Where The Bad Engines Go

[@theforgottenengine]

This was amazing! Great job as always daylight!

[@ashhaep82]

Man, that sure was a creepy story. Seeing those engines and their disfigured faces was really haunting. They all looked like something out of Sodor fallout. I would think something like this wouldn't happen in a world of non-faceless steam engines, but given the amount of cruel and barbaric practices inflicted by humans onto other humans, something like this is definitely in the realm of possibility, which is absolutely terrifying. Great video as always, can't wait for the next one.

[@5edI]

"good engines don’t lie, good engines don’t lie!"

[@Iloveminceraft]

We saw Toby in the background of episode 4 sleeping after he was shunted in to the scrap line

[@5edI]

01101110 01101111

[@Rainbow2997]

​@@5edIDid you realize something about Gordon in a scrap look in "The Ffarquhar Siren?" Gordon was a 4-6-0 locomotive. In his original look, he's a 4-6-2 Pacific. Would that mean it's a different locomotive they found?

[@roxaclock]

@@Rainbow2997 no, that would just mean the trailing bogey was lost at some point, still Deceived Gordon

[@lukechristmas3951]

@@5edI Since you guys are discussing Forest Horrors, I've been thinking on what lady does with the crews of the engines she takes. My theory is that she turns them into trucks. "The Ffarquhar Siren" revealed she did that with that crazed Fred guy.

[@RANDOM_MAN6]

My face after the teacher turns on the lights without telling us: 9:38

[@dimpledch33ks]

Lol

[@nerdboy4555]

Even with a melted face, yellow bad engine can still speak, literal shivers

[@FriskDreemurrOfBiggCityPort]

Why was it giving Gaster vibes?

[@lukechristmas3951]

Somehow I was hoping this would be another installment of the Forest Horrors series but the eeriness of this one did not disappoint. I am impressed by the scenes of the young narrator in the house with his grandfather as the narration really sells the the imagination of that scene. A rainy day turning into a sunny day all the while the grandfather tells a very dark story.

[@someguy9293]

It's probably not, but I think the theme ties into the Forest Horrors.

[@hypergamingnow5719]

It's amazing how much the music makes the atmosphere in the Intro it really makes this possibly upbeat the first 2 minitues eirie

[@engineerskalinera]

Wow, what timing! Might not be a Forest Horror but this still looks to be awesome

[@rodimussupreme2329]

Unless he works it in.

[@AIB2K8]

I’ll never forget the horrors in the shed. I thought that scrapping an engine would be the worst possible fate, even if it were for a bad engine, but this…… This was torture……. Not even Sir Topham would go through with this……. I could only hope, that one day, those memories, would fade from existence, without a trace…..

[@Sudriantank743]

Topham wouldn't do scrapping

[@amtrakpepsiproduct1605]

Man, this is such a fantastic creepypasta. It's such a unique take on one. Instead of it just being another "lost episode" or something, it actually takes place in the Thomas universe. Bravo, dude!

[@Bulbasaur617]

A well done adaptation to this story. I like how this went. Interesting to see in a sort of realistic or RWS standpoint where we see the very bad hearted engies go to. And it's a fate much worse then scrap in a way. And this is why the engines always be good and apologize for their actions. Sure there's bad engines in the RWS/T&F too, but at least some were given a chance to be good. Or at least don't go to extreme lengths like what happened to Robert's twin, Ken, here. A fantastic job on adapting this. It's been awhile since we've seen you adapted something since you're working on your own T&F/RWS series here. Keep up the great work and take care!

[@Xx_Its_Oli_xX]

Proteus’s face at 11:33 is nightmare fuel lmao Also, isn’t that the same face (or something similar) he made in “The Ffarquhar Siren?”

[@roxaclock]

not the same face but it’s the same model

[@armaniajoseph8668]

I think that’s gaster

[@Dmays-wd2zt]

Yeah, I'm pretty sure they took inspiration (or just completely stole) from Gaster's face from Undertale for the scene.​@@armaniajoseph8668

[@OrangeConeMan]

WD GASTER? WHATS HE DOING HERE

[@josiah3203]

@@OrangeConeMan he is scattered across all time and space so... well I neednt gossip, afterall... it's rude to talk about someone who's listening.....

[@thanatos7361]

make a sequel to this video only the shed is abandoned and forgotten and someone comes to explore and see what's still in the shed and the rest is up to you

[@J.Tstudioproduction6375]

I’ve seen the audio story, despite being a bit dark, it was a good story to tell during the mont of Halloween, I’ve also seen a few adaptations, such as the one made by one of my friends Brandon, I’ve never expected to see an adaptation made by you. I’ll admit, you did a nice job on some of the good animation on some of the scenes along with the use of TRS19. Anyway, nice job on the video daylight. 👍

[@hanz_mannerich1645]

I am the 1k like, you're truthly a nostalgic-alike piece of gem for the last couple of years pal! Keep going!

[@RogueRail]

This took fates worse than death to a whole new level.

[@EmperorJack1000]

Big time

[@Serial__DesginationN]

This was just amazing. The set up, the scenery. The theme and build up. Is incredible. Good job. If I could recommend a story If you don’t mind, is a story called *”A Scrap Engine’s Torture”* it’s a story with a similar set up and theme to this one but it’s just as good. :)

[@loganbloom6191]

By God, so Alfred wasn't truely scrapped, and hell on earth does exist in there world. I hope one day redemption finds them if only in time

[@gothnerd887]

Either that or someone's going to get their hands on some souls, they're very valuable, you know

[@loganbloom6191]

@@gothnerd887 depends on the soul honestly

[@zerosen1972]

There is no redemption for these souls. That's why it's hell. Unforgivable crimes earn you an unimaginable sentence - no matter how sorry you are.

[@loganbloom6191]

@@zerosen1972 their not dead. Only being punished as test subjects

[@sodormanstudios]

Wow! Another Outstanding Adaptation! Great Work Daylight!

[@NorthWestern1919]

Very great adaptation! I'll admit this is actually the first time I had heard this story. I've been reading the FNAF "Tales From the Pizzaplex" books lately to catch up on that series' lore, and this story honestly feels like a RWS/Thomas take on the kind of twisted story that you'd expect to find in a "Fazbear Frights" or "Tales From the Pizzaplex" books. Especially the detail about the black liquid coming out of the eyes; in the "Fazbear Frights" books, that's a sign that something has been infected by agony. Makes you imagine... what if non-faceless engines existed in the world of FNAF? With the crazy plots of some of these official FNAF stories, that honestly wouldn't feel too far fetched.

[@gtcreations7666]

Daylight once again, delivering nothing but GOLD! Solid shiny valuable GOLD. Great work man.

[@autotechxbox163]

Maybe this could be incorporated into your series later on. I don't know how you plan to end your series but, if you plan to end it on a good note with Sodor ridding itself of the curse, maybe Lady could be sent their to suffer a slow, agonizing, ruthless, and painful death for all the carnage that she's caused on Sodor.

[@gothnerd887]

Sounds like they need a priest or an Onmyoji

[@zakthemrconductor5920]

Outstanding Performance 😃👍

[@LadyChandraoftheMoone]

Ooohh I’ve heard of this story, can’t wait to see.

[@RandomTrinidadian]

This is definately right up there with "The Wandering Coach" as one of my fave creepy stories

[@1ne1housand]

I love this story

[@Rainbow2997]

At 10:30 You can see on the left of the screen, James and Lady are in there.

[@Kia76210]

R.I.P KEN WE LOST A GOOD ONE

[@malamutehunter]

That was wonderfully terrible! I felt the chills and terror! So good!

[@SpaceDetectiveTravis]

Oh i remember this story. Never thought itd get an adaption. Great job as always! ^^

[@noname-iw3tj]

I liked this story wonder how your adaption will be

[@Trainboy11]

Nice work I can’t wait

[@amitysluzara2022]

Incredible adaptation! This was so much darker than I thought, I expected this to be a story aboyt scrap 0-0

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Excellent work!

[@xXLiamsTrainsXx]

This is one of my favorite spooky Thomas stories

[@Tailsdude22]

I'm very glad this popped up when watching similar stuff. Chilled and Also subscribed now.

[@Korusdatoaster]

Old story retold? Awesome 👌

[@Somebody99999]

That shed, is a fate worse than death. I wouldn’t even put my most hated enemies into that shed.

[@carlosdiner729]

Love how "Eyeless Arthur" from the episode Steady Eddie is used for one of the mutilated bad engines!

[@angelhuerta1626]

Your videos are awesome

[@retrorobbyreviews]

Great job with this horror story. Those bad engines have a fate worse than scrap.

[@aguy17]

The engines wasting away are creepy, but I think the kid’s face might be the most unsettling thing in the whole video.

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

If I make a TTTE horror audio and it's good, would you adapt it too? I have no way of making this myself and seing an own idea picked up by someone would be my biggest dream.❤ ~Lexie

[@daylight39]

@@ALCO-C855-fan maybe. I guess it depends because I only have so much free time at my disposal and I really only adapt the really good ones now. I’d make an audio story first and post it youtube. That way if I don’t adapt it, someone else might.

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

@@daylight39 That was my plan anyway.😁 I still prey you'd be the one who makes it cuz I favor your stuff🥺 and some other guys don't like me. I simply feel the most comfortable here.😍

[@king_son1118]

11:06 how is the killdane expiriment a bad engine?

[@williamPeaslee]

Where did the Proteus model come from? The engine at 9:56.

[@toyotaprius79]

Now that gave me chills bravo! 👏

[@grantpool]

Thank you daylight 3 for another masterpiece but I have a suggestion could you make a sort backed on schedule engines where Thomas and 2 other engines go to the iron works to do work but then they encounter the taken

[@mikestudioz216]

9:38 Damn! I think the visuals really emphasized my subpar narration

[@gothnerd887]

Don't be so modest, you were great👍

[@noname-iw3tj]

Didnt have wifi and just watched this this is AMAZING

[@Axel-mz2wh]

"Good engines don't lie.., GOOD ENGINES DON'T LIE, *𝐆𝐎𝐎𝐃 𝐄𝐍𝐆𝐈𝐍𝐄𝐒 𝐃𝐎𝐍'𝐓 𝐋𝐈𝐄"*

[@tropicalties3806]

We need more videos about these bad engines.

[@Christopherbellfan203]

I was hoping this story would get more attention!

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

I saw an airship in 1 shot. British R101?

[@justine23ds62]

The perfect episode for Halloween

[@williamscheuerman1867]

Watched this at 3 in the morning, bad idea. But fantastically scary story. Though I wish you did the news at the end of your videos related to the incidents like before. Thanks again for your work

[@J4CK50N.]

Oh. Not Arthur too! He had a spotless record.

[@RedNosedLugia]

Me: yo pass the aux cord Friend: you better not play trash *GOOD ENGINES DON'T LIE*

[@TheGreatNateVA]

So if these engines are not scrapped, do they just go insane while they rust to death?

[@8-BallBlues]

Interesting to see the Angel make an appearance here.

[@noorayneladha470]

Geez that was disturbing oh horrors!!!! 😮😳😨

[@maurocarrerafernandez770]

Well at least this story has subtitles, they were automatically generated so at times they were confusing to understand but I understood the story It is a very dark, scary and creepy story about what they do to bad engines, I felt very scared and if I'm not wrong, the men who had briefcases and approached Robert I suppose they took parts of him which is terrifying but in part satisfactory since Robert was very evil just like the other 30 trains, those designs of the 30 trains are too scary and creppy, I wouldn't like to be there at that moment and even more so hearing that phrase "good engines don't lie" (If you ask how I can speak in English it is because I use the translator)

[@della1923]

Ok I think I won’t be able to sleep for a few days now after that and I have more respect for the old steam engines 😳😰🙏🏻

[@5edI]

11 more minutes yay, i waited for hours!

[@lieffian]

Shed17 vibes anyone? On a side note, this should have a part 2 where he finds the shed

[@harrygrant6805]

100% agree

[@tmwarthunder1016]

Yeah The Shed

[@harrygrant6805]

@@tmwarthunder1016 yeah and he explains that there to rot but he can help them turn there lifes around and for the good it should have a turn of events to make it change from a horror totoure to a good endning

[@harrygrant6805]

100% agree shows what they went through

[@BellaZuikaku4785]

That good engines don’t lie, reminds me of that vine “ Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room…”

[@Trainboy11]

That was scary and terrifying

[@8The_Train]

Good engines don't lie

[@mikestudioz216]

Correction: I narrated this, not TFE

[@daylight39]

Oh, sorry. I had no idea. I will credit you in the description when I have the time.

[@mikestudioz216]

@@daylight39 It’s fine

[@paramount3603]

@@daylight39 WHO WOULD MAKE A DEATLY STORY LIKE THIS ?

[@theforgottenengine]

Me lmao@@paramount3603

[@smilyboi9847]

@@paramount3603Mmmmm I don’t know. 22Tesla maybe? 😏

[@maxlivert1745]

8:03 engine on the right be like gas gas gas😂😂💀💀💀

[@smilyboi9847]

Wheelslip has left the chat!

[@jamesthomas5109]

Hope we see more of Robert, Ken amd the other wartime engines in future. 😊

[@LNER-H-Class]

Percy has right about another railway

[@commandofoxygaming45]

Hey I have a good idea for a video You should make the autobots from transformers meet Thomas (Like in smudger and the magic mirror)

[@ryleeculla5570]

Who wouldn’t like trains at a young age they are just so interesting and cool looking

[@iki492]

why there is a blimp sighting

[@TheDman131]

I wonder if this story is related or unrelated to the ongoing story of the engines going missing on sodor? So far I haven't seen a clear connection to it but who knows...

[@Tnpt_studios]

Proteus was a bad engine!? Who would've known. This is an interesting story.

[@smilyboi9847]

I don’t think it was proteus, I think he just used his model to represent another engine like him. But all being said maybe he was actually dark...

[@TimTheWellTank]

Proteus died another way

[@EvexiansVideoworks]

Oh this looks so good!

[@harrygrant6805]

Id love for there to be a part 2 to this alone its got me on my seat what happenes to Robert it would be good to see what happens to them please please do more like this

[@AliasTaurusVectron1212Liam]

Im inpressed look at the image picture !!!! ❤❤❤❤❤ pure smelters yard . !! Keep going like this . Like + sub . 🎉🎉🎉 😊😊😊😊😊

[@josephjones8177]

11:05 the killDane experiment made an appearance

[@smilyboi9847]

and Dudley at 10:39

[@loganbloom6191]

I just thought of a question for you daylights 3 if Henry's forest part of the forest horror series then could that be why he hasn't been taken yet Or is he going the be taken soon in an unforseen way? And could lady just kill warship with her power why is she so scared of him if she has magic

[@FictionalADDON]

I think this is inspiring by “That’s where the bad kids go.” A rather obscure creepypasta but a bit memorable.

[@gulaschkarauski1384]

The Gmod assets are cursed but well included

[@lemmyspeaks]

Who died? But seriously good job I love dark thomas videos

[@Iloveminceraft]

When is the next forest horror coming out

[@daylight39]

I don’t know

[@SouthernFlyer1011]

I've never heard this story,it was pretty heavy to say the least Good engines don't lie...

[@CrazyThomasFan]

9:57 Oooh is that Gasters face form Undertale i see???? But Bravo. This one gave me real chills. Those engines probably deserved it

[@rkwatchingyt2097]

Is this continuation of the series or a remake?

[@daylight39]

It’s an adaptation.

[@petersylvester6991]

@@daylight39 first James and the new engine and now Where the bad engines go I wonder what if happen next after this I mean the missing 411 through devious disappearances after 10-2 months went all of this has to stop this madness 6:51

[@pugtrainmaster5326]

If I may can I make a suggestion Daylight before the final have the NRM buy Flying Scotsman for the nation but have it be a underhand deal to protect the famous A3 from danger and have him be replaced by a new engine

[@chavopatyfanstudios2005]

Will mr conductor appear

[@austincharbonneau1206]

Wow what a story 10/10

[@TheOrangeTractorOffical]

Is this an episode of forest horrors?

[@daylight39]

No

[@TheOrangeTractorOffical]

@@daylight39if you don’t mind me asking when is the next episode and how many more till the finale? I really loved your last episode of james btw

[@daylight39]

@@TheOrangeTractorOffical thank you, but I don’t know when the next episode will be finished, but if all goes to plan, there should be three left.

[@bearmanpig1130]

​@@daylight39WAIT FOR REAL!?!?! DUDE THATS GOT ME SOOO HYPED UP!

[@sos0421]

So Thomas and Diesel 10 Will Team Up to Fight Lady in Final Episode?

[@Bluemaxs]

Robert’s scream was personal O_O

[@BumberenzoThePumperTruck]

11:51 Holy shoot! What are they? Are they supposed to be military medics or scrapyard workers?

[@someguy9293]

It's creepy but, in a way, deserved. Robert was very evil. He thought he could kill his brother and get away with it. But he got what he deserves in the end. To rot way and be forgotten. I imagine that the man with the brief cases we're coming to collect his parts as spares for other war time engines. This is how I imagine a close hell for trains in Thomas's universe.

[@vincenta.ferrervincekun2007]

I guess that place... that place is truly a place... where the bad engines go...

[@VicarstownFilmProductions]

i love it.

[@Jetthehawk1994]

Anyone else notice a BR engine when Robert's manager sends him away?

[@EngineerRiff]

Thomas and friends is now canonically tied to Team Fortress 2

[@Froggyman145]

To think that building is probably abandoned now And he's still there...