The Phantom Coach

[@teaoftraffic]

I’m glad we get to see a more softer side of Duncan here. He did gladly accept Agatha’s offer, even if he didn’t know it was a ghost. Plus, him just saying “That poor coach…” after hearing the full story is just… wow. We need more Duncan stories where he’s not plain speakin’.

[@sirrliv]

A fantastic story. I was rather surprised when Duncan agreed to help Agatha so quickly after moaning about being delayed getting back to the shed; I almost expected him to refuse and for Agatha to haunt him. But since the Works was on Duncan's way anyway, it did no harm to take her along. I'd love to see a sequel of Duncan determined to get Agatha home, working hard to ensure the mountain line is in perfect condition even as the workmen don't believe him, then maybe taking Agatha cab first to keep an eye on her and stop if she starts to vanish; "Oh no ye don't! We're getting your passengers home no matter what."

[@ciarangleeson2880]

Alternatively, he could push her from behind.

[@BrentSudric]

Could risk pushing her off the cliff again, with both him and his crew unable to see the line ahead@@ciarangleeson2880

[@jamiebullock2023]

Another chilling but fascinating video. I see how you made Duncan’s character from a grumpy old man at the start to realising what something he found later would turn out not to with them. Smudger does quite wonders with his narration.

[@andrewscolari5724]

Nice to see Duncan being helpful and kind. And wanting to help Agatha especially after learning she was a ghost

[@belindamolina6140]

Cool

[@comicfan1324]

She’s truly dedicated to her work.

[@thinaphonpetsiri9907]

This one is rather sad, just a story of poor lost wandering souls. It's also nice to see usually grumpy Duncan get an emphatic moments like at the end of video.

[@amitysluzara2022]

Great story! It was nice seeing a ghost not wanting revenge but, rather get her workmen home. Could Agatha possibly make the connection if they went a different way?

[@JosephRailwayStudios2000]

I like seeing stories where Duncan would’ve actually matured as a character

[@EnticinglyDeadly]

A very touching ghost story. It’s like a narrow gauge version of your story The Banker.

[@articusramos808]

The even small twist that Henry was pulling mail.

[@flippydafox3313]

Sir toppem just casually dropping an F bomb😂

[@Bulbasaur617]

Woah what an spooky and sad story here. Nice to see Duncan's softer side here. Shows that he can be nice instead of just being his usual Scottish complaining self. Plus it's a nice change of pace here. I like how this story went. A fantastic job on this story. Keep up the great work!

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Crumbs... What a story... Poor Agatha...😧 Great work by the way!👍

[@milkythomas9029]

Waking up to a new video is so cool!

[@Tnpt_studios]

Neat concept, GREAT execution!

[@sodormanstudios]

Wow! Amazing Story quite chilling.

[@DarthWill3]

As if that tale about the ghost on the Old Iron Bridge wasn't spooky enough, Duncan has to endure something haunting as well as sad.

[@trevortyrrell175]

Great story as always.

[@brianfalzon6739]

Another chilling tale well done!

[@Somerandompokemon]

Agatha… may she rest in peace

[@scotty87able]

Very Good follow up to the 13th van

[@LightningTheLMS3FJinty2020]

Cool Video. Also Poor Agitha

[@ciarangleeson2880]

Okay, I have a few questions. 1. If Skarloey remembers Agatha, does Rheneas remember her, too? Or the other coaches? 2. Was Agatha used on passenger trains, privately owned by the quarry, or what? 3. How come John appears in the flashback. I thought he was a Mid-Sodor engine.

[@TroublesomeSlateTruck]

Good Job.

[@IslandofSodorStudios]

Genius

[@adamtain7627]

At 2:22 I remember that music from older movie trailers but I still don’t know what it’s called

[@jessielorah7616]

How about the extended railway series like Stanley, Jim the jinx and closure?

[@ciarangleeson2880]

And Albert?

[@jessielorah7616]

@@ciarangleeson2880 we already see albert in 2 year ago from TheGermanofSodor

[@GWRChurchwardStarProduction]

Awesome

[@pendremacherald6758]

Ah yes, Agatha from Indigo.

[@fishpop]

Why do some of Duncan's faces have a V on his forehead?

[@h.s.ch-98k79]

4:02~5:15 Can you tell me what this music is? I think this music will captivate me.

[@ryleeculla5570]

Wouldn’t that mean the Skarloey railway use to have 5 coaches

[@jacobganttbudokai]

where's sir handel and duke?

[@Toysonicandfriends2]

Duncan second ghost meeting

[@kohkiLightning]

duncan's head lump is biggest.

[@paramount3603]

Why is he still doing these ghostly Thomas stories

[@SteamLance]

Its a good story, but there are some words the narrators says that I can't understand.

[@atomicreptiliascreator738]

I enjoyed the video, but I DON’T enjoy the ending of it!

[@TOPGLOGAN2.0YT]

WOW THIS STORY MADE MY ARM HAIRS STICK UP !