the most literal adaptation

[@rigorgrynn]

My condolences for your little girl. She sounds like a delight. Don't ever let folks discount your connections. She mattered to you and you to her, that's the important bit. Nothing silly about it.

[@Xylofox]

I will miss her.

[@NoahK754]

May she rest

[@Hjh826]

omg what happened?

[@bats9218]

@@Hjh826did bro never watch the end of the video

[@PotatoPatatoVonSpudsworth]

Christ almighty, I saw this comment before watching the video, and spent the entire thing thinking he was about to reveal that he'd lost a child. It MAY be wise to reword your comment so more people like me don't end up thinking "thank goodness it was _just_ a Guinea pig," since losing a pet is still tough.

[@toganium4175]

I want Bryan Cranston to return to the role of Commissioner Gordon because he did such a great job.

[@emperorsean1]

He'd be a great live action version

[@baldomiropoopito812]

He's the comic accurate Jim Gordon we've been waiting for.

[@somedorkydude6483]

Hes retiring in 2025 or 2026

[@andyf3269]

@@somedorkydude6483wait for real? How old is he?

[@helflower2025]

I feel like he’s such a natural pick for the role that it baffles me he hasn’t played him more, especially post-breaking bad now that everyone knows he can do really dramatic performances

[@tylerbertram7065]

Bryan Cranston as Commissioner Gordon is such perfect casting that I think he would make for a great live action Gordon.

[@Alacaelum]

True. Gary Oldman was amazing in the role, but Cranston would be able to give equally the gravitas the character deserves but in a different way.

[@deaconcaudill9751]

Rip Malloy

[@thequestion8697]

I've been saying this for years bub.

[@tylerbertram7065]

@@thequestion8697 I've been too

[@jordanslater4705]

I'm sorry for your loss of Marlene. Losing a pet is never easy. We remember their names, so that they might live forever. Not gone, merely marching far, far away.

[@mrl2322]

My condolences for marlene. On the brightside she has basically been immortalized on the internet through your outros. May she rest in peace.

[@luckydog1996]

I had to pause your eulogy for your beloved pet because if I finish the video I might be a wreck. Please, please, please never feel silly or any kind of way about sharing your experiences with a pet that you loved dearly. Many of us have known or will know the unfortunate pain that comes with losing a very beloved pet. I absolutely love your content and I've been an avid fan for a couple years now. You are in my thoughts and I send my deepest condolences to you and whoever else might be affected. I hope within time the grieving process gets a bit easier. Much love. Sincerely, a pet parent who has been there.

[@warehouse13agent1]

never feel silly for grieving the loss of a loved one. you gave her the best life you could, that's all we can do for them.

[@EtchaSketch444]

I'm real sorry for your loss man. Pets are part of the family, so losing one can hit just as hard as losing a sibling.

[@The_Phantasm]

Bryan Cranston as Jim Gordon is one of those castings that sounds like it would be too obvious but actually ended up being pitch perfect. If only the same could be said about Ben McKenzie as Batman. That was definitely a miscast.

[@zackanderson7440]

Honestly i think it works for a just starting out batman like we saw in the movie, later on however i agree.

[@tylerbertram7065]

Ben McKenzie is up there with Billy Baldwin and Jason O'Mara as one the worst Batman actors.

[@aneelahuja1212]

@@tylerbertram7065Jason O’Mara gets way too much hate as batman I thought he was great

[@elijahbowers1]

This film is nearly perfect and Bryan Cranston as Gordon both in animation and live action is a dream casting.

[@AlchemistOfAnark]

Love for a pet is never silly and often times their passings can be harder than losing a person love your pets and cherish them as much as they cherish you

[@DavidRYates-tk2tq]

I kind of like the idea that Bruce becomes Batman not exactly when that bat flies in, but when he asks for help from Alfred. Also, Bryan Cranston was great voice casting for James Gordon.

[@wesc8065]

I always loved seeing Marlene at the end of videos. Rest In peace

[@cspahn3221]

10:20 So sorry for your loss man. Pets are family. I hope that one day you'll meet your friend again.

[@xiphoidreporter9036]

Rest in piece, Marlene (I hope that's right). Pets never die, they're always with us.

[@AxelWendorf-q5t]

I lost a cat recently, you don’t realize how much you love them until they’re gone. I wish you the best man!

[@DavidRYates-tk2tq]

Fun fact: it's been implied that the head trauma baby James Gordon Jr sustained when Bruce caught him is why he's a psychopathic serial killer now lol

[@jediastartes6595]

You have my sympathies for your loss. I just lost one of my ferrets recently, so I know your pain all too well. May you find peace in your memories of her, and knowing that you gave her the best life possible.

[@uslessyoutuber3092]

i've lost many guinea pigs in the past and i've never gotten past it but hopefully with time we will grow to appreciate what they helped us through

[@H3llf1re60]

terribly sorry for ur loss. Loosing a pet isnt easy no matter the size or shape they have they all deserve love and being mourned.

[@milkiassamuel780]

My deepest condolence for your loss, man. She seemed like such an adorable bundle of joy, and as someone who's had a handful of different pets in his childhood, the pain is always there, but the memories, connection and good moments you had with her make that pain feel less heavy to burden. Don't let anyone diminish the love I'm sure you had for her. RIP Marline. Before watching this movie, I wasn't sure of the idea of Bryan Cranston as Jim Gordon; however, as soon as I saw it, I finally saw the vision and was amazed by his subtle and great performance in this movie; he really would be an incredible pick to play Jim Gordon in live action. If I'm being honest, whenever I watch this movie, I'm actually more interested in the Jim Gordon storyline than I am in the Batman storyline, even though the Batman moments are really cool.

[@kelvingoce7587]

1:34 THANK YOU, i've been saying this for years now

[@ag7898]

Sorry to hear about Marlene! It really sucks to lose a member of the family. I never understood the guinea pig animation in the beginning of the videos. But it made me smile to see that even though she is gone, yoi will still keep her memory alive through that animation.❤

[@chethasgb1964]

Sorry for ur loss. Marlene rest in peace.

[@Muteki_REN]

I lost my piggie 3 years ago now, so hearing how much your experience echoes mine is bringing me to tears again. I know she loved you as much as you did her.

[@Nikcadem]

Rest in Peace Marlene, never feel wrong for wanting to honor someone beloved to you.

[@SNG2me]

Pets are family and losing any family member hurts. RIP sweet girl, you brought joy to a life.

[@gir2195]

As a former piggy papa, take your time to heal. From their dumb little faces, joyful wheaks, cuddles, and coos are always with us.

[@HilariousMemesForDays]

So sorry for your loss, hope you made great memories with your guinea pig.

[@PotatoPatatoVonSpudsworth]

Your mention of "supernatural forces" in the form of coincidence reminded me of a character I've been trying to make work in a story for years now. Basically someone who can sense the narrative patterns their world operates on and use it to their advantage, but not in the usual 4th wall breaking way. More-so they can feel some higher power influencing things, infer when the story is focusing on them, and position themselves to benefit from whatever narrative tropes are in play.

[@exospaca]

I get it, I had a herd of guinea pigs myself, led by a magnificent fellow named Wilbur. We let them eat off our yard and would pen them in outside to let them enjoy the summer weather.

[@To4sty_bunz]

I’m very sorry for your loss losing a friend is always really hard

[@arkyung9549]

The emotional connections we form are always, always, always important. It does not matter who or what we form them with. I think we are happier for having the memories of our animal friends than we would be without them, even if it is hard when we reach the end of that road.

[@BlackShardStudio]

Your eulogy brought me to tears. I'm so sorry, man. There's something so simple and genuine about the love of a pet, a kind of meaning that you don't really get from any other kind of love. It's one of life's greatest tragedies we don't get to spend more time with our little friends. Thank you for choosing to tell us. I wish you peace.

[@meowcow21]

First Mike as Gordan and now Walter? The craziest thing is that they both work in different ways

[@kmp3e]

My condolences. Pets are truly the bestest of friends

[@bunkets]

Rest in peace Marlene, you live on in our hearts sweet piggy. Fly high.

[@ShadoTempest]

I’m so sorry for your loss. I just started vet school this year and I’ve really enjoyed listening to your videos in the background while I study, so thank you for providing me with joy, and I know that you were an awesome dad to her

[@kingdragoonmk10]

Not a dam thing wrong with wanting to pay respect to the little lives that despite their small stature are like a candle in a storm that refuses to go out, comforting you with they're warmth and light , and much like the Bat that comes when bruce needs it the most , a sense of purpose and the feeling of being needed.

[@mosquite1986]

My condoleces. I recently lost my cat and I can understand your pain. She wasn't just a cat, she was my friend and the love of my life. Just thinking about the amount of sorrow someone else might feel when they lose a pet, brings tears to my eyes.

[@AlbertPaulMariLucero]

Condolences to Marlene. May she rest in peace.

[@jackarmer8924]

Sorry for your loss, you gave her the best life she could have asked for.

[@ForWeAreMany]

the pain we feel at the loss of a loved one does not stem from the realization that we will never see them again. no, it is the debt of gratitude for the happiness, love, memories, both good and bad, that were made while in each other's company. it is a debt of love, love gathered over multiple years paid over the course of weeks, months. this is why the pain is intense, because it a large gathered over a long time repaid all at once over the course of a fraction of the time the friendship was formed over. know that your friend will be the recepient of your emotional outburst, they will be humbled in the afterlife and thus exalted.

[@nickclute6199]

Implicitly Pretentious dropped. Its a good day.

[@Apollothesxn]

im sorry for your loss, may marlene rest in peace. never feel silly for grieving a loss, i wish you well!

[@davidrivas8005]

I’m sorry for your loss. You changed each others lives and nothing can change or diminish that

[@MrMilla22]

Sorry for your loss I always thought how lucky we as humans are for being in a world with animals that love to be pet and give love back. What a special moment in time we often take for granted

[@ThePhildefer001]

Thank you for the video. Please know that despite it never getting easier, our hearts and lives improve with pets. I hope you find the strength to meet new friends who can bring you their own kind of joy. None have been the same for me, but I cherish them all!

[@timelessmoron]

Stay strong. She'd be happy to know youll keep taking care of yourself

[@andersonrearickiii6392]

I have found your various video essays thoughtful and well executed in your ability to support your claims even when it’s your personal opinion. Also you have my shared sympathy in the loss of an animal friend.

[@andyf3269]

Wait you like resident evil!! You sir are amazing! Also, never feel bad for loving, regardless if it’s a person or animal my friend.

[@ThrowingCrunchy]

Condolences on your loss fam. Losing a beloved dependent is never easy. I'm grateful for your sharing, and hope it helps with your grieving process.

[@AGuyNamedRicky]

Thank you for covering Batman Year One. My condolences for your friend.

[@coreymaddox3962]

RIP Marlene. Think of things from her perspective - she only knew the love you gave her.

[@michaelhardy9264]

I'm sorry for loss, Imp. I hope that she is at peace and that you keep the sweet memories in your heart of her.

[@squeethemog213]

May she rest in peace and may the memories you had bring you great joy. Much love man.

[@Pascanchik.]

I am really sorry for your loss. We will all miss Marlene

[@Hi_Just_Fred]

Great video, and may your sweet guinea pig rest in peace. Pet owners forming a strong bond with animals they care for is very sweet, even to the end.

[@EmanuelCampos]

I sorry for your loss... great video as always. Lost my youth companion as well, a 14 years cat. I do know how do you feel.

[@AkaiNanashi]

I'm sorry for the loss of your pet. It's amazing the time we get to share with something you never knew you could miss so badly once they're gone. Sometimes you just need to talk about it when you need to.

[@Chrono-and-Co]

I'm sorry for your loss,I lost my dog recently who I loved so much and he drew out the best version of me. He was all I had of my grandfather who passed away when I was too young to remember so when my dog passed away so did he,even during the moments where I felt know one understood me he would be willing to sit next to me and comfort me. What I'm trying to say is,I understand and you have my condolences.

[@DareToEntertain]

Beautiful Video. The epilogue was very sad and I am so sorry mate. I hope you are okay.

[@2centdeposit87]

Very sorry for your loss. While the adjustment of coping with loss/sadness initially feels solely weighted down by absence of future opportunities for joy rather than the fond memories of the past… Thankfully with enough time passing; it’s only the positive memories that remain in one’s heart & mind thanks to love that made them possible. Good luck to you moving forward. Great work as always! Year One has always been one my favorite DCAU adaptations.

[@tavishr3194]

My condolences for Marlene Leo. Thank you for these videos.

[@JamCooper]

I can't... I can't bring myself to talk about or even think about losing pets. I have two dgos, and I teary eyed just writing this. I'm so so sorry fr you loss.

[@masongrae5010]

My heart goes out to you man it’s never easy putting a friend to rest for the last time

[@DanteBelmont96]

Thank you for your heart felt Eulogy at the end. I just lost my 10 year old Rottweiler today due to cancer, so I went from crying to persona 3 music to your video to get a break from crying, so needless to say the ending hit like a truck. I hope you are doing okay and that your "Bitch in the red dress" is doing well too.

[@nuyabuisness7526]

Losing a beloved pet is a difficult thing. Stay strong and know that their life was better for having you in it.

[@edfreak9001]

The video overall was excellent as always. The bit at the end about your beloved guinea pig passing was very sweet. I'm sorry you lost her but i'm happy you had the chance to spend that time with her to begin with. The world is just that little bit warmer for you both having had one another.

[@srobinson9893]

Didn't realise Cranos played jim, dam I really want him to do it in a live action. It sucks ass when you you lose anything you care about, thank you for sharing that bit and hope you are doing well. Keep up the work your vids are always a unique incite

[@johnnywhoa343]

I'm so sorry to hear about Marlene. I think everyone has at least one pet like that at some point in their lives, one that means the world to them. One that you love while they're with you, but never realize quite how much until they're not. Thank you for taking the time to eulogize her and share your pain with us. I think it's a wonderful thing, to create some small permanent abstraction of what she meant to you in the wake of her passing. I wish you only the best in processing this grief, and hope you take the time you need.

[@Ihaveagoodnickname]

As someone who had a similar situation with loss i understand why it feels so sad to lose a pet because end of the day, she was family. I hope you are able to take the time needed to heal and that you and ada live on in her memory

[@SirFalstaff44]

My condolences on Marlene. I had a very similar relationship with a pet rat a long time ago, so I understand how that loss can cut deep.

[@randomomega9966]

Great, now I'm crying and laughing. You... wonderful madman.

[@switchedup5834]

Aw brother thank you for sharing about your beloved family member, thank you for being an amazing creator ❤ and sharing your talents with us

[@eddyprescott5359]

I just want to say I really appresciate your content. It feels nice to have the explanation on how these shows and movies make me feel and what they mean.

[@palemoonpresence3435]

Condolences for Marlene, she brought love to your life and that is wonderful, never feel bad for morning that love it is not in any way wrong to do so❤

[@TheSykobanana]

I have missed the little cut scenes and clips of Marlene for ages now. Condolences mate.

[@AxelWendorf-q5t]

I only just now realized that his hamster is the one in the intro, he will be missed😢

[@garrettwhite5943]

Sorry for your loss. Pets are a blessing and a curse in some regards. It's a relationship we know ends in sadness, but it can still be the most wonderful friendship in the world. Also wonderful essay on a wonderful adaptation.

[@ACE10617]

I'm sorry for your lost. It's never easy losing a pet, a freind and companion in life.

[@raphaelorozco7950]

the ending got me bro 😢im really sorry to hear that. i hope shes in a better place

[@jankaczurak1041]

o7 for Marlene, the boys will always remember you

[@syrup-man6704]

My condolences, she couldn't have had a better friend than you.

[@elendoy]

Sorry to hear about your beloved baby pet. It's always hard to lose a furry friend. She shall live in your heart and memories. Take it from me, my almost 20 years old cat passed last April and I'm still mourning the loss while at the same time remembering her fondly as I'm working on an acrylic painting of her. Also, great video. I watched the animation but I've never read this comic. It's cool to see the differences you point out

[@emperorsean1]

Wish all the dcau animated movies were as faithful as this one including Crisis on infinite earths.

[@BigAl2-u7e]

Personally, I have no qualms with adaptations that deviate away from the source material. After all, if I just wanted the source material, then I would've just consumed that instead of the adaptation. As long as the essence of the original story is kept and it maintains, if not exceeds, the quality of the story. Then I have zero problems.

[@NightRunner2099]

I somewhat agree. However, a possible problem is that the continuity for that story might not match the current status quo and basically create contradictions. Also, no matter what, people will still complain about certain aspects. For example, Ollie killing Parallax Hal at the end of the gl movie with an arrow is comic accurate. Yet, people still complained. Syndicate's death in COIE was also similar to the comic. But they still complained.

[@NightRunner2099]

@@BigAl2-u7e a good example of changes done right is Mask Of The Phantasm. It takes so many stuff from year 2, rearrange and changes them for the better and tells an overall better story.

[@Gurd-f2z]

@@NightRunner2099idk if it counts but all star Superman, the red hood, jl apokolips war and the flashpoint paradox

[@NightRunner2099]

@@Gurd-f2z I agree with Flashpoint and Under The Redhood. I'm not the biggest fan of All Star. It has the overall story. However, it skips a lot of good moments that have the story its depths. And AW isn't really based on any comic. The closest that comes to my mind is The Darksied War. However, the story elements are drastically different. The most common thing is that they're both Darksied stories. And I wouldn't say that movie is better than Darksied war. I don't like how edgy it is just for the sake of being edgy and Superman's plan didn't make any sense.

[@threetrees5888]

Goodnight sweet princess Marleen, may your time away from IP be tranquil until you both meet again. My condolences IP, I just lost my dog last month so I know the pain. I also know that Marleen will be waiting for you, you only have to wait for her too.

[@alienbob7025]

Life is beautiful and short. At least Ada has a chance to live a happy life. I'll think of Marlene whenever I watch these videos now, which is more than most Guinea Pigs get

[@7spidersofhh]

condolences man. its not goofy at all, i feel for you

[@plasmatorchic]

My condolences for Marlene, I hope you can know that she loved and cared for you deeply! She will always remember you as you remember her, with love. I hope you enjoy your time with Ada, remembering Marlene and making new connections of love.

[@System_Anomaly]

Wonderful comparison. Thank you for sharing Marlene's story with us, as well. It was extremely touching. My condolences.

[@KC3clips-k]

Love your video and rest in peace to Marlin I will always keep her in mind while I watch your videos stay strong implicitly pretentious

[@Toastfreak]

I'm sorry to hear about your pig. I know it's not easy. I just lost one of mine a few weeks ago. She passed just a few months after one of her daughters. Please be sure to give Ada lots of extra love and attention these next few months. She needs to know she's not alone.

[@Jesters-Jinx]

Sorry for your loss.

[@aliminator1310]

Sorry to hear about your Guinea Pig. Hope you and Ada feel better. 😢

[@jamilfrost6217]

Both versions are great, but I always preferred the animated movie more, than my brother who prefers the comic. Also my condolences to you and your guinea pig.

[@YoungLiam74]

Great video! Batman year one is one of my favorite movies, i’ve never read the comics so to see it so different was very interesting. In the end each has a story to tell in its own way. and sorry for your loss :(

[@cjokersl]

Another great video as always! I'm sorry for your loss, i can tell marleen was a really loved pet and that you gave her a great life

[@bornimusic]

Deepest condolences for your loss. Thanks for an amazing video. About two of my favorites. Blessings.

[@not.sure.yet.]

Great video as always. I never comment on your videos, you always hit all the points and I really never have anything to add to the conversation. A loss is a loss, be it a large pet or a small one. The love they help grow in us or even help us find that love is something special and unique that only a pet and or animal can do for us humans. They want us to know we are deserved. Rest your heart as your friend rests her's.