The Greatest Unsolved Mysteries w/ The Chosen and Sarah Christ | Smosh Mouth 22

[@mariovanette4377]

This feels like 2 toddlers saying "no you cant do that because i have a shield that makes you not able to do that"

[@yomintdawg4246]

lol right like saying to your sibling "no matter what you say or do I'm stronger by a million times infinity plus one forever"

[@I.Call.Shotgun]

Yea well I'm a million times stronger times infinity plus TWO forever ​@@yomintdawg4246

[@Blu3Flam1ng0]

or like in a roleplay when the kids wants to always win so they just say "blocks"

[@alaynahrichards5737]

"Wake up, light a cigarette. Immediately put it out because I quit." Had me dying

[@pedroeubg]

As a smoker, this is my favorite line

[@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi]

I love that they've talked for more than an hour in a podcast about unsolved mysteries and managed to not solve a single one

[@spacebaby125]

I'm amazed they could go that long completely in character

[@fancypants3828]

That’s majority of all unsolved mystery podcast.

[@hazelbanadera2228]

I was just listening to this while doing chores and I was like, this intro is so long hahahahha 😅

[@KiwiPew]

@@fancypants3828 and all of unsolved mystery youtube videos and history channel shows.. 😂😂

[@wileyfoxyx]

жиза

[@heyitzsamurai]

this episode was fucking insane they managed to touch on ONE mystery and went off the rails for an entire hour. amazing

[@zekep2814]

Literally Shayne said the topic is jack the ripper and immediately got side tracked

[@captaindrachma2041]

Shayne stifling a laugh as the Chosen is one of the best character breaks on Smosh

[@Jiddy12345]

easily

[@stewartmoyer5105]

What are you talking about? Shayne wasn't even in this video.

[@HannahGunton]

he always cracks at amanda but sarah christ is impossible for him

[@Tabulatelk15]

Shayne breaking character is practically in character for the Chosen at this point

[@JinMasaX]

always sounds like a balloon deflating :P

[@PeachLagoone]

Amanda’s timeline of the creek side killer is KILLING me. At first it was 45 years, then it was centuries, then it’s 30 years lol I love her

[@HukarusHuko]

She is forever stuck in a never-ending loop of Creek side killer's murders

[@AJ-ht3kf]

And Chosen's "I was in middle school when I was Chosen but also 11 years old."

[@alexconverse4839]

What are you talking about? Amanda wasnt in this episode

[@disgusted2704]

Clearly, the creek side killer is not a person but a mantle. Classic mistake 😎

[@anchoraxe19]

​@alexconverse4839 she came in for a couple ads

[@hestiahearth4435]

I cannot tell if the combined IQ of Chosen and Sarah Christ is 2 or 200

[@RealBradMiller]

Classic mistake. 🕶️

[@DeFlanko]

Clearly over 9000.

[@perfessorclown5543]

It’s 200, but every digit is cut out from magazine print and pasted on

[@flyingwolfcub]

That would still only be 100 each which is below average 😂

[@terriblehibibi4333]

Actually that would be above average in america just by slightly@@flyingwolfcub

[@mattiemiller640]

why is their relationship so wholesome tho like sarah dropping the chosen off at his mom's house and protecting her

[@meganlewis5878]

it’s giving neighbor who hates kids and everyone meets kid who thinks he’s cool and stays by her cause she lets him talk without interrupting

[@shemybacchus3937]

I love how Sarah Christ committed to saying the Chosen is dependent on his parents. The Council of Chosens just being his parents makes so much sense for that character.

[@wolfe6819]

I always imagined his mom was the chooser

[@sunnydayzz0]

"thats one of the choices a Chosen must choose and I chose that" is maybe the best line in anything ever

[@eceelakat6296]

I watched the whole video and somehow missed this.. timestamp? :D

[@kittenloveer1625]

​@@eceelakat6296 26:17

[@eceelakat6296]

@@kittenloveer1625 thanks!!

[@sourkrowt]

these guest stars???? how can they afford??????

[@DannyXNightmarez]

You think these two care about money? The Chosen seems like he'll take any opportunity to talk into a camera ever. Same with Sarah Christ

[@DannyXNightmarez]

Sarah probably has to be distracted whenever the chief of her precinct has a press conference- otherwise she'd storm the podium and rant about the Creekside Killer

[@85BRox]

Anthony sold all of his rings

[@brandonwelty]

@@Blakkberry7r/wooosh

[@ivalicetifalucis]

@spewky2955his 900 dollar sweatshirt

[@Barmander]

The real mystery: Where did Shane and Amanda go? Why were they not present on their own podcast? They would never leave their guests alone like that! Did.... DID THE CREEKSIDE KILLER KIDNAP THEM?

[@jojisotherkid]

u mean kidnepap them

[@liriodendronlasianthus]

​@@jojisotherkid OMGGGGGG

[@criticallol3039]

Testament to Amanda and Shayne's abilities to stay in character (for the most part) for over an hour.

[@Mack10011]

oh, have you seen them play uno over quarantine? amanda (sadly) didn't, but shayne managed for a few hours until.. he broke..

[@pumpkinkoot865]

​@@Mack10011uno... Like uno uno.. A FEW HOURS? regular uno? I need to fine thus now... Or in an hour rather

[@michaeldeboer]

That time Amanda spent bullshitting in bars on camera helped her become the improv goddess she is now.

[@criticallol3039]

​@@michaeldeboerBar/restaurant Amanda walked, so Smosh Amanda could run

[@FreneticPotato]

​@@criticallol3039 those Mexican Salsas paid off, yes.

[@melgirl31]

the fact that Amanda and Shayne could (as their characters) talk about nothing for 75 minutes and still be wholly entertaining is amazing. What incredible improv actors and comedians

[@codydamon9347]

I already know this is going to be an hour-long fever dream

[@niogel]

It was.... 😵‍💫🤒🤯

[@neatguy89]

It's a battle of wits there's not much between the 2...but it's there😂

[@witterways3528]

the best way to describe this

[@juliahamilton3358]

Dude, their love is blind video was a fever dream. They're just getting in the holiday spirit

[@smolfloof3016]

love how its cannon that Chosen and Sarah Christ regularly hang out

[@beardlessdragon]

I love how Shayne turns away and covers his mouth when he laughs as if we aren't going to see or hear that he's laughing lol

[@Kanekonagase]

We need an ongoing "buddy cop"-esque show with these two going out into the wild to solve mysteries.

[@oliviae.4703]

Pleeeeaaasssee

[@RoeBoats]

YEEEESSSSSS

[@ev1533]

This!! 110% yes!

[@ashleyisdead8466]

Absolutely!

[@kylersaurus42]

YES PLEASE!!!!!!!!

[@milkjake15]

Amanda always cracks up when she's not in character. I cannot believe she can just shut that down when she's Sarah Christ.

[@robyn_lilyy]

I cant tell whether you’re saying she’s hilarious in both or whether u prefer Amanda as herself?

[@skystrife3756]

​@@robyn_lilyythey meant that amanda always laughs easily when she's not in character

[@robyn_lilyy]

@@skystrife3756 OHHHH i read the comment as “cracks ME up”, that’s why I was confused 💀 makes complete sense now

[@sunshinemaia1706]

@@robyn_lilyyI read the same thing 🥲 thank god there was clarifying comments

[@calycalyps0]

​@@robyn_lilyywhat the hell?😂 i also read the same thing but i swear it said "cracks me up" 😂

[@taylorbrookeec]

Sarah Christ roasting The Chosen so hard but then also wanting to protect him from Bobby is golden. I JUST WANNA TALK TO HIM vibes 😂

[@Peoe500]

I cannot explain how fucking rad I know this episode will be. Side note: If Amanda ever does a Sarah Christ origin story, we need Peter to play her partner!

[@KayeHalliwell]

Sarah Christ swearing to God every five minutes xD

[@allowallie2819]

Peter as her partner would be HILARIOUS. It would be so good if Peter like ‘betrayed’ her and so she could no longer be his partner! (he never betrayed her, she just thinks he did)

[@beetehotraroy3468]

Agreed, but only if Peter does not play any character. It is just Peter.

[@Derpguineapig]

and the creek side killer was him this whole time

[@samanthaminter6023]

And redacted returning to play her current romantic interest or recent ex. That would be so great

[@LindaKentoffio]

Sarah Christ and the Chosen has immediately become one of my favorite character duos. They work so well together.

[@italiahockey]

The way The Chosen subtly inserts random anime lore as fact is hilarious.

[@thomaseustice122]

This is a masterclass in absurd comedic character improv

[@gregbocadella02]

I love how whenever The Chosen gets questioned about something absurd he says, his response is always either "I cannot reveal my secrets" or "that was a test."

[@rachelbicknell1491]

When Sarah Christ mentioned she had a picture of the creekside killer, I legitimately expected them to pull out a picture of Spencer Agnew

[@ManubibiWalsh]

according to the lore Spencer is a Chosen from another universe, right?

[@handlerone5172]

Sarah Christ's morning routine fits the character so well, how did she improv all of that so well?!

[@ayoung283]

The Queen of gab delivers 😂❤❤

[@kaitlynnc15]

⁠@@ayoung283Her delivery is truly just so cold. Ice cold.

[@jojisotherkid]

because it’s not improv, that’s sarah christ

[@JohnemonSilver]

when creating an improv character you need to think about all of that stuff

[@nairocamilo]

@ 29:29

[@toadt0ad]

obsessed w them briefly touching on a few mysteries n mostly just talking lol their character work was so solid

[@maritimus_]

why do i feel like sarah christ was the Chosens babysitter and now that hes older he just wants to impress her no matter what😆

[@DuckYou2]

😮😅

[@aarondonald1611]

I’m thinking either babysitter or librarian he talked to all the time at the library

[@Screechsmom]

Sarah is so unhinged that she’s making Chosrn uncomfortable. 😂

[@tgupta4658]

In a totally plausible reality, The Chosen has absolutely idolised Sarash Christ as his mentor.

[@rdp16rulez]

Well I have a theory that Mr. Grub is her ex husband who canonically is The Chosen's teacher. So your theory is plausible.

[@oftheHowl]

The Chosen doesn't idolize anyone except Keanu Reeves

[@icyclestick178]

the Chosen doesn't idolize a human, only Keanu Reeves.

[@erin1912]

the chosen and sarah christ’s mutual respect and semi-chill vibe was incredible

[@ashleyduckworthyt3224]

The silly goose department definitely pushed for this episode

[@sydneymitrecic]

Heheh

[@angeninja]

Sarah Christ's consistent continuity errors are my favorite 😅

[@thepineapplegal9099]

Yeah “he’s been killing for centuries” and then “for 30 years” was great

[@Hddjridhanaksldndh]

Smosh has been killing it with the quality videos lately

[@rattled1557]

the Golden Era

[@irbesmilgaine7140]

It's the Anthony running in their veins..

[@basedmarlon]

@@rattled1557I’d call it more of a renaissance

[@desdemonathomas511]

YUUURRR

[@swiftlylovestruck]

i'm sorry but this sarah christ eats EVERYONE up she's by far the FUNNIEST character in the channel idk how amanda does it. it's so simple but yet so complex and genius 🤣

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

She's so good! Honestly, if Amanda doesn't leave for a big opportunity, I think she's gonna become one of the main pillars of smosh!

[@swiftlylovestruck]

​@@hernameispekka_Rebecca wholeheartedly agree❤

[@jennifervaughn2466]

​@hernameispekka_Rebecca she better not leave!

[@isaacgame7304]

I like how Sarah Christ's cigarette has a permanent glowing cherry, burning forever with the light of passion for finding the Creekside Killer.

[@gmcollazo1118]

😂😂😂 this comment made me laugh more than it should

[@tylerdavies1280]

34:18 "There is good that exists in the darkness..." "Like what?" "Like me." Top 10 coldest lines ever spoken

[@YTFlove4ever]

The Chosen is Shayne's inner child. I feel this pure joy and excitement emanating from him whenever I see him playing The Chosen

[@Yivia]

The way Sarah Christ believes everything the Chosen says 😅😂

[@jacksonhunter2621]

So impressive that Amanda never broke character, actually so insane.

[@haliensexist]

It's because this was the true Amanda all along... 😂

[@roziehoff2801]

She definitely broke lol but that doesn’t change how amazing she is

[@ashleyhoughton8592]

Yeah she absolutely broke. Just really good at recovery.

[@slsthewriter1299]

3:56 "You should have me over some time. Maybe I could, uh…, jump on that gameboy a couple times." *Chosen celibate confusion commences*

[@abbygcruz]

the way they kept adding little bits of lore to their characters to one up each other like little kids adding powers when they played mermaids in the pool😭😭

[@mellow.dramatic4876]

I love how Sarah christ can never get her timeline straight 😂

[@kayinwright8485]

Chosen’s shark tooth story is even funnier bc Orlando is in the middle of the state with no beaches.

[@Oley44]

that’s my thought too lol

[@annikan42]

Same! I was like, does he know that Orlando isn't on the coast lol

[@ManubibiWalsh]

No you don’t get it, he was swimming in the ocean of darkness that is in his cursed subconscious and he beat a shark there, and the necklace appeared in his hand after flailing wildly in the middle of Disneyworld for some 5 minutes

[@falaksuteri]

for those who are wondering: no smosh cast today since they took a break for thanksgiving!

[@ErikTheOkapiYT]

Oh.... I see. Thx for the update.

[@monkebrainiac]

A CHARACTER THEMED PODCAST??? this is amazing, please get other characters soon 😭 just a suggestion, this would probably be funnier if they talked about their opinions on real life stuff (maybe a q&a from fans?), kinda like how people create characters and develop them by putting them in random irl situations

[@ashleyduckworthyt3224]

“And what she sent me was somewhat of a hellscape” I’m laughing sooooo hard

[@monkebrainiac]

@@ashleyduckworthyt3224 they nail these all the time in any smosh channel, when they hold back their laugh it becomes even funnier too

[@rashindus]

This episode would be even better with the most powerful of the Great Old One warlocks, Mr. Grub.

[@okaythanks7855]

Can't wait for Boneless to guest star

[@rdp16rulez]

​@@rashindus You mean Sarah's ex husband?

[@ibperson]

I love that when Sarah explains the Sephora story, it's "a man" but she was actually trying to arrest Courtney for burping. It's like she's embarrassed now

[@Evan_L_Rodriguez]

You guys could easily translate this into a recurring radio drama.

[@neatguy89]

I wouldn't have made it 5 mins she looks like she's sweatin bullets holding it back dedication

[@maggiek558]

I was JUST thinking this!!! A smosh character radio drama would be insanely fun. Shayne and Amanda would be great as co-writers intertwining these characters into a universe.

[@simfamr.]

I want more side characters on

[@yoakleoakle]

@@maggiek558 god i love this ! me and my husband love radio dramas

[@ManubibiWalsh]

@@maggiek558with a guest episode featuring Mr. Grub. I feel like the flavors of unhinged would mesh really well to get absolute pure chaos lol

[@kayleerodriquez9465]

I would love to see someone play The Chosen's mother, and for her to be like totally in to what the chosen is saying, with no understanding of what is happening, just like a sweet old lady who thinks that he is really fighting demons and monsters. or has the chosen's mother showed up already on smosh

[@IrinaGreenman]

Didn't Damien play her in a TNTL?

[@rnataliad]

i want a sarah christ, the chosen and briana boho true crime podcast

[@trezalkapeliskova2121]

yessssss

[@mollyoreilly472]

OMG AUGUSTUS PLEASE @thorincampano1525

[@ayoung283]

@thorincampano1525Yaassss

[@rhettmitchell]

@thorincampano1525 I feel like Boneless would be way better for a true crime podcast than Brianna Boho

[@goingghost8297]

@thorincampano1525how about Damian’s teacher character instead of Augustus?

[@ThisIsMattyTrying]

I’m obsessed with the subtle implication that the creek side killer is just Big Foot.

[@juliastorch4021]

I absolutely died at Amanda chiming in with "b0ner's back" 😂

[@KH-hu9sv]

The best part about this is that regardless of what character Amanda is, whoever she is, cannot help but be a maternal and protective force with any counterpart and yes - that means the chosen as well 😂

[@matekolonics]

My favorite thing in life is watching Shayne as the Chosen trying (and failing) to hold back laughter

[@speshuul2]

I genuinely can’t tell if they’re into each other or if it’s a mother son dynamic? Or both? I love this duo 😂

[@RoeBoats]

AHAHHAAAAAA YES SAME IM DYYYYINNGGG

[@zachmaranto]

“So I’m doggy paddling in Orlando, Florida” has got to be the most un-Chosen and simultaneously most Chosen line I’ve heard yet

[@lunaskisses]

the chosen literally talks like a 10 year old boy, and i love that😂 it's so fitting for this character

[@renegoss4650]

Sarah's "nightmare" is to Chosen's "hellscape"

[@baileighchadwick3995]

More than an hour of them BS-ing and was enjoyable the whole time 😂

[@xander9190]

This is the most sincere compliment I can give this episode. I work at a library and I have to remain quiet. listening to this episode made me absolutely lose my composure at some points. Love this

[@execrisiscoreonearth]

"I use this Gameboy advance for meditation" I truely do not know how shayne didn't break from that, I cackled in the middle of public and I..... I just can't. Lmao. Particularly in a discussion about ancient devices, to a character with extreme boomer energy. The absurdity is just off the charts with that line, lemme tell yall lol.

[@currentlykmss]

how do I just know they’ll get through absolutely NO mysteries

[@Blonde.booknerd]

34:22- I’m dead😭 “Me~💅” is the best quote ever.

[@cayanne3420]

This is the deadliest duo, we can not handle their power.

[@sweetlilweirdo]

This is all a joke but I just love their dynamic so much?? They complement each others so well. I thought it was so sweet, despite it all being a joke, when The Chosen said he will find the Creekside Killer if Sarah Christ were to ever die xd

[@monkebrainiac]

the fact they posted this with that epic trailer on the main channel... man smosh is going through another golden age mayhaps

[@k.kr7p]

sarah christ’s “What.” makes me giggle every time

[@JoeBurgettMusic]

This felt like a fever dream. The best fever dream! lol The fact that all Shayne and Amanda did here was improv as their characters for an hour is amazing. I now want an hour-long scripted show with these two, as they attempt to hunt down the Creekside Killer.

[@melodyofmedli]

I’ve watched/listened to this so many times already. This is my new Roman Empire

[@frijidcrushhd]

I swear these two are on exact opposite sides of the spectrum of otherworldly entities 😂😂 loved this one!

[@heatherg9423]

I always love when these two are on-screen together. These characters crack me up and when they meet up it's just chaos. LOL

[@da.re15]

What if Anthony is the creek side killer and this whole time she’s been looking for him

[@Corbomite_Meatballs]

I think the *real* Creekside Killer is one of the people that ran Defy Media....THINK ABOUT IT Sarah!

[@oliviae.4703]

That explains his funeral. These two finally got to him

[@Dexter-do6hz]

then this will be the most insane spoiler I've ever seen 😂

[@glooperscooper]

The fact they did improv in character for over an hour is SO impressive

[@Helbereth]

If I learn nothing else from this episode, I'll at least know that Sarah Christ wants to jump on The Chosen's Game Boy...

[@kw8081]

Omg please do another collab with these characters. This was so funny. Great job 👏

[@chasestudio2736]

smosh is really blowing their budget on all these celebrity guests

[@oliviae.4703]

They’re like two kids one upping each other with their make believe personas. I love it so much!

[@chikitabowow]

Alright having two characters like this in a full podcast episode is pretty wild, major kudos and many likes 👍👌

[@rebeccalevy8491]

😂😂😂 I would actually watch a show about these 2 solving mysteries

[@lindsayschechert9050]

this... this truly is an exercise in self control 😂 you can genuinely see them having to breathe through trying not to break and it's fuckin hilarious. you two are incredible actors, and if this doesn't prove it, i don't know what will.

[@frederickhernandez3609]

I play magic and this shit was sending me. I love when shayne brings up MTG and jokes about neckbeards lmao

[@ghostgameplays7797]

I want the "I was there man!" guy to be on this show next!

[@potatoman7594]

and its just Amanda and another guest completely normal and they're telling stories and occasionally he butts in and goes "I was there, myan!"

[@ghostgameplays7797]

@@potatoman7594 yes!😂🤣

[@chrisrlillo]

dude YES

[@PoppysLilPlanet]

Came for unsolved mysteries, stayed for whatever the dynamic between Sarah Christ and The Chosen is.

[@ashleyhoughton8592]

It's amazing

[@sanninmusic212]

I've never seen The Chosen have his confidence rocked so many times

[@YAXIAN1000]

Omfg this episode killed me, I have to suppress my laugh so bad bcs I was at my job I don't know how they were able to maintain the character without breaking in laugh so bad all the time I love this, this made my fucking day, maybe my favorite episode so far haha

[@SabiSunni]

Sarah Christ x Chosen ghost hunting would be a must watch

[@brennahaggs]

so all i’ve learned is that sarah christ’s mom is the creek side killer.

[@spookydivorce]

Sarah Christ and The Chosen are such a good pair 😭 I need more of their interactions in the future

[@louisehay7945]

If they don't make a series following their investigation to find the creek side killer I'm going to be devastated!

[@notyourregularelevator2157]

I love this show so much. “THE ONLY THING I’M ADDICTED TO IS PURPOSE”

[@Bumstany]

as a follow up episode we should get Amanda's Chosen and Shayne Christ to host hahaha

[@tricks_and_bricks8735]

The fact that I have switch from just listening to watching this podcast just cements how good this podcast truly is

[@ayoung283]

39:40 Dude these ads were actually entertaining AF lol. Good advertising guys!!!! ❤❤ Love the podcast

[@Jackalsblood]

This NEEDS to be a series Chosen & Sarah Mysteries

[@abyssoffortitude]

And then maybe tim will guest star since they both mysteriously dated and broke up with sweet sweet tim from IT.

[@ashleyhoughton8592]

Would love this with other smosh characters as the other characters.

[@minxisto]

I love how they just put 2 characters to talk and it turned out so good

[@uchiharose9927]

They need to do a mini series with the chosen and Sarah traveling to a place or country resolving this long case 😂

[@sydneymitrecic]

The team up we didn't know we needed. This is incredible. I love Chosen so much and Sarah always cracks me up

[@Ratapley1s]

Can Sara Christ and the chosen do the scene from twilight where Bella knows she’s a vampire Sara: I know what you are Chosen: say it, out loud

[@kaitlynnc15]

Having just finished watching the whole series the last two nights, I can hear them. 😂

[@MyJOXO]

Full respect for them not cracking out of character that much