The Devil in Me - What Happens if You Tie Up Charlie Vs Trust Him

[@francescostabile3560]

Erin, the greatest sound expert of the world who can't even recognize a bad edited recording. Great job.

[@DanteKrystal]

I mean, she's a rookie, but yeah, even a baby would have noticed.

[@LOWBORN-the-LOATHSOME]

The kicker: even Mark would have recognized that the audio was doctored (if Erin is not at this scene).

[@denverm7909]

@@DanteKrystal Erin is a bitch, i killed her on the first chance.

[@eriksimca9409]

thats the twist of the game, when you think pure logic would sort things out the characters go full retard....

[@s_mai8970]

and that's why she ain't paid lmao

[@Mailman2-1Actual]

But like, I didn’t know his body was built like THAT 👀

[@angelit161]

It’s a video game, chill.

[@sass_king5576]

@@angelit161 it’s a joke, chill

[@maxwellflora2744]

@@sass_king5576 joke? He didnt say so, so stop acting like you know everything

[@sass_king5576]

@@maxwellflora2744 it’s not that deep, go outside

[@onlyyour._shu]

@@maxwellflora2744 chillax, they're only guessing bro

[@devonetn8176]

Honestly even if Erin should’ve known it was edited she still had a LOT MORE reasoning than Ashley saying Emily is infected. She wasn’t thinking straight and with Charlie strangely surviving the furnace trap, having them lock up their phones and kissing Dumets ass the entire game. I would’ve believed it myself as well. Plus Erin actually shows remorse unlike Ashley and Sam being like “Oh no”. She obviously feels terrible calling herself an idiot and when looking at Charlie blames herself.

[@hmp2125]

who is ashley and emily

[@mikar1377]

@@hmp2125 from until dawn game

[@axtridxx]

@@hmp2125 BRO-

[@axtridxx]

@@hmp2125 HOW MANY GAMES DID YOU MISS DAYUM

[@kathryn-]

so you would be fine with locking yourself in a small room, defenseless, with someone who was bitten/scratched by a wendigo & not be panicing? if you said yes i'd say you're full of shit.

[@Georaffe]

Everyone about to just kill the poor man just to see his chest lmfaoooo yall something else I'm dead

[@Georaffe]

@Embercub From the little I've allowed myself to see, Charlie has some pretty fucked up death animations. They really had it out for him this game LMAO

[@oisinlynch8427]

@@Georaffe same with Chris in until dawn

[@oisinlynch8427]

@Embercub kind of like Chris from until dawn

[@Jay-bq1dq]

Now we need to figure out how to make the curator undress and then playthrough can be considered 100% completed. [Completionist goals]

[@Georaffe]

@@Jay-bq1dq LMAOOOOOOO?????? JAILLLLLL NOT THE CURATOR....

[@sketche7913]

Glad y'all are realising Charlie is hot asf, shame it took seeing him dead for you to notice lol

[@muhfuckingat]

DADDY

[@me8018]

We, dilf enjoyers, always knew

[@MasonMacFerren]

I remember in the beginning Charlie said “I am fit as a butchers dog” I didn’t think he was serious until now 😅❤

[@CreativeUsernameEh]

4:23 it's so frustrating. There's FOUR of them in the room. The killer is so weak that a lamp thrown at his arm stumbles him, but they all RUN??? So stupid. In a different playthrough, Charlie was there with them two, so there was at least a man to fight. And Charlie is apparently RIPPED underneath the shirt too. AND THEN ERIN. Isn't she a sound expert? She can't tell the "recording" isn't edited? With the long pauses? "It's been edited. I'm such an idiot, I'm a sound tech, and I fell for it!" Yeah, well said.

[@LocseryuOfficial]

Well, phrase it like this, if a man has a knife, you dont charge towards him dumbass

[@CreativeUsernameEh]

@@LocseryuOfficial Uh, yes you do. Especially if the other options is blindly running AWAY from him into another trap... which is unfortunately exactly what they do multiple times during this game. They should absolutely bumrush him when they could have, and maybe picked up a makeshift weapon or two, and then four armed angry people could proceed to beat the shit out of one man. I mean, he was staggered by throwing a lamp, surely two men and a butch lesbian with ANY makeshift weapons could take him. The characters were so dumb and irrational I just couldn't suspend my disbelief and it ruined the game.

[@LocseryuOfficial]

@@CreativeUsernameEh He is also cunning enough to make several traps. For all we know, he faked the stumble in a attempt to trick them. Also, you bumrush him, you get impaled motherfucker. and what makeshift weapons. The outside area is barren as hell

[@CreativeUsernameEh]

​@@LocseryuOfficial "He faked the stumble in a attempt to trick them" ...What are you even writing. How do you fake a stumble: He was clearly off balance and more vulnerable, it wasn't an optical illusion... And depending on how they're stabbed they may not die, most people murdered by a knife get stabbed 20+ times. And even if they are stabbed, with adrenaline going they won't even notice and can still fight and die later. Don't forget there's 4 of them: he can't kill them all... It was just a dumb scene in a bad game. "What makeshift weapons" I don't know, a plank of wood. A rock. Some dirt to throw in his eyes. Break some furniture and use that. Throw another lamp. Literally anything. Think, Mark!

[@DanteKrystal]

You know, for plot purposes. The killer is either a jellybean or the reincarnation of Senator Armstrong.

[@MrBrknsyt]

Wow. Charlie knocking him down and all 5 of them just ran away after. I dont know about about bodybuilts or anything but maybe each of them could grab a hold of a limb and one of them chokes him out? Like... guys... its a 5 on 1 and charlie knocked him down.

[@redacted8008]

Charlie's built like a tank. He can 1v1 ez

[@rhf101]

I think because they were in panic and honestly most people would choose to not confront a dangerous person especially when they get traumatized a lot after all these traps and it would take a lot to build courage

[@annabassirou]

Fr

[@drunkdadof4]

Considering Du’Met absolutely tanked a three story fall they’re practically fighting Myers in an HH Holmes costume 😂

[@Theforestking89]

@@redacted8008 as long as du'met doesn't have a weapon? Yeah Charlie wins

[@JuneMcCready]

Didnt realized charlie was daddy only when he is complicit

[@everythingbobi]

on other news,,, charlie is looking mighty fine for his age likeee

[@hisdarksecret]

Been saying this. He's kinda cute (jeez, I know... he's a 49 year old, dammnit 😂).

[@ennasy7997]

I WAS JUST ABOUT TO SAYYYY LIKE

[@bryan2733]

Daddy

[@SnoEntertainment762]

all the gay anime guys in the comments 🤡🤣

[@testerfox6998]

didnt expect his pecs

[@GemiARC]

Erin definitely took an L here but it’s understandable in my case. Charlie was so open to everything Du’met did and after hearing that tape I would probably think he’s in on it too. And to tie him up I think was justified cause if he was in on it then Du’met wouldn’t kill him. It’s funny though cause during the game I honestly thought Erin was in on it. She disappears for awhile while Mark is exploring the house and even when Kate arrives she’s no where to be seen til’ startling her on the stairs so I was so suspicious of her til’ the end.

[@Baniwinnie]

It was so obvious it was edited 💀 would have got someone killed for no reason

[@fpeter01]

@@twilightresonance1789 Good point. After they escaped the house, the storyline is messed up and and some details are missing (due to the lack of time?). It is still a good playable movie with multiple outcomes, but the last parts could have been better.

[@Ninja-oo9bd]

I thought that Erin was sort of being kept alive to lure in a new group of victims.

[@redacted8008]

Understandable? Tying someone up you suspect is one thing, but in this case, tying him up = him being easily murdered, which they should have well known. You don't just tie someone up defenseless and leave them alone when a serial killer is on the loose. But then again, they did the same thing with Erin two seconds after she'd been attacked, so this lot was clearly mental to begin with.

[@Megawaps]

@@twilightresonance1789 You can't really know for sure how people will act in THIS sort of situation.

[@queenphoenix121]

This comment section is either arguing about how Erin was in the wrong and or traumatized, or Charlie's body...i came for the body but hey, Im also a Captain Price simp. I see an older man with a nice body, I click.

[@PrøxxyNyxx]

Right like omg 😆

[@redrose1179]

Poor Charlie, but people hate on Erin so much like she isn't easily manipulated by dumet... She has severe anxiety issues that dumet targeted, also, he tormented her the most, she of the 5 was tortured the most by dumet.

[@bigronchus5885]

Tbf Charlie can get his hand crushed, his face slashed and at least be scorched in the fire trap. On top of that he has to live with the fact that he potentially got 1-4 people killed

[@cherylvictoria970]

YES

[@miloradowicz]

I agree, you shouldn't hate Erin. But on the other hand, as you said she is very easily manipulated. That's why her opinion should be devalued to a point.

[@weezyf775]

When i watched a play through in which Erin was dead right away thus never getting to listen to the tape, and Mark finds the tape with Charlie, I thought oooh that'd be cool if you need to have Erin survive to this point to spot the fact that the tape is edited, but then the evidence is right there.... would have been cool if characters and their specific skills could impact of the story...outside of electrician gets screwdriver, cameraman gets camera.........

[@thedeets_]

Something that was the most bothersome to me was how Erin's head moves way more than her eyes ever did, all of the characters kinda have that issue but with Erin it's like x10 with her, it's the most unnerving part of the game

[@MintyMiku]

She's Indian that's why

[@microwave.e]

shes indian they do it irl too lol

[@lavender9658]

@@microwave.e the hell are u saying

[@milannoelle1576]

@@lavender9658 ; exactly what they said. culture plays a part in body language & behavior. her being indian/south asian influences the way she moves her head when speaking.

[@faimynth6030]

People who think Erin is unreasonable for falling for the fake call clearly don't understand how the brain works when you're scared and panicked. You do not think straight, at all. You cannot process things very well... Causing you to act irrationally and act out, so no actually Erin isn't entirely to blame for this, Sure she could have had more faith in Charlie but let's be fair here... Charlie was being extremely mean and cruel towards her, showed signs of aggression (not directly at the team but still) and his ability to survive the furnace... suspicious...

[@tuppiee1752]

Aren't du met have PhD on psychology tho?

[@stamatedragosc.2302]

Woman moment

[@icy5656]

Erin is bad and pathetic.

[@faimynth6030]

@@icy5656 someones projecting

[@faimynth6030]

@@MrConredsX "I would rather kill a woke person" *Acts confused people would think theyre the murderer* I think you need therapy my guy

[@etherealdens]

I didn’t even had option to tie him up because I didn’t find evidence while playing Erin, so 😂

[@firemario8126]

Me too but that's because she died right after finding the audio log.

[@ahstiasummers5583]

Needs Erin to have low friendship with Charlie

[@KubilaySavs]

@@ahstiasummers5583 No you don’t

[@firemario8126]

@@KubilaySavs true, just need the "evidence" and both Erin and Charlie alive

[@icy5656]

Erin is toxic psychopath.

[@richiecantos7793]

I understand the speculation, but those recordings were so badly spliced together that it's questionable how Erin fell for it.

[@rufure9294]

To be honest, Erin did what she could with her experience of survival skills possibility none. She isn't a soldier or fighter . It's normal she is in shock and seeks the first action for her survival when she panics. Unlike us , she doesn't have a pause function to analyse what happened and have no idea of what others did. You can't blame her to not process everything calmy when you almost died 10 times in less of 2 hours. She recognised she was a fool and asks forgiveness once she release her mistake

[@richiecantos7793]

@@rufure9294 that's true and I do like that Erin actually apologizes for her mistake unlike most characters in other games when they are wrong they get defensive.

[@icy5656]

@@rufure9294 And you make excuses for her? She is a psychopath. My congratulations. You defend a psychopath who killed a men.

[@rufure9294]

@@icy5656 I don't defend her but making a point that in that situation she was completely justified that being paranoid about Charlie's actions and seeking survival. Even without the tape, there were a lot of evidences of Charlie could been accomplice: he was the one who accepted the invitation , also followed the rules of no phones, been awful to everyone and seems to care more about his show more than his employees ,was supposed to be dead and reappears by unknown miracle . Thankfully you control the other guy so you can reason with Erin. She panicked like anyone normal after almost be killed 4 times in the same hour. She was on the survival mode and seeks safety by being suspicious at everyone. She wasn't on her right mind sure when she asked to tie Charlie but that didn't make her psychopath trying to survive and panic. I think it made more human because human (or at least regular civilian person ) normally can't act rationally when they are in danger. Besides She didn't kill him , it was the killer. I agree the tying someone while there a killer around is 100% guilty but Erin did what she thought was right to survive. She was wrong and Thankfully you can correct her before she makes a fatal mistake

[@alienjesus796]

Tbh throughout most of the game I thought the twist would be Charlie was involved, he kept making excuses for DuMet, and dismissed Erin's fears when she nearly died in that room. I assumed he was involved but DuMet turned on him and tried to kill him too with the fire

[@miloradowicz]

He wasn't the only one who dismissed her fears. Any reasonable human in his place would dismiss her fears. And why don't you apply the same logic to her case? According to her own words, she was locked up in a room with the murderer, all alone by herself, yet for some reason, she wasn't killed? Suspicious, isn't it? Oh, I know, she must be an accomplice herself.

[@РамильАхмедов-и6ю]

True

[@РамильАхмедов-и6ю]

After all even the most innocent person can be a devil in disguise

[@yamiyugipokemon99]

Would've given the game a better twist tbh instead of some copycat guy just...Michael Myersing himself everywhere

[@JDDimensions]

Goddamn supermassive made this game to where your choices can make anyone hate a character or make them become likable

[@seabass2035]

I know it’s for conspiracy effect but erin seriously is stupid for this one, charlie speaking normally the whole game but believes the recording that the killer left immediately

[@kingwolfinsheepsclothing4188]

Okay but like charlie is kinda buff😳😳😳😳😳😳

nah, tying up charlie is not a bad ending... it's a hot ending DAMN! 🥵

[@Yassin5643]

Charlie would literally wreck mark, i don't know why he didn't stop mark from doing that.

[@Starcaholic]

In all honesty, CHARLIE IS HOTTTT

[@bandana.7077]

WHAT???

[@juliettepourcher4648]

@@bandana.7077 I AGREE

[@ChaotikBabe]

Yuck

[@maxwellflora2744]

Omg wth is wrong with yall he is dead he is an old man he is not real yet yall simp for him

[@vstxtk]

@@maxwellflora2744 idgaf

[@phoenixginny62442]

It was just a prank, Charlie.

[@benjaminhawkin5564]

I love games like this that have many different choices & outcomes. When I watched this game. Erin was the first to die & apparently there’s another scenario where she makes it this far 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@RopeDrink]

TLDR -- EVERY character was being played by a former FBI profiler who abused both their physical and mental traits. If you are the type of player who immediately picked a side, then you would have been a perfect target for Du'Met. After all, a team that in-fights and distrusts itself is a lot easier to split up and abuse, hence there were so many mind-games before Du'Met started acting like a budget Vorhees Myers. There's two sides to consider. Firstly, keep in mind that Erin is a young and impressionable intern with confidence issues, not a wisened expert with tonnes of life experience - hence Du'Met lured her into a room full of fake evidence and then used Jamie to test Erin's loyalty, knowing they were close with each other. Ironically, we (the players/viewers) can listen to the entire (unedited) Charlie conversation immediately after the prologue, but the 'fake' version is discovered so much later that even the players/viewers will have forgotten the normal version. As for Charlie, people need to remember that he's desperate to save the show, hence the stress, impending eviction, ignoring logic, using an unpaid intern, undercutting a skeleton crew, the need for smokes, and being an ass in general. However, as soon as he realizes that the danger is legitimate, the first thing he does is tell everyone to get the hell out before being targeted. He also shows the most empathy and dismay if he survives the ordeal and gets informed of dead comrades after escaping the house. Whether you love Charlie or hate him, he arguably had the most brutal experience of the night. Being partially cooked in a furnace, risked being ground up into a paste in a crusher, was scared shitless by Connie, was punched by Mark, risked being killed by his own team, risked falling to his death crossing beams, avoided a meathook to the chest, avoided decapitation, and THEN decided to try and quit smoking. That shit's rough, and we'll never know if he ever got to finish Season 1 or made Season 2.

[@NewMateo]

Charlie is ripped af.

[@muhfuckingat]

Hey baby

[@tanooki81]

You can see Charlie running at 4:26 even though he's not with the group lol.

[@kodiakprior5659]

I had to watch twice but your right 😂 how did they not catch that??

[@juan66]

I burst out laughing when the achievement popped up on 5:39 XD

[@Tuturial464]

Charlie has it rough. Trying to make it in this rough world

[@muhfuckingat]

Hey baby

[@KleioChronicles]

Funny, TeosGame played this co-op, saw the tape with Erin and was waiting for the confrontation but it never happened, they just found the other tapes and she said she was an idiot. This game was so bugged in co-op they were playing totally different stories with different cutscenes.

[@VeriCheri]

For me in co op charlie died but she she still told mark charlie was evil but she saw him die!

[@D3niz3n]

There was literally static between the clips of one of the recordings, how did erin possibly fall for it?? When she dies, others like mark listen to the tapes instead and are like huh. Clearly fake.

[@redrose1179]

Dumet knows Erin has severe issues with anxiety and asthma, and being an FBI agent he can easily manipulate Erin into thinking something was real because of her issues, also, he tormented Erin the most, she has the most trust issues cause of it

[@white-tea970]

Oh man... Dead even if he was innocent... It is so sad

[@MintyMiku]

Charlie is such a GILF

[@stellaraysexton9129]

Come on Charlie, has a body!

[@krislikesred]

Mark being able to hold down and tie up charlie makes no sense. It says in the medical record that charlie weighs 204lbs and mark only weighs 119lbs. Charlie also looks built compared to mark so he could easily overpower him. maybe charlie was just being compliant in this case?

[@Cawld]

have you looked at mark? makes no sense to be 119 lbs

[@scottslattery7195]

What medical record

[@krislikesred]

@@scottslattery7195In the control room, go downstairs and you'll find a bulletin board and a table with information about the team. There is a book on the table with the crew's medical information.

[@mmsss8803]

@@Cawldyeah I’m 120 lbs and way skinnier then mark. if mark was 120 lbs he’d basically be anorexic

[@moonpixelle]

medical files also say erin is the same age as jamie so there’s errors all up in there ig

[@emmastone8068]

i feel bad for charlie

[@oisinlynch8427]

Well to be fair he was making a lot of excuses for dameth

[@emmastone8068]

@@oisinlynch8427 true, but he probably didn't know Du Met was doing this, but the guy in yellow coat

[@Yallyah]

Erin was doing a lot here.😂

[@IsaGh0st]

me, who has seen 1 and a half gameplays of TDIM wherein everyone died in basic af ways, reading the title: you can WHAT

[@nellylenaj3601]

I mean. While that recording was fake, im impressed on how authoritive she got on tieing up Charlie.

[@nightcrafter7886]

Poor charlie, (Singleplayer) He had to survive the blazing Hell on that furnace,it even showed him having Burns idk if major,minor but damn thats a metal grate which also makes it hotter? Idk science but still that blazing heat can probably kill you (Multi-player) Goddamn mark didnt help (1) Man thats just cruel (Door attempt) Thats sad, even if charlie escaped he'd be badly burnt & dumet just gonna slice him up to pieces, or maybe knowing dumet charlie will probably just get thrown back at the furnace and lock the door once more (Grinder) My god thats goddamn terifying most people wouldn't be calm it that situation (QTE) Then lastly This scene, Charlie survived Blazing Hell just to get betrayed by a set up or if saved he still protected everyone by knocking out dumet in that house or building

[@sbeltred]

AYOOOOO CHARLIE'S BUILT DIFF FOR AN OLD MAN

[@veitongowarriorjml440]

Bro’s 49 💀

[@tuppiee1752]

@@veitongowarriorjml440 still look hotter than most 21 year old man

[@MintyMiku]

Fr

[@miloradowicz]

@@veitongowarriorjml440 "bro"? You mean "daddy", right?

[@hirizigli2062]

This is the first time you make Charlie died like this and you got the achievement

[@ShiharuMichiko]

Left-handed killer in the former scene, right-handed in the latter, huh.

[@thegreathufflepuff7877]

He could be ambidextrous

[@idhertog]

Why is Charlie kinda-

[@eliaslui8372]

In no other dark pictures game did i think that u can easily fuck up the killer like in this one

[@blackairforce13]

Cause the killer was a human working alone, well I think he might have some kind of teleporting powers but human nonetheless. There were 5 of them, they could've tackled him and beat the sh*t outta him instead of playing cat and mouse with him

[@Belf_Mainsiel]

@@blackairforce13 There's actually a theroy of 2 killers: Hector Munday and G. Du'Met (Don't know how to spell his first name). The evidence for that is obviously the post credit scene where the mask is picked up, but also because the Curator has a list of names crossed out. Both names are on there, but he only crosses out Hector Munday if the killer "dies" on the boat.

[@eva-rz8gm]

@@blackairforce13 The scene with Erin, Jamie, and Kate shows how he gets around so quickly so I'm pretty sure he's just a normal dude. Though it is weird that he survives at the end of the game even if Mark throws the hook right into his heart and possibly gets shredded to bits by the boat..

[@Paolo-nc6ge]

I love this game thank you

[@jameshill8795]

Am I the only person that remembers the “COMPLICIT” carved into Charlie’s chest from something else I feel like it’s a reference or just really similar to something i have seen before.

[@Yassin5643]

"I'm an idiot" You sure as hell are.

[@humanangel8007]

I know Erin was in the wrong here, but it was so satisfying for me to see her confront Charlie like that, this is pretty much the only moment we see her being this assertive. She's the one person in the group (besides Mark perhaps) that actually tries to be nice to everyone yet Charlie just treats her the shittiest. And unlike the other characters, she doesn't have the confidence to stick up for herself. I also believe one of the reasons she went that hard on him was because of pent up anger from being mistreated. If she already secretly resented Charlie, that tape probably just aggravated it.

[@miloradowicz]

You remind me of morons who'd cheer on a homicide as long as it's "girl powah". But even that aside, think about what it would do to Erin. The only time she tried to be assertive and take a stand, she ended up killing an innocent man. It will ruin her self-confidence for the rest of her life. You know, sometimes you have to "supervise" a child or even take their agency away completely for their own sake. You do not learn to swim in the midst of a marathon.

[@humanangel8007]

@@miloradowicz did you really have to insult me? I said I KNOW Erin was in the wrong. I'm not justifying her actions, and I'm definitely not saying killing an innocent man is "girl power". All I said is that it felt satisfying for me to see her take charge here. To be honest, I felt somewhat represented by this scene. I'm also usually subdued and struggle to take the reins, but when I'm angry/feel vulnerable I also attempt to take charge in a hasty way like she did, and I ALSO fuck up in most of those moments because they come from me being stressed. See? I'm literally admitting she was hasty and fucked up. I never got as far as indirectly getting someone killed, but I still felt seen here. See? It has nothing to do with radical feminism, it's a personal sentiment. You completely misinterpreted my comment.

[@Mylo.J.Jacobs]

whats more frustrating than Erin not noticing the obvious edit (and it doesn't matter that shes a sound technician, literally everyone who played the game knew it was an edit) is that when they finally DO realise it's an edit they choose to turn the light on first INSTEAD of untying Charlie? Just leaving him out in the pouring rain where theres possibly a murderer running around?

[@siaed7094]

While it's stupid that this is a point of conflict at all, given that Charlie almost burned to death AND Mark saw it on cams too I'd say that you would have to be insanely short-sighted to side with Erin on this. Du'Met is shown to only kill accomplices AFTER he gets what he wants from them, and while at this point you don't undoubtedly know that, it can still reasonably be inferred that he wouldn't put his accomplices in potentially deadly situations well before he got what he wanted from them(in this case, the deaths of Lonnit's employees). Yes, the writing is bad; yes, Erin's logic is worse; but if you decide to tie up Charles Lonnit then your reasoning is actually the worst.

[@shyviolets]

Honestly, the fact that he survived the burning to death makes him pretty sus. If I thought I saw someone die on video and then they suddenly turned up again after a night of me being hunted by a psycho killer... I don't know that I would immediately trust their story. Throw in that they're totally confused about what's going on half the time and have no idea why all of this is happening it doesn't seem like such a leap that the person who brought them there might be in on it.

[@siaed7094]

@@shyviolets No? I'm not talking about you, the player, not the characters. There is literally no reason to suspect Charlie post-incinerator trap. Literally there is a Picture that shows him dying with his arm through the door.

[@shyviolets]

@@siaed7094 that's true, I agree with everything but calling it bad writing. I think it adds replayability and optional gameplay. If you want everyone to live then it's a stupid option. If you want to shake things up then it's an option 🤷‍♀️

[@kshdkxjsoajaps]

WHY IS CHARLIE SUCH A DILF HELPPPP

[@muhfuckingat]

Hey baby

[@user_chan-gy6ds]

​@@muhfuckingatis that a jojo reference 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥

[@theblitz1687]

Honestly, first recording never sounded fake to me, it just sounded like charlie was really tired and depressed but still had a hard time ordering the job

[@miloradowicz]

It didn't sound fake to me either, more like it appeared fake. The location where it was found, the fact that the murderer used a tape recorder, the absence of the second party on the recording, and I simply wouldn't implicitly trust the murderer or any of his evidence.

[@fbiagent3998]

Ok but when he was tied up, why did Charlie look kinda.... 😏🥴

[@purplevoncreep9920]

Why didnt Erin stop and calmly think about it, have you seen the video of billy on the street where screaming "name a woman" at someone made them not be able to name a single person

[@jeanseverin7486]

Bro, if this was real life and that was me I’m sorry, but the owner of the hotel is getting jumped ☠️

[@lowhp_comic]

Du'Met: **closes door** Charlie: We aren't trapped in here with you, you are trapped in here with ME!

[@crazycora3337]

Ok Erin now help me up!😊 Erin: (.( your fine.

[@rainbowkitten8990]

4:59 Correct me if I am wrong but why did she lie? She doesn't know if he made it out, she literally tied up him up with a serial killer on the loose so how can she say that? He was most likely killed soon after they left, maybe not even 10 minutes after. She also used her horrible recording skills to falsely accuse him of setting them all up to die. When I do my own play through, she isn't making it 🤣🤣

[@storiesbyJTK]

wow you’re just as a bad as the killer

[@jaesjmes5498]

Dumets just a normal guy right? Immortal or something but his muscles ain’t stronger. Couldn’t they have just, idk, knocked him out when he entered that room and that girl slapped him with the lamp, or when Charlie pushed him?

[@BrovarSpirytus]

no, he's a terminator that can teleport, be in multiple places at once and can survive getting stabbed into a chest

[@Picnicl]

No need for Charlie to diss Mark by saying "You're both f mad", just after Mark said he believed Charlie. Some of the script could have used a bit longer in the oven.

[@fruitisto4355]

Erin took the L in here

[@luxluther436]

“Omg I can’t believe I trusted a clearly edited tape of my boss saying he wants us dead even though I’m a SOUND TECH and he has almost been killed just as much as we have!” NO SH!T SHERLOCK-

[@ashleyud5674]

erin didnt heard any recordings in my playthrough? how to get this scenario?

[@dee-dr7kt]

inspect areas you’re in

[@ashleyud5674]

@@dee-dr7kt is the recording in the treatment center ( the one with doctor and patient animatronics)? i cant find anything there lol

[@MLPvZ]

@@ashleyud5674 It's there, I think it was behind a folding screen

[@Caverman1234]

@@dee-dr7kt in the asylum room, across where the 2 animatronics are, there's a white folding screen you can go up to and pull aside, where the tape player is sitting on top of a stretcher

[@Theforestking89]

@@Caverman1234 I'm pretty sure it's called silver ash

[@МихаилКокотюха]

The whole moment with edited tapes doesn't make sense. Why did Munday do this? Just to troll Erin? It's just pointless. If he wanted to make Charlie a mastermind behind this in case the police will find out about the murders, he still wouldn't escape the punishment.

[@RopeDrink]

He's a former FBI profiler. He tailors the house and traps based on each character's personality and weaknesses. For example, funnelling Erin into a room full of fake evidence and then forcefully having Jamie test Erin's loyalty at the risk of death. Things like that, the mannequin dinner, the fake groundskeeper (etc) are all to separate the group and sow discord. Erin breath-traps (O2 vacuum and enclosed dusty spaces), Charlie furnace (smoker), Jamie & Kate rivalry (glass-trap decision), the desire to use Kate as leverage against Mark so that he'll become the new Ferry Man, etc. Du'met's plan doesn't hinge on Charlie being blamed - he just dangled some bait and let everyone in-fight.

[@kyun9840]

I like the way everyone is defending Erin because they like her

[@RopeDrink]

Defending the impressionable young intern who was under duress before everyone else, then shoved into a fake evidence room to have her loyalty forcefully tested by a former FBI profiler turned serial killer? The latest rookie/recruit who is playing it by ear under pressure, instead of an expert working on the clock in a professional environment? After weeks of unpaid labour, enduring Charlie's overbearing nature, and capable of discovering his desperation (eg. eviction notices)? Of course people will defend her. She's a likeable character, and the situation has two sides. I feel the same when I see people immediately hating on Charlie just because he's a desperate and overbearing addict trying to save his passion project. I love Charlie as a character, but I can also give you a shopping list of reasons as to why most people will do nothing but hate him before the dinner scene has even concluded, even when you try to play him 'nicely'. That's the joy of this situation. Both sides have justification, even if Charlie is (ultimately) not guilty.

[@tarajane1334]

I didn’t even know this was an option.. I must have missed something..

[@RoyalF0X]

*Can you please record it even MORE darker? I can almost see something there, this time* ... *>: (*

[@ShasOSwoll]

10:39 Considering how Charlie's weak tackle managed to floor Du'Met why didn't they all just jump him on the spot? xD

[@lynnx5444]

I don’t remember this part in jacks play through…is it because he got Erin killed?

[@Becksnnc]

Yes. Jack did find the tape though but it's just the clip of Charlie saying it was bullshit and that it was edited. A lot is omitted from Jack's playthrough because of Erin dying early sadly. She adds a lot of extra content if she's alive for a long time.

[@Coldzeroz]

my dumbass thinking that recording was real 😑😑😑 dw i still didnt tie him tho

[@iranoutofpuns]

Everybody calls Charlie a selfish idiot, yet they're all more selfish than him

[@cherylvictoria970]

Tbh ur wrong i love charlie but i have to admit he's the most selfish one of them

[@iranoutofpuns]

@@cherylvictoria970 after Kate yes, he is :) But he can evolve

[@bluuch1154]

He's fine

[@Chill527]

Luckily I didn't find everything in silver ash so she didn't find anything suspicious

[@WaddIes]

I watched about 7 different streamers play this game, and everyone basically had the exact same outcome /story

[@thealgerian3285]

Anyone with half a brain would've realized the message was edited, seeing how the killer loves to use recordings to make his "mannequins" say what he wants.

[@Reecma]

How did you do it and make erin hate him in my game she didn’t say anything 💀i wanna do the gulity trophy

[@zumabbar]

made her listen to the recording in the silver ash room?

[@Reecma]

@@zumabbar i did it actually but she didn’t say anything in the end

[@yan562]

I thin she needs to see the note of eviction in charlie's bag

[@Solararisa]

They did Charlie so dirty with the death animations. He had the most FOUL death animations, LMFAO.

[@baobaosang2740]

Their game is fine, but they started to not focus on character development. Which is kinda sad and bad. The characters are acting for the sake to create conflict, Like when Charlie saw the blood "Yeah, it's a bit odd" They are not creating a character that is 'loveable', more like unreasonable characters always fighting. which is super annoying.

[@eva-rz8gm]

Nah Charlie seeing a trail of blood on the floor and his only reaction is "it's a bit odd." is just a normal British thing

[@idk-wo8ry]

Erin and jamie is my fav fr 😻 but how come she can’t figure the audio is edited?

[@candyrayne215]

killer had time to carve his chest and kill charlie and attack mark in like 2 min smh

[@criminalchip2772]

yknow even if he has a knife its 5v1 right here

[@Wyllwho]

What comes up if Mark says nothing?

[@eddiesena2636]

Yall these comments are crazy when yall are Talking about Charlies body but i mean im not gonna lie it did catch my attention 🤭🤭

[@blueharvest14]

what was in charlie's mouth?

[@tanyaneilsen5680]

Yes it was the script that Kate edited

[@mmsss8803]

@@tanyaneilsen5680why did it say complicit on his chest even though he was innocent

[@CR42069]

thx for the spoilers with your thumbnail and title

[@Jason-688]

Better choose Erin Death in my own gameplay. Idk, i just hate her much much more than Charlie. Charlie just have a Smoking Issue that Made him fall in to trap once in Furnace thing, but Erin 🙂. Edit : 8:14 "I Know What I Heard" 🙂

[@nyxen8712]

Why was complicit marked on Charlie's chest tho

[@lookhoneyanabomination]

Several reasons come to mind, but I say it's because they thought he was Sus, so I guess it's mocking from Du met? Like "Oh? You thought he was in on it now he's dead."

[@pennyred2797]

I thnk he literally was - he says he accepted everything DuMet said without thinking because he wanted it to work so badly. He ignored countless red flags even while everyone expressed their discomfort or unease. He handwaved so much. He is definitely complicit - just not because of the recording at face value like Erin thought.

[@lookhoneyanabomination]

@@pennyred2797 I'd say he's more gullible than anything, I was sus of everything the moment the group got into that limo tbh.

[@lookhoneyanabomination]

@@foolspath Well yea, but that explanation is like defining a word with that same word xD

[@pennyred2797]

@@lookhoneyanabomination I'd disagree. I think there's a line between gullibility and willful ignorance. With each passing weird thing he chose willful ignorance. I was also suspicious of everything as a viewer (I'm not unfamiliar with Dark Pictures games so I knew they were in for a time), but Charlie flat out ignored and downplayed every downright suspicious occurrence - including blood smears (and this was *after* so much else that the others pointed out)!

[@no_0ption516]

Isn’t Erin a SOUND TECHNICIAN yall defending her even tho she has anxiety her profession should’ve had a major impact on that whole situation

[@mmsss8803]

I hated Erin the most lol. My favourite was kate

[@JellyfishButItHasAGun]

Your legit the complete opposite as me, though at the lighthouse she *was* annoying, like, really. Wasn’t as bad as some people in previous games, looking at you until dawn..

[@miloradowicz]

Kate may be a bitch, but she's the person with the most integrity. She's forgiving and understanding if Jamie chooses to save herself; she's willing to die a slow and painful death rather than be the reason the next five innocent people got lured into the death trap. Erin came across as nothing but a petulant child to me.

[@storiesbyJTK]

@@miloradowicz kate was just annoying & a jerk!

[@franklinaurelio6914]

This decision is just dumb Everybody know that you have to trust a PLAYABLE character And the game is from DARK PICTURES still a great game tho

[@Machina-me8sf]

One thing you learn from these games is that you always kill the non-playable characters when given the chance.

[@tylragor1653]

I really hated Erin in this game.

[@selebodys]

jamie haves a bad taste 💀

[@Timeliner01]

@@selebodys 💀

[@xionmastu4548]

Me when I don’t know good characters

[@deedreed7003]

And she is supposed to be sound engineer

[@BlockateBasketball]

gets treat like poop from the same guy: you suck..

[@TheCatloverCG]

I came to this vid wanting to see how many people were disturbed by his death now I'm just more disturbed with this comment section wth lol

[@jaesjmes5498]

Bro Erin was fucking tweaking that whole time wtf!? Bro I’d just run wtf!

[@nuttapongpunpipat918]

2:00 This is SPARTA!!

[@adrianpaulo7302]

But like, it looks normal to me. Unless i see abs. 👀

[@miloradowicz]

Second this. We want to see abs. And below too, because what if he was skipping the leg day...

[@harrypotterchannell]

What happens if you choose 'say nothing'?

[@haphoerart]

How did this scene happened tho, what are the choices? I never saw this 😭😭