The Mystery of Planet Nine with Robert Finch

[@joaovictorromaniello3616]

Saving for later. Going to bed and listen to Event Horizon videos is one of the best things ever hahaha.

[@mancramps]

This is my ritual as well

[@1stclassknowledge144]

I do this alot of videos on KZbin...

[@bony3603]

mine too.

[@DeadlyFungi]

Yup

[@succulentadam5782]

And I thought I was the only one doing that

[@earthrise9064]

The real mystery is when the James Webb telescope will launch.

[@Dadecorban]

That's no mystery. It will launch on the first commercial cargo SpaceX Starship flight.

[@-KillaWatt-]

@@Dadecorban I know it would cost double and NASA has a strained budget to begin with but I never understood why they don't make two of every satellite/telescope they make. I would literally cry if they lost the Webb telescope while enroute. I've waited years for this. The last big event for me was the Pluto Flyby. That seemed like forever.

[@bobrobert1123]

@Daniel Kintigh yeah we don't have a shuttle to fix the shit later

[@Dadecorban]

@@-KillaWatt- lol. You give the reasons why they don't it and then you said you don't understand. = )

[@toanotherplace]

@@Dadecorban speaking of not understanding

[@ortonh1]

Am I the only one that falls asleep to event horizon every night? But I need more videos!!!! Please!!!

[@arthurballs7083]

I can recommend nick zenter and his geology lectures on the Pacific Northwest here on KZbin. Utterly fascinating

[@ortonh1]

Just started one of his lectures... absolutely fabulous. Thanks!

[@mikeyoung260]

JSM issac Arthur for me. He has great science videos.

[@cicurilloj]

I used to do that with secure team lol

[@johnberry9331]

I cannot sleep w/o my horizon video

[@EventHorizonShow]

Do you think Planet Nine exists? What type of planet is it? Does Planet Nine Exist? Featuring Dr. Konstantin Batygin: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXiYaZyal5t7q6M

[@yourstruly4817]

I know it exists, it's Pluto ;-)

[@bitcoinmining6361]

As we can't even agree on our definition of 'Planet'...I very much doubt it will be able to be classed as a Planet...But there's def something interesting out there.. Which with such an affect it causes to our solar system...I theorise that it is a stablalising force to the centrifugal caused plane we find the Main Bodies of our Solar System...comment before listening...I always like to see how wrong I am or different others perceive everything...lets see haha

[@NoMoreForeignWars]

Have you checked uranus?

[@bitcoinmining6361]

@@NoMoreForeignWars with smoke and mirrors 🙋‍♂️

[@wolmntn]

I believe something is out there either a planet or large asteroid. I am undecided about the brown dwarf theory.

[@ballerinafantastique]

Ok but like, am I the only person who’s never taken any sort of astronomy class but watches stuff like this for fun? I’ve always been super into space I’m just not good enough at math 😂

[@mistymetheny2987]

Just never found a teacher I could stay awake for the whole class. They tend to be rather dry and montone and boaring to me. Wish I could find an energitic instructor for the basics.

[@buckeyejim2989]

Geomagnetics hold our universe together. The glowing horizon tell me the blue kachina is getn closer. Secrets make us easier to control. Mathematics and astrological understanding plays heavily in tryn to figure things out. You mite try crazy catfish Briggs... Our sun is smaller than we are lead to believe. Much Love👍

[@stephenbrand5661]

@@buckeyejim2989 🤨

[@buckeyejim2989]

@@stephenbrand5661 in 58 when nzsa was born, don't you think contrlrs knew in hebrew it meant to decieve?

[@phantomwalker8251]

dont need math to understand,.just watch viper tv,on sumerian tablets. we were born of alien dna..everything your taught is a lie..

[@planetoftheatheists6858]

What a mystery, sounds like we need a plan .....Plan 9, from Outer Space.

[@mikewade777]

Beat me to it🙁

[@exoplanets]

True

[@andersforsgren3806]

Lol, I say the same thing as Wade - it was my pun here also. :p~

[@Pintkonan]

why would we want a plan that is going to fail pathetically =b

[@wellardbr]

@John Barber Yeah, take us to your stupid leader! No, not that orange one again, the real leeeeader!

[@tonyk4615]

I like “Planet X”. I secretly imagine that the X is for the Roman numeral 10 and Pluto is planet 9 just the way it should be.

[@daniellogan-scott5968]

If we decide that Pluto is a planet, then Eris is planet 10 since they are roughly the same size. It was the discovery of Eris that got Pluto demoted. Eris began as Planet X, then it was called Xena and its moon was called Gabrielle. Finally they settled on Eris as the official name.

[@truthseeker908]

Just don't call it "Nibiru"

[@lsb2623]

you shut up now! pluto is 9 and pluto is now. this is bigger than your precious "science". this is PLUTO!

[@sincity7890]

Planet X is the birth place of the X man

[@broken1965]

Falcon x, SpaceX

[@aimeefrost3903]

You should make these into podcast format! I would love to be able to plug an episode into my car speakers for my commute!!

[@EventHorizonShow]

Coming very very soon. It’ll be $5 a month for every episode of event horizon and all of johns channel. As well as a bonus show.

[@aimeefrost3903]

@@EventHorizonShow Awesome, looking forward to this!

[@sawyerflechsig7329]

I'll be browsing on KZbin earlier in the day, and see a new event horizon video. And save it to enjoy listening to when crawling in to bed. That's my bedtime ritual

[@MikeSmith-cl4ix]

This is probably why we need the space force. Countries of the world need to stop fighting stupid wars and learn to work together to defend our planet.

[@alexdevisscher6784]

Almost 100k subscribers! Keep up the good work!

[@EventHorizonShow]

Thank you Alex.

[@zapfanzapfan]

@@EventHorizonShow 50% growth in 6 months, awesome!

[@gunnerkobra]

Pluto still my planet nine.

[@12201185234]

Bring back Pluto!

[@arostwocents]

Planet X is a much better name for a mysterious missing planet than Planet 9

[@gunnerkobra]

@@evanroberts2771 I only persecute people that think that meaningless taxonomies are progress

[@codename495]

gunnerkobra Pluto doesn’t check all the boxes of what a planet is currently defined as. So I wouldn’t say the taxonomy is meaningless. It looks a lot like a planet, but a shark looks a lot like a whale yet they are both very clearly different in meaningful ways.

[@necrosunderground]

@@arostwocents But does Planet X have an adamantium skeleton and claws?

[@sidoney101]

100k subscribers! Congrats John, Ross and Eryn

[@EventHorizonShow]

Thank you Sidney!

[@generationxpvp]

Time to close my eyes and travel to a far off part of outer space only event horizon can take me to.

[@exoplanets]

Yes

[@Ziggy_Stark.]

Ride into the "event....... cheers

[@ancientbookshigherknowledg9165]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5WblKuJoLSNa8k

[@issafacelift]

Hello John! Great video as always. The way you open with mystery, introduce your guests, and then sort of "plead their case," if you will. Consistently mysterious and eye-opening at the same time.

[@slyguythreeonetwonine3172]

Behind planet 8 and in front of planet 10! Now where is my Goddamn Academic award?!?

[@InimitaPaul]

🎖

[@codename495]

Start looking for tickets to Sweden poopsie.

[@slyguythreeonetwonine3172]

@@InimitaPaul 😄😂 Thank you sir!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Well...when I think about it....you....must.....be right! 👏👏👏👏👏😊 So here you are....🏆🥇🏅

[@Guust_Flater]

🧾🏅

[@MaudeHerringsdaughter]

Here's how we find Planet 9, which should be named for the Roman equivalent of Persephone, Proserpina: Nuclear flares. Take a few dozen high yield nuclear warheads jacketed with nuclear isomers that emit light at predetermined wavelengths when exposed to high levels of gamma radiation, and launch them in the general direction over where you think 9 might be. When the warheads get outside of Neptune's orbit, detonate them in a predetermined sequence, and have every telescope available watch for the reflected light of the explosions off any unseen bodies. Using the individual calibrated wavelengths of light from each warhead, the time and position of each detonation, and the time delay of each flash of reflected light, you can then calculate the position of any newly detected objects. And you use up some of those dangerous and expensive to maintain nukes. It is probably possible to build an arming mechanism that can't be activated within the Earth's gravity well.

[@tenormdness]

John M Godier: Where is planet 9? Pluto: Hold my beer

[@rebellion2054]

Pluto’s beer is definitely served in a frosted glass

[@2013Arcturus]

I really hope it's our missing Super Earth!

[@EventHorizonShow]

We do too Nicolas.

[@TrailRunnerLife]

@@EventHorizonShow A planetary mass primordial black hole would be much more useful.

[@EventHorizonShow]

@@TrailRunnerLife it certainly would be interesting... kzbin.info/www/bejne/kH22mnmiZauZjdk

[@scottbrown2252]

@@TrailRunnerLife and then we send probes out there and they find the billions of socks that went missing in the laundry. Eerie, indeed.

[@EventHorizonShow]

@@scottbrown2252 currently missing well over a dozen socks.

[@robertevans8126]

Yes it does, NASA imaged it back in 2007-08. Planet 9 (Nibiru) orbits the Brown Dwarf Star Nemesis. Nibiru is planet 6, and it comes up through our system between Jupiter and Mars, where the larger planet Tiamat once was. Nibiru has been seen in our system since 2016, and 11 or more of it's 13 satellites are being seen in our skies right now.

[@robertevans8126]

@@destro3cobra61 The Chemtrailing is for two reasons 1 Depopulation 2 To hide what's in our skies!

[@darkstar8057]

Very nice to see some longer videos, awesome quality and information as usual.😎✌

[@johntimken9842]

Many decades ago Sitchen claimed that "his" planet 9, Nibiru, has an orbital time of 3600 years. The guy on this podcast quotes 3500 years as the orbital period predicted by his model. Coincidence?

[@LS-pv4dh]

Gotta check that out

[@johnkauffman8731]

His research was based on the Sumerian tablets that describe the solar system with planet nine (Nibiru) on a 3600 year orbit. Sitchin's thesis is that ancient civilizations knew astronomical information that would be impossible without technology to view it or receiving the information from the inhabitants of Nibiru. It is interesting that this gentleman has arrived at nearly the same orbital time.

[@decaman23]

Good point. Exactly what i was thinking. Too many coincidences. Where there is smoke, there is fire.

[@UmbraHand]

@@decaman23 Or not. Remember the orbit he mentioned, 82 AU. Neptune is 30 AU and was only discovered thanks to relatively large telescopes . No way of seeing it.

[@UmbraHand]

Black Body Radiation Based on bollocks and nonesense. Every time a Nicholas Cage movie comes out, fatalities in the ocean increase. Does that mean the Cage is responsible for these fatalities? No. Actually think about the topic

[@DJRonnieG]

This episode is awesome.

[@erictaylor5462]

Perhaps it is, in fact, "planet nein."

[@R1door]

Eric Taylor haha good one

[@erictaylor5462]

It's a crazy place where they mix German and English. A very ugly language called Gernglish. But then we have words that are a mix of Latin and Greek, like "television" so I imagine it sort of works, but it's a very ugly language. Hard to imagine a language uglier than English but these aliens managed it. Even the name is ugly.

[@alanlee1355]

@@erictaylor5462 English isn't ugly.

[@Dadecorban]

@@alanlee1355 What he means by ugly is to say that it's a functionally adaptive language that has covered the Earth, that will be taken to the stars.....while German is an intransigent artifact that will be eventually become a dead language spoken only recreationally by a small community of underwater archaeologists who specialize in excavating small ugly German cars and industrial generators from the North European Sea.

[@erictaylor5462]

@@alanlee1355 Well, that, like, just your opinion, man. Just the same as my opinion that it *IS* an ugly language.

[@TheB345t0r]

Congratz on 100K subs. Stay healthy!

[@lsb2623]

Planet Nine is in my heart... it's a planet that is called PLUTO. I will never abandon our distant ally! I will never abandon our far flung friend like SO MANY DAMN SPACE SCIENTISTS!!! You hear that NEIL?!

[@seanyoung5598]

Actually that has since been amended with the passing of our trans-universal probe. The data we received from our probe passing Pluto in very close proximity it settled the debate of whether Pluto is a planet and removed all doubt/argument against Pluto's classification! It is in fact a planet with a solid iron core and distinct north and south poles. It also has not 1 but 5 small orbiting moons.

[@rasputinsliver9092]

John Michael Godier. Probably the best interviewer in any genre in the media.

[@desther7975]

He certainly knows his stuff!

[@glockhead4597]

Thank you for talking about planet 9. It's such a great mystery that we can get a close look at. Keep us updated please.

[@OptimusGnarkill]

Happy Thursday...I mean Event Horizon Day ya’ll!

[@McLovinlt]

Happy Friday from Australia

[@OptimusGnarkill]

Sal Vastola 😂 Haven’t completely lost my marbles yet, I promise!

[@OptimusGnarkill]

Sal Vastola #KAG!!!

[@Shaden0040]

James Webb was supposed to originally launch in 2013 it is now delayed 7 years with an earliest launch date of 2021 for a total of 8 year delay. So far it is a boondoggle.

[@friendlyone2706]

Or secretly slowed down by what doesn't want the Webb to reveal something now invisible? :)

[@amangogna68]

Great video !

[@SideWalkAstronomyNetherlands]

If we find it, can we move Trumb to this planet?

[@DavidEvans_dle]

Still hoping its a strange primordial black hole, need something to power my Halo drive. Pull up in my ride to Alpha Centauri Romulan style.

[@andrewmccarty8412]

What is the music you play at the end of Event Horizon? I love it b

[@EventHorizonShow]

Ascent by Stellardrone, link in the description.

[@muglymae7408]

Space music is always better than the stuff that plays on the radio or gets sold in stores

[@stonemason1694]

Join music channel you dummy

[@vahangood5999]

Congrats on the 100k milestone! ✌️

[@TheEmperor2052]

Can anyone please explain why there is a missing segment at around 9.31?

[@EventHorizonShow]

You mean a missing word?

[@TheEmperor2052]

Well, I dont think there is only a missing word there. The entire segment seems to have been edited out.

[@MohakJoshi1]

Do you deliberately distort the guests voice? Not complaining, just curious.

[@TheGhostGuitars]

Blame it on Ma Bell for the sound fx, or her successors, actually.

[@Lasselucidora]

Neil deGrass Tyson is not a human. He failed on one of the requisites. But we took a vote and decided to call him a Dwarf-human.

[@sitchinstudies8381]

Great video.. Thank you.

[@mikkirefur]

Nice to hear an astronomy video admitting and pointing to all the unknowns. Strictly theoretical conjecturing.... and it is also important to remember, with mathematics and simulations EVERYTHING is possible. Then you can convince people it is probable. Then you can tax them.

[@SuzNews]

Dr. Godier, Your guest mentioned more than once that the asteroids they were making their calculations from were clustered in two places, so we were expecting him to talk about these as Lagrangian points to calculate the location of the planet from, but he never did!

[@MiThreeSunz]

I’ve been fascinated with Planet X for many years. I wish I had some rudimentary background in astrophysics to understand the technical jargon in this video. Nonetheless, it was still very fascinating and informative!

[@patrickbowers8359]

If there is a planet 9 nasa. Never a straight answer because you will never know

[@larrybuzbee7344]

Fascinating. Thanks.

[@ole9421]

I do long for the day when your graphics actually match up with what's being discussed. I think coupling the two would go along way in helping your guest explain the complexities of these mathematical laws of physics. Seems it would also help smooth out the guest's train of consciousness.

[@tscoffey1]

That would require hours and hours more production work.

[@ole9421]

@@tscoffey1 You might be right. Let me jump over to Anton Petrov's site, he uses some pretty good sims to provide visual aid in explaining recent astronomical discoveries, and ask him how long, on average it takes him to create one. I don't think he has a staff that helps put his material together, but I could be wrong.

[@EventHorizonShow]

We always try to match what is being said with something that fits. However, we are working on improving the visuals this year

[@JohnMichaelGodier]

@@ole9421 The last thing on this earth that I would do is fire up a webcam and play with a sim while I'm talking to an eminent scientist.

[@ole9421]

@@JohnMichaelGodier My apologies. I just assumed you'd have a couple days of preparation before the show to put something together.

[@MisterXdotcom]

\o/ event horizon video \o/

[@mr.wilmer2588]

Great video

[@ssssaa2]

Glad he could check in on his HAM radio.

[@joey_after_midnight]

That first Link in the notes points to the Paper in PDF format, equation 31 he mentions as the possible solution to solving for range vectors is beyond me but looks something like the 3D Matricies we used to solve in grammar school.. only much larger. I guess from the surrounding text you need to solve it for each additional "asteroid" to creep up on the actual current position. - Step by Step, Slowly I turned.

[@TheGhostGuitars]

Yep, ye got the basic drif of that part. And yes, it will take some serious computing power to come up with the answer, that's why Finch referred to it as "work." As in that it will take time to crunch thru the numbers for each body then aggregate them together to get a probable spread of target loci before we can start looking using telescopes.

[@notgerhardnotrichter4951]

Stellar 💫

[@garysmith1135]

Could it be the solar mass black hole left over from the star that preceded the sun? If that's not likely, shouldn't there be one somewhere though?

[@GH29111]

When we find planet 9 we’ll have another mystery as to what is gravitationally influencing planetX

[@sitchinstudies8381]

Would like a follow-up video on this science.

[@balcofono666]

Please, make it also into a podcast!

[@EventHorizonShow]

Currently working on this, a premium podcast option.

[@brittanylaferriere3783]

So many questions Planet 9. 1. Will it take anything with it that would a potential impact for the sun, us, or our planets? 2. Would we have to revisit ancient Sumerian text with a modern eye because Sumerians have mentioned a 9th planet? 3. In which planets would this pass between? Thats probably undetectable at this time.

[@b.griffin317]

29:00 wouldn't it be easier to spot at perihelion rathe than aphelion?

[@phantomwalker8251]

did you sneeze..

[@marcgoecke9401]

I hope I live to see prove of Planet9 one day

[@bitcoinmining6361]

Event Horizon...Could you please explain or get a guest to explain the 3D big bang...As all the diagrams/illustrations of the universes development and celestial gravity interaction is always depicted in 2D... Someone can correct me where my thinking and understanding is wrong... As I image the big bang to have been a 3D event.. Where from the singularity, the explosion occured like a ballon inflating...matter spread in a globe like structure....(maybe at different rates in different regions..but this is a layman analogy)..What I can't understand is 1) matter further out from that 1 central point has to be moving faster than matter nearer to the central point...So how can we tell that we are accelerating and not deceletrating...As the spacial relativity of our position can only be measured to similarly affected points of reference... 2) If our universe is flat...would it not make sense...like a solar system..Galaxy Our Universe is also rotating around a central point of gravity?..which i would class as the 4th dimension - As it is like that point..just over the horizon!!

[@TheShootist]

someone has turned your mind into a single bit

[@bitcoinmining6361]

@@TheShootist a singuhilarity rotating around a higher dimension...I know dude..🤣...been told before....and I have to deal with him every single day....🕺🍺

[@ptmarkoviitanen]

Matter further away is NOT moving away faster... it is common misconception that they are "flying away from us"... They are not actually "moving away"... Thing is... there is more fabric of space CREATED everywhere in space, which is why when we look further, there is more space created between the 2 objects, which increases the distance, and this same thing happens everywhere in the universe. Think like this: bird moving further away in the sky... but it's not actually flying, it's just levitating.... it is stationary from it's point of view, but there is more air created between you and the bird, which moves it away from us. The more further the bird is, the more air is created between, which makes it look like the further away it is, the faster it moves away from us. What you see is the second biggest mystery in the universe, right after big bang. We don't know what is making more space all than time.

[@TheSilmarillian]

Fascinating hello from Australia :)

[@zapfanzapfan]

JWST is not a good survey telescope but once Planet 9 is found JWST will be very useful. WFIRST has a very large field of view, that might be able to scan enough of the sky to find it. Or maybe the LSST will finally find it.

[@awkc63]

I've said for a couple years now, for people who say "it's impossible" for Planet 9. The planet HD 106906 B gives the possibility for this to happen. Look how far that planet is away from its host star.

[@xjohnny1000]

I don't think anyone has said that.

[@awkc63]

@@xjohnny1000 Really? It's only been the the past like 2 years that people are warming up to the idea. Most people either don't believe it to be a thing because they can't see it... Or... They think Pluto is still the 9th planet.

[@xjohnny1000]

@@awkc63 Our definition of "people" is probably different. Outside of pro and amateur astronomers, opinions on astro phenomenon don't matter because they are uninformed. I base my opinions on people like Robert Finch and Mike Brown. If they told me there were 100 planets out there, I would give them the benefit of the doubt.

[@awkc63]

@@xjohnny1000 Sure, that's a way better thing, people actually in the field. Even so, it's still relatively new. You heard from both sides a few years ago, whether Planet 9 could could be real or not. As time passes, we may not have found it yet, but it's more likely it's a planet than it being anything else.

[@gregbrockway4452]

This is old news, decades ago Ed Wood made a documentary called “Planet Nine from Outer Space”. JK, thanks John and Dr. Finch for this fascinating interview.

[@yourstruly4817]

What's the science multiplier for Planet 9?

[@planetearth2249]

I think Planet 9 would either be: 1. Pluto :'3 2. A planet almost twice the size of Earth that is habitable (Also has an atmosphere that is earth-like, but since the planet is so far away, it would require a powerful greenhouse effect to balance out) 3. A super-Neptune or mini-Jupiter gas giant

[@phantomwalker8251]

# 2 is correct.its in all ancient texts,indian vadas,american indian legands,dogon myths.sumerian tablets.why do you think we are here & have speech..??..

[@uafc1]

Recently 160 rogue planets very near us were discovered just by looking at one point in the space with a telescope. Could it be possible that while the sun travels through the galaxy, it gets close to these rogue planets and then the objects far away from it in the oort cloud and the kuiper belt are affected greatly by these rogue planets producing these changes in their orbits?

[@Chumfin]

What would have caused planet nines crazy far out orbit ,interstellar rouge star ,black hole , it’s possible but sounds like a massive inescapable gravity well either way

[@nutyyyy]

Likely Jupiter ejected it, its likely Jupiter and Saturn ejected multiple planets from our solar system, planet nine was probably able to remain in a highly eccentric orbit, whereas others were completely thrown out, which fascinates me. Imagine a planet thrown out of the solar system 4 billion years ago? Where could it be right now and how far from us? It could be anywhere in the galaxy.

[@stricknine6130]

I prefer Planet X it just sounds better. Great interview I think it's out there. Thanks for the episode!

[@ffagilar2245]

Found these objects with the odd orbit be made of a strange material. Once they are in a certain orientation, they then act like a solar sail?

[@johnfoelster507]

Instead of Planet IX or Planet X, they should call it something less confusing, like Bene Tleilax or Neoplutomus or Kepler 452b.

[@breakitd0wn]

i read that title as 'with Robin Finch' and thought what would a guitarist know about Planet Nine xD

[@wellardbr]

I had to turn on the closed caption because Mr. Finch's voice is very low-fi in this video (as compared with the host's silky, bottom-enhanced crooner voice). It helped a lot re: comprehension of his torque-focused approach to pinpointing #Planet9 's orbit, but was also very funny sometimes. For example, the proper name Batigyn is impossible for the CC system: I took note of ~grandpa tiger and ~petechiae! That said, thank you for posting this, Mr. Silky Voice Godier.

[@mah-ky4pi]

It is Niburu

[@greaterthings5652]

Lol maybe its on the other side of the sun and we cant see it because it has the same orbit as we do.

[@TheWeatherbuff]

Ah. My sanctuary from the news and human insanity. Thanks, JM. Your channel is most appreciated.

[@muskyelondragon]

Damn that's good work

[@InimitaPaul]

It's our original planet, we destroyed it. We terraformed Mars and, destroyed it. We terraformed Earth and...

[@GeorgeNoX]

what if we already discovered planet 9, we discovered so called ''dwarf'' planets or planetoids in outer solar system (Sedna, Ceres, Eris etc.) so what if one of these is the elusive planet 9? I never was one of those people that dismiss ''dwarf planets'' as main planets of our solar system just because they are small. I still consider Pluto a planet as well. So by that logic, not only that we discovered planet 9, we discovered a total of 18 by that count. Frankly, current definition of a planet is absurd to me when instead it should be if its a spherical object and is not a moon to a larger object it should be called a planet, no matter how small it is. Just because these ''dwarf planets'' are smaller than our moon that doesn't mean they are not planets, our moon is an exception and not a rule after all, all other moons in our solar system are much smaller than our moon and our moon is larger than it should be compared to others. Hell, if we go by sizes then our moon is a planet as well. Also considering that even Mercury, which is classified as a main planet, is smaller than even some of the moons in our solar system. I think the entire definition of what a planet is needs to be redefined altogether

[@phantomwalker8251]

buddy,niburu,ect,,comes around every 36,000 yrs,we,were invaded by them,why the hell do you think we have speech.& not swinging in trees..??.

[@ThermaL-ty7bw]

we have more then 9 planets , there just to small to be of any significance or have different orbits , not especially only in our part of the galaxy , they move in and out we have more then 1 moon too , smaller ones

[@futhark3899]

I would look in the area between planet 8 and 10

[@TaswcmT]

Talk about the scientific world creating a mystery when none is needed. Planet 9 is right where it's always been. You'll find it a bit past Neptune, big heart-shaped surface feature - can't miss it. #JusticeForPluto.

[@phantomwalker8251]

its not pluto.they know what & where it is.the vatican knows,most high gov,s know,hindu,s know,its been written about for thousands of yrs.its written in the sumerian tablets.as our creators.''made in there image''..nothing to do with religion..hinduism,is not,,a religion..

[@cyanidejunkie]

Correct me if I’m wrong, but a planet that sized, the same age as the rest of our solar system (native) should have shone red hot in the last infrared survey... and nothing was found? Shenanigans?

[@TheShootist]

was the entire sky imaged?

[@nutyyyy]

You are basically looking for an object moving slowly across the sky somewhere, if its aligned with the milk way in the sky it could be very hard to find, it's not, but still its difficult to find. You have to point your telescope at the exact spot for long enough to track its movement and identify it against the background.

[@Officerufo1]

Very interesting video and topic. According to spiritual science there are 2 secret planets. One is the planet in question in this video, and that planet is Persephone which has an orbit that goes out the furthest from our sun. The other secret planet is the opposite, it actually orbits closer to the sun than Mercury, and the name of this planet is Vulcan; that's right Vulcan, just like a planet bearing that name in Star Trek. Vulcan because of it's extremely high vibration remains a mystery to astronomers because it appears and then disappears.

[@phantomwalker8251]

spiritual science eh..i say bullshit..fact is,,this planet is where our creators came from,not,,the bible god garbage.id be rid of your spiritual science,& start reading sumerian tablets.real fact..not bible bullshit..

[@dasdaleberger5683]

People working hard to get Pluto reinstated.

[@EventHorizonShow]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qmTVpaiim8mrqbs

[@nutyyyy]

I think it's fair, or at least classify dwarf planets as a legit type of planet. There really aren't that many that are true dwarf planets that it would be too much to keep up with. Would we consider a extrasolar planetary system that has 20 planets to be too many and decide that some had to be reclassified so people could remember them easier?

[@johncnorris]

I've read it could be anything from a Brown Dwarf that was either captured or flung out of the center of the solar system, to another Ice Giant like Neptune, or even a big rocky core of a depleted Gas Giant (possible like Mercury but bigger.) I tend to thing the odds favor a rocky core that was flung outward maybe in an encounter with another Gas Giant like Jupiter and/or Saturn. It would explain why we don't have Gas Giants orbiting in the inner solar system like a lot of other solar systems.

[@kricketflyd111]

Very nice.

[@mikekline2505]

Look up Terral BlackStar here on KZbin

[@curtcoller3632]

The first "singing" narrator - should get a reward or a kick in ....

[@Peoples_Republic_of_Cotati]

I really really want this thing to be a 'micro' black hole.

[@jeffdunnell508]

Louis Brown close your eyes you'll see it

[@oker59]

Mike Brown and Batygin showed on a PlanetX(they call it Planet9 for false reasons; glad to see Robert Finch agrees with me and hopefully more people that Pluto is a planet!) blog that they can't use the calculations to pinpoint PlanetX. I think this was from the girl who showed that PlanetX exerts a torque on the Sun! I keep forgetting her name.

[@HotspotsSoutheast]

We already have a planet nine. It’s called Pluto. I realize that it offends many European scientists to have to admit that one of the planets in our solar system was discovered by an American and thus it is easier to just redefine what a planet is and call it something else like “dwarf planet” but a planet is still a planet. Shall we rename Jupiter to a “failed sun” and not call it a planet anymore? It’s like how do you define what the difference is between a river and a stream? There are many rivers that are shallow enough to wade across or even jump across. It’s not the width or depth that determines a river but it’s length. Yes there are other “dwarf planets” out there too. And possibly larger ones. You can call them whatever you want if it makes you happy. And you can call yourself a unicorn too if that makes you happy.

[@nkordich]

Ceres was discovered before Pluto, has an orbit closer to the Sun's than Pluto, and was originally called a planet. If you're against demoting planets after they're recognized, then by order of discovery and counting outward from the Sun, the existence of Ceres means Pluto never should have been considered planet nine. Where's the outrage over Ceres being demoted because other small objects were discovered in its orbit, causing them to change its designation after we'd already been calling it a planet? We could have continued calling Ceres a planet, just one with many asteroids occupying its orbit - we'd pretty much have to, if we were pretending to be objective and allowing Pluto back into the planet club that it was kicked out of for the same reason. I'm fine with Pluto being grandfathered-in and even with Ceres being demoted back to queen of the asteroids rather than elevated to (dwarf or non-dwarf) planethood along with Pluto, but let's be honest, it's not because we object to a planet being demoted because it hasn't cleared its orbit - exactly as happened to Ceres a hundred years earlier, because astronomers wanted to exclude asteroids as a potentially unlimited number of minor planets. We dislike it specifically because it's a change to what we learned in childhood - our childhood - when science was all planets and dinosaurs and the Bohr model of the atom, and we are really defensive about that. That's fine, but let's just be up front that it's about protecting our inner child, not defending science against some irrational new wave - leave that to the Flat Earthers and their accusations of 'scientism.' If you really want to attack the idea that planets need to clear their orbits, point out that Jupiter not only has Trojans, Greek, and the Hildae (at the L3 Lagrange region), but many asteroids in its orbit that don't fall into these camps. If clearing its orbit is required - or even just sorting all the asteroids in its orbit into Lagrange regions - then Jupiter isn't a planet. If a classification for planets doesn't work for Jupiter, it's useless.

[@Bizmonger]

Could a star system host a hybrid-matter system? Could dark matter be at work on the outer solar system that would also affect orbital bodies? Why not?

[@cyanidejunkie]

Scott Nimrod There’s no such thing as dark matter... These guys just haven’t adequately added up and weighed the actual matter, dust, gas, plasma, red and brown dwarfs, planets, that is there.

[@2013Arcturus]

Chances are no, because the density of dark matter is too thin. Dark matter can't clump like regular matter. The object causing the disturbance at the edge of the solar system must be compact (i.e. planet size) for it to cause what we're seeing.

[@cyanidejunkie]

Nicolas P. Cage You have a better chance of finding Planet 9 using nothing more than an old toaster oven, than finding “Dark Matter” it doesn’t exist.

[@arostwocents]

Dark matter is just a funding scam not something that's real so no it cant be. Unless you want funding to determine if it is. Then, maybe.

[@2013Arcturus]

@@cyanidejunkie maybe, maybe not. I'm open to alternative explanations. MOND and Electric Universe theory are both interesting possibilities, but neither has been tested as well as Dark Matter theory has. The hardest thing for you to have wave Dark Matter away though is gravitational lensing. We can see, in visible light, the bent and distorted images of far away galaxies due to gravitational masses greater than observed luminous matter. Again I'm open to other explanations, dark matter just fits observations best atm.

[@Talkathon408]

"we only ran the simulation for 40 million years"

[@yodaco]

Meanwhile in a laboratory just outside of our universe. "We ran the simulation for 13.772 billion years, will that do it? Yeah, kill it, let's get lunch"

[@jeffpeffers4519]

An still tan out of time!?

[@Lopfff]

After I watch political videos and videos about creepy stuff, I like to end with the calm voice of JMG discussing space. Clears the palette.

[@ReNicolAstrO_]

Yup 👍😂😉

[@keithrosenberg5486]

Unless "Planet 9" meets the IAU definition of a planet, it cannot be called a planet. 1> It orbits the sun and 2> probably has hydrostatic equilibrium. But it is not yet clear that it has cleared its orbital neighborhood. In some sense it meets none of those since we have yet to directly observe it, assuming it exists.

[@traceydeanrainey]

Well if planet 9 is a reality , perhaps it having an elliptical orbit that comes close to innermost planet’s or not could be the source of extinction level events that nearly wipes life on Earth out of existence every so many years ?

[@gerardfraser]

Going to save this for video for bedtime watching,interesting as anything on the internet,thanks for sharing.Planet nine has to be a super earth ,lets say 4.5 times bigger than earth.So yes it exist of course no one knows if it is a planet.

[@vannakauth7988]

Planet nine was the Asteroid Belt between mars and Jupiter. Explained by the Ancient mesapotamian text about the structure of this solar system. According to the story an ancient comet or object outside the universe came and collided with a planet in between jupiter and mars and destroyed it to pieces.

[@joestromer7727]

Planet 9 is Niburu home of the Annunaki. The ones who created us.

[@fagnani7]

kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk crazy

[@TheReaverOfDarkness]

It's very possible it's not out there. I think it is, the data looks pretty strong to me. But what I also think is that even if it's not there, there probably is another Earth-sized object out there somewhere anyway. It would be stranger if there wasn't. People keep assuming that there's nothing in all places where we haven't yet found something, but nearly every time we look closer, we find more things.