The GENIUS Of Al Bukhari (I Am NOT Convinced)

[@islamtouni892]

Just to clarify a little more. There are Hadith that are called Mutawatir (recited repeatedly). meaning that multiple Sahaba (companions) transmitted the Hadith. Now, there are hundreds of Mutawatir Hadith in text (exact same words related by the narrators) and over 1000 Mutawatir Hadith in meaning (the wording is very close, but the meaning is the same). Think about it, if I ask 10 different people about what a person said, and they quote his exact words, I would have no doubt in accepting it. And if those 10 people were to tell me the same story but in their words, the number of testimony gives me a pretty clear insight into what happened. As for the Ahad (singular Hadith) present in Sahih Al-Bukhari, then yes, the video resumes simply the way he went about grading the Hadith. May Allah guide us all.

[@fadilxheka1232]

There are ahadith that could only witnessed or narrated by one, for example Aishah the prophets wife pbuh.

[@shahidachoudhury6925]

@@fadilxheka1232 Yes, and when Maa Ayesha describing there were not only one person. Same Mutawatir .

[@genseric3712]

not hundreds, only 120

[@islamtouni892]

@@genseric3712 Depending on the compilation, there are up to 300. However, most Ulama' agree between 100 and 200.

[@islamtouni892]

@@fadilxheka1232 Absolutely, the first Hadith in most Hadith books from Omar (RAA) about intention is a single narration. It is the Sanad that makes it authentic in this case. Jazakum Allah Khayran.

[@Zvarkove1]

The same people who transmitted to us the Quran they transmitted Hadith, Bukhari was living in the time of children of Tabiine (sons of Sahaba) so thr chains of Naration were so close to Prophet Mohamed PBUH .. his tremendous work has saved a lot of our Prophet tradition.

[@me2016]

No comparison, Quran was saved by Allah swt, if the people had a chance to corrupt Quran they would not hesitate

[@monosodiumglutemate8216]

You're kidding right? Hadith book was compiled around 230 years after the death of the prophet, which sons of those sahaba survived for 230 years?

[@dramaclips9022]

@Yusuf Talib he didn’t say the other Hadith’s are not Sahih. Like lots of other Hadith’s Imam Bukhari didn’t mention in his book. His student Imam Muslim did in his book. Just that those Hadith’s he put in Sahih Bukhari, he didn’t have any doubt.

[@shaggy8737]

That´s what you say, but you don´t know it for 100%... If the Quran say it is protected and there is no way to corrupt it, it´s not the same for the Bukhari... I mean they corrupted a whole religion like the christianity why do you think they can´t corrupt the bukhari ? we are not different than christians, arabs or muslim´s in that time could also make mistakes

[@me2016]

@@trueicecoldfire yes bro, as you said sahih Hadith should go through Quran, I think you mean it shouldn't contradict Quran, that how myself accept Hadith.

[@wisnupribadi6686]

i love the way you think. keep doing research bro, dont shut down your brain to learn about islam, may allah guide you and us all

[@faras010]

ALLAHﷻ

[@amiiina8769]

He said that he prayed Istikhara prayer. It's a special prayer, like you are asking for advice from God and it is very helpful every time

[@7years6months3days5hours7min]

When you pray Istikhara nothing will happen but the best .

[@de-addiction1681]

He is the great imam, scholar, leader of the believers in hadeeth, Abu ‘Abd-Allaah Muhammad ibn Ismaa’eel ibn Ibraaheem al-Bukhaari. He was born in Bukhaara in Shawwaal of 194 AH, and grew up as orphan. He lost his sight as a child, then Allaah restored to him his sight. He memorized hadeeth as a child, and he was a prodigy in that, may Allaah have mercy on him. The imams attested to his good memory, precision, knowledge, asceticism and worship. Imam Ahmad (may Allaah have mercy on him) said of him: Khorasan has never produced anyone like him. Ibn Khuzaymah (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: I have never seen anyone beneath the canopy of heaven who has more knowledge of the hadeeth of the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and who has memorized more (hadeeth) than al-Bukhaari. Al-Tirmidhi (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: I have never seen in Iraq or in Khorasan anyone with more knowledge of hadeeth criticism, history and isnaads than al-Bukhaari. Al-Bukhaari had more than one thousand shaykhs whom he met in the countries and cities to which he travelled. Among them were: Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Hammaad ibn Shaakir, Makki ibn Ibraaheem and Abu ‘Aasim al-Nabeel. Among those who narrated from al-Bukhaari were: Muslim ibn al-Hajjaaj the author of al-Saheeh; al-Tirmidhi; al-Nasaa’i; Muhammad ibn Nasr al-Marwazi; and many others. Al-Bukhari wrote many books, the most famous of which are: al-Jaami’ al-Saheeh; al-Tareekh al-Kabeer; al-Adab al-Mufrad; Khalq Af’aal al-‘Ibaad. He died, may Allaah have mercy on him, on the night of Eid al-Fitr, 256 AH.

[@alphawolf0777]

he was from Uzbekistan

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@dinostar7656]

@@syedbaqir2687 rafidha.🤫 Rawafidh/shiya sect are liars.

[@syedbaqir2687]

@@arab_dude Its still in ur bukhari. u make no sense. You just want to argue and start this blame game. Open your book for once and read how daughter of Prophet was hurted by abu bakr Bukhari 4240

[@azote339]

@@syedbaqir2687 Cite the entire hadith rafidi. Abu Bakr entered upon them, and then `Ali uttered Tashah-hud and said (to Abu Bakr), "We know well your superiority and what Allah has given you, and we are not jealous of the good what Allah has bestowed upon you, but you did not consult us in the question of the rule and we thought that we have got a right in it because of our near relationship to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) ." Thereupon Abu Bakr's eyes flowed with tears. And when Abu Bakr spoke, he said, "By Him in Whose Hand my soul is to keep good relations with the relatives of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) is dearer to me than to keep good relations with my own relatives. But as for the trouble which arose between me and you about his property, I will do my best to spend it according to what is good, and will not leave any rule or regulation which I saw Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) following, in disposing of it, but I will follow." On that `Ali said to Abu Bakr, "I promise to give you the oath of allegiance in this after noon."

[@mrstandupguy]

‘When I read the Quran, I felt guided, I felt it to be revelation from God’ says Bobby. You know what to do bro but Allah is the best of planners and he knows best In shaa Allah

[@samm7166]

Yes Stay with the quran only

[@homer1273]

yes stay away from these hadith its a fitnah

[@abdulkarimjabal2627]

But the same men who he is having doubts about them are the ones who transmitted the holy Quran!! Doubting the Hadith is indirect doubting the holy Quran Further more Allah said in the Quran that we should follow the teaching of prophet Muhammad (SAW) then how could we follow the way of the prophet lifestyle without Hadith?

[@rumblingsu1582]

@@homer1273 lol anti hadith detected

[@homer1273]

@Abdulkarim Jabal you don't know anything about hadith or Quran. They are not the same men who brought hadith and Quran, nor did false hadith have same history like the Quran. Bukhari alone suposedly memorized 600.000 hadith and then rejected 99% of the hadith. This did not happen to the Quran. No one collected 600.000 surahs of the Quran and then reject 99%

[@SohailJafar1]

Bobby, there is a good science behind the chain of narrations. This allows us to follow the Prophet (sws) because the hadiths are graded as sahih.

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@justamuslim2628]

Bro, chain of narration is not a science, it's a logical fallacy. Watch Hassan Al-Maliki's lectures. Conformist = Honest narrator Dissident = Liar How come? Isn't that unfair?

[@oman7787]

I would like it if someone could explain to him the concept of Tawator تواتر

[@oman7787]

@@justamuslim2628 Stop spreading misinformation. It is a great science that our umah is unique for. Even non-Muslim scholars testify for this especially in the field of history I believe

[@SohailJafar1]

@@justamuslim2628 When I mean science, I mean it is a system and method that is used to follow who have made these narrations etc. As for your questions, there were narrators who called themselves liars and so they wouldn't be trusted with what they said. Also, this doesn't mean a hadith gets lost forever, there are many chains of the same narration even if one chain is cancelled out. That is my understanding so far.

[@kamijo1412]

what i love about islam, they are very detailed and thorough

[@flameamvs6082]

Hello Bobby, I completely agree with you that the words might get corrupted over the years. I would recommend you watching videos about the types of hadiths to understand how we manage to differ the ones that may have been tampered with and the ones that are authentic.

[@RodriguesPaul360]

Brother Bobby thank you for this Akhi !! Your not the only one that has had these issues.. May Allah swt grant you and all your family and loved ones jannah Ameen Ameen Allahumma Ameen

[@marianur71]

It makes me cry. People always make the world tight by jealousy. What a legend! What a memorable life❤

[@foreverfamily5816]

Greatly beneficial video and your reaction is appreciated and beneficial as well. The takeaway here is ...... the amazing potential a soul can accomplish with complete focus, complete sincerity, and good intentions and seeking divine guidance. You are correct.....we should not put our complete faith in ordinary men. This extraordinary imam was an ordinary man who made great contributions by the will of God who deserves all the glory. However, i would certainly be more trusting of Imam Bukhari than listening to Kyle for example. I definitely learned something from your video today and i hope you takeaway a clear and positive view of the bigger picture. We all have a preordained destiny. What we do has a lasting affect whether we realize it in our lifetime or not. Hopefully we put our grand view in the right context. May we all be guided to the correct path.

[@jasonphipps2407]

my Journey is very similar to your own, found the Quran and was really inspired and then found the Hadiths and it reminds me of all the Church rules and regulations from all different sources that frustrated me in the first place. If not for that i would convert myself.

[@MRCroosingTootH]

I have same as you, but i have now submitted my self to Allah cause i do believe in the quran as the Word of Allah from the Messenger Muhammad (saw) Hadiths are problematic and the more you look in to the science of it and the books of these people you see there is no unity. Even the 322 Mutawatir Hadiths are contradictory to Quran. You have for example a mutawatir hadith that talks about the verse of stoning being forgotten out of the Quran but the narrator remember it being recited. Thus meaning that Quran is not complete and that stoning has been removed from the Quran? Just imagine this is one of the most authentic Hadiths and it’s contradictory? My recommendation as I am doing now after all the research of it I only believe in Hadiths that are Sahih (authentic) THAT either is confirmed by Quran in full (for example that you should pray) and then see what they say about praying since it’s oral and practical learning by everyone. But for example if a Hadith is saying bad things about dogs and contradicts Quran then I don’t believe in it or at least don’t act on it since Quran is first. Last of all, Quran is peace , way of life , helping others and first and foremost believing in Allah and only in Allah and obeying his messenger. All about being a good human nothing about weird semantics and weird rituals. Just my 2 cents :)

[@danidavino8275]

We appreciate your honesty and your searching for a better understanding and belief May Allah give you hidaya guidance to the truth inshallah

[@mohamedaburahma2519]

Bobby everyone learn on his own pace . I personally love hadeeth as an Arab I can appreciate its flavor. and I have trust in the generation before me in what they conveyed to us about the prophet. may god open your chest to islam

[@digitalboy4415]

He is one of his kind born once in centuries.

[@zubairhussain3645]

At the time of Al bukhari, Uzbekistan was part of persia and was predominantly ethnic persians. The region was known as khorasan and included most of Afghanistan and Turkmenistan as well.. Centuries later the turkish invasions changed the dynamic of the region somewhat and made turkic languages dominant.

[@agostocobain2729]

Exactly, and it’s pronounced “Bo-Khari” which in the Persian language means “heater” and Khorasan in the Persian language means “where the sun arrives” such a beautiful place word. The imam was a Persian through and through. Whether he was a Tajik Persian or western Persian doesn’t matter. His family converted to Islam from Zoroastrianism

[@yurTherapizt]

Arabic people was famous for their strong memory and these imams were extraordinary among them so the way Hadith was spread is whenever their new Hadith, it had to be announced publicly in musjid nabvi and if the person add or subtract any word from it that word was challenged and looked up for correction so the narrations of authentic hadiths is about how many people confirmed its truefulnness

[@RuleofThehyperbolic]

its very important to point out that the prophet (pbuh) heavily warned about distorting hadith to the point of some people at his time had to exactly say what he said or they would just not say it to any one if even a word they forgot, more over when different people spread the same hadith to different lands, the two lands would still have the same hadith generations after

[@MTaufikZoelkifli]

The authenticity of Bukhari's hadith is far more reliable than the authenticity of the New Testament and the Old Testament.

[@soniabenhamed8549]

I just finished an online course by Sh. Omar Sulaiman about the book "Heart softeners" by Imam Bukhari and his biography. His story has so much more to it. The course itself was a fantastic eye-opener. May Allah be pleased with him.

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@taylank6418]

Omar suleiman isn't anyone to take knowledge from.

[@baumapfel4463]

@@taylank6418 yes sadly he is pretty "liberal" for a muslim

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise...

[@danialassyrian4867]

Women defending islam is like chicken defending kfc🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@AK-ij7be]

BROTHER you are absolutely RIGHT human cannot avoid error by nature that’s why Allah took it upon him self alone to preserve the Quran but, saheh Al Bukari is very very very credible and the error within the book is far less then any other like it . I advise you to search about Emam Al-Albani on that matter.

[@greenado]

Love your criticism! I am learning together with you. One point to clearfiy, Bughary did a prayer, but not just a prayer, it's called istichara prayer. Like you said, you know many that pray, but still do corrupt thing, istichara prayer is asking Allah to guide you for certain things. Like, I want to write this hadidth, guide me to the truth. I want to buy that car, guide me to the best solution etc ... Keep up the good work. Keep critical and thanks a lot. Peace be upon you.

[@amexvr]

Bobby 11:24 Istikhara prayer is a prayer you make when you need Allahs guidance on a worldy matter, like if the job/woman/business/investment is good for you or any other important choices

[@amexvr]

The Answer of Allah comes then in multiple ways to confirm its good for you

[@alialmahdi7256]

@@amexvr Personally I wouldn't regard it as valid reasoning to make all of sahih al bukhari correct. If 100 people asked god if something is halal (lets say a new invetion) I assume that the 100 people wouldn't all get the same answer. I believe that some matters we shouldn't take istikhara in. Also he is a regular human. Not chosen by god or anything. He is still subject to wrong and that fact alone is enough to prove that he is prone to error. And if he is prone to error there is bound to be errors in sahih al bukhari.

[@amexvr]

@@alialmahdi7256 bro I just tried to describe Istikhara prayer, but yes you are right. Probably one of the reasons every generation of sholars study and analyse the work of humans on Islam.

[@alialmahdi7256]

@@amexvr yes and also, what is regarded as right by a scholar can be regarded by another scholars as wrong. So in the end i belive we should judge with our own critical thinking about each subject and analyse if it is in concordance with the quran. If there is nothing in the quran that touched this specific subject one is to do what he thinks is correct. Though it should be his own opinion and he shouldn't preach it as law.

[@amexvr]

@@alialmahdi7256 yeah I have a friend which thinks like that and in the end we should follow Quran and Sunnah with the sholars Allah gives us and not our desires or own logic.

[@canaaknight2305]

Hey man, been here since the beginnning and my journey as been right alongside yours with every video. I think Bukhari was very wise and has wisdom in his teachings, yet I also question the gamble we take when we believe the stories were told with such emotion, which could very well not have been what happened. God knows best and I only feel the connection with god grow stronger as I research. I hope the same is the case for you as well, brother. Stay safe

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise.

[@osamahomar8025]

Well I also question albukari story and all but this has nothing to do with the religion.. We worship the only God (ALLAH) and we follow the Quran and the Hadith that says what is matching with the Quran because we believe Mohammed peace be upon him is the word of God and he will not say anything that is not matching with the Quran so any Hadith that guides you to do what is not in the Quran don’t take it also any Hadith that tells story that is not matching with what is in the Quran don’t take it. You don’t need any emotional story to know the truth and the straight path just read the Quran with open mind and heart and Allah will guide you but only if you want the truth, may Allah guide you to the straight path because it is a simple concept just worship the one who deserves your worship the one who created you and don’t associate anything or anyone with him and follow his rules, the rules that he made for you and your peace because he doesn’t need your worship you need to worship him .this concept is the way for peace within ourselves may Allah bless you

[@Tata-ps4gy]

I also admire the hard work of Al-Bukhari but I reject his work. Everything the true hadith says must be contained in the Quran, that's why I don't take any secondary sources along side the words of God.

[@canaaknight2305]

@@osamahomar8025 that seems really fair, although let’s be honest. 95% of muslims don’t hold this belief and whenever I say I only follow what’s in the Quran it comes with a lot of decisiveness. You feel like you’re doing the right thing but that something is missing because of how everyone else around you is living

[@canaaknight2305]

@@Tata-ps4gy fair, although when we do that it comes with many people calling us kuffar or uneducated because we don’t believe all these Hadith narrators were trustworthy

[@محمدالجعلي-م2ت]

May Allah grant us and you Bobby to what he love

[@aaaaaaaaaaaa9023]

I recommend the video "Are Hadith reliable? A practical demonstration" It gives a small glimpse of the Hadith sciences.

[@GODSPEED_911]

Even though we are aware that there are some minor criticisms levelled at a few ahaadeeth that are recorded in Saheeh al-Bukhaari, we are certain that there is nothing wrong with applying the label of saheeh to all the ahaadeeth in the book, for the following reasons: 1. Most of the scholars and muhaddithoon think that Imam al-Bukhaari is in the right with regard to matters for which he was criticized. It is well known that it is not correct methodology to accept criticism just because it exists, rather it depends on evidence and proof. Al-Haafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allaah have mercy on him), in his great book Fath al-Baari and especially in his introduction which is called Hadiy al-Saari, discussed the answer to these minor criticisms, and explained what is correct. 2. The number of ahaadeeth in Saheeh al-Bukhaari, including repetitions - according to the numbering of Muhammad Fu’aad ‘Abd al-Baaqi (may Allaah have mercy on him) - is 7563. When we realize that the number of criticisms is less than twenty, and that most of these criticisms have to do with matters concerning the isnaads, or whether the hadeeth reaches the highest level of saheeh, or they have to do with one or two words in a hadeeth, and that the criticisms which have to do with matters affecting the soundness of the matn (text) are rare and affect no more than one or two or three ahaadeeth - when we know all that, we realize that applying the label of saheeh to everything that is in al-Bukhaari, texts and isnaads, is correct and cannot be denied. Imam al-Nawawi (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: The ummah is unanimously agreed that these two books are saheeh and it is obligatory to follow their ahaadeeth. End quote. Tahdheeb al-Asma’ wa’l-Lughaat (1/73). Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah said: There is no book beneath the canopy of heaven that is more sound than al-Bukhaari and Muslim, after the Qur’aan. End quote. Majmoo’ al-Fataawa (18/74).

[@notalkkkerrrrr3637]

My brother Allah says in the Quran ‘This book is complete and left without no DETAIL’ also he says in prayer make sure to put no partner next to me and what do we see in the 5 daily prayers? tashahud and the salutations. I’m not saying your wrong but if God says one thing and then you do another aren’t you going against it?

[@GODSPEED_911]

@@notalkkkerrrrr3637 if you refuse hadith, you refuse the sunnah, if you refuse sunnah you refuse the Prophet and if you refuse the Prophet that means you indirectly refuse the Quran because it was revealed on him. “And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it) , and fear Allah. Verily, Allah is Severe in punishment” [al-Hashr 59:7] “Say: "Obey Allah and obey the Messenger, but if you turn away, he (Messenger Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)) is only responsible for the duty placed on him (i.e. to convey Allah’s Message) and you for that placed on you. If you obey him, you shall be on the right guidance. The Messengers duty is only to convey (the message) in a clear way (i.e. to preach in a plain way)” [an-Noor 24:54] “We sent no Messenger, but to be obeyed by Allah’s Leave” [an-Nisa’ 4:64] “But no, by your Lord, they can have no Faith, until they make you (O Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)) judge in all disputes between them, and find in themselves no resistance against your decisions, and accept (them) with full submission” [an-Nisa’ 4:65].

[@baffevlogs5745]

@@notalkkkerrrrr3637 يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ۖ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى شَىْءٍۢ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ تُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْـَٔاخِرِ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ خَيْرٌۭ وَأَحْسَنُ تَأْوِيلًا ٥٩ O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution. Surah nisa ayah 59

[@notalkkkerrrrr3637]

@@baffevlogs5745 Obey the messenger, meaning his MESSAGE (which was the Quran) Following Allah and the prophet is the same thing. Allah told the people of the time to follow him, because his path was the true path. Allah knows best.

[@sacredrider]

@@notalkkkerrrrr3637 brother, the application, the details and much more things were revealed and shown to us through him. Even the physical movements of salah was taught to us by him, not in quran, the details etc. For you to simply refuse all his teachings would be ignorance, but who am I to tell you what to believe

[@serenity7857]

It’s understandable for a non Muslim to be skeptical of the Hadith’s; however, although the Quran is complete in of itself, Hadith’s are what we go to, to understand the Quran and apply it’s teachings! If you ever read the ahadiths you will see that they never contradict the Quran, they just make it easier to understand. Moreover, when we pray our five daily prayers, the routine you see is found in Hadiths, not the Quran! That’s just one example amongst many! As always God bless you, and may HE increase you in knowledge! 🤲🏻

[@Memoiana]

Sounds like made up stuff after the Koran was revealed.

[@wazzabanzook5028]

what are you talking about man, it's understandable even for a Muslim to be skeptical about alot of hadiths, yes alot are true but alot are fabricated aswell.

[@thesectless]

You are wrong brother, QURAN doesn't depend on other books to understand it. It's a not a normal book as its the Rope of Allah. And if you believe it's not easy to understand without other books you are rejecting many verses of Quran and becoming a QURAN rejector. May ALLAH guide all of us to the righteousness

[@serenity7857]

@@thesectless euh! Not it's not easy to understand! Not bcz you read the translation it makes it easy! Being an arab myself, arabic it's an extremely rich language that one word can mean so many different things. If we didn't have Hadiths we wouldn't be praying the way we do! So many things we believe in is derived from aHadiths, including the signs of day of judgement and much more! Being Sunni means following the Sunnah of prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and that is found in Hadiths! Don't make statements without backing anything up! We are not scholars so we can't speak from our heads! The big scholars all agree that we need both the Hadiths and Quran to live as a true Muslim! Ppl are already interpreting the quran to suit their needs. If anyone can interpret the quran theyll male haram things halal! That's the nature of humans!

[@thesectless]

@@serenity7857 you started with " it's not easy to understand" without giving any proof and suddenly changed the topic to "it's incomplete" as QURAN doesn't explain how to pray Salah. I can destroy your wrong approach in a single punch but I don't take " Confirmed" QURAN rejectors seriously. Salam

[@arwaa9163]

you have the right to think like this. you still needs more time to learn about Hadeath and Quran. its good to know the fundamental things in Islam and by time you will understand everything gradually and your mind will accept it naturally.

[@geriademi9368]

muhhamad didnt wat hadiths to be written

[@arwaa9163]

@@geriademi9368 : peace be upon him.

[@geriademi9368]

@@arwaa9163 does prophet muhamad gain anything from you saying that or is it that you gain?

[@arwaa9163]

@@geriademi9368 : its part of respect for our prophet peace be upon him. and we say that for all prophets too include prophet Jesses peace be upon him. and we gain good deeds Insha'Allah by saying these words> may Allah guide you to the right path for worshiping Him and by following His last message to all humanity. the message that prophet Mouhammad carried with love and honesty.

[@geriademi9368]

@@arwaa9163 well God will write every deed even in atom weight so that explains a lot , ty for response have a good day .

[@rasalkhaimah]

The Sunnah is the wisdom (al-hikmah) that is mentioned in the Quran in many verses, such as the following (interpretation of the meaning): “Similarly (to complete My Blessings on you), We have sent among you a Messenger (Muhammad) of your own, reciting to you Our Verses (the Qur’aan) and purifying you, and teaching you the Book (the Qur’aan) and the Hikmah (i.e. Sunnah, Islamic laws and Fiqh - jurisprudence), and teaching you that which you used not to know” al-Baqarah 2:151. The Authentic hadeeths are also revelations. As Allah said “Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. 4. It is only a Revelation revealed” [al-Najm 53:3-4]

[@infostatics]

Inshaallah, sometimes the Imam are of those people Allah loves for they have the characteristics of that waliyullah.. Keep learning, Allah surely guides whom seeking for the truth.. keep it up! Allah's willing, u will be fine. as long as u accept Allah is God, Prophet Muhammad is the messenger from Allah, inshaallah will be good

[@zerperior]

the prophet pbuh did mention that the best of people, are the two generations have him, also bukhari did have some miracules points in his life, Allah has blessed him, as long as we do not have a reason do doubt it we should it to our creator, trust that Allah swt has preserved this religion, and Allah has preserved it indeed, and only he knows best.

[@MddLud]

Hey bobby you should watch “many young adults are learning about islam” by Islamica definitely recommend! Asalam u alaikum ✌️

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@kemanakakimelangkah]

Keep it up, Bob ! Sending respect from Indonesia 🇲🇨

[@chucklarock8010]

No one is pointing fingers at you Bobby, you are on a path of knowledge.

[@s3sellsword]

i explored Islam deeply the last few months and followed it as close to sunnah as possible. Yesterday I went to my local Catholic parish and received absolution for my dabbling with Islam and then went to Mass today. It feels good to be back in the Church. I am also free to speak more freely with myself about the Haddith and how I found it odd to read. The Prophet giving advice on women's mensuration as well as saying after saying of how the Prophet's wives washed his semen out of his garments really took the 'holiness' out of Islam for me. I appreciate the point of Hadith in that through them Islam is able to keep coherency in the teachings (the same way the Catholic Church does with Christianity) and how it all falls apart when one strays from it (ie. Quran only Islamists, Protestant demoninations aplenty with their own interpretations).

[@Aa-dc2xu]

I'd recommend talking with Sheikh Uthman Ibn Farooq or especially Mufti Muhammad Ibn Muneer regarding questions to do with Hadiths. They would probably be able to clarify any doubts or questions for you.

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@justamuslim2628]

Bro, better to watch Hassan Al-Maliki's lectures.

[@samwon1]

I AGREE WITH BOBBY IN HIS ASSERTIONS THAT MEN ARE FALLIBLE. (Hence, a mistake or two at a minimum must have CREPT IN ! [given that many enemies of Islam also may have tried throughout history, and would still try to deceieve in future; and attempt some corrupting!] MOREOVER ALLAH PROMISED TO PROTECT THE QUR'AN (and no mention of protecting any hadith !!) So, like Bobby, I am. (...cautious, but with a healthy amount of trust!) (A pinch-of-SALT-skepticism may always be a safer approach !!)

[@idolwrecker]

May Allah swt showers infinite blessings on the ruh (soul) of imam Al bukhari Ra.

[@agostocobain2729]

You’re right. Khorasan was Persia, and it shrank when you look at it Persia today. He was a Persian, like a Tajik Persian. He also came from a Zoroastrian family that converted to Islam. Uzbekistan back then was Khorasan province, and was inhabited by Persians in Al Bukhari’s time. Later it got inhabited by Seljuk Turks. Bukhari through and through a Persian. Even “Bukhari” a Persian word that means “Heater”

[@Mohammed-jf2sp]

Brothers, hit the thumbs up so that the message reaches Bobby 9:09 For this reason (the possibility of a trustworthy memorizer man making mistakes), hadith scholars developed the science of Al elal, which searches for hidden errors in hadiths that appear to be authentic. This is a very accurate science, and it is often based on comparison between the narrations. This is from Google translation, and I wish I could explain more to you, but for lack of accuracy, I contented myself with this, and you must know Bobby that the knowledge of hadith is greater than you might think, and the secret of that is that God was the one who facilitated this Science and its rules to preserve hadith, because the Qur’an is not understood without hadith, and hadith is not known without special knowledge of it, so to preserve God book and its correct understanding, God preserve the hadith of his prophet through the science of hadith. I hope that you will collect your questions about the science of hadith and then ask them to a specialist in this science, such as Sheikh Othman.

[@anashabeeb3741]

Brother Bobby, you always impressed by Islam and I like that also regarding this narration of saying of the prophet, you sees as modern day transmission, but on those days peoples are usually very specific and they transmit it. Also, it seems to have a problem with the people writing prophet Muhammad sayings, but do you know in the Quran God said follow the leaders and imams, but if they contradict, then get back to Quran and prophet saying, so there’s many ways is Landon protected one of the way is these imams so as long as if they don’t contradict for the Quran, then you can take it you won’t be sinful.

[@JesusisaMuslim]

Bobby, you need to speak with either sheikh Uthman or Shamsi on Hadiths. They both are experts in this field.

[@justamuslim2628]

No bro, those people repeat the same propaganda over and over. Better for him to watch Hassan Al-Maliki's lectures. At least this man never uses logical fallacies.

[@ibrahim.ky_159]

Assalamu alaikum my brother ❤️😊

[@userfromdz]

He already did

[@Apache-t9o]

@@justamuslim2628 hahah rafithi

[@badmanbajing4965]

@@justamuslim2628 what do you mean repeat the same propaganda? Sheikh Utsman?

[@warriorpg3d776]

the point u made about the "telephone game" , it has to be said that these words arent whispered into somebody's ear, rather than people who knew each other and talked face to face loudly, aswell, back then when people used to speak the "fus ha" dialect of Arabic, it was very rare to find words that sounded similar (not saying there weren't any just stating that it was very rare), moving on, lets give you the benefit of the doubt and say maybe the narrarators did hear some words incorrectly, it ultimately wouldn't change the true meaning and main point of the hadith(s) I hope this narrows down your impression on how you think these hadiths had mistakes and how you don't have high trust in the hadiths generally. if this answer still doesn't satisfy you, id recommend asking a sheikh about these types of things, ask sheikh Uthman the next time you see him! Thank you bobby for actually giving your true and critical opinion on this matter and on your reactions and not just blindly agreeing with Islam for a few clicks, it shows that you're actually sincere in your search for the truth and I highly respect that. May Allah (SWT) guide us all to the truth.

[@rickroll3060]

Istikhara prayer is a special prayer in which one asks Allah for guidence for tough decisions. to make the right decisions with the guidence of Allah.

[@Ramirez83786]

If your istihara is accepted, you’ll be answered in your dream by color. Black/red is bad and white/green is good.

[@rickroll3060]

@@Ramirez83786 Not true. Not every guidence from Istikhara is a dream. In fact it is rarely a dream. More often Allah guides your heart regarding the matter.

[@1goal1]

@@Ramirez83786 look for more information about istikhara. Its not like that. Specific colors. I remember mufti menk explaining how it works. Its simple.

[@Leb.Mountain]

salam brother , may Allah bless all ur work u doing , as a muslim i would say i have the Quraan clear enough and I may respect hadith but i don't believe or I don't go with it , cause if Allah said in the Quraan and told prophet Mouhammad peace be upon him , This day I have perfected your religion for you and completed My favor to you. I have approved Islam to be your religion. That means that's it nothing to add nothing to remove .

[@remanalmersal5968]

Your right Bobby hadith was never meant to dictate Islam. Quran should be mentioned more then hadith. This alone should make people concerned.

[@malik2433]

You're scepticism is healthy. I also have an issue blinding trusting the chain of narration. We all know humans are fallible only god is perfect

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@Someone_KhabibbeatsJonesEASILY]

Then u are weak in Iman, the Sunna is protectes just as the Qur'an is, u are no Muslim if u deny a single Hadith, i'm sry but don't be surprised if u wake up as a Non-Muslim at the day of judgement.

[@ML-jw8kf]

Given that there are many 'Sahih'' hadiths that are downright contradictory to the Quran and are subversive in nature, I too am not impressed with the video. All of this reminds me of Imam Paul and the Bible.

[@Someone_KhabibbeatsJonesEASILY]

@@malik2433 Ur whole existence is weak u ignorant Jahil, u say "we all know humans are fallible 🤡" when literally it was humans who preserved the Qur'an, but that was only possible through ALLAH (SWT), the same God who preserves the Sunna u JAHIL, there are miracles and prophecies that confirm it, 160 Prophecies of the hour in Sunna whoch most of them came true JAHIL.

[@sakheef]

Bobby, I agree with you a 100%. As a Muslim, I find myself exclusively relying on the Quran. To rely on human endeavor which is prone to errors and politics is quite dangerous. I have no doubt that some of the hadiths we have today are authentic, nevertheless, there is no way for us to confirm with certainty its authenticity. The Quran states within it that it is complete and has details for everything.

[@IslamPlusOne]

Salaam bobby, take a look at "Allah and the Cosmos - ONE THRONE SECOND [S2 Part 1]" It's a series named Allah and the cosmos, it's really great and a must for every Muslim to watch.

[@ehsunn6494]

Yeah Bobby you'll love that series .. react to season 1 as well.

[@digitalhouse6969]

that is one of the most amazing series on youtube

[@TheWatchmanWebsite]

In Islam, the IMPOSTER of Jesus (Isa) is Kalimat Allah "word OF God" and the Qur'an alters the divinity of Jesus in the sense that Isa of the 7th century Qur'an is merely a prophet/Messenger who is "a confirmer of a word FROM God" (QS 3:39) or “an apostle of Allah, and His Word that He cast toward Mary and a spirit from Him.” (4:171) who is CREATED (QS 3:45-48). In Islam the word is not God as is expressed in John 1:1-3 (or Isaiah 9:6) where the Word/Son IS God and CREATOR. Muslims firmly insist that Muhammad is prophesied in Isaiah 29 and 42) so it would be the highest order of hypocriticy for Muslims to suddenly dismiss the book of Isaiah as unreliable! 700 years before John, God announces through the prophet Isaiah that He (God) will come to earth in the flesh and he (his glory) will be revealed to mankind (all flesh). "The voice of one crying in the wilderness: “Prepare the way of the LORD; Make straight in the desert A highway FOR OUR GOD. Every valley shall be exalted And every mountain and hill brought low; The crooked places shall be made straight And the rough places smooth; THE GLORY OF THE LORD shall be REVEALED, And all flesh shall SEE IT together; For the mouth of the Lord has spoken.” (Isaiah 40:3‭-‬5). From this verse-without a shadow of doubt-God himself was coming to the earth and would be SEEN in a human body (flesh) by all flesh (men). Jesus is the the brightness of God's GLORY (Hebrews 1:3). But who was to prepare the way for 'the Lord'/'our God'? "Behold, I send My messenger, and he shall clear the way before Me; and the Lord, whom ye seek, will SUDDENLY come to His TEMPLE, and the messenger of the COVENANT, whom ye delight in, behold, he cometh, saith the LORD of hosts." (Malachi 3:1) There are two messangers in this verse: First, the messanger that prepares the way (John the Baptist). The second messanger is "the messanger of the covenant". This is not John the Baptist because John did not deliver a message about a covenant. Jesus is the messenger of the new covenant of GRACE: "And of His fullness we have all received, and grace for grace. For the (covenant) LAW was given through Moses, but GRACE and truth came through Jesus Christ. (John 1:16‭-‬17). As stated previously, Malachi 3:1 says God would come to his TEMPLE. "Jesus answered and said to them, “Destroy this TEMPLE, and in three days I will raise it up.” Then the Jews said, “It has taken forty-six years to build this TEMPLE, and will You raise it up in three days?” But He was speaking of the TEMPLE of His BODY (John 2:19‭-‬21). So the temple YHVH refers to is the body of Yeshua. This gives us: "Behold! I (YHVH) send my messanger (John) and he (John) shall prepare the way before Me. And shall suddenly come into his (YHVH's) temple (Yeshua's body) the Lord (YHVH) whom you seek; and the messanger of the covenant (Yeshua) which you delight: behold, he (Yeshua) shall come", saith YHVH of hosts. What did Jesus say of John the Baptist? "For this is he of whom it is written: ‘Behold, I send My messenger before Your face, Who will prepare Your way before You.’ (Matthew 11:10). In announcing the news of Jesus's birth the angel says: 'Behold, a virgin shall be with child, and shall bring forth a son, And they shall call his name Emmanuel, which being interpreted is, GOD WITH US.' Matthew 1:23 (see Isaiah 9:6) What did John the Baptist-the messenger preparing the way for Jesus say when the Jews sent priests and Levites to ask if he was the Christ? He said: “I am ‘The voice of one crying in the wilderness: “Make straight the way of the Lord ,” ’AS THE PROPHET ISAIAH SAID.” (John 1:23). John the Baptist's mission, as prophesied in Micah 3:1, was to make way for Jesus, the Lord-for God, who would come in the flesh. "By this you know the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has COME IN THE FLESH is of God, and every spirit that does not confess that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is not of God. And THIS IS THE SPIRIT OF THE ANTICHRIST, which you have heard was coming, and is now already in the world." (I John 4:2‭-‬3) What is common between Islam and most heritic cults like Jehovah Witness and the Mormons? They deny John 1:1-that Jesus is the Word of God and IS God. Islam IS ANTICHRIST as it denies, as prophesied in Isaiah, that God would come in the flesh, in the form of the God-man-Jesus Christ. Allah of the Qur’an is an IMITATION of the true God of the Torah and Gospel (QS 29:46). The Qur'an is not the criterion (QS 25:1) which Muslims believe "corrects" the previous scriptures but rather the Qur'an is an abomination which OPPOSES the will, promises and covenants of the true God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Allah has no written historical records or oral tradition of his existence before 610, except as the pagan god, Hubal ("He who is Baal") worshipped at the centre of pagan worship in Mecca. Hubal was the Allah of the Kaaba. 1. Islam: the religion of Baal worship [start at the 19th minute mark] kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKS5m3Wkq5KtfNU 2. Allah's true identity exposed: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qKfbnKtmd9N0d5o

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@IslamPlusOne]

​@@TheWatchmanWebsite Why can't Jesus come back Now? What's stopping him, I thought he was god, And why did Jesus let Muhammad (pbuh) spread Islam and teach the complete religion before his death, and be the reason for billions to go to hell? Where was he? History says there were many chances for Muhamad to die or be killed and yet someone protected him to die a natural death, If he is god, why can't he just get rid of Satan/ego/evil, I thought he was all powerful? Indeed, Jesus/Isa (pbuh) can't do anything for himself let alone others, he is just another Prophet From God, sent to warn the Israelites and no more. Other than written text (mostly by anonymous writers) we don't have any evidence that Jesus was even a prophet, let alone being god, don't mean to offend, just open your eyes. Stop preaching against Islam and start becoming a follower of Jesus (Isa) (pbuh). If Christianity is true, God will guide whom he will towards it. And if Islam is true, God will guide whom he wills towards it.

[@muhammadbinibrahim6943]

Hi Bobby! I adore your accent. Keep up the good work!

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

Hey, thanks!

[@TariqHabibAfridi]

@@TheBobbysPerspective Just to clarify a little more. There are Hadith that are called Mutawatir (recited repeatedly from different chain of peoples from different places). meaning that multiple Sahaba (companions) transmitted the Hadith from which again multiple tabiun companions of sahaba narrated with similar words but same meaning. Now, there are hundreds of Mutawatir Hadith in text (exact same words related by the narrators) and over 1000 Mutawatir Hadith in meaning (the wording is very close, but the meaning is the same). Think about it, if I ask 10 different people about what a person said, and they quote his exact words, I would have no doubt in accepting it. And if those 10 people were to tell me the same story but in their words, the number of testimony gives me a pretty clear insight into what happened. As for the Ahad (singular Hadith) present in Sahih Al-Bukhari, then yes, the video resumes simply the way he went about grading the Hadith. May Allah guide us all.

[@zaanouniyassine8843]

Salem alikom, but in hadith there's not only one chain of narration, for one Hadith you can find multiple chain of narration from different people coming from different places that doesn't know each other, if all of them say the same hadith with their chain and by verifying their chain you can tell it's authentic or not, I think if they all agree on the authenticity of Hadith, that's another test passed

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise.

[@blackeagle5392]

@@syedbaqir2687 go beat your chest

[@aamaal84]

👍

[@EM_HARB]

You are right no human is sacred ..thats why you can revise Bukharis hadith and his criterias...and many Hadith scolars still do ...so it's still very objective

[@omarhassanfada]

May Allah bless. I wait every day for your new video. InshaAllah we will all continue watching you after becoming a Muslim lecturer

[@Boobajo7213]

Bobby I want to thank you so much for your open mind and heart. It's your own right to question and be skeptical...the journey is long and it's a test. My Allah guide you to your peace. Inshaallah.

[@Pekara121]

It is said that on his dzenaza (funeral) even the ones that were spreading lies about him, the ones who were his enemies, felt sadness (as they probably regret losing such a great man).

[@pombear127]

"It is said"

[@mohameda5947]

Bobby, the difference between broken telephone and this, is is this falls in to lesson giving, or teaching and learning, which follows certain principles including but not limited to verification and confirmation. When you are learning something you would repeat it back and check what you heard and ensure you heard it correctly, and it would generally be presented audibly, and clearly among other criteria for teaching and / or guiding. As for broken telephone, the information transmitted one way in a muddled whisper, and the listener often doesn’t, or isn’t required to verify And confirm what he or she has heard, and just continue passing on what they assumed the person said in the spirit of the game. However when guidance or lessons are being disseminated down, you would generally double check content and many times the point or lesson is repeated numerous times by the the teacher or by other pupils/ listeners, there by giving you ample opportunity to verify what’s been said.

[@edmus9167]

Zakir knows how much these old schoolars were gifted and he cant compare they are in a leauge of their own ..

[@nu-nisamiracle2401]

Bruh, those sCholars like iMam Al Bukhari is like an isLamic Super HuMan with their knowledges.. 😑

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@jangzstarr]

@Bobby, I appreciate the challenge/difficulty to wrap your head around and trust this process due to faults seen in other faiths and simple games we've played (Chinese Whispers etc) HOWEVER, Allah is thee greatest and will protect and preserve the practical bits shown and instructed by the prophet by a method that is sound and works! Think about it, Qur'an initially started off the same way, people heard, memorised as a community of people and those who memorised would be able to spot or correct any errors or additions immediately, they'd teach the Qur'an down to their students and there is a chain even in that regards just as we have the same with Hadith, if you can step away from the faults seen else where Islam does this right with the blessing given by Allah who is not weak to protect his religion for us now nearing the end of times... The fact we are VERY aware of those that are weak and fabricated hadiths and compared to those that are sound and authentic hadiths is enough proof that Islamic scholars (generation after generation) would never allow or advocate anything that would harm the believers faith or practise. Note: Hadith don't break the religion about the oneness of Allah, the pillars of Islam, the articles of faith etc, it aids in the how and what we do in the day to day... Hadith is yet another side of Islam that is so rich in its detail and strictness that it just glows with such awe and appreciate of Allah's beautiful religion to us. Don't make the mistake that 'mans word' as the same issue that Christianity has been plagued with and corrupted by anonymous authors that changed the belief and true sayings of Jesus and misguiding people away from true monotheism , Hadith does no such thing to Islam and Islam would not come to make the same mistake as Allah promises to preserve this final message! This shouldn't be a deal breaker and we need this as reference on how to do stuff as practising Muslims on the day to day. Sorry for the essay...

[@ahmadshahahmadi6661]

Proud to be Tajik and to have great men such as Bukhari, Imam Ghezali, Rumi, Avecina ...

[@aishasarwar174]

Allah doesn't like any kind of pride in humans.

[@ahmadshahahmadi6661]

@@aishasarwar174 You are wrong, it is not different when a family is around when their children achievements.

[@ahmadshahahmadi6661]

@@aishasarwar174 Also Allah doesn't like music instruments and locking up a bird that you have proudly put in your youtube display ;)

[@alizee4343]

So much different between albakhari and those bakahari sacrifice his life serve Islam gathered Hadith but these people spiritual,poem ,philosophy .

[@ahmadshahahmadi6661]

@@alizee4343 yes we are good in e ery feild

[@malenedietl3369]

Bobby, Bobby, dear Bobby, I really admire your insisting on studyingand digging thru different areas of Islam. You've come far and the Qur'an has your love, so why let the hadith stop you. As you say you can't worship a mortal man, the hadith is not made to be worshipped, it's a tool. I am a convert and I tried to dig a little into hadith, but gave it up, not that I reject it, not at all! I just decided to leave the study of it to others. I stick to the 40 Nawawi and some Qudsi hadith I allways loved the the 100 hadith qudsi, a book I have. Hadith don't confuse me anymore, they did 25 years ago. I am a sunni muslim in peace with hadith, knowing that hadith are an unseparable part of my faith, I use many of them, unknowingly for sure, because I am not a knower of them, but when I do wudu, pray, greet ppl, eat, say duas ect ect it's all thanks to hadith. Don't dig any deeper, you just risk getting confused. Take your shahada and you will automatically implement hadith in your daily life in a usefull balanced way. Things take time, maybe after some time, years, Allah only knows, you will come to truly understand the hadith and be able to use it as happily as you use the Quran. Or maybe not, that wont make you a bad muslim. Come on take your shahada, Bobby.

[@haziqmatsaleh9430]

Bobby i think you could have a dialogue with syeikh uthman about the science of hadith. If im not mistaken, he has a master degree in hadith. From what i knew Imam bukhari has the strictest disciplines in accepting hadith as a authentic hadith (not just that have been mention in the video only).

[@haziqmatsaleh9430]

@Dan M I'm sorry to tell you that the concept which tells us that we are born with a sin just doesn't makes sense to me. And then after that, to tell us that other people (or you call him son of god) sacrifice for me for the sin that we didn't commit at the the first place is just sounds nonsense to me. Plus, the story of prophet Abraham (PBUH) and his son sacrifice is not the same at all with the story of jesus that you believed in.

[@elynoorzai9407]

Brother you need to have another chat with sheikh uthman again he has studied Hadith in depth

[@Tawhidi]

The thought that the Prophet (P) wasn't infallible but Bukhari was is insane. 600K hadiths in 16 years and he sorted them all correctly? Meanwhile the sunni """sahih""" hadiths claim that the Prophet (P) could forget the QURAN!!! (bukhari:5038) And they also claim that he was influenced by Iblees (satanic verses episode). And of course this book was biased : there only are a few hadiths narrated by Imam Ali (as) when he was his oldest male sahaba and let's not even talk about the amount of those narrated by Fatima Zahra (as), the "mother of her father". And he didn't cite a single hadith from the Shia Imams while he was contemporaneous with the 10th and 11th Imams while the Prophet Muhammad (P) has said : I [Muhammad] left among you two treasures which, if you cling to them, you shall not be led into error after me. One of them is greater than the other: The book of God [Quran], which is a rope stretched from Heaven to Earth, and [the second one is] my progeny, my Ahl al-Bayt. These two shall not be parted until they return to the pool [of abundance in paradise, kawthar]. (mutawatir hadith)

[@hannibalm090009]

Bobby One very important condition on Sahih ahadith is that they have to have multiple chains, which basically decentralizes its authenticity like Blockchain nowadays. For example, If you have a Hadith and it has some wrong or different wordings, you'll catch that from the other chains and narrations that you already verified, then you can reach a concenses on the on that the majority of authenticated chains agree upon

[@ramatarawneh3293]

كلمتان خفيفتان على اللسان ثقيلتان في الميزان " سبحان الله وبحمده سبحان الله العظيم"

[@ojhib9518]

أذكر إن الشيخ عثمان الخميس قال تقريبا إن المرأة لا أضع صورها على منصات يستطيع الكل رؤية الصور فيها

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@ramatarawneh3293]

@@ojhib9518 صور نت وليست صورتي

[@ojhib9518]

@@ramatarawneh3293 الله يبارك فيك يا أستاذة لكن أيش الفرق عموما ممكن تبحثي أكثر في المسألة ممكن تشوفي موقع إسلام سؤال وجواب والله يجزيك خير

[@ramatarawneh3293]

@@ojhib9518 طيب بما انك عربي مثلي وعي الناس بأسس الاسلام ربما يسلم على يديك شخص وانا في كل موقع انشر كلمات من القرآن والحديث بارك الله فيك

[@محمد-ر6غ4ذ]

There are early *written* manuscripts of the Hadith that were used by Ahmed ibn Hanbal. He verified what he heard with what was written and saw that it matched perfectly. Not even a single difference between the manuscript and what was memorized by the narrator. That's just an example of how well preserved the Hadith are.

[@ibnadem6182]

Assalamu aleykum bobby. I recommend that you learn the strict criteria used in the science of hadith. The science of hadith has many branches. The lives of the narrators were kept down to the smallest detail. And these hadiths were learned by thousands of hadith circles and were told over and over again. It was not much different from memorizing the Qur'an. In an article I read before, which I can't remember exactly, they listen to their national epics from the mouth of a folk poet in a village in Bulgaria. And they see that this epic is almost exactly the same as the original. In the example of whispering in your ear that you mentioned in the video, the reason for the change in the spoken word may be that the spoken word cannot be heard clearly.

[@mtl_yg]

waleykum salam

[@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306]

When i first read the Quran i was amazed and i felt connection with God, it made sense so i accepted the Quran i then accepted “Islam”, what i failed to see is what i really accepted was Sunni Islam which is very different to the real Islam of the Quran, i studied what the hadiths were and I couldn’t believe that people believed this is what Islam was, people coming after Prophet Muhammad and collecting hearsay about him from other people who are all non prophets and then other non prophets have to decide for us which one of those are authentic and to be followed, and this is apparently the religion of God? I will stick with the Quran, the book that God and His messenger gave us. Sunnis and shia and different sects of islam differ on what hadiths to follow, but the Quran all sectarians agree on, why then do they not return to the Quran and see where they went astray? God foretold that this would happen- 45:6. These are God’s Verses which We recite to you in truth. In which hadith (narration) after God and His verses, will they believe? God knows what’s in each heart. Peace

[@acronyx991]

Even if you're skeptical of the hadith, you must learn to accept them, they help clarify so much of the Quran and the stories of the prophet and how he lived his life. We learn from the example of the prophet. Likewise you can learn about the most authentic hadiths and their criteria, they have a very strict criteria for being accepted as authentic. Much like the Quran, the hadith are a source of information that help guide you.

[@monaafni7693]

Salam, why do he need to accept something that Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta´la have not authorized? If you read the Quran it says that it is fully detailed and the only guidance.

[@aaliyah3037]

@@monaafni7693 And whose interpretation of the Quran should we follow? You wouldn't even know how to pray without hadiths.

[@SALAH-_-EDDINE_THE-IV]

@@aaliyah3037 الصلاة و الوضوء أشياء مذكورة في القران بشكل واضح لكن الفرق هنا أننا نصلي كما كان الرسول محمد يصلي لكن طريقة الصلاة حتما موجودة في القرآن هذا عكس بعض الاحاديث نجد أشياء لا أثر لها في القرآن ونجد أحاديث تعارض بعضها البعض واحاديث اخرى تعارض القرآن. بمعنى اخر ليس كل ما هو حديث يعني انه صحيح حتى لو كان موجود في كتاب اسمه صحيح البخاري أنا أتحدث عن نفسي لقد تعلمت كيف اصلي عن طريق اجدادي بدون ان اسمع حديث واحد عن كيفية الصلاة واجدادي تعلموها عن طريق اجدادهم الى ان نصل الى اول شخص كان يصلي بهذه الطريقة وهو النبي محمد ... لا ننكر كل الاحاديث لكن لا يمكن ان نتجاهل بعض الاحاديث التي من الواضح ان الرسول لم يقلها أبدا لأنها بشكل واضح تعارض القرآن وفي الكثير من الاحيان تعارض نفسها.

[@mightbyson]

He might become a Qur'anist; much better.

[@Tata-ps4gy]

@@aaliyah3037 and what interprstation of the hadith should we follow? You follow what you understand of the signs of God. You can ask other people to help you reflect.

[@bodesanad4328]

The thing is bobby, i agree with you about the possibility of error in transmition of anything but that possibility is gone when you give multiple exact word transmission of different narrators , that happens with the hadith and those are the degree of hadith, the other thing is the 600,000 hadiths each one isn't unique they get repeated but if the same saying is narrated from another route of narrators it is considered a different hadith hope u get what im trying to say.

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise...

[@saranasser9642]

He is the Paul of islam

[@sacredrider]

In the game of telephone you and your friends play, you usually can not hear what the other person said, and almost no one is praised for their good memory. The narrations however are all reliable, honest people with a really good memory. And they did not talk in secret, so the next narrator could clearly hear and memorize what was said.

[@mohammodc]

Many hadiths had multiple chains (mutawatir) of narrators so they were transmitted through multiple companions and tabi'een. When someone narrates a hadith from Spain and someone in Iraq narrates that same hadith but with a different chain of transmission and another person narrates it from elsewhere, that hadith is deemed authentic beyond all doubt.

[@raveneye3088]

I’m a revert myself and I also have a skepticism and fear of taking anything other than the Quran too seriously. Hadiths aren’t useless but I think we should be skeptical of them. They are not the word of Allah.

[@Pondermonarchie]

The trustworthiness of people is always questionable but the thing is if you read the books of ilm al rijal “science of men” which basically goes into the detailed biography of every individual in that link of narration and sheds a light on these individuals and examines their lifestyle along with their Islamic practices and mental capacities. It is a very precise science which reduces the chances of error greatly. It is still possible to say that Sahih al Bukhari isn’t a 100% accurate book but it is the most accurate and precise human written book in regards to the prophet peace be upon him.

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise.

[@nu-nisamiracle2401]

It is 100% Accurate..

[@rukkyxarat]

@@syedbaqir2687 they were Human being but they did a great job of spreading islam so dont bring the hatred into them

[@syedbaqir2687]

@@rukkyxarat Then he is not qualified to be caliph of muslims when he does not listen to Prophet's (S) warning and does not respect Prophet's daughter Bibi Fatima (Sa) THis is not new. Prophet warned sahabas many many times. This just shows how unimportant Prophet message was for them to not care about it and act so reckless. And u still defend them is amazing to me.

[@noorularfeen743]

I am very much impressed by IMAM AL BUKHARI'S memory. He set toughest criteria for authenticing Hadith. The greatest of all IMAM.

[@homer1273]

so you think all the 99% of the 600.000 that bukhari threw away was also sahih it just didnt reach his supposed "strict" criteria which mufti Abu layth showed was not strict at all. supposedly Bukhari would hide names of untrustworthy narrators by using surnames and names like Muhammed , so you cant know which Muhammed he means since many had the name Muhammed

[@Satarobi]

@@homer1273 abu layth😂😂😂😂 the same man who thinks lying isn’t haram or that isa عَلَيْهِ السَّلَامُ didn’t speak as a newborn.

[@homer1273]

@@Satarobi what has Abyu layth opinion on lying got to do with topic of bukhari. do you also reject non muslim scholars just because you dont agree with them on islam. this is the problem with some muslims like you behaving like a cult and raising scholars to level of saints. you either worship a scholar and treat them as saints, or you reject them completely.

[@homer1273]

@@Satarobi i dont agree with many things abu layth says especially things that are based on his opinions but that doesn't mean his wrong in everything. even things that are not based on opinion but facts of history of hadith

[@homer1273]

@@Satarobi do you deny that Bukhari used tadlees and deliberately used fake names to confuse his readers?

[@Khalid-ji6rs]

the trust we put in Sahih Al-Bukhari is not just because of the Narrators, but also because all the grand Scholars of that generation and the generations after it until this day could not point anything missing or not right about any single Hadith of the 7300 in the Book and the Prophet PBUH said that Allah will not unite the Nation of Islam 'Ummah' on error !! so whenever the great majority of the scholars have one united saying on a matter, it will be with Allah's will correct ! that's the faith we have in Sahih Al-Bukhari

[@bosaleh55777]

رحم الله الشيخ البخاري ضحى بحيات لخدمة الاسلام والعنايه بحديث رسول الله

[@shober16]

Dear brother, you can also watch videos about the pure Imams of Ahlulbayt (aleihi as salam). They (a) were the living love of Allah (swt). This would be nice. Greetings from Bavaria.

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@Jaymaleek]

Masha Allah

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@NMarkeTech]

This is the best you can get. These people did not have TV, radio and cellphones. They had their memories that were sound and if they were pious they wont make stuff up. Many of these people's biographies are known by many other people, not just one. So for those in the narrator chain they have to be the best of narrated tradition you can get on earth.

[@islamic10001]

Please don't compare Paul to these Imams, they are on high level in front of ALLAH and his Rasool.

[@emranba-abbad8335]

Most of the narrators were actually students who were taking notes. As for Imam Al Bukhari was an exception that he was committing to memory. However, when he was finalizing his book, he mostly relied on written accounts.

[@edmus9167]

I am muslim and I believe that Qur an is unchanged but Allah nowhere promised that Hadith - narrations will be 100 procent correct ..

[@Nonkohrrsaaa]

ofcourse u are a muslim

[@edmus9167]

@@Nonkohrrsaaa what about it

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise

[@nu-nisamiracle2401]

Sahih Hadith is 100% Correct.. that's why it's Graded Sahih.. but not the other Graded Hadith..

[@edmus9167]

@@syedbaqir2687 point being ? Sahaba were not perfect but they were among the best of people

[@ook19]

Brother Bobby, I watched some of your content lately and I’m really impressed with your journey and your critical eye on things, in search for the Truth. In my opinion and based on my experience you already reached it brother. الحق هو الله. God is the truth. Allahs words The Quran is the way. Allah swore by it and swore to protect it. And never forget that you became a Muslim because you read it… Alone. The fact that an intellect and a critical thinker like yourself with a Christian background converts to Islam just by reading the Quran sums up what I’m trying to say here ☝️. I watched one of your videos where you touched on the idea that in Christianity and many other religions, people left the message and worshiped the messenger.

[@moushippa4694]

You'r wrong Bobby hère realy wrong .

[@aliaouji]

جاء في كتاب " الملاحم " لأبي داود أن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم قال : ( يبعث الله على رأس كل مائة عام من يجدد لهذه الأمة أمر دينها )

[@muamerblazevic]

Well by that logic what can you believe of islam? We pray the way we pray because of the hadith it's not written in the Qur'an how many rakah to pray in which prayer. They lived with the Prophet saws and they not only memorised but thought about it non stop. Many people have movies that they love and they can say everything from like 10 different movies. How? Repetition and being concentrated and emotionally invested in what you're listening. The telephone game is a problematic analogy because you whisper and when you whisper it's not as easy to understand while if you just say once outloud clearly then everyone can repeat what you said without a mistake. The hadiths weren't whispered either it was something they thought about they would bring them joy and fear and hope. Nothing was more important than that so how can they forget or make a mistake?

[@syedbaqir2687]

Sahih bukhari Hadith Ref 4240-4241 *Abu bakr and umer* made daughter of Prophet Bibi Fatima(sa), leader of women in Paradise hurted so much that She (SA) died angry with them and asked Imam Ali (AS) to bury Her without informing them. Due to fadak. Lets not forget this is same fadak that usman being Ghani gifted it to his cousin marwan. *Prophet (S) used to warn "sahabas" many times and said* Fatima (S) is part of Me (S) whoever hurted Her hurted Me. Allah said in Quran: WHoever hurted Prophet hurted Allah. Bibi Fatima (SA) was well aware whether property fadak belonged to government, charity or Herself. She is not just an ordinary women (like umer used to say when abu bakr wanted to see Her). She is honoured by Allah to be leader of all women in paradise...

[@muamerblazevic]

@@syedbaqir2687 The property of prophets cannot be inherited

[@baselmhamed2145]

Hi Bobby, interesting video to say the least, and I do understand your skepticism. in the past few years, there were numerous campaigns against hadith and personalities like Al Bukhari , that forced us who lacked knowledge to seek it, and to get the proper picture on this I do strongly suggest talking to a Hadith scholar ( Like sheik Uthman Ibn Faruq , you already spoke to him once and he has an Ma on the matter so he will be able to explain a lot better than me) Hadith is different from Quran, you can easily lead yourself astray if you dive headlong without any prior knowledge. its like someone who never tried swimming and just dives into an ocean and expects not to drown. journey

[@tofie3852]

Lot of Hadith are wrooong !!! Go back to Qoran that’s the truth

[@BassamAbubassam]

اتق الله، اتق الله، اتق الله.

[@SoulReaver34]

My friend, having such a resource is a blessing in itself.If there was no such work, we would be exposed to a million times more strife than the strife that has occurred on the hadiths.I think it is as important as whether these hadiths are authentic or not. It has blocked the way to seditions that may occur later.Sit down and research if there is anything that might contradict the Quran.it's that simple.

[@mrx8080]

people always have conflicts, but if Allah wants to guide someone, he guides them, regardless whatever or whoever is in their way.

[@mrx8080]

@Dan M i honestly am qualified to answer any theological questions regarding the bible or any holy book. If your desire for truth is real, then you may search further and get to the people who can really answer your question or give you proper guidance, in the correct manner. the Bible was for a specific time and group of people, while the Quran is the timeless miracle of Allah, it belongs to all the ages of men and jinn that come after till the last hour.

[@mianzarrar3796]

We are trusting chain in which we can check every narrator

[@ishagabdulrazzak6298]

Today, many people quote and rely on hadhees more than the Quran. It is the Quran they should rely on.

[@ph0uad]

The main thing that helped me with accepting hadith is understanding that the Quran isn't the only thing that is preserved -- everything that is necessary for a Muslim to understand the Quran is also preserved. The Arabic language is preserved. The large Muslim community which recites and interprets the Quran is preserved. So naturally, the words and teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (SAW), the walking Quran, would also be preserved. It makes no sense that Allah would command us to follow the Prophet (SAW) while giving us no authentic way to do so.

[@AliaS69-y1l]

2 things: 1. What was the state of Hadeeth before Al Buchary began his work? How were the Ummah dealing with Hadeeth? 2. Fact: Qur`an reached us in a very different way. The noble Qur`an was read daily and repeatedly by the prophet and his community, memorized by hundreds and thousands during the time of the prophet (ص) and written down at his time. The way of how the noble Qur`an reached us is not the same how Hadeeth did.