The REAL REASON Why puppet IS NOT FOOLED by the MASK in FNAF2

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

*I love the puppet...but feel so sorry for her...what about you?* Continue the theory work here with us - kzbin.info/aero/PLqvFZk-dYG5d577z9igUupPQ5pnf6HGe3

[@harisafeef101]

Same

[@Mr.Pickleplayz]

Hey bub I you don't know you are MICHEAL AFTON in FNAF 1-6 going back to fix your father's mistakes (William Afton's killings) also the reason any of them attack you I'm the first place if your Micheal is because you look like your Dad (William A.) if you need it why don't you go watch the videos from Game Theory with MatPat and Tom

[@CalebS-t2i]

Same. Also what are these animations in your vids?

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

@user-zs3ey5gi6m link in description and if not one of them the water Mark's of the video makers will be on screen

[@FnafandFiguresReviews83rd]

@@TwistedAnimatroniccan I get a shout in your vid

[@MansieMonke]

Simple Reason: The Puppet can see their uniform and can see their not in a full suit. Though this is still a great theory! Well Done!

[@Arnut-stuff-tr]

The others are fkin stupid?

[@Singularitous]

wow.

[@MansieMonke]

@@Singularitous Ikr

[@TengryEmily1982]

I think there's a strange relationship between Charlie and Michael. Charlie obviously doesn't hate William, but at the same time, throughout the timeline, she tries to prevent or kill Michael, even though he is NOT even her KILLER On the reverse side of the coin, the situation can be viewed from Cassidy/TOYSNHK. Following the Logbook and partly UCN and theorizing Cassidy's presence in FNaF 3 and FFPS, even he/she does NOT do THIS, being on the contrary the most AGGRESSIVE spirit. He/she knows/assumes interactions between Michael and BV and, perhaps, that the older brother also wants to help everyone, and goes to meet him, although, if you think about it, there is no benefit for him/her to help others, he/she just wants revenge, while Charlie, being the same DEFENDER of spirits and the same aware, does the exact opposite. She doesn't want to cooperate with Michael and help him in helping as a joint goal, she's just trying to kill him in FFPS, lol

[@Starbonniexofficial]

I love the fact that after Charlie possesed puppet she got more brave ! And also feel bad fir her

[@PyroTurtleGaming]

You had me 100% in the first half. You were building this whole case for Charlie recognizing a person they saw wearing mask in while alive and tying that to Mike. I was really feeling the buildup and agreeing all the way. I followed your logic directly to the Bonnie Bro and was just waiting for you to say it... But then you took a hard right turn and talked about it being because Charlie knows the anamatronics, so she would know you're not one (which feels like it's leaning on the "but I am very aware" line you kinda denied as a viable explanation at the beginning.) Then, you meandered a bit through the fact that the new models have a facial recognition system tied to a criminal database (and claimed it would also recognize previous employees as part of the same protocol. Which is never stated. It's simply stated that while the place is locked down, previous employees are not supposed to be there. Nothing ever connects this idea to the facial recognition system.) None of which is relevant to the puppet, who predates this feature in the Toys by a long shot. Then branching off this, you go on about Mike having been the guard before Jeremy (which I thought we generally agreed was William, who was moved to dayshift the week we play as Jeremy, and caused the DCI, thus why "previous employees " were under suspension.) All this just to loop back around to Jeremy is the Bonnie Bro. Which I agree with, but the way you presented this didn't make the strongest case for it it could have. I feel like this would have been a better argument if you had led into the Bonnie Bro conclusion alongside your case towards the idea that Charlie can recognize people they saw wearing mask in life and considered child killers. Then built up your case for him being the Bonie Bro. The meandering through all these other subjects in the 2nd half weakens the punch of the Bonnie Bro conclusion. Thanks for reading! Have a good one!

[@skyenight-by8yh]

Dang, Puppet seemingly acting like a “god” of William’s victims is honestly both interesting and bizarre at the same time. 😮 I honestly think it’s more tragic (I know, not the right word) then the Foxy theory. 😅

[@MimicTheories]

“It’s just a theory” -FNaF Theorists, MatPat

[@hellmareking]

After matpats retirement, this channel became my new to watch theory channel, even with other things on youtube, i refuse to watch videos until i saw all video from 1 youtuber playing the fnaf (fan) games out

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

That's awesome to hear !!!

[@the-real-brady-boi2]

Part of me wishes that withered freddy had his own mechanics and wasn’t fooled by the mask since it’s literally his own head

[@joshuawatt1826]

Yeah same

[@amaccoy]

Freddy: "Oh,no, that's just Freddy." Foxy: "YOU'RE FREDDY!!" Freddy: 🫥

[@I_Have_foundYOU]

@@amaccoy lol

[@BloxyOfficial90]

Freddy: Pretty Sure That's Freddy.

[@MajinMuu]

@@BloxyOfficial90 Foxy: OH GAWD DAMN IT! you're freddy!

[@neptuneplaneptune3367]

I think the "Im wary aware" quote more refers to her being more aware of herself. She is basicley entirley Charlie in full control of herself and fully sentient, while the others are more animalistic, not fully themselfes anymore. And because Charlie is a fully aware human she of course isnt dumb enough to be fooled by a simple Freddy Mask. Ore heck maybe Fazbears security uniforms where purple and simply seeing the purple triggerd her to attack

[@bryceblake9264]

I agree plus when she says I used to be afraid of you not anymore I think she was afraid of Afton when she died but now in her new form she has power over her oppressor

[@bryceblake9264]

I believe in UCN we play at William in his own personal hell.

[@WilliamplaysOfficial]

I love your Content, I love the Puppet aswell especially the Voice, its creepy, also Congrats on 50K, been here since pre-10K can't wait to be a member!

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

You rock!

[@WilliamplaysOfficial]

@@TwistedAnimatronic =) You are my favourite youtube.

[@sithmaster345]

1:25 Hey, when did Freddy Fazbear get here?

[@silverbullet1620]

Hey Twisty, have you ever played a 1.0 version of FNAF World? Now hear me out. Find an unaltered version of FNAF World. Play an early build of FNAF 4 then FNAF World where you have to put the pieces together then go back and play FNAF 3 Happiest Day. This way you can see if the box opens. Scott did this for FNAF Ultimate Custom Night and FNAF World.

[@SSCRoomyy]

Another theory is that the others have facial recognition, while the puppet doesn’t, it sees everything not just our head. Again about another theory. In another video I saw. It says that when the bite of 83 happened, Henry knew Charlie was there and started not taking her back after it was closed. And William killed Charlie after Henry said that he was cut from the business.

[@iamalbertwesker2]

Considering the pattern of seemingly playing as characters linked to the bite of 83/crying child's death, I wonder if it means Mike's asked his friends to help him release the spirits from the animatronics

[@AstraFulminous]

@1:24 Twisted? Aw man. I had a question. Where'd you go? Oh hey Glamrock old buddy? So anyway I had a quetion. Recently this ex security guard I met, that beautiful punk rock anamatronic and the new redhead around the block all sent me an invite to some 10 year celebration party, what are the odds. Still it feels really important what should I bring? Huh Faz Cake? In this economy!? Wait what do you mean your going too?

[@frogtorwho]

fun little easter egg if the bonnie bro was the guy who got bit on the forehead/ bite of 87. bonnie in fnaf 2 is missing his faceplate not the intire face just the forehead down to the top jaw

[@nachonaitor5535]

You can say that karma gived him a "piece" of IS own.medicine

[@danlevinte]

1:26 just stay away from water😅😅

[@Stechin_VrMystik]

Jeremy/Bonnie Bully is Cassies dad (Game Theory's theory) Jeremy is Bonnie Bully.. IT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE YK! Bc Cassie says Bonnie was her dads favourite making sense for him to have the Bonnie Mask... CRAZY!

[@Human-qw1ic]

i love to watch these videos when eating and drinking coffee thanks for these videos🤩

[@MichelleConner-z8l]

This content is darn good keep up good work

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Thank you

[@Toy-vc9oo]

I think my only problem is that it is implied in FNaF 1 the bite of 87 victim died, witch wont make sense to be a character who is theorised to be cassie's father, but it would make sense to be one of the bully's, maybe the Freddy or Chica mask

[@AstraFulminous]

So she has the experience and the technology

[@Arnut-stuff-tr]

I think it's a similar reason to Foxy She had seen mike with a mask on (Foxy mask) so she knows what he looks like with a mask on

[@simplyymoonlightYT]

Wait, I have a theory What if foxy and the puppet are related in some sort of way since they aren't fooled

[@alfarnafae2762]

Def bro did that for the foxy video

[@thunderstudent]

I don't think it's the bullies or Mike. Because they would be around 15 judging by how large they are in 4. Even Afton wouldn't let Mike become a night guard at 15. I tend to think that the original night guard before Jeremy was Afton himself under an alias. From the "SAVE THEM" mini game, it's still set in the FNAF 2 location but none of the toys except Mangle are moving. Also 5 new animatronics, one is rebuild daily at that point and we have 5 new dead kids. Because Jeremy and Fritz are wearing the same uniform, and Charlotte is more aware of what's happening around her she can go "Ah ha! You're not an animatronic, you must be Afton!" even when it's not. Also Scott tends to reuse names a lot. Hell, Jeremy is the name of the child possessing Bonnie. So Bonnie Bro can't be Jeremy Fitzgerald. Furthermore, I don't think she would attack Mike or Bonnie Bro knowingly. What happened to Evan/CC was an accident. Mike isn't a killer like his father and she would know this. Bonnie Bro is Mike's friend and likely some stupid kid. I don't think she would attack him either simply because it was an accident. A prank gone extremely wrong. Good try though.

[@AloneTheorist]

Mike severely injured CC, but apologised, soothing his spirit. CC dies in hospital, in darkness BECAUSE William Afton pulled his life support. You hear this play out in the ending cutscene of Fnaf 4. William Afton killed CC because he didn't believe he'd recover. The puppet can talk to souls, she'd know Mike is trying to help from encountering CC's disembodied soul so would have no real reason to attack him specifically as his brother trusts him to help save the spirits. Arguably CC wouldn't let harm come to Mike, even in his broken state because he cherished Mike's apology. Good memories are the key to happiness in Fnaf, this apology from Mike in Fnaf 4 would be one for CC. CC might even be TOYSHK from UCN, but that hinges on his death, parallels, lack of body recovery and the fact that UCN appears to made of the darkness he died in, in hospital.(See Golden Freddy cutscene.) UCN is a world of agony controlled by a disembodied boy that refuses to rest his soul out of the sheer agony he was put through pre death.

[@Enchantingech]

GREAT THEORY bc it make so much sense

[@amerehills9737]

Thanks for another entertaining theory video this is just what I needed after a long day of work🤩💯

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@monkeydluffy-lq5nh]

i love the videos man keep it up

[@ShareseNeal]

Thanks

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

No problem

[@charjess9490]

8:38 this makes so much sense tbh

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

*PS SUBSCRIBE to Help us Reach more FNAF THEORISTS!!* - kzbin.info/door/qhh2w3HNXEt0Kl6uTLtDrA

[@Mango-123-o5s]

Hi it’s me from the stream yesterday!

[@RileyJackson-j8d]

before the video i only thought she knew the victumes clearly

[@Empoleontrap]

1:25 WHERE'D HE GO!? WHERE'D HE GO!?

[@ThatSkateKidd]

Dang i didnt know freddy had a youtube channel

[@Happyworldshark]

Idk why but i adore phone guy being depicted with an old phone for a head

[@FnaftheUltimateking2]

Jeremy Fitzgerald he's the bonnie mask kid in Fnaf 4 and he's cassy dad

[@Darlene-jn5wy]

I love also Puppen sie is my Favorit

[@Darlene-jn5wy]

I mean puppet

[@ConConPomPom]

In fnaf 2 reimagined roblox at the end we speak to golden freddy and he says the reason they left us alone because william was wearing a mask when he murded them so i think freddy told the toys and the withereds but foxy and puppet dont believe it

[@THEJSTR_EDITS]

She recognized mike because maybe she is used to him wearing a mask or maybe instead of the foxy mask in one point of time he tried a freddy mask?

[@NobodyUndefined]

Occam's Razor, the Puppet just knows it's a suit because of the fact that she's aware. Like you said, you can tell if it's a person wearing a mask or not and the others are too unaware to realize it. I think she just mistakes the security guard for their killer like the rest, given that FNaF 2 was so early in the games development, I don't think Scott thought ahead that much. I think the plan from the start was that the animatronics just mistake all adult men as their killer, like when Golden Freddy says "It's me" he means "it's me, one of your victims", he's taunting the guard thinking they're their killer, the Puppet is just trying to protect the kids from their killer. I definitely don't think its to do with CC's death as Scott was going to end the games with the third game so it doesn't make sense that he thought ahead that much in FNaF 2 or that such an important piece of the lore was included in a game that wasn't planned at it's time of release.

[@ShareseNeal]

Cool wow

[@Am.3lia]

I believe all your theories, I think they are very good! Keep up the good work!

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Thanks!

[@Eddieavina123]

Love your video and keep up the great work. You are awesome, and the puppet is smart. That's why

[@stephaniegagne3376]

The day shift security guard can’t be Michael. It has to be William because of the dead bodies and what Phone Guy says regarding investigations being out there and then coming to the restaurant. It’s possible that there were at most two shifts when William was night guard that he had Michael go in his place because he’s the spitting image of his father which could have caused the Puppet to get the two confused. It’s because of this confusion that the Puppet appears to be “always thinking” as Phone Guy says in one of his calls. And when William shifts to the day shift, he can’t possibly expect the switcharoo with Michael to work as, while his spitting image, Michael’s appearance is that of a physically younger William. So William is the day guard whose position suddenly becomes available. This is the only way for this theory to be valid while taking into consideration that William was also there. Also, Charlie could have seen the Bite of ‘83 before her death by being at the restaurant that day because her father was an owner as well and would have brought her there too.

[@princessmarlena1359]

Makes sense, lore wise.

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Yeah

[@Mango-123-o5s]

True man keep it up! One day u might pass mattpat!

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Maybe one day!

[@mariocaltabiano3759]

Thumbnail is hot😖

[@glamrockfaelynnlockheartedits]

Honestly I agree with your theory. A lot of your theories make sense to me lol also first

[@Fumble6917]

Dude can make the edits so fast if its an editor then give him a raise lol

[@nachonaitor5535]

I have a theory: the reason charlie habe full control over puppet is because puppet was turned off when she posseded it, while the other ms kids posses fully funcional robost, and their minds are fighting agains the ai of the robots, and thats why they are so agresive. They strugle to control the body and that make them act lile animals . Charlie was just lucky that puppet was empty inside

[@LizAndFriendz]

14 MINUTES AGO!? I dream about FNAF now

[@DrippingCat]

Best part of the video has to be the bonus part at the end

[@loganentertainment1814]

Another banging video as always. I sent you an email about a theory revolving around VIP. The e-book interactive novel, that’s supposed to take place in the Pizzaplex. Don’t worry about paying for it, the book is free. if you haven’t read it, I recommend you do, it’s amazing!!!!!! 😱😀👍

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

100%% will check it out thanks Logan!! You're a great help!!

[@loganentertainment1814]

And friend. 😜😁😉😀👍

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

0f course haha

[@molsonr]

Good job with the vid and make more pls❤❤❤

[@biggiecheez4203]

Has anyone ever thought that the “bite of 83” the date shown on the tv on Fnaf 4 was actually the established date of the restaurant?

[@Ollie-y6u]

the placement of charlies death wouldnt matter, no matter what she could have been watching, assuming shes watching at all. we know the puppet can go outside, so nothing would be stopping her watching the bite.

[@nelsonboubou7006]

"The others are like animals but I am very aware"

[@Gojo-g6o]

Hi love your vids❤🎉

[@YandereShiki]

Can you do a video on why foxy dont like the flashlight. Thats been bothering me for so long.

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Great idea

[@Gl1tch_pl4z3]

Slayy 1 hour gang

[@LiantheMan]

here

[@Love_heart133]

Here

[@jamesfrancisgalang7350]

Puppet is a Security Puppet Meaning she should be equipped with a program that detects anything a Person Wears she'll record it She sees us a a "Person with a Freddy Mask" therefore she can't be fooled (she could literally see your torso so she detects it's a person) I'm more interested why Animatronics attack us? I mean, The Previous Night guards quit the job almost immediately

[@skoru4838]

So, before actually watching more than a minute, my guesses are "The Puppet doesn't have the facial recognition systems all the other animatronics have, which prevents the mask from keeping the ghost inside from detecting that the person wearing it is, in fact, someone they're trying to kill", or "whatever system the Puppet uses to get around the pizzeria when the music box unwinds defaults to flinging it at whoever is in the office during the night".

[@MarloSalvatierra-g6f]

Mike isn’t the one in fnaf 2…. It’s a character named Fritz

[@Nine-2545]

I really love the ambiance sound you use, can I know the name of the ambiance sound?

[@Nine-2545]

Specifically at around 2:40

[@Quaglander]

ShadowsLew you cannot hide from me, I know it's you

[@toyloliSpare]

Of the spirits in the game, Charlie and Crying Child are the most aware. I just assumed Golden Freddy told the Puppet "Thats my Brother!" Now, I think when the player has the mask on, the puppet still think's Michael is an animatronic; but is still aware he's Golden Freddy's brother.

[@Cult_of_Rosalina]

poor puppet they didnt deserve death, also I COMPLEATLY AGREE!

[@ImmortalAbsol]

I do just think she's more lucid than the others in general, I don't think it refers to something specific like being aware of paranormal phenomena or however you put it.

[@omglolgosh]

I think in fnaf 2 night 6 mike gets fired, then changes his name and goes back for another night!🙁

[@isaiahalexander886]

I think it is more so similar to the idea of "you are a means to an end". As stated, she "Doesn't hate you, but you need to get out of her way" which implies simply she has no morals anymore. She is still a vengeful spirit and she is waiting for the day to get her revenge yet again on William. Hence also why Henry couldn't just find his daughter and hug her; she is feral yet sentient. She is aware of the person behind the mask as she still holds her intelligence; but since she is driven by revenge and justice, she is blinded and simply will just kill anyone who tries to get in her way.

[@UberPodfan]

The others are like animals, but i am very aware

[@willwispagaming8144]

Well the puppet jumpscare isnt cannon cause if it was the person would be dead so the puppet technically never jumpscared him

[@ImmortalAbsol]

Cannon is the weapon, and canon refers to a given continuity. Have a nice day! (Sorry I think I'm developing a pet peeve for this the more I see theory comment sections)

[@willwispagaming8144]

@@ImmortalAbsol i didnt even notice i spelled it wrong

[@ghosttaki8547]

You’re picking up where GameTheorist left off thank you.

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

You're welcome ! Let's share it with people who would like it !

[@ghostg.7075]

This theory also proves that Mike worked at sister location and died first. Hence his oder of a corpse.

[@biolossauro3261]

Hi man great video.Just wanted to let u known i have a theory u might like.Where can i share it with you?

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Go ahead! Email me !!

[@biolossauro3261]

@@TwistedAnimatronic where is your email?

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

@@biolossauro3261 go to the about or more info on the front page

[@biolossauro3261]

@@TwistedAnimatronic ok thanks

[@biolossauro3261]

@@TwistedAnimatronic sent you

[@SugarF-AJ]

I was the 1000th like.

[@GAMERBOT_420]

She probably thinks the night guards are William

[@CatInAVortex]

Bro this theory is so good! I really love your theories!!

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@Sooonic928]

Hello

[@Gojo-g6o]

Nice for being first😊

[@Mango-123-o5s]

Hello burger

[@Sooonic928]

@@Mango-123-o5s hi

[@stephaniegagne3376]

The day shift security guard can’t be Michael. It has to be William because of the dead bodies and what Phone Guy says regarding investigations being out there and then coming to the restaurant. It’s possible that there were at most two shifts when William was night guard that he had Michael go in his place because he’s the spitting image of his father which could have caused the Puppet to get the two confused. It’s because of this confusion that the Puppet appears to be “always thinking” as Phone Guy says in one of his calls. And when William shifts to the day shift, he can’t possibly expect the switcharoo with Michael to work as, while his spitting image, Michael’s appearance is that of a physically younger William. So William is the day guard whose position suddenly becomes available. This is the only way for this theory to be valid while taking into consideration that William was also there.

[@MujiaoChen]

Omg the puppet is a genius Mr William killed someone who killed a kid her memory is great

[@moyinaark651]

I also have a theory the puppet can see William soul so when he put on the mask😊

[@TheRealSullie]

Under an hour

[@shelaghkabatoff3811]

He’s like the new matpat

[@shadowcrow_3474]

Btw in toys are parts of souls they used parts from whetered animatronic so murdered kids possessed withered there was taken parts of them to toy and they was destroyed and that's why thay are like animals

[@DolpharonXD]

The Foxy video was so popular you had to do it again lol

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

You know it!! We have to cover the puppet this time!!

[@loganentertainment1814]

Why not? XD

[@DaLemonHead1]

puppet is barely more of a animatronic shes more of a human soul which explains why she can see thru the mask

[@Alexs_the_king348]

I actualy had the theory that the bonnie bully was jeremy Fitzgerald before cuz in 2020's jeremy would be around 50 years lld and Cassie is like twelve so that would make Jeremy aroudn fourties while he had cassie which isnt that old and yeah i always found it odd that puppet attackd Jeremy for no reason so what wad my theory i thiught off before i watched this vidoe

[@enderandbonnie335]

Great theory tho Micheal or Mike accidentally killed his own brother (which not on purpose) but then again great theory!

[@B1n1Sama]

where did you get your freddy head? if you could let me know who u got it from or what website i would greatly appreciate it

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

You cant just buy a freddy head, I made it myself

[@B1n1Sama]

@@TwistedAnimatronic gotcha, did you 3d print the parts?

[@zenaitvqx]

my theory before watching the video: Charlie saw the children die and afton take off his spring bonnie suit to reveal his true, human face

[@Xborutothegod]

Real reason when she say i recognize you i not afraid of you not anymore she thinks your William afton

[@5BlackSquares]

I never liked the idea of puppet being just another victim. It's boring and I don't like the fact that one victim is "more aware" than others for some reason. When I first saw the Give Gifts Give Life minigame in fnaf 2 I thought it was some paranormal creature that made the animatronics possessed in the first place. That would make things far simpler.

[@BreadBear1983]

I’m just gonna say this before I see the real answer I think the reason that the puppet can see through the mask is because since she’s aware, she knows who’s all there Just realized I spit bars😂😂😂😂 hey my theory was right

[@sinistertoni]

but its already known that chica was the first she has seen everything

[@DinoD959]

Omg, the FNaF lore is getting to complex now they are using achievements to put in the lore😢

[@Nil_Bloxd]

ITS ANOTHER GREAT DAY!

[@TwistedAnimatronic]

You know it!!