The Most Robbed Players in Modern Survivor History

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

But are you in the Bandit Survivor server though? 👀discord.gg/PQXNzu8Anw

[@averyseldin8485]

These types of videos are why I really want a Survivor season about pre merge boots that had a chance to go far, but for some reason, got knocked out before they could really show what they could have done.

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

Survivor US Return of the Outcasts (Pre-merge v merge contestants) is something I've always wanted to see.

[@MTAVx2]

Love the video! Idk how much I’d call Sabiyah robbed. Yes she was voted out due to Idol shenanigans. But speaking for myself, it’s hard for me to see a world where I sacrifice my vote with only 4 people voting! That’s a CRAZY risk, even if I felt confident in the other 2 votes

[@kranbabushka7887]

Sabiyah was robbed because Shean quit the very next episode

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

I think it's very unfortunate she went 3/3 in terms of her tribe losing (even the Ua tribe had more of a break in 41). Then with the idol on top. It's definitely debatable though!

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

In Maddy’s exit interview, she explained that tribal went very differently than presented: Apparently Matthew got up and whispered something to Brandon who then asked Kane point blank if he needed to play his idol that night, Kane of course said no which was the main reason Brandon held some resentment against Kane in the following episode. There was a lot of motivation to switch the vote and I really don’t think that Maddy timed the move well even without hindsight

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

Very insightful! Thanks for the explanation I didn't realise the bit about Kane and Brandon.

[@JackTheFlopYT]

Yes, Matthew did get eliminated earlier than expected. However, he took himself out. He literally scaled a rock face for zero reason and injured himself. I can’t really see “robbery” in that case, more stupidity.

[@paintbrush3753]

And he constantly took his arm out his sling. If someone played as recklessly strategically as Matthew did physically, we wouldn't be giving them the benefit of the the doubt.

[@JackTheFlopYT]

@@paintbrush3753 …oh god I forgot about that. Yeah - he wanted that full Survivor experience and… injured himself to get there.

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

I mean production should have definitely stepped in. That could have been a death on the show. People on Survivor when tired and not thinking straight want to do risky things. For example the contestants in Guatemala wanted to go into the water multiple times but production refused because of the crocodiles.

[@HenryHickmanSurvivor]

It seems a lot easier to be robbed in modern Survivor, with advantages flying around 24/7, there's very few ways to play around production just deciding they want to screw with the game for a bit of banter...

[@vaporterra]

Exactly. Before the advent of advantages in Worlds Apart, you could reasonably play around every twist.

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

100% mate!

[@tylerhaggerty4805]

In the world of survivor, I will never stop feeling bad for Jenny.

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

I'm the same :)

[@itzmeconar6991]

Let’s be honest, if Maddie doesn’t go early in 44, she probably wins the season.

[@caidenmagill1006]

Idk about winning but I can see her going really far like final 7

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

It's plausible and I think the good thing about new era casting is everyone *can* win under different timelines with varying circumstances.

[@Aviator43]

I'd argue with Matthew, and the logic in this in general that you can't call someone "robbed" when their own actions are what caused their downfall. No disrespect to Matthew, cause I think he would've been a great player especially going against the Tikas. But to be devil's advocate here, he did climb that rock on his own will and knew the potential consequences. Whereas with Sabiyah, she knew the risk of burning the idol in public at tribal and should've taken into account that losing a vote with that little people wasn't worth it.

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Brando’s circumstances actually managed to be worse odds than portrayed because of another key event of that pre-merge Kaleb giving Drew the “goodwill” advantage which then allowed Drew to give the advantage to Austin who otherwise would have had to burn his idol to cast a vote that night. Had Lulu voted out Emily over Brandon, they likely lose reward and Reba might not had gotten the advantage, Had Lulu not won the reward challenge then Brando might have stayed, Had Kaleb not gone to raid Reba, Brando likely stays in the game, had he not been swapped with ride or die allies Drew and Austin he might have stayed. Had Brando been swapped with any other Reba member that wasn’t Drew then Austin would have had to weigh up his idol vs losing a Reba.

[@eastonburnor4018]

Yeah but Austin not having a vote would have been a lucky situation anyway and he wouldn’t have sacrificed his vote and Brando would still be gone. And he should have had the numbers with Kendra and Emily due to the twist that didn’t air on day 1. He got outplayed by the Reba’s

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

When you put it like that it is really crazy. With Kaleb picking the red tribe then selecting Drew who was allied with Austin who had the idol who then managed to keep his vote 3-2 at the swap.

[@teamsteed1]

Thank you for posting the video.

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

You're welcome!

[@bubblybeluga1178]

Julie should be in the next video. Dee would've, and SHOULD'VE gotten out there, if it wasn't for some incompotency from Katurah. She then went on to win the season. (To be fair, Jake is still partly to blame for that play but Dee still should've gotten 2 votes.)

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

The merge one has sooo many good options it will be hard to bring it down to 5.

[@aaronbentley6373]

Charles from Australian Survivor! He was 100% surviving that tribal council until producers gave immunity to 3 players and took away everyone’s votes except for those 3.

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

100%. Probably the most screwed Australian Survivor contestant (outside of Baden?) and that's saying something!

[@tamamela]

I completely disagree with Matthew being robbed, his entire demise was caused by his own stupidity, he climbed up the rock, he fell, he chose to ignore doctor orders to rest his arm, he quit. One thing i find bizarre is how so many people think he was a good player, he made a fake idol to trick Jaime to gain her allegiance (Yeah cuz JAIME was hard to make loyal) but even if that was a smart move, he blew it up the second he exposed Jaimes "idol" to Carson, who immediately told everyone else in the game about it when they merged. If Matthew was still in the game, I see either OG Ratu flipping on Matthew or Jaime flipping on Ratu, either way, it'd be a disaster for Matthew.

[@sashamars6910]

That thumbnail is sooo cool!

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

You're welcome!

[@JoD-qu7ed]

Honestly I think Charles from this season of Australian survivor is the most robbed player in survivor history

[@queenzoroark]

Phil as well

[@JoD-qu7ed]

@@queenzoroark yeah he’s up there for sure

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

If I were to do Australian Survivor then yep!

[@swedishfishoreos]

Nice video, but most of these people weren't robbed imo. Sabiyah made a massive mistake in turning against her #1, and Kaleb and Emily rightfully got her out. Even without the vote-losing twist, it would've at least been a tie, but they probably could've convince Sean to get her out Brando got lucky getting the advantage, and didn't notice it in time. Plus he would've gotten voted out regardless. His social game wasn't good enough to get Emily on his side. Matthew only has himself to blame for climbing the rock.

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Actually according to her exit press, Sean was actually her #1 Still think it was a bad move since her and Emily had serious beef but I do question if either Emily or Sean would have pushed it to rocks

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

I’m expecting Phil to be on this list, they were so robbed in BvB

[@BanditSurvivorContent]

He features in my first boot list. Completely robbed.

[@tommacpherson5852]

Feel like it's a stretch to say Matthew got robbed... I guess he probably would've won the season if production put a "do not climb this" sign on all rock faces. They should've foreseen the fact they casted an idiot

[@eastonburnor4018]

5:49 He wasn’t swap screwed he had a good swap but he just got outplayed

[@realityrob1951]

Xander and Mike.