The Last of Us Part 2 reaction at the Playstation Experience 2016

[@internetexplorer5423]

Little did they know it was coming out until another 4 years 😂

[@kalkos6162]

😂😂😂

[@Transfurred]

And likely a huge disappointment

[@owenstahl9324]

fax bruh i’ve been waiting like 5 years

[@owenstahl9324]

Riru Kito i started playing it in 2015 so it’s been 5 years

[@diamondredstone491]

@Riru Kito it's not horrible but at the same time it is company actually got paid to give it a good review and the game is technically a movie and the movie and the gameplay has not changed so sorry bro but in honesty it is kind of disappointing

[@bretbret8293]

They opened and closed the PSX conference with Naughty Dog games. That studio is a monster. Take my money ND.

[@paladindarc]

Bret Reed they opened with marvel vs capcom but ok

[@bretbret8293]

Joshua Davila That was the second game they showed. They opened with Uncharted: The Lost Legacy. Maybe you missed that.

[@luzbeldados8284]

u remember when this year sony open the e3?

[@lucnillesen7517]

Bret Reed what did they all have I only know the last of uss part 2. And yes i,m hyped!!!!!

[@joseantoniogarciagonzalez8353]

Ris _ 03 s

[@bumblebee9736]

0:39 - "WOOOOO, called that shit !". I love it.

[@guilhermezalla2032]

The power of Playstation

[@Musiclovergirl1232]

Geralt Marston The power of *The Last of Us

[@whyarewestillhere1073]

Geralt Marston power of gamer

[@caiovargascomarella2996]

Alexandria Maxwell ps>>all.

[@kingslove666]

All of the above

[@teorasduxas754]

Gandalf Marston of Rivia tf does ps have to do with this? £ower of naughty dog more like

[@dylangutierrez7482]

Still gives me the chills I’ve been waiting for 7 years

[@Sc00byg00ky]

Yikes

[@pikantoz7146]

I offer you my condolences

[@chrism.m4906]

7 years of waiting wasted

[@casheycashey3614]

It was def worth it it me, I loved it

[@tj-bk1eb]

People who hate on tlou2 just wanna hate for no reason 🤣

[@Skitz0frenix]

That dude in the left down corner literally took a step back at 0:36 when he realized what he was watching

[@spike5609]

Anybody else hear the cow scream a 3:55

[@elliemalik2869]

jose chavez lol it's like me screaming hahaha 😂😂

[@Alina-tl4rj]

jose chavez hhahaha oh my god ...that got me

[@picklejuice4513]

Tratts Spike 😂💀

[@funforsameer1769]

Tratts Spike Banshee*

[@KJCOD]

Tratts Spike I

[@firaga21st]

So, after she killed, she plays them a song for their sick souls...

[@titiv22]

FireLeaf i guess so

[@firaga21st]

that's why i love this trailer.

[@libertarianvoter]

It's a lot more elegant than tea-bagging, eh?

[@firaga21st]

lol

[@felipemorales5724]

FireLeaf dude Joel swear her he gonna teach her to play guitar

[@gustavodelfino703]

5 years later and i got chills every time.

[@slowedjaze5012]

Ah the KZbin algorithm has brought us all here again. Too bad the game doesn't bring the same amount of positivity as it did in this video anymore.

[@Aurosis]

why? i didn't buy the game. what's the deal with the last of us 2? could someone tell me without any spoilers?

[@ChoZenWuen]

DarkRainyCloud hard to say without spoilers to be honest

[@nick23347]

@@Aurosis dogshit story

[@dr.doctor4878]

@@Aurosis shitty story, changed character personality that makes me hate her, Joel killed so early, and more

[@xdbetamale3178]

@@dr.doctor4878 Dude he literally asked for no spoilers

[@brandonharris4430]

I didn't even play the first one and I'm hyped for this.

[@edwin99901]

Brandon Harris bitch you bettah

[@xavierquiles3037]

Brandon Harris No. You play the first one before this.

[@tldoesntlikebread]

you gotta play it. really awesome game, a work of art. and this Part II is a tad bit spoilery of the TLOU Part I

[@brandonharris4430]

I watched TheRadBrad play it, since I didn't have time to play it myself.

[@tldoesntlikebread]

Brandon Harris oh that's too bad then.

[@kokocute123]

Imagine the disappointment of these people now. - June 2020

[@putudemasardinamerta2306]

The Story is meh, poorly writing

[@josephl9289]

Gelar Pradipta the story is complete trash the only good thing about it is voice acting, graphics, and level designs

[@itgoodthings9158]

We all on the same boat F*ck drugman

[@ajack3526]

Gelar Pradipta Yeah, it’s a 5/10, as compared to the first game which is a 10/10

[@connor2015]

I actually really enjoyed the game.

[@HRavenfolks]

Everyone : "I can't wait for this game to come out!" Neil Druckmann: *Execute order 66*

[@rock-n-party9241]

i wonder how their legs felt after a long stand outside

[@JohnDoe-dw8eh]

I mean the presentation was like 1,5 hours.. that's not so bad unless you're not on your feet often lol

[@rachidahidrony556]

RoCk-N-PaRtY introvert?

[@ungobungo7986]

@@rachidahidrony556 hes saying they are all introverts... jesus I swear people get more retarded and cant recognize jokes every day

[@pepsimanv6124]

feels like it got blown off with a double barrelled shotgun, getting held while on the ground and forced to endure pain with a golf stick... Joel in one I guess...

[@frostyphox]

Worst time to recommend this to me

[@raddarat8471]

*best

[@anembassyfromhell8140]

Yep.

[@someguy9451]

@@raddarat8471 is that sarcasm

[@alexcastelan1432]

@@raddarat8471 no

[@technique1983]

😂😂

[@Kuzgunrunner1]

I think inside was full, that's why they are outside!

[@jordanjones8120]

Elite Kara it was filled to the brim inside for sure

[@sliverspoon195]

KZbin throwing mad shade to naughtydog for recommending all these reactions to everyone's feed

[@Meshari92]

And now PlayStation KZbin channel turned off comments and likes & dislikes for all Last of Us videos. They knew the fans are going to rant about the game

[@Gamersaures]

So true XD

[@Yuqirang]

Lol did they expect fans to praise them after they bruttaly masacre part 1 fans favourite (joel). They even force us to play with the character who we dont even want to play (we want to kill her!!!).....

[@turkeybreakfeast3965]

Only if they knew that the game was gonna be a golf simulator

[@forestfire47]

*trans porn simulator

[@mallorquinista0611]

*cry simulator

[@potato6216]

And that joel was the ball.

[@raddarat8471]

Guitar simulator

[@pepsimanv6124]

Joel in one

[@K0RGAN0S7]

4 years later.. I regret why i so hype for this 4 years.

[@remyr4268]

We waited 7 years for a golfclub.

[@BFancybones]

game bad

[@romanlinnik7441]

@@BFancybones it is.

[@BFancybones]

@@romanlinnik7441 that's wierd. I've never seen a bad game get 10/10 and 5/5 as consistently as TLoU2

[@isayuh5303]

@@BFancybones it got 10/10 from shitty critics, it's not surprising or weird at all, they probably got paid to give them 10/10 or 5 stars

[@Ricky911_]

@@BFancybones maybe you should also ask yourself why only 42% of Google Users liked the second game whereas 97% of them liked the first game.

[@itmereef564]

I come from the future! You’d be surprised about what happens when it finally got released

[@トホク]

Why KZbin, don’t recommend this to me. It hurts.

[@fegeleinherman8587]

Because today you suffer with me

[@odinson5911]

Who's here after.... Ya know.....

[@TheTwitcher]

Poor guys , they had no idea lol

[@MaikeruNoKen05]

The Twitcher Rip Joel Miller

[@sonicdark1375]

Bro signal the spoiler you dingus

[@TheTwitcher]

Sonic Dark i honestly couldn’t care less lol

[@sonicdark1375]

not you, sorry. I meant Michael Giardinelli

[@goodninji8]

I was in the other line watching this outside! So glad to see the audiences admiring this franchise and knowing what's what (:

[@igorlukyan206]

I envy everybody who wanted to play this and died before the leaks came out

[@joshua7010]

so you're basically saying you want to die?

[@comicsmania6782]

No, it was a joke.

[@Thraiel]

@@joshua7010 i wish i can

[@boomboxlamb8791]

Boy o boy, looking at the past and knowing the future sure is something lol

[@-goosemono-7293]

Yes ma'am

[@boomboxlamb8791]

- Goosemono - Wrong gender.

[@-goosemono-7293]

@@boomboxlamb8791 Yes dad.

[@boomboxlamb8791]

- Goosemono - Wrong gender again.

[@raddarat8471]

Yes freak

[@shannon655]

The reaction here just shows how much the game got to people! Shivers!!

[@necrago]

now it literally got to people 🤣

[@shannon655]

Necrago OOOF 😂

[@deadshotdaiquiri_4217]

Shannon You came back after 3 years points for dedication

[@harrylazan9301]

Ma'am here's your golf stick

[@dariushardy3659]

I see all the reactions and I still have chills.

[@aacurrie1]

If only they knew...

[@williamsantiago9284]

yea it’s such a hit to the head tbh realizing what it ends up being... like a golf club to the head :(

[@Gamersaures]

I thought This was game called the last of us not assassins creed where you kill your targets one by one.... Revenge and sh*t and to be honest they just used Joel for their profit

[@BFancybones]

@@Gamersaures they used everything for profit...?? That's how a business works? They created a story to sell a game.

[@pikantoz7146]

@@BFancybones yeah a shit story that's what

[@abbadereltitan]

@@BFancybones It's a shit story and when the leaks came out people realized it was a shit story. Naughty Dog was in danger of losing sells so what they did was falsely advertise after that. I'm glad most people cancelled their preorders for this game.

[@avian9033]

Trailer still gives me chills

[@andreatoppi5627]

And.....we re finally arrived. 4 fucking years, 7 from the first game. Many fans died, in the meantime.

[@flamingphoenix3819]

I dont own a ps4 only an xbox one but i did play the first last of us and i gotta say that game is one of the greatest games i have ever played and i WILL be getting a ps4 just to be able to play this game.

[@pepsimanv6124]

pls dont

[@YungBalaklava]

Whatta big middle finger to xbox players

[@Dorion95]

😂

[@Elllie101]

They look so hyped Little did they know

[@RealMilkmann]

Does someone remember when we all thought the girl that was about to be executed was Ellie’s mom? No anyone?

[@altryen5796]

I member

[@jbann6668]

It's awesome how they all screamed when they saw the Fireflies logo

[@iNeon-03]

2016, everyone: there 2020, everyone: not there

[@realkingofantarctica]

Imagine coming home from work early because of all your stress and migraines and just trying to lie down and relax for a moment... Then this happens

[@ReeceyBoy_4]

man that gives me goosebumps.

[@RatedRLoquender]

And now?

[@TheCaptaintoontown]

Xbox players r shaking in their grave

[@muhammadibne4928]

We as a PS player we know their feelings 😂😂😂

[@ToxicGam3r02]

Ivan Ringle fuck the leaks I’m hyped!!!

[@SUPERSTARSUDEEP]

@Ivan Ringle one game turning into shit is not gonna make us shake. We still getting that Ghost of tsushima 💀 what y'all getting?

[@jasqr6338]

TANGY JASON when?

[@tomoca1246]

@@SUPERSTARSUDEEP wtf? Gos is a ps exclusive

[@simonevandermerwe4445]

I love how as soon as that fireflies logo appears, everyone just *knows* 🤩

[@adhamajram7243]

How much does this game cost?

[@simonevandermerwe4445]

@@adhamajram7243 uh I don't know dollar that well, but if I convert from our currency, I'd say about $70

[@adhamajram7243]

@@simonevandermerwe4445 yo bro thank you

[@dratylapio]

@@simonevandermerwe4445 its 60... pretty much all standard games cost 60. The digital version is cheeper

[@TheBearWithOrangeFur]

adham ajram Lol don’t waste your money on another Golf video game.

[@Soup_man347]

When I first saw this I cried with tears of joy. I was in my English class at the time and me and my buddy where so hyped. I'm so happy that this game is almost out

[@AnalogFoundry]

Same, dude. :) Tears of joy.

[@Sc00byg00ky]

How you guys feel about the game now?

[@Soup_man347]

@@Sc00byg00ky I'm worried but I'm still excited for it

[@aseem2985]

Imagine how crushed these guys were after watching the leaks 😂🤧

[@Danebrass12]

Jesus you are so handsome

[@Virtual_Sphere_]

Crushed is an understatement lol... I feel... Ultimately betrayed

[@gjgr7772]

@@Virtual_Sphere_ why is that?

[@Danebrass12]

Don't kill Ellie, please - She's the last of us, too!

[@salaahkhayr2398]

Dane Brass simp

[@KidAL0]

Guy with flannel and backpack is unimpressed

[@marwanelsayed4834]

DelsinJordan lolol

[@joshmiller1066]

He must be a Xbox fan.. 😁

[@DarkBond98]

+Joshua O'Hara he must be a normal person.

[@codyferrell5075]

It cause he thought joels cosplay of joel was better than his

[@theevilwithin8946]

He prolly is thinking about how fast he has to sell his backpack so that he can finally get rid of his stupid worthless FUCK-BOX and join the real gaming family.

[@Ghost-pq9eh]

Before people start saying that PlayStation is better than Xbox, can we just stop and agree that both consoles have their ups and downs but they still have games that bring us joy and that we can come together and appreciate

[@owenstahl9324]

nah xbox has no good exclusives

[@MrJackrussell12]

I own both, and hands down Xbox is cheaper then PlayStation! The menu sucks, party chat audio sucks, graphics aren't that great, and more. The only game I actually like that's an exclusive to Xbox and steam is sea of thieves! Only thing that keeps my Xbox on

[@TheZantose]

Ghost this dude speaking facts

[@TheDarklord176]

PlayStation is better than Xbox!!

[@dave.the.collector.]

We really had no clue. No idea what was coming.

[@alphaaicore8493]

Did youtube try to make me watch every single tlou 2 announcement video

[@ThatDudeJCrash]

Haha was that filipinochamp at 3:49 on the right side?

[@thelastbosses]

Yup, Yipes was in line too.

[@mexic8l]

thelastbosses there were no "women" in the "crowd" in front of u, right?

[@MohamedIbrahim-hg5mu]

4 years later I feel sad for this people if they just knew the truth 😔😢😢

[@MaikeruNoKen05]

X Gamer Rip Joel Miller

[@JesusPerez-ln6gp]

Just a couple of days now. I can’t fckn wait!!!

[@yeetskeetlit3771]

Jesus Perez the game is trash dude, have u seen the leaks? can't believe they killed joel with a golf club

[@mr.memeking5719]

@@yeetskeetlit3771 so what's wrong with Joel dying?

[@satantcor1546]

@@mr.memeking5719 Nothing is wrong with it. You play as the same woman who killed Joel for a long majority of the game, Abby. Honestly I think we all expected Joel to die this sequel, BUT the story about vengeance and all that with the unnecessary, unlikable characters doesn't favor me. The gameplay is impressive though.

[@JesusPerez-ln6gp]

YeetSkeet Lit nahh I ddnt know. But well tbh I seen that coming. Since the end of the first one. It just makes sense that something bad happens to one of em it’s supposed to be a kinda dark game. Just remember what happnd to Joel’s daughter 🤷🏻‍♂️😅 regardless it will be a masterpiece just watch 😎

[@xEspurr1]

REVENGE IS A FOOL'S GAME - Arthur Morgan

[@TheCarlos1135]

This didn't age well. Lol

[@pepsimanv6124]

yep

[@KabroSaavedra]

Absolutely

[@piyush2173]

Well it aged well actually, if you pay attention to the trailer and the lyrics of the song it will hit differently.

[@PetalsFourArmor]

The game was amazing tho

[@Lymezy]

@@piyush2173 I think he was referring to the trailer showing Joel alive. Also this scene and what he said in this scene never actually happened in game.

[@crnx5483]

WHO is here after it came out

[@RatedRLoquender]

Me and i liked the game

[@mxv2704]

Im Crying

[@gymbrogamer]

Adrian Navarro same, every time I see these reaction videos

[@mxv2704]

Peke Peke 👌

[@akisenpai5797]

Peke LIKE YOU HAH

[@mentorassassin0282]

Oh how the tables have turned

[@301Made]

Xbox is taking so many L's 😂

[@handmeadozenbeers8655]

Ssj .Blurr you mean Xbox 180 cuz they keep changing their policies...

[@301Made]

Hand me a Dozen Beers you mean 360 buddy?

[@handmeadozenbeers8655]

Ssj .Blurr 180 because they did a complete turnaround (180 degrees)

[@301Made]

***** i have both and i actually prefer xbox live and there controller more

[@301Made]

***** they are taking L's. they have no games and the ps4 is out selling them. obvious L. I feel bad for all the ppl without a ps4 that wont ever get to play the last of us 1 or 2. and the ps4 already looks great.

[@Jaybi_Haider]

Oh how times have changed.

[@futuredemon2843]

Looking back at this is different and just image the hype they had and they just found out later that this game would be delayed so many times

[@yeetskeetlit3771]

Future Demon and that the game is absolute trash.

[@Fyde2]

YeetSkeet Lit play it then speak

[@gray01216]

@@Fyde2 No, thanks. The gameplay is already enough to see the game is completely shit and i'm not going to spend 60 bucks for garbage.

[@산딸기-l6x]

2016: SHITTTTTTTTT 2020: Shit.....

[@idontevenknow1859]

Remember watching this live some of the most hype shit ive ever seen. Now im just dissapointed...

[@wallacesousuke1433]

@@idontevenknow1859 hahahaha you deserve that dumbass

[@lruwlmq]

So it’s About 3 years later and I honestly wanna know what’s everybody’s opinion on everything that has to do with the game right now. 👍 or 👎

[@yeetskeetlit3771]

Lucky This game would have been probably the best game of the year, but unfortunately the devs ruined it with the story they gave us. Me and some freud s aren't gonna buy the game because I don't want to play this bad of a story.

[@satantcor1546]

👎 Definitely. We'll wait and see.

[@FR0ZENxTUNA]

I am from the future. It's not worth the wait.

[@rasohigh]

Whose here after playing the last of us 2 and mourning what could’ve been?

[@morganborzelli8942]

LESS THEN 4 days I remember watching this back in the day

[@RainbowsClone]

The day this game releases is the day my PS4's fan takes off

[@GonzalezJio]

Is it ready?

[@chrism.m4906]

@@GonzalezJio hell no cause this game is never gonna touch my ps4

[@dr.deadpool5959]

Most of the people you see here didn’t buy the game or did buy the game and proceeded to throw it in the trash after seeing the ending

[@maiz3558]

Awww feel so sorry for them

[@soulstriker773]

“Surely goodness and mercy will follow all the days of my life” part gave me goosebumps

[@phatbeatz1311]

Watching it this while it about to be release hours from now in june 18 2020. Damn its been way too long, such a amazing game.

[@pepsimanv6124]

oh no

[@Sam-qv8dq]

So much fucking potential. I can't believe they did us so wrong. The worst part is hyping Joel's presence so much in the trailer. And his presence isn't even a major part of the game. Revenge is the most over used trope in story telling, especially when done wrong. And considering what a masterpiece the first story was, nobody expected anything less from naughty dog. Joel and Ellie deserved better.

[@jononaka543]

look at this poor souls..

[@chrism.m4906]

Why did they do you like that

[@lynn.chaaaa]

RIP Joel 💔

[@saratoga4126]

You're a poor soul

[@markalfa2689]

Ehy joel wassup

[@Fachri444]

I'm from the future and this game look's..........................

[@kelIin]

the game looks amazing but the story itself just can’t be compared to the last of us 1.

[@millionareowl6302]

We were such fools... such fools...

[@chrism.m4906]

Not me I already knew that if they did a sequel it was gonna be shit they should've left it alone it was already perfect

[@John-core]

There's still alot of delusional people who think this game is great (probably naughty dog and Sony employees) Also druckmann is trolling the fanbase on his twitter page, how disrespectful is that? Its the fanbase that made this franchise popular in the first place!

[@ariesgonzalezag]

John Powell cause y’all are annoying as fuck. The game is good, aint no ones fault y’all expected the same shit

[@Myemnhk]

4 years to develop that can of shit

[@lesterbronson2385]

Tlou2 trailer still makes me emotional till this day. Naughty Dog is the greatest and most consistent gaming development team of all time. Hands down.

[@panzerkampfwagen-drei]

Seven years of development for THIS?

[@supermariogalaxy2pro874]

Shivers galore!

[@denis_t89xd64]

it's amazing to see their reaction when they saw the last of us part 2 in 2016 when it just came out in 2020 it's beautiful to watch these videos

[@JJcrabtower]

Feel the excitement and goosebumps of everything with this game, you feel you are watching a realistic movie

[@KabroSaavedra]

Poor people... they didn't know what would happen

[@aydenmcdaniel4088]

bruh i cry literally everytime i watch this

[@chrism.m4906]

I bet you cried when you played this game lmao

[@aydenmcdaniel4088]

@@chrism.m4906 lol i wish, cant get it until friday but my whole twitter feed and youtube feed is this game, hard to stay blind, im sure it will be great tho

[@pepsimanv6124]

@@aydenmcdaniel4088 oh how wrong were you buddy

[@aydenmcdaniel4088]

@@pepsimanv6124 i was wrong to cry?? ok bro

[@pepsimanv6124]

@@aydenmcdaniel4088 I meant the great part, game storyline isnt great in fact its kinda shitty dont get me wrong but if you wanna spend 30 bux on a game that kill their own popular character and make the game's writer be in there, spits on Joel, then go on ahead no ones stopping you

[@LordDosser]

4 years in a 1 week is gonna be real

[@iskegt7562]

Xd

[@poopplug8215]

Fax

[@dratylapio]

5 days o-o

[@iskegt7562]

Wait I don't have any PlayStation. HOW CAN İ PLAY TLOU P2?! FK

[@dratylapio]

@@iskegt7562 u need a playstation my friend

[@Samurasa.]

Here we are

[@Davee_10js]

In 7 days we finally can play it 👀❤️

[@Davee_10js]

Geonic Publico wym

[@RatedRLoquender]

Kury Whats wym?

[@Davee_10js]

RatedRLoquender what you mean

[@steveluna1627]

It's a shame they did a full Game of Thrones move

[@psydoof]

You mean a sadist move

[@clarkwayne339]

It's golf time

[@JohnDonovan1968]

Watching this was like getting hit in the head by a golf club.

[@AddinRoyale]

Hey, I am new to the last of us Franchise and i got a question Why is everyone disapppinted of the 2nd game. I saw the gameplay and i actually liked it. Can someone explain?

[@repxic9314]

You will learn it son, you will learn it.

[@GeZeek]

You must play the first one to understand the second one

[@crazykinglv]

You will find out once you start playing the second half of part 2

[@alessandrocajili3840]

I swear If they don't rewrite this game I'll be so mad!!

[@crazykinglv]

ChknHows 917 Thry can’t just remake a game that would take years to do, they just need to add a cut scene at the end where Ellie wakes up from a dream or something.

[@PhoenixAUST]

ellie: sings for 0.2 seconds crowd: *instantly cheers*

[@TheMaxbohmer]

How the tables have turned

[@firepitch5113]

"oh how the turns have tabled" - michael

[@JohnDonovan1968]

Max Bohmer Neil Drunkmann, one guy alone destroyed Naughty Dog.

[@jms53h47]

John Donovan god I want to punch that guy in the face

[@boristheblade5933]

@@firepitch5113 "look how the turntables" If you're gonna quote office, please get it right

[@firepitch5113]

@@boristheblade5933 meh only watched it 8 years ago so didn't think it was right in the first place😂

[@giftycustom5560]

Imma smash that screen if i knew the story is gonna be like this

[@sonecabr06]

I wish i could Tell them: dont be só excited...

[@suhailmustafa2724]

When the firefly logo comes in.... shivers galore

[@noname-gq7zg]

Feels good to have the Switch, Xbox, and Playstation ;)

[@Gerraint]

The comment section didn't age very well

[@hasancirkin7921]

Truly saying this : Every freaking time that ı watch part 2 trailer , ı went shaking because of the first game

[@pepsimanv6124]

you'd be shaking your head wih how bad this game is gonna be today

[@hasancirkin7921]

@@pepsimanv6124 Yea bro. I have finished that piece of shit in 3 days after release, and I am very upset. It is so bad that ruined the first game for me.

[@hallo4651]

Litlle did they know... Wonder how they are goin now

[@DoubleDuck_]

Now everyone wants to go back to that

[@theclickbaitdetective9196]

Loved how hyped everyone was for this game & now they are shitting on it.

[@jcs44444]

Because it’s shit

[@catsexe6932]

Finish the game and we will talk

[@pepsimanv6124]

@@catsexe6932 why would you do that when the leaks is correct anyway?

[@catsexe6932]

@@pepsimanv6124 maybe he have the game that is why