The Genius Storytelling Tactics of It's a Wonderful Life | Writing the Catalyst & Dynamic Characters

Finally we have another episode of #CinematicStorytelling. Whether you're struggling with character development, choosing the most important scenes, or how to write a satisfying ending to a story, this movie is FULL of pro tips.
Hiii welcome back. I have been so excited to do an It's a Wonderful Life movie reaction! This is my favorite Christmas movie of all time, and, in this video, I show you why. In this video, we're doing a George Bailey character study and looking at writing tips from It's a Wonderful Life.
As I say in the opening, one of the main reasons why It's a Wonderful Life is the best Christmas movie is because it is TEXTBOOK storytelling. In this video, you'll learn about:
* how to write a dynamic character
* how effective a premise can be
* the difference between your character's INITIAL goal and the goal they end up having
* writing the catalyst part of a story
* the importance of a strong set-up
* character consistency and motivation
* how to write natural dialogue
* how to develop stronger characters who change slowly throughout your story
* SO MUCH MORE UGH
* TIMESTAMPS *
00:27 - film background
00:59 - movie starts
01:55 - starting "in medias res"
03:28 - introducing supernatural elements
03:59 - motivation for Clarence
04:35 - POV mash-up
05:18 - why telling works
05:51 - Harry falling into the ice
06:20 - write the beginning with the end in mind
07:30 - character development for George
08:29 - helping Mr. Gower
09:25 - keep the rest of your characters busy
10:10 - Bailey vs. Potter + framing
11:14 - character consistency for George
11:55 - frustrate your MC's efforts
12:52 - why George Bailey is the BEST T.T
13:50 - intro to George's family
14:17 - natural dialogue example
16:01 - theme/premise stated
17:14 - the catalyst
18:27 - George's internal conflict
19:40 - Uncle Billy as the foil?
19:49 - obstacle: run on the bank
20:56 - more character consistency for George
22:10 - Potter plays into George's struggle
22:36 - more internal struggle for George
23:52 - how George should have changed by now
24:16 - Bailey vs. Potter + framing again
24:43 - including passage of time
25:53 - UNCLE BILLY RUINS EVERYTHING UGH
26:53 - three types of irony
28:18 - "you're worth more dead than alive"
28:39 - the dark night of the soul
29:19 - George's lowest moment
29:59 - MORE character consistency for George
31:13 - "I wish I'd never been born"
31:21 - the first time George gets what he wants...
31:44 - George thwarts Clarence's goal
32:19 - life without George
32:56 - George doesn't accept things easily
33:38 - best line in the whole movie
34:29 - Harry's fate
34:48 - "you really had a wonderful life"
35:22 - how setup creates impact
36:41 - George accepts the premise
37:10 - the falling action
37:52 - the finale
38:57 - impact of the final scenes
39:24 - ending for Clarence
40:06 - final take-aways
* If you're working on a story and want help, let's work together! *
meganmaclaine.com
* Or, if you'd like to support this channel so I can keep doing what I do, join us at *
/ onwriting
* Hear Jimmy Stewart talk about It's a Wonderful Life: *
• James Stewart Talking ...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
This is an its a wonderful life reaction to several its a wonderful life scene from its a wonderful life movie | its a wonderful life explained | writing tips from famous movies | writing tips from movies. It fits as an its a wonderful life summary | it’s a wonderful life full movie | writer reacts to its a wonderful life | writing the catalyst | writing dynamic characters | movie reaction | storytelling tactics of its a wonderful life #writerreacts
*I claim no ownership over the film clips used in this video. All clips are included for educational purposes

[@OnWriting.]

Do you have a favorite Christmas movie? 🎄🎥

[@BKPrice]

Die Hard

[@ChromeVader]

This one. Also Die Hard. I grew up liking Jingle All the Way. I'm also a shameless Hallmark movie junky. Speaking of Hallmark Christmas movies, there's a Gary Sinise Hallmark Gold Crown movie called "Fallen Angel." It's fantastic, on a similar level to It's a Wonderful Life in terms of story quality and emotional impact, and I think you would really like it.

[@OnWriting.]

@@ChromeVader haha you gotta love a good Hallmark movie.... no shame😆. I love recs for good ones, too, so thank you for that!

[@val3kyria]

Besides all the silly Netflix ones (that seem to always include Vanessa Hudgens) I always loved the Polar express and Home Alone as a child ♥

[@johnmavroudis2054]

This film would DEFINITELY be tops on the list... but ANOTHER fantastic film (and it stars Jimmy Stewart, too!) is "THE SHOP AROUND THE CORNER"... which, again... is VERY well-written and I think you would love it. Then there's the story-telling brilliance of "A CHRISTMAS STORY" with Jean Sheppard providing wonderful narration. Great stuff!

[@melenatorr]

Also, I have to put in a word for poor Uncle Billy: one of the lines that gets lost in the scene taking place at his house is that he has looked for the money in rooms that "have been locked since I lost Laura." Billy is a widower, has apparently been one for many years, and the loss has been so strong that he cannot bear to go into certain rooms in his own house. This goes a long way to explain his general state of mind, and why the people around him are so tolerant. I feel we should be at least as tolerant as they are in the recognition of such a personal devastation.

[@Blue_KNIGHTglows]

Excellent Point 👏 As many times as I've watched this movie over the years (its my #1 Favorite) I've never caught that line ! I'm both Shocked and Impressed 😊 Thank you for pointing that out 👏

[@melenatorr]

@@Blue_KNIGHTglows It's hard to catch: I didn't notice it until fairly recently, and then started working on what that line could mean for Billy.

[@wgandy9541]

Wow! I've watched this movie probably 30 times and I had not caught that line.Wow! Thank you for pointing that out!

[@melenatorr]

@@wgandy9541 It really is a great movie in so many ways, and one of them is that there's always something new to catch!

[@OnWriting.]

Noooo don't get me empathizing with Uncle Billy!! Dang it! Haha. No, that's a great point and definitely a line I think I've always missed. Gosh darn it, how can I be mad at him now?

[@brianmonahan6838]

I was am elementary school teacher for 29 years. Although I didn't teach writing at your level, I really appreciate your dissection of this story. I learned a great deal about the advanced writing process. It is obvious to me that you are a very talented teacher. My one observation that I would like to add, is that so many young viewers of the movie today, cannot actually read the message from Clarence in the closing scene because they can't read cursive writing.

[@OnWriting.]

Aw thank you tons, this means a lot! And yesss I can’t believe kids don’t learn cursive anymore. That makes me so sad!

[@boomerbristol3774]

Instead of another typical reaction video, you gave us an excellent analysis of a beloved classic that I thoroughly enjoyed. Nicely done!

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you tons! This means a lot :)

[@seancosgrove1]

"To my big brother George. The richest man in town." Gets me every time

[@OnWriting.]

EVERY TIME. Yesss me too T.T

[@joeconcepts5552]

This is such an example of a movie that I think you can only "get" if you are older. I remember as a kid being sort of forced to watch this and just thinking it was a nice, okay movie. Then you live a little bit and start to understand George, and like him you've maybe started to appreciate simple things in life. It's very much a story that means different things depending on who the audience is.

[@disphoto]

No, kids in the 1960s got it when it started being played on television. Those kids brought it back from oblivion when it started appearing on TV every Christmas. I can't imagine a studio in Hollywood that would make this type of story today.

[@emilywolfe7319]

I agree. Anybody who watches this as a kid but hasn't watched it in adulthood... I HIGHLY recommend sitting down and REALLY watching it. I've heard it described as one of the few movies that can make grown men cry, FOR GOOD REASON, but only MEN and WOMEN, grownups, can really grasp it's gravity. For that reason I have decided not to watch it with my kids until they are teens. Not because it's inappropriate, but they won't be able to appreciate it yet. We watch lots of other Christmas movies, but I am very much looking forward to watching this with my kids when they understand more about the world.

[@HassoBenSoba]

One of the great screenplays of all time; almost flawless in its natural progression as we see George's selfless humanity save the town, while his own personal goals continue to spin out of control. One note: I would NEVER describe Uncle Billy as "arrogant"..no way. He's one of the most benign, good-hearted guys in town. He's just careless and forgetful, and was having a great time needling Potter (with that great line about "not every heel...") when he absent-mindedly handed him the money. Billy doesn't have a speck of arrogance about him.

[@Jessica-yy5wm]

I'm 15 minutes in, and i've already learned so much about writing; you have made me want to start writing again. Thank you for this.

[@OnWriting.]

Aw this is so great to hear! I'm so glad :)

[@phantombrakeman4983]

One of my, if not my favorite movies. Love your explanation on the writing. One thing I noted was George and Mr. Potter both have what I think is their hero's displayed in the background. Potter has a giant portrait of himself and a bust of Napolean. George has a photo on the wall of Peter Baily and one of Abe Lincoln.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! And haha that's awesome - great observation! Fits perfectly

[@thereisnopandemic]

Two different sides of the same coin.

[@moviewryter1985]

I was in my early 20s (~early 1990's) when I first watched this Masterpiece, nearly 30 years ago, and to this day it is still my all-time favorite movie. The story touches on just about every imaginable element of humanity, life and living -- from sacrifice, selflessness and courage, to battling with greed and evil, all among the importance of family, friends, community, love, and making a difference more than we know -- All timeless messages, so wonderfully portrayed, and that's why I love it so.

[@insanitypepper1740]

I don't have any training in writing or storytelling, but I am a sucker for a perfectly executed moment in a film. No matter how many times I've seen "It's a Wonderful Life", the last 10 seconds brings me to tears with the fullness of hope, joy, wonder, and the synchronicity of life and the human spirit all tuned to the rousing and wonderfully sentimental Auld Lange Syne. And the final coup de gras of the church bell ringing and celebrating Clarence's success in a lovely wink at the audience... gives me warm and trembly emotions I can't even explain in words.

[@TylerSmith-fl2jg]

I weep every time I see this, great perspectives on the narrative and cinematic parts of the movie. It's always a pleasure to get a professional viewpoint that validates what we all know, which is that this is just an amazing story and an amazing classic movie.

[@OnWriting.]

I do tooo 😭. Thank you for watching ❤️

[@sharkdentures3247]

Me too. Every Christmas I watch this and every Christmas I weep. Every. Single. Time. That ending is SO beautiful, touching and just purely "good", it is practically a Pavlovian response now. Even if I 'steel' myself, when everyone runs into George's home to save him, my tear ducts are flowing by the time I hear the words, "The richest man in town."! Love this movie. And I enjoyed this great analysis of it.

[@OnWriting.]

I'm right there with you! And so glad you enjoyed this! :) @@sharkdentures3247

[@geoffmower8729]

I love the way the director uses snowing and not snowing to help distinguish when George doesn't exist and when he comes back brilliant.

[@chadbennett7873]

Not just my favorite Christmas movie, but my favorite All-Time movie! I have a Frank Capra signed photo on my wall as inspiration for my own writing. Nice analysis!

[@OnWriting.]

Aw, that's great! It's so great. Thanks for watching :)

[@jasonjanisewski78]

It isn't only the Greatest Christmas movie ever but possibly the Greatest Movie ever. Other movies may have been more innovative, have superior cinematography, have more plot twists, etc. However, at the end of the day, those are merely tools that one utilizes to entertain and enthrall the viewer. Hardly any movies can match its charm and how much you invest in the main character. Possibly the Greatest Ending in all of cinema that within minutes transforms a tragedy into the ultimate tale of inspiration and hope cements its position among cinema's greatest.

[@Mpshfromlowell64]

The young actor, Bobby Anderson, who plays the youthful George does a great job in establishing George’s character; he basically does the heavy lifting so that by the time James Stewart appears as the adult George, the audience likes and roots for the character even before Stewart delivers a single line….

[@OnWriting.]

So true!!

[@disphoto]

Excellent insight into the storytelling of It's a Wonderful Life. I appreciate the emotion you showed at the key scene. By far, my favorite movie (I have literally seen it about 50 times). One thing: I think you skipped over one of the most impactful scenes when, after his father died, they wanted him to run the bank or "they'll vote with Potter otherwise."

[@OnWriting.]

Yesss I know I had to cut a lot to keep this from being just as long as the movie haha. That’s such a good moment tho! Glad you enjoyed the vid! 🥹

[@thomaswilson8530]

@@OnWriting. I mean this sincerely and if you don't want to that's understandable, but would love to see a super long version of your takes on this movie. :)

[@OnWriting.]

I could talk about it all day! Would love to do another version that's longer. I did hit some copyright snags with this one, unfortunately, but I'll see what I can do when the season rolls around again. So glad you enjoyed this, Thomas!@@thomaswilson8530

[@alanberg5575]

This is, perhaps, as close to a perfect piece of story-telling as any film ever. By the way, it's my absolute favorite movie of all time! Also, I've seen this film dozens of times, and I cry EVERY time---and I'm not embarrassed to admit it!

[@OnWriting.]

No shame in those tears!!

[@757optim]

"Casablanca: and "It's A Wonderful Life" raise the movie bar of the '40s to extraordinary. The scene with Mary and Vi at the counter is a great set-up for their later roles. In addition to Clarence, of course, Mary is George's Guardian Angel.

[@OnWriting.]

Yess haha I love that early scene with Mary and Violet. "I'm still thinking" is precious haha

[@billyjac274]

I tear up every time I watch it. One of my favorite movies, Christmas or otherwise! 🎄

[@rbl4641]

It's an absolute masterpiece, of course, but in the old maid scene, the glasses can't hide the stunning beauty of Donna Reed...

[@OnWriting.]

Too true!

[@custardflan]

"is he sick?" "Worse. He's discouraged." Love it. (sniff)

[@OnWriting.]

🥹

[@warmongeir8427]

The part that gets me is when George is asking for money from Mr. Potter and George states "HE misplaced the $8000", Potter then emphasizes "YOU misplaced $8000" when Potter knew Uncle Billy was the actual person who messed up. That banter just showed how much of George's selflessness to others was the willingness to sacrifice himself over anything else. Enormous effort from the writers to subliminally implant that in the reader's/viewer's brain.

[@perrydubreuil1514]

I like the crack about the Mallennials

[@OnWriting.]

:P

[@TedLittle-yp7uj]

Thank you for this inciteful review. One element that I wish you had had time to explore was the use of repetition. For example, Clarence wants wings, George wants to "spread his wings," Harry becomes a naval flyer, waiting for Harry's train, George mentions plane engines as one of the greatest sounds, and in the dinner scene, George's butterfly collection is on display behind his father and the collection appears again behind George at the end. When George proposes a date with Violet, he suggests they smell the pines and later complains that Mary's house smells of pine needles. There is also tremendous consistency in all the characters George helps. When he doesn't exist, Mr Gower goes from a man who faces stress by drinking to being a homeless alcoholic, Violet goes from being a flirt to being a prostitute, Uncle Billy goes from being a lovable eccentric to the insanity in an asylum, and Mary, having no one to love till the day she dies, becomes an old maid. Another interesting point (at least to me) is that, though the whole town prays for George, Clarence does not appear until after George himself asks for God to show him the way and, though George shouts for Clarence to bring him back, it does not happen until he asks God to let him live again. It seems to me that repetition is essential to art.

[@62impalaconvert]

I've been watching this for at least 50 years and I am still picking up nuances like the ripping up of the arrest warrant, which I always thought was a bank loan paper. It makes more sense.

[@OnWriting.]

So many perfect details 😩😍

[@okay5045]

This was a great reaction video. But I think you could have added more about Mary's character. Her character was a rescuer and she could see the future in that she saw George for what he could be she so his potential as a husband and she saw the potential of the he broken down house as a home and where George is read to give up because he would not let others in on his problems. Mary was open and knew that once people found out George was in trouble that would help. I don't know what they call her in writing terms but she is pivitol to the story because she was always the optimistist.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you so much!! And yessss, I really wanted to talk about Mary more. She is so instrumental to the story. I did have more on her originally, but cut most of that out in editing to keep this from being even longer haha :(. She's so great, though!

[@michaelt6218]

@@OnWriting. In many ways, I think Mary is the real "hero" of the story, even more than Clarence, who's just doing his job, or George, whose life is mostly driven by circumstance. I really like both of those characters, but it's Mary whom we see always standing strong in times of trouble, smoothing the way so that others can get their big moments.

[@OnWriting.]

So true :')

[@vly9257]

Thanks for this comment thread. I was thinking how it would be nice to study more on the development of side characters, like Mary and Uncle Billy, but that it would make your video too long. It might be a nice separate offering someday. On Mary, I recently saw an article written about her on the premise that people didn't believe that she would have become an old maid, and even someone in these comments mentioned that it was an outdated concept. I think that people don't appreciate how different it would have been to choose to be single in the early 20th century; as a woman who couldn't get credit on her own, and wasn't welcome in much of the workforce, or as a man who wouldn't have been taught to cook or clean or care for a home. Especially in a small town... there is probably something to pick up about it in Violet's character arc. Another commenter says that the original story planned for Mary to be married to an abusive husband. I've never heard that but 😨... In the end, I think I agree with the article that it is believable that Mary could choose to stay single and to choose an enriching career of helping people expand their world through books. Absent George, she never showed any interest in another man, certainly not Sam who always seemed to have another woman around whenever he talked to her. And I can imagine she'd become a potentially beloved figure in the booklovers of the town. 😊

[@lorendigiorgi]

What a great perspective hearing this from a writer’s point of view! Loved this.

[@OnWriting.]

Aw thank you so much! Glad you enjoyed it ❤️

[@ninevoices9401]

We love George because he is the saviour of the town from Potter. We love Clarence because he saves George's life and shows what a difference he has made. But I don't thnk we give enough praise to Mary's character. She is the one who truly saves George in the end. One of the most important lines in the film is at the end when Billy says "Mary did it". She went round town and rallied everyone to help. When george stops Mr Gower from poisoning a kid, Mary is witness to the whole thing. George promises to never tell, but Mary never tells either. When there is a run on the bank and everyone wants money, it isn't George's idea to use the honeymoon cash. Mary holds it aloft and says "How much do you need". She is just as selfless. She already knows and accepts the truth that George has yet to appreciate. That he has a wonderful life.

[@Francisco-xu8ef]

I wanted Megan to talk more about Mary as well. I've watched this movie like 3 dozen times, and I only recently have noticed the importance of Mary being there at the drug store and overhearing what happened with Mr. Gower and the medicine/poison mix-up. Not only is it a big deal that Mary never told a soul either, but it also shows what motivates her character throughout the movie. She doesn't just have a crush on George for no reason, Mary knows George is an unsung hero.

[@OnWriting.]

Yes Mary is totally the unsung hero

[@custardflan]

I knew what media res is, but one of the great explanations is in Amor Towles' "Lincoln Highway," even though it does not begin in media res.

[@thomaswilson8530]

Not sure if you've read about this, but Jimmy Stewart, right in line with George Bailey, joined the WW2 effort and became a pilot flying and leading many very dangerous missions. This movie was not long after WW2 ended and many soldiers including Stewart were dealing with post-traumatic stress. There are some good articles which explain and appears Stewart confirmed that this movie's dark side allowed Stewart to work through some of that stress, trauma and grief. Stewart I believe said he almost didn't take the part and Capra was dogged in having him take it. And I assume you know Capra's background and other movies. Not sure if you've seen Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, but that's another Capra gem starring Stewart.

[@ginnyjollykidd]

One thing I got was George's resistance to the whole premise his father outlined. At each turn George denies the truth and what his wish is showing him. Another turning point is the moment he tries to meet Mary and she screams in fright at him. Now George accepts. He's been shown to his face that the one thing he could always count on isn't there. That's when he makes his decision. Another thing I noticed is a barrage of parallelisms: between his father and himself. Mary's contrast since she married to avoid being an old maid. Potter trying to steal from George: first during the run on the Building and Loan and then when Uncle Billy was at the bank. (BTW: Mr. Potter committed grand larceny when he didn't return the money). And a big parallelism between the run on the B&L and the people of Bedford Falls offering their own money to help George because he helped build the community with his selflessness. "This is just a loan," George would say. "Pay it back when you can." This also tells me a good story doesn't have to be completely true to life. While George lends out his own honeymoon money and receives money at the end, they don't say how he balances the books. The people of the town help him out, but they don't have 8,000.00 in the town. At least they acknowledge that and have Sam telegram real help. We can then feel alright about that. (Still not the whole financial story.) My first novel fell straight out of my head. As I try to write outside of that arc, it's like pulling teeth. I realized a long time ago that there wasn't anything for my protagonist to overcome. All my side characters are "movie extras." I only recently gave some character to two of my characters, and I found a big obstacle for my MC to surmount and grow from. I know a little more about writing from your video, and I can incorporate a bit of everything in my story. I think my takeaway I hadn't thought of before idea to give side characters interactions with each other apart from the MC. Thanks

[@mikeshirleyforever]

Absolutely lovely narration, Megan. You have a wonderful voice. One of my favourite films of all time and yes, it is certainly a classic!!!

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it. It certainly is :)

[@EricAntonsen-uz2tq]

I’m so glad I found your channel here! I am also so very glad I found someone who loves this movie almost as much as I do too! As a fellow writer, I really appreciated your breakdown of this type of story and I will now go and watch all of your other videos! Thank You !

[@OnWriting.]

Aw yay welcome! Glad you’re here :)

[@clurkroberts2650]

This is one of the finest analysis of this film I’ve seen. I have always found the plot and script to be the backbone of this movie, all derived from a very simple Christmas story. Thank you for detailing the structure and points of the story which were carefully wove together to form this heartwarming Christmas tale.

[@OnWriting.]

Wow, thanks! I really appreciate it. So glad you enjoyed it :)

[@amurmurmur609]

I never noticed that George added the coconut even though Mary said the she disliked it 😄 And that job-offer scene wasn’t 1946. They had not had any kids yet. If the movie was meant to have it’s final scene in 1946, you have to subtract the age of his oldest kid to get the approximate date of that scene.

[@wrob08]

Or add it to the 12 in 1919 since Potter says how old he is.

[@coolaunt516]

Everybody cries at the end of this movie. No exception.

[@user-ph8cv7mf8s]

There are other brilliant examples of Capra showing not telling in George 'becoming ' a type of his father, as when Peter's framed picture during the board meeting is eclipsed and filled with George's own face as he leans towards Potter. Insightful, enriching analysis, by the way, from the literary perspective. Your responses are beautiful. I watch all first watches to this, my favorite film of all time. God bless you - you are doing so much good for folks...

[@OnWriting.]

Love this point! I'd never noticed the contrast between the authority figures in both mens' offices, too. For Potter, himself and Napoleon. For George, his father, Lincoln, etc. Another person commented about that, and I thought it was awesome! Thanks so much for watching, and I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@thomaswilson8530]

@@OnWriting. Also the 1939 film Mr. Smith Goes to Washington which predates this and was directed by Capra has a very dark soul scene which is significant at the Lincoln Memorial so Lincoln being there as authority figure would have been a less direct call back to that as well.

[@scottbooker8602]

This movie and A Christmas Carol are treasures. They both bring a sense of spirituality and personal reflection during the holidays and start of the new year. Love your analysis,..new subscriber.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you!! Glad you're here ^.^

[@larrycrawley-woods4515]

I think this film has all the elements of the classic "heroic journey" tale, going back to the Golden Age of Greece, if not before. (The Bible, both Jewish and Christian scriptures, is replete with them) In part, I believe this movie resonates so much and well with an audience because it elicits self-consciousness of one's own heroic journey in life....and we are each on one....though ours might not be as obvious, dramatic or sentimental. (Don't get me wrong, I mostly like the movie because it simply makes me feel good, still teary-eyed and sighing deeply at 75 years of age) I feel fortunate that I have lived long enough to behold such tales now being told from the female perspective rather than the male, as has been generally true throughout history. (Perhaps this weekend I will again have the great fun of watching "Moana" or "Frozen" with my four-year-old granddaughter)

[@OnWriting.]

Definitely - love these points. Thanks for sharing it ^.^ The film definitely gets you in a more self-reflective place (well, it gets me there at least haha)

[@emilywolfe7319]

I heard the book that this movie was based off of ("The Greatest Gift") actually took the Book of Job as a template/inspiration. It very much is age old, and the heros journey 💓

[@aw3752]

I think I’m in love. You are so beautiful and intelligent. I loved your analysis of this- my favorite movie of all time. I’ve never seen anyone break it down like this. You’re amazing. I’m definitely subscribing. 😘

[@OnWriting.]

Haha oh goodness. Thanks for your support! And I'm glad you enjoyed the video. This film is just perfection ^.^

[@001Flange]

Tom, who takes his full $242 during the bank run, is one of very first to show up at George's house to give money at the end.

[@OnWriting.]

Oh Tom 🥺

[@user-ph8cv7mf8s]

His exact line to George is an ironic, jovial "Another run on the bank"...

[@philpascali4070]

it's a wonderful movie , I have seen it many times and each time I do cry to , how can't we if we are human , if we are or try to be good people , how would not want to be like george , helping others in whatever ways we can , as small or big , even my first time seeing you , I wish you a merry x-mas and a lot good things for next year 🥳

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! Merry Christmas to you as well!

[@tnae]

It’s not much but I joined your channel membership. After watching this video. As someone who used to dream of being a writer and who is an aspiring filmmaker, working actor and creator here on KZbin, I so greatly appreciate the value that you offer in your content. You’re truly remarkable and I am glad to be able to support your work, in my own small way. I’m looking forward to seeing more videos from you.

[@OnWriting.]

Ohhh thank you so much! 🥹 That means a ton!! I’m so glad you’re getting a lot out of them ❤️

[@tnae]

​@@OnWriting. Absolutely! Maybe one day we can find an opportunity to collaborate. Happy holidays ☃

[@AQuietNight]

Pure Frank Capra who directed films like It Happened One Night and Meet John Doe (which smacks of It's A Wonderful Life before It's A Wonderful Life was thought of by him).

[@StephenMOaks]

Great Review Megan !! Yes, the one thing they got completely wrong is that there is no way Mary ends up an old maid - Impossible. Sam Wainright wanted to marry her - just for starters.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! And yes, psh... c'mon now. Mary's a catch

[@Mpshfromlowell64]

I like how the different styles of prayer of the people of Bedford Falls reflect their different personalities…..

[@OnWriting.]

Yes! Love that too

[@ptrookie]

I always cry at the end too!

[@OnWriting.]

How could you not 🥺🥺🥺

[@joeellis3281]

Thanks for your analysis and insights to one of my all-time favorite movies. I'm currently developing a plot for a second book in a detective series. I'm struggling at this point. This is my third Outer Banks mystery series, and the bookstore owners and readers are anticipating the next book by May of 2023. I like to plot out the chapters in detail before I begin writing the novel. Several of your points about how the characters had to face conflicts and challenges before completing their goals have stirred some possibilities. I watched another movie recently that got the plot wheels turning again--Hitchcock's Vertigo (another Jimmy Stewart flick). I hope to finish the plot by the end of December and put in the hours during the winter and spring months to complete the novel. If I do, it will be a minor miracle, but thank you for posting this video and your insightful analysis.

[@OnWriting.]

You're so welcome! Thank YOU for watching. It's one of my all-time favs too. And good for you for outlining in detail before you start to write, haha - I am a big supporter of that method XD. I'm glad this and Vertigo have gotten the wheels turning for you again and good luck finishing!! You can do it :)

[@shawngross5420]

This movie gets me every time! It is definitely my favorite.

[@OnWriting.]

It’s beautiful 🥲

[@sal7777777]

Great video. Besides being perfect for the time of the year, is a great movie too. It really hits all the points that make both the main character and the story compelling. Awesome video for the holidays season , plus your lipstick and sweater really added to the atmosphere as well. How long did it take you to watch it with all the stopping for the commentary?

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you tons ^.^ Haha I had two hours of footage!

[@machineoutlivestheman1192]

I used to only see this movie in snippets when it was on tv. From it I gathered that he’s a guy who yelled at his kids a lot and got slapped around as a kid. I didn’t get the appeal Wasnt until I really watched it start to finish that I really got it. Now it’s a Christmas Eve tradition in our house. Every time we get to the end and Harry says , to my brother the richest man in town I lose it. It’s like one of those try not to laugh challenges on YT but in reverse. I don’t wanna be friends with anyone who doesn’t cry at the end of this movie.

[@billolsen4360]

You have brilliant story structure insights. 22:49 James Stewart was exactly the right actor to cast as George Bailey. During his time in the Army Air Corps as a bomber pilot just a few years before he made this movie, he was always conflicted about the innocent people his bombs were killing on the ground while he & his buddies were carrying on a war to rid the world of fascism. I'm sure a lot of his colleagues in his Air Corps unit were bothered by the same thing. I like Violet.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! And yes, for sure. Very timely for him

[@user-rz2hf8rm7r]

This was a wonderful analysis. Perhaps my favorite movie, and you brought out so much of its depth. There's one other really cool story-telling technique used that I'd love to hear you explain as a professional writer: foreshadowing and maybe what could be called "anti-foreshadowing." George running down the main thoroughfare in the run-on-the-bank scene vs. George running down the main thoroughfare after he's redeemed. Potter cynically advising George "Why don't you go to the riffraff you love so much and ask them for the $8000?....Because they'd run you outta town on a rail", and, of course, Mary following this plan precisely, but proving Potter wrong. And then the million examples of "contrast foreshadowing" between the parallel universes, e.g., Violet's sexual attractiveness in the Bedford Falls world vs. Violet's broken sexuality in the Pottersville world

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! It's such a wonderful film :'). And I love that! Yes, that would have been an excellent point to touch on, even thinking about it as parallelism of sorts. I love the irony as well of Potter's jab at the end - I really only noticed that while I was editing! EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS FILM IS PERFECT haha okay, okay, calming down...

[@melenatorr]

For Mary, here's my thought: Mary is not an old maid here because she's 28. She's an old maid because she has made the decision not to marry -- she could have married Sam Wainwright, presumably, in this universe, but she didn't. Why? First because she never found a George to commit to. Second: she is still in town, which means she must have a reason for being in town. That reason, I think, is that she is person taking the place of the Baileys against the forces of Pottersville. That's why she's a librarian (she might also have been a teacher). She has no chance alone against Potter, but she has apparently stayed to fight it out as best she can. You can't really tell George's story without including Mary, though she is often behind the scenes: during the bank run sequence, George could not have moved forward if Mary hadn't made the move to offer the $2,000: he didn't ask her - she understood immediately what was at stake and offered a solution. While he worked there, she spent the day arranging to get control of the Granville house and in making it as welcoming as she could on short notice. She is active and in equal partnership with George in the welcome-Martini scene, and we can assume she's encouraged the idea of Bailey Park. And last but not least, it's her warmth and friendship with Sam Wainwright which probably clinches that huge amount of money for George at the end. And in conjunction with that, a key line in that falling action section is when Uncle Billy tells George that "Mary did it", that she's the one who went to figure out what was wrong and what to do about it.

[@mwcolton11]

I love your reactions! ❤

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you tons!! I'm so glad :)

[@tomw324]

Just started watching the first five minutes, you are very sharp. Subscribed.

[@OnWriting.]

Thanks Tom! I appreciate it ☺️

[@isaiahgallego]

Thank you for making me aware of this film 😭💕

[@OnWriting.]

Oh my gosh you are so welcome 🥺🥺🥺

[@Tarzan91303]

👏👏👏 thanks for the lesson. I learned a few things about order, especially about the dark night of the soul. I used to call it the phoenix raising sequence, but I like your term better now. Thankx

[@OnWriting.]

My pleasure!

[@joeconcepts5552]

Going along with the "show don't tell" premise is I think a scene skipped here, one of the best bits of acting is when George hears Harry has a good job waiting for him when they're at the train station. For a moment he's alone and you can see him at first upset, but then he pushes down those feelings and resolves to stay and let Harry go, and puts on a happy face. All in like maybe 20 seconds with no dialogue.

[@ajonteampanalo]

Beautiful scene. Right up there with his face when the train whistle blows when he’s standing outside of the welcome home party. Breaks my heart 💔

[@OnWriting.]

Yesss such a great moment by Jimmy Stewart, and your heart just sinks along with his

[@val3kyria]

One question: You were mentioning that we are shown how George is a good person through his actions. Do you ever feel like writing in first person hinders that effect since the person HAS to think about what they are doing? I am reading "This coven won't break" by Isabel Sterling and I keep feeling like the main character sings her own praises, but also is kind of just normal internal dialog that one would have while making a choice. IDK if that made sense hahah

[@OnWriting.]

This is a great question! I think it would come down to the types of thoughts that we're being shown. I'd definitely connect more with a main character who has realistic doubts, worries, concerns vs. one who simply knows the right thing to do all the time. You'd probably want to make sure there are elements of humility in there to balance out the praising haha. What do you think?

[@val3kyria]

@@OnWriting. I think you are right! Because a perfect main character who knows they are right would not only be boring but very unrelatable haha Do you have any videos on how to choose the type of narrator? (First person, 3rd person, omniscient, etc)

[@OnWriting.]

Yes! I have this one: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mnyXaYOKmdqMb6s Let me know if it helps ^.^@@val3kyria

[@DonnaCPunk]

I have a character I write in the first person. She's pretty smart when it comes to history but she has certain gaps in her knowledge. Some times she has to rely on her best friend for the information, as they're areas she deems not worthy of her time. In one story, this bites her in the butt more than once. So she's got to admit there's value in the knowledge her friend has because it was important to surviving the situation she was trapped in.

[@vincentdrago2847]

First I love this movie, but what everyone doesn't realize is that the bad guy (old man Potter) lost out in the end. When George went to him asking for the money, he was willing to sign over the building and loan to him, which was what Potter wanted. But, Potter was blind to that fact due to greed. So in the end Potter did get what he deserved, he lost out. Good triumphs in the end.

[@OnWriting.]

So true. He doesn’t get in trouble for stealing the $8,000 but he still loses out!

[@seanmcmurphy4744]

One of the things I like most about this movie is that it is not about "justice". Potter does not get punished for keeping the money. George continues living in his little town, and the Baily building and loan will continue to be threatened by the ruthless forces of greed like Potter, and may go out of business. The movie is not about some silly fairy-tale solution to George's problems, but about having the right values. Compare this to the popular movies today, superhero movies, which also focus on supernatural intervention in human lives. The underlying message of these movies is _ordinary people don't matter_ . I would say we have gone downhill since 1946.

[@jasongraves9958]

The motif of falling into water foreshadows Clarence falling into the water and George saving him.

[@georgecindyaustria4995]

Enjoyed your reaction. Also, like the typewriter on top of bookshelves. Looks like a 50's Smith Corona.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! And good eye - it sure is! 1954 silent super

[@paulamoya7956]

I love the way you soak up this film.. I feel it just like that too‼️You are🎄 Awesome at what you do.🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you tons! It's truly one of my favorites :')

[@jtaitslick]

Thank you so much for this... THIS is how I just found your channel. I watch every reaction video to It's a Wonderful Life because I love it so much... I just LOVE seeing how others react to it as well. I'll be watch all of your videos as I am JUST beginning my first book. In a side note: there is an SNL spoof of this and the ending that is HILARIOUS: Dana Carvey is George and I think Phil Hartman is the uncle who during the celebration remembers where the money was and that Mr. Potter has it! The whole town goes down and beats him up... it's funny/not funny. :)

[@OnWriting.]

Ohh thank you! Congrats on starting your first book - that's so exciting ^.^ I'll definitely have to check out the skit too haha. Glad you're here!

[@jtaitslick]

@@OnWriting. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rKibaqJmlsuVaKM

[@jtaitslick]

It's... a "little" dark! LOL

[@OnWriting.]

Haha I’m so disturbed 😆

[@kathyastrom1315]

Your mention of Harry Potter prompted me to parallel him and George Bailey-they both have a “saving people thing.”

[@TerryYelmene]

"This movie is so GOOD!" "It's textbook, people. It's So Freakin' GOOD!"

[@OnWriting.]

Hahaha I can't handle it!

[@marcstamper9079]

Great analysis, I fully enjoyed this. When George catches up with Violet in the street scene and George says “I’ll probably end up at the library” do you think that was intentional? As George ends up in front of the library looking for Mary in the alternate sequence?

[@OnWriting.]

I was wondering about this! I thought it tied more to George's desire to learn about other places, etc., but I can't imagine it wouldn't be a tie to the alternate sequence as well, given that every scene seems so intentionally placed! What do you think?

[@GreenRiver72]

23:19 - That scene was actually in 1933 so 433K or so. ...Now we see his necessity of charging exorbitant rent for a shack.

[@OnWriting.]

Yes!! Crazy

[@GreenRiver72]

So did Megan have a favorite character? Really can't beat Peter Bailey (...I just realized George & Mary named their first born after him). Then there's Mary who is the epitome of class - with the story telling only revealing this at occasional yet key moments - as in the early scene with Mr. Gower where it's quietly implied she also never says anything about the tainted capsules ... or in the alternate track where she never settled for Sam.

[@OnWriting.]

Aw it’s hard for me to put anyone ahead of George, but Mary is right up there!

[@ChromeVader]

I love this movie, but it's hard to watch sometimes. I feel like a lot of us at some point feel a little like George, maybe not from financial woes, but perhaps loss of loved ones, reputation smearing, illness, or family struggles. It's a great message in the movie, but also one that hits home more often than some of us would care to admit. There's a lot of continuity in this movie. I see elements of Chekhov's Gun in the story composition; at the beginning, we hear various people praying for George because they care about him. At the moment it seems like the film is just establishing George's character by showing you how he's affected those around him, but this is actually also foreshadowing the conclusion where those same people come to his rescue. By the time they save him at the end, we've forgotten about they're prayers in the beginning, and then it all comes rushing back to us and makes the conclusion so great. Also, when Clarence jumps into the water and George is looking down at him and without hesitation dives in after him, it's like a beat-by-beat recap of the childhood rescue of his brother--no hesitation, just a completely selfless act to save a life. It shows that despite everything he's been through, George is the same person he was when we saw him as a child. And his selfless act of saving his brother and then Clarence is finally mirrored by the acts of George's friends at the end who save him from going to jail, essentially saving his life just like he saved his brother's life and Clarence's life. I feel like there are so many things that need to be considered when writing a story that it becomes a little overwhelming. But if I keep on it and don't give up, my books will be better for it.

[@OnWriting.]

Hits home for sure. I think it touches on some deeply-seated themes for us all. Great point about the continuity! Another reason why this movie is a work of art 🤌. And I feel you there - there ARE so many things to consider. Honestly, that's why I talk a lot about outlining and prep up front because trying to get this level of storytelling by pantsing it is way, way harder.

[@ChromeVader]

@@OnWriting. I guess I struggle with knowing how to start an outline. I have notes to myself and little blurbs about things I want to include, themes I want to explore, character arcs, plot beats and turns, etc. But putting it all together itself seems somewhat daunting. I wrote stories a lot as a teenager, and I work as a professional writer in a niche field, so I'm not new to writing by any means--I guess I just haven't tackled a project this big before, and I want it to be perfect.

[@OnWriting.]

Oh man yeah, this all sounds super familiar haha. Honestly, creating a full outline is daunting. I can't remember if you've watched my outline videos, but I'd encourage you to start with the big picture. Where does your character start? Where do they end up? Then what's the primary pivot-point that turns them from point A to point B. From there, you can add more detail. Or, if it's helpful, I know resources like the Save the Cat beat sheet have really helped me by providing more of a template. I would encourage you to try to set aside the pursuit of perfection too. You can always revise your outline before you start writing and you can always revise after you finish your draft! Just my two cents though haha I don't want you to give up!!

[@ChromeVader]

@@OnWriting. I have watched your outline videos, but I should definitely go back and watch them again. You're right, I can always revise the outline. Once I have something down I can start molding it into what I envision, but gotta start somewhere. Perhaps I can dive into this over Christmas vacation. Thank you, and I hope you have a merry Christmas!

[@OnWriting.]

Same to you! Merry Christmas, and let me know how it goes :)@@ChromeVader

[@joeconcepts5552]

The movie hinges on George being a good hearted person, but also trying to maybe be a little selfish while struggling with doing the right thing. Even though it's not like seeking adventure is a bad thing. But he's paired up with Mary who is as good hearted as George, but she doesn't struggle with it. She already knows what George has to learn over the whole length of the movie.

[@OnWriting.]

Yesss, Mary is the real MVP :'). And you're so right - his selfish desires/ambitions are a big barrier

[@logos9391]

Do you do video requests? If so it would be great if you did an analysis of *The Shawshank Redemption* because that movie is one of the most inspirational movies I have ever seen.

[@OnWriting.]

Love video requests! Thanks a ton - would love to do Shawshank

[@bobbuethe1477]

It never struck me until just now. George sees Harry's gravestone because Harry died in 1919. That means that piece of land was already a cemetary in 1919. But in the "real" reality, it's Bailey Park. Does that mean that George built all of those houses on top of a cemetary?

[@AQuietNight]

Suspension of disbelief was required. In the scene where George calls Clarence on bridge, the snow falls opposite of the direction the wind was blowing.

[@jd-zr3vk]

The actor who played Mr. Gower was actually drunk during the eat slapping scene. He swung too hard on the child actor and drew real blood. Both actors stayed in character.

[@OnWriting.]

So crazy! Also poor Bobby Anderson

[@LilHoss]

The look Mary gives George, as they watch people giving them money. Starts me cutting Onions!!😥

[@OnWriting.]

How could it not!!

[@stevenvicijan4338]

Wholesome ending. This movie can hit one differently, depending on the life's path one's experiencing. . .

[@OnWriting.]

For sure!

[@totomomo18]

t's a Wonderful Life is more than a Christmas movie I am not christen and I love it. It is a feel good movie and one of the first time travel element movies. It is so much about time travel or alternative realities that Back to the future 2 allude to it :). Fun fact the movie was not a financial success when it came out and was forgotten. Only because of a copyright registration error ( Which was fixed decades later) the movie was considered public domain for years and because of the that the Tv Networks aired over and over every Christmas till it became a cult classic. Another fun fact the scene with the uncle that was drunk and fell down was adlib because one of the stage worker dropped something in the middle of filming. I love George speech to Mr Potter about the working class. The actor who plays Mr Potter is by the way Drew Barrymore great uncle. If you want another great Jimmy Stewart movie you should watch Mr Smith goes to Washington and Harvey.

[@michelle172ct]

Do you think the Sesame Street characters, Ernie and Burt got their names from this movie?

[@OnWriting.]

Haha I looked into that and apparently it was a coincidence, but I’m not 100% convinced 😉

[@ChubbyChecker182]

Its the Greatest Movie of All Time.

[@alanschlesinger8687]

The $20k offer was in 1935 not 1946, in the middle of the Depression. Worth the equivalent of almost $500k in today's dollars. My father was living on $5.00 a week in 1935 in New York City. $20,000.00 per year during the Great Depression when a decent house was $5000.00 was incredible money!

[@OnWriting.]

Yes! Quite a few folks have pointed this out :) So crazy!

[@arthurrubiera8029]

Two things reactors don’t realize in this movie is for the first time in Hollywood movie history at that time, is that the bad guy, Potter, gets away with a crime he committed. The second thing is that towards the beginning of the movie, when they show the movie theater, on the front of the movie house it says now showing“, The Bells of Saint Mary’s” Another great older movie with Bing Crosby!

[@josepwwalter2689]

The actresses who played Zuzu Bailey, Karolyn Grimes, is still alive in her 80's! Bless her heart, she makes festival apearnces every year, and her merch site where she sells autographed memorabilia looks like evey Grandmas Geopage in the 90s, its too cute.

[@OnWriting.]

Yes!! As does Jimmy Hawkins (Tommy Bailey) :) that’s too sweet about her website. Good for her!

[@josepwwalter2689]

@@OnWriting. YES! There were 3 of the Bailey Children left living last I had heard.

[@KalElvis]

Yep, you are adorable, keep up the great videos.

[@OnWriting.]

Thank you! Will do!

[@bradharris8935]

Damn that song!

[@OnWriting.]

Gets ya every time :')

[@cjmacq-vg8um]

there's an old hollywood saying - anyone can write a good beginning to a movie. the trick is to write a good ending. i suggest writers write the ending first. then go back and write how you get to that ending. you can add all the character development and twists and turns you want. just as long as you convey a plausible path to that ending. i can tell you just might not be a very good writer. how? because you're such a good teacher! as woody allen once said (paraphrased) - those who can't do, teach. those who can't teach, teach gym. thanks for the lesson. it is an exceptional film isn't it?

[@cjmacq-vg8um]

two years later Lionel Barrymore plays a good guy, much like george bailey, in "key largo" which stars bogart, lauren bacall and edward g. robinsnon as the gangster "johnny rocco." barrymore also starred with jimmy stewart and jean arthur in another capra classic "you can't take it with you" (1938). barrymore suffered from severe arthritis in his later years and did his acting from a wheel chair.

[@Jeff_Lichtman]

You said the blood from George's ear when Mr. Gower slapped him was fake. It wasn't. H.B. Warner, the actor who played Mr. Gower, accidentally hit Robert James Anderson (young George) too hard, and his ear started to bleed. Warner apologized to Anderson as soon as the scene was over. When Potter said that George was playing nursemaid to a bunch of garlic eaters, he was referring to immigrants like Mr. Martini. That reveals something else about George's character: he doesn't discriminate. The Building and Loan does business with immigrants, Catholics, ethnic minorities, giving them opportunity and a better life when no one else would. It was common in those days, even legal, for lending institutions to refuse to loan money to anyone but the select few. You can see this theme in other scenes, including the end when the townspeople come to George's rescue. It's another example of showing it instead of telling it. An interesting thing about the movie is that it assumes the viewer knows what a bank run is. Most of the audience had lived through the great depression, when bank runs were common (especially in the early years). No explanation was necessary. Another example of dramatic irony is when Potter says to George, "Why don't you go to the riff-raff that you love so much and and ask them to let you have eight thousand? You know why? 'Cause they'd run you out of town on a rail." Of course, the opposite happens. We can see this when re-watching the movie. Moments like these make it rewarding to see the film even when you know exactly what's coming. A movie I'd love to see you analyze is The Apartment (1960). It's been said to have a perfect screenplay. Thanks!

[@OnWriting.]

Well that explains why it's so tough to watch! Poor little Bobby DX. And yes! I looked that term up later and learned it was a slur about Italian immigrants. Brutal - but I love your point. That does reveal an added layer to George's character. Just when I thought I couldn't love him more... I noticed that line by Potter during editing - LOVED the fact that they put that in there. It's so satisfying because Potter's smug and hateful in that moment, but he's so, so wrong haha. Thanks a ton for adding these points!! And for the recommendation ^.^

[@disphoto]

@@OnWriting. Of course, Frank Capra was Italian and put that in on purpose. In all likelihood, the goat in the scene at Martini's new house was put there by Capra. "Capra" in Italian means "Goat." Similarly, there were many musicals written by Jews that wrote about the plight of Blacks (ex. Show Boat, Porgy and Bess) and other groups (South Pacific Pacific, Flower Drum song). In many ways, they were writing metaphorically about the plight of their own families and friends. They didn't feel "safe" to have the story centered on Jews until 1964's Fiddler on the Roof.

[@g587802]

I saw an interesting post about how Mary is the real hero. I though that was a bit of an overstatement. But is there a name for a charictor who is so fundamental to the plot, but inany ways more of a second tier player to the main action?

[@OnWriting.]

Yes, secondary characters! Still integral to the plot and influence the main (primary) character, but the story doesn't revolve around them :)

[@tucsab9705]

Que interessante! A cena do início em que o chefe bate no George criança enquanto o menino diz saber que o chefe recebeu o telegrama sobre a morte do filho então tem relação com o perdão que o próprio George merece não só da família e amigos mas também do expectador no final depois que ele é grosseiro em casa com a mulher e filhos. Eu nunca tinha feito esta associação. Ainda estou assistindo aos seus comentários, no início ainda ma já valeu a pena. 😊❤

[@vly9257]

My first time being exposed to that thought too. I always thought it was a little sad (I can't think of a better word here) that everyone had to sacrifice for George even after he took out his troubles on his family... but you are both right that he deserves the same compassion in his hour of darkness that he afforded Mr. Gower in his similar darkness. Thank you for that perspective 😊

[@reverts3031]

You picked up on "Henry Potter" but did you notice "Bert and Ernie" in human form???

[@OnWriting.]

Haha of course! Didn’t keep that in the final edit tho unfortunately 😆. I’ve read that it wasn’t the basis for the Sesame Street characters but I like to think otherwise 😉🤭

[@johnmavroudis2054]

I've watched this film dozens of times... and I NEVER fail to be moved by it. I think it's some sort of litmus test. If you don't cry during this film, your humanity card should be revoked. (or at least therapy sessions are advised) I LOVE your thoughtful comments with the perfect dash of humor. SUBSCRIBED! (One quibble: George gets what he wants when he marries Mary!) ... You have a wonderful way with explaining writing so the channel title makes sense... ha ha. I'm looking forward to hearing more! Cheers!

[@OnWriting.]

Oh thank you so much! It is definitely a litmus test, haha. I'm seeing it on the big screen tomorrow - can't get enough ^.^ And oh you're so right!! I always see that more as Mary getting what she wants, haha, but yes of course! Thanks for the kind comment and support - glad you're here

[@vly9257]

I would say George gets what he needs when he marries Mary 😊, he wants the honeymoon... the exotic travel and adventure. And Mary wants it for him, but she sees that he needs to help the town instead.

[@myfootballjesus]

todays movies can learn from this .....its a good all american story normal people can relate to, it didnt race swap the character, or make him gay, or have a political message and has a good traditional family message and values , and that why so many people like it, and it no one dislikes it

[@kaneinkansas]

Sorry, but you missed pointing out one visual moment, that I thought was almost too obvious. In the scene where involving the board meeting... ... When George is standing up to Mr. Potter in defense of his father, we see his father's portrait on the wall, - and then - as George thrusts himself at Mr. Potter in his argument, he thrusts his face in the exact place his father's portrait was, completely eclipsing his father's picture - and thus the story teller is giving us a clue, that George is in the process of assuming the role of his father in the battle with Mr. Potter and he brings a little vim and vinegar to the position that his father lacked. The writer has given us a clue that George himself may not have realized yet.

[@OnWriting.]

Love this!! Thanks for adding it. There's SO much in this film. It's a masterpiece :')

[@OnWriting.]

Also the fact that Potter has a portrait of HIMSELF in his office... x.x

[@TheBTG88]

“Garlic eaters” was a slur against non-WASP southern Europeans, ie. Italians.

[@OnWriting.]

Sure was 🥴

[@kathleenking47]

Until they married the Irish and had kids

[@JeffreyCantelope]

They changed Mary's alternate life. Originally they wanted to her have an abusive husband but it was decided that if would be too much for the movie audience to handle in 1947

[@OnWriting.]

Oh, interesting! I'm kind of glad they chose not to include that, yeah

[@tomw324]

Minor point, but the scene when Potter is offering George the job must be still be the early-mid 1940s. "George" is the real war hero btw given that Jimmy Stewart has just returned from being a bomber pilot and squadron leader flying very dangerous missions over Germany in WWII. Would love to see you analyze The Best Years of our Lives from the same era..

[@OnWriting.]

I’d love to look at that one!

[@adrianmcgrath1984]

I’ve always heard the fairly implausible tale that the movie was not popular, it did badly at the box office and did not become a success until the copyright expired and TV stations started showing it. I always found this hard to believe especially as Jimmy Stewart was such a beloved star. Some time ago though, I heard a different explanation from sources that seemed credible, that the movie had 'failed' when it was released, because a great deal of pressure had been put on the studio, distributors and movie houses, not to show it. It’s suggested that various political forces did not like the movie for its various themes and storyline. The explanation given was that it invoked un-American sentiments - Potter, the capitalist was a hated figure who must be overcome, while the 'building and loan' could be regarded as a metaphor for socialism. However you peel back the layers, you may find themes of beating capitalism, rejecting personal material wealth for social progress as being noble. There are also immigrants who add value to society and an African-American who is loved and considered 'part of the family'. - the immigrants were Italian, the Martinis, at a time when Italians weren’t treated very well and were also treated with suspicion following WW2 (Capra was an Italian immigrant himself) the movie was released in 1946. It was also ten years before Rosa Parks made her protest, making the character of Annie potentially awkward in some parts of the USA. -=Addng to the possibility that the movies 'failure' was down to political interference is the fact that Frank Capra did get blacklisted during the McCarthy era. I think he was blacklisted for eight years? In a somewhat sad and ironic twist, some of the devastation of blacklisting has accidentally been erased. There are writers who now have movies included in their personal writing credits and biographies,, when their names did not appear in the movies credits, and in some cases even on the movies payroll. Blacklisted writers who were given uncredited work by sympathetic producers and directors. - a grim time, and a grim reminder as we see books being taken off shelves in libraries - and movies boycotted and protested for having African American mermaids, or even just female leads.

[@OnWriting.]

I was surprised to learn about its "failure" upon opening as well but super interesting to look into the history and whole capitalism/socialism threads people were pulling out. I can see how it would have been more controversial at the time for sure, but so so glad it was played once the copyright expired. I had no idea Capra was blacklisted - eesh... Thanks for adding these details!

[@adrianmcgrath1984]

There are few “official” blacklistings, but Capra went 8 years without working. Sadly it’s a chapter in Hollywood that they don’t like to talk about. And while many blacklisted creators were helped by working off the books, in some cases - post McCarthyism - these names were added to the credits. While that is fitting, it does cover up the fact that at the time of production, they were blacklisted. Ronald Reagan was an actor who was notorious for calling colleagues communists and naming them to the various committees etc.

[@disphoto]

I think you have been reading a bunch of left-wing propaganda-based myths and revisionist history. Liberty Films was a new company formed by Capra and some other directors and released by RKO. It was hurried into release to qualify for the Oscars (which it didn't win other than for the snow special effect). The combination of a new studio and the rush release meant it didn't get the build-up it needed. The story was seen as too much of a downer with the suicide story after WW2 and not the fun picture people wanted to see then. The picture ended up losing at the Oscars. You couldn't get much bigger flag wavers and proponents of capitalism than Jimmy Stewart and Frank Capra. Frank Capra was not blacklisted, although he associated with many of the writers who were blacklisted. Capra hated what Hollywood was becoming, which was why he cut back. Quoting his book "Name Above the Title":, “The winds of change blew through the dream factories of make-believe, tore at its crinoline tatters ... The hedonists, the homosexuals, the hemophiliac bleeding hearts, the God-haters, the quick-buck artists who substituted shock for talent all cried: "Shake 'em! Rattle 'em! God is dead. Long live pleasure! Nudity? Yea! Wife-swapping? Yea! Liberate the world from prudery. Emancipate our films from morality!" "Practically all the Hollywood film-making of today is stooping to cheap salacious pornography in a crazy bastardization of a great art to compete for the 'patronage' of deviates and masturbators.” Kind of the opposite position to which you seem to favor sexualizing children (the only books that were "banned" were those being forced on minors).

[@disphoto]

@@OnWriting. This was a bunch of revisionist history. The financial problem was that it was a new small studio, Liberty Pictures. It got rushed into release to try and get Oscar consideration, and the suicide story was a downer coming just after WW2. All the stuff by @adrianmcgrath1984 is leftist revisionist history. The "blacklist" in Hollywood today would prevent a story with the family values and morals that Frank Capra believed in from ever getting made. It seems every story in Hollywood is about a perfect person from an oppressed group, that has no story arc other than to go from being inherently perfect to infallible.

[@adrianmcgrath1984]

While most of that reads like gibberish, your last sentence tells me where you are coming from@@disphoto

[@bookwoman53]

Before the film It’s A Wonderful Life was a live radio program so it wasn’t unusual to have narration.

[@OnWriting.]

For sure!

[@lisathuban8969]

Just a small correction. Mary is not 28 in the alternate reality George visits. They have a 12 year old son in the main timeline, and she went to college before that. She's somewhere between the age of about at least 34 to 36. So, yeah, old maid territory as an above age 35 and approaching 40 year old woman.

[@OnWriting.]

Phew! That’s a little more tolerable I suppose 🤭 haha

[@jamessumita9523]

Yes Mary and Harry graduated from HS same year so they should be approx same age.... Harry was born in 1911 according to his tombstone in the cemetery ..... and I believe the movie did not take place in 1946 the World War ll ended Aug 1945... so it's probably Christmas season 1945 that makes Mary probably 34...