The Full Story of GIMLI! | Middle Earth Lore

[@istari0]

Gimli exemplified what was best about dwarves while overcoming their least attractive traits. He's definitely one of their greatest.

[@KaineTheLongshot]

Well said

[@FireCrack83]

He made me fall in love with dwarfs. Its my most favorite fantasy race

[@MistahBryan]

I would like to think that MOST Dwarves would have stepped up as Gimli did after experiencing what he had with the Fellowship. Maybe having Gloin as a father helped as Gloin spoke kindly, if not highly of Bilbo Baggins to his son.

[@HinderYourGeneral]

Gimli has always been so underrated as I feel the movies downplay his achievements. I think Gimli deserves to be recognized as important to the dwarves as any other.

[@mikedench1110]

I think Gimli deserves recognition as one of the greatest dwarves because of his open mindedness in accepting Legolas as a true friend and his respectful adoration of Galadriel combined with his acceptance of the ents and Fangorn.

[@Thehomelessathlete]

He wanted galadriel nutttt

[@johns1625]

The part in the movie where he's scared to ask Galadriel for a strand of her hair and he's just completely emotionally crushed when she gives him three has made me cry more than once.

[@Jayjay-qe6um]

"Well, here's one dwarf she won't ensnare so easily. I have the eyes of a hawk and the ears of a fox." -- Gimli

[@hadleyscott1160]

Always wanted to add: and he smells like a dung pile to that line. lol

[@jay-1800]

And then before the dude leaves he gets what she wouldn’t even give Feanor

[@zekejeager2451]

"The dwarf breathes so loud we could've shot him in the dark". -Haldir homeboy

[@kingcrab1924]

Let them come there is still one dwarves yet in moria who still draws breath - Gimli

[@federicaesu8580]

Yes Gimli definitely deserves a place among the greatest Dwarves

[@danwinger1865]

I agree 100# that Lord Gimli was one of the greatest Dwarves ever! Also for him to go over sea with Prince Legolas attributes to his greatness as an Elf Friend.

[@legionarybooks13]

"There is one dwarf in Moria that still draws breath!" To answer the question at the end of the video, I will take it one step further and say that, not only was Gimli one of the greatest of his race, but one of the greatest characters in Tolkien's legendarium. We only see a sampling of this in the films, and even in the LOTR books. But when one delves deeper into his story, it is clear that he has among the greatest depth of any character chronicled in Middle Earth.

[@Greye13]

I totally agree with this.

[@mrdark9916]

Fuckin nerds.... Lol

[@HellfireHound-YT]

I had the great pleasure of meeting John rhyse-davies at comic con last year in November where he helped me propose to my now fiance. All while I wad wearing a replica of the one ring, passing on another ring and having a small chat about my love for gimlis character. From his bravery to his playful rivalry with legolas, he's easily always been one of my favourite characters from tolkeins works. Getting to meet him and have signatures done along with helping with a special part of my life is a moment ill never forget. Such an amazing man and a dwarf any fellowship wouldn't be complete without

[@michaelt.5672]

In the beliefs of the Dwarves, their creator Aule (whom they call Mahal) will rebuild the world after it is broken in the Battle of Battles, and the Dwarves will assist him in this act. With Gimli sailing to the undying lands, it's amazing to think that he would actually SEE Mahal with his own eyes. To the Elves, Valinor were a place to escape the suffering of Middle Earth, and a place to live in peace and happiness. To Gimli, it was all of that and more; He could live in peace, but still had a mission to look forward to. To him, Valinor was just a glimpse of an Arda that was to come. A template to improve upon.

[@Divine_Chareka]

Finally the video I've been waiting for. Thank you The Broken Sword! This legend truly deserve a video of his own

[@seanpoore2428]

Ya missed the part when Gimli found Pippin stuck under the troll he killed during the battle of the black gate :) saved our idiot boi's life!

[@lukefranklin7363]

Fathers of the dwarves! Great video, one of my main gripes with the movies is how they sold Gimli short. Awesome content lads and congrats on 100k

[@donweatherwax9318]

10:45 - LOL at the look on Celeborn's face, coming into into view from the right.

[@Dr_Cole]

To answer your question of the day requires an agreed upon definition for “one of the greatest dwarves.” If we define this as excelling in everything exclusively important to dwarves (mining, battle, maintaining the honor of dwarves, etc.), then he is likely one of many. If, however, we define this as making the world around him a better place, then Gimley is absolutely one of very few to attain this level. Having played an instrumental role in ending Sauron would be enough, but he was instrumental in restoring relationships between not only dwarves and elves, but between dwarves and men, he helped carry forward the history of dwarves for other races to remember, and so much more. In this definition, the question is almost silly to ask.

[@deancairney4619]

You should honestly cover all the subjects that you mentioned as deserving of their own video. Loving the content.

[@salazarway]

Just finished Would love to know more and more about the other Dwarf races. I see that most seems to have some kind of own history and culture

[@evenstar1608]

Watch the triology of the 'Hobbit'. It's the dwalves backstory. You also see the backstory of Legolas and Trandruil.

[@jamiegregg9211]

awesome vid James really enjoyed it hell yeah gimli is one of the greatest if not the greatest dwarf of middle - earth barring durin

[@BrianEthridge-wk6hz]

All of the videos you suggest I would like to give yes too cuz everyone of them you've made so far I always like it's always assume that we want to see something that you would want to do it's just that easy this is the best channel out there and I listened to every bit of content you have

[@noble1825]

My favorite LoTR character ❤️🪓 idk why but I’ve always loved the dwarves the most in any story.

[@lordofthehouseofstormcrows8615]

BARUK KHAZAD!! KHAZAD AI-MENU!! KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK!! You make the first hour of Monday work bearable. Thanks MELLON

[@annaroselarsen4218]

Aww he is my favorite character!

[@wally7268]

Now I wish in LOTR trilogy Gimli was more of that type of character then mostly comical

[@scottw5526]

Hell yes, Gimli was a cold serious killer, not comic relief. They diminished him by making him a joke.

[@Jannesverige]

I do love Gimli in Lotr.

[@korye6324]

Easily the most fearless character in the movies. Minus the one time he didn’t want to mess with the undead.

[@Diavolo]

congrats on 100k man

[@elite_rock_god2292]

Gimli is my favorite character in LOTRs and is The greatest dwarf Who ever lived.

[@chucknutly3290]

To talk of Dwarves and not mention Gimli son of Gloin would be strange. Gimli is a great character in the books and in the films.

[@rangerofthenorth1970]

Gimli is one of the greatest dwarves to have ever lived, he established the new dwarvish realm at Hornburg, he presented his people in one of the greatest quests ever taken in legendarium, he helped reestablished Moria....many great deeds and a phenomenal performance by J.R.Davies!!!!! James another great video, when is the live stream?!

[@nateorgain2495]

By far the greatest dwarf ever written into Tolkien’s works

[@SveninColorado]

Bravo! Yes, I would like to learn more about the Dwarves as individuals, their ancestry and Tolkien's take on them as a race.

[@christophereason7863]

Fathers of the Dwarves, though I know it all having read it myself many times, of course. I enjoy your narration and want my children to love this lore as much as I

[@kimberlysharp2780]

Beautifully done!

[@Greenmick6982]

Fathers of the Dwarves, x100 This is the best video you have done (for someone who reveres the dwarves above all the races of middle earth). So so so well put together. Thank you.

[@TheBrokenSword]

Thank you 😊

[@daanyd13]

Elves and dwarves relationship would be something cool to delve into! Great vid as always

[@AlexxxxAlpha]

I just wished that the last few Journeys of Gimli and Legolas will have a scene or movie on it's own!

[@vinyamar3604]

Great Vid 😁 Azaghâl, Lord of Belegost in the First Age, has to be my favourite though, hard as nails 💪🏻

[@scottjuhnke6825]

You tease us with these horrid questions! Of course more Dwarves! Gimli is underrated, largely because he is used for comic relief in the movies.

[@Nat1videos]

Yes!!! I didn't even know I was waiting for this video, but I was....

[@johnycoho7830]

Yes I completely agree. Gimli is one of the best Dwarves to ever live

[@mehere6865]

Gimli was not corrupted by wealth or the drive to obtain it, he sought the wealth to be found in lasting friendship which is why i think he was gifted not on hair but three by the lady Galadriel

[@kathyhamer6118]

Yes, he is one of the greatest dwarfs ever lived.

[@Huskytabby]

What-if video idea for you to do: What if Gandalf never fell at the Bridge of Khazad-dum and continued with the Fellowship to Lothlorien and forward?

[@johnt.inscrutable1545]

One of your videos about the whole history of the Dwarves would be most welcome.

[@ic3901]

Just made my commute!

[@PozerAdultRacingTeam]

I like that Gimli put aside dislike of elves to become friends with Legolas.

[@Thedawntempest]

Fathers of the Dwarves - the dwarves are my favorite Middle Earth race and I'd love to see a video about them

[@geistersound937]

'Golf' of Lune? at .44 seconds? Gimli: a fantastic deep character reduced to burping comic relief by Jackson in is revisionist movies.

[@redfrog2275]

Fathers of the dwarves for sure. That would be a great video.

[@salazarway]

I'm on a 1.30h train voyage right now. Pleased to have some good info right now

[@HardluckHutch]

🥹👍 I looove this! One of my favorite characters.

[@bobashmore6442]

Fathers of the dwarves. When an editor working on The Hobbit corrected Tolkien that the Oxford English Dictionary showed that the plural of dwarf was dwarfs, the author penned an angry letter back simply saying “I wrote the Oxford English Dictionary!”

[@susandolan9543]

Next to Thorin Oakenshield, yes Gimli would be one of the greatest dwarves ever.

[@MistahBryan]

@1:04, because there ARE no Dwarven Women. The Dwarves just "spring up out of the ground!" "It's the Beards...." Lol! :)

[@toddfeather5760]

Gimli is best dwalf and Thorin and Dain ironfoot close second and third on my opinion and carry on with the brilliant videos

[@Handz0r]

Fathers of the Dwarves...definitely

[@stevenmills3]

Gimli is one of favorite people in the movie!!

[@paulliston8561]

Gimli is the great champion of the Dwarven race. I find that he is the greatest dwarf in Middle-Earth, as he was not a king nor one destined for high leadership. He was a simple warrior and servant in the halls of Erebor. He served constantly......his family, his lord of Erebor, his companions in the Fellowship, his friends, Rohan, Gondor, King Elessar! Gimli's achievements set him apart because he did not chase a crown, riches, or greatness. Instead he pursued only his duty and his conscience, and this lead him to greatness to receive some of the highest honors from all the Free Races in Middle-Earth. A true champion indeed!

[@danielwindle7441]

Was the tree telperion in moria? I never read the books but believe I heard the Balrog was guarding the vein under the tree in which the rings where made. Iam assuming since they ran n2 Balrog thts would be where the tree was located

[@johnt.inscrutable1545]

Bridging the gap with many elves and attaining a spot on the last ship to the west makes him greatest.

[@lucasabel3642]

And yes gimili is without a doubt one of the greatest dwarves of middle earth. He did no much that few of his kind could and accomplished a multitude of feats

[@DOSHIELD]

Dwarven history and Elven history would be good to see.

[@mrcheaterson]

the only dwarf to reach the undying lands and "discoverer" of the glittering caves, favored by the lady galadriel? If he's not the best, he's certainly up there.

[@nilszeman-zachar9112]

Of course Gimli is one of the, if not the greatest dwarf to ever have lived, only head to head with Thorin Oakenshield and possibly Durin the 7th (if Durin the 7th fights in the Dagor Dagorath).

[@ShadowWizard123]

The dwarves of the elden times were undoubtedly physically stronger and accomplished than Gimli. The feats attributed to them are so impressive that they seem almost to be fairytale. However, Gimli is not comparable directly to those dwarves; Tolkien wants you to see that Gimli's openness to experience and philial love for the Elves and Men make him an entirely new and unique model for future dwarves to aspire to. If this general story arc sounds familiar at all, it's probably because it is taken directly from the Bible. In the Old Testament there are people living 900 years, saving all life on arks, destroying their enemies by blowing a horn. But the New Testament brings an entirely new model of how to live; what used to be 'eye for an eye' becomes 'turn the other cheek' and 'love thy neighbor'. The Numenoreans and Aragorn can be described in almost the exact same way. It's not nearly as on the nose about it's Christianity as a novel like Lion Witch And Wardrobe, but it's definitely there below the surface.

[@mrdark9916]

Dwarves are a long lived race.... Shithead Lol

[@ShadowWizard123]

@@mrdark9916 this may come as a shock to you, but there is more Tolkien than just the movies. Read about Dwarves in the First Age before you continue to look silly here.

[@mevb]

Gloin is not prounounced Glow-in but Gloy-n. Likewise Oin is prounounced Oy-n.

[@matthewanderson9754]

Deep dive into Dwarven royalty if there's more known now please!!! Dwarves deserve it, even if they're not part of Eru Illuvitars original plan...

[@aarondemiri486]

please do a video about the blue wizards

[@aarondemiri486]

@@e23g72 ooh thank you very much!

[@MeteoricMist]

Fathers of the Dwarves! I want it! Give me more! My heart thirsts for more knowledge!

[@ianmacdiarmid1249]

While I love the Peter Jackson films, my biggest issue with them is the portrayal of Gimli and the Dwarves in general. Legolas was massively OP.

[@psychocuda]

I still feel that Gimli was used too much as comic relief in Peter Jackson's films, and not as the serious and noble character he was written as by Tolkien.

[@scottw5526]

yes

[@BrianEthridge-wk6hz]

I honestly did not like gimli to begin with but after he met galadriel it humbled him out a lot and it changed him. He became somebody I would like to know and a good friend to legolas and everybody else he quit being such a hothead and that's kind of person I like. To me yes he would never get top spot but that's just because I don't know much about the rest of them

[@JdK3R]

Always thought this character had a cool personality, and after this video his was played magnificently.

[@ekamonthewise2395]

Fathers of the dwarves. Grant us this video

[@austinwilkes8556]

Fathers of the dwarves

[@lostpony4885]

Sleepy, Grumpy, Gimli my 3 fave dwarves

[@georgegleason3248]

yes i do agree that Gimli is one of the greatest Dwarves' that lived

[@Emixam9090]

Father of the dwarves

[@jasondrew5768]

Yes!

[@thomasbrown8468]

Love ya Gimli

[@counttommymarion7319]

Fathers of the Dwarves. You can check out second edition dungeons & dragons. There is almost 200 books. But it's the most accurate to real world and history including the critters

[@caseybranton812]

Yes he was hands down

[@dalepride8671]

Of what we know he is definitely in the top 3, But if Tolkien shared his thoughts more on the dwarves he'd be in the top 10

[@Greye13]

I believe Gimli is 'the greatest Dwarf' ever! in Middle Earth. The Lady Galadriel, having the ability to 'know' things, obviously thought well of Gimli and must have seen great things in him, otherwise she would not have gifted him three strands of her hair. This, as well as all of his other achievements, could cause him to become known as 'the greatest Dwarf' in Middle Earth.

[@ic3901]

Father's of the Dwarves!!!!!!!

[@ecoop20]

Fathers of the Dwarves!

[@garywhite189]

Fathers of the dwarves. Although I think it should be named "Dwarf Daddies"!

[@jordanlane870]

Father of the dwarves and yes gimli is one of the best

[@davepowder4020]

I gotta invite folks over to Lord of the Rings Online. The representation of Middle Earth is really quite good, and while I watch these videos, what I've traveled through in that game really makes it all nicely personal for me.

[@c5on]

Lotr is my favorite trilogy. I wish Gimli wasn't joke character in the trilogy.

[@AKPiratePrince]

Don't trust anyone who wouldn't put Gimli in a Top 5 of best Dwarves.

[@doublestarships646]

FATHERS OF THE DWARVES

[@pattonramming1988]

Gimli is the greatest dwarf of all of the third age

[@feykabah]

Not one of the greatest but in my humble opinion, the greatest of dwarfs!

[@Vestolord]

Father's of the dwarves. Let's do this

[@counttommymarion7319]

Interesting fact about dwarves, the women had beards as well, however the reason why a girl grows a beard is a high testosterone levels which means that she has a high sex drive at the time and her facial hair grows faster than normal. A woman can actually sport 6 to 8 in beard

[@michaels.ramsey7803]

Pikel Bouldershoulder is the greatest dwarf ever.

[@LycaonsMemories]

the big problem with this question is, we have so very little information on individual dwarves. so would gimli be the most impressive, probably not. make a top 10, maybe

[@pjhaywood1]

Why have you changed how you pronounce Gloin?? Your video on the dwarves of Thorins company you said it as they do in the movies. Never heard it pronounced glow-in before.

[@jprocha1570]

Yes Gimli is "one of the greatest Dwarves".

[@starkilr101]

Epic hero

[@khartog01]

Gimli is why dwarves are my favorite race in ttrpgs

[@kurumtelefon7148]

Whats ttrpgs, Blackadder?

[@khartog01]

@@kurumtelefon7148 tabletop roleplaying games like dungeons and dragons