The Kulture Study: ASTRO Moonbin & Sanha 'Bad Idea' MV

[@coffeebean_18]

“Why is he dressed like a butcher? Probably because he’s killing it.” This is the only answer I’ll accept 😂😂😂

[@coolgirl312]

There's so many quotable statements in this video: "I don't go to Astro for the sin" "Why is he dressed like a butcher? Probably because he's killing it" "They're touching each other" I'm distracted by this sexy base and...Moonbin's arms" "What a sexy transition, just like the entire music video" "If you have Moonbin, you have sexy" and my personal favorite "MOONBIN'S ARMS!!"

[@scandalmomo]

My favorite is the silent "huuuu" at 5:24

[@liasori]

agreed!!!

[@sleepynoa8277]

PD: *Silent for a solid 30 seconds* PD: "They're touching each other" PD leaving the room to get more water is a mood-

[@Void-g2n]

this deserves more likes

[@german9879]

"if you have moonbin, you have sexy" no lies detected

[@dawn8080]

The very comment I was gonna leave if I couldn't find it 😁

[@trishaihsan8126]

This whole thing was just PD fanboying and representing all of us

[@praetoriatormont3502]

"Sometimes moonbin’s not wearing a shirt, you know, it’s inevitable" IM SCREAMING

[@lillians.4897]

But is PD wrong tho? 😅😖

[@musaviki783]

"Moonbin's arms!!!" "They are touching each other " " bloody, smirking, maniacal Moonbin is an aesthetic I didn't know I needed" -PD-nim 2020

[@malaki.h]

Lol everyone remember when sanha was a curly haired kid with braces, cause I totally forgot👀👀

[@coolgirl312]

Same. I look at Sanha and have to remind myself that this was the kid with the curly hair and overly blushed cheeks in Hide&Seek. He grew up well

[@malaki.h]

@@coolgirl312 yeah he did😌

[@jen_greatguys2721]

honestly this mv reminded me that he had curly hair and braces

[@malaki.h]

@@jen_greatguys2721 im honestly sick of maknaes of idol groups growing and glowing up and totally shedding their young innocent looks like who the hell gave them the right🙂🙂

[@aryabharath2516]

Ikr I can't believe this is the same kid that said "I'm cutie" like omgggg

[@coolgirl312]

"I don't go to Astro for the Sin" me neither, but hey, if they deliver it I'm not one to refuse the package xD

[@brittany7298]

Bluefame is top tier, "THATS NOT MOONBIN IS IT, sorry" will forever be iconic but this time we got "MOONBINS ARMS"

[@caplan9986]

this video should have been titled “PD freaking out over moonbin for 15 minutes”

[@ayeshakhan8503]

Also can someone correct me, but is this not the same set as JUS2.’s Focus on me

[@anastasija4553]

Just wait until PD sees that they performed in crop tops on mcountdown...

[@ronja_kkat]

omfg yes

[@purple_owl2112]

THEY DID WHAT NOW??!!

[@rishakalita4065]

@@purple_owl2112 yes MOONBIN and SANHA performed in Mcountdown in crop tops

[@ronja_kkat]

@@purple_owl2112 yes they did, both, in the thumbnail it looks like it's just Bin but they both have croptops on lol

[@ronja_kkat]

I mean in the beginning lol

[@blueboo5489]

I'm sorry I lost it at "they're touching each other."

[@nanabella123]

THIS IS THE MOST GENUINE MENTAL BREAKDOWN IVE EVER SEEN HELPPPP

[@merryroha6226]

"Blood moonbin laughing maniacally is the asthatic I thought I never thought I needed" Same

[@gstudioz3973]

We are used to the classic "pd.exe has stopped working" But first time... 5:58 pd not found..

[@GeorgieX-1918]

I love how PD just GETS it when it comes to ASTRO. They deserve so much more recognition and love bc they are truly one great group with refreshing songs and concepts!

[@IstanbaldlegendsSungjinDOandKe]

Pd is gone, that’s moonbin’s power y’all

[@Frimizen]

LMAOO THE WAY THEY LEFT THE ROOM RIGHT AFTER AND LITERALLY LEFT IT ROLLING TO GET WATER OMG YES SAME

[@malaki.h]

PD Leaving the room in the middle of a reaction is a mood I'm living for😂😂🙃🙃

[@luciarivero4828]

I came here looking for gold and I found DIAMONDS. I can quote this person all day, I love you.

[@sunflowersinspace]

I love watching the Astro Kulture Studies because I know PD will always freak over Moonbin as much as I do and I just feel so related to 😂

[@raneerah7730]

"I don't go to Astro for the sin" "Don't give me sexy Astro" I never thought it would take me this long to realize why I love ASTRO so much. They are that unique group I love because of their fresh, bubbly, sentimental and aesthetic songs and vocals. Personally, my favorite album is Blue Flame (every song is just a masterpiece) but when it comes to concept, my most favorite are the fresh/emotional ones such as Gateway, Rise Up and Dream Series plus of course their first full album All Light (Actually I just love every album so its hard to pick a fav). Its just SOOO ASTRO; angelic, beautiful, and you can feel the gentleness and overflowing love from their songs. Even Blue Flame actually, though it's dark, the song is still kinda soft for a dark concept compared to Bad Idea. I definitely love the Blue Flame era, but I would prefer more the cozy and fresh looking ASTRO. They could go for a sexy/dark concept but yeah, I think it would suit a subunit of Moonbin&Sanha more since I can't just trade the 6 angelic ASTRO to a sinful one. Lolz. Astro is my ultimate bias because they are my comfort, I guess, and I just feel safe and loved listening to their music. So yes, in conclusion, I just love Astro so much, and thankfully I found the main reason why I can't just turn my back to this wonderful group.

[@caplan9986]

pd: is fine *moonbins arms make an appearance* pd: *panic*

[@leviphan9554]

first time ever i see PD-nim simping over, like, anyone on his channel. But its Moonbin. understandable

[@sanj2819_ykd6]

I’m waiting so badly for him to react to one since it released.

[@cassiearoha573]

I’m amazed you caught the ‘Sanha is stuck in a dream loop’. From what we’ve pieced together, Sanha (cream sweater) has bad dreams on loop so Moonbin enters them and turns back time to stop them from happening. So when he got shot, he was sacrificing himself to save Sanha (he was shielding Sanha from the laser guns) but time got reversed again. This time it was by the evil Sanha in Sanha’s head (the one that looks bloody and dark, that’s why it showed him controlling the guns). So evil dream Sanha and Moonbin fight each other (and reality Sanha continues to toss and turn on the bed) and evil dream Sanha thought he won, but Moonbin actually defeated him (which was why he collapsed after smirking very victoriously). With that, reality Sanha wakes up from his bad dreams.

[@cutiepets423]

I love your therapy, But why first in the video it seem like moonbin who drugged sanha

[@LhimSantos]

MOONBIN'S ARMS: SEXINESS CHECK. PERIOD

[@ericka7901]

“sorry my mind just suddenly got transported back to blue flame and that sinful music video” PD sir your words are God’s work HAHAHAHA YOUR MIND IS BEAUTIFUL AND RELATABLE

[@scandalmomo]

"I don't go to Astro for the sin. Sometimes they bring the sin, sometimes Moonbin is not wearing a shirt" Facts

[@kulsoomshaikh3950]

Watch me stan astro because of pd ;;

[@ericka7901]

don’t give me sexy astro there’s too many boys! this is two boys and I could barely handle two boys 😂😂😂😂 i understand your struggle

[@escoups5267]

When PD got out and came back with water... MOOD

[@ronanedgeworth9162]

6:01 I WAS LIKE WAIT PD WHERE ARE YOU GOING WE STILL NEED TO TALK ABOUT MOONBIN'S ARM

[@ray4223-1d]

Waiting for your reaction to Astro's ONE and their Album 😊

[@niabailey362]

"Their touching eachother.." 🤣 Down PD. Lets be real though..this whole subunit is something I didn't know I needed in my life

[@gemsimagine8486]

WE**** didnt know WE needed 😂😂

[@fararoha9016]

omg every single comment pd said is mood omg I laughed so hard at THEY'RE TOUCHING EACH OTHER

[@cspade5654]

Hope you react to ASTRO full 2nd album too ._. or just their ONE MV! I’m waiting!!!

[@StarshineStranger]

"Don't give me sexy Astro." THANK YOU. SOMEONE ELSE FINALLY SAID IT. As PD said, I go to Astro for the serotonin boosts and beautiful ballads, not the same sexy stuff that literally any other boy group can give. If people like that, fine, but Astro always differentiated themselves so well from the crowd because they do refreshing and bright and happy better than any other group currently in existence, and I'd prefer if they stuck to what they did best. Of course they can experiment with their sound and look in the process, especially as they get older, but I think darker, sexier outings are best suited to b-sides, concert specials, and subunits like this. And even then, to me, Bad Idea came across as more classy rather than just straight sexy. Also, someone at Fantagio had drunk an extra helping of creative juice and was working overtime coming up with this Inception-like concept and MV storyline, which had me rewatching multiple times trying to come up with theories for what it all means, and whoever they are, they deserve a raise.

[@sruthiprasad346]

Exactly bad idea was classy with an amazing story line. Astro are classy men.

[@itsacmr]

Or .. Astro will do whatever they want, no matter the concept 😊

[@shunleileinaing2885]

"they're touching each other.." -iconic line by PD in 2020...

[@catastrophybaby]

“MOONBIN’S ARMSSSS!!” That part got me

[@aryabharath2516]

I'm LIVING for pd losing their shit over Moonbin......such an accurate representation of all of us after watching this mv

[@svttrash5089]

The song is growing on me, wasn't super into it at first. The visuals and the choreo are just 👌🏼

[@sunshineorstorm]

PD not being able to function properly over this MV and song is such a mood

[@nenes24]

the concept for the mv is that moonbin is acting as a "therapist" of sorts, by entering sanha's nightmares (bad dreams) and battling him in order for the "real sanha" to return. my explanation is a bit all over the place but i it based off from what moonbin said himself!

[@Sam-dc8ti]

You should react and fanboying with us on Moonbin’s 24 hours performance, you’re going to represent us all all over again

[@ericka7901]

THE WAY HE FREAKING LEFT THE ROOM TO GET WATER FK HAHAHA I’D DO THE SAME THING GODDD

[@thaynapinheiro6904]

PD to the mv through the whole video: Talented, brilliant, incredible, amazing, show stopping, spectacular, never the same, totally unique

[@cindyfernandez8319]

PD speechless, walking out after watching the vid to drink water is so funny 😂

[@stantalentstanastro4178]

please react to astro one 🥳👆🏻 would love to know what you think of their new sound! (their b sides are still very much ASTRO though, gemini, all good and our spring are written by the members!)

[@franksasstattoo]

This MV was something ELSE So in love. Some parts of it reminded me of Jus2 Focus on Me (aesthetic wise)

[@bibiaysha845]

Imagine Moonbin in a drama as a villian!!!! His hair pushed back and all 😍🤩 Edit: the story line is that Sanha is trapped in a bad dream and Moonbin goes into the dream to 'save' him which is a bad idea Just my interpretation anyways 🤪

[@drinpixeled]

PD thinking I come here expecting a cohesive review of an ASTRO song. That shit knocked me off my feet too man!

[@gemsimagine8486]

"if you have moonbin, you have sexy" Facts only 👌

[@kalpani8506]

PD leaving the room and drinking water is the funniest thing lol. I always enjoy your astro reactions. They are so accurate

[@Lucyy_00]

*He basically said: STREAM BAD IDEA.*

[@engenestay_arohatomoon_ali4087]

I honestly agree with the comment he made about if you have moonbin you have sexy, I am a huge moonbin stan myself

[@m.s8249]

WHEN PD LEFT TO GRAB THE WATER I LOST IT

[@El0dieG]

Are you gonna react to Astro's new album ? It is really good, I like all the songs, they did a good job and 3 members each wrote and composed a song on this album.

[@XcuseMyCharisma_]

OKAY BUT THIS WHOLE REACTION WAS THE AROHA FANDOM IN A NUTSHELL. MINUS THE TEARS, CAUSE I'M SURE WE FLOODED THE WORLD WITH OUR TEARS ALONE.

[@fararoha9016]

yes we all needed water after that mv

[@adamsilvestre7293]

This is the time when PD is such a mood for freaking 14 minutes

[@stayinyorlaine]

guess we all needed some water at some point in time while watching the video hahaha

[@itsmeaddie]

I don't want to spread sadness, but please accept my virtual hugs. I'll miss this kind of reaction of yours watching Moonbin and Sanha.

[@darylg.9765]

thank you pd! confession: you’re one of the reason why i got hooked with ASTRO. it was your reaction to Always You MV when you mentioned that moving light throughout the MV that made me appreciate more their music and aesthetic MVs haha btw im a 16 months old solid aroha hehe

[@ashlin7701]

That “ sometimes Moonbin is not wearing a shirt “ just hits different 😂

[@heyjayjayjay]

I was waiting for this PD!! I still can't over your last reaction to Moonbin dancing on water lol

[@natt3212]

"Don't give me sexy ASTRO. That's too many boys. This is two boys and I can barely handle two boys. I can't handle all that many boys." - PD, 2020

[@sweetpotato3276]

Ahahahahahahahah I loved your reaction, I know it's like this when we talk about Astro; also as a Moonbin lover I feel you * * I totally understand what you say about their music, Astro are amazing but their music is what really trapped me, they have their own fresh, clean and minimal but sophisticated sound. This unit was unexpected but I love it, happy to hear something different from them ^ ^

[@leancrame3500]

SAME WITH THE BASS THE SONG'S FUNKY AND SEXY DAMN THEY KILLED THIS ONE

[@bananamilkeu2004]

5:25 LMAOOOO THE WAY HE JUST GOT UP LIKE ‘aight I gotta go’ AND WAS GONE FOR LIKE 40 SECONDS AND RETURNED W A WHOLE ASS BRITTA BAISHSJWISBEIW I CANT

[@factsoverfelix]

From what I understood of this music video, it's about Moonbin trying to save Sanha from his own mind, or his 'Bad Ideas'. He drugs Sanha, and then himself so that they're both in Sanha's mind. There, Bin tries to take all of Sanha's burdens for himself, hence him turning back time to get shot instead of Sanha. That's why there's the scene of them fighting, Sanha wins, but Bin has a pained smile on his face... he's happy that he freed Sanha from his dark thoughts. I'm not too sure about the ending, but I think that it didn't end up working, because seeing Bin in pain because of him made Sanha's 'Bad Idea's worse. That's why it kind of restarts, Bin probably tries again.

[@hokutoast4680]

The thumbnail: 'i got thirsty so much i had to bring a pitcher' 🤣

[@rabh888]

PLS THIS REACTION WAS ALL I NEEDED OMG I LOVE PD 😭😭😭😭

[@sg0648]

i can’t believe you actually went through with the random thumbnail idea you talked about in stream

[@moonbinisatongue]

*Issok PD-nim. We can all RELATE* 😌 Moon Bin's Frickin Arms!!! Also, that cut at his Waist? Oh god😍

[@weewoong4893]

we all love moonbin's arms

[@jessethejoyful]

I think this is my favorite of your reactions 🤣🤣🤣

[@fira2212]

MOONBIN ARMS!!! RIP earphones. This is exactly the reaction I expected from you.. It’s always fascinating to watch your “fanboy” reaction over Astro. Thanks for the video! 😊😊😊

[@Andrea-bc1mb]

omg I ***DIEEEDDDD*** when PD left the room for an eternity and returned with a WHOLE PITCHER of water and then poured it and drank it without saying a word

[@ashley-or7zp]

ooo was just listening to it. it’s addicting! and the choreo is so good as well.

[@julieduong6571]

When you left...me: “he’s DONE” then came back with pitcher of 💦: 😆...💜

[@hmssurprise1805]

What a wonderful MV, in music, production values and execution. In this MV - Moonbin is actually entering Sanha’s bad dreams and is trying to help Sanha fight his bad dream/ideas. At one point we actually see “Bad” Sanha (also dressed in black) fighting with Moonbin, and although he seems to win - Moonbin laughs and changes the whole ‘darkness’ vibe to one of release and healing. Sanha awakes and is back to reality, no longer in his bad dreams/thoughts. This is one I will be watching/listening to over and over again! Thanks so much for your review - your reaction, as always is spot on and true!

[@salamiander]

0:41 the zoom-in on pd's stank face when they said "dark... and sexy" killed me :'D and tbh they weren't wrong lolol

[@Momobibii]

absolutely lost it when you got up for that holy water 😂

[@prettylilay]

NO REACTION VIDEO FOR ASTRO'S ONE? T_T I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR YOUR VIDEO SINCE ONE RELEASED T_T

[@bridgettabago6891]

PD : *MOONBIN'S AAAAARMS!*

[@gee3003]

from what fantagio music said, the mv is a therapist (?) something like that. sanha was having a bad dream and moonbin entered his dream to stop and fight that's why you saw them fighting each other (sanha's bad dream)

[@mybiasastro_6]

Pd sir plsss you are such a mood when you go crazy after seeing Moonbin😂🔥 I'm Moonbin biased too^^

[@katielm1328]

The Moonbin focus cams for this song are **chef’s kiss**!! He is one of my favorite idols to watch dance! He has such great proportions and body lines and he is so graceful and pair that with this song and choreo and DAMN WHAT A GIFT TO A MOONBIN STAN LIKE MYSELF!! This song took me back to the crazy sexy cool days. I wish their BSides both on this album and Astro’s albums explores this sound a bit more. It feels like majority of their songs are ballads and I wish they got to do a more even mix of upbeat songs!

[@aryabharath2516]

When it zoomed in onto pds face omg I lost it

[@__myungbinnie]

I feel you, this unit era is crazy, sexy and cool.

[@flaviabiswas1019]

hi....this song will hit you different if you watch the performance ,,,,,,,its on another level

[@thepark_s4577]

You're the biggest moonbin fan i know and i'm here for it !

[@annam3598]

Pretty good about the dream state! Bad idea also reference bad thoughts, memories, etc. Sanha is fighting off these bad ideas, thoughts, memories, etc

[@emilyd1364]

"they are touching each other" -said with extreme jealousy

[@madelyn4508]

their b side tracks are awesome too soulful and r&b touch. all iwanna do is my favorite.

[@kimh5444]

Love it when PD's reaction/review is literally just him fanboying. I literally thought he was not coming back after he left to get water XDDD

[@eternalblris8616]

Around 0:29s of the MV, looking back, spotlighted Moonbin is just “homme fatale” material of all time. Just before that cut, Sahna stare at the Moonbin is also beautiful. At that time, Moonbin and Sanha’s dangerous “rendez-vous” has started. Speaking of which, rendezvous, especially “space rendezvous”, which means two different spaceships approaching very close, it’s so creative and bit sensual metaphor of two men getting close each other, I think... because, at the spaceship, they are fighting each other till bleed, and Moonbin has get shot of his heart... so... yeah... Anyway, visual aesthetics from Matrix, Inception, Tenet, 2001:A space odyssey... are beautifully brought together for crazy sexy cool Moonbin & Sanha.

[@ahgraeyo]

사랑해유 아재..우리 아스트로 아가들 이쁘게봐줘서 고마워유..허허

[@victoriaperez5975]

THE ONLY REACTION VIDEO THAT MATTERS. STAN ASTRO.