over 700 times in Tanach, the Jewish Holy Scriptures. Jerusalem is not mentioned once in the Koran. 7. King David founded the city of Jerusalem. Mohammad never came to Jerusalem. 8. Jews pray facing Jerusalem. Muslims pray with their backs toward Jerusalem. 9. In 1948 the Arab refugees were encouraged to leave Israel by Arab leaders promising to purge the land of Jews. Sixty-eight percent left without ever seeing an Israeli soldier. 10. The Jewish refugees were forced to flee from Arab lands due to Arab brutality, persecution, and slaughter. 11. The number of Arab refugees who left Israel in 1948 is estimated to be around 630,000. The number of Jewish refugees from Arab lands is estimated to be the same. 12. Arab refugees were intentionally not absorbed or integrated into the Arab lands to which they fled, despite the vast Arab territory. Out of the 100,000,000 refugees since World War II, theirs is the only refugee group in the world that has never been absorbed or integrated into their own people's lands. Jewish refugees were completely absorbed into Israel, a country no larger than the state of New Jersey. 13. The Arabs are represented by eight separate nations, not including the Palestinians. There is only one Jewish nation. The Arab nations initiated all five wars and lost. Israel defended itself each time and won. 14. The PLO's Charter still calls for the destruction of the State of Israel. Israel has given the Palestinians most of the West Bank land, autonomy under the Palestinian Authority, and has supplied them. 15. Under Jordanian rule, Jewish holy sites were desecrated and the Jews were denied access to places of worship. Under Israeli rule, all Muslim and Christian sites have been preserved and made accessible to people of all faiths. 16. The UN Record on Israel and the Arabs: of the 175 Security Council resolutions passed before 1990, 97 were directed against Israel. 17. Of the 690 General Assembly resolutions voted on before 1990, 429 were directed against Israel. 18. The UN was silent while 58 Jerusalem Synagogues were destroyed by the Jordanians. 19. The UN was silent while the Jordanians systematically desecrated the ancient Jewish cemetery on the Mount of Olives. 20. The UN was silent while the Jordanians enforced an apartheid-like a policy of preventing Jews from visiting the Temple Mount and the Western Wall.

[@mannyperez4010]

​@stinkeye460 the idea that it's not a country so they don't matter its so backwards. Let's use native Americans for an example, they lived in the US before it was colonized. Does that mean that native American never had ownership of its land?

[@mannyperez4010]

​@@stinkeye460also the concept of " my great great great ancestors lived there thousands of years ago so it belongs to me" is so stupid.

[@samirahussein2005]

@@stinkeye460 i hate to break it to you but the fact that the palestinians have never had sovereignty over their own land and have been perpetually a colony of some foreign empire, only makes israel coming to further abuse them and disenfranchise them even MORE evil and villainous. who looks at a colonized people oppressed in their own land and says to themselves "hmm i see an opportunity here, i bet they'll go down easily and i can get their land!" its basically comic book villainy

[@stinkeye460]

@@samirahussein2005 The Jews took over this land over three thousand years ago and have lived there ever since. The Arabs invader this land when they came out of Arabia in the 7th Century CE. The ass holes could have had their state decades ago but choose to try to destroy Israel instead. Even the Koran says this land belongs to the Jews.

[@chompythebeast]

From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free 🇵🇸

[@hurbrowns5397]

Hello ChompyTheBeast. You used the forbidden phrase. On behalf of the German government, I am arresting you for calling for genocide against the Jewish people. We still feel guilty and have no concept of learning from past mistakes so 🤷🏻.

[@elli6220]

Palestinians have more rights in Israel than Arabs do in any other Arab country (and have an objectively better QOL than Arabs in any other non-petrostate). You want to make the lives of Palestinians worse?

[@Erinvllc]

The IDF is doing just that as we speak 🇮🇱 👌🏾

[@raanangeberer1903]

From the river to the sea, Israel will always be!

[@AppleCinnamonPie]

@@raanangeberer1903 No it won't darling. You are under a divinely-mandated exile. The land will throw you out as it did twice before, for your corruption and moral bankruptcy.

[@JuneBarbone]

So, depressing to learn all of this at my age. The United States Government, did an excellent job covering up the criminal activity by Israel.

[@bettymagpali5079]

Zionists and Nazis appear to be one and the same.

[@TJ-Judge]

Apparently some early Zionists collaborated with nazis... and they said that it was good for Zionism because it would drive more Jews to settle in Palestine.

[@socialdarwinism3056]

Jihadis are far worse

[@JuneBarbone]

So shockingly so..😭

[@albertoauditore02]

Yes

[@markmanning6542]

The Haavara Transfer Agreement commemorative coin.

[@chickensoup9869]

Socialism reserved for a specific nation. Hmm.

[@chompythebeast]

"I've heard this bedtime story before. Nazis... I hate these guys."

[@danielzak4405]

Nazis weren't leftist economically, and did not really believe in socialism for one race. Even with in the aryan race, they believed that the weak would fail and the strong would rise. The word "privatisation" was actually invented to describe the Nazi economy, which auctioned off public institutions to private companies. Back then, Socialism was just a trendy word. Hiter's definition of "socialism" was for people to love their race, expand their territory, and stamp out moral ineuity, to allow the strongest their race to flourish through private property.. @beansworth5694 @@chompythebeast

[@TeWakaOAoraki]

Nazbols

[@DanRyzESPUK]

National-socialists... Where did we heard that from?

[@seekingabsolution1907]

Strasserites. Trying to fold left wing economics into reactionary social and political positions. Vile.

[@timmcdraw7568]

Another brilliant job, and another huge asset in educating the population of the world about the “complicated” history of the occupation of Palestine, and how its not terribly complicated at all. I am commenting to boost as well as to celebrate the work you did.

[@bennelong8451]

It’s not an occupation Jews were there first Palestinians are the occupiers

[@liamoconlocha3264]

​@@bennelong8451a crooked little spine has spoken with his crooked little mouth

[@StrPtrn]

It's not complicated. Ethnonationalism is racism.

[@timmcdraw7568]

@@StrPtrn exactly. And its not complicated, the history was brutal and they knew it then, just like they know it now. I would go further and say nationalism is fascism, fascism is relies on identity politics and grudges, thus nationalism naturally bends towards ethnonationalism and thus: racism. I put “complicated” in quotes because the way people who are just hearing about this are dissuaded from looking into it as though they would need a masters degree in the history to understand.

[@timmcdraw7568]

@@bennelong8451 im a jew and 1% of my DNA can be traced to Palestine. 90% of it is traced to Russia and Austria. Palestinians were jewish, Christian, and Muslim. You could have moved there without making it an ethnonationalist state like it 1939 24/7 over there. In fact, the palestinians invited us to during the war! Then they were cooked by a zionist flame thrower after being rounded up, unarmed, and placed in a pen. A greatest shame to us all.

[@abuttandahalf]

The depopulation that happened after land purchases was just as much ethnic cleansing as what happened during the Nakba.

[@waspwrap1235]

Land purchases be like Yo Britan, can I have this land?

[@noahburstein7541]

Where Jews settled the Arab population increased. The standard of living increased and the health increased immensely.

[@marcriba7581]

@@noahburstein7541 I'm sure feeling an increase of audacity rrright under your feet.

[@handsanitiser9832]

@@noahburstein7541 Ah yes, the supremist mentality at play. They were massacred (nobody denies that anymore) and expelled. The most educated population in the region, and cities, like Haifa, rivaling Paris and Belgium. Clean hospitals, laudatory universities, two airports, and olive oil production and innovation ahead of its time. Of course, it takes humility and actually reading to know that. Bet you didn't know one of the world's finest Buick dealerships was in Palestine? Please humble yourself and be on the right side of history-people are doing that every day!

[@fun_ghoul]

​@@waspwrap1235 Exaaaactly. Title deeds made up in crayon.

[@scientifico]

the study of zionist history should open all chapters of all settler colonizers.

[@fun_ghoul]

💯💯💯

[@sofiaochoa5281]

You guys clearly have some fetish with colonisers 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@paulgibby6932]

And we in the US -- GUILTY! -- Hmm. reparations?

[@fun_ghoul]

@@paulgibby6932 Yes, reparations, but "cut the check" won't cut the mustard. Decolonization or bust (the planet)!

[@DSan-kl2yc]

​@@paulgibby6932 US did give reparations

[@elpito9326]

This video gotta be trending in the Zionist colonial regime cause damn, you got the whole Hasbara bot team spamming this comment section 😭

[@AestheticHair-ek5iq]

Where ? Commies are 🧠 d Stalin personally called himself a Z and not only voted for the creation of IS and armed them but also created another J state in Siberia "J Autonomous oblast". In 1944 he also tried to deport Greeks, Armenians, Bulgarians and Tartars in order to create a ✡️ state in Crimea

[@AestheticHair-ek5iq]

Where ?

[@chompythebeast]

@@AestheticHair-ek5iq For all others passing through: In a hidden comment (which you can find by sorting by New), this guy revealed he is a classic fan of 1930s dominant German politics. Ignore him.

[@AestheticHair-ek5iq]

@@chompythebeast And? You think that will change the fact that Stalin was an admitted Zionist ?

[@chompythebeast]

@@AestheticHair-ek5iq I don't particularly care whether Stalin was an admitted Zionist, that's a matter of history, something to learn from, but not a thing of the future. I certainly understand, however, why a fan of 1930s dominant German politics would have a grudge against Stalin

[@pelegsap]

As with all the previous videos in this series, I have to say (again!) that it is brilliant, and extremely accurate. As a Jew who grew up in Israel I must say that you have a much better and more realistic presentation of the historical facts than anything I've been taught throughout my years of Zionist indoctrination. And also that your pronunciation of Hebrew is incredible. I know I write these things almost every time, but they are worth repeating (and also helping with the algorithm etc. is not bad).

[@ykwtfim]

KZbin asked me to rate your comment. I rated it as excellent, but I found it interesting I was asked to rate this particular comment haha.

[@pelegsap]

@@ykwtfim Could be random, who knows ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@richietozier7091]

So a type of socialism meant for a single nationality of people? Some kind of National Socialism?

[@neochatterbox516]

Bad comparison tbh

[@someguy4512]

@@neochatterbox516 "Socialism but for my people" is just nazism

[@beansworth5694]

@@neochatterbox516 Where does the comparison fail, in your eyes?

[@neochatterbox516]

@@beansworth5694 The Nazis used ethnic communitarianism to scapegoat Jews for Germany’s economic woes, whereas the Zionists used it to stabilize Jewish population growth in Palestine, the latter of which they saw-however erroneously-as a necessity for keeping their people safe, in part as a direct result of persecution by groups like the NSDAP.

[@neochatterbox516]

TL;DR: the driving forces for both were starkly different (not to mention the outcomes)

[@manawa3832]

is it just me or is there something deeply unsettling about settler colonialism? i can't put it into words. typically when bad world events occur, you can easily blame an empire or a warlord or an institution like an army. but with settler colonialism it is literally the people themselves that are personally responsible. in fact their host empire is usually a disinterested 3rd leg trying to disassociate from the whole affair and having trouble controlling the little monsters unleashed on helpless indigenous population. it's creepy and unnerving for some reason.

[@fun_ghoul]

Your analysis is wrong. The settlers are who? The dregs of empires, sent to be exploited in themselves exploiting the native population. The idea that empires don't do this purposely or benefit from it is...well, where did you get such an idea?🤔

[@plurabelle5]

Non-settler imperialism has a lot of participation from the citizens, who are all beneficiaries too - take it from an Indian. When you meet ordinary Brits, they'll tell you to your face they think one British life is worth a hundred Indian ones.

[@fun_ghoul]

@@plurabelle5"Non-settler"? Dude, do you know how many millions of "Indians" proudly claim descent from Europe? Edit for clarity: "Indians" as in people trapped in the Anglo-colonial "India", not the people of the Western Hemisphere called "Indians" to paper over Columbus' navigational failure.

[@intricatic]

"Those indigenous weren't using the land right, so we had to come in and show them how it was done. Right before driving them off or killing them." Naw, that's not creepy at all.

[@joe-zy8pe]

@@intricatic you’re a thief

[@lorenam8028]

Despicable, from beginning to end. Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@lorenam8028]

​@@victormeidan1062 No, free Palestine from the settler colonialist project of the zionists.

[@lorenam8028]

Free from liars.

[@chompythebeast]

@@victormeidan1062 "troublemakers" lmao look at this duuude

[@fun_ghoul]

​@@victormeidan1062 Go back to Ukraine...or are you hiding there already on your second passport?🤔

[@bobsanborn2395]

@@lorenam8028 "Usury age-old and age-thick, and liars in public places..." ~Ezra Pound

[@armandogavilan1815]

"Let´s us make a genocide and then we built an ideal society for us" zionism - 1948

[@catherinewalks1207]

Found this by chance and what a find. Real historical depth and Intellectual robustness. Subscribed.

[@user-em3vl6li5w]

Back in the day we were so naive. I was desperate to go work on a Kibbutz. The idea I thought was to live communally in a hate free world. Silly me.

[@nagibanina]

Me to. My parents questioned my choice and asked me to look in to whats going on But i just thought they tried to put a stick in the wheels for me and i went…

[@MimiSoup]

@@nagibanina How was your experience there?

[@deboraandrade132]

The Kibutz dream made possible due to the blood of hundreds of thousands of palestinians since 1948.😢

[@clairefoxgloves4824]

I can't bear it!!☹

[@Cybercult]

I-Land will pay for it - its built on stolen palestinian land and bood of palestinian childs - I-Land will pay for it.

[@bluestar6879]

The Arabs need to accept they lost those wars of extermination & agree to move on. Otherwise, they condemn their descendants to eternal death, destruction & misery.

[@ncrongendov733]

Utter shite you spout. Read some history, go visit

[@WhaddupDoc]

Looong before that, look at the timeline established in this video; this project has been in effect since the late 1800s

[@beachesney7920]

brilliant - this important documentary should be mandatory part of education in schools and main stream media news ... thank you

[@Sayid-al-Furat]

Mohamedian propaganda. Will definitely help further their invasion of the West.

[@vanessazlatic7849]

Don't be silly! The only mandatory history subject at school is "holocaust". And don't you deny it or you'll go to jail!

[@YouTubdotCub]

Incredible series, so happy you're making this.

[@elmiraphilosophia7745]

How disgusting ethnic cleansing and Colonialism. Free Palestine 🇸🇩

[@mohammedalkahlout3596]

That is the flag of Sudan🇸🇩 although they are also going through a bad time so free them too. This is the flag of Palestine 🇵🇸.

[@Rafphaelhubner]

So, mostly of them are communist / nonbelievers (atheist), but for sure they think their imaginary God gave and promised them that land? They are not any "Chosen people", nor did God give and promise them that land. These are colonialists, thieves who saw that they could steal palestinian land and did so. Most of the towns and villages (and these kibbutzim) that were built after 1948 were actually build on Palestinian villages. Many villages were unfortunately given to settlers after the Palestinians were expelled, even the house where Golda Meir lived belonged to a Palestinian Christian family.

[@ullebor]

@@victormeidan1062 Ashkenazi are converts, they are not from Judea either.

[@lorenam8028]

Isn't it crazy how they have the chutzpah to come into this kind of videos and still try to convince people in the comments that they are the victims? 🤔

[@ron0311]

@@lorenam8028 You really hate them, do you. What happened, did someone of them touch your private body parts?

[@ron0311]

@@ullebor Proof?

[@shifa444]

@@ron0311why are zi0nists so obsessed with SA and r4pe?

[@kerryannegarnick1846]

My family "planted a tree in Israel" for me for my Bar Mitzvah, up until now I had thought it was just a means of normal conservation efforts. I had no idea planting trees could be a form of colonialism.

[@_mo_aj_]

yup, they planted trees over the rubbles of our villages so we could forget

[@atata2000]

yes, it's also used in other parts of the world. Mainly with pine and eucaliptus trees. They grow fast so they produce a lot of wood. But pines acidify the soil, making it imposible to sustain native species, changing the environment, and eucaliptus suck a whole lot of water, drying the soil. Other invasive species are used too, but these are the ones I remember right now

[@AnitaHWells]

Native’s Across Turtle Island Stand in Solidarity With Palestine 🇵🇸 ✊🏽

[@MFTQ]

'socialist' colonialism

[@DMC1982]

National socialist

[@orlandowilsondasousamelim4447]

Reminds me of the south african "socialist parties " who only organized white labour during apartheid

[@usersar2213]

Nazbols

[@user-qg2og7ds4f]

@@DMC1982 you cannot say that..because national socialisme was organic.. germany for germans.. israel is just a project for city of london. or britisch colonialism

[@AestheticHair-ek5iq]

Marxist Socialism was invented by Moses Hess a ✡️ and I've videos of ✡️ admitting in a meeting that it came from the Torah!

[@melloncollic]

Your videos keep getting better and better!

[@inversebrah]

the amount of work you put into these documentaries is amazing, thank you so much 🙏

[@fun_ghoul]

So...Sub-national Socialism? "SS" for short?

[@thyCarrot]

🤫🤫🤫

[@ArnavSharma-bj4ct]

Hmm but I'm seeing many musnazis with a swastika. I wonder why🤫🤫.

[@blackcreekorganicfarm296]

Yep

[@user-qg2og7ds4f]

you cannot say that..because national socialisme was organic.. germany for germans.. israel is just a project for city of london. or britisch colonialism

[@marchaustein1429]

drumset sound badum tsss

[@marcelleratafia2360]

all jewish settlements in palestine are at the costs of displaced palestinians

[@sofiaochoa5281]

Stupid beyond repair

[@arielfradin7963]

All Palestinian settlements in Judea are at the cost of displaced Judeans/Israelites.

[@richardquimby7046]

BS. Israel from the river to the sea.

[@arielfradin7963]

@@Ella1235-l3r Of course the Philistines existed. They were a Greek seafaring people, not indigenous Canaanites, nor Arabs. However, the modern day Palestinians are not descended from them, being a mix of Canaanite and Arab, and so the Philistines are virtually irrelevant to this conversation.

[@kucingcat8687]

​@@arielfradin7963 Palestinians are barely Arabs by bloods lol. On the other hands, the Israelis are literally Europeans claiming ownership of land in the ME

[@emseek9822]

Since Part II of this amazing video series came out I've been waiting impatiently for this third part and I must say with every part your work only gets better and better.

[@GreatRedMenace]

It's idiotic. Especially the part where he ignores that the British supported way more the Arabs than the Jews precisely because the Arabs were ultraconservative Fascists.

[@fun_ghoul]

​@@GreatRedMenace Yeah...let's just skip Balfour and Sykes-Picot to make your lies true.

[@GreatRedMenace]

@@fun_ghoul That European and foreign imperial powers like the British, French and Arabs decided to divide up lands for their own ambitions is absolutely nothing new. But the indigenous Jews built their own state, and defeated the imperial powers who wanted to shackle them.

[@fun_ghoul]

@@GreatRedMenace No "Arabs" negotiated Sykes-Picot, dunce. Try again.

[@GreatRedMenace]

@@fun_ghoul Jews didn't either. And Jews are indigenous to that land.

[@eypu999]

They’re so ev-l

[@ron0311]

Indeed. that's why Israel is fighting them.

[@lorenam8028]

Ev-l ans liars. Can find them everywhere trying to convince people that they are the victims. Like comment above.

[@ron0311]

@@lorenam8028 What really bugs you is that they are not so easy to fuck with anymore.

[@lorenam8028]

What really bugs me is that they are a settler colonial project that has stolen the land and the lives of millions. But of course you know that. You're just trying to engage to get paid a few more cents.

[@Proudguy211]

They do this all the time and end up getting fcked for their actions and then cry for the next 1000 years about it 😂😂 ​@@ron0311

[@JuneBarbone]

I wonder, if the Israeli citizens, are aware of the millions of people protesting against them, and in favor of the Palestinians?

[@Nathan-gn3ls]

Really good piece of work here. Free Palestine.

[@victormeidan1062]

Free it from 7th century settler-colonizers.

[@catherinejames2734]

@@GreatRedMenace😂only in your eyes,loser😂

[@mrcocoloco7200]

​@@GreatRedMenace Cope

[@handsanitiser9832]

@@victormeidan1062 Try again. That land always had people. The Palestinians are decendents of netufians and canaanites. Their decendents were always there, regardless of borders, what your called them, or their language. People lived there long before Judaism. Sociologists say its very rare for a people to completely leave a land; people were always there.

[@daneyal7162]

no, free the world from your stupidity.

[@user-vn4pn6ct8c]

This is outstanding. I have not heard most of your information before. I have posted it on social media. Well researched and powerful. Thank You so much

[@guillaumecabano33]

Same thing happened in South Africa during 1910s-1924: White nationalist communists tried organizing proletarian trade unions and even tried organizing syndicates and soviets to destroy capitalist exploitation & British imperialism, but at the same time these White communists excluded Black people from participating in these soviets, motivated as such by a very long history of White supremacy. The White nationalists, opportunistically, ultimately won political power in the South African state, which then implemented a colour bar to placate the White proletariat by gaurranteeing them more favourable labour conditions, at the expense of Black people, despite the fact that Black people were the indigenous and majority population. Thus the capitalists succeeded in placating White communists and recruting White nationalists to continue their exploitation over South Africa, with White supremacist characteristics. The communist movement was then purged of White nationalists, thanks largely to correct advice from the USSR and ComIntern.

[@fortunatomartino8549]

South Africa was purchased from the African tribes Once prosperity flourished, black people came in to do the menial jobs And just everywhere in the world, they brought their uncivilized culture with them Would you want to live next door to people who don't understand how to be civilized?

[@chompythebeast]

@@fortunatomartino8549 "Purchased" lmao Casual bigotry from a casual imperialist. You wouldn't say this in public

[@johnkrieg9368]

Their motto, correct me if I'm wrong, was: Workers of the world unite to keep South Africa White..

[@fun_ghoul]

​@@fortunatomartino8549 _"I made him an offer he couldn't refuse..."_ 🚣

[@fun_ghoul]

​@@chompythebeast maybe you have a better "public". People, or rather squatters, say such things all tell time in Ottawa. As long as you don't say "f*ck", you can spew all the Nazism you want and no other squatter will bat an eyelash. Ever heard of Joe Warmington?

[@happy-go-commie]

Brilliant work, well worth the wait!

[@subversivelysurreal3645]

Americans say : Free Palestine! 🇵🇸❤️✌🏽

[@Charger_13]

*NAZIONIST*

[@Jamonpere]

Babe, new Bes D. Marx video dropped! Palestinians have no path to liberation other than resistance الفلسطينيين مافي عندهم أي طريق للحرية غير المقاومة 🇸🇾♥️🇵🇸 كل الحب من الناس السوريين

[@christopher5846]

I'm glad to see so many Syrian comrades as an Iraqi.

[@Jamonpere]

​@@christopher5846 I'm the same person you saw last time, just from a different account. KZbin muted my account for speaking honestly about what I'd do to an IOF soldier. بحبك يا أخي ♥️

[@christopher5846]

​@@Jamonpereloool my account is flagged as well. If I use certain terms mostly to do with politics, my comment doesn't appear but other users are fine for using them. It's a badge of honor if anything. احبك انت وسوريا اكثر يا رفيقي

[@fun_ghoul]

@@christopher5846 Many people watching a video like this are similarly censored. I'm on 24h bans more often than not now, almost always alleging "hate speech". Pigs.

[@humanwithaplaylist]

​@@Jamonpere🥰

[@Sam-yj6br]

Who is the real local people of the land. well look at their clothing. Palestinians mostly wear traditional clothing while zionist.....

[@victormeidan1062]

Arabs originate in Arabia Jews originate in Judea Whose the colonist ?

[@Sam-yj6br]

@@victormeidan1062 The jew from Europe is the colonist.

[@freepalestine7687]

So all Americans speaking English or Spanish come from Spain or England ??? ​@@victormeidan1062

[@itzelouise8714]

@@victormeidan1062🤡

[@BlueBedouin]

​@@victormeidan1062Palestinians are Levantines that are Arabized, stop being dishonest

[@DrAnarchy69]

Thanks for this. I’ve seen some people, including scholars, argue that the Kibbutz movement was an Anarchist movement. You’ve clearly argued that this is far from the case. Nicely done

[@lucillab9033]

To say that Jews are good farmers is such a lie. In fact those Jews living in Russia near the border with China needed help from Chinese farmers in order to learn how to farm !

[@ultravioletiris6241]

Lmfao

[@pivomanslovensko]

Okay? So what

[@lucillab9033]

@@pivomanslovensko They are not farmers . They have other interests , not farming. They lack the ancestral know-how in farming. That is it.

[@pivomanslovensko]

@@lucillab9033 Bro youre saying weird stuff

[@Suhmatiya]

Thank you for another brilliant and rigorous video. We really, really needed your content on youtube.

[@lebladful]

Your job telling the truth deserve a great support

[@laylah150]

Thank you for making this, Israel's horrors did not begin in 1948. I always knew about the insidious nature of modern kibbutz, but I didn't know just how bad.

[@fun_ghoul]

_"Where's my orange? Who took my orange???"_

[@olterigo]

Thanks for reminding me to buy a watermelon to celebrate nakba this year.

[@johnstout5623]

To celebrate or commemorate?​@@olterigo

[@barryleveson6147]

Hand back that maple syrup or else Humus will take you hostage. Canadian! Where did put those cholera blankets?

[@olterigo]

@@johnstout5623 I guess my response was deleted by the system... Of course, to celebrate. Arabs planned to push Jews into the sea, but what came out of it was such a catastrophic failure.

[@fun_ghoul]

@@johnstout5623 For once -- just once! -- you should take the "Israeli" at their word.

[@All.Eyes.on.Palestine]

As human being i stand with Palestine, i will never stop talking about the war crimes committed by Israel for +76 years in Palestine Long live Palestine🇵🇸❤️🇵🇸 Long live resistance 🔻🇵🇸🔻❤️

[@desireedebellis6766]

as do I, Long Live the resistance

[@chiocampo3124]

Thank you for this video i learned a lot in the history of israel- palestine conflict which started decades ago.. palestinians have the right to return to their land!

[@christopherkucia1071]

It started literally over 100 years ago…. After 1918 is when it really started but these plans were in the works since the mid 1800’s or even earlier….

[@Taxistheft.]

I am going through these videos one by one. I just completed the first video, and I did research alongside it. It is truly sickening how much gets covered under and is not heard about, further so people will just otherwise lie about it. Your videos are different though. I can prove that with the information I have seen. (And the books you mention.) truly great work Marx 🤝

[@Pythoner]

Fascinating

[@gago198]

Excellent series. Thank you for making it.

[@nickhockings443]

The illegitamacy of the Israeli claim to be "returning" needs to be addressed. 1) Returning is not accepted anywhere else as grounds for ethnic cleansing. 2) Present day jews are mostly of minority ancient Jewish ancestory, due to gradual dilution by religious converts over 2000 years. 3) present day Jews are descendants of just the Pharisic sect, and follow religious scriptures and practices that were not invented until after they left the region. 4) The Palestinians are substantially descended from the ancient Jews and other Cananite and Philistine populations who never left the region, and became Christian in the Byzantine period and later Muslim. 5) The same Torah that Zionist use as their claim to come from Palestine, tells us that the ancient Jews originated in Ur in Iraq, invaded Canan, and committed genocide inorder to steal the land.

[@TJ-Judge]

Yes, I have found that all of the Zionist argument points are actually just slogans and rhetoric and nothing more... definitely not based on any logic or ethical reasoning. Which is often the case in colonial propaganda. Take "manifest destiny" for example. The argument used to commit genocide against the native Americans.

[@nathanlee8981]

Too bad you weren't making this argument in 1924 but the year is 2024. A little late to reconsider Israels Right to Exist. There is eight million people born and raised in Israel plus two million immigrants. Unless one plans to reverse 100 years of history, which will fail, this list means absolutely nothing.

[@nickhockings443]

@@nathanlee8981 too bad we've done decolonialization worldwide to imperial colonies hundreds of years old. The states that remain all acknowledge the citizenship on their indigenous population. While you run a racist sectarian state you remain the pariah. Also we do restitution of land stolen by racist regimes since the 1940s, worldwide.

[@meatrealwishes]

@@nathanlee8981 Actually, international laws dont recognize bible as a valid source for evidence. Not even israel’s own court does. It was called country because UN and backing from the big powers said so! It would have not been possible if the brits didn’t get hold of that land. Nations and empires generally die in the hands of far right. Middle east takes it to a whole new level. The damage is typically irreversible. Israel is already showing cracks. The liberal and educated people are fleeing the far right government. Those who are left lean towards extremism.

[@mazin_iq1499]

@@nathanlee8981only 8 million?? And surrounded from all sides except sea where they gonna leave in hypothetical scenario where the resistance and arab countries win. Syria war made 15 million people leave do you really think 8 which is half as that isnt possible? The middle east has had some big and horrific wars happening in the last decades and i can assure you that something as that is quite possible in this region. So his argument does matter.

[@r.w.bottorff7735]

Awesome, I'm looking forward to your video on this subject, thanks!

[@user-ip4cn7mn1h]

This is brilliant what an absolute gem your channel

[@LuckyOtter_WorldBuilding]

the sentiments around these Kibutzs, remind me alot of how Americans traditionally think of the frontier, both propose that, one can achieve libritory ideas, (communism) and (liberty) by..... being a settler! 😬

[@user-ok1el9mg4h]

Faszinating! I am seeing parallels to the methods used by Cecil Rhodes.

[@siogbeagbideach]

Absolutely. The Round Table Movement 1909....Balfour, Rhodes, Roths child etc

[@kjw6383]

Foreign workers doing the work. So much of Israel is a construct, a mythology to paint themselves in good light. Watching a documentary about oct7 it mentioned that after the hamas fighters went through then gazan civilians came.it stated they may have been some of the gazan day laborers than worked outside the fence So it introduced the idea that some of the violence could have been a result of resentments of employees/employers.

[@noahburstein7541]

Nonsense!

[@chompythebeast]

Class is absolutely a factor in this revolution

[@fun_ghoul]

​@@noahburstein7541Wait, so you're saying "Arabs" ( I assume you don't grant Palestine people their natuonhood) DON'T hate "the Jews" (Judeo-Crusaders)? Think about this now... 😂😂😂

[@victormeidan1062]

Nice nonsense!!

[@chompythebeast]

@@victormeidan1062 Damn you still here? You're really tearing your hair out over every widely documented fact about Isn'treal, aren't you? You got a brother in the IOF🔻 or something? How come you deleted all your previous comments, Hasbara?

[@johndorilag4129]

Evil people colonizing

[@Handlingkol]

So are the Palestinians claiming the Temple Mount where the Jews built the Third Temple if your are Christian you should know what it's going to happen and calling Israel a colonial state while both the Palestinians also colonize Jerusalem by Building this "Holy mosque" built right underneath the Jewish Temple

[@johndorilag4129]

@@Handlingkol Palestinians were expelled or murdered and their lands confiscated and colonized by Israeli settlers.

[@chompythebeast]

Evil has little to do with it. Sionisma is a rational system for committing settler-colonialism and geno side. It isn't predicated on good or evil but upon empire and what materially works. Time is long passed that its own devices are turned against it

[@chompythebeast]

No hope for the sionistas

[@kucingcat8687]

​@@Handlingkol the indigenous Canaanites arent colonisers in P_lestine. Please, provide us your genetic test.

[@hsjshdhsjshsh958]

My Dad grew up in one of these. He is brainwashed, perhaps irreparably

[@Wodden_door_Goyim]

Great video. Looking forward to Plan Dalet.

[@eypu999]

Now they c-r-y when you say the word “colonize”

[@WTF00007]

“You will own nothing and be happy” - While they enjoy their mansions and palaces and billions

[@isht_ma_ala4920]

yeah, nice to see faces of land stealers

[@ammanite]

Fantastic work, comrade!

[@polivkamikulas6401]

Thank you for continuing this series! The context you add is really important and almost completely ignored.

[@cherylmason5788]

“Leo Pinsker, a Jewish doctor from Odessa, published a small book called Auto-Emancipation. Its powerful nationalism inspired the founding in Vienna of the journal that coined the term “Zionism,” drawn from a historical symbol of the homeland to which Jews in Exile yearned to return.” Page 9. “After Pinsker published Auto-Emancipation, BILU loosely linked its local societies under the name Hibbat Zion (“Love of Zion”). Time to Drain the Swamp (and you think Trump came up with that term) it’s a coded term. Baron Edmond de Rothschild answered the call and financed settlements, built factories, salt mines, founded schools and drained the swamp. Yes, and farming meant laying claim to the land, a practice used by Colonialists everywhere. Great video, thank you!

[@metalheadz9635]

From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@fausiasimjee9143]

Palestine needs to be free of the occupier.

[@charissecoal]

the irony of early Zionists branding Arabs "Nazis". Who are the Nazis now? 😂😂😂

[@j-dub.d-trey]

As always, fantastic work Bes. Thank you

[@Sjnez]

great video yet again sir!

[@RoAgVa]

Excelent videos my brother, keep it up

[@DMC1982]

To define criticism of Zionism and Isreal as Antisemitism that is Orwellian newspeak. Remember 1984 was written in 1948 the year of the Nakba?

Great and necessary work. Thank you. #FreePalestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🍉🍉🍉

[@guccipucci3941]

Junge ich hatte den KZbin short am Anfang fast verdrängt 😭 Banger Video as ever, Free Falastin 🇵🇸🫡

[@veronikalynn5084]

Rewatching this because it’s just so well put together 😩 Thank you again ✌🏻🖤

[@bluestar6879]

Yes, this kr@pp is well put together. So the overall effect is a meaningless tapestry of Boolshytte.

[@veronikalynn5084]

@@bluestar6879 That’s a little contradictory, don’t you think? Seems like it holds a tremendous amount of meaning in your mind.

[@bluestar6879]

@@veronikalynn5084 I think it tells the story well.

[@veronikalynn5084]

@@bluestar6879 at least we can agree there. Regardless of opinion, I’m sure we both can appreciate skilful vs. lazy propaganda.

[@nono-fg5iq]

I was raised in an Israeli moshav, adjacent soc-dem movement to kibbutzim in Palestine. I just wanna say good job on your work, very comprehensive!

[@shukeelc5177]

Kibbutzim Communism looks remarkably similar to National Socialism. Didn't Hitler have such a plan too?

[@bluestar6879]

The kibbutzim have now been transformed to ordinary suburbs - mostly operating on a free market basis.

[@bobzthebuilder4236]

whenever i see those israeli " israel is so great" BS i almost throw up

[@justapassione5554]

Why is a hypocrite worse than a liar? A liar doesn't believe their own lie.

[@theearlba]

Amazing. You did a great job producing it and everything was presented with sources. I will be sure to go through them. But Amazing effort. I hope your video gets over a million views.

[@rahulahmed7905]

These settlers make me sick to my stomach and the worlds acceptance of this is beyond worrying

[@hussainsuhail1733]

Amazing, eye opening video! Let the world know the true colors of Israel!

[@aworldtowin955]

Ahh yes the peoples’ ethnic cleansing

[@fun_ghoul]

*Volk 🙋🏻‍♂️

[@pivomanslovensko]

Israelis are Stalinist patriots for real!!

[@theunknowncorps22]

Good work

[@jantsak6500]

Keep up with your great work comrade! Greetings from Greece

[@chompythebeast]

Καλησπέρα, σύντροφε! Much love to my dearly beloved Ελλάδα from the Pacific Northwest

[@allypoum]

An excellent and well researched deep dive into the history of modern Zionism, only one minor quibble I feel is worthy of raising - I feel your treatment of Einstein lacks a bit in nuance. I'm no academic and have no claim to special expertise in the matter but I have read several biographies of Einstein and had the impression that while he became a target of the Zionists' attention and was initially supportive, he quickly developed deep reservations about the Zionist project and definitively distanced himself from it and its partisans. The best-known expression of this was his refusal to accept the fledging nation's offer to become the Zionist state's first President, which was taken as a serious snub by said Zionists. Remember his international prestige was very high at the time and it seemed clear to many - including Einstein himself - that the Zionists had merely wanted to exploit his good name. I can't remember the text of his letter of refusal but I seem to remember it spelled out his reasons for turning down the post and included mention of the whole settler colonial underpinnings and its incompatibility with his socialist convictions. Correct me if I'm wrong any assiduous researchers out there.

[@BesDMarx]

I agree with you, and note that I didn't do any treatment of Einstein aside from just mentioning which Zionist force he supported. If anything, knowing this serves to distance him from Zionists who claim him since the current he supported rested on an unfeasible vision which fell apart precisely due to the practical reality of Zionism to be exclusive. I generally do not bother too much with harsh assessment of scientists like Einstein or, say, the early Oppenheimer since 'fellow travelers'/ non-communists who are not politicians and focus on shooting rightward are an important element for the communist movement.

[@Krokant17]

What I find absurd is how there is general consensus that facts should be considered over assumptions & (conspiracy) myths, yet people don't question the conspiracy myth of the left uniting with the right, the muslims, some jews, arabs, terrorists, fascists and religious fanatics, while literally no one calls out the Nazis still in power, still rich and opposing the Palestinian cause (like the AfD and von Storch). The "Zentralrat der Juden" saying the same things as the "AfD". And while the bourgoise FAZ prints about the "left-right-uniting antisemitic mob", the JAZ prints about the "bourgoise elitist academic Pro-Palestinians", while right white supremacists burn synagogues and the public wont call the right out because they use it to fight against left opposition.

[@GlobeHackers]

Great work, informative, and challenging. I appreciate your including your list of solid references in the video description.

[@markmanning6542]

Invaders. Aggressive dominant invasive species behavior. Human crocodiles.

[@muhammadibrahimbhatti1427]

Free Palestine!

[@lopezmv17]

Excellent work, thank you!

[@yotam6x7]

Great work. Are there any books specifically about the colonization and settlement of Marj Ibn Amir/Jezreel Valley?

[@BesDMarx]

Sure, Colonizing Palestine: The Zionist Left and the Making of the Palestinian Nakba, by Areej Sabbagh-Khoury, 2023 an excellent book just from last year, I worked a lot with it for this video

[@arielfradin7963]

How about some books on the Arab/Islamic colonization of the Levant and the entire Middle East/North Africa region? Or some on the explicitly racist/nationalist pan-Arab movement that was the norm amongst Arab nations who opposed Zionism before and since 1948?

[@tariqmostafa]

Zionism is colonialism project for those who miss those old days but with less cost

[@fun_ghoul]

There is more than a little truth to this! Amerikkka still justify, and even glorify, "Manifest Destiny". This undoubtedly leaves some Amerikkkan Jews with a lust for extermination...

[@sarahl3795]

This is dystopia….

[@NoraGermain]

Definitely, and I was sort of strangely reminded of ppl who want to live at Disneyland, Succession’s season 4 design for communities, and even ppl who live inside walls of country clubs…

[@samnaderiofficial]

Very well done. This needs to be shared and used for educating people. Thank you 🙏🏼

[@bdleo300]

Kibbutz is how AdoIf envisioned his Lebensraum....