The McElroys Create a Wild Magic Table for Roll for Sandwich Season 5

Jake from Roll for Sandwich asked the guys to create a Wild Magic Table for him to use in the new season of the show, and they were all too happy to oblige. Enjoy this peek at the process that went into building the list, and be sure to follow Roll for Sandwich on KZbin and Tiktok to see what happens once the dice are rolled.
Check out Roll for Sandwich on KZbin: @adventuresinaardia
Watch the Season 5 premiere of Roll for Sandwich: • Roll for Sandwich EP 2...
Follow Roll for Sandwich on TikTok: / adventuresinaardia
Follow The McElroy Family on TikTok: / themcelroyfamily

[@jordantherrien74]

This had big “naming of the year” energy. Twenty-Magic Shell: Make it Cold Twenty-Ball it Up: Whatever it Takes

[@Jeevesie1988]

Twen-turlet: As many bags as it takes, just get it in there!

[@Rutskarn]

It's like a "name the year" with only losers, but in a good way.

[@lesbleus71]

This is Monster Factory for a sandwich. It's very, very good. Very powerful.

[@TheMcElroyFamily]

Very nice, very evil

[@BucklingSwashes]

No middle sliders!

[@bitrotter]

@@BucklingSwashes slow clap. you win the day.

[@annamoss9804]

I want to like this but there are already 69 likes.

[@FUSIONJAZZMAN420]

Brought you you by Wendy's

[@foolharde-love4322]

the Poo-Vide line was inspired, and went utterly unremarked by the brothers. Griffin is a fucking gift. 11:58

[@suppersready]

it's right up there with "panenis"

[@hoardlydad]

I thought the same thing! I was like "Really guys? Nothing?" It was so good.

[@mattfinin6934]

I was just about to say it

[@zrrob1149]

He's so happy with himself!

[@h0t3lp4p4]

What I came to the comments for

[@danielleschmidt2954]

Love how you guys were like "oh no blending it is too far but let's make him dunk it in the toilet".

[@g00go]

many times did i shake my head in disagreement at the balk-then-acceptance of the toilet dip

[@chasemillermusic]

It’s in a bag, Travis

[@shrimp.trap3]

i also think it breaks the No Poison rule edit: I mean you can get very very sick from ingesting toilet water so I think that probably counts as poison but I don’t know what definition the boys are going by

[@g00go]

@@shrimp.trap3 i wouldnt be dipping my sandwich in booboo water no matter how many bags you put it in. It's Poison!

[@tiffanyb3147]

😂😂😂

[@baphometsvomitcomet2350]

Travis trying to correctly pronounce "jus" while he brothers just keep repeating "jeu" was pretty funny

[@AdamDrew]

I AM GLAD I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO NOTICED. THANK YOU.

[@Saeko]

Justin being so worried about allergens, but suggests an almond spread 😂

[@nicolehunt7548]

Griffins delight at 12:00 at "poo-veed" is fantastic

[@natrick]

The lack of reaction from Justin and Travis made me sad 😂😂😂 I heard that and I lost it

[@ssaquiettraveler]

The leap from make it greasy to put it in the toilet is astronomical.

[@ikebert3914]

"Like a Poo-Vide!" Criminal that this was glossed over

[@adventuresinaardia]

😂 yes that killed me

[@mpbx3003]

I think the best part here is that they never really made the connection that "It has to go in the toilet" being No.2 was itself a solid joke. [I also enjoyed "greasy" and "Greece-y" being on opposite sides of the 'middle rolls' of the list.]

[@MicahIphone]

I loved how Juice jumped on Griff bit on the Greasy/Greece-y and was like... well hold on. We do in fact need to make it Greece-y.

[@mpbx3003]

@@MicahIphone Juice knows when a bit is worth pursuing!

[@adventuresinaardia]

This is going to be… something 😅

[@Spalfos]

What a phenomenal crossover

[@TheMcElroyFamily]

Off to a good start, at least!

[@alexanderdean1300]

What did you sign up for? But this is the crossover we never knew we needed.

[@mollymeadows5849]

Yeah good luck with this one. Can't wait to watch.

[@bassetts1899]

14:28 the phrase "YOU HAVE HIM DIPPING IT IN A TURLET!" keeps popping into my head at random times

[@mockduckcompanion]

I love that Griffin independently and inadvertently invented Hot Pockets

[@peterbyrne5004]

"Ball It Up (Whatever It Takes)" sounds like it should be a song on the Top Gun soundtrack

[@freehim939]

After hearing Travis' suggestions I am now convinced that he eats like Will Ferrell in Elf

[@jonahlyons4646]

With the sheer amount of food monster stories they have about him I made that assumption LONG ago 😂

[@nataliemintz6507]

In a super early episode of MBMBaM they address the fact that Travis eats like someone is about to take his food away 🤣

[@clintlose9105]

Justin's pretty little kitty rolls up to pay respects to Mario at 4:20 my friends. Have a blessed one.

[@johnfay6140]

Blaze it

[@pink_sunflower_girly4705]

thank you kind traveller

[@tiffanyb3147]

Oh I missed that

[@tiffanyb3147]

Omg…kitty stares at the closed door then walks away…my cat would sit there

[@NateCummings]

God bless

[@Nono-hk3is]

Wait, Griffin looked at a pepperoni sandwich and thought, "this need SALT" ?!?!

[@Jeevesie1988]

Big "pouring soy sauce into your ramen" energy for sure. XD

[@Carrigan1248]

Reminder: They ARE from West Virginia.

[@laneywangler574]

Eat it in a Subway has me in tears😭

[@BryanIsche]

This captures the magic I miss from yahoo answers: a silly, simple prompt that opens up a wide space for these good boys to play in

[@gz5163]

The kind of sandwich they serve at Plato's Rave

[@Rictavio27]

they only serve wings at Plato’s Rave. (dry rub on 3, sauce on 6)

[@MsDianagentaToYou]

I think I'd have added "liberal sprinkling of bluest Kool aid mix available". Just to have a nice blue tongue for a visual experience.

[@digdude64]

This is a just streamlined version of titling the year on MBMBAM and I'm here for it.

[@MattFredFry]

Justin's hair is MAGNIFICENT

[@ollyoxenfree6935]

Hot take: hands free was the superior suggestion to toilet. Love the rest lol

[@OhGodWhatIsThisAah]

Jesus i feel like im losing my mind. there's no way toilet should have made it on to this list lol

[@tiffanyb3147]

As soon as that was mentioned my mind started to formulate a plan or attack…

[@PancakesForLunch]

Y'all 1 Tbsp of cumin on a single sandwich is SO MUCH cumin If you're making hummus, for 1 pound of chickpeas I'd start with 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon of cumin. These boys are saying "yeah and just 12x that amount doesn't seem like too much". Please make more food hacks/demands for tiktok influencers, this is my new favorite McElroy subgenre!

[@hijimushi]

Griffin: We can't do cutting sandwiches into shapes, that's what I'd do for my kids. Too entertaining Griffin, 30 seconds wiser: PUT A FACE ON IT! :)

[@caesarsalad77]

They have mentioned Taskmaster and now I only want all three of them on it.

[@dogwild]

hell they could do a knockoff version with their dad and a few other family members or collaborators for one of their charity or pledge drives. that'd whip ass.

[@julischrier]

This is my favorite crossover of all time - I cheered when y’all showed up in the roll for sandwich vid lol. Also this is making me realize that some of my favorite mcelroy content is just brothers on camera brainstorming an idea,, this, Plato’s Rave, naming of the year eps…

[@Account-go7lv]

Love seeing Justin’s cat just chill while the brothers create this wild list

[@kendoola_petula]

Shocked and devastated that the j man didn’t add “put a little jelly on it” to the list

[@ProperEarWorm]

The font Hoops went with is adding to the chaos of this experience. (Toilet dip actually made me tear up out of fear)

[@GirlTheGamer]

Justin is worried about the Arbuckle curveball making him deconstruct the sandwich when I always assumed he films all the rolls first then puts together the sandwich

[@guyunderwood2297]

You are correct but the problem is he edits in clips of the construction of the sandwich between the rolls so he would either have to reveal the wild magic roll early or pretend to build a normal sandwich and then rebuild it after the wild magic roll.

[@GreenPiCat]

they tried so hard to think outside the box and it made them so mean 😂😂😂 the original wild magic table is, as far as I can tell, mostly ingredients. and at least half of them are pretty workable ingredients kldjgkdfmg

[@jamespeetz4008]

griffin was waaaay too proud about "poo vide" that being said it brought me much joy today thank you

[@fjr4205]

Grilling everything is the answer. Grilled PB&J? Yes. Grilled Fluffernutter? HECK YES.

[@alushandatramp]

Grilled fluffernutter is the most insane thing anyone has ever said and I need to try it IMMEDIATELY.

[@tiffanyb3147]

Love grilled PB&J

[@tiffanyb3147]

Just googled fluffernutter…OMG…looks so good

[@hvymtllion5231]

Hoops is absolutely serving today with that perfect coif.

[@theheathen42]

it took me watching this three times before I picked up the fact that Griffin said he was in high school for 7 years 🤣 also, I would probably pay money to watch these three make a list like this for any topic/purpose. I laughed so hard I cried 🤣🤣

[@tiffanyb3147]

Me too

[@blahblah9036]

Can anybody hit me with a timestamp for this?

[@jamesnolan5813]

Bread to portobello polymorph would be great. Remove bread and replace with two large portobello mushrooms.

[@zeemyrdin]

"wrap it in fruit loops" should've been on there somewhere

[@owenheller378]

I can’t believe they’d make a list and not test it out themselves to see if it’s good

[@adventuresinaardia]

I’m not worried

[@watchrsj]

Heated and wholesome is the best setting for these fellas.

[@Starlysh]

"Make it Greeceyh"

[@akareject]

"A poo vide" 😂🤣 Griffin is undefeated!

[@thuggles42]

wild magic conceptually is probably my favorite game mechanic ever

[@Christina-xc7on]

Two of my favorites coming together!! You guys have to all roll your own sandwiches and have a little lunch together

[@detectablethickness]

the delight on griffin’s face when he said “poo-vide”

[@zacharyliles8657]

This is an all-time crossover

[@kalstarrcomedy]

So glad you're finally not shutting down Travis, it only took a decade or so! 😂

[@kalstarrcomedy]

Spoilers: they still shut Trav down 🤣

[@MicahIphone]

@@kalstarrcomedy You just have to though. Can't let him have too much.

[@dylansewell237]

griffin so proud of his 'Poo Vide' joke

[@MattShubert]

This is the ultimate collaboration. Hell yeah

[@alexbelardo7940]

A TABLESPOON IS SO MUCH CUMIN FOR A SANDWICH

[@bingusbongo4301]

omg this is a crossover I didn't know I needed but I do need it

[@claireishere9638]

My two favorite pieces of content collide. I didn't know I needed this. Thank you Jake and Brothers for this unholy matrimony.

[@0kieD0kiee]

Travis and Justin look so alike in this vid like if Justin was wearing glasses they’d be indistinguishable

[@Jeevesie1988]

Not only is this a hilarious video, but I have to thank you for introducing me to Roll for Sandwich. I'd watched ten episodes before I even realised it. :D

[@scottsimpson459]

I can’t BELIEVE you didn’t have put a little jelly on it.

[@Harphh]

Justin's kitty makes a cameo around 4:20. Nice.

[@bisexual.ghost13]

this is the naming of the year energy but with sanwich and im here for it

[@joobis_del_boobis]

Actually insane the reaction to canned oysters

[@lokiiago_x0x]

Griffin’s pepperoni sandwich was THIS close to being Abendbrot/Brotzeit but then the ball thing threw me 😂

[@irishbearsfan12]

This took 25 min video for the list. I lost it on “external mustard” in quotes 😂😂😂

[@RedBairnMedia]

Aww poor Griff looked so happy with Poo Vide.

[@athens202]

Sauce flip's journey of redemption was truly inspiring

[@kaitmarie6505]

Every time the brothers discuss sandwiches I feel like I'm sitting on the sidelines waving my hands frantically. Put me in, coach! Add some pickled onions. It's what you've been missing. And somehow they never read my mind and add pickled onions, and so my torment continues.

[@tiffanyb3147]

Anything pickled…

[@jenolafson]

As a chef I'm so upset we just glossed right over "poo vide". Thank you for this horrendous visual, Griffin.

[@mcmosfet2856]

I think the real issue with the idea of adding tinned/smoked oysters is it would be a duplicate of "Make it greasey" and "Toomami"

[@isabelflann4087]

I honestly love smoked tinned oysters 😅

[@DivaAngel9006]

I'm just here to shout out Travis' FOB shirt he has on. Great choice, got mine at my show. 👍

[@natashalevesque6589]

This has nothing whatsoever to do with the video (though I freaking love roll for sandwich), but I just have to say it don't know if its just me, but DANG JUSTIN! He is bringing the thunder lately for absolute hotness. I'm not sure what it is, but the vibes are immaculate.

[@abj6920]

The need for this video was created and fulfilled the second it appear before me

[@willowfarmln]

this is so incredibly within my niche

[@JasonLihani]

I wonder how many hidden knives are in these shots.

[@gerlern]

This isn’t easy, ya’ll are just the best to ever do it.

[@2goblinsinatrenchcoat]

whatever sandwich this makes will be imbued with all sorts of dark magics

[@jamieulrich4842]

THIS JUST MADE MY DAY!! I’ve been waiting for this collab!!!

[@PNWGardener]

This is just lovely.

[@roboticd]

Finally, the Grippo's shout out I've been waiting for from Travis. The best chips to add to sandwiches. Box vs bag Grippo's for preference, and not the twin bag.

[@Nono-hk3is]

7:14 Justice for Travis, finally

[@funkle_berry]

collab of the century

[@theheathen42]

spoilers for the final list, but if you want to know which roll for sandwich corresponds to each item . . . . . . 2 - it has to go in the toilet -> Episode 228 - Dec 11, 2023 3 - tinned oysters -> Episode 4 - eat it at a Subway restaurant -> Episode 202 - Oct 11, 2023 5 - humanize it (name, backstory, body) 6 - 1 tablespoon cumin -> Episode 213 - Nov 3, 2023 7 - black licorice jelly beans -> Episode 208 - Oct 23, 2023 8 - magic shell (make it cold) -> Episode 211 - Oct 30, 2023 9 - make it greasy -> Episode 225 - Dec 4, 2023 10 - ball it up (whatever it takes) -> Episode 11 - eat it while listening to Christmas Shoes -> Episode 216 - Nov 13, 2023 12 - make it Greece-y -> Episode 13 - sauce flip -> Episode 220 - Nov 22, 2023 14 - dippin' jus -> Episode 210 - Oct 27, 2023 15 - BBQ chips -> Episode 201 - Oct 9, 2023 16 - wash it down with a Clearly Canadian -> Episode 219 - Nov 20, 2023 17 - almond crunch sauce -> Episode 207 - Oct 20, 2023 18 - fried cheese curds -> Episode 19 - pan fry in butter -> Episode 205 - Oct 16, 2023

[@notatrueroute]

3 - Tinned Oysters -> Episode 234 - Jan 8, 24 10 - Ball it Up -> Episode 250 - Feb 16, 24 12 - Make it Greece-y -> Episode 247 - Feb 9, 24 5 and 18 remain

[@Dantalliumsolarium]

“That’s a common character we can all get behind!” I don’t know any of the names they were throwing around

[@kylepribble7459]

Love the joints on this table 👍🏽

[@Dantalliumsolarium]

I must make this clear!! It will! Go! Into his body! I love these three so much. Self centered grease!!

[@trebotski]

Man y'all I didn't know I was craving this kind of conversation but please more

[@leauxgan]

the collab I never knew I needed

[@randalabra3852]

Came straight here from the new rfs...and holy shit yall lol

[@colonelstunts4885]

its been an hour and I'm still quaking over poo-vide

[@isabellaconidi3261]

Love this!!

[@StarlingArtistry]

10:05 "I don't wanna watch or know of anyone who enjoys watching someone eat a frozen sandwich" ...Me, casually enjoying my frozen Uncrustables that I've been eating frozen since I was TEN and I'm THIRTY NOW

[@classy2329]

Watching or listening to the brothers get roudy will always make my day

[@quartjarz]

more of this, absolutely more of this

[@Nono-hk3is]

4:21 baby alert 🐈

[@claireronan7404]

Iconic crossover!

[@raineinspaine5986]

I’m so incredibly excited by this

[@MickySarge]

More of this sorta content please

[@thewahodimension]

This video is gold.

[@kenabaker903]

Yall are wild 😹😹 this is about to be the most lit season of RFS tho

[@206unknown]

In Travis’s defense, tinned oysters are delicious

[@katiedavis7476]

The collaboration I’ve always wanted! 😍

[@hauntedmasc]

"poo vide" went overlooked and that's a tragedy

[@fioblah]

this is so powerful