The Political Economy of Higher Education in Pakistan I Pervaiz Hoodbhoy at PIDE Seminar

We (Pakistanis) are very intelligent & talented but our Youth is not heading in the right direction, We have to realize what is actually wrong with our Education system, institutions & universities - Prof. Pervaiz Hoodbhoy
Complete Seminar: • The Political economy ...
#HigherEducation #Education #Politics #PoliticalEconomy #Seminar #Pakistan #PervaizHoodbhoy #TheBlackHole #Youth #Future #technology
For Further Details Please Visit:
www.pide.org.pk
/ pideofficial
/ pidepk
/ pideislamabad
/ pidepk
/ pidepk

[@amitnair1235]

Very good! Unbiased assessment!

[@scrappy__coco]

Bogus Ideas discussed here. The only reason pakistan is in this condition because we dont teach our children Quran enough. Only Quran can bring all the goods and wellness to our country. He is dumb he never read quran. Quran have answer to all the things. Teach your children to study quran and insallha we will be rich after some days. Alhumdullila.

[@ratangangopadhyaygangopadh9826]

Muslims of no less than 60 Crores in a country would have become a threat to humanism

[@bharathvansh5127]

@PIDE OFFICIAL, I cant understand how the holy mullah and moulvi are tolerating this kafeer speech, This fellow is speaking against the aasmani kitab. This fellow should be sent to madrasaa, instead indulging in eeshalamichasation, he is speaking against the holy book, World is flat and sun rotates around it. But he is outrightly claiming these falls. Paki is now becoming a kaffeer land. Dont know how these kaffeers are tolerated.

[@lordabhikingfisher8087]

when I was a student in US (from India), I was shocked to experience Pak students were always discussing how to take illegal jobs and apply for asylum while Indian kids were busy figuring out scholarships. Most of the Pak students worked in Gas (petrol pumps) stations while Indian kids got campus jobs under good professors who eventually helped them to land lucrative jobs after graduation. I got my job offer 6 months before graduation while my Pakistani friends went missing (when underground to avoid being detected by immigration). Something is wrong with Pakistan culture. Pakistanis take pride in cheating the system. But in the end system cheats them of opportunities. Pakistani students have hard time getting A grade. Mostly C. They take pride in C grade and suffer from inferiority complex. One more trait that I see is, most of them introduce themselves as desi. Never as Pakistani. They are ashamed of their country and culture.

[@faisalrazzaq6002]

Due to Poor family back ground they do such jobs , just to survive.

[@khittaykachoudhary2360]

They're leaders and elite are cheaters. Their parents are cheaters So naturally the children also become cheaters

[@umai2110]

Bro its the opposite it in Canada. Waterloo. all the labour jobs and amazon delivery jobs are Indians. This mostly happened after covid.

[@lordabhikingfisher8087]

@@umai2110 These are not Master's degree students who jumped off universities to escape deportation. They are labors working as labors. Can't you read what I stated? God help Pakistanis.

[@lordabhikingfisher8087]

@@yasarmehmood4055 Why? First thing you need to learn is accept the reality. Only then change will come. Don't fight the truth. No Pakistanis are CEO any large multinational firms. Why do you think that is the case? Not hate - just reality.

[@amoldurve1295]

Pak's 'Cutting Edge' Technology : Sar Tan Say Juda !!!

[@skagraw2]

👏 👏 👏 👏

[@sureshshukla87]

Teach more islam which contains all the science and knowledge of the universe. No other education required. Period!

[@Mkay1808]

Dr Hoodboy, lots of respect to you. May I add thing more about our charcter matters. TRUTHFULNESS IS SOMETHING THAT EVERYONE MUST CHERISH TO BE A GOOD HUMAN. WE CAN'T LIE , OTHERWISE WE ARE DOOMED

[@bharathvansh5127]

@PIDE OFFICIAL, I cant understand how the holy mullah and moulvi are tolerating this kafeer speech, This fellow is speaking against the aasmani kitab. This fellow should be sent to madrasaa, instead indulging in eeshalamichasation, he is speaking against the holy book, World is flat and sun rotates around it. But he is outrightly claiming these falls. Paki is now becoming a kaffeer land. Dont know how these kaffeers are tolerated.

[@ABCD-cw3fs]

Your Book 📚 is only to be memorized.. Not to question

[@BeyondBorders2020]

So much respect for this man. Had he been in India, he would have made great accomplishments in research for India. I feel so sorry that he has been carrying the frustration in his heart for so long and will end with it. I don't know why IIT did not offer him any prestigious post. I know he was called in India for lectures. Not just in India but also in Europe and the US he is well known. I wonder why he stayed in Pakistan?

[@shankarghose1357]

Because Dr. Hoodbhoy wanted to serve his motherland Pakistan, to educate students modern science. But in Pakistan, nobody wants to get real educated. His bosses in Jinnah University even blocked his efforts for purely scientific education, without the influence of Islam. Pakistan Govt. did not extend his tenure post retirement. What a pity. Such a gem like him got wasted by the radical society..

[@sandeepnerurkar4918]

He is trying to change atttitude, culture and ecosystem of Pakistan.

[@yogendras04sm]

This man seems to be really wise and sensible. Pakistan needs such educationalist

[@appupappu6412]

The height of his wisdom can be found where he says his car mechanic can run the car on water 😂😂😂 if that was true then why doesn’t that mechanic make other cars run on water as well ??!! Ok his guy is just a wise fool among ram fools

[@aminaabdulla5854]

He is still a typical islamist talks on Hinduism on just a like any common Pakistani on the street. CHeck some of his talks on Black Hole channes. Peacefuls are piecefuls they will not change.

[@AmjadKhan-py6bo]

Houdbhoy is very clear supporter of the western DAJJALIC society, that means an open opponent to The Quran. kzbin.info/www/bejne/faCThnape5yWlbc Astro-Eschatology channel. By Muhammad Amjad.

[@rajibdhar3148]

Dr.pervez is the academic icon of pakistan, great personality ,but nation like pakistan could not recognise this great personality

[@Rosemoon938]

Dr. Hoodbhoy's views are greatly appreciated. He rightly innumerates several high services exports from Indian industries. However he forgot to highlight one of the most important exports from India, the Space Technology. India earns millions of dollars per anum launching sattelites in space for several countries each year from Sri Hari Kota in Andhra Pradesh.

[@bharathvansh5127]

@PIDE OFFICIAL, I cant understand how the holy mullah and moulvi are tolerating this kafeer speech, This fellow is speaking against the aasmani kitab. This fellow should be sent to madrasaa, instead indulging in eeshalamichasation, he is speaking against the holy book, World is flat and sun rotates around it. But he is outrightly claiming these falls. Paki is now becoming a kaffeer land. Dont know how these kaffeers are tolerated.

[@gulzaman532]

Prevaiz hoodbhoy-A man with eyes and a humble heart.

[@Dr.ArbazRahmann]

Fantastic discussion by Dr. Pervez Hoodhboy

[@quddusquddus136]

How a mind of a Muslim that has been in a state of idleness for centuries could show a capacity to think? Women, half-covered, sit faceless listening to facts impossible to bear. Are they thinking? Their idleness led to the great Holocaust of 1947 in India. The same idleness of the Muslims led to the Genocide in Bengal in 1971. In both disasters, the religious scruples remained constant. How to save Muslims from themselves in a polity of Muslims remains an enigma?

[@ViewsNewsChannel]

We are glad to see Prof Pervez Hoodbhoy, Professor Ishtiaq Ahmed, and many others criticizing the Two-Nation Theory, questioning the partition of India, and exposing Jinnah. In India, intellectuals and professors are also lambasting Gandhi. However, the credit for initiating this discourse goes to author Nasim Yousaf. He was the first writer to expose Jinnah and Gandhi's dirty politics in his two separate books on Allama Mashriqi and Jinnah (published in 2007) and Allama Mashriqi and Gandhi (published in 2013). He criticized Jinnah and Gandhi’s politics, the partition of India, and the Two-Nation Theory long before professors, intellectuals, and the public started to question them. There was a time when Jinnah and Gandhi were heroes, but the situation has fast changed, and people with political acumen do not consider them heroes, rather tools in the hands of the British. According to author Nasim Yousaf, "It has been established that Jinnah and Gandhi helped the British in partitioning India. Moreover, Pakistan was created by the British and not by Jinnah. Under these circumstances, writing more books supporting Jinnah and Gandhi and their politics is not a good use of time. It is now necessary to write more about how Jinnah and Gandhi helped the British to divide India. Why did Allama Mashriqi refuse to support Jinnah and Gandhi? People need to know this interesting and eye-opening information. Such a book would be in great demand and read by a large number of people." Views & News Channel, April 21, 2023

[@abdulrahmanamin2742]

Hoodbbhoy is real intellectual. A nice human being. Huge respect for Pervaiz Hoodbhoy from Afghanistan.

[@frazbest]

The best and the most honest analysis. Wish there was a single discrepancy between the facts, history and the current situation, but found none.

[@zahidnawab9924]

Well said We have been taught nothing but obedience from the initial step that questioning and rising are the" absolute forbidden" That is how we hv collapsed today in all faculties.

[@aminaabdulla5854]

Nope, he is saying madrasa will guanrantee unproven what ever after life 72.... plus what ever but not in this world.

[@ABCD-cw3fs]

Just as... Soldiers not to reason why... Soldiers only to do and die.. No scope of reasoning and questioning in your holy book..but in Indian culture.. Question and discussion, introspection, correction,... refining.. redefining.. reforms all are open and welcome..eg.Bali pratha (Animal sacrifice) is replaced by braking Coconut (symbolic of skull)..

[@emmkay]

There's something called 'corporate social responsibility' (csr). Indian govt has developed this policy that industrialists and big companies mandatorily contribute in social activities which includes contribution towards education. That's the mindset difference. Some companies genuinely want to make the difference and some companies make contribution to build their name and advertisement. But overall Quality of education and public institutes is multiplying either ways..

[@harshapatil3497]

Guys, I am doing my research interdisciplinary area, especially in tissue engineering. It's a headache job. Open a small shop and become an entrepreneur. This man has seen the world. My respect to Dr.PH sir.

[@bharathvansh5127]

@PIDE OFFICIAL, I cant understand how the holy mullah and moulvi are tolerating this kafeer speech, This fellow is speaking against the aasmani kitab. This fellow should be sent to madrasaa, instead indulging in eeshalamichasation, he is speaking against the holy book, World is flat and sun rotates around it. But he is outrightly claiming these falls. Paki is now becoming a kaffeer land. Dont know how these kaffeers are tolerated.

[@ambarishupadhyay921]

India’s IT exports in the year 2022 are worth US$ 200 Billion and not 120 Billion 🙂

[@akbarkanji5368]

bullshit, your country growth is superficial it is all farce, if it is true why you people want to go to usa, canada or uk

[@ambarishupadhyay921]

@@akbarkanji5368 Because India is a better version of itself now, but just not quite like Europe (where I live since past 16 years), US or Australia. But India still is a shining example of how a country can come out of hundreds of years of invasions and occupation and become the world’s 5th largest economy, a global epicenter of IT and Pharma, one of the top startup hubs in the world, and continue to be the fastest growing large economy in the world. Not perfect by any stretch of imagination, but still, PRETTY GODDAMN FANTASTIC! ❤️😉🙂❤️😉❤️😉😉

[@MukeshPanicker]

Indian IT export is 120 billion USD . 200 billion is the total service export.

[@faisalaziz288]

More shameful for us.

[@rahulvats95]

That's service Exports.

[@Anas-oo4ze]

Sir Dr hod bhoy I love you ❤sir please keep up our nation❤❤❤❤

[@BRNavalgund]

Prof: PH should not be sitting in a room discussing things in front of a few people...He should be the Advanced Science Education Head and should be speaking to them.Makes good use of this amazing human being...he speaks from the heart

[@thelntworks9344]

I appreciate your efforts ❤️. #PIDE

[@navinbhatia9936]

Brilliant analysis with context and facts.

[@armankhanownproperty8674]

Thank you for your information

[@muhammadanjumyousufzai6762]

Very nice talk...

[@ashesdharraina5368]

Very rightly said about Mughals. One more farak in attitude was Hindus were always knowledge seeking. The oldest universities of world were Nalanda and Takshashila,. Hence the difference

[@navinbhatia9936]

Few facts 1- India service exports during 2022-23 are $350 billion of which IT+BPO+business consulting is $280 billion 2- India has 1120 Universities with 3.8crore students with GER at 30% 3-India produces 5lakh engineering graduates every year 4-India has 87,000start up with130 unicorns

[@ashishparakh9670]

Very intelligent discourse. Just go for democracy and keep Army out of Administration.

[@faisalrazzaq6002]

Well explained Sir, we have left behind.

[@BRNavalgund]

Naturally I am fan of Hoodbhoy...as i studied Master of nuclear Science.

[@venkateshprabhu7027]

Wonderful. !!

[@hamnawa9063]

Wow... Zabardast

[@rossgolla876]

Dhaka University started from 1921 and its much before than Pakistani born and Dhaka collage founded in 1841 and universitie of kolkata 1857 and Dhaka collegiate school is the first high school in undivided United Bengal established in 1835

[@skagraw2]

Takshila aur nalanda universities ko todne wale bhala nayi universities kyu banayenge.

[@Centerfiremedia]

“There is something within us which is stopping us….” What is that something? 1. Excessive adherence to Islam. 2. A generation brainwashed to hate “Kafirs” 3. An unwillingness to accept oneself as “Hindu ka bachcha” 4. A theocratic state identity. 5. The mullah’s prominence.

[@mutesatendolkar2561]

Agree with Prof.Hoodhbhoy's views, but time to act. Hearing about Pakistan's problems for too long. It is also in India's interest to see stable and prosperous Pakistan. Economy, stability is not a zero-sum game. Stable and prosperous Pakistan/Sri Lanka/Nepal/Bangladesh is good for the entire region and will benefit India as well. India should not think it is in this by itself, India has the resources, know-how and moral responsibility to help its neighbors.

[@debs7739]

Thought he will be exceptional but so sorry to hear that he also take pride of mughals, invaders, like other madrassachhaps.

[@TheAaryanQ]

inspiring, love from india.

[@cx4vr1dh4j]

Good talk

[@yougantsingh2262]

Sir,you are inteligent persen muja asa lag raha ha jesha AAP bufalao ka agha bi ho

[@rizwanelahi3666]

Very good sir ALLAH PAK ap ko is ka ajar da

[@AUDI639]

Allah foreign beach par maze le rha hai

[@skagraw2]

Nahi Allah hooro ki chut chat raha h. Usko fursat kaha.

[@aawoops]

Very good speech

[@professoraftab7488]

We intend to export some videos of politicians, judges and respectable citizens.we can earn billions from this sector,the only left for.

[@sureshshukla87]

Read namaz 5 times, curse modi and worry about akhirat. That's the true purpose of this life.

[@avinashchandrapathak5366]

Namaste 🙏 right sir indian r allways education and vadic culture..

[@atanumandal3586]

Sahi bola Hood bhai ne!

[@pervezmemon743]

Really shocked.

[@GyanamInfinite]

Not fully correct on one aspect. I am from India and visited Rennes School of Business in France very recently in Nov 2022. I met a lot of professors @ Rennes School of Business who have studied at Pak Universities - and I tell you - I am amazed by the knowledge they have. And they have all studied in Pakistan, done their masters and phd in Pakistan. My belief & respect about Pakistan universities have increased after I met them.

[@dr.dilipmishra7376]

Unless you allow to question no progress is possible

[@nadim606]

100% True 👍

[@gautambatwar7231]

Pakistani people are more educated than the world over, because they worship 5 times a day .. keep it up... Pakistan ek Zinda Kom hai... Jo kalme se bana hai.... Bahut jazba hota hai in Mai... Allah who is Akbar ....

[@GPJhala]

In higher education ,we get more in-depth knowledge of specific branch. After getting the huge amounts of knowledge, how to use it, how to implement different branches of knowledge is not taught in University. Your own mental discipline is required for it. Arrogant and single minded people do not get knowledge

[@jayantkhanagegulbarga7570]

Sir a question to you, how far is the madarsa education in Pakistan is a hinderance in revamping system. Jk South India

[@benjaminbenjamin8834]

The last true intellectual living in Pakistan is Respected Dr Pervez and after him I am sure Pakistan will become like Afghanistan InshAllah .

[@abdularham9226]

Yes 😞

[@skagraw2]

Ye koi intellectual nahi h. Ye ek rotdu banda h. Jo sirf chhati pit-ta h. Pervez ne khud kitne inventions kiye h ya inke kitna students h jinhone koi bhi inventions kiye ho.

[@abdularham9226]

@@skagraw2 I agree with you sir ye bas lectures dete hen Jo inku universities me deni chayie na k KZbin per

[@skagraw2]

@@abdularham9226 jab maulana gun ke jor pe Quran padha sakte h to pervez jaise log gun ke jor pe physics, chemistry, maths padha sakte h. Inko kisne roka h. Ek akele anpadh Mohamad ne apne dimag ki takat se sari duniya me jiteji aur marne ke bad bhi tufan macha rakha h.

[@abdularham9226]

@@skagraw2 Are sir mujhe kia mene konsa Pakistan me rehna he mujhe to pata he Pakistan ka future Kya hoga Afghanistan Ya somalia jesa hoga itna radicalization he society me apki soch he critical thinking or freedom of speech to he nahi to is desh ka Kya future hoga

[@vasukinagabhushan]

Science can be studied in any language as most Europeans do. Like most misguided Indian and Pakistani intellectuals, Dr. Hoodbhoy is an Anglophile. Chinese, Koreans, Germans and French developed by educating in their mother tongue. Pakistani Punjab has outlawed education in Punjabi language.

[@venkateshprabhu7027]

No God. No religion. This is TRUTH 👍🌅💗

[@murlimenon7892]

Good message to Pakistan peoples.

[@vasukinagabhushan]

In Pakistan, Lower Education is Low Quality Higher Education is Lower Quality

[@shahabali9608]

In every sphere of Pakistani society there is dominance of a prerogative class called Ashrafs. It is clash of personal, social and political interest of different Ashraf groups ,which has resulted in series of problems for pakistan. 💔

[@gautambatwar7231]

Lahore and Sindh in Pakistan were a classic example of how Hindu, Sikh, Sindhi community Prospered and the society at large

[@pervezmemon743]

Good evening.

[@Sandaesa]

Which mechanic made a car that is fueled by water ? 😮 How does it work and on what principle?

[@rossgolla876]

1st reason, One of the main fundamental reason why Pakistan going back ward - - Most of the people of Pakistan don't know that The colonial system of jaghirdar / jamindar was abolished during land reforms in former East Bengal / East Pakistan now (Bangladesh) in 1950,India in 1951 but still it is totally absence in Pakistan. Still Pakistan protecting the colonial system of jaghirdar and General's and establishments. When 1% ( jaghirdar and Punjabi Ruling Elite and Army Establishment ) of pakistan controls 99 % Pakistan then Nothing will be OK.That 1% was a gift of colonial British mindset. People of East Bengal realized that colonial mindset from 1st day but still people of Pakistan living in Denial mindset of colonialism.2ND Reason why Pakistan going back ward that is majority people of Pakistan are not serious about their country. 3rd reason is that people of Pakistan are sleeping last 75 years but don't want to wake up and those people of East Bengal did wake up and fight for equal rights & justice from first day to 1971 they're now one of the fastest growing nation in the world. 4th fundamental reason pakistan and the people of pakistan systematically destroy own identical roots , language ,traditional values and heritage of ethnicity and diversity. Another reason is that people of Pakistan always take short cut policy and their is no long-term futuristic Sustainable development program or plan for future - No Educational & Socioeconomically plan but still waiting for next Sultan or kind of Leader to Grow. Last 75 years Pakistan made a lollypop mindset in Pakistan that Pakistan and people of Pakistan are only greatest and Rightful but rest of the world fake & false . It's a multi organ failure of Pakistan.It's too late to make changes in course correction after 75 years in the DNA of Pakistan.it's a martial race nation and its not a country for the people but it's a country for jaghirdar and General's with colonial setup of mindset and still living in confused Denial mindset and conspiracy mentality and it became self-destructive nation. 1% ( jaghirdar and Punjabi Ruling Elite and Army Establishment ) use Pakistan as a strategic depth to sell own land and sovereignty to the foreign power and create different types of Armed Terror group for Billion USD and destroying neighbor's but when you keeping snake in your backyard and expect them to only bite your neighbor's but that snake bite you too . Pakistan became as a garrison state with colonial setup. Pakistan is an over Militarilise state. It's neither a Islamic nor a democratic country.Socially- Politically - Economically and Mentally Pakistan became Black Hole and still Pakistan is existing part of colonial legacy . If the Grass look greener on the other side of the world. Stop comparing, Stop complaining and Start watering the grass you are standing on.*PAKISTAN SE ZINDA BAAGH *🙈🙉🙊.

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

how to change the attitude though a million dollars question for the Attitude though ?

[@pam4840]

Parda Karo sab teek ho jaayega . An Indian who likes the comedy show called Pak. Thank u guys.

[@santtomar1885]

I respect you sir An indian

[@gauravdubai2980]

Raw talent and intelligence are the cheapest things on the subcontinent. Every second person is one or the other or both. USELESS until you have the educational and support systems to develop them. There are ANY number of Indians who start / have started off life in very humble circumstances and who utilize / have utilized the education system to climb to the very top of their field. India's former President, A P J Abdul Kalam, started life as a fisherman's son in a tiny hut in an unelectrified, remote village. Former PM, Manmohan Singh, a renowned economist, was born in West Punjab, and started his education as a refugee studying under street lights. Present PM, Narendra Modi, famously started as a tea-boy at a railway station. There are literally hundreds of thousands of such stories in academicia, business and the professions. When Pakistan produces their first such person, it'll have arrived. Forget that - when Pakistanis learn to admire such persons among themselves, BEFORE they are successful, they'll know they are on the way to arrival: in India even a street urchin who displays talent is recognized - even idolized and feted - and some person or organization will invariably come forward to assist his education.

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

az dehshat e shah e jahan larzad zameen o aasmaa ?

[@jeraldcastelino7622]

Creation of Pakistan itself on religion basis was wrong. India has invested heavily on the education system. We love our country, India runs in our blood, our armed forces do not interfere in the domestic affairs of the country. Pakistan's obsession with kashmir is primarily responsible for its downfall. Pakistan could not win a single war against India, so started using terrorism and promoted terrorists. Pakistan's defence budget is huge compared to its GDP, citing threat from India as an excuse. Pakistan did not encourage local industry so nothing to export apart from salt,football,cricket bats and garments, a u-turn from this point looks impossible as pakistan cannot service its own debts.

[@venkateshprabhu7027]

It is money in the stocks. It is the high to middle of stock. It is okay.

[@pichannaml2683]

In India 14 private banks were nationalised in 1969 by then Prime Minister of India Smt Indira Gandhi.That was the turning ponit govt banks gave loans to agriculture,it benefited farmers and India became self sufficient in food grains .

[@rizwanelahi3666]

حقیقت بائیاں کرتے ہیں

[@nitovatorsnitj]

I disagree a little with Dr. Parvez at around 9 minutes. There are good Muslim Run institution in India, established during British Rule, like Aligarh Muslim University, Jamia Milia Islamia. These are still good College. Also, in south Osmania University was established.

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

shekhol Hind Hosain Madani retaliated against pakistan whereas sir syed walas supported the Partion endorsing promoting the mi5 mi6 formula the rezults of which we harvesting enjoying like anything though ?

[@neeraj1752]

Good Lecture by Physics Professor Everbody acts like Politician by giving random examples.

[@vishnukapoor7436]

Now have you guys realised where you stand... It's an uphill task to reach the top of a very high mountain.... Most of you will perish trying to achieve this task....

[@vasukinagabhushan]

Even the educated Dr. Hoodbhoy seems anti Indian and anti Hindu. He talks about scientific achievements of ancient Middle East. But he never talks about the scientific and mathematical achievements of ancient India.

[@blindeagle9109]

In this room also I notice ladies with regressive thought sitting. Thanks that there is no post box kind lady.

[@msr7373]

i think apart from the fundamental issues which have been rightly highlighted by Parvez Hoodbhoy, another problem with us is that we are overly obsessed with India. why do we have to look at india for everything? india was not comparable to pakistan even at the time of independence. Pakistan is a much smaller country then india and despite being a part of British India there are many fundamental differences between the 2 countries. its better to compare Pakistan with other success stories like Philippines and Vietnam which had to face hard situations in the past and are now doing much better. even Malaysia and turkey can be good examples in may things.

[@rahulvats95]

Pak books teach you about hating India. Indian books don't even mention Pak unless necessary

[@aminaabdulla5854]

Because your ancestors were Hindus whether you accept it or deny it. Truth will not change.

[@msdolly6101981]

"Even at the time of independence " , what does that even mean? A country called Pakistan was formed "AFTER " India became independent from British, by partitioning India . You guys can't get even the basic rights. Most of you talk as if a country called Pakistan existed before 1947. That land was part of India

[@msr7373]

@@aminaabdulla5854 and what does that has to do with anything in my comment ?

[@msr7373]

@@msdolly6101981 Didn’t india and Pakistan gained independence together and where have I written that Pakistan existed before 1947?! Matlab kuch bhi. And Didi please mind your own business. Pakistan was indeed born in 1947 and we are proud that we struggled to create a brand new country (india would have gained independence sooner or later anyways as European powers were broke after WW II but had we not struggled for Pakistan we wouldn’t have gotten it). Plus it doesn’t matter if our country didn’t exist in 1947, the truth is that we do exist now which also proves that Bharat khandit ho chuka hai , so Bette you guys don’t sweat over what term we use for our independence or creation

[@MumtazShah786]

Outcome based education was applied in the West in 1950s.

[@ashishparakh9670]

Indians are thankful to Nehru for his farsightedness that he stood away from Orthodox and focused on IIT and democracy

[@amandeep9930]

Education system of India is also quite bad. At least Pakistanis have courage to accept that their education system is bad. All the IITs, IIMs and good universities of India are islands of excellence in a sea of mediocrity. Maybe the cream of India performs better than the cream of Pakistan but most of the average students of both the countries seems to be essentially unemployable.

[@vpsinghngp]

You people have a good scope to open an International School of Dramatic...it will earn you acolades and good forex atleast from India

[@vpsinghngp]

Drama & Theatre of Pak origin are very much appreciated by educated society here

[@rkmoitra123]

I was surprised by Hoodbhoy's comment near the end as to his mechanic being able to devise a way to run his car on water! Did I hear it right? Otherwise it was an excellent talk, as always.

[@yogeshparashar8696]

It was a joke. Ones someone in Pakistan claimed that

[@annasmith-uw8xg]

I think each sentence must have felt like a hard slap on the faces of those present. So in the end he just decided to show some mercy and give them a pat on the back as small encouragement!

[@ibratnak]

Hoodbhoy's comment on Middle East rejecting Pakistani doctors is false. The MD postgraduation degree, which only a handful of Pakistani doctors have, was banned in Middle East since it is not accredited by the Pakistan Medical Council. Most Pakistani doctors have FCPS postgraduation degree which is still in-demand there. Hoodbhoy's comment on Pakistani doctors not being admitted in the US is also false. USMLE registration now requires WFME accreditation which was suspended not only for Pakistan, but also for India.

[@shekar7367]

My son (American citizen) graduated with a medical degree from an Indian University and left for US to take the USMLE exams and cleared step 1, and is taking step 2 next week. In-between he is also doing rotations. I dont know what you are referring to here about some accredition requirement...some of the Indian Universities (not all of them) have all the necessary accreditions.

[@ibratnak]

@@shekar7367 Yup Pakistan and India's WFME accreditation nightmares were resolved a year or two ago. Hoodbhoy needs to update his knowledge.

[@pam4840]

Agar nahi tho wo bhi ho jaayega. Let imran Khan come with new wave of islamisation

[@ibratnak]

@@pam4840 Imran's wave is more dangerous because now the educated class is an equal participant in the collective psychosis, which is eerily similar to Nazi Germany. He gives examples of the Ottoman Empire, which Turkey overthrew to become what it is now.

[@gautambatwar7231]

Recently the Australian PM said, Indian education certificate will be appreciated in Australia

[@Usmankhan-yr3dl]

Pakistan need people like Abdul sattar edhi Pervaiz hoodboy Anwar Maqsood Atif mian economist Imran khan

[@skagraw2]

Disagree. You need to get rid of Quran 1st. Kyunki ye hi mullo ke dimag me kida dalti h.

[@BharathCalgary]

How come there are only few students here? I am amazed.... some university in India should bring Pervez to India... its a humiliation to any human Intelligence!!!

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

misbah ismail se bhtr kon janta hai political economy of higher education in pakistan ?

[@truthmatters-tr8if]

SIr but dont you think this based on the founding of the country itself? Based on religion and exceptionalism based on what religion they follow. This was the basic flaw. But it is easier to get out of this and change attitude - you dont have to collapse the system - all you have to do is face facts and deal in facts - accept that it was wrong to carve nation based on religion. Then move on and say what needs to be done to build a nation. Focus on science, education, math - not on religion, violence , unfinished partition, India etc - move away from past and look towards the future. That will change attitudes.

[@jayantkhanagegulbarga7570]

Hoodbhoy sir, I appreciate your realistic views, yet, why don't Pakistan emphasize on present suitable education system., Jk South India

[@adnan_hashmi]

Is highlighting problems and not proposing solutions not a problem in itself?

[@skagraw2]

Bhai, solution bata ke apna gala katwana h. Jis desh me science aur technology haram h wo itna bol gaya. Dua karo we kisi jehadi ke nishane pe na ajaye.

[@rahulvats95]

@@skagraw2 rofl

[@sanjivsaran9222]

Mr. Hashmi parvez bhai is not p.m. of napakistan.

[@adnan_hashmi]

@@sanjivsaran9222 Yet you are the PM of Rundia.

[@shirishmoharil6386]

In 1 week..1 businessman of India lost 35 times more money than entire reserves of Pakistan...now compare

[@raheelrao8964]

India best in the world

[@MultiRmw]

What's the solution now instead of condemnation???

[@ssryr6427]

Reforms , make politics strongest entity keep army at borders snatch there powers,,allow people to question and answer everything , reforms in law system, allow all religions science, tech ,economy experts to hold big posts if they're super talented ,all big companies are run around world by Indian CEO ,in India a Jain was allowed to start ISRO ,a Parsi allowed to start Atomic Research institute,a muslim allowed to make nuclear bomb and missiles, a Jew Indian General made chief of Eastern command and governor of various states ,a Christian as army chief and later governor of various states, can u do this in Pakistan ???take example of scientist Abdus Salam what happened to him.

[@VinodKumar-xv2dq]

Sir, Adani groups and comeback ❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 I respect to you sir ❤️

[@abdullahghani5080]

Pak has intelligent brains as he mentioned his mechanic like late dr abdul slam and many more researchers and analyst. Problem is pak is being brainwashed and youngsters not getting govt support and platforms to perform their ideas.That's happening for many bcz of our govts as recently people are leaving their country.

[@beedlebard2649]

Hoodbhoy was just being polite - there are next to no intelligent Pakistanis - hardworking maybe but not intelligent. If the mechanic was intelligent he would have learnt to read and write - he is just hardworking.

[@debs7739]

🤣

[@sunildeubey]

Parvez sir goodwisher of Pakistan but Government of Pakistan in mode of denial.

[@Bharatbarsh2005]

Dr. Hoodboi is a teetotaller and a very respectful person. But does Islamic regime of Pakistan take him seriously. He should have been born in India.

[@arshadsaeed9854]

Question: Obedience is also part of Indian culture? Why their economy is succeeding?

[@urrasscal8380]

ur guys r not iindian u guys r aarrab ...please don't compare....

[@khittaykachoudhary2360]

Because Indians Don't say Inshallah, Alhamdulilah, Mashallah in every sentence.

[@arshadsaeed9854]

@@urrasscal8380 go and read your facts again, boy. I belong to the region where your ideology finds ground. Your entire philosophy is grounded in Taxila/Harappa, and it is Pakistan right now. So please stop giving me moral sermons of Arabs vs Indians.

[@arshadsaeed9854]

@@obaidkhan4083 brother although your observations are true. But I would this is shallow when we are talking about economies. I am curious why the scholar linked obedience with factors of production. It's emotional I believe rather rational argument.

[@rahulvats95]

@@arshadsaeed9854 look at how easily hindus make fun of their God's, mistakes and myths. That's absent in muslim, they're fearful of Their God, your politician make use of that. Imran khan talks about Fahashi but he swings both ways Men, women and Transgender. That is hypocritical. Rich Muslim women would bang all of the town but still appear in burqa and preach islamiyat.