The one mistake to resist post-election: Good vs. evil | Amanda Ripley

  Рет қаралды 56,702

Big Think

Big Think

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 412
@carlosdominguez3108
@carlosdominguez3108 Ай бұрын
What we honestly have in this country at this point is collective idiocracy. People have lost the ability to examine data and think critically. It blows my mind how absolutely stupid this country has become. And the fact that almost no one is willing to talk about serious issues because they lack the ability to separate emotion from conversation/debate.
@Grassdia
@Grassdia Ай бұрын
I think it’s mainly due to a ‘comfort syndrome’ where we have no reason to venture into unknowing grounds even if it’s smarter to do so at a fear of lost comfort
@rainbeauxunicorn5237
@rainbeauxunicorn5237 Ай бұрын
That’s was done by design. Eroding education standards to create less educated sheep that are easily manipulated politically is a constant goal of Republicans.
@PerceptionVsReality333
@PerceptionVsReality333 Ай бұрын
You are right 💯
@MysticLegend31
@MysticLegend31 Ай бұрын
Personally, part of it is how pervasive misinformation is now. It's hard to trust sources
@micahgmiranda
@micahgmiranda Ай бұрын
When was this mythical time when everyone could think critically?
@niltonnunes1319
@niltonnunes1319 Ай бұрын
I Agree to Dosagree with the statement in this video. Trying to intellectualize what has just happened to the country feels like an act of arrogance. There is a lack of education, common sense, honesty, and decency in an ultra-capitalist society, where money and status reign supreme. This country is off the rails, and it should be on high alert-not just for its own sake, but for the sake of the world.
@b1r2y3n
@b1r2y3n Ай бұрын
Unless of course the person running has told you in their own words how evil they are.
@cindylandham4337
@cindylandham4337 Ай бұрын
Exactly why we need to NOT do the same thing.
@Timidor23
@Timidor23 Ай бұрын
McCain, Romney, even Bush weren't evil. We had healthy differences in how to organize society. But don't gaslight us. Sometimes evil actually does rise within a political party. We saw a very similar pattern in 1920-30 Germany.
@jonathananonymouse7685
@jonathananonymouse7685 Ай бұрын
Yep. The fact that "people can have very different answers" to a question on abortion asked in different ways doesn't really matter. Each person seems to have exactly one view on things like fascism, racism, and misogyny: either for, or against. Those are inherently divisive modes of thought, and being friends with people of the opposing view doesn't seem to change anyone's mind, it just paints a target on half the people's backs.
@s.davidcox7523
@s.davidcox7523 Ай бұрын
Agreed. Tens of millions of people just voted for someone who is openly hate-mongering and openly wishes to have dictatorial power. Those voters want a "strong man." They are not being duped or hoodwinked or manipulated. As an aside, this video was clearly made before the election. She talks a lot about abortion as an example, and abortion was a non-issue in who people voted for. Missourians passed an amendment protecting abortion while overwhelmingly re-electing Josh Hawley and Donald Trump. Finally, I'd like to ask Ms. Ripley in this video--who seems like a perfectly nice person--what were good people in Germany supposed to feel in the late 1930s? There comes a time when moral condemnation is the only righteous response. Human beings tend to wait too late.
@dvvinever
@dvvinever Ай бұрын
I think the concerns of authoritarianism based on the rhetoric, behavior, and purposefully lying of a factionalist candidate in order to intimidate, threaten, or incite the worst reactions and binary thinking of the electorate is strikingly similar to movements to shutdown thinking in 1930s fascist movements. This is not just a normal election with a normal candidate. This is a person who lied, tried to force his way into power after the 2020 election, was indicted for multiple crimes and convicted in another set of crimes. He also said exactly what he intends to do including going after the press, political opponents, and even legal documented immigrants, and on his recent speeches he doubled down by stating that he made promises that he intends to keep. Those might also include being a dictator on day one. So this isn't some simplistic political divide of parties, this is existential to all Americans and democracy itself if this individual runs with the power he believes he can use against political opponents, to consolidate powers of the executive by gutting experts and departments that provide critical protections from run away greed and short term profit seeking, or weakening intelligence and law enforcement agencies that defend America which should never be used as political weapons or weakened to such a degree that they can no longer perform their very necessary critical roles in the 21st century. When a person openly plans to abuse power and demands more than the constitution would allow, and they do it for their own purposes and benefits than helping uphold rights and protect the constitution, it could easily be described in some ways as evil or selfish intent that intends to cause harm to others by design.
@AuntieMamies
@AuntieMamies Ай бұрын
Thank you! Precisely! Also, W called him to congratulate him so, some Bushes qualify
@mcelonconnell-i2k
@mcelonconnell-i2k Ай бұрын
Nooooooo we did not see a similar pattern
@johntucker3750
@johntucker3750 Ай бұрын
Lady, folks in the US are willfully ignorant. We don't want anything to get in the way of our selfishness and materialism. Fast food is more important to us than the truth.
@greenandgold2185
@greenandgold2185 Ай бұрын
Sarcastic but true...
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
Democrats yelled at the country because they couldn't afford food period for 4 years and are still confused why they lost every branch of government. The White House literally reported for months that inflation was fake news. I'm a Democrat that voted for Trump precisely because of this arrogance
@barnz008
@barnz008 Ай бұрын
'Conflict entrepreneurs." Hit the nail on the head with that one.
@micahy.6190
@micahy.6190 Ай бұрын
Right and wrong were blatant this time around. We’re devolving 😔
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
Correct. The moral side won. The side against Americans lost
@jadedjaden3790
@jadedjaden3790 16 күн бұрын
​@@themeangeneThis election resulted in devolution. Glad you agree.
@BendingPinkSteel
@BendingPinkSteel Ай бұрын
"People are hard to hate close up." - Brené Brown This is the mentality I try to keep in mind, especially during political seasons. People, at their core, just want to protect what and who they love. That's a good common ground to start every conversation with.
@cynthiadavis3102
@cynthiadavis3102 Ай бұрын
Not narcissists. Personality disordered people are dangerous.
@Merriwether-w8k
@Merriwether-w8k Ай бұрын
The illusion of control
@jonathananonymouse7685
@jonathananonymouse7685 Ай бұрын
Mmsure, but they're easy to kill, enslave, and oppress close up. Southern slave owners. might not have *hated* their slaves; some were even said to care for them from time to time (to the extent that they had children together! Aww.) But that doesn't change the fact that slavery IS evil. The racism it's founded on IS evil. And I'm willing to engage with anyone who's willing to change their mind. But there ARE some people who equate those kinds of philosophies and their identities. They don't just BELIEVE in racism, they ARE racist, and have no intent to change. Those people aren't just doing something evil. Those people ARE something evil. And if I have something in common with them, I'm doing something very, very wrong.
@kukoistava.
@kukoistava. Ай бұрын
I don't disagree with this mindset; it's a healthy way to be, and I aspire to it. But I'm also at conflict with it: There's no common ground I can find with those who are abusive, or who tolerate and dismiss abuse. It may well be true that they are just protecting what and who they love, but if their doing so denies another person's safety, we will never be on common grounds. Any victim of abuse knows well that the abuser will require you to meet their perspective; and never yours. We must unequivocally reject any tolerance of abuse. Yet, so many in this country let a person known to abuse power into a position of power. I don't wish to hear that they did so for economic policies, or whatever their reasons. This is not just a political season: We will be extraordinarily lucky to see another American president in 2028, or ever.
@Steve-wz5pz
@Steve-wz5pz Ай бұрын
Rethuglican "people" just want to protect what and who they OWN. There's the problem.
@tractorpoodle
@tractorpoodle Ай бұрын
How about imperfect democracy vs. authoritarianism.
@Thewhiteandorange
@Thewhiteandorange Ай бұрын
u.s. is an autocracy and has been for a while. maybe now is the time to start talking about more than a two party political system.... before authoritarianism fully sets in.
@craigmerkey8518
@craigmerkey8518 Ай бұрын
People in the US have the strange need to be entertained and worship celebrities! “When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time.” ~Maya Angelou. The US has been showing what is is by behavior to those who will listen for centuries! I will firmly remain in the camp with people who can speak in complete sentences!
@robynwells8249
@robynwells8249 Ай бұрын
In theory I agree, and until several years ago I had the attitude of “Seek first to understand”. I live in an area that is very proud of their confederacy heritage. There are many prominent symbols though out the city. The last few years the rhetoric has gotten bolder along with the assumption that everyone one agrees, even if it’s stated you don’t. These actions and words are horrible. Sometimes you have to wish people well from a distance. For now, I’m choosing to do just that and “breakup” with some business. While they have a right to say what they want I have to a right not to spend money supporting these ideas.
@jacksonmacd
@jacksonmacd Ай бұрын
Pardon my ignorance but I am not sure I understand your point. Are you saying that you object to the removal of Confederacy symbols and choose to boycott businesses that support such removal? Not trying to be provocative but I genuinely thought your statement was unclear.
@robynwells8249
@robynwells8249 Ай бұрын
@@jacksonmacd the symbols can’t be removed they are on private property. My point being I live in an area that has a racist past and tendencies. For many years I have attempted to understand why this is and what leads a person to feel this way. As the rhetoric has gotten bolder, and the assumptions that I’m in agreement has become more prevalent I have to distance myself from those people. How this correlates to the topic is at times actions and words are evil and destructive so you have to back away. Not sure if this is tribal but it’s needed for sanity.
@robynwells8249
@robynwells8249 Ай бұрын
@@jacksonmacd I can see your confusion. I live in an area that I feel has hateful rhetoric and symbols. The last few years have been worse. As the video suggests people result to tribalism for security sake. What I was saying is sometimes you have to take a reprieve from people who may not have the best intentions. Which means, for a while, I will not do business with people who engage in racist rhetoric, but I will wish them well, at a distance.
@jacksonmacd
@jacksonmacd Ай бұрын
​@@robynwells8249ok, I had interpreted your original statement completely backwards. Thank you for clarifying.
@MinistryOfMotivations
@MinistryOfMotivations Ай бұрын
"Success is not final, failure is not fatal: It is the courage to continue that counts."💪
@ianemory5800
@ianemory5800 Ай бұрын
I hate the enlightened centrist fallacy. I can't pretend that I don't hear the things from actual people in power like "we should teach the Bible in school" or "I'm against abortion even in the cases of rape" at that point it doesn't matter what the person's individual opinion in the matter of who you vote for is a loon.
@cynthiadavis3102
@cynthiadavis3102 Ай бұрын
Thank you for this idea! It is very useful. The enlightened centrist fallacy! Brilliant! This woman sounds kinda like JD Vance saying that London just doesn't feel English anymore. ...naive and sophomoric/attempting to sound sophisticated. Glad you said "I hate"!! 😅
@micahholt9895
@micahholt9895 Ай бұрын
I hear her making an argument about social nuances, but I'm not sure she is trying to claim there is a balanced validity of socio-political views. She seems to be more worried about allowing prejudice to get the best of people losing themselves to mindless, vitriol behavior that likely promotes blatant hatred towards the other side. You're right about focusing on the people in power to infringe the rights of others. However, I don't think she is encouraging against that point to ignore your concerns. Note: I already voted for Harris and think Trump is a complete imbecile, so please don't somehow see it as my conclusion because I disagree with you over this lady's discussion.
@kmscheid3303
@kmscheid3303 Ай бұрын
@@micahholt9895 Man, I wish I could believe. But social nuances isn't in trump's wheelhouse, or his administration.
@micahholt9895
@micahholt9895 Ай бұрын
@kmscheid3303 I wasn't speaking for Trump. He's trash. I voted against him like I claimed. The nuance is more directed at fellow American citizens. Not to validate their views if they oppose yours but initial give the opportunity for change respecting their choice to change. The lady seem to speaking against prejudice that would prohibit that or at least what I took from her. Unfortunately, Trump won. I believe she is right as social justice can be stronger through cooperation and group cohesion over echo chambers and confirmation biases. Like I said, you don't have to corrupt your views and integrity but don't let your prejudice blind you from opportunity if there is one or more.
@jaynem9896
@jaynem9896 Ай бұрын
Yep. It takes a lot of privilege to take that position too.
@colinz226
@colinz226 Ай бұрын
Hanlon's Razor: Never attribute to Malice that which is adequately explained by Stupidity.
@JK-yy5gm
@JK-yy5gm Ай бұрын
Also don't believe the projections of narcissists who actively know that they are hurting others and trying to convince others they are just ignorant
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
Exactly. The average Kamala voter in a compact nutshell
@mekabar77
@mekabar77 Ай бұрын
"Which is ideally what journalism would be doing". What a great underhanded burn! 🔥 I like this Lady! 😊👍
@Allenwatts-y9n
@Allenwatts-y9n Ай бұрын
Watching this captivating video stirs up painful memories of the recent end of my 4 year relationship. My beloved partner chose to depart, leaving me with an unyielding ache. Despite my relentless efforts to reconcile, I find myself grappling with frustration and an inability to envision a future without him. Despite attempts to purge him from my mind, I remain haunted by his absence, feeling compelled to express my longing here.
@vivianMarvin-z6k
@vivianMarvin-z6k Ай бұрын
It's hard to let go of someone you love; I went through a similar experience when my 12-year relationship ended. I tried everything to get him back, and eventually I had to turn to a spiritual counselor for assistance.
@Allenwatts-y9n
@Allenwatts-y9n Ай бұрын
Interesting! How did you locate a spiritual counsellor, and how can I get in touch with him most effectively?
@vivianMarvin-z6k
@vivianMarvin-z6k Ай бұрын
His name is Father Obah Eze, and he is a great spiritual counselor who can bring back your ex.
@vivianMarvin-z6k
@vivianMarvin-z6k Ай бұрын
he is father obah eze, he has great powers, he can help you.
@Allenwatts-y9n
@Allenwatts-y9n Ай бұрын
Thank you for this valuable information, i just looked him up now online. impressive Wow I just looked Father Obah Eze on the net he’s very legit thanks once again ❤
@vv7299
@vv7299 Ай бұрын
It doesn't matter if everyone on the other side thinks a certain way. It matters what people in power think
@nathaniverson
@nathaniverson Ай бұрын
Sanewashing of insanity
@exodia0017
@exodia0017 Ай бұрын
❤❤❤CONFLICT ENTREPRENEURS❤❤❤ This distinction/phrase/term NEEDS to go mainstream. Conflict sells and creates immense opportunities for certain people to capture more wealth and power Which is why I love that she called them "conflict entrepreneurs"...
@whodat-d9w
@whodat-d9w Ай бұрын
Nonsense. There is a right and a wrong. Smart people know the difference. I will not break bread with people that hate my family for who they are, sorry.
@OneOfEightBillion
@OneOfEightBillion Ай бұрын
Well said!
@jebaker2
@jebaker2 Ай бұрын
The idea of surrounding yourself with more people that think differently than you is a great concept. Unfortunately, those who need that exposure do not actively seek it - in fact they avoid it. This is why the closer to a city center a district is, the more "blue" it votes. And in homogeneous districts, their fear or misunderstanding of other groups pushes them to the xenophobic "red" vote.
@Timidor23
@Timidor23 Ай бұрын
I don't think the people who need to process vastly different religious, cultural, ethnic and sexual worldviews every day in urban centers are the ones in a bubble. The people in ethnic and culturally homogenous small towns and rural areas actually prove themselves less capable of accepting others.
@jonathananonymouse7685
@jonathananonymouse7685 Ай бұрын
@@Timidor23 That's... what they're saying.
@jebaker2
@jebaker2 Ай бұрын
@@Timidor23 isn't that what I said?
@Timidor23
@Timidor23 Ай бұрын
@@jonathananonymouse7685 You're right. I misread it opposite
@Timidor23
@Timidor23 Ай бұрын
@jebaker2 Yeah, sorry I misread your comment
@DybalaSony
@DybalaSony Ай бұрын
Nice video and well explained. Thank you for bringing up this video. Financial education is indeed required for more than 70% of the society in the country as very few are literate on the subject. Thanks to Expert Citadel Moore the lady you recommended.....
@MarisKumar
@MarisKumar Ай бұрын
I feel grateful to have met her also. She has been a game-changer in my financial journey. I Withdraw $50k yesterday
@MarisKumar
@MarisKumar Ай бұрын
I was advised to diversify my portfolio among several assets such as stocks and bonds since this can protect my portfolio for retirement. I'm seeking to invest $270k across markets but don't know where to start.
@GilbertTevez
@GilbertTevez Ай бұрын
Profitable trading requires experience, a solid strategy, and preparation, which we lack. Understanding buy/sell ratios, identifying market leaders, and diversifying are key to reducing risk
@MercyGreenwood
@MercyGreenwood Ай бұрын
Recession coming soon? Jim Rogers says next market crash will be the worst, holds cash. Plan B should be on investing
@SimonBaker-ez9ru
@SimonBaker-ez9ru Ай бұрын
Great! I've heard about her, but I haven't had the chance to work with her. I'm curious to learn more about how she's been helping people during the recession. I'm glad I came across across this comment.
@rvaldrich
@rvaldrich Ай бұрын
"Most of us aren't sure what to think about anything" What? How is that possible? How can you consider yourself even remotely responsible and not have an informed decision about things like reproductive rights, access to health care, child labor laws, etc? We're not debating income tax versus property tax, we're debating whether Trans people really exist. This video seems to be advocating we tolerate and accept a deliberately (even maliciously) uninformed populace. Perhaps this might have been an reasonable argument back into 1990s. But post-Patriot Act? Post-MAGA? No, the divides are pretty binary. This feels staggeringly tone deaf and both-sidesing the modern socio-political scene. This is fence-sitting.
@danporath536
@danporath536 Ай бұрын
YOUR remedy?
@rvaldrich
@rvaldrich Ай бұрын
@@danporath536 Denounce ignorance? Don't foster tolerance of ill/mis-informed? Stop placating aggressive pride in one's ignorance as an acceptable lifestyle/personality? Don't produce and share videos of advocating for how we all just need to get along and try to understand the people that want to deny agency and autonomy to half the population (at least)?
@danporath536
@danporath536 Ай бұрын
@@rvaldrich That’s VERY courageous talk on…SOCIAL MEDIA. It ignores the fact that in the real world of face-to-face human relations one can’t just isolate from others. If you don’t develop skills to deal with conflict, you will never thrive socially, nor have the humility to realize that you don’t have all the answers. Good luck with your way, it is a failing strategy.
@rvaldrich
@rvaldrich Ай бұрын
@@danporath536 What's courageous about not tolerating ignorance, about not lowering standards for the people you associate with? And what makes you think its a losing strategy? Based on the proliferation of harmful ideas and rhetoric, placating and accommodating ignorance and intolerance doesn't seem to be working too well.
@danporath536
@danporath536 Ай бұрын
@ If you don’t growth and change…you wither. Good luck
@reincarnatedphoto
@reincarnatedphoto Ай бұрын
This is so profoundly true and a vital addition to the current zeitgeist. Thank you @bigthink for your relentless efforts to provide essential insight and support. I only wish a broader demographic would tune-in to your channel!
@Robert-yc9ql
@Robert-yc9ql Ай бұрын
I voted the way I did not because of good and evil (I am an atheist) but because of the character of the people running for office. The difference, to me, was very stark with absolutely no emotions involved. I like facts. There was no black and white... there was a felon vs a prosecutor. I fear America did not choose wisely.
@Track3qualize.65
@Track3qualize.65 Ай бұрын
💯
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
A prosecutor that extended prison sentences for free labor vs a political inmate arrested by his opponents to influence the election. That's how the other side viewed it. Trump had a comeback narrative that resonates with Americans. America loves under dogs.
@Heprit-w1x
@Heprit-w1x 23 күн бұрын
As someone who's not American and looking outside in, we all see the democrats as the side which is toxic, spreads hate based on sex, race and overall greed as compared to republican 🤔
@DK-tj8nm
@DK-tj8nm 12 күн бұрын
Courts are mostly biased against male and treat women very gently Also family courts are very anti male
@AuntieMamies
@AuntieMamies Ай бұрын
I wouldn't call it comforting. It's extremely upsetting to think half your country that you live in thinks it's fine if women get their rights taken from them. I'm sorry, idk how we're supposed to react to people voting in autocracy because they believe the price of eggs is gonna go down. People made it loud and clear that the well being of their fellow earth dwellers being ok is not a concern if it helps their pocket.
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
Unaliving a child isn't a human right. Also: Democrats can't even define what a woman is anymore You clearly have no empathy
@Heprit-w1x
@Heprit-w1x 23 күн бұрын
That more than half are women and from outside in as someone who's not American, we all see the democrats as the more toxic side which spreads hate and looks down on people and their opinion
@realblackbetty2204
@realblackbetty2204 19 сағат бұрын
Excited to see a strong and powerful America now that a true leader is in.
@vers9034
@vers9034 Ай бұрын
Thank you for these few minutes of sanity.
@al1vel1keyou
@al1vel1keyou Ай бұрын
Unfortunately, this is the illusion of sanity. True sanity is dead.
@cindylandham4337
@cindylandham4337 Ай бұрын
Well said. Thank you. This is exactly why I have joined Braver Angels. I want to know how to build bridges rather than polarize.
@CarrieLovesLife.
@CarrieLovesLife. Ай бұрын
Don’t be naive. Hate and Evil are real things
@cindylandham4337
@cindylandham4337 Ай бұрын
And Love & Goodness are even more powerful.
@Heprit-w1x
@Heprit-w1x 23 күн бұрын
That's why they lost in the election. Hate can't win and people see it
@pdxyadayada
@pdxyadayada Ай бұрын
I just texted my oldest friend on the opposite side of the political spectrum and wished him well. I fully agree with you!
@dillpickleMMO
@dillpickleMMO Ай бұрын
Thank you for the kind reminder Amanda :)
@seth5226
@seth5226 Ай бұрын
How about we split politics into "the side that is fully captured by a conflict entrepreneur" vs "the side that is not". What do all this thoughtfulness and empathy and understanding do to address such a conflict?
@AttackChefDennis
@AttackChefDennis Ай бұрын
There have been some lines and behaviors that can't really be forgiven, to do so would encourage the same types of behaviors in the future. 1st off: How can we ever trust those American citizens who voted for Trump in the first place. Why did I know instantly that Trump was terrible for the nation no matter what he said while millions of supposedly intelligent people thought he was God's gift to them. 2nd: they did it again in 2020, voting for
@barrymoore4470
@barrymoore4470 Ай бұрын
And now many Americans have voted for the same menace a third (and very possibly last) time.
@DK-tj8nm
@DK-tj8nm 12 күн бұрын
May be you hate men and due to trump love young men and want to help them in anti male environment Thats why you resent him
@mauricioangulos.2830
@mauricioangulos.2830 Ай бұрын
"Resistance is Futile"
@JK-yy5gm
@JK-yy5gm Ай бұрын
Resistance to what?
@stevelestermusic
@stevelestermusic Ай бұрын
I would simply like to have decent people leading us. That’s a better division, decent and indecent.
@31VeggieBurgers
@31VeggieBurgers Ай бұрын
Brilliant. Thank you for this. I tend to think people are neither good nor bad, we make good or bad choices and then we either learn from them or get stuck in vicious cycles. I’ll be sharing with friends and family.
@deadend1041
@deadend1041 Ай бұрын
Well then you are simply wrong. There is such a thing as evil and there are people that are evil. Look at the results of what it is they do, no matter how flowery the language and if some of it is bad, if it requires breaking some eggs to make an omelet, they are evil. Another great way to identify evil people as they say things like the ends justify the means.
@99btyler
@99btyler Ай бұрын
Practice being calm and objective 👍
@brothermine2292
@brothermine2292 Ай бұрын
Ripley shows only a glimmering of understanding of the true source of the problem, which extends far beyond the example of the "good or evil" labels. In general, adjectives and adverbs and labels that semantically act like adjectives are actually vague abbreviations for relative comparisons to unstated alternatives. For example, consider the adjective "big." The statement "X is big" really means "X is bigger than some Y that I haven't specified." The threshold between "big" and "not big" is undefined, and many things could be compared to X using the "bigger than" relation, so the use of the adjective "big" creates a misleading false dichotomy. When playing the game Twenty Questions, only a loser would ask "is it big," but the comparitive question "is it bigger than a breadbox" elicits a helpful answer. Ripley's example, the abortion issue, has more than two possible policies. So it's a vague & misleading false dichotomy to say "I support the right to abortion" or to say "I oppose abortion." A statement such as "I support X" means a relative preference for X over some unspecified Y. An example is the Obamacare health insurance proposal in 2009/2010. Polls asked voters if they "supported" it. Although a majority said they opposed it, the majority was comprised of two groups who had opposite preferences: those who thought it didn't go far enough (toward single-payer Medicare For All), plus those who thought it went too far (away from private health insurance). Pundits treated the majority "opposition" as if they all sided with the nascent Tea Party, abetting their false claim that a majority favored private health insurance. False dichotomies with political implications are the most insidious. Good or evil, support or oppose, right or wrong, approve or disapprove, etc. They can be used manipulatively to lump together people who have opposite reasons for describing something the same way. For another example, two people who say they "disapprove" of Joe Biden might be abbreviating opposite preferences: one of them might mean s/he prefers Trump over Biden, and the other might mean s/he prefers Bernie Sanders over Biden. Or suppose 75% say "we're on the wrong track" and 25% say "right track." That makes the current track appear very unpopular, but the 75% might be comprised of 35% who prefer a track that's further to the "left" and 40% who prefer a track that's further to the "right." In this case, the current track is preferred by a 60% majority (35%+25%) over a track further right and by a 65% majority (40%+25%) over a track further left, so the current track is actually the most popular. Ripley claims without evidence that the best solution is for individuals to get to know people with whom they disagree. But an alternative solution is for polls to ask people to rank alternative policies in order of preference, then use that data to count all the head-to-head majorities. This would identify the alternative(s) at the medians. (Loosely speaking, the most popular compromises.) For example, a voter's order of preference "Sanders Harris Trump" should be counted as a preference for Sanders over Harris and a preference for Sanders over Trump and a preference for Harris over Trump, in the three head-to-head comparisons. It's possible that an alternative that's the favorite of very few people is actually preferred head-to-head over the other alternatives by majorities (like the current track in the previous example). Ripley claimed without evidence that the reason why people use the false dichotomy "good or evil" is because that makes them feel good. But the ubiquity of false dichotomy adjectives in human languages strongly suggests a different reason: the convenience of abbreviations for relative comparisons to unstated alternatives. It's much easier & quicker to not specify an alternative(s) being compared. Also, many people presumably have trouble thinking clearly enough to figure out and describe to themselves an alternative to compare.
@alonsogu3562
@alonsogu3562 Ай бұрын
Jesus Christ. Congratulations to the people that read the whole comment.!!!🎉🎊👍
@cynthiadavis3102
@cynthiadavis3102 Ай бұрын
​@alonsogu3562 Thank you. I choose to feel congratulated. I loved the answer.
@cynthiadavis3102
@cynthiadavis3102 Ай бұрын
Thank you. Greatly appreciated. ❤
@DoloresLehmann
@DoloresLehmann Ай бұрын
@@alonsogu3562 I read it completely, although I'm exhausted and should be long in bed by now. And I found it very good. Not that it solves anything, but the analysis is on point.
@Kamran-f2s
@Kamran-f2s Ай бұрын
Thank you, Big Think, for not over producing with too much background music
@Asuncion-r1x
@Asuncion-r1x Ай бұрын
You're totally right! People within specific group think differenttly in one way or another. Their main need is THE NEED OF BELONGING. Hello from Ajijic Mexico 🇲🇽🇺🇸
@jaeolsen-x1x
@jaeolsen-x1x Ай бұрын
I know I'm in a constant state of anxiety. Like it or not, we're all in this together. Maybe we humans as a species are failing to adapt to our environment, and we're driving ourselves to extinction.
@barrymoore4470
@barrymoore4470 Ай бұрын
Our eventual extinction is highly probable--most species do become extinct given enough time. With current events, our extinction might come a lot sooner than it otherwise could have, and we'll have no one to blame but ourselves.
@jaeolsen-x1x
@jaeolsen-x1x Ай бұрын
@barrymoore4470 it's true that most species do become extinct. But I'm pretty sure only human do it to themselves and everything around it
@barrymoore4470
@barrymoore4470 Ай бұрын
@@jaeolsen-x1x Certainly, we're the only creatures who self-consciously destroy ourselves.
@kimwilson2295
@kimwilson2295 Ай бұрын
What if they won't listen to facts? Then you're screwed.
@ADude-f3z
@ADude-f3z Ай бұрын
Contempt, and disgust, and hatred… an unacknowledged admission of inability to resolve?
@bestdiver
@bestdiver 16 сағат бұрын
As much as I understand and agree on what Amanda Ripley makes us aware of I also see that big power and people not willing to change their dangerous habits in the face of a massive danger to our species has to be confronted with a “good vs evil”-comparison. After decades, yes decades of research and facts presented that our way of living IS endangering not only the future of a stabile situation of the planet but our own existence as a species I am not willing to accept power and habits that ignore this essential development.
@nathanngumi8467
@nathanngumi8467 Ай бұрын
Very insightful on conflict entrepreneurs, thanks!
@IfokSeen
@IfokSeen 28 күн бұрын
As a Beginner what do I have to do? How can I invest? On which platform? If you know any please share
@SarahJames-y4m
@SarahJames-y4m 28 күн бұрын
Please how can I make a profitable investment as crypto has become dominant?
@AngelinaAhmed-w2v
@AngelinaAhmed-w2v 28 күн бұрын
Waking up every 14th of each month to $210,000 it's a blessing to I and my family Big gratitude to Josefa
@NelsonMandela-w9p
@NelsonMandela-w9p 28 күн бұрын
Yeah, 253k from Josefa looking up to acquire a new house, blessings
@ElsieJohn-t2n
@ElsieJohn-t2n 28 күн бұрын
Who's this Josefa Guerrero?
@ElsieJohn-t2n
@ElsieJohn-t2n 28 күн бұрын
Can I start with as low as $1000?
@ivyparker5617
@ivyparker5617 Ай бұрын
Evil did win
@Apeiron242
@Apeiron242 Ай бұрын
Get your TDS checked.
@ivyparker5617
@ivyparker5617 Ай бұрын
@@Apeiron242 You're in a cult, call your dad
@breal7277
@breal7277 Ай бұрын
Evil (hatred) won the battle, good wins in the end.
@barrymoore4470
@barrymoore4470 Ай бұрын
@@breal7277 Let's hope so.
@zachsole8919
@zachsole8919 26 күн бұрын
TRUMP WON! 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@PaulWirsing
@PaulWirsing Ай бұрын
Curious how to scale this up beyond individual conversations...
@TorgerVedeler
@TorgerVedeler Ай бұрын
This is very wise. It’s also very hard to do. Hard, but hopefully not impossible.
@misterfunnybones
@misterfunnybones Ай бұрын
In politics we split the world into dumb & dumber...
@ChrisAnderson1986
@ChrisAnderson1986 Ай бұрын
The main reason why you see bad people in politics its because good people are not attracted to power and position. Most psychopaths and narcisists are attracted of those positions. So their values doesnt reflect prosperous behavior.
@CarrieV9
@CarrieV9 Ай бұрын
Except it is good vs evil. Just like during WW2.
@sharonhearne5014
@sharonhearne5014 Ай бұрын
My fundamentalist Christian siblings are so fundamental in their Biblical beliefs that there can be no core or flexible discussion: I consider this understandable but intractable. This is a wall that cannot be breached as to political voting or political understanding is concerned. Two things prior Trump just being elected were, for me, that democracy and The Constitution have been my key issues as an American and now even those appear to have been breached.
@TheresaReichley
@TheresaReichley Ай бұрын
I don’t think it’s just a loss of *intellectual* standards, though they’ve definitely fallen by quite a bit. A bigger issue is the complete absence of morality. Simple things like commitment to telling the truth even when it doesn’t help your side win, commitment to equality of worth, not lying, cheating, stealing, harming or wishing harm on other people. These things are critical. You can’t have Trust without first being trustworthy. You can’t make peace if the other side doesn’t have the right to exist and disagree. You can’t create a culture willing to share when everyone is cheating to get ahead.
@michaeldudley3756
@michaeldudley3756 Ай бұрын
so... pretend jan 6 never happened? wtf
@aaronmyers6686
@aaronmyers6686 Ай бұрын
and heeere weee gooo
@patrickfitzgerald2861
@patrickfitzgerald2861 Ай бұрын
Trump and Putin gratefully approve of this video.
@tourist9862
@tourist9862 Ай бұрын
@@aaronmyers6686 trump supporters are not evil or the enemy. I can think this while thinking that Harris is a slightly better choice for the future of our country.
@arxsyn
@arxsyn Ай бұрын
​@@tourist9862just slightly? 😮
@logancade342
@logancade342 Ай бұрын
The GOP could disavow Trump, put forward *any* other candidate, denounce Jan 6, and distance the party from the MAGA cult. They could do that. And then I could take their worldview seriously. Until that happens, as far as I'm able to be concerned, the American political system has one legitimate party. It's the Democratic party, and Republicans since 2016 have made it this way.
@Sam478y
@Sam478y Ай бұрын
You guys can still save it the people are the power
@jaynem9896
@jaynem9896 Ай бұрын
Oh, how silly of us! We could’ve just put our petty differences about kids in cages aside and REASONED with the fascists this whole time? Has anyone tried this life hack??? What were the results?
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
Kids weren't put in cages. They were separated starting with the Bush and Obama administrations because adults were trafficking kids with them. The Trump administration was separating kids so they could make sure they were actually with family. You don't keep kids with their abusers. Since that policy was abolished in 2021 over 360,000 kids have been victims of human trafficking. That's just KNOWN CASES. Is that more moral? This is why I voted for Trump despite being a Democrat. I actually looked into this topic. Please do the same.
@onwa._
@onwa._ Ай бұрын
She said nothing…
@micahgmiranda
@micahgmiranda Ай бұрын
Are you saying anything?
@jonathananonymouse7685
@jonathananonymouse7685 Ай бұрын
@@micahgmiranda Better to say nothiing in three words than in five minutes.
@micahgmiranda
@micahgmiranda Ай бұрын
@@jonathananonymouse7685 it's better to critique what is said than to undermine the character of everyone who disagrees with you.
@kelsealawrenson7188
@kelsealawrenson7188 Ай бұрын
Even in response to this incredibly nuanced, thoughtful message, it is very difficult to find nuanced, critical thinking. Instead, people gleefully partake of the hatred, disgust and contempt she warns against. These are indeed sad times, but not for the reasons most people stuck online will tell you.
@ashcatthedude
@ashcatthedude Ай бұрын
😒 Behold the banality of dichotomy.
@MikeD-tf7dk
@MikeD-tf7dk Ай бұрын
This isn’t like anything previous so tough to try and pidgeonhole
@Pj4ms
@Pj4ms Ай бұрын
The rise of social media, which was supposed to usher in more freedom, but instead sorted misinformation and conspiracy into vast asymmetrical pockets of the psychological landscape. This environment fosters a preference for populist leaders who offer simple solutions to complex issues, appealing to emotions rather than reason. Many Americans lack the capacity to engage meaningfully with democratic practices, leading to a potential erosion of democratic values. It's stone age hardware operating in a technological shitscape where it's not about hunting for food and surviving in a world with the constant threat of being eaten by dire wolves, cave bear, tigers, or 'other bipedal hominids'... Instead it's a new world where the struggles are internal and the emotional distractions are constant. The decline and eventual failure of democracy will be in large part attributed to the cognitive and emotional limitations of the populace. We're essentially all to blame because, even if you know that your reasoning is sharp and critical thinking is finely tuned, you still failed at helping your fellow Americans to understand the trap they are sliding into. You may believe that you're more skilled at regulating your emotional response, but the internal dialogue in your head is making you dizzy. It's not them, it's all of us. Well, except for the iterations of vainglorious oligarchy waiting to take command, & over the next 20 years demonstrate a new measure of dysfunctional American governance.
@ChadKovac
@ChadKovac Ай бұрын
It's team sports politics and it changes nothing..
@myradioon
@myradioon Ай бұрын
Nah, it's team Sports MORALS. That's the problem with this Cult. It's not about politics to them - it's about imposing their flawed morals (by any simple standards of decent morals) on the country. It definitely changed Roe vs. Wade and the woman's life who just died in TX trying to get pre-natal help. It also changed my life when the decent Party instituted the Affordable Care Act. Don't both sides it and reduce it to "politicians will be politicians". This is much worse now. Nobody would say the Naz*s were "just another political party".
@aidandorrian920
@aidandorrian920 Ай бұрын
"What kind of American are you?"
@OneOfEightBillion
@OneOfEightBillion Ай бұрын
Wish I never watched that movie, however Jesse Plemons was brilliant so it was worth watching.
@mpaczkow
@mpaczkow Ай бұрын
I think it is a high bar to convince someone who is a believer and if that belief is based on both deep seated biases supported by decades of confirmation. Good example is trying to convince someone that there is no god or there is a god. It is easy to say that all I need is to give you the facts, but for abstract qualities, there may not be any facts.
@TheSkystrider
@TheSkystrider Ай бұрын
Simplistic view that a country has to fire all nukes if they gonna fire one. I don't have the words to explain, but there are situations where tactical nukes could be used by Russia and allies have plans for how to retaliate - many many plans that dont involve responding with nukes. I've read that the US is positioned to hit where it really hurts if Russia uses a tactical nuke, that in theory would convince them to back down. Just not sure they would back down but by not responding with nukes, its not a good idea for Russia to keep using nukes.
@OneOfEightBillion
@OneOfEightBillion Ай бұрын
Sorry but it's now definitely good vs evil, right vs wrong...
@themeangene
@themeangene Ай бұрын
Then evil lost according to 51% of the country
@Heprit-w1x
@Heprit-w1x 23 күн бұрын
Yeah, that's why they lost the election. You can't run the election with hate as a medium
@jadedjaden3790
@jadedjaden3790 16 күн бұрын
@@themeangene did you watch this video?
@christopherbasham1551
@christopherbasham1551 Ай бұрын
What anxiety and uncertainty?
@jonathanhoward5663
@jonathanhoward5663 Ай бұрын
What does it matter? You may be a conservative, but if you vote for a reactionary candidate with extreme policies when they get into office they are going to implement those extreme policies. So sanesplain as much as you want, but my conservative friends really do think those ideas aren’t bad ideas. I live in a red state, so of course I have right leaning friends.
@lacusrengoku5087
@lacusrengoku5087 Ай бұрын
Amanda Ripley? For a moment, I thought it was the female protagonist of movie franchise "Alien" who just decided to make a comment on real world politics.
@harrypearle9781
@harrypearle9781 Ай бұрын
KAMALA HARRIS may help to bring US together, as our first WOMAN PRES. Yes, she can! Yes, we can, come together with DEMOCRACY ================================================== TNX
@snowflakemelter7171
@snowflakemelter7171 Ай бұрын
Trump 2024. Build the wall 🧱
@robertdouglas8895
@robertdouglas8895 Ай бұрын
It's not engagement that brings peace but forgiveness, metanoia, changing your mind. It's seeing everyone as innocent spirit instead of the guilty things bodies have done. Then you don't want to sacrifice them to justify yourself. "If you had known what these words mean, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the innocent.'
@gllty
@gllty Ай бұрын
im open to discussions if anyone wants to vent in the comments to me
@strangertimes44
@strangertimes44 Ай бұрын
Womp womp
@kimpreston3628
@kimpreston3628 Ай бұрын
Everyone in the USA should watch this video ❤ Thank you
@LouAlvis
@LouAlvis Ай бұрын
for decades i have kept connection with those that do not see the world the way I do.. I do so in hopes of learning from them? and maybe even showing them another way but fo this idea that all we have to do is tell them,, more truth have done this a LOT. "The thesis here,, when you tell them about their mistake.. has just been demonstrated NOT to be the case. ( november 6) Alas, they, even those that are friends from other views. see my alternate view as WRONG or even hostile. to try to correct misinformation? labels me as "the enemy". the facts were widely avaialble., but as Mr Twain says, A lie can get halfway around the world, before the truth gets it's pants on, Lying , for now, has Won. Dr RIpley? I Laud what you say, and wish it were so. but it is time we face an uncforable fact Hte ones with the biggest megaphones are the ones that dictate what truth is.
@kmscheid3303
@kmscheid3303 Ай бұрын
I'm sorry for what i said. This is a good message, just maybe not right now.
@CGMaat
@CGMaat Ай бұрын
Trump the candidate. - justice - not official duties
@LouiesEngalladoCoy
@LouiesEngalladoCoy Ай бұрын
Been there before..
@lilhacker3133
@lilhacker3133 Ай бұрын
Definitely a Democrat
@geoffworkman7994
@geoffworkman7994 Ай бұрын
Xoxo
@Sofia77991
@Sofia77991 28 күн бұрын
The entire critical thinking approach/rational thinking doesn't work anymore. The conclusion of these videos don't matter, it's the approach of these videos seem to stop working anymore.
@invox9490
@invox9490 Ай бұрын
This has to be a joke... A journalist talking about why we split the world into "good vs evil"!? Take a look in the mirror Amanda.
@annettealleva1553
@annettealleva1553 Ай бұрын
Please see posts from Dr. Bandy Lee MD
@4644-om
@4644-om Ай бұрын
me and my friends love hanging around watching your videos
@al1vel1keyou
@al1vel1keyou Ай бұрын
Oh please… the world is fucking evil.
@Apeiron242
@Apeiron242 Ай бұрын
Is something an evil person would say.
@al1vel1keyou
@al1vel1keyou Ай бұрын
@ Meh, you don’t know anything about me. But, maybe I should give the hate and division movement a try. It seems to be what the people want nowadays. Instead of creating this illusion that therapy and self improvement will actually make a difference. That ship has now sailed my friend. I am giving up on peace in Amerikkka. Screw this country. It’s time to do things differently. The USA, Russia, China and North Korea are all on the same team now and in complete control. THATS EVIL. Not me.
@voodaii
@voodaii Ай бұрын
@@Apeiron242 or an observant one...
@docjaramillo
@docjaramillo 21 күн бұрын
Both sides-ism drivel.
@tatyanaandrus14
@tatyanaandrus14 Ай бұрын
🌞♏🦅🫶🌟🗽
@MVW-g2i
@MVW-g2i Ай бұрын
TRUMP is back 🎉
@GrimFowler
@GrimFowler Ай бұрын
Wow, an unbiased discussion involving the 2024 election? Whatttt Have compassion for those opposing me? Jesus and Buddah would approve of this handling.
@JimmyMatis-h9y
@JimmyMatis-h9y 26 күн бұрын
Their manspreading offends me.
@kristianprigl7895
@kristianprigl7895 Ай бұрын
You are right. But you are explaing complex things in 4 minutes. You dont make a service to this problematic
@galacticunderground1
@galacticunderground1 Ай бұрын
***Good Ole Crowd Control*** Let's chill n be real people, cause we dumb and we're overreacting.
@SoloJetMan
@SoloJetMan Ай бұрын
we're a fractured country - society
@Divchyk
@Divchyk 26 күн бұрын
Poor selection of color: speaker's clothing and the chair she is sitting on is surprising and sad. This particular video would be better as a podcast (no video)
@baronvandedem3997
@baronvandedem3997 Ай бұрын
You Americans are so funny. As a European I’m laughing my balls off. just vote Trump, to be absolutely honest and fair, he’s by far your best option.
@carlosdominguez3108
@carlosdominguez3108 Ай бұрын
Exactly. But you don't understand how well oiled the mainstream media propaganda machine is. They're very good at what they do. To the point where people will vote for candidates that will make their lives objectively worse because the orange man tweets mean stuff.
@Timidor23
@Timidor23 Ай бұрын
No, Trump's literally ranked our worst president. He doesn't understand our country's values at all. This will be a slow catastrophe.
@barrymoore4470
@barrymoore4470 Ай бұрын
You as a European should know better.
@baronvandedem3997
@baronvandedem3997 Ай бұрын
@ please explain. Most of us Europeans don’t give a shit about the Ukraine, we had a great relation with Russia and we Dutch even voted against Ukraine joining us in the first place. The Ukraine holds absolutely no strategic or economic value to us. Furthermore, we’re also running to the right. Migration is a very big problem and our housing and economic situation isn’t in the great shape either. We don’t need woke or environmental bullshit, we need action. Damn, the UK is even becoming the first Islamic nuclear power in the world. Civil war is around the corner only because the left let it all happen with their good intentions politics. Well newsflash, the world doesn’t work that way. I’m glad you guys voted Trump so our leaders will finally wake up and realize they need to act in the peoples interest and not their own. And be honest, Kamala would’ve been an absolute disaster. They’re lying about the 2020 elections (20 million votes just don’t go up in smoke). You’d be stuck with Pelosi and the rest of the democratic establishment who’re only filling their own pockets. (There’re plenty of examples). They didn’t open the border because they felt sorry for those people, they only wanted cheap labor. Trump on the other hand runs the country as a business. And he speaks will all leaders around the world. Communication is important, something the democrats don’t know a fucking thing about. (Just look how they lost the election 🤣).
@LouisRichard-ri4mu
@LouisRichard-ri4mu Ай бұрын
@LouisRichard-ri4mu
@LouisRichard-ri4mu Ай бұрын
The first step to successful investment is figuring your goals and risk tolerance either on your own or with the help of a financial professional but it's very advisable you make use of professional.
@AndreasPoland-rm4zv
@AndreasPoland-rm4zv Ай бұрын
You just mentioned Expert Mary, Indeed, wow that woman has been an incredible mentor to me, imparting a deep understanding of the economy that I wish college had provided.
@AndreasPoland-rm4zv
@AndreasPoland-rm4zv Ай бұрын
I know Mary, she has really set the standard for others to follow, we love her here in the UK as she has been really helpful and changed lots of lives.
@LouisSmith-wt9vh
@LouisSmith-wt9vh Ай бұрын
Interesting! But I'm new here. How can I get to this person's guidelines??
@WillPerry-b7r
@WillPerry-b7r Ай бұрын
She mostly interacts on Telegrams, using the user-name,
@MullerNita76
@MullerNita76 Ай бұрын
@MullerNita76
@MullerNita76 Ай бұрын
The first step to successful investment is figuring your goals and risk tolerance either on your own or with the help of a financial professional but it's very advisable you make use of professional.
@WillPerry-b7r
@WillPerry-b7r Ай бұрын
Now, I Just realized that the secret to making a million is saving for better trades. I always tell myself you don't need that new Maserati or that vacation just yet. That mindset helped me make more money trading.. I Traded with 10k in Crypto and made about $146k,but guess what? I put it all back and traded again and now I am rounding up close to a million
@WillPerry-b7r
@WillPerry-b7r Ай бұрын
I know Mary, she has really set the standard for others to follow, we love her here in the UK as she has been really helpful and changed lots of lives.
@MuchParrill
@MuchParrill Ай бұрын
Your explanations are clear and straight forward It's always a honor to have you here as a mentor, I appreciate you for the time being spent to educate us financially. Regardless of how bad it gets the economy, I still makeover $28K every single week. I truly value Mary, and her helpful guides.
@MuchParrill
@MuchParrill Ай бұрын
She's the best honestly I'm also a beneficiary. This inflation has taught people the importance of multiples income investment
Who will you become during a crisis? | Amanda Ripley
9:27
Big Think
Рет қаралды 241 М.
The disappearance of men | Christine Emba
11:13
Big Think
Рет қаралды 526 М.
How many people are in the changing room? #devil #lilith #funny #shorts
00:39
Slavoj Žižek meets Yanis Varoufakis (Part 1)
21:33
How To Academy
Рет қаралды 154 М.
Jon Stewart On What Went Wrong For Democrats | The Daily Show
14:45
The Daily Show
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
The REAL Reason MEN VOTED for TRUMP… | Scott Galloway
8:47
The Diary Of A CEO Clips
Рет қаралды 792 М.
Psychologist debunks 8 myths of mass scale | Todd Rose
31:45
Big Think
Рет қаралды 1,9 МЛН
Why meritocracy is a LIE... (it's way worse than people realize)
17:49
The Market Exit
Рет қаралды 491 М.
Why You Will Marry the Wrong Person
22:20
The School of Life
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН
The Tipping Point I Got Wrong | Malcolm Gladwell | TED
16:45