The Kulture Study: ASTRO 'WHO' MV REACTION & REVIEW

[@evie_m3000]

Moonbin and Sanha woke up and chose violence with this comeback.

[@formoftherapy]

I guess violence is a sin so

[@dbloskidelros]

@@formoftherapy l saw this when you first reviewed it and shared it today with a friend who is a new Aroha. Have to say... 'violence' meaning Ddankong attacked us in so many ways in this MV. By the way, PD... I LOOOVE YOU!!! 😍

[@lm9333]

I tweeted this but I think I should comment on it here :) The concept Moon Bin chose was "Constantine" (as he said on Universe - I think it's the movie as per my research) who is a demon hunter/slayer. I saw that clearly in this MV. Sanha was the one possessed by the demon (if you saw the change in his eyes) & Bin is Constantine who does rituals (someone lying down covered w/ a red sheet and him waving the handheld watch I think) for the demon to get out of Sanha. In the part with mirrors, Sanha is still being chased/trying to be possessed by the demon (the hands you saw) looking confused & later in the MV he does gestures to break the mirrors which Moon Bin saw & analyzed to maybe looking for traces of the demon. (I'm not so sure) Towards the end of the MV, it looked like MoonBin did another ritual (him w/ blood stains) to eventually get rid of the demon inside Sanha. which he successfully did when they showed Sanha had normal eyes again. These are just my observations based on the Constantine concept.

[@astroddoca5236]

oh oh! In the Constantine movie, he used a mirror to summon the demon

[@lm9333]

@@astroddoca5236 yes he did!! I almost forgot about that!!

[@jacyfaraldo6424]

Thanks for clarifying - also, there aren't any specific religious objects, like crucifixes or hosts or chalices, and their "priest" outfits aren't accurate, so nothing's really been used in a wrong context I don't think. Unless Sanha is wearing a rosary, which would be kinda bad but I don't think it's a rosary.

[@heatherhiott3000]

@@jacyfaraldo6424 He was wearing a rosary

[@jacyfaraldo6424]

@@heatherhiott3000 Oop 👀 that’s not cool but what can you do now

[@Laura-pq3uh]

I absolutely LOVE how much Fantagio has been promoting Astro lately with everything from the group comeback, eunwoos acting, mj solo, two sub units, jijnjins radio work and more. These boys deserve everything. This comeback was simply amazing from the concept to the song and choreo, a 10/10 for me ❤

[@hannahmalate6297]

Andalso the dramas. Fanmu are doing great

[@moonbinisaghostiemermaidpr4950]

Now we need a dongmin and mj duo comeback- like cmon- thatd be crazy- but theyd probably do a solo dongmin album

[@hannahmalate6297]

@@moonbinisaghostiemermaidpr4950 Eunwoo&Son is the name of their sub-unit hahahaha

[@jennab8649]

I agree and I hope Weki Meki gets the same treatment soon

[@YoYo-xx8xi]

FINALLY SANHA GETTING THE RECOGNITION HE DESERVES!! he's such an underrated performer!!!!!!!

[@jayisundead2887]

As an ASTRO Stan since 2017 I honestly love the current approach they’re taking with having the subunits alongside the main group. It adds a lot of genre variation.

[@annam3598]

Me too! I love the different concepts we are getting from the subunits and soloist. It’s speaks volumes how much talent Astro has so when they do something as a group, it’s so impactful

[@ayunniaaafandi]

Agree T^T

[@trellbell]

I am not an ASTRO stan.....I honestly only knew of Moonbin....and i dont recall ever watching a MV of Astros....but uuuhhhh, excuse me!?!?! SANHA has grabbed me! This MV is magic.

[@karen_lila2purple547]

Stan astro 💜

[@MilkshakeCowboy]

Watch their first subunit mv Bad Idea too. Sanha is really growing into his on style.

[@ayunniaaafandi]

@@boxfox3555 yess

[@xuenyun3566]

Same with me!! Before watching this MV, I only know eunwoo and Moonbin. But after watching MV, I stan for Sanha, he looks amazing in this concept.

[@shunleileinaing2885]

"ah the original sinner" LMAO I'M DEAD PS: hoping to see the album reaction on Patreon soon too!!! recently joined so i'm, excited!

[@wennyclaudiia]

ME TOO HAHAHAH caught me off guard

[@kekelovesu2948]

Yes, a male succubus is called an Incubus. That is a great explanation of Moonbin. I do admit that this is Sanha's comeback. He ate. We are so used to Binnie destroying everything that Sanha was a wonderful surprise. They are priests from a Hell dimension for sure. This whole concept is sinful. Loved the reaction. Video, visual, everything is a 10/10.

[@anime_addict21]

'I'm a loyal hoe.' 🤣🤣 SAME. I'm a Binnie stan myself, but I feel the same, Sanha really grabbed my attention this cb. This mysterious sexy vibe REALLY fits them. I love it! I am Catholic as well and I have no qualms about the sexiness. 🤣🔥🙌

[@robynbrowne1277]

I'm also Catholic and this was AMAZING! also being a loyal hoe perfectly described multistans

[@smile_chingu]

I said it before Sanha is a good actor. He can act through his eyes. You can feel the emotions of the eyes. Thank you for a great reactions again

[@dbloskidelros]

I have said this too when I saw him in "The Ultimate Watchlist of Latest Trends 2". I really think Sanha is a great actor (nevermind that he is my bias). 🤩💛

[@aussiecountry9320]

It still astounds me that we somehow got from hide and seek era Astro to this. I can't think of any other group that has had the Pokémon evolution that Astro has had. And it's been really fun to watch them grow and evolve, not only as a group but individuals as well.

[@보라달-z1d]

The way that Moonbin want this song to be a "seen" song.. I guess it works like that for you .. the experience you only will experience with kpop

[@OneRandomRuth]

seeing PD fangirl over both Bin and Sanha as he tries to analyze the mv is what I live for

[@i_dont_pick_my_biases_they6713]

I've always thought of Sanha as a cutie doing his iconic "bbu bbu" aegyo, and here it shows that he can be sexy too. As for Moonbin, I'm not surprised, he was always super sexy 😁

[@detoxifyoursoul]

I love how you picked up on the visual presence. MoonBin mentioned that he wanted to pursue a more visually powerful concept this album, so like you said, I think the performance, styling, and aesthetic is firmly tied to this track. And Sanha totally ate this up.

[@juschilin777]

Sanha getting the recognition as the all rounder that he is👏... Also the concept was suggested by moonbin i am really proud of him for coming up with such interesting concept hope he gets to participate in future cbs too coz he has really creative ideas

[@stantalentstanastro4178]

"i feel like i'm going to hell just by watching this video" FELT THAT

[@ngeata]

I really want to praise their facial expressions because in this mv there's not a single frame of them looking even slightly off their characters. This is just stunning! I'm in awe! I have no choice but to stan.

[@ray4223-1d]

Oh wow I just realized when the mirror breaks at 3:49 its like they broke through because you can see Sanha on the left and Moonbin on the right, like they broke through to each other, that's so cool!!!

[@el.6253]

Thank You PD!! Finally Sanha gets recognition!! Sanha is an excellent performer, his dance moves and facial expressions are just ON POINT!! He’s improved a lot even since bad idea era. This DUO (Moonbin And Sanha) They’re really Perfect Together!! 'Bad Idea' and 'Who' are masterpieces 💜

[@astro.pentagon]

the difference between astros 2 sub units is so funny

[@stantalentstanastro4178]

and mj's solo too hahahha VERSATILE KINGS!!

[@NikkaVim]

they are exorcist priest in this concept heheheh eunwoo will also be having a kdrama soon titled "Island" and his role there is also an exorcist priest~ he also wears the similar priest outfits as ddankong ^_^

[@NikkaVim]

btw this part that PD pointed out 16:31.... Sanha also does that facial projections too on their live performances so far (which were the Media showcase, and Comeback showcase) even when the camera wasn't focused on him.. omg talk about stage presence~~ WOO-E-WOO ♥♥♥♥♥

[@shannidee2384]

I expect that from Moonbin, but Sanha really showed a different side of himself. Beautiful video!

[@blinkz191]

Sanha really blow up .. he only 22 but he’s so beautiful and gorgeous all together. I really love music video and song! They both looks so good with all outfits , performance, acting so good. Happy Santa didn’t more recognized . Moonbin is my bias . He vocals sounds so good on his song as well.

[@roseanneducut8525]

Sanha's acting skills have gotten really good! He slayed it here

[@jayscakemix7896]

I was shooketh.....I sat there being attacked and loving every sinful second. Moonbin was my first love in ASTRO, but then Sanha had to come in and say I don't think so.

[@jasminenoel8472]

Moonbin being my bias and Sanha being my second fav, you could imagine my excitement for their music. They both did AMAZING but I agree Sanha didn’t come to to play this comeback. He took the concept and made it his🥰🥰

[@annam3598]

The MV gave me chills, not just because it’s darker but the vibe along with the song was really good. I’m enjoying the album so much too!

[@veronicaa5001]

Thank you for reacting to this wonderful video, Moonbin and Sanha just get better and better.

[@wennyclaudiia]

i love how much you appreciate the MV , and you're so right about sanha. he is on THE NEXT LEVEL here it's insane. i can't get enough of this MV and song

[@VeraOroz]

Dankong.Moonbin najtalentiraniji Idol.❤❤❤

[@aaliyahaquino695]

Love this review! Finally! Sanha getting the recognition he deserves!

[@xtina4864]

Liked your analysis. I do agree, Sanha has grown and it showed in his performance. Moonbin said in their showcase that Sanha absorbs all the good things from his older members and I also thought so too, when I saw Sanha in the cover of 'Idol' last year with Rocky, Jinjin and other idols from other grps. He will only get better from now. Moonbin still is a dance genius and he just destroyed with this look. Thanks for reacting to this.

[@pote-take]

Watching reaction videos made by various KZbinrs, I always think at the end. PD, you are the best of the best. Thank you for your deep consideration, easy-to-understand commentary, and your love and passion for K-pop. I'm always looking forward to it, so please continue to work for a long time.

[@alexmartinez7584]

This video deserves better, is absolutely AMAZING 10/10

[@bells5524]

"Special unit in the Vatican" - Yeah, clearly the unit is Moonbin&Sanha, and they're dropping a 🔥 mini album

[@govindapriyadasi286]

The entire album, in my view, is great. So much experimental sound and dynamic development of the musical thought. Great instrumental production in every single song as well. What I like about ASTRO and its units, is that even if they choose to portray a visually and musically darker concept, the idea is still related to healing, it's always that emotional, spiritual depth. Rather than just a really common aggressiveness or cuteness for its own sake, just to catch people's attention.

[@SaranyaGanesh89]

Amazing review and right on point. MOONBIN SANHA TEAM IS BRILLIANT!

[@acciocake]

this comeback is just sinful and so amazing all together 😭 this concept really suits this unit so well

[@Rrika]

My thought was that Sanha is an exorcist priest and while he was performing an exorcism he himself became possessed by the demon so the whole MV he's fighting with the demon inside him. And he's winning over it at the end as he's eyes go from black to normal. For MB though, I can't decide if he's either a fellow priest or the person on whom the exorcism has been performed. I tend to believe is the second option. As he really looks like a demonlike creature in this story. I might be biased but I was 99% focused on Sanha watching this MV, and I watched it multiple times, because it's so damn good. His acting blew me away and he held the emotions through the entire MV. This is by far one of my favorite MVs. PS: I watched the showcase and I know they talked about the songs and explained them, but I didn't really understand as I'm not proficient in Korean, I'll check when the subs will be uploaded. So these are my thoughts not influeced by MB&Sanha's.

[@sweetpotato3276]

I'll be sincere, I clicked just to watch how much PD would freak out because this is SO GOOD! I was expecting something like Bad Idea, but not something like THIS! The beat and the visual and the music and their voices...I can't listen to the song without thinking of the MV, they are just one thing, one cool thing and I love it! DOPE! I agree with everything you said, also my bias is Moonbin and I think he did great, but Sanha really stood out for me, the visual and his voice are so cool and mature. Wow, they really exceeded themselves, every time I watch the video I get goosebumps just like the first time O.O

[@Sunny-bc2mu]

The part when they rhyme _Rockabye/Bye/Why_ has me on a chokehold

[@jaaaaazzzzzzzz]

Yes. This MV was pure sin. I love it.

[@megadams9665]

this was AMAZING!! as someone who spent most of her childhood in church (not catholic), i LOVE religious imagery and blasphemy, it's always so cool to see. this mv was so beautiful and the song is fantastic, i'm so stoked for the rest of the album!

[@mxm7647]

Like the song. Love the MV and vocals. The "Rockabye A-bye A-bye" parts are my favorite. Felt like I was doing something wrong while watching the MV so I agree with you on that part. Moonbin and Sanha as a duo are dangerous so I kind of knew what I was getting into but this still took me off guard.

[@franciapierreditgerard7571]

That was so fun to wtach and I like the 'oh, the original sinner" 😂. I could not find any review from you about "one" of Astro... please 🙏

[@amongthecrowd]

The best sinners. Daaaaaamn. Loved it!

[@lunaa764]

not an astro fan but this concept was gr8 !!!

[@ten10dae96]

KEEP UR SHIT UP PD!!! IM THANKFUL FOR U GIVING ALL DIFFERENT GROUPS A CHANCE OF REACTION NOT JUS THE BIG GROUPS BUT EVRYONE

[@stantalentstanastro4178]

thank you for the reaction as always! you're my favourite reactor to astro videos :'> i agree that sanha really shone in this video, the two served VOCALS AND VISUALS AND ACTING they're giving us all

[@leekuno]

All I can say is: SANHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@raneerah7730]

I too feel like going to hell just watching this MV and I still go playing it for hours. It's disturbing yet fascinating at the same time. Like PD mentioned, it's really bold of them to do such a very... veeery literally sinful comeback. And we're all for it.

[@RitzyMeow]

We're all a simp for Moonbin 🙌🙌

[@WellDressedGypsy]

I’m surprised you didn’t mention the transition from when Moonbin says who are you looking for because it was so cool. The way the video team edited it, makes it look like hands are grabbing and pulling him down towards something, maybe hell/the underworld

[@yutaat0.57inkickitmv]

"I don't go to Astro for the sin" -PD during Bad Idea reaction, and now we're here🤣

[@Mhieeeeegvs]

One word: AMAZING

[@MeruHina]

I had to pause like 5 times in my first watch because I was having a mental breakdown (in a good way), so yeah, I totally get what you mean by REALLY enjoying the music video experience.

[@chaeunmoo]

As a Catholic, I was literally surprised that they were that bold with their concept to the point that I worry because if a religious person will see it, they will definitely question it! But it was so good it was like watching a movie!!

[@jackierockers3552]

They are coming to steal our souls and all I can say is I am totally here for this! This whole experience was stunning. It actually gave me chills. Thank you Moonbin and Sanha for taking our breath away! This is hot and sexy and seductive and totally on fire!

[@laolaapanda3723]

This reaction is probably the funniest one I have watched of yours 😂😂😂😂😂

[@MilkshakeCowboy]

He's always so cool and poised with his other reviews but gets so hyped for Astro 😆

[@TheAllycat21]

Moonbin is my ult bias, when you called him the original sinner........... I LITERALLY had to pause this video and hide behind my hair. I do not know why that was my reaction but there it is. btw I might be too loyal cause I agree that Sanha did AMAZING (did it feel like they were trying to present Sanha as not a baby anymore?) but Moonbin still had me shaking to my core. lol

[@VeraOroz]

Genijalni Moonbin❤

[@uwuzaraalex4099]

I think they really chose the concept of this album in line with Eunwoo's drama Island which will be released soon, I think it's really wise to do that. Fantagio made sure to release something related to his two activities with Astro, I think that's great. With “ Ghost town” I already noticed that there was a link with Island and this one is really obvious, is it going to be in the sound track of the drama ? I hope so.

[@stantalentstanastro4178]

i hope so too!! having it as an ost will be great exposure for astro for sure, the world needs to stop sleeping on these talented men

[@NikkaVim]

i'm excited to see your reactions to the B-side songs as well~!!

[@nz_aroha]

Calling Bin the original sin was as hilarious as it is absolute unequivocal FACT

[@liwenhan6970]

lets go madness!!!!!!

[@tia5845]

i think even non-moonbin biased aroha are full time simps for him tbh ahah. i am a loyal jinjin gal but bin’s power is just tew much sometimes!

[@lelayyyy]

You're right. I sin every time I watch Who MV. Mygaaahd

[@breensprout]

someone took his altar boyz role a little too seriously lol

[@karen_lila2purple547]

This is insane...moonbin and sanha left us in shock...i love it ! the versatility in astro 🔥 Thank u 💜

[@lex.7284]

I giggled like a little girl the entire time

[@adaybernaldez705]

Condolence po... Kaway2 sa ating namatay nang dahil sa mv na ito...

[@jhoichan1884]

🥲

[@NikkaVim]

OHMYGASH YAYS I JUST REFRESHED AND U FINALLY UPLOADED THANK YOU PD~!!!!!

[@adrianapaiva7887]

Simply splendid. The concept, costumes and these increasingly sexy and talented boys! maddening

[@楊舒涵-p7c]

moonbin&sanha is perfect!!!!!

[@islandgirlpassing4302]

It's a movie!

[@missow2980]

Love the song, the facial expressions, the concept and the choreography. I dont know where else to look for but everything is here. And man…theeeyyyy are so good portraying the role given. They are truly an artists. What more can you ask for?

[@inahbabe21]

Great reaction! Always looking forward to your ASTRO reaction! More power to your channel PD!

[@mintcho5568]

never expect you will upload this fast! my fav channel and my fav group

[@ave0123]

I'm in love with the overall of WHO. IT'S JUST PERFECT. And yes, I do feel like I'm going to hell for this. But damn!!! BINSAN NAILED THIS CONCEPT

[@Ram875]

That MV and song are SINFUL for so many reasons...

[@ayunniaaafandi]

I waitt for your reaction >< thank youu for supporting moonbin sanha ^^

[@jemiyu7977]

Please watch their Live performance for this song. There are some in You Tube since yesterday.

[@nagischwarz2724]

I do feel like I'm going to hell after that music video. But I also love the song in and of itself. The more I listen to it, the more I like it, for reals.

[@astroaroha0282]

Yeyyyy astrooooo thank you for your reaction 💜

[@limo8699]

It is just incredibly amazing. My mouth can't close all the time the mv is playing. For me, this song is really just stuck in my head! It is so greattt

[@vivicavids3486]

12:35 "The original sinner." 😝😝😝 Sanha was always cutesy until this subunit. They always appear in #dirtymind shorts.

[@astroshama6201]

Thank you so much for reacting 💜 love your reaction 😍

[@viendo7100]

10/10 agree!!!

[@ItsMe-zt6ov]

Love this!!! Thanks for checking them again!!!

[@isabellangelica8695]

literally love the song

[@juzual4251]

I am so happy haha Thank you for the reaction :)

[@elsayeon]

It was really a strong powerful performance.

[@govindapriyadasi286]

Thank you so much for your valuable and professional insights! I like reaction videos which are educational as well!

[@kollie3931]

I find your videos so comforting thank you so much for your content and thank you for loving astro as always

[@_EllaLost]

THIS. THIS IS IT. my favorite reaction video from you lmaooooooo why is this so accurate to my reaction lol

[@nadila5544]

Totally agree about the visual concept. I am not such a big fan of the song itself, I prefer Bad Idea, I think, but the video is just very mesmerizing, like I can't stop watching it!! It is so well done (and yes, a tiny bit uncomfortable cuz of the church stuff xD). I was suprised by the concept, didn't expect that from ASTRO, to be honest. I like they try different concepts, tho. Sexy concept just goes so well with ASTRO, and I'm glad they explore it more. Thanks again for reacting, love the production point of view you share.

[@chickenfish3888]

Thank you so much for this incredible reaction video! ❤️🔥

[@ryndw]

Thankyou for your reaction 💕